The written record
Read the transcript
Read along with the recording · About 17 min to read
21st Precinct, Sergeant Waters. Yeah. Who is it, his wife? Do they live there? Well, can't somebody stop him from beating her up? What's the address there? Yeah. Yeah.
You are in the muster room at the 21st Precinct, the nerve center. A call is coming through. You will follow the action taken pursuant to that call from this minute until the final report is written in the 124 room at the 21st Precinct.
All right. I'll send the officers right over there. Yeah, don't worry about it. They'll be right there.
It's just lines on a map of the city of New York. The 173,000 people with the nine-tenths of a square mile between Fifth Avenue wouldn't know if you asked them that they lived or worked in the 12 of the men of the 21st Precinct. The 21st. 160 patrolmen, 11 sergeants, and four lieutenants, of whom I'm the boss. My name is Kennelly, Frank Kennelly. I'm captain in command of the 21st. I was working my night tour, 4 p.m. to 8 a.m. 33 patrolmen were assigned to regular post, which they were. Ten others were assigned as operators and recorders in the precinct's five sector cars. These men were under the direct supervision of three sergeants. Sergeant Tierney on telephone switchboard duty in the station house. Sergeant Rosen on foot in congested districts. Sergeant Waters on radio motor patrol, operated by patrolmen. The sergeants were directly responsible to Lieutenant Gorman, the desk officer on the job.
One of the functions of the sergeant on radio motor patrol was to respond to every call within the confines of the precinct broadcast by the Manhattan Communications. The reason for this is twofold. To provide adequate supervision at the scene of an occurrence, and to ensure the immediate response of sufficient manpower in the event the occurrence is of a more serious nature than the original call that the police indicated.
Until 5 p.m., a radio call was broadcast for sector car number three. A disturbance in the hallway at 762 East 74th Street. As sometimes happens, the sergeant's car was closer to the scene and the first to arrive.
Let's go.
Yes, sir.
See anything?
Cops, lady? Cops is with me.
What's the trouble?
Him. The crazy one. Third floor to the rear.
Yeah?
He was beating her and kicking her and pulling her up the stairs.
Who?
His wife, the poor thing. It's all quiet now. He must have settled it.
Oh, he probably settled it by killing her. That's how he accepted it. Crazy. He's crazy enough to kill her.
What's their name?
Gerard. Mr. and Mrs. Gerard. He never seen anything like the way he beats up that poor woman.
Did any of the other neighbors hear this?
Oh, I don't know whether they did or not. I don't know whether they care, even. All I know is that I'm tired of it. It's sick. I'm sick. He comes home crazy and beats her to an inch of her life. Tonight in the hall. Bad enough in their own flat, but tonight he has to do it in the hall.
There's only one flat in the rear on the third floor?
Yes, that's all. Just one apartment. He ought to be locked up for good, that man. Or better, sent back to the insane asylum. That's where he belongs.
Was he there?
Well, I wouldn't say a thing like that if he wasn't.
Oh, he's that way, all right. He don't like my cat. I think he poisoned one once. I think he poisoned Cynthia. I think he poisoned my cat. I think he poisoned Cynthia. I think he poisoned Cynthia. I think he poisoned Cynthia. I think he poisoned Cynthia. I think he poisoned Cynthia. I think he poisoned Cynthia. I swear it was him.
Yeah. Well, it seems to have quietened down now, but we'll go up and talk to him.
Ask him if he didn't poison Cynthia. I bet he denies it. I just bet he does.
What's your name, lady?
Mrs. Edgar. Mrs. Helen Edgar. E-S-C-H-E-R.
He had no business poisoning Cynthia. No business at all.
All right, Mrs. Edgar. You get back inside and we'll get back to you.
I'm sorry. I'm sorry. I'm sorry. I'm sorry. I'm sorry. I'm sorry. I'm sorry. I'm sorry. I'm sorry. I'm sorry. I'm sorry. I'm sorry. I'm sorry. Oh, I'm bad. I have no inkling that and we'll take care of it. You send him back to that instant asylum now. That's where he belongs. You send him back there.
Close the door. We'll see in a minute.
I will, but don't you forget.
We'll see you young man. We won't forget.
Why? I thought you promised.
Okay. Oh, it's going to be a great debate as to Sascha and his case, Sergeant.
Yeah. Right on the mailbox there. to it. That's a good way to get your neck broken, skates in a dark hall. The carriages are bad enough, but at least you can't miss being quiet in there. You've probably got an oversized imagination.
Officers, we want to talk to you.
About what?
You can't yell in the hall.
Open the door.
I'm not going to open the door.
Now listen, I think you were causing a disturbance straight now to open the door.
You better go away and leave me alone.
Where's your wife? Is she in there?
Go away, will you please?
Is your wife in there with you?
Warning you now, go away.
Look, Mr. Gerard.
Go away. Get out. Stay against the wall. I want you to go away. You've got to go.
Go on downstairs and ring in. Tell them we've got a psycho with a gun here.
Yes, sir.
Wait a minute. Send Micah through the basement or around the building to get into the rear courtyard. I want to make sure this guy doesn't go out the window back there.
I'll get going.
Okay, sir.
You better go away. I mean it. You're the worst. What do you say about coming out here and talking, Mr. Gerard?
I warned you to go away. I warned you.
I think it's in his head. That's where the trouble is. The neighbor downstairs said he was beating up his wife in the hall. He called in. We knocked on the door and he's been shooting through it. I think his wife's in there.
I don't want to hurt you. I want you to go up to the roof and come down the fire. It's on the other window. I just want you to sit there and see that he doesn't go out that way. Open that window until we find out what's with the wife.
I'll get going.
Just to type that.
Yes, sir.
Are you still there? Don't you believe? Why don't you open the door and talk?
Get away from the door. Don't you touch it. I know better than you are. The door she does is to make me trouble. She makes me trouble from the minute I wake up in the morning.
Yeah. Well, sometimes wives can be like that.
It's not only sometimes. She's like that all the time. All the time. You know what I go through. You don't have any idea. She makes me feel like killing you.
Look, Mr. Gerard. It's not going to get you any place talking.
Stay inside your flat. Stay inside your flat. This is the police.
Just as bad as anybody. Those neighbors don't give you a minute's peace. Not a minute's peace. And they're always taking her side. I'd like them to take her side. What's between a wife and a husband? Is there an affair?
Yeah. I think so. You've got to make them respect you. Because if they don't respect you, you're just like dirt under their feet.
I wouldn't go that far, Mr. Gerard. Sometimes neighbors are good to have.
I'm not talking about neighbors. I'm talking about wives. My wife. You've got to make them respect you.
Well, look. Supposing I come in and we'll talk it over.
Away from there. I don't want to have to kill you.
If you don't want to kill me, we'll talk it over.
I'm warning you.
No. You can't say I didn't warn you.
No, I can't say that. It won't do you any good to count the shots I fire either because I've got a pocket full of bullets and the gun is always loaded. And they're going to run out of bullets. You can put that down in your book.
Sorry, Mr. Gerard. What's your wife doing?
None of your business.
Is she in there?
Of course she's in there. What do you think she'd be? Close yourself down and close to you there. Here?
Yes. Right here. In the living room. I couldn't let you do that.
Why not?
I couldn't let you do it, that's all. I'm sorry about all this. I don't like to cause anyone trouble.
All you gotta do is open the door.
But I guess I've got a good excuse. I was in the state hospital, you know.
Oh? Were you?
That's for people who are sick. A person can have a sick mind just as he can have a sick heart or a sick lung. He's ill. And he can get better. Did you know that?
Yeah. I know it. You've got to see what the doctor told me, and I'm glad you'll realize it. Not many people realize that.
Talk to your wife, Mr. Gerard.
Why do you want to talk to her?
I just wanted to tell her not to worry. I'll give you my word of honor.
I'm opening the door.
Oh, I couldn't do that. And don't you try it either. I warned you before, and I'm warning you again. All right. You better not. You want to know what's good for you? Here's what I'm worried about you.
You don't have to worry about her. You said she was right there. Let's see her side here. Right here, where I killed her.
You wouldn't do a thing.
I did it. I just couldn't stand it another minute. She could have realized that I have feelings, too. After all, she can't take me like that. Somebody's got to respect you or your mouth or nothing in this world. Nothing at all. And they try to make you dig. Dig under their feet. And I'm tired of all that. There comes a day when a man has got to assert himself.
Yeah, Mr. Gerard. And this is pure your day. The largest city.
Now back to 20. Within a few minutes, a radio motor patrolled from the adjoining sector. Detectives and an emergency service car equipped with tools and tear gas responded to the scene. Men were placed on every floor of the building, on the roof, on the fire escape, and in the rear courtyard. Instructions of Lieutenant Matt King, commanding officer of the 21st Detective.
When the second call went out over the radio, I was in the hall on York Avenue, discussing with the manager complaints of rowdiness we had received concerning some of his patrons. The call was heard by Patrolman Farrell, who was waiting downstairs in the car. He came into the manager's office and gave me the information. And after Lieutenant Gorman, the desk officer, gave me whatever information he had, we made the run. Now six departing vehicles on the scene, and the sidewalk was crowded with curious men. Three men were on the job, keeping the crowd moving, as I walked into the building where Patrolman Mercado was posted at the door.
Special Lieutenant King, upstairs.
No, sir, he's down here, in that flat back there. Talking to the woman who called in with the original complaint.
What about the wife?
Oh, the man. Keeps saying he killed her.
Well, Lieutenant King is. Three or four years. I couldn't say exactly. The landlord would know how long they've been here.
Oh, the super. This is Mrs. Helen Escher, Captain Kennelly. Is that her?
How do you do?
Mrs. Escher, you know for a fact that he's been a patient in a mental institution?
Well, his wife told me herself.
Well, so? Where's he worked? Do you know that?
I think it's down in Wall Street someplace, for an insurance company. He doesn't have much of a job. He was the one that brought in most of the money. He was always taking time off. Being sick and things like that. Hanging out at the bar and grill down at the corner there. I knew something like this was going to happen. I could just feel it. But he did to her the cruelest thing, even. He would brush it off and go right on being civil to him. His fitness.
Well, you see what loyalty got her, don't you?
Yeah, not much. I'm telling you, he was beating her within an inch of her life on the stairs. I just couldn't stand by and see her take it like that. I just had to call the police once and for all.
All right, Mrs. Escher. Thank you. You really think he murdered her in cold blood like that?
He says he did. Oh, man. He should have been put away long ago. Long ago. That's what she gets for trying to be loyal. I told her. She can't say I didn't tell her.
Well, we better see what we can do about him.
You be careful now. Don't let him kill you, too. Don't try not to.
OK, Captain.
Yeah. Glad to have left you. Thank you.
All right, you two come with us. You stay down here.
All right. How many shots has he fired, Matt?
Four, Captain.
Mercado.
Yes, sir. Upstairs with us.
Yes, four shots. What, did he shoot his wife?
He don't know how. He killed her, if he did. Mercado and Sergeant Waters were here within two minutes after the call was put out.
All right. Well, Captain. He's hurt no shot. I don't want anybody hurt over this, Matt. I think we can take him without anybody getting hurt.
Hello, Sergeant. You men hold it there. Talking to him, Sergeant?
Yes, sir. Come out now. Give him no sign of it.
Mr. Gerard. What have you got out there? More policemen?
Look, Mr. Gerard. You've got policemen on the fire escape, too. You're making a big mistake, you know. You're forcing me to kill someone else. Well, I don't want to kill anyone else. It's going to be your fault. Everything's going to be your fault.
Well, how about unlocking this door and coming out? Then no one else will get hurt.
You know I'm not going to do that. You'll have to do it if you want to get your wife to the hospital. Anything like that.
My wife is dead. Don't you take me to the hospital. You better go away. Leave me alone.
Captain, he wasn't kidding. I see all four shots came through the door.
Yeah, he meant it all right. Give me a second. Keep your eye on the door, Mercado.
Yes, sir.
I'm getting a little impatient with this guy.
Well, that's better than getting shot.
Yes, sir, it sure is. How much do you think it would take?
Much, Lieutenant. One good boot at the lock. Unless he has an extra bolt on it or a chain.
Well. What's he going to do while I'm kicking the door on him?
He's thinking about having the ESP men crack that Wilson fire escape. If he does any shooting, he'd be toward the fire escape.
Sounds all right, Lieutenant. How am I supposed to know whether he's shooting toward the door or toward the window?
No. Think about the wife. You think she's dead in there?
He keeps saying she is. I believe him.
Situation on the fire.
Okay, Lieutenant. More trouble than a red-hot gunman.
Well, you don't have to worry about hurting the gunman, Matt. And you know you have to take care.
Yes, he is. And keeping those people behind the doors.
Yeah, Lieutenant. Tell me, was he confined, Matt, you know?
Best information we can get. He was up there nearly four years.
Why'd they let him out?
Question I'm going to ask.
The window of the room he's in opens onto the fire escape.
Yes, sir.
Well, maybe we'll be able to work it.
I think so, Captain. Brick walls. They tell shots won't hurt anyone.
No. Who's down there? Staying away from the window?
Yes, sir. They've been able to get a look into the room from the window, Matt?
It's very drawn down to the bottom. The window's locked. They can see if there's a light on in there.
What's the situation?
No change, Lieutenant. I'm going to try something in a few minutes with the window. In the meantime, the front door.
Okay, Lieutenant, fine. It's getting pretty cold out here. Here's how we're going to do it. One ESD man down there has a crowbar to knock out the window. Don't drop the shell shooting this way.
Don't try to come in. He's in the window.
Are you sure he's under control?
Let you know when we're ready.
Okay, Matt. With these men, you handle it. I think all you have to do is know we're set before you break the glass. I'll send a man up to pass the word, okay?
Okay.
The government told me to tell you that Inspector McBride is on his way. See if he's been notified. He'll probably be all over by the time they get here.
Yes, Sergeant? I had a couple of words with him, that's all. Nothing new, Captain. Break the window on the fire and drop in a tear gas shell. We'll kick in the door.
Yes, it's got to be okay. You're right about at the lock. Ought to do the trick.
Yes, sir. That ought to do it. Unless, like I said, he's got a slide fault. He'll still have to do it.
Marcano, King, we're set any time he's ready.
Yes, sir.
Hey, I'm going to stay here forever. I know it's an awful lot of time, but I'm going to stay. So can we.
That's your business.
Yes, sir. I have to do it. Go away and leave me alone. Bothering you? Bother anyone. No one at all. Just go away. That's all you have to do. Get away from there. I'm telling you the truth.
All right, Mr. Gerard.
They don't believe me. They don't respect me. Your arms are done for here.
Precinct, Sergeant Waters. How'd they break in? What's the name of the owner there? Oh, he does, huh? Putting out a call on us? Let me know about that. I'll notify the detectives and let you know.
Precinct in the city of New York is a flesh and blood merry-go-round. You can catch the brass ring. You can catch...
Largest city presented with the official cooperation of the Patrolman's Benevolent Association. ...of more than 20,000 members of the police department, city of New York. It's flown in the role of... CBS Radio. CBS Radio by John Ives.
