The written record
Read the transcript
Read along with the recording · About 27 min to read
21st Precinct, Sergeant Waters. All right, get on over to 2nd Avenue. The third alarm on that fire just hit. Sergeant Tierney's on the job there. He'll put you to work on traffic. Yeah, that's right.
You are in the muster room at the 21st Precinct, the nerve center. A call is coming through. You will follow the action taken pursuant to that call from this minute until the final report is written in the 124 room at the 21st Precinct.
Okay, you're gone. Ring him when you get back on your post. Yeah. All right. 21st Precinct.
It's just lines on a map of the city of New York. Most of the 173,000 people wedged into the nine-tenths of a square mile between 5th Avenue and the East River wouldn't know if you asked them that they lived or worked in the 21st. But that they know it or not, the security of their homes, their persons, and their property is the job of the men of the 21st Precinct. The 21st. 160 patrolmen, 11 sergeants, and four lieutenants, of whom I'm the boss. My name is Kennelly, Frank Kennelly. I'm captain in command of the 21st. I was working my day tour, 8 a.m. to 6 p.m. It was raining hard when I came on the job, and the 63 men who would patrol the precinct on foot and in sector cars for the next eight hours turned out wearing rubber coats, boots, and cap covers.
At 10 minutes after 9, Lieutenant Gorman, the desk officer, rang into my office and informed me of a two-alarm phone, a fire, and a loft building on 2nd Avenue. By the time a car came by the station house to take me to the scene of the fire, the third alarm had hit. The teeming rain added to our difficulties, and it had not stopped until about the time the fire was out at 11:14. I returned to the station house to finish the paperwork and begin a required inspection of departmental equipment. My calendar showed that I was scheduled to give a talk on safety to the student body of Julia Richmond High School at 1:30 p.m. So at noon, I changed to civilian clothes and took my rain-soaked uniform trousers under my arms. It was my intention to leave them to be pressed while I went for my meal in the restaurant a few doors from the tailor shop on 3rd Avenue operated by Philip Parazzoni.
Hello, Miss Parazzoni. How are you?
I'm fine.
I'm Captain Kennelly.
Well, you don't have to bother him. Phil! Phil, come here!
Mrs. Parazzoni, I...
Hello, Captain. Oh. Phil, how are you? Phil. Uh, Rose, uh, you better get to 2.11 and pick up the work.
Oh. All right. Yeah, the night doorman's uniform and the elevator operator's uniform from the soup house.
2.11?
Yes, 2.11. All right. I'll get you. Yeah, only press if they want them back by 5 o'clock, huh? Only press. Why, Philippine?
Yeah. Yeah, sometimes they ruin more customers than they're worth. Uh, yeah, yeah, Captain. I got them soaked this morning, Phil. I'm giving a talk to some... some high school students at, uh, 1:30 this afternoon. I wondered if I could get them pressed.
Oh, sure. They're not too wet, are they?
No, don't worry about it. I'll take care of it. I'm gonna have lunch down the block. Could I pick them up in about half an hour?
Well, I'll... I'll deliver them to the station house if you want.
No, no, that's all right. I'll pick them up.
Yeah, okay. Thanks a lot, Phil.
Oh, uh, Captain?
Yeah?
Uh, could I ask you something?
Oh, sure. What is it, Phil?
Uh... Look, Captain. Captain?
Yeah?
I'm... I'm sorry, I rose to ask you. Uh, what happened? You two have a fight?
Yeah, I guess it's a Florida fight. Anyway, I'm sorry.
Um, don't worry about it.
Oh, I am worried about it. You see, the street people like that, customers, especially you.
Oh, it happens in the best of families.
Yeah, in the best of families.
I left Phil Parazzoni's tailor shop and went a few doors down the street to a restaurant where I had my meal. When I returned for the uniformed trousers a half hour later, Mrs. Parazzoni was not in the shop. At 1:30 p.m., I was introduced to the student body at Julia Richmond High School, and I talked for 20 minutes on the subject of safety, especially safe driving. It was 2:10 p.m. when I returned to the station house, where in the muster room, Lieutenant Gorman was desk officer, and Sergeant Waters was on telephone switchboard.
Uh, Captain?
Go ahead and take the call, Sergeant.
Yes, sir. I'll sign the block. 21st Precinct, Sergeant Waters. And where were you born, the borough of Manhattan? Well, you go down to the Department of Health, 125 White Street. You can get a copy of your birth certificate there. 125 White Street. And where are you, on the east side? You take the Lexington Avenue Express downtown and change at 14th Street for the locals. Right at the White Street, and it's just upstairs there. Oh, okay. You're welcome.
Yes, Sergeant, did you have something for me?
Oh, yes, Captain. What? Uh, you know that Phil Parazzoni from the tailors' company?
Oh, what about him?
Came in to see him.
Yeah?
He and his wife are asking to wait in your office.
Oh, are they in there now?
Yes, sir.
All right. 21st Precinct, Sergeant Waters. All right, where do you see?
Hello, Phil.
Oh, Captain. Hello. Uh, you know my wife, Rose?
Yes. Oh, hello, Miss Parazzoni.
Hello.
Well, what can I do for you, Phil?
Well...
He told me it wasn't the right thing to do. He told me in so many words, I wouldn't listen. Now, Rose...
That's what he told me. It wasn't the right thing to do.
What wasn't the right thing to do?
It was all my fault. He didn't have anything to do with it.
Rose, let's just talk to him. Would you wait outside for me? It's my fault. Would you just stand outside, and I'll get it straightened out? Is that all right with you, Captain?
Yeah, I guess so. Yeah, go ahead, Rose. Let's get it straightened out, huh? Yeah. All right. But it's my fault. Everything.
Yeah, could I close the door, please?
That's all right. I'll get it. Is it all right to wait here?
Yeah, sure. That's all right.
Well, what's the trouble, Phil?
Captain, when you came in the store to get the pants dressed...
Yeah?
Well, that's why she acted so funny. Because it was you. You see, she thought you came to arrest her. That's why she acted that way.
Arrest her for what?
It's a long story. It's a very long story.
Well, what did she do?
Look, Captain, when somebody who's worked so hard for so many years, worked, really struggled, can you blame them too much if they see an opportunity to make some money just like that?
Is that a big opportunity to make it?
Well, I can't blame them if it's legitimate.
Well, in this case, it's legitimate and it isn't.
Well, it can't be both.
Well, I mean, the money don't really belong to anybody.
Uh, you better start at the beginning, Phil.
Yeah, well, it was yesterday morning. We were in the shop.
Yeah.
But Rose was at the counter, like when you came in today, and I was in the back at the person who came in.
Yeah.
Well, the door opened and a customer came in. A woman. A very pretty young woman.
Yeah.
Well, she came in mad as a wet hen. Well, I heard her talking to Rose, and I came up to see what the matter was. But she had on a nice wool suit, see? The front of the skirt was dirty and smudged, and I didn't blame her for being mad. Anyway, she said she was on the bus. She said two men got on, and the man who was sitting next to her saw the two men. Well, she thinks they were detectives, and they were after the man that was sitting next to her. Well, anyway, he jumped out of his seat and crawled all over her and ruined her suit with his shoe, and went out the back door of the bus, and the two men ran out after him.
Uh-huh.
Well, anyway, after a minute, she looked down on her seat, and there was a package. You see? A pretty big package. Must have belonged to the man that the policeman was chasing. She picked it up.
And did the woman have the package when she came into the store?
Oh, yeah, yeah. She had it all right. It was right down on the counter there all the time. Only... Anyway, I said... I tried to fix up her skirt as best I could, and then she went in the dressing room.
Yeah.
Well, I was in the back there working on the skirt, and then the lady asked Rose to bring the package into the dressing room. She'd like to take a look at it while she was waiting. So, so Rose brought the package in, and Rose said, you know, how curiosity can get the best of ladies. Well, they sat there looking at it, and Rose was hoping that she would open it up, and finally the lady decided to open it up.
And what was in it?
Well, I didn't know. I didn't find out until last night.
Oh, really?
Well, she didn't say anything to me about it while we were in the store. I was busy back there. I didn't know what was going on in the dressing room.
I see. Your wife only told you what was in it.
Yeah, I never saw anything in there.
Well, what was in the package?
Money. Lots of money, Captain.
How much?
Well, I don't know, Sassy. Rose said at least $3,000, they say. Aren't they, too?
Well, Rose told me they didn't count it. They were so scared they didn't count it.
Oh, well, the money... the money wasn't all that was in there.
What else?
Oh, number slips. You know, slips from playing policy.
Oh?
Yeah, well, they figured out, Rose and the lady, that this fella on the bus was a racketeer. You see? And he was being chased by the cops.
Yeah.
Oh, you're going to ask Rose, then?
Well, I think we ought to have this story from her, don't you?
Yeah, yeah, I think we ought to. Uh, Miss Parazzoni.
Yes?
Would you come in now?
All right, sir.
Have a seat.
Yeah. You tell them, sir?
Well, not everything.
Well, good job, Miss Parazzoni. Thanks. I, uh, I only got up to the part after you opened the package in the dressing room.
Oh.
Yes, I'd rather hear the story from you, Miss Parazzoni, instead of what you told your husband.
Yeah, I think so. Now, how much money was in there?
Well, we didn't count it. We saw that money in the policy slips. We got scared.
You and the lady?
Yeah. We wrapped the package back up again.
What was it? A stack of money?
Yeah, a stack. About this thick. About two or three inches thick. Lots of money.
And was the pile of money tied up?
Yeah, with a rubber band. A couple of rubber bands.
And what was on top?
Uh, a $20 bill.
Mm-hmm. You see the bottom?
Yeah. There was a 10, I think. There was a $10 bill on the bottom.
You never did take the rubber band, though.
I didn't even touch it. She was holding it.
And you decided to wrap it up quickly?
Yes, she decided it. She said the best thing to do would be to call the police. That would be the best thing.
Well, why didn't you call the police?
Well, I, I came back with the skirt. You better let her tell it, Phil.
Oh.
Yeah, okay. I'll know.
Well, uh, Phil came back to the dressing room with the skirt, and she had the package all tied up again. I, I took her out front of where the telephone was, and she walked over toward it, and she picked up the telephone. All of a sudden, she hung up.
Where was Phil?
Uh, I wasn't back there. I was working on some work, uh, at the press in this room. I don't know. I, I didn't see any of it.
No, that's right. He didn't see any of it.
Did she tell you her name?
Not then.
Well, did you ever find it out?
Well, later she said it would be best if I didn't know her full name. She said her first name was Marion.
Uh-huh. Did she tell you why she didn't call the police?
Yeah, she told me that she was afraid to call the police. She said that she was afraid that they'd find out that she had 22 parking tickets on her car and never went to court about any of them. She was afraid she'd be arrested and find a lot of money and things like that. She said maybe it would be better if she left the package in the store and if I'd call her.
Did you agree to that?
Well, I, I didn't care, but, and she said there wasn't any reason why we couldn't keep the money to ourselves. Better that we should have it than the criminal.
I see. The only thing was, she was afraid that the man from the bus might have gotten away from the cops and might have remembered us. So what did you do?
Well, it, it was decided that we could leave it in one of those lockers in Grand Central Station. You know, one of the lockers right in the waiting room there.
Yeah. The little locker with the key that you take out and put in a dime.
Yeah, I know.
Well, because she was scared, I took the package. Went out of the store and she followed me. I, I went over and took the subway and rode down to Grand Central. I put the package in the locker and she said I could keep the key because I didn't know her full name or where to get in touch with her, but she sure knew me and she was sure I was on it.
Is, uh, the package still in the locker?
Yes, still in the locker.
And, uh, you've got the key?
Yes, I've got the key. I've got it right here.
How much cash did she ask you to put up?
Well, did you tell him she asked me to put up cash?
No, no, I didn't tell him that.
How, how did you know she asked me to put up cash?
I knew. How much was it?
Seven hundred and fifty dollars.
Have you given it to her yet?
No, no, I'm supposed to meet her this afternoon.
Well, you're lucky, Mr. Parazzoni.
What do you mean lucky? I'm worried to death. Scared to death.
You're lucky. You not only didn't find three thousand dollars of someone else's money, you didn't lose seven hundred and fifty of your own.
You are listening to 21st Precinct, a factual account of the way police work in the world's largest city. Now back to 21st Precinct and Captain Kennelly.
I took Mr. and Mrs. Parazzoni upstairs to the 21st Detective Squad and into the office of Lieutenant Matt King, the squad commander. Hinshamming, bunko, and pigeon dropping is the small business. All con games are called, are old stories and easily recognizable to police officers. But to the victim, they're most convincing. This is especially true because in many, there is a blinding streak of larceny exceeded only by that in the con artist. These confidence rackets are invariably based upon the victim's desire to get something for nothing, something that belongs to somebody else. To the police officer, the gullibility of people is amazing. It's incredible how many in the city of New York fall victim to these same old small con games year in and year out.
In this case, Lieutenant King and Detective Louie DeLuca questioned the intended victim very closely as I listened.
Why should she give you the key? If she were on the level, why wouldn't she suspect you'd go to the locker and get the package for yourself?
Well, she told me that she trusted me because she knew where to get in touch with me. We were in business. She walked in off the street with a smudge on her suit and that's sufficient reason for her to trust you with $3,000?
Well, she told my wife she had to trust somebody.
Yeah, that's right. She couldn't go to the police on account of a 22 parking ticket.
You've known these people a long time, haven't you, Captain?
Yes, ever since I've been in the precinct. Many years. As far as I know, they're good, honest, hard-working people.
It was all my fault. After I told Phil, he said, why didn't I go to the police? I should have gone to the police. That's what he said.
Gross. Please.
If I told you to go to the police, I would have insisted. Now, let's pick this up for a minute while we left York.
Yeah, all right. Yesterday, you and Miss Marion took the package down to Grand Central and you got one of those dime lockers.
Yes, that's right. Then what did you do?
We went to a, I don't know, a coffee bar, I guess they called it, in Grand Central. We stood there and we had a cup of coffee and she said, well, I guess nobody followed us. I guess the detectives arrested the man. I said, yes, I guess they did. So, she thanked me a lot for helping her. And she started to say how much I should get for helping her. She mentioned something like 25% of what was in the package. Well, I would have been satisfied with 25%, but anyway, we settled on the fact that I should get a third. We were supposed to meet at Grand Central, right at this coffee bar, exactly at noon today. We'd take the package someplace and open up and then split the money.
How did she happen to give you the key?
Well, it was her own idea.
It was very nice of her, wasn't it?
I thought it was.
Then you parted company.
Yes.
What time did you get back at the store?
It was about an hour after I left.
Your husband asked you where you'd been?
Well, yeah, yeah, I asked her. She told me she had to go out with a lady to help her out. I asked her why she had to help out a crazy like that. She said she just did. She had to, that's all.
You accepted that answer?
Well, I couldn't do nothing except accept it. What else could I do?
When did you tell him about the money?
Last night after dinner. I just couldn't keep it in me anymore. I told him about the package and about everything that was in it and how we went to Grand Central, how we put it in the locker and how she was going to meet me there tomorrow and I was going to get one third.
Your husband told you to go to the police, didn't he?
Yes, he told me.
Yes, Paula, but with no enthusiasm. With no enthusiasm whatsoever.
Well, at least he told me.
And you were intending to meet her at Grand Central Station at noon today and open up the package?
Yes, that's right.
Well, it was about noon that I came to your store. You were still there.
Yes, I know I was there. See, I got a call from her on the telephone at 9:30 this morning. That's Marion?
Yes, Marion. She said she was in awful trouble. She said she got home the night before, went to bed and when she woke up in the morning there was a policeman there. A policeman. The phone almost fell out of my hand. She said the policeman came to arrest her on account of the 22 traffic tickets that she didn't show up in court for. She said the policeman took her down to the magistrate's court and she was sitting there just waiting for her trial. So she said she couldn't meet me this noon but that I ought to go down and put another dime in the locker at Grand Central Station. I told her I'd do that. She made me promise to be sure not to open the package because we'd have to count the money together and I told her I wouldn't but I just put the dime in.
Did you go down to Grand Central?
Yes. I went down there and I went out of the store when the captain was in there. Do you remember that captain that I left?
Yes, I remember. I'm so nervous I didn't know what to do. I thought you came to get me. That's what I thought but when I found out you didn't I went over and got the subway and went down to Grand Central and put another dime in the locker.
Did you look inside to see if the package was still there?
Yes, I opened up the locker and I looked inside to see if it was still in there, the package.
Then you went back to the store?
Yes.
What time was that?
It must have been about a quarter to one that I got back.
What time did you hear from Marion again?
About one o'clock she called.
What did she say this time?
Well, she told me she'd been up before the judge. She said the judge was very mad at her for ignoring the twenty-three traffic tickets and he fined her seven hundred and fifty dollars. Seven hundred and fifty dollars! She had to have the money right away or she'd go to jail. She had to pay the fine by four o'clock that afternoon. She said she didn't know what she was going to do. The judge wouldn't let her leave the building but he let her go out in the hall and use the pay telephone so she could call some friends. If she didn't have it by four o'clock that afternoon she'd go to jail.
What did you say to her?
Well, I told her, I told her she had all that money in Grand Central Station and I said she ought to be able to use that. She said no, she didn't want to do that. She didn't want to take the chance on opening up the package. Not down there because there are all kinds of cops around and everything. There's always all kinds of cops in the courthouse.
Did you have any suggestions of her?
Yeah, I told her I could open it up and throw the policy slips away. I could go to the ladies room in Grand Central Station and throw them in the wastebasket or something like that and just bring the money down. She said no, that wouldn't be any good because we'd have to count the money together and each take our share so there wouldn't be any suspicion on either side.
That seemed fair, didn't it?
Yeah, but I knew she was in such trouble she had to pay the seven hundred and fifty dollar fine.
Did she have any suggestions?
Yes, she had a suggestion. She wanted to know if I had seven hundred and fifty dollars, if I could get it. And I said yes, I could go to the savings account. And she said please, please wouldn't I do her a favor and draw out the money so she could pay the fine. And after she paid the fine we'd go up to Grand Central and get the package and we'd split it right away and I'd get my seven hundred and fifty dollars back. And she'd give me half of the rest instead of only a third.
Did you agree to do that?
Well, fine. Finally, I told her, all right, I would. And I told her that I'd meet her with the seven hundred and fifty dollars.
Where was that?
In the courthouse, down on Center Street.
Where in the courthouse?
On the second floor, right by the pay telephones there. She said that the judge had given her permission to go out and stand by the telephones to wait for calls and to make calls, but she had to be back inside the court and pay off the fine before [inaudible] o'clock.
And what time were you going to meet her?
At a quarter to four.
Well, you ought to be thankful if you decided to break the law. You'd have given the whole thing to me. You'd have given her the seven hundred and fifty dollars and never seen her again.
Yeah, but the package, I had the key to the lock of the packages in there.
Yes, you'd have gotten back thirty of your seven hundred and fifty dollars. Twenty on top and a ten on the bottom.
Well, it looks like money to me.
It always does. What made you decide to come see me?
Oh, it was Phil's idea.
No, no, Rose, you decided it yourself.
No, it's not true. It was his idea.
See, he keeps the bankbook in the drawer of the phone. He was putting a new lining in a coat and he wouldn't get away from it. Finally, he stood up to get something. I got the bankbook. He saw me. So he asked me what happened. I told him. He says, no, I can't go to the bank and get the money. But I told him I promised. He said, I don't care what you promise.
But she decided to come here herself. She decided. He told me.
So I decided.
What do you think, Lieutenant? Think I ought to get out of Grand Central and pick up that package?
What kind of a man are you?
I don't know.
Now, uh, what is this? You think you ought to leave it there at least until we're sure that this Marion is down at the courthouse. Just as we're able to be standing in Grand Central watching that locker. If she sees the police officer or Rose go get the package, she's not gonna show up at the courthouse. If she stays there in the locker, then she's sure the deal is on.
Is it, Owens? What should I do?
You don't have to worry about that, Miss Parazzoni. We just do what we tell you.
It was decided that Mrs. Parazzoni would go ahead and complete the transaction action with the con artist she knew only as Marion. A dummy package of money prepared in exactly the same manner as the package left in the locker in Grand Central was gotten ready. There was a twenty dollar bill on top and a ten on the bottom. In between was plain paper cut to size. The serial numbers of the two real bills were recorded for evidence. Detective DeLuca was instructed to see that Mrs. Parazzoni waited until the exact time of the appointment, entered the building, and took the elevator to the second floor. Lieutenant King and I went into the lobby of the building and met two detectives of the fifth squad. The four of us took the elevator to the second floor. It was hardly necessary to make ourselves inconspicuous in the corridor. The place, as always on court days, was jammed with police officers, defendants, witnesses, complainants, bail bondsmen, and attorneys waiting for their cases to be called in the various courts. The two detectives from the fifth squad were planted near the elevators. Lieutenant King and I walked to a place in the corridor close to the telephone booth and there we waited.
Captain, it's the first time I've heard of the criminal court building being part of a con game.
Impressive, Matt. I'm gonna give her credit for that. That's impressive, all right.
There's a woman waiting. Think that's her?
Pretty close to the description. Wait a minute. There's another one down there.
Where?
At the drinking fountain.
All right. Lots of them, Captain. Now, I guess we'll just have to wait and see. How's the time?
She's still up there now. How about moving across there while we can see the elevators?
Yeah, Chuck. Blue dress would be hard, too. Now, let's see. Look, we better not both watch the elevators, Matt.
No. I'll, uh, I'll look this way. You just let me know what's going on, okay?
Okay.
There's another one that could be the gal. The description says half the women in New York.
Yeah.
There's Miss Parazzoni coming off the elevator. She's starting to look around.
Does she see us?
Not yet.
Which way is she looking?
This way. Here she comes.
You think Marion's killed?
Yes, I think she's killed. Miss Parazzoni is walking over to her. The one in the blue dress. I better keep looking this way.
Yes. She's greeted her. They're making the change. Oh, he's giving us a package. She's got it.
All right. Let's go.
Good looking, all right.
You, uh, think that'll help her?
Let's go for her. I don't know how much good it'll do from now on.
Now, where will I wait for you?
All right. We're police officers. I'll take that package.
What package?
The one you've got there. I'll have it, please.
Did you bring them?
Why'd you bring them?
Because you were cheating me.
Give me the package. I didn't mean you. I'll tear your eyes out right out of your head.
All right. All right. I'll kill her. I'll murder her. I'll kill her.
Hold still there. I'll kill her. I'll kill her. Stand over there, Miss Parazzoni. I'll kill her. I'll kill her.
I don't think so.
No, I don't think so either, but let her believe it.
What'd she do? Open up the package in Grand Central?
No. She's still there.
What made her ring in the north?
You picked the wrong mark. She was a saint.
Yeah, but you didn't count on one thing. She's got a streak of honesty.
21st Precinct, Sergeant Waters. Yeah, that's right. It was our policeman. It wasn't her. What do you want to know for? Well, how does what they're doing concern you? Yeah. Yeah. Well, you'll just have to bear with us a while, mister. Getting her out is more important than your losing a little sleep. All right. Yeah, we'll be through there right away. As soon as possible. Yes, sir. Yes, sir. You're welcome.
And so it goes. Around the clock, through the week, every day, every year, a police precinct in the city of New York is a flesh-and-blood merry-go-round. Anyone can catch the brass ring, or the brass ring can catch anyone. 21st Precinct, a factual account of the way the police work in the world's largest city, is presented with the official cooperation of the Patrolman's Benevolent Association, an organization of more than 20,000 members of the Police Department, City of New York. Everett Sloane in the role of Captain Kennelly, Ken Lynch as Lieutenant King, Harold Stone as Sergeant Waters. Featured in tonight's cast were Bryna Rayburn, Joan Allison, Larry Haynes, and Bill Quinn. Written and directed by Stanley Nist. Produced for CBS Radio by John Ives. Art Hanna speaking.
