The written record
Read the transcript
Read along with the recording · About 24 min to read
21st Precinct, Sergeant Waters. Yeah, where's this? Yeah. Yeah. They beating up a man? Who is? Yeah. Yeah. Which corner is it?
You are in the muster room at the 21st Precinct, the nerve center. A call is coming through. You will follow the action taken pursuant to that call from this minute until the final report is written in the 124 room at the 21st Precinct.
All right. I'll send the officers right over there. Yeah, right away. Okay.
21st Precinct, transcribed. It's just lines on a map of the city of New York. Most of the 173,000 people wedged into the nine-tenths of a square mile between Fifth Avenue and the East River wouldn't know if you asked them that they lived or worked in the 21st. Whether they know it or not, the security of their homes, their persons, and their property is the job of the men of the 21st Precinct. The 21st. 164. Patrolman, 11 sergeants, and four lieutenants, of whom I'm the boss. My name is Kennelly, Frank Kennelly. I'm captain in command of the 21st. I was working my night tour, 4 p.m. to 8 a.m. It had been a busy night in the precinct. Before I turned out the platoon at midnight, there was a three-alarm fire in a tenement on 78th Street, a pedestrian killed by an automobile on Park Avenue, an armed robbery of a delicatessen on 2nd Avenue, and the mugging by two youths of a hospital orderly as he walked from his work to the 77th Street station of the Lexington Avenue subway. Things quieted down after the late tour took over, however, and I was able to stay in the station house and clean up the paperwork, reading and signing reports and communications that normally I would have finished hours earlier. While I was so engaged, patrol of the precinct continued, and among those on the job were patrolman Paul Vaccaro as operator and William Coley as recorder in sector car number three. At 1:10 a.m., they were driving in a downtown direction on 2nd Avenue in the 70s.
Well, I don't know about that. My wife and I looked at some of them out in Jamaica last week. Price hasn't gone up any.
Hasn't gone up any since when?
Since last Christmas.
Are you kidding?
No, I'm telling you.
What, did you look at the large ones?
No, we couldn't get a large one in the house, a medium-sized one.
Where's this place you looked?
Out in Jamaica there on the left.
I don't know, I can't find any bargains.
Well, the fellow told me there wasn't any shortage or anything like that. There's plenty of them around.
Yeah, I see them. They're beating up a guy. Pull in. Let's go.
Come on. Hold up there. Hold up. There they go. There goes one in that doorway. I got him. Get the other guy. Hold up, you. Hold up. You. Come out here. Come on out. Come on. Get out of my way. Come here. Let me go. Hold still. Let go. Get against there. Let me loose. Go on. Get against there now. All right. All right. Settle down. All right, okay. Pull your feet way out.
What do you mean?
You know what I mean. Pull your feet way out and lean against the wall.
What I guess you mean?
Feet out further. Come on. I'll fall. Come on. That's it like that.
Look, I want to tell you something.
You've got plenty of time to tell me anything. Now just hold still.
I got nothing on me. I'm carrying nothing.
I'll find out about that for myself. All right, now stay there.
It was his idea. It was all his idea.
Yeah, yeah, sure, sure. You had to beat up an old man because it was his idea, huh?
It was his idea.
All right. Put your hands behind your back.
I'm leaning with my hands. Why don't I hold on?
Lean on your head. Get those hands behind your back.
Wait a minute. All right, now straighten up.
Hey, look, you've got those things on awful tight.
They're awful tight.
They're going to stay on tight, too. Now tell me something. How old are you, huh?
17.
17. That's all, just 17. Well, in 17 years, you ought to have gotten some sense into your head.
Oh, come on.
All right. Let's see if you'll kill that old man.
I didn't mean to kill him. I didn't want to hurt him. It was his idea. We just wanted to get some money. It was Ernie's idea.
It's making a difference whose idea it was. I didn't mean to hurt him. I didn't want to hurt him.
Yeah, sure. You didn't mean to hurt that other guy tonight, either, did you?
What other guy?
The one you mugged down 77th Street there near the subway station.
How do you know it was us that did it?
Go on.
Well, how'd you know?
A little birdie told me.
Hey, listen, you don't think he's dead, do you? I mean, I know he's old, but I didn't hit him so hard. And he kicked him. Ernie kicked him. I didn't.
He doesn't look good, does he? All we wanted was a little money, that's all.
Hey, listen, you've got this on awful tight.
That's too bad.
Mister? Hey, mister?
I'm all right. I think I'm all right.
All right, just don't try to move.
I'm okay. I'm really okay.
Look, you just stay here. We'll get an ambulance for you.
No, I want to go home. I just want to go home.
Well, we better see if you're hurt first, anyway.
Hey, I'm sorry, mister. I'm awful sorry.
I'm sorry, too. For you. I'm very sorry for you. All right, you just sit here, mister. Don't try to move now. I'll send for the ambulance.
All right.
Come on, mister. I think so.
Well, I'll make that hurt. Let's walk to the car.
What's your name, huh?
Carl.
Carl what?
Carboard.
Ah. 17 years old, huh?
Yeah, 17, that's all.
You think the other cop will get him? Ernie, I mean?
Yeah, he'll get him. Climb in there. Sit on this seat.
I didn't want to kick him. It was Ernie's idea to kick him. He said, kick him good, hit him hard. That'd make him lose his memory. What a face has he made.
All right. 6-8-1 to Central, K. Car 6-8-1 at 2nd Avenue and 74th Street. We had a mug in here. We got one suspect. The victim is injured. Send an ambulance, K.
Hey, that's pretty good how that works. You talk to them, they talk to you.
Yeah, that's the idea.
Hey, that's pretty good. That's like a telephone to house, huh?
Come on, Carl. Get out of there. All right, let's go. Over here to the man. Come on, let's go.
He ain't gonna die, is he?
He couldn't die if he's talking like that. He's talking like he's all right.
What are you worried about him dying for, huh?
I wouldn't except you caught me. It was Ernie who said kick him. I didn't say kick him. I was against it.
How are you feeling now, mister?
I don't know. Better. Not so good. I don't know. I can't tell. I just hurt. Hurt to the side here.
That's where Ernie kicked him.
You kicked too. You kicked me too.
Well, just a little bit, not as much as Ernie.
You kicked me enough. I want to thank the officer. He saved my life. They were gonna kill me. They said they were. They were gonna kill me.
They weren't gonna kill you. We just wanted the money, that's all. Just the money.
You wanted the money? You should have asked. I'd have given it to you. I'd have given you all I had. A dollar and 20 cents. You just asked me for the money. I'd have given you the dollar and 20 cents.
You all right?
I don't know. I think so.
Well, the ambulance is on the way.
You think he got Ernie? Wouldn't be fair if he didn't get Ernie. Get me and not get Ernie.
Look, don't worry about Ernie. We'll get him.
Well, you bet. It's not fair. He did the most. It was his idea.
What's your name, mister?
Mr. Soker. Philip Soker.
Now, look, Carl. Don't move around so much.
Well, the thing's tight.
You got all right.
Well, the more you move, the tighter they get. Now, just take it easy.
Where do you live, Mr. Soker?
Around the corner. Three, eight, and seven. My wife, my wife is there waiting. She won't know what happened to me.
Look, we'll send somebody around to see her.
No, I think I ought to see her myself. She'll get scared. She's sick. She's not a well woman.
Well, look, let's see how you are first. Then we'll wait until the ambulance gets here.
All right. You think? You ought to wait always.
Yeah, I think so.
Is that the ambulance? Is that it?
No, I think it's another police car.
Hey, where's that cop with Ernie? You ought to get Ernie. It's not fair me being caught in him now.
We'll get him.
You're going to get him? Where is he? I don't see him.
More policemen, huh? Is that who it is?
Yeah, that's who it is, Mr. Soker. Now, look, just lie back there now and take it easy.
What have you got for us, Sergeant?
A mug and sergeant. Yeah, this boy here and another one jumped this man.
They were killing me. A cop saw it just in time.
Why not kill him? You keep quiet. Coley took off after the other boy while I grabbed this one here.
Which way did he go?
Well, I saw him turn a corner down there.
All right. Yes, Sergeant. Go around the corner there. Coley was chasing a boy that way. Take a look for him.
Yes, sir.
How are you feeling, mister? You hurt very bad?
I don't know. Not too bad, I guess.
Hey, listen, couldn't you loosen this thing up a little bit? I mean, it's awful tight. You know, I'm not going to run away. I'm not going no place.
I just want to make sure of that, Carl.
Give him my word of honor. I wouldn't try to sit up there.
I think I might. I'm all right.
Well, we'd better wait and see what the ambulance doctor has to say. Just stay like that, huh?
Okay, if you say so.
Listen, I'm not going to no station house without Ernie. This was his whole idea. I don't want to go in there alone.
We agree with you. We'll both go together.
Well, don't look that way. Don't look like you're going to catch him.
We'll catch him, all right.
Is that the ambulance you think is at us?
No, Dad. Sounds like another police car.
You called the ambulance, didn't you?
I called the ambulance, yeah.
Oh, where is it? Oh, it must have come all the way from the hospital.
Oh. Oh, I see. What do you need all the cops for? Not to handle me.
Don't pull that thing, will you? You just sit still.
It's Meister and Farrell, Sergeant.
Don't get out here. Coley's chasing another boy around the corner on foot. Go take a look for him.
Okay, Sergeant.
Listen, my side is beginning to hurt a little bit more.
Well, you just stay still and I'll see what the doctor has to say.
It's beginning to hurt pretty bad. You don't think there's anything broken in there, do you?
That's right. Where'd he kick me?
I didn't kick you. Not there. I didn't kick you in the side.
Yes, you did.
I never kicked anybody in the side in my life. I don't kick in the side.
He told me he and the other fella jumped that hospital orderly near the subway entrance, Sergeant.
They would have killed him, right?
Oh, they did, huh?
All we want to do is get a little money off him. Just get a little money off him. That's all.
Did you ever hear of working for your money?
I heard of it, yeah.
Hey, we should have heard something from Coley by now, Sergeant. Maybe he chased him up into the building.
Does your friend live around here?
Who's that, Ernie?
Yeah, Ernie.
He's no friend of mine.
Does he live around here?
No, he don't live around here. He lives uptown. We both live uptown.
Is there any place around the corner he might go? Any building he might duck into?
No, not that I know of. How should I know where he might duck into?
Does he have any friends around here?
No, I don't think so. Not around here.
What's the matter? Is somebody hurt? Did somebody get hurt?
It's all right, lady. Everything's under control. Just move on, huh?
Well, what's the matter?
Nothing's the matter. Just go ahead. Move on.
You think I asked for the world. All I wanted was a little information.
Where were you going, Dad? Were you on your way home?
Yes, that's right. I was on my way home.
Where'd you been?
I was over to my brother's house for a pinochle game.
What happened?
I was just walking by. Somebody said, hey, wait a minute. It was them two. They came up and one of them grabbed me. The other one started hitting me. I grabbed him and Ernie hit him. They started cursing me. They wanted money.
Who cursed you?
Not me? You knocked me down. You hit me. You kicked me. You got tough. You shouldn't have got tough.
All right, all right, okay.
Well, he got tough.
Those things are too tight. Loosen them up a little bit, will you?
Well, I'm pulling them and they won't be so tight. You don't have to keep them so tight.
I'm going to run away.
Yeah, yeah, I know all about it.
Sergeant.
Yeah?
All right. Keep your eye on him. Where's the ambulance? It'll be here. I'll be right back. It should have been here already.
Yeah, I... You see Coley?
No, sir. He wasn't any place in the block there. Meister and Farrell came around there looking for him. I thought I'd better come back and tell you.
No sign of him, huh?
We couldn't see him. It was a hack driver who had his car parked in the block. He was waiting for Farrell who was up in the building. He'd been up there about ten minutes, he says, and he saw no sign of a police officer coming around the corner chasing a boy.
Was he looking?
He was just sitting there in the cab parked facing this way, just sitting there waiting. Said if a cop came around the corner chasing somebody, he'd have seen him.
Just the cab driver in the block?
Well, there was a man walking there, too. He lived in one of the buildings.
A young man or an old man?
Well, about 40. He couldn't have been the other boy. He said he was standing on the steps saying goodnight to someone he knew. He didn't see anybody come in the block, either.
Vaccaro!
Yes, sir?
You said you saw Coley turn the corner after that boy into the block?
Yes, sir, I saw him.
Vaccaro saw him turn the corner.
Well, yes, sir, but where'd he go after that?
That's what we'll have to find out. That boy he was chasing could have been armed. Might have turned on him.
Might have.
Yeah. Let's hope he didn't.
You're listening to 21st Precinct, the factual account of the way police work in the world's largest city.
You'll hear your confession repeated over and over again. Drummed into your head. They make you memorize it. Sign it. And by torture and drugs, they finally get you so you yourself believe it. Then, finally, they put you on the witness stand. And you hear a voice admitting the guilt. You don't even care anymore. You hardly realize that it's your own voice, repeating the words they want you to say. Yes, that has happened in some countries. But there's a very good reason why it couldn't happen to you. Fifteen words in our Bill of Rights are your protection. They say very clearly, no person shall be compelled in any criminal case to be a witness against himself. When we read about the rigged trials, the phony witnesses, the drug confessions that take place in certain countries today, we're pretty glad that our Constitution was written by men of foresight. Maybe they couldn't look ahead to our day, but they were determined to protect us against such things happening in this country. For ourselves, for generations to come, this right exists, assuring us of fair trials, due process of law, and no one can compel us to be a witness against ourselves. It's right there in black and white, in words that have been unaltered for 165 years. It is one of our freedoms.
Now back to 21st Precinct, Captain Kennelly.
In another few minutes, two detectives who were on patrol arrived on the scene. With Sergeant Waters and the patrolmen already there, they began an intensive search of the neighborhood for patrolman Coley and the suspect he was chasing. Sergeant Waters rang in from a call box and apprised Lieutenant Gorman, the desk officer, of the situation, and requested that more help be sent. Lieutenant Gorman immediately informed me and I instructed him to have a car come by the station house to take me to the scene. In the meantime, an ambulance had arrived from Metropolitan Hospital and the mugging victim was taken there for treatment. When the car in which I was riding approached the scene, there were several uniformed officers and detectives gathered around Lieutenant King, commander of the 21st Detective Squad. Despite the lateness of the hour, a dozen or so curious civilians were also on the sidewalk.
Okay, get on the job. Give him a hand here.
Yes, sir. And you two go on down to the other end of the block.
Yes, sir.
Hello, Captain.
Sergeant, any word from Coley yet?
No, sir. Looks like he might have chased the boy into one of those buildings on the block, Captain. We've got men out looking. We're getting ready for a building-by-building search.
Good. We're going to start through them all, from the basement to the roof.
Good. Where's the other boy?
Vaccaro's got him in the car, Captain.
I want to talk to him.
Yes, sir. This way. Oh, and Matt, when you're set, I want to go with you.
Yes, sir.
Okay, Sergeant. You three will go into the first building on the other side.
They're the same ones that mugged the hospital orderly, Captain.
Yes, I know. Hello, Vaccaro.
Captain.
Good work.
Thank you. Only, I wish we could locate Coley.
We will. What's his name? Tell the captain your name.
Carl.
Carl Boyd.
Well, you got yourself into some trouble, didn't you, Carl?
Yeah, I guess so.
What's your friend's name?
Ernie.
Ernie what?
Ernie Vantella.
You know any place in the neighborhood that he might have gone?
Listen, if I knew, I'd tell you. You think I want this all by myself? I don't want this all by myself.
Where does Ernie live?
Up near me there.
Where's that?
Up 113th Street.
How old is he?
He's got a pretty complete description, Captain. I gave it to him. I told him what he looks like.
I don't want to take this all by myself. You catch him. I hope you catch him.
He's 18 years old, 150 pounds, 5 feet 9 inches. He's got on a khaki field jacket, blue slacks, no hat or cap.
Is he armed?
Armed? No, he's got nothing except maybe a knife. I don't know.
A switchblade knife?
Yeah, I guess so.
Don't you know?
Yeah, a switchblade. And he'll use it too, won't he?
I don't guess he carries it for decoration.
I don't guess he does.
We're all set, Captain.
Oh, okay. Go on, you men, get moving. Stay with your prisoner for us.
Yes, sir.
All right. Get the men on the job, Sergeant.
Yes, sir. All right, keep moving up there. Get on your toes.
What do you think happened to him, Matt?
In 20 minutes, he should have come back to the car or sent someone back, Captain. Or he should have rung into the station house.
Yes, sir. You know, the boy had a switchblade knife.
I know. There were two or three witnesses. Nobody saw them run through the block. My guess is that he chased the boy into one of those buildings, either up to the roof or down into the basement. And the boy might have jumped him with the knife.
Good possibility, Captain.
Well, if he did, maybe the boy went home.
Yes, sir. I sent two men up to where he lives to plant the place.
Good. All right, get going. Start into those buildings.
There's three abandoned tenements that are going to be wrecked, Captain. We're going to try them first.
Oh, that's a good idea. Then we'll try the occupied buildings. We'll search them all, top to bottom. If Coley went up into a dark hallway, that boy could have been waiting on a landing. One swipe with that knife would be all it'd take.
Yes, sir.
Captain. Captain Kennelly.
Yeah, who is it?
Ahern. Over here, Captain, on the stoop.
All right. Come on, lad. Here I am, Captain.
Okay.
Yes, Ahern. Captain, this is Mrs. Protea. Captain Kennelly and Lieutenant King.
How do you do?
Mrs. Protea. She lives on the top floor of this building. Top floor, fourth floor, fourth floor rear.
Yes. She says she heard somebody on the roof a little while ago. First in the hall and then on the roof, running up the steps and then running up onto the roof.
I heard them.
Were they men?
Yes, men, making lots of noise.
How many?
I don't know. It sounded like a lot. I was scared. I didn't move from the bed. I didn't know who it was. Robbers, I thought.
Do you think one of them could have been a police officer?
I didn't see. I only heard.
Sergeant, get the men to go straight to the roofs there and cut over this way. We think they went to the roofs.
How long ago was this, Mrs. Protea?
I don't know, 10 minutes ago, 15, I don't know. Somebody was running up the stairs yelling. They went on the roof. Then they ran around on the roof. I heard them. They were right over my head.
Why didn't you call someone sooner?
Well, I've got no phone. I had to get dressed to come downstairs.
You waited a long time.
Sergeant, here's Sergeant. I was scared. I want him to stay with us, Sergeant. We're going up to the roof this way.
I stayed in the bed until the noises stopped and I got dressed.
All right. You stay down here on the street, Mrs. Protea.
Sure, yes.
Did you close the door to your apartment?
I closed it. Locked it, yes.
All right. Let's go. Come on, Ahern.
That's it. Watch it. Now, he's liable to have come back down the steps. He might be on any landing.
Okay, Captain. Keep your light handy, Ahern.
Yes, sir.
Okay. These buildings are all the same height, Captain. Could have jumped from one roof to another.
Yeah. Think we ought to try the doors, Captain?
No, not yet. Let's not wake up any more people than we have to.
Okay, go on. Come on. On the top floor. Go on. In the front, I think. Easy. Easy. That side of the door.
Police officers, did you just slam this door?
Yes, I wanted to go to the side, but why? What is the trouble? I see all the policemen in the street.
There's no trouble. Better bolt your door and stay inside, lady.
All right.
Okay, let's go to the roof.
That's it.
I don't think that boy's around here anymore, Captain. Wherever he's going, he's on the way.
Yeah, but where's Coley?
Let's go. Go ahead. Post yourself right here, Ahern.
Yes, sir. Right at the door. Keep it open.
Yes, sir.
Captain.
Yes?
All right. Send your men downstairs and into the buildings toward the other end of the block.
Let's look that way, Captain.
Okay. Watch it. Don't trip over that aerial wire.
Yes, sir. Toward the back. Come on.
Not on this building. How about the one that way?
You don't think the woman was hearing things, do you, Captain?
I don't know. Now watch it going over. Copper flashing. It'll rip into you.
Beautiful night, isn't it?
Well, just a little bit cold, that's all.
Nothing back here. Let's try the front.
You know, Matt, I think we ought to... Hold it. Something moved.
Okay. All right, you, raise up.
Take it easy, Matt. It's Coley. Coley. He's out, Captain. Coley.
All right. Take it easy. You'll be okay. Ahern.
You'll be all right, Coley. Cut. We found Coley.
Oh, cut up. Go downstairs. Ring in for an ambulance.
I chased him up here.
All right, Coley. Take it easy. Put your light on him, Matt.
Yes, sir. All right. I guess I just passed out for a little while. I'll be all right. Sticky on my neck. Lots of blood.
You were bleeding a little bit.
Stuck me three times, if I remember. Tell us about it later.
I'm all right now. Chased him up here, about 10 yards ahead of me all the way. I saw him come out on the roof, and when I got over here, he was laying for me, jumping.
Okay. Don't worry about it. Did you say which way he ran?
Well, he went that way, over the next roof, I think. I think I saw him go that way before I passed out.
Yeah, he was on the way, Captain.
Okay, good. Thanks, Sergeant. Coley?
Stay with him, Sergeant. We want to take a look over here.
Yes, sir.
He ran this way, Captain, over to the next roof.
He didn't run over to the next roof, Matt. He jumped.
Hmm. Some jump. Could be 10 feet across there.
At least.
Well, we know where he lives. We'll get him.
Just hope Coley's going to be okay.
I think he will, Matt. Passing out worries me, though. It's a bad sign.
Not necessarily.
Looks more like a 12 or 14-foot jump, Captain.
Matt?
Yes, sir?
Put your light down there in the courtyard. Sweep it around down there.
Okay.
Maybe you're right. I guess you don't have to look for him at home.
21st Precinct, Sergeant Waters. Well, who got bitten? How old? Four. Where's the dog? Is the dog there? Where? What's the name of the girl who was bitten?
And so it goes. Around the clock, through the week, every day, every year. The police precinct in the city of New York is a flesh and blood merry-go-round. Anyone can catch the brass ring. Or the brass ring can catch anyone.
21st Precinct transcribed. The factual account of the way the police work in the world's largest city is presented with the official cooperation of the Patrolmen's Benevolent Association, an organization of more than 20,000 members of the Police Department, City of New York. 21st Precinct has come to you through the worldwide facilities of the United States Armed Forces Radio and Television Service.
