The written record
Read the transcript
Read along with the recording · About 24 min to read
21st Precinct, Sergeant Rosen.
What happened to it?
Was it stolen?
Yeah. Yeah.
Well, where'd you keep it?
You are by transcription in the muster room at the 21st Precinct.
How long?
The nerve center. A call is coming through. You will follow the action taken pursuant to that call from this minute until the final report is written in the 124 room at the 21st Precinct.
Well, I'll tell you what you'd better do. You'd better come on into the station house and make a report of it.
No, you'd better come right away.
Okay. Yeah.
21st Precinct.
It's just lines on a map of the city of New York. Most of the 173,000 people wedged into the nine-tenths of a square mile between Fifth Avenue and the East River wouldn't know if you asked them that they lived or worked in the 21st. Whether they know it or not, the security of their homes, their persons, and their property is the job of the men of the 21st Precinct. The 21st. 160 patrolmen, 11 sergeants, and four lieutenants, of whom I'm the boss. My name is Cronin, Vincent P. Cronin. I am captain in command of the 21st Precinct. I was doing day duty, 8 a.m. to 6 p.m.
After I turned out the platoon and the men marched out the front door to take over their post, I walked through the back room and out across the iron grating to the smaller building in back of the station house, where the detention cells are located. There I found Patrolman Bailey, the station house attendant, cleaning up. The doors of all six cells were standing open. There had been four prisoners held over during the night, but at 7:30 a.m. the patrol wagon had come by the station house to take them to [inaudible]. With Patrolman Bailey walking a step or two behind me, I conducted an inspection of the cells to see that they were clean, supplied with paper drinking cups, towels, and so forth. After I completed this inspection, Inspector Carr, number three, came by the house for me. I went out on patrol to the precinct.
While I was still engaged, Sergeant Rosen had telephoned switchboard duty, and Lieutenant Gorman was the desk officer.
Sergeant.
Yes, sir?
Give me the communications bureau on here.
Yes, sir.
21st Precinct, Lieutenant Gorman. Stick report, C.B. It's Foreman James Reels. S like in Sam. 10th Precinct. He went sick at 8:50 a.m. at home. 792 East 93rd Street. Surgeon to call.
Okay. Sergeant?
Yes, sir?
I want to talk to the carol when he rings in.
Okay, Lieutenant.
Excuse me, Sergeant. You'll have to talk to the desk officer, Mr. [inaudible]
No, I'm sorry. Excuse me, Lieutenant.
Yes?
I'm John Froud. I own the package store at 284 East 75th Street.
Oh, yeah, yeah, Mr. Froud. What can I do for you?
Well, Lieutenant, I got a license to keep a gun in the store. I had three stick-ups since I've been there. I got this license.
Yeah, what about it?
Well, the gun is gone. Disappeared.
What do you mean, disappeared?
It's gone. I don't know.
Well, how could the gun just disappear? You think it was stolen?
I don't know. It's gone. Nothing else was taken.
Well, where did you keep it?
Well, I got wines on one side and liquor on the other. In the middle is this little counter with a cash register and wrappings. In a drawer right under the cash register.
When did you miss it?
Last night. I went to get something. I got something else out of the drawer and I saw the gun wasn't there.
Well, why didn't you report it then?
Well, I thought maybe my wife would know where it was. Maybe she saw it or my son. I looked all over the store and when I got home, I asked my wife. She didn't see it.
What about your son?
Well, he wasn't home yet. I fell asleep and I didn't see him until this morning. He didn't know anything about it.
Sergeant.
Yes, sir?
Put a call out for the skipper, will you?
Okay.
I don't know what could have happened to it. I got no idea. How long have you had this gun?
Twenty-first, please, sir.
Well, let's see. It's about three, four years.
Is this a license to carry or just to possess on the premises?
Possess on the premises.
All right, Mr. Froud. You wait right over there, huh? I put a radio call out for Captain Cronin. He'll come in and talk to you about it.
Well, can't I get back to the store? My wife is there and she has to go someplace. Her sister is in the hospital.
No, you'd better wait for the captain and also for the detectives to come in.
Well, I could come back just after.
He'll want to talk to you now. I'm sure of that.
All right. I guess I'd better wait.
Yeah. You'd better.
Section 1897 of the Penal Law of the State of New York, otherwise known as the Sullivan Law, is perhaps the most stringent and strictly enforced law relating to weapons in the country. A license to carry or possess a firearm that may be concealed on the person is extremely difficult to obtain. Applicants for such licenses are carefully investigated and personally interviewed by both the precinct commander and the detective squad commander. The loss of a pistol by a licensee is a serious matter. And the manual of procedure requires that an immediate investigation be conducted by the precinct commander.
When the radio call was put out for me, I instructed my operator, Patrolman Fowl, to stop the nearest call box. I rang into the station house and Lieutenant Gorman informed me of the particulars. I told him to have Mr. Froud wait. When I arrived, Lieutenant Gorman handed me the file copy of the LD-80, the application for a pistol license. And I took the liquor store owner, Mr. Froud, into my office, where I began to question him.
Crazy. I don't know. It's just plain crazy. How can it disappear like that from nowhere?
Well, we know it didn't just walk out by itself, Mr. Froud.
Yeah, that's the thing, Captain. You kept the gun in a drawer in the counter under the cash register?
Yeah.
How long have you been keeping it there?
Well, since I got it. Your license was first issued January 23, 1953. That's how long, yeah. The whole thing.
Guns in SNW-38, Terrier, Blue, and Sunny.
Yeah.
Did you get the drawer locked?
Well, I locked it when I closed up the door. I didn't lock the drawer at night, Captain, but, well, when the store was open, I didn't lock it, because what would be the sense of locking the drawer if suddenly I needed the gun? I was stuck up there three times, you know, in ten years. Who knew when it was going to happen again?
Mm-hmm. When did you last see the gun?
Yesterday morning when I opened the drawer, when I unlocked it.
You're positive it was there then?
Oh, yeah. Yeah. I keep in there also my bank book, deposit slips. I saw it in there when I went to get them out.
And when did you miss it?
Last night, 10 o'clock. When I closed it.
You had no occasion during the day to go to the drawer, see whether the gun was in there?
No, sir, no. No occasion.
How many employees do you have in this front?
Employees? Yeah.
Well, he's not really what you'd call an employee.
Who's that?
Joe. Joe who?
Joe Aguada. He's the fellow that comes in every morning. You know, he sweeps up, he unpacks some goods for me. And when I've got a delivery in the neighborhood, he makes it. He does the same thing for [the] Delicatessen on 3rd Avenue. Cleans up. Makes deliveries. We sort of, um, what we share is time, half and half.
How long has he been working for you?
Oh, a long time. I don't know, three, four years.
Did you ever miss anything out of the store prior to this?
Nothing, no. Not a thing.
I don't think Joe would do anything like this.
Did he know you had a revolver on the premise?
Well, it wasn't any secret, Captain. I didn't go out of my way to tell him, but there wasn't any secret.
Was he in the store yesterday? Between the time you saw the revolver? Was the revolver in the morning and when you missed it at night?
Yup. Yeah, several times. He was in and out all day.
Were you able to observe his actions on each of those occasions?
Well, I didn't see him do anything suspicious. That's what you mean. No, I don't think he'd steal anything, Captain. I really don't.
Do you have any other employees?
No, sir, no.
You're open from about 10 a.m., 10 p.m.?
Yeah, about.
Were you there all that time?
No, I live on 75th on the other side of 2nd Avenue. My wife comes about an hour when I go. We need luncheon, and then she comes to get us for [supper] time.
You say your son helps you out in the store once in a while, too?
Yeah, once in a while, Captain. He goes to CCNY, and he's in the store maybe, well, like one night or two nights a week. [So] Ella and I can eat supper together, maybe take it [easy] a bit.
What's the boy's name?
John, sir. We call him Bud.
Was Bud in the store last night?
He was there, yeah, for a little while. When I came back from supper, he was there with Ella, my wife.
Do you think your son might have taken [it]?
No. Oh, well, why could he?
Well, you thought he might have last night.
Who said that? I didn't say anything like that.
Mr. Froud, you said the reason you didn't report the gun missing last night was that you went home to talk to your wife and your son. To ask them if they saw it.
Yeah, I know, but I'm...
Now, your wife said she didn't, and your son wasn't home when you went to sleep.
Oh, I didn't think he took it. I had to ask him, though, you know, before I went off half-cocked.
Did you ask him?
I asked him that, if he'd seen the gun in the store. If he... If he... If he... If he put it anyplace besides the drawer, he said no. He didn't touch it.
And what did your wife think?
Same thing.
Uh, this, uh, Joe, Joe Guder...
Guada.
Guada. Where does he live?
Harlem, uh, 26th [Street], I think. But he'd be around the neighborhood of your store or the delicatessen this morning. He's supposed to be.
Did you see him this morning?
No, not this morning. And he's supposed to come in, clean up the store?
Well, I didn't go to the store this morning yet. My wife went to the store.
Yeah. Uh, excuse me.
25th Street. [To] Captain Cronin.
Okay. Yes, ma'am. You want to talk to him? Okay, ma'am.
Uh, Mr. Froud, I've asked the commanding officer of the 21st Detective Squad to come downstairs.
For me?
Well, you've got a gun. Can't be accounted for. We've got a [presumption] since stolen.
But I... I don't know who would steal it.
And that's partly a matter of who had access to the drawer, isn't it, Mr. Froud?
Well, I guess so.
Do you know anything about this Joe, besides the fact that he's worked for you and the delicatessen for around three years?
No. Not much.
Is he married?
I think so, yes.
You know whether he's ever been in trouble with the police?
Not since he's been working for me, at least I don't think so. He's been pretty reliable.
How much you paying?
Well, he gets $22.50 from me and $22.50 from the delicatessen, plus tips on the deliveries he makes.
How old is your son, Mr. Froud?
What?
21. He's going to be 22.
He's going to college?
Yeah. Pretty [mad], he said. Bright boy, real bright boy. He was in the army two years, that's why he's a little late in school, but he's going to make a fine doctor. Real fine doctor.
He's going to school on a GI Bill?
Yeah. He just got in under the wire just by a month, six weeks later.
How are his grades at school?
[B's?]
Not bad.
I don't want you to accuse me.
I'm not accusing anyone, Mr. Froud.
Well, he didn't take it, I'm telling you.
All right, we'll make sure.
You don't have to make sure, I'm telling you. I just don't want you thinking he did because he did.
Mr. Froud, apparently you're the one who thinks he might... Mr. Froud, apparently you're the one who thinks he might... It seems to be on your mind.
No, he didn't, I'm telling you.
You were suspicious enough to want to talk to him before you came here.
I just wanted to ask him if he'd seen it.
You having any trouble at home with [Bud], Mr. Froud?
No, no. I mean, he's a boy, you know, he's a boy like any other boy. He's got ideas.
21 years old, he's been in the army, not much of a boy anymore.
What makes you think he took the gun?
I don't think... Now look, Mr. Froud, if he has got it, you better help us get it back from him before he gets in worse trouble.
What kind of trouble?
The kind of trouble a gun can bring.
Do you think he took it?
I don't know. He says he didn't, but I think so.
Now why do you think he took it?
If he did, who knows why? Who knows why he does anything? Why he went to quit school, why he went to [spend] all kinds of money, why he went to get married? Who knows why a kid does anything?
Well, maybe we'll find out.
Because theft of the revolver was suspected, Lieutenant King assigned one of his detectives to go to City College and get [Bud]. In order to pursue my investigation, I instructed Sergeant Rosen on telephone switchboard duty to have a car come by the house for me. When it arrived, Mr. Froud and I got in. I told the operator, Patrolman Ricardo, to drive us to the liquor store on East 75th Street.
Okay, Mr. Froud.
How is something like this? Oh, wait here, Ricardo.
Yes, sir.
We don't know that it was him, Mr. Froud.
Well, Joe wouldn't do anything like that. I just know he wouldn't. Somebody could have walked in the store.
When?
Captain.
Yeah?
Please, don't say anything to Ellie. It'll be bad enough when she finds out.
When we're positive.
All right, Mr. Froud.
Twelve hours a day I spend in [the store], seeing [to things] like that for him. It's my ambition he should have a profession.
John, hello. Any business?
A little, not much.
Oh, this is Captain Cronin. This is my wife, Mrs. Froud.
Glad to know you.
Well?
Well, what?
Nothing.
This is the draw, Captain.
This is a very serious matter, Mrs. Froud. It's a dangerous... Something like that gets in the wrong hands and causes a lot of trouble.
I know. Nobody knows better than me, I realize it.
What time were you in the store yesterday?
[One].
Ella, answer the question.
Don't ask. Don't ask.
Well, I was here when John went to lunch. And I was here when he went home to supper.
At lunch? What time was that?
What time, John?
About 12:15, 12:30.
About 12:15, 12:30. Anyone come into the store during that time?
One or two customers, maybe.
Were they ever in the front of the store alone? Where they could get out the... Where they could get out the... Where they could get out the...
No, they stood there on that side of the counter, and I waited on them.
Was anyone else in the store?
Who? Joe?
No. No, Joe didn't come in when I was here during lunch. I guess he was eating [his lunch].
What time did Mr. Froud get back?
What time, John?
A little after 1.
A little after 1. Then what did you do, Mrs. Froud?
I talked to him for a minute, and then I went. I went to go to the market, and then home to [get supper ready].
Hmm, I see. And what time did you come back to the store again?
When it was time for John to go home for supper.
You see, Captain? She eats, and she puts my [soup] on the stove, and then she walks over to the store, and I go home.
Uh-huh, and that was what time?
Uh, last night, uh, about [5:30], huh?
About, yeah.
Did anyone come into the store while you were here alone?
Well, my son Bart, he came in.
Oh, did he usually stop in when you were here alone?
Sometimes. He was at his girlfriend's house. He went there from school, and he [came] in.
What did he do? What did he say?
We talked. I asked him, did he eat? And he said no, and I told him to go home and have supper. It was on the stove.
He wouldn't come home?
He wouldn't come home because I was there. If you'd leave him alone and stop nagging him, he'd be all right. But you won't leave him alone.
I want him to get those crazy ideas out of his head. I want him to finish college. I don't want him to get a job and get married. What could he have?
He could have a wife.
Joe. Come here, Joe.
Hello, Mr. [Froud]. Miss [Froud].
Joe.
Joe, this is Captain Cronin, Police Department.
Police, uh, uh... Oh, policia. Oh, uh, uh, glad to, uh, to know you.
Joe. Huh?
Uh, Mr. [Froud] keeps a gun in the drawer. Did you know that?
You see, I know.
You know where he keeps it?
See, I know, I know.
Where?
In the drawer. Here. In the drawer.
You [also] know why he keeps the gun.
See, for robbers. Isn't that right, Mr. [Froud]?
For robbers? Yeah, Joe.
When did you handle that gun last, Joe?
Me? Yeah.
Oh, no, no, no, no. It wasn't that. No, no, no. I know, I know. Touch. Not me. I, I, I don't want nothing to do with no gun. I, I don't like it.
You afraid of me? Afraid of the gun?
No, no, no. Not afraid. I, I just don't, don't like it.
Somebody took it yesterday, Joe.
The gun?
Yeah.
Who took it?
Well, we hoped maybe it was you, Joe.
No, no, no.
You know that you were cleaning the drawer and you took it out by mistake.
No, I don't touch. No, no, no. Today. Not me. No. I don't like it. I don't go near these drawers.
And you're never. Do I, Mr. [Froud]?
Not that I've ever seen.
No, Mr. [Froud], do I, eh?
No, Joe.
No. No, I, I don't like guns. I don't go near these drawers. No. No. Never.
You want me to take out the cartons this morning, Mr. Froud? You said yesterday.
Ah, Captain [Cronin] is talking to you, Joe. Excuse me.
That's all right, Joe. I'll talk to you later if I have to. You go on. Get back to work.
See, see, see. Come on and back, Joe.
No, I, I don't go near the drawer. Never, never, Joe.
I'll be right back, Captain, as soon as I show him what to do.
All right, Mr. Froud.
I don't think he did it, not Joe. Doesn't look that way.
Maybe somebody came in from the outside while John was in the back and just took it.
That could happen, couldn't it?
Maybe.
Mrs. Froud, how long has this trouble between your son and your husband been going on?
Trouble? Oh, it's not trouble. It's just a family disagreement.
How long has it been going on?
Oh, since Bud came back from the army, almost. And he says he's too old to go to school. He wants to earn a living and get married. And John's got it in his head that Bud should be a doctor, but he don't want to be a doctor. He's tired of living off the GI Bill and going to the college and studying when he says it doesn't mean a thing, nothing to him.
Oh, why doesn't he quit?
Oh, you'd never hear the end of it. John's crazy enough on the subject.
You think Bud might have taken the gun?
Bud? No, why would he take it?
Bud doesn't have much money. Maybe to sell it?
No, he wouldn't do that. Somebody [else] said it. Not Bud.
Was Bud ever in trouble, Mrs. Froud?
What do you mean, trouble?
I mean, was he ever arrested?
No. He didn't take it, not Bud.
He was never in any trouble?
He was never in any kind of trouble.
No. Well, wasn't Joe. You see what I mean?
John, would Bud take the gun?
No, huh? Why? Why [ask] Joe?
I don't know. I just asked.
No.
All right, excuse me.
What can he do with it?
[Inaudible]
Yeah, sure, he's a captain for your front. That's all right.
Captain Cronin.
Oh, yes, Matt. OK, Matt. Thanks. I'll be down in a little while myself.
Well, I've got to get back to the station house.
Oh, do you?
Yeah, and I think you'd better come with me.
Come with me, Mr. [Froud].
Captain, I was just there. And I can't stay in the store all day. I came here without making the bed [or getting properly dressed]. And my sister's in the hospital.
I think you'd better come, Mr. [Froud].
All right. Ella, I'll come back as soon as I can.
All right. Have Joe sweep out in front as soon as he gets through, huh?
All right. Bye, Mr. [Froud].
Yeah.
Did Bud take the gun? Did he do such a thing? I don't know. I tried to do the best. Make something out of my [boy]. I spent my whole life trying to do that. So you could do it. Well, maybe it's a good thing he didn't get too far.
We got into the car and were driven to the station house by patrolman Mercado. Mr. Froud didn't say a word all the way. He just sat there looking straight ahead. Possession of a gun by an unlicensed person is a serious crime in the state of New York. I wondered as much as the father did as to why the young man took the gun. There were two obvious reasons. One, to sell it. The other, to use in a robbery. A few minutes later, the car pulled up in front of the station house. Mr. Froud and I came out of the car. Mr. Froud and I came out of the car. Mr. Froud and I came out of the car. I got out. I instructed patrolman Mercado to pick up his partner and resume patrol. As the car pulled away, we crossed the sidewalk, mounted the three worn stone steps that led to the muster room.
Well, Lieutenant [Gorman] was desk officer and Sergeant Rosen still had telephone switchboard duty.
Now, you wait here, Mr. Froud. I have to go around and sign the blotter.
All right.
Please send Sergeant Rosen.
Captain.
No, Sergeant.
Hello, Captain. What's the matter, Lieutenant?
Nothing, Captain. Very quiet.
Good. Oh, uh, did you see Whitey Howard go upstairs with the other men?
Oh, yes, sir. Just a few minutes ago.
Okay. I'll be up there with the detective.
Yes, sir. Come on, Mr. Froud.
All right.
I'm gonna go upstairs. Is that where they have him?
Yeah.
Yeah, he's up there.
No, right ahead, Mr. Froud.
Don't understand. He struggles the worst. What do we do it for? For him? To take a gun and hold up somebody?
We don't know that that's the reason.
Ah, [Captain]. What other reason could there be? He never should have got that gun. Not if I had 40 stick-ups. If he'd wanted one, he'd have got one. He'd have got one somewhere. You can be sure of that.
All right. All right, now. I'll take your time.
Come in, Captain. Go ahead, Mr. Froud.
You're working hard. Look at you. Steal but to steal from your own father and a gun. What are you trying to do to me? Didn't you eat my heart out enough since you got back from the Army? What are you trying to do to me now? Kill me?
You've got it all wrong.
I got it terrible. I got it lousy. That's how I got it.
Ah, listen. Don't touch me. Leave me alone.
I didn't steal the gun.
No. What? What? What did you do?
I took it out of the drawer and hid it in a case of wine on the floor by the window.
Why did you do that, Bud?
Because he's been carrying on about my wanting to quit school and wanting to get married. He's been carrying on like mad.
You're not going to quit.
I quit already, Pa, today. And I got married last week.
Oh, you didn't.
Yeah, I did. I was going to tell you and Ma last night in the store, but I lost my nerve. I didn't know what to do or what to say, and that's why I hid the gun. I didn't want it around.
You thought I'd... that I would do something with the gun? That I'd be that crazy to kill myself?
I just didn't want to take the chance.
Oh, Bud. Bud, how could you think that?
I know. I know. I've been a little...
You got married.
Yeah, last week at City Hall. I'm sorry, Pa. We didn't want to keep it a secret, but I wanted to get it done. I wanted it my way for a change. My way.
You're right. You're right to do what you wanted to do. But I'm glad for you. I'm very glad for you. I caused you so much trouble.
We've got plenty of real trouble around here, Mr. [Froud]. This kind of trouble, I like.
What do you think, Sergeant [Rosen]?
I don't know, sir. The captain's not in the house right now. He's out on patrol.
You've got who?
I'm so sure.
Around the clock, through the week, every day, every year. A police precinct in the city of New York is a flesh-and-blood merry-go-round. Anyone can catch the brass ring. Or, the brass ring can catch anyone.
21st Precinct transcribed. A factual account of the way the police work in the world's largest city is presented with the official cooperation of the Patrolman's Benevolent Association, an organization of more than 20,000 members of the police department's city of New York. James Gregory in the role of Captain Cronin, Ken Lynch as Lieutenant King. Featured in tonight's cast were Santos Ortega, Jack Orison, Bill Zuckert, Martin Newman, Ralph Camargo, and Ethel Everett. Written and produced by Stanley Nitz, Art Hanna speaking.
