The written record
Read the transcript
Read along with the recording · About 22 min to read
What is the girl? 16. Where is it? Yeah, 75th and the base.
You are in the muster room at the 21st Precinct, the nerve center. A call is coming through. You will follow by transcription the action taken pursuant to that call from this minute until the final report is written in the 124 room at the 21st Precinct.
All right. The officer's on the way over there now. You wait outside for them. Show them where it is. An ambulance, too. An ambulance is coming. All right. They'll be there right away.
21st Precinct. It's just lines on a map of the city of New York. Most of the 173,000 people wedged into the nine-tenths of a square mile between Fifth Avenue and the East River wouldn't know if you asked them that they lived or worked in the 21st. Whether they know it or not, the security of their homes, their persons, and their property is the job of the men of the 21st Precinct. The 21st. 160 patrolmen, 11 sergeants, and four lieutenants, of whom I'm the boss. My name is Kennelly, Frank Kennelly. I'm captain in command of the 21st.
I was working my night tour, 4 p.m. to 8 a.m. It was a cold, windy night, and I was on patrol in sector car number two with patrolman Edward Farrell as operator and myself as recorder. It was about 11:30 p.m., and I had instructed Farrell to drive west on 75th Street from First Avenue to Lexington, and then return to the station house where I was due to turn out the platoon for the late tour at midnight. After we crossed First Avenue, there was no traffic in the block ahead of us, and I saw no pedestrians. Cold weather keeps them off the streets. It's a good policeman. Our headlights cut a swath in the darkness as we cruise slowly in the long block toward Second Avenue.
Kennelly, I think he wants us.
Go ahead. Pull up. What's the trouble, Tom?
He's killing us.
Where?
In the basement there.
Let's go, Farrell.
He's killing us.
What's the problem now, mister?
Stay still or you've got plenty more.
He's all right now. Get those hands against the wall. Sit down on the floor. All right. I said sit down on the floor. You won't kill anybody, mister. Watch it.
Let me take a look at her. I'm a police officer. Only a kid, Farrell. Just take it easy. We'll get help. Watch him, Farrell. I'm going to call in for an ambulance.
I got him, sir. Everything okay?
Come on upstairs, Tom.
Yeah, yeah. Okay. You know that girl?
Yeah, sure. She's a true rocker from my building.
This building?
No, the next building. That one. Fourth floor here.
You know him?
No, I never see him.
She live with her folks?
Her folks, yes.
All right. You go upstairs and tell them, okay?
Yeah, yeah. Tell them.
All right. Thank you.
Car 681 to Central, okay? At 3880, 75th Street in the basement. That's right. An assault case. Send an ambulance and assistance, okay?
Within a few minutes, in response to the radio signal, Inspector Car No. 4 and the sergeant's car were on the job. When the call was heard on the radio monitor by the desk officer at the station house, he notified the 21st Squad and Detective Jameson, and Louis DeLuca hurried to the scene. As we waited for the arrival of the ambulance, the assailant, Joe Packett, sat on the floor in a corner of the basement with his back against the wall under the guard of Patrolman Farrell. The victim's mother had been summoned from the apartment. She tried to comfort the girl.
I need you. My baby, my baby. My baby.
Mrs. Troro, don't touch her, please. Where's the doctor?
She's gone. The ambulance is on the way.
Where, where is it?
Mrs. Troro, you... You'd better stand over here.
No.
It'd be better for her.
Come on, Mom.
Mrs. Troro. Yes, all right. The ambulance will be here right away.
Sergeant.
Yes, sir. Oh, baby.
Yes, sir, Captain.
Stay here with the girl.
Yes, sir.
Is that the ambulance?
Yes, I'm sure it is. Let's go over here, Mrs. Troro.
I don't like to leave. I don't like to leave my baby.
Oh, yes, MacLeese. This is the girl's mother, Mrs. Troro, Detective MacLeese.
I'd like to ask you two questions, Mrs. Troro.
Yeah, anything. Yes, sir, baby.
This fellow, this Joe Packett, he said he's known her for a long time.
Oh, six months, maybe seven. But she don't want anything to do with him. He comes around to the house. He scares us off. He brings a bottle of whiskey and sits down in the kitchen. He says he wants to marry her. She don't want anything to do with him.
Well, then why didn't you call the police?
I said once I would. I said, get out or I call the police. He said, what would the police do to him? Nothing. He'd come back and tear up the house. So I didn't... He didn't call. He'd come. Anita would lock herself in the bathroom. We were all scared.
Well, where was she tonight? Did she have a date with him?
Oh, no. She went to a girlfriend's on First Avenue. We do our homework together. She's a good girl, Anita. She goes to school. She wants to learn. She wants to learn to go to business.
They take her where? To a hospital?
Yes.
What hospital? Could I go?
Yes, you can go. I mean, what was he doing? Was he waiting for her on the street?
I guess. I don't know. I want to help.
Let's leave it to them, Mrs. Troro. They know what they're doing.
All right, easy. Easy. Put her on.
My baby, my poor baby. Oh, Mom. Oh.
All right, all right. Come to the house. He said, where is she? I said, out. He sat down with a bottle of whiskey for two, three hours. I was scared.
Now, watch the turn there, easy.
All right, listen. Up with her. He said he'd kill her. I mean, I was glad he went. Easy now. Keep it high.
Can I go with her? Can I?
Uh, Sergeant.
Yes, sir.
See that Mrs. Troro gets over to the hospital.
Yes, sir.
Wait. Wait for me.
You can call her to the mother later, Captain MacLeese.
Oh, yes, sir. Right now, I want to talk to that bum over there. All right, you men. Don't stand around here. Get back on patrol.
How's he doing, pal?
All the same, Captain. He's no seven.
All right, you get on your feet. You put it very tight. Get on your feet.
My praise.
Yes, Captain. What's your name?
T-A-K-U-S.
And where do you live?
East 81st Street. 86.
What do you do to justify your existence?
What do you mean?
Have you got a job?
Yeah, I work.
Where?
Different places. Contractors. I'm a plaster.
How old are you?
27.
27, huh?
Yeah.
Well, you'll grow gray by the time you're through with this one, mister. I'll keep you to leave that family alone. I'll keep you to stay away from 16-year-old girls.
I want to marry her. I love her.
That's a fine way to show her you love her, isn't it? Almost killing her. You're no good. You're plain no good.
I was a little...
Oh, that's a great excuse, isn't it? You get half in the bag and you think you own the world. Well, I'll show you what you own. You don't own any part of it. You don't even own your own time.
All right, Max. Take it easy. He should be in the hospital, not her. That's enough.
Joe, what are you coming around here making trouble for that family? They told you they didn't want anything to do with you.
I want her. I want to marry the girl. She won't speak to me. She won't see me. She'll go out with other guys.
All right, I'm waiting for her tonight. To talk. We're just to talk. When I saw her, she tried to go away. She wouldn't talk. Okay, sister. You won't talk. You'll do what I tell you.
You threw her down on the cellar and you beat her up and you almost killed her. And she might die.
Yeah, it was a whiskey. I didn't mean it.
16-year-old girl. 16?
I don't know. I don't care. I want to marry. She's a woman.
And you're a man, huh? Well, not in my book, mister. In my book, you're enough. A great big typer.
The suspect, Joe Packett, was taken to the station house in the custody of Patrolman Farrell, the first officer on the scene. Detective MacLeese rode with them in Sector Car No. 2 and I returned in the sergeant's car just in time to turn out the platoon for the late tour at midnight. At the station house, Packett was taken upstairs to the 21st Squad, still in the custody of Patrolman Farrell. There, he would be questioned further by detectives and on completion of the investigation, booked in on charges of felonious assault.
As the senior officer on duty in the 6th Division, during the night, I was called to the 25th Precinct, where a three-alarm fire in a loft building had caused the evacuation of two tenements. It was 2:20 a.m. when I returned to the 21st Precinct and walked into the muster room and around the desk to sign the blotter.
Hello, Sergeant.
Captain. Captain. Red. 21st Precinct, Sergeant Collins.
What about that choro girl in the hospital, Red? How bad is she?
Two broken ribs, Captain. Her face is pretty badly cut up. No internal injuries, I don't think.
Mm-hmm. Lieutenant Gorman, Eisman's bringing in. He made that notification on York Avenue. He got hold of the brother.
Okay.
All right, Eisman. Did they book that guilt Packett yet, Red?
No, sir, not yet. They still got him upstairs.
Mm-hmm. What about Sal?
He's still there. As soon as he's booked in, he'll get a couple of hours' sleep before he has to go to court with him.
That's a mean one, that guy, Captain. Sixteen-year-old girl.
Yeah. I'll be in my office, Red.
Yes, sir. 21st Precinct, Sergeant Collins.
Hello, Sergeant.
Yeah, all right. You take your meal now, all right?
Okay. That's it, Captain.
Sergeant, I'll tell you what. I want you to... What's that? In the back room. Come on, Sergeant.
Yes, sir.
Somebody fell down the steps.
Yes, sir. That's what happened.
What happened, Max?
He tripped and fell down the whole flight of stairs.
Did he?
He fell. He fell like a light.
What's going on? What's happened? Where were you, Sal?
You sure a prisoner?
Well, Captain, we're... Wait a second.
Thank you. Thank you, Sergeant. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you, Sergeant. Thank you, Sergeant. Thank you, Sergeant. Thank you for an ambulance, will you?
Yes, sir. Right away, sir.
Well, he's out, all right.
All right, Sal. Where were you?
Oh, we were taking him down to book him. He left his hat in the squad room. I went back inside for it.
You were alone with him, MacLeese.
That's right, Captain. Yes, sir.
How'd he fall?
I don't know. He tripped, I guess.
Did he? On what?
Captain, I didn't lay a hand on him. If anybody deserved to get thrown down those stairs, he did, but I didn't lay a hand on him.
We'll find out about that, MacLeese. We'll find out about that right away.
Through 21st Precinct, a factual account of the way police work in the world's largest city. Since 1910, the work output of each of us has more than doubled. In the same period, machine power has increased four and a half times, and the average annual income from $2,400 a year to about $4,000 a year in equivalent purchases. In spite of all this, about 18 hours has been cut off the average work week in the same period. Those facts are but a few in the great story of our American economic system, a story that adds up to this for all of us. The better we produce, the better we live.
Now back to 21st Precinct, I'm Captain Frank Kennelly.
Any unusual occurrence concerning a prisoner, injury, death, escape, or attempted suicide is a grave matter. The commanding officer of the precinct concerned is required to make an immediate and thorough investigation and forward his report to the office of the chief inspector and the New York State Commission.
No correction. Joe Packett did not regain consciousness by the time the ambulance arrived. He was taken to Bellevue Hospital. In the meantime, I had instructed the desk officer, Lieutenant Gorman, to telephone Lieutenant Matt King, commander of the 21st Detective Squad, at his home and inform him of the incident. Lieutenant King was at the station house within 25 minutes and sat in my office as I questioned first Patrolman Farrell.
Oh, sir, I didn't leave him for a minute, not since I brought him in.
You got him into the station house about five minutes of 12.
Yes, sir... How come you didn't bring him downstairs to be booked until 25 after 2?
Well, MacLeese was conducting an investigation, Captain.
Well, there wasn't much investigation that needed conducting, was there? You were an eyewitness to the assault, so was I.
Yes, sir.
Then you had another witness, that old man that stopped you.
Yes, sir.
Did MacLeese make any threats against him?
Joe Packett's up in the squad room.
No, sir.
You just talked to him calmly?
Well, not exactly calmly, Captain. MacLeese didn't think much of him.
I heard... What?
Did either you or he use any violence in the squad room?
No, sir.
Well, then when you started downstairs to book him, what happened?
Well, we came out of the squad room and into the hall. I heard Packett's body. As soon as we got outside, MacLeese said his hat... He left his hat inside.
Whose hat?
Joe Packett's.
Didn't Packett say anything about it?
No, sir. I guess he forgot.
So you went back for his hat?
Yes, sir.
That was your prisoner, Farrell. You weren't supposed to leave him.
But it was just that. When we got back in the squad room, we were out in the hall. I didn't really leave him, Captain.
And when you came out with the hat, Packett was down at the bottom of the stairs.
Yes, sir.
You were in the squad room with Packett all the time? Between about midnight and 2:25?
Yes, sir.
Was it MacLeese?
No, sir.
Where'd he go?
Well, when we first got there, he printed Packett. Then we went into your office, Lieutenant. MacLeese started to question him.
He didn't touch him, is that... No, sir. He didn't hit him or murder him. But he didn't touch him.
Then about 1 o'clock, MacLeese went out.
Where'd he go?
I don't know, Captain. He said he'd be back. We'd book him in when he got back. I just stayed there with Packett until he came back.
About ten minutes after 2.
Any more questions, man?
No, sir.
All right, Farrell. That's all.
Yes, sir.
He didn't go on home. Packett won't be going to court tomorrow.
How is it, Captain?
We're waiting to hear.
Thank you very much.
Yes, sir. Tell MacLeese to come in here.
Looks like a rough spot, doesn't it?
I'm sure it's timed out right.
Yeah. I'm kind of anxious to hear what Packett says this thing. I mean, he was unconscious when they took him out of here. He was unconscious when they got him to the hospital. He might not get to hear what he has to say.
It doesn't look good for him, man. He was an awful wallop on the head, he took.
Come in.
Yes, Captain. Oh.
Sit down over here, MacLeese.
Yes, sir.
Lieutenant MacLeese, sit down.
Yes, sir.
You're in a jam, huh?
I'm not in a jam, Lieutenant.
What do you call it?
Excuse me?
Yes, sir. 21st Precinct, Captain Kennelly.
Okay.
Yes, sir.
Pain consciousness?
No, sir.
All right, then. If you hear anything else, ring in here, hmm?
Yes, sir.
How is he, Captain?
Possible fractured skull.
Why did you push him down those stairs?
MacLeese, I've been in command of this precinct two years. Every day, 24 hours a day, people go up and down those stairs. There's all kinds of people. Cops, complainants, drunks, narcotics addicts, everything. In two years, the only man to... Fall down those stairs is somebody you've been holding back your temper on all night. From top to bottom, he fell and fractured his skull.
I didn't lay a hand on him, Captain. And it happens just when you send the only possible witness back into the squad room for a hat. Nobody around, only you.
He tripped and fell, Captain. I didn't touch him.
You were itching through all night, though, weren't you, MacLeese?
Well, who wouldn't? I'm only human. That guy weighs almost 200 pounds, and he's no good. He's not even near human. He beat a 16-year-old girl within this far of killing her, and he would have killed her.
Listen. The captain and Farrell didn't jump him. So what am I supposed to do? Love a guy like this like a brother? I want to see him get what's coming to him.
That's just the point, exactly. You're a cop, that's all. You're not the grand jury. It's not up to you to see that he gets what's coming to him. Your job is to bring him and the facts before the people who decide that. Not to put yourself up on a throne and decide who's right and who's wrong. That's not your job. Get that through your head.
Yes, sir.
Did you throw him down the stairs?
No, sir. He tripped and fell.
Where'd you go about 1 o'clock?
I went out for a meal, sir. I went out for a meal, sir.
Where else? You were gone over an hour.
Bellevue Hospital.
Why?
To interview the victim and her mother.
Did you?
I saw the mother, Captain, and the victim was still in the treatment room.
You didn't need the mother or the girl. You had two police officers and a novel civilian as eyewitness.
Yes, sir.
There wasn't any doubt in your mind that on Farrell's testimony alone, Packett would be held without bail for the grand jury, was there?
No, sir.
Well, then why did you have to go to the hospital at that point?
I don't know, Captain. I thought I ought to get the girl's story.
This was a felony case. Did you call the sister's attorney?
No, sir.
Why not? It was your instructions, wasn't it?
It looked open and shut to me.
It looked open and shut to me, too, MacLeese. I've got the same feeling about it.
After the interview with Detective MacLeese, Lieutenant King instructed him to return to his duty. At 3:30 a.m., Lieutenant King and I drove to Bellevue Hospital where we found the mother of the assault victim waiting in the corridor. Mrs. Troro told us her daughter was at last asleep and that she intended to wait at the hospital for any word about her condition. We said nothing of the injury to Joe Packett to the mother. In order to talk to her, we suggested that she have something to eat. She went with us to a nearby all-night luncheonette.
Do you want something else besides the soup, Mrs. Troro?
No, it's enough just the soup.
Some coffee?
No, nothing. Oh, the poor baby. I don't understand how she happened to get involved with this guy. How did that happen?
Her girlfriend knew him. They met. He wanted to come to see her to take her on dates and so forth. She didn't want to. She didn't want anything to do with him. She used to come in the house, breaking on me, grump like a maniac. It scared her. Scared me. Hit me in the kitchen and holler. He wants to marry her. Pushed me around. I was scared of him.
Well, you don't have to worry about him anymore.
I'm still scared. Believe me, Mr. Kennelly. He's got brothers. He goes to jail. He's been there. He's been there. He's been there. He's been there. He's got brothers. They're just as bad. One came with him once to the house. Just as bad. I don't want anything more to do with him. I'm moved. I take Anita. It's just the two of us. That's all.
He'll be in jail?
No, that's worse. The brothers will find us. I don't want anything to do with sending him to jail. I told the detective that. I said to him before.
Detective MacLeese?
Yes, MacLeese. I told him I didn't want anything to do with it.
And what did he say?
He said not to be scared. I don't have to. He said Joe Packett would be fixed. Fixed. Good. Nobody would bother us. Not anymore.
Fixed good, huh?
Yeah. I told him, don't fix him. When the brothers come around, they fix us. I told him.
Maybe I ought to go back to the hospital. This is very nice, but maybe Anita wakes up. And where am I? Very for soup and soup.
Yeah, all right. Then we go, huh?
Yes.
I'm going to ring in, man. Order me another cup of coffee, will you?
All right, Captain. I'll be right back.
Very for soup. For a restaurant.
Now, Sergeant.
I guess he isn't dead, Roosevelt.
We drove downtown to Bellevue Hospital. We drove into the grounds at 30th Street and Franklin D. Roosevelt Drive and parked the car. Ward on the second floor of I Building is under supervision of the Department of Corrections. As we were admitted through the bar gate to the room.
What does that make you, beating up a 16-year-old girl? Tell us how you came to fall down the stairs.
Well, I have nothing to do with you.
You've got plenty to do with us. Tell us about how you got hurt.
What is going to hit you? Stay in here on my back. Hit me. Go. I'll get more.
Get more what?
Money, that's what. I'll get money. I'm going to sue through the city. I'll take them over to the cold head treatment.
What kind of treatment?
Never mind. I'll take it up with my lawyer.
What's flapping that girl around? Can do for that?
Nothing. I ain't worried. I'll take only half the money I'm going to sue for and the city will be glad to get off the hook.
Get off with nothing.
All right, I'll go to Florida.
You've got great ambition. I guess we'll pin a medal on you, too.
I wouldn't be surprised.
He's dead to right. They can't do that.
You don't seem hurt, MacLeese.
Yeah, well, the pain.
What makes you think you're entitled to sue the stairs? The detective said you tried to break away from him and missed the top step.
That's it. Get up with my lawyer. I'm trying to break away. Don't let him tell you I was. He's lying.
I don't think so.
I wasn't. I was walking down as quiet as you could. The heel of my shoe. That's the city's fault, ain't it? I tripped and I... That's not what happened.
What's the truth now?
I caught it on the step. I fell. I tripped on something that was sticking up. I tripped. I tripped. I tripped and fell. The city has to pay for that, don't they?
If he wouldn't tell you what happened, he don't like me. He don't want me to collect.
Doesn't he? Like he never beat up a woman. Big man. Get him to tell you the truth. Big night, man.
You know, I've got to admit it. I thought my police gave him at least a little help down those stairs.
Thank you, boys.
Is that a lie, man?
Yes.
He shouldn't try to be judge and jury or something, man.
It's Sergeant Collins, girl. What's the address? Oh, which way did they go? What color?
And so it goes. Around the clock, through the week, every day, every... Precinct in the city of New York is a flesh and blood merry-go-round. I can catch the brass ring. The brass ring can catch anyone.
21st Precinct. A transcribed factual account of the way the police work in the world's largest city. It's presented with the official cooperation of the Patrolmen's Benevolent Association, an organization of more than 20,000 members of the Police Department, City of New York. Everett Sloane in the role of Captain Kennelly. Ken Lynch as Lieutenant King. Featured in tonight's cast were Bill Quinn, Louis Van Rooten, Phil Sterling, Joan Morgan, Barbara Weeks, Jack Orrison, and John Larkin. Written and directed by Stanley Nitz. For CBS Radio, by John Ives. Bob Hille speaking.
