Skip to content
On Air
All channelsAll
21st Precinct artwork

From the 21st Precinct collection

Case of the Picture

Episode 015October 13, 195326 min 18 secTranscript

The written record

Read the transcript

Read along with the recording · About 21 min to read

21st Precinct, Sergeant Climes. Where is this? 3361? How was he shot? How many hold up men? Just one.

You're in the muster room at the 21st Precinct, the nerve center. A call is coming through. Which way, when? You will follow the action taken pursuant to that call from now until the final report is written in the 124 room at the 21st Precinct.

All right. You just stay there. Yes, that's right. Just stay there. You'll have assistance immediately. Yes, sir. Right away.

21st Precinct. Brought to you transcribed by Plymouth. With an invitation for you to see the big, bright, beautiful, new 1954 Plymouth coming Thursday.

21st Precinct. Just lines on a map of the city of New York. Most of the 173,000 people wedged into the nine-tenths of a square mile between Fifth Avenue and the East River wouldn't know if you asked them that they lived or worked in the 21st. Whether they know it or not, the security of their persons, their homes, and their properties is my job. My job and the job of the 150 patrolmen, 11 sergeants, and four lieutenants, of whom I'm the boss. My name is Kennelly, Frank Kennelly. I'm captain in command of the 21st.

Now to 21st Precinct and Captain Frank Kennelly.

Although the East River is one of its boundaries, the 21st is not, in the technical sense, a waterfront precinct. Most of our waterfront is park and parkway. The few docks are confined to the unloading of fuel intended for various power plants and the loading of garbage scows by the 21st. This is the Department of Sanitation. But a waterfront emergency is a citywide emergency. And although I was scheduled to be off duty, I came directly from a meeting of all commanding officers in the line-up room at Police Headquarters, 240 Center Street, to the 21st. It was 10:45 p.m. when I walked into the muster room. Sergeant Klein was on duty on the telephone switchboard. Lieutenant Gorman was desk officer.

Oh, hello, Captain.

Sergeant.

How are you doing, Lieutenant?

Pretty quiet tour, Captain. Keep your fingers crossed for me, will you, Captain?

Why, Sergeant?

She heard that the commissioner is making five captains, 12 lieutenants, and 23 sergeants tomorrow.

Where'd you hear that?

A friend of mine in the chief clerk's office. I hope it's 12 lieutenants. I'm number 11 on the list.

Just my luck, you only make 10. Then you'll be number one on the list. That's an honor in itself.

Well, worry about it tomorrow, Sergeant. We've got other problems tonight. The emergency chart is going in.

The waterfront situation?

Yeah. There'll be an order coming through any minute now. You better get out the emergency call cards.

Yes, sir. We'll be going on two platoons, 12 on and 12 off.

That could be it.

That is it. Here's a U.S. 73 card. How many notifications have we got to make?

38, Captain.

All right. Get the sector cars in here to distribute them to the men on post. We'll dismiss the third platoon at midnight with instruction to return to duty at noon.

Yes, sir. We'll turn out the first platoon at midnight and they'll patrol until noon. Members of the second platoon will be held in reserve here at the house until we get instructions regarding what precincts they're to be templated.

Yes, sir. Oh, excuse me. 21st Precinct, Sergeant Klein. Where's this? 3361? How was he shot? How many? Just one? Where'd he go? All right. There'll be assistance there right away.

Robbery and shooting, Captain.

Okay. Get a car to take me there.

Yes, sir. Hello, CB. Sergeant Klein at 21st. At 3361 Lexington Avenue.

Now, as well as the city-wide emergency, there was an emergency within my own precinct.

But, Kennelly, I'm sorry. I'm sorry. I'm sorry. I'm sorry. I'm sorry. I'm sorry. I'm sorry. I'm sorry. I'm sorry. I'm sorry.

The Communications Bureau dispatched Sector Cars three and four to the scene of the shooting and sent an ambulance from Metropolitan Hospital. Sgt. Klein on T.S., if he was required in such cases, notified the 21st detective squad. He was told that Lt. Matt King, commander of the 21st Squad, was on patrol with two detectives and had undoubtedly responded to the radio signal. While I waited for Sector Car 1 to come by the station house for me, I gave my instructions regarding the distribution of the U.S. 73s to the 38 members of the force residing in the 21st. Those notifications appeared right at times. Report cards would be given to the sector men and men on post for delivery to the homes of members of the force attached to other commands.

A car came by and drove me to the scene of the robbery and shooting, a small all-night luncheonette. Despite the lateness of the hour, a considerable crowd had been attracted by the presence of three police cars and an ambulance.

Come in, Captain.

What have we got, Sergeant?

A stick-up. One man. He shot and killed a counterman. The victim's name is Vantella, Louis Day. The hold-up man went around behind the counter to get the money. Vantella started the fight with him. Two shots and he fell. He was dead when the ambulance got him. I notified the ME's on his way. After he shot him, the stick-up man threw the gun down and ran out. There it lays.

Who are those people Lieutenant King is talking to?

Witnesses, Captain. They were in the place when it happened, the three of them. The lieutenant was out on patrol and heard the radio call.

Well, you don't need all of these men here, Sergeant. Get some of them back on patrol. The emergency job is in effect at midnight. Notifications to be made.

Yes, sir. That's your car number three, white.

All I'm asking you to do is tell them...

Oh, hello, Captain.

Matt?

Are you a captain?

Is a captain higher than a lieutenant?

Yeah.

I make a perfectly straightforward statement, Captain, and this lieutenant won't believe me.

Now, Sarah, dear.

Don't be fair on me.

We'll go over it again in a minute, Mrs. Trecheter. You just sit down in that booth for a minute.

Well, that's the way it is.

Sarah, please.

A lot of thanks you get for your cooperation.

How many witnesses was that, Matt?

That's Mr. and Mrs. Trecheter and that fellow there.

Did you talk to him?

I'm afraid he's not in a talking condition, Captain.

You think you can tell me your name now, mister?

Uh, what's my name got to do with it? All I want is another cup of coffee, black. That's all I want.

What's your name?

My name is, uh, Arthur J. Bookham. J., believe it or not, it's a January. Yeah, that's right. I was born in January, so my mother...

Did you see what occurred here tonight?

What?

Did you see what occurred here tonight?

Uh, yes and no. A no and yes. All I want is a cup of coffee, black.

All right, Bookham, just sit here a minute.

You know, he's going to be a big help.

Now, where's my coffee?

Yeah, he sure is.

All right, Mrs. Trecheter, now we can talk.

It's certainly about time, Sarah. I told you not to stare at me.

Now, Mrs. Trecheter, how old would you say this man was?

Oh, I couldn't say exactly. Somewhere between 25 and 35. Closer to 25.

You told me he was 5 foot 8 or 9 inches tall.

Who told you that? Not me. I distinctly said he was at least 6 feet. My husband said he was 5 foot 8 or 9.

That's all he was, Sarah.

He was 6 feet if he was an inch.

He weighed about 160.

I couldn't say what he weighed. I'm not a judge of that.

About 160.

Blonde hair.

Yeah, sort of balding. Very thin on top.

Sarah, my impression, he had a full head of hair.

Where'd you get that impression?

Well, I saw him.

Well, when he went behind the counter, he wasn't that far from me. He was balding. I made a distinct point of remembering.

But Sarah...

Well, they're straightened out, folks. Let's not worry about that point now. Matt, can I see you for a minute?

Yeah, sure.

Well, I say he was balding. Why?

The victim was going to be more help.

Listen, Matt, you know the emergency chart is in.

Yes, I heard. We've got about 40 notifications to make.

Wouldn't hurt you any here if I pulled off Sergeant Collins and his operator and got them back on patrol. That'll leave you two of my men. All right?

Sure, that's fine, Captain.

Good. Well, looks like you've got a rough job here, Matt. Those witnesses aren't going to be much help.

No, sir, not much. At least they agreed on one thing. It was a man.

Before I left, two detectives from Manhattan East Homicide arrived to aid the 21st Squad in their investigation. Also on hand in another few minutes were an assistant district attorney, a deputy medical examiner, fingerprint and ballistics experts from a police laboratory, and a police photographer. The investigation was well underway when I was called to a meeting at Division Headquarters. At 2:40, I returned to the 21st and went on patrol. When I returned to the station house, I went to sleep on the couch in my office. At 7:30, the attendant woke me up according to instructions I had left. Brought in a cup of black coffee from the sergeant's locker room and the morning papers. The two tabloids played the homicide very big. I drank the coffee, then I went to the washstand to shave.

All right. Good morning, Captain.

Oh. Oh, Matt. You get any place with your witnesses?

Oh, hardly any place at all. Mr. Arthur J. for January Bookham never was any help, and Mr. and Mrs. Preston are awfully conceited.

Oh, sorry, Matt. What'd you say?

I said Bookham never was any help.

Huh?

By the time we got a straight story out of Mr. and Mrs. Preston.

Oh, yeah. Oh, yeah. Oh, yeah. Oh, yeah. Oh, yeah. Oh, yeah. Oh, yeah.

It was too late to take them downtown to BCI to look at mugs. They're coming in today, all of them.

Well, how about fingerprints on the gun?

Well, no fingerprints that could help us, but there might be something to the gun.

Yeah?

It was purchased and registered by a machine shop in Yonkers. Night watchman is a retired cop. He carries it on the job. The gun was stolen out of his locker last week.

Any idea who stole it?

Yes, sir. A fella quit his job in the shop that same day, a fella named Joe Erich. He's the one I'd like to talk to.

Any reason outside of the fact that he quit his job?

Yes, sir. He did once before for armed robbery.

That sounds good, Matt. You got an address on him?

We've got an address, Captain, but he's not there. It hasn't been for a week, excuse me. 21st Precinct, Captain Kennelly. Yes, Sergeant. What's it about? Would he say that? All right, Sergeant, put him on. This is Captain Kennelly. That's right. I told you I was. What is it you want? What's your name? You do the talking.

Matt, get on it.

Okay. Where are you now, mister, who said you wanted to give yourself up on Central Park West or on Fifth Avenue? Yes, but listen, I tried to keep him on the phone.

Who was it?

The man says he's the killer, wants to give himself up. I have to meet him in an hour.

Well, that's the way it goes. He can break your back on these things when they walk in the front door.

What difference does it make, Matt, as long as they walk in?

Little that surprises the police officer. If a man calls in and says he's the killer, you believe him until you learn differently. I was on the bench. Facing 64th Street, just outside the Central Park wall, five minutes early. Lieutenant Matt King had planted detectives behind the wall in automobiles on both Fifth Avenue and 64th Street and on the sidewalk. The weather was fair, the street full of strollers. I watched the approach of every pedestrian coming from either direction. They all passed. Finally, a carelessly dressed and hatless man who looked in his middle 30s turned off the walk and came toward the bench.

Do you mind if I share this bench?

If you're that captain waiting for it.

Let's go right ahead.

Thank you. Still want to give myself up. I couldn't sleep a wink last night. My conscience, soul lying in a pool of blood.

What's your name?

My name is Audley. Selwyn Audley. I don't know how I could have done it. I came from such a fine old family. It must have been a compulsive reaction.

What did you do with the knife?

What knife?

The knife you stabbed him with.

Oh, that knife. I threw it down the sewer.

Where?

I haven't any idea.

You remember how many times you stabbed him?

Several times. Again and again and again. I don't know.

You should remember. Who were you waving to, please?

Oh, just some friends of mine.

Stabbed him again and again and again with blood from head to foot.

Everything okay, Captain?

Yeah, just fine.

How do you do?

Matt, this is Mr. Selwyn Audley.

How are you?

He says he stabbed that counterman to death in cold blood.

I belong in jail.

We have a nice jail for you, Mr. Audley.

You do?

I know where you're sending me. You're not sending me to jail. You're sending me to Bellevue.

Well, we'll go talk it over, Mr. Audley. I proved to them I was all right. I proved to them I was fine. You can't fool me. I've been there before.

Oh, that's good, Mr. Audley. You know your way around.

The police are always interested in help from citizens, but sorting the useful information from the irrelevant often takes hundreds of man hours of investigation. On the way back, Lieutenant King told me he had obtained mug shots of the principal suspect, Joe Erich, from the Yonkers Police Department. And had sent for the three witnesses in the case for a further interview. Detectives of the Homicide Squad and the 21st Squad had paired off and were now at work trying to locate the suspect.

At the station house, I walked around behind the desk to find the brother.

How long do you think they'll keep the emergency chart in, Captain?

Until the trouble gets settled.

Thank you, Captain. And did those promotions come through yet, Sergeant?

No, sir, not yet.

Well, and so are they.

Well, you don't think they'll hold them up because of the emergency, do you?

I might.

You got any idea where you'll be attached if you're made?

No, sir, I haven't any idea. But in the Bronx someplace, I hope. If I could save 20 or 25 minutes traveling time each day, that'd be a help.

Hey, listen, where am I supposed to go?

What do you mean, where are you supposed to go?

My wife, she told me a detective called and said I was supposed to come down here. I was supposed to...

Mr. Bookham, you were a witness to a homicide last night. Why didn't you do the decent thing and sober up so you could help the detectives out this morning?

Why, dear sir, if I was like this then and I was sober now, how could I... I remember what happened when I was like this, huh? Would you answer me that?

Shall I call upstairs and have them come get him, Captain?

Come get me and take me where?

Don't lean on the desk, can't you read the sign?

Read it? I can't even see it.

All right, I'll take him outside then.

Oh, blaze up. I keep asking you that question and I cannot get a satisfactory answer. I just simply cannot get a satisfactory answer.

Well, Mr. Bookham, that puts us both in the same boat. Neither can we.

I took the witness through the back room and helped him negotiate the narrow and worn stairs to the second floor. Inside the office of the 21st Squad, I walked him straight to Lieutenant King's door.

Captain Kennelly and friends.

Captain Kennelly and friends.

Hello, Captain. Well, here's your witness, man.

Good morning, Mr. Bookham.

Good morning, good morning. It's a wonderful morning. I... It's boys, Mr. Bookham.

Well, what do I do, huh? Tell me what I have to do and I'll pitch right in. I'll just pitch right in.

I think you ought to go home and pitch right in bed.

Huh? Hey, I just got up.

All right, snow back. See that Mr. Bookham finds a comfortable place to wait until we need him.

Go sit over there, Mr. Bookham.

Over here?

This way, that way.

Well, too bad, man. I've got Mr. and Mrs. Fessinger in, Captain. I think they'll be helpful. You got time to come in?

Yeah, sure.

Mr. and Mrs. Fessinger, you remember Captain Kennelly from last night?

Yes, of course. Good morning, Captain.

Good morning. Captain, I've told Mr. and Mrs. Fessinger that we have a suspect in mind in connection with what happened last night.

You've got him in mind or you've got him in jail?

So far, just in mind.

That's two different things.

I know.

Well, I have a half dozen photographs here. I'd like you to look at them and see if you can identify the man who held up the restaurant and shot Mr. Van Teller.

If you have his picture there, I'll identify him.

All right.

Richard?

Oh, Sarah. You know what you said.

All right. It's all right. You'll remember that last night there was some question.

Between Sarah and myself, I thought the man had a flat hair and he said he was balding.

Yes, I remember.

You remember, too, Captain?

Yes, I remember.

Well, after we got home, we had some discussion on the subject and I came to the conclusion that Sarah was right. He was balding.

Well, we'll see about that. Now, Mrs. Fessinger, I'm going to ask you to look through these pictures and see if you can identify the man. Would you please?

Yes.

No, not this one. This is not at all like him. No. No. Well, this one has him. He's got a full head of hair. That couldn't be him.

Sure, as I'm sitting here, this is the one.

Richard?

We'll get to him.

You're positive, Mrs. Fessinger?

I told you. I'm sure as I'm sitting here.

Yes.

All right. Thank you. May I have the pictures, please?

Yes.

Now, Mrs. Fessinger, I'm going to shuffle these.

Yes.

Richard?

Now, don't make a fool out of me.

Mrs. Fessinger, would you please look through these pictures and see if you can identify the man who shot Mr. Vantella?

Yes.

Here you are.

Well, it's not that one. He wasn't even sure. He got a good one. Look.

Yes, I was.

No.

Have you been in the police department very long, Captain?

Yes, ma'am. Quite a long time.

No.

Do you enjoy your work?

This is him. This is the man.

Which one?

Let's see, Mrs. Fessinger.

This one.

Well, I see we agree, Richard. At last, we agree on something.

I just picked out the man that did it. That's all.

Well, I thank you both. You've been very helpful.

Helpful? The murder's solved. It's all over.

Not quite, Mrs. Fessinger. We've still got to find the man.

After the identification of the suspect photographed by two witnesses, Lieutenant King assigned four additional detectives to the job of tracing Joe Erich. He told me that with the help of Yonkers' detectives, his men were checking on all the known friends and acquaintances of the suspect in that community just beyond the New York City limits.

A few minutes later, I returned to the muster room. The teletype was clattering away. Both Sergeant Klein and Sergeant Collins were reading the communication as it bounded out.

The promotions are coming through, Captain.

Oh? What'd they make?

Five captains. And so far, six lieutenants.

Calm down, you're in.

I'll believe it when I see it.

Hope, that's a friend of mine. We were partners in the tents for a while.

What did the order say?

Uh, code signal 19. The following sergeants have been promoted to the rank of lieutenants. Are transferred and assigned as indicated to take effect immediately. All are instructed to report to the office of the chief clerk at 9 a.m. for the issuance of lieutenant's shields and swearing-in ceremonies.

All right, Collins, I'll take it, sir.

It's like waiting for a baby.

21st Precinct, Sergeant Collins. That's 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8.

All right, keep taking it.

Sawyer, that's another friend of mine. He got what he wanted. The squad. Did they get to you yet?

No, not yet. This is number 10 coming.

Oh, there you are. Congratulations, lieutenant.

Oh, thanks.

All right, let's see what the job is. Assigned to 11th Division Headquarters. That's plain clothes work.

Oh, I, uh, I don't know what I wanted to ask. You've got it, though.

Well, at least the job's near home. Congratulations, lieutenant.

Thanks, Captain. I'm, uh, sorry to leave this job. Really sorry.

The teletype machine continued to pound out promotions and went through a list of 23 patrolmen made sergeants. One patrolman from the 21st, Glass, was made and transferred to the 44th. As is customary, both men were relieved of their duties for the rest of the day in order to survive. The detectives secured the uniforms and insignia of their new rank in time for the swearing-in ceremony.

Late that afternoon, Lieutenant King told me they had located a girlfriend of the homicide suspect and were questioning her in the hope of learning the whereabouts of Joe Erich. She insisted she had not seen him. But she gave the detectives the name of another friend, a man. A man was found at his work in Long Island City. He admitted knowing Joe Erich and told the detectives the suspect had recently taken a room on East 63rd Street in the 21st Precinct. The detectives located the house. It was 10 p.m., not 24 hours after the homicide, when I met Lieutenant King on the street nearby in response to a call from him for assistance from the patrol force.

Hello, man.

Captain.

Thanks for the men, Captain. We know this boy is in. The neighbors have heard him. I don't know what he's got up there. He lost a gun last night, but he might have another one. So we better get the street covered before we go up.

Yeah, sure. You said.

Okay. I've got men around in back and two went up to the roof of this building. They'll have a chance to find him.

All right, let's go.

Okay, Lieutenant.

Klein got made a lieutenant.

Yes, sir, I heard. I hate to lose him. He's a good man.

Open up. Get away from there. Open up. Come on down, Joe. Call on your wife. Come on down.

Get him, Matt.

He didn't put a deal.

Ah, you're right. The only trouble is, you found it out a little late.

21st Precinct, Sergeant Collins. Who's missing? Is that your wife? What's your name? How do you spell it? I-N? I-N? Where is it you live? 502? What floor?

And so it goes, around the clock, through the week, every day, every year. A police precinct in the city of New York is a flesh-and-blood merry-go-round. Anyone can catch the brass ring, or the brass ring can catch anyone.

Drive to New York. A factual account of the way the police work in the world's largest city is presented with the official cooperation of the Patrolmen's Benevolent Association, an organization of more than 20,000 members of the Police Department, City of New York. Everett Sloane in the role of Captain Kennelly, Ken Lynch as Lieutenant King. Features in tonight's cast were Lawson Zerbe, Jack Grimes, Edgar Staley, Bob Dryden, Joe DeSantis, and Barbara Weeks. Written and directed by Stanley Nist. Produced by John Ives. Gaylord Avery speaking.

End of transcriptBack to the beginning ↑