Skip to content
On Air
All channelsAll
Barrie Craig, Confidential Investigator artwork

From the Barrie Craig, Confidential Investigator collection

The Corpse Who Was Wrong

Episode 037May 25, 195429 min 21 secTranscript

The written record

Read the transcript

Read along with the recording · About 20 min to read

William Gargan stars as Barrie Craig, Confidential Investigator.

Murderers really have a hard time. In other fields, if a man's work is properly appreciated, he gets higher pay. All a murderer gets is higher voltage.

The National Broadcasting Company presents William Gargan in another transcribed drama of mystery and adventure with America's number one detective, Barrie Craig, Confidential Investigator.

Barrie Craig speaking.

It all began quietly enough. He walked into my office, stared contemptuously at the rug, sourly at the furniture, and coldly at me.

He said, "Good afternoon, Mr. Craig. I am W. Stubbins."

"How do you do?"

"I am an attorney. I represent Arthur Philip Peterson."

"You do, huh?"

"You are questioning my word?"

"I was just being friendly."

"That is not necessary."

"Oh, forgive me. Tcha. Is that annoyance or Russian soup?"

"I find your levity irksome, Mr. Craig."

"There's no extra charge, Mr. Stubbins. Were it not for Mr. Peterson's insistence upon hiring you..."

"That's Arthur Philip Peterson?"

"Never mind that. Tcha. You might tell me about the case instead of trying to impress me with Mr. Peterson's importance."

"I shall."

"Good."

"I have here a photograph."

"Thanks. Of Mrs. Peterson."

"Stella Peterson, to be precise."

"Now I have the photograph. Also, on this paper..."

"Uh-huh."

"The address of the lodgings where Mrs. Peterson was last known to be, plus her last place of employment."

"I am to assume that she no longer lives or works at these addresses?"

"That is correct."

"And I am to locate her?"

"If possible."

"How long has it been since she dropped out of sight?"

"Oh, three months or so."

"Somebody wasn't in a hurry."

"There were circumstances..."

"Oh, I'm sure there were. The photograph's nice and clear, but..."

"I have also here a physical description of the, uh, lady. Age, coloring, height, weight, and so on."

"Well, that might help, but it isn't exactly what I had in mind. Hmm. It says here she was 24. How old's Peterson?"

"61."

"Well, now we know a lot more. How well do you know Mrs. Peterson?"

"I barely know her at all."

"Well, in that case, I'll have to see Mr. Peterson."

"Seeing Mr. Peterson would do you no good."

"Well, why? Is he bashful?"

"No. He's dead."

With which remark, W. Stubbins decided I had enough information, wrote, deposited a check for $500 on my desk, and left. I wondered what the W stood for.

The address of Stella Peterson's last known lodging was 1217 West 29th Street. The neighborhood wasn't nice. Unless the photograph was telling lies about Stella's appearance, it wasn't the right neighborhood for her. As a matter of fact, it wasn't the right neighborhood for anyone.

"Yeah. You're Mrs. Cole, the janitor?"

"Superintendent."

"Sorry. I've been checking the mailboxes in the hall. Stella Peterson's name isn't on any of them."

"Why should it be?"

"She lives here, doesn't she?"

"No."

"Oh. She must have moved then."

"Not from here, she didn't."

"Not from here. Mrs. Cole, are you trying to tell me Stella Peterson never lived here?"

"I told you."

"Oh. She may have been using a different name. If you take a look at this photograph, you might recognize her."

"What would a girl like that be doing in a house like this?"

"Well, that's one of the things I wanted to ask her."

"Don't bother dropping around with the answer when you find out."

"You don't recognize her?"

"No."

"Well, tell me, how long have you been superintendent here?"

"Ten years."

"Thank you, Mrs. Cole."

"Don't mention it."

"One thing puzzles me, though."

"Yeah?"

"You recognized her name immediately. Didn't ask to have it repeated."

"That's so."

"I'm still puzzled."

"You oughtn't be, mister."

"What makes you think you're the first one who's been here asking for her?"

The interview was definitely at an end. Mrs. Cole shut the door in my face. I had no regrets about leaving that house. It was a process that only the dead wouldn't have enjoyed. I climbed into my car and went away. I wondered how big a liar Mrs. Cole was.

It took ten minutes for me to be sure I was being followed by someone in a green car. I decided it was too early in the case to get drastic about it. I let him follow.

Stella Peterson's last known place of employment was in the low 50s. It called itself the 1020 Club. I had the feeling that the only qualifications for joining consisted of being alive and foolish.

"Hey, you're a little early, pal. If you was a bird, you'd get the worm."

"And if I were a worm, that bird would get me. I'm looking for Stella Peterson."

"It so happens I ain't got her around me. Maybe I left her in my other suit."

"Does the name mean anything to you?"

"It's a girl's name."

"Well, she may have worked here under another name. Take a look at her picture."

"Oh, let's you and me both go look for her. Then we'll toss a coin."

"Why don't you save it for the customer?"

"No sense of humor. Recognize this?"

"That there is a beautiful shade of green. I like the way they engraved those 20s in the corner. Let me have a closer look, huh?"

"Thanks. Where do I go to find Stella Peterson?"

"You tried the lost and found department at Grand Central?"

The nice thing about being a confidential investigator is you get to meet such lovely people. Even policemen.

"Well, Lieutenant Rogers. Hello, Barry. Buying me dinner or are you working?"

"Well, maybe we can combine the best features of both, Trav. Name one good feature of working."

"Well, you get paid for it."

"I keep forgetting that. Working for the department, it's easy to do."

"Wouldn't your boss object to your eating on his time?"

"He's dead."

"I guess he wouldn't object. He must be a lively corpse if he's going around hiring investigators."

"The name's Arthur Philip Peterson."

"Oh, very impressive. What's he hired you to investigate?"

"Well, I've got a picture here. See?"

"Hmm. Didn't anyone ever tell him he couldn't take that with him?"

"He's not really trying. He died sometime last week. Heart. That's his wife. She left him more than three months ago."

"Uh-huh. What information do you want stolen from the department?"

"Anything the department has on her. If it has anything."

"We'll see. What's the front name?"

"Stella."

"I'll feed it to the gallery boys. What else?"

"A green car keeps driving around behind me. License number 1W17660."

"You want us to discourage him?"

"No, I'd feel lonely without him. I'd like his name, though, in case we ever meet socially."

"1W17660. I've got a couple of hours' work here, Barry. After that, I'll be your guest."

"Fine. I'll go back to the office. You can call me there. Maybe we'll eat at Willie's Wagon."

"No, thanks. I've still got scars from the last hamburger I tried to eat there."

"Well, you can't say the meat isn't fresh."

"Or does it have to be alive?"

"In a couple of hours, then."

"All right. Keep out of trouble."

"I intend to be very hungry."

I headed back to the office. The green car was still behind me. I couldn't make up my mind whether or not to worry about it. I decided. I decided to postpone the decision. But I didn't use the front entrance to the building. The back door and the stairs up would be smarter under the circumstances. Every once in a while, I do the smart thing. It always leads to trouble.

"No."

"Huh?"

"Don't put the light on."

"Why not?"

"I'll shoot you if you do."

"How good a shot are you?"

"Pretty good. You're a big man. I'm not very far away from you."

"Meaning anybody who could hit the side of a barn door?"

"All right. I'm willing to discuss the matter."

"I'm not going to discuss it. I'm not going to discuss it. I'm not going to discuss it. I'm not going to discuss it. I'm not going to discuss it. I'm not going to discuss it. I'm not going to discuss the matter. Get away from the light switch."

"Want me to leave?"

"No. Go to your desk."

"What am I supposed to use instead of vision? Radar?"

"Your eyes must be getting accustomed to the dark. Just walk straight forward. Straight forward. Women and cats are much better at this kind of thing."

"Look out!"

"Ow!"

"That was a chair you ran into."

"Thanks for telling you."

"I tried to warn you."

"If you really cared, you'd let me put the light on."

"No. Sit down."

"You mean I happen to be directly above a chair right now?"

"No. Right now? The one you knocked over. Pick it up."

"Oh. Okay. If I knew exactly where you were, I could throw this chair at you."

"That wouldn't be nice."

"It might be. The only trouble is, I don't know you well enough yet to decide whether you deserve being thrown chairs at."

"Well, thanks for asking me to sit. Mr. Craig."

"Yeah?"

"Why are you looking for Stella Peterson?"

"What makes you think I am?"

"But you are, aren't you?"

"One of the things you want to look for, if you ever hire a confidential, is whether he knows how to keep his mouth shut."

"About confidential things?"

"Well, yes."

"Your looking for Stella Peterson isn't a secret."

"It hasn't made the front page of the Times, either."

"You've been asking people about her?"

"When I went down to lunch today, I asked the boy at the newsstand who won the 6th at Jamaica. I'm not investigating a racehorse."

"That's not the same."

"No, it isn't. But there's nothing you can do about it."

"Look, I... Why not try telling me why you're so interested in anyone looking for Stella Peterson?"

"Stella Peterson. I'm interested because..."

"Yeah?"

"Because I'm Stella Peterson."

By this time, my eyes had adjusted a little better to the absence of light. I could see her, but not well enough to tell whether or not she was lying. If you want to stop a search, the best way is to indicate that the object searched for has already been found. I wasn't satisfied.

"You may be Stella Peterson."

"Don't you think I know who I am?"

"But I don't."

"Well, I am Stella Peterson."

"Repeating a lie doesn't make it into a truth."

"I'm not lying."

"I didn't say you were. I'm not saying you're telling the truth, either. One way or another, I have no way of telling."

"But why should anyone imitate me?"

"Why should you be afraid of letting me look at you in the light?"

"It's too dangerous. Someone outside might see the light go on here."

"Sooner or later, it'll have to go on."

"But luck went on here. Okay. Good night."

"But you haven't told me why you've been looking for me."

"I haven't told you that I am looking for Stella Peterson, either. I..."

"Too early for Trav. Someone's out there."

"Yeah. Outside the door."

"What are you doing?"

"Moving up to the door. On one side of it. The door isn't locked. We're going to have company."

"Don't use that gun of yours."

"So glad you could come."

"Hey, let go."

"Never come visiting with a gun in your hand."

"Okay, I'll drop it."

"You're breaking my arm."

"Oh, thanks. Now, get over to the side. All the way over."

"Wise guy."

"Now, nice. The gun."

"Yeah. And I think... The lights."

"Where the... Hmm. The door to the next office. Jimmy'd open. That's how she got in here."

"How who got in here?"

"You don't see anyone here now, do you?"

"She could have got out through that door to the next office."

"Who could have?"

"The one who got in."

"And who was that?"

"Well, that's what I asked you."

"We're back at the beginning again, huh?"

"Yeah, it looks that way, don't it?"

"All right. So far as you're concerned, it began with your walking in here. Carrying a gun in your hand. Why the gun?"

"I thought the joint was being burgled. I am a public-spirited citizen."

"And you happen to be strolling past the office? Up on the fourth floor of an office building, late in the evening?"

"That's right. It ain't so drafty up here like down on the street."

"Not as safe, either. You're not gonna try any rough stuff, are you?"

A police lieutenant named Rogers is going to be along in about a half an hour.

I already got all my tickets to the policeman's ball.

Maybe, but... What he'll give you is a burglary charge.

Burglary?

Yeah, yeah. Breaking and entering. Plus attempted armed robbery. Add it up for yourself.

Add it up? That could be ten years.

Easily.

Oh, now, wait. I didn't burn...

My word's a lot better than yours.

It ain't enough.

Maybe you're right. Hmm. See that pen on my desk?

Yeah. Pick it up and put it in your pocket.

Well, what do you... Hey, wait. That'll prove that I robbed...

Nothing doing. Nothing doing.

Would you rather I shot you as you were breaking and entering?

But you didn't.

But I will. Pick up the pen.

No. What do you want from me? What's your name?

Empty.

Who hired you?

Uh-uh.

You prefer ten years up the river? Meaning you're more afraid of whoever it is. I better get out of here.

Hey, come back here.

He knew I wouldn't use the gun on him.

Barry Craig here. Why not? On 29th Street? 12-17 West. 12-17 West, 29th Street? She was the janitor? Excuse me, the superintendent there? I'll meet you there.

Yeah?

I didn't waste any time standing around and looking surprised. The green car was registered in Stella Peterson's name. That might be important later on. Right now, a woman named Mrs. Cole was more important. She was dead. But I thought she might have something to say to me anyway.

Hey, uh, Lieutenant.

Oh, hello, Barry. Uh, how was she, uh...

Strangled? Not pretty, but quiet.

Yeah. Body was discovered fast by accident. Grocery boy walked in, found her.

Uh, break, maybe.

Not for Mrs. Cole?

I wasn't thinking of Mrs. Cole. Could I have a look at her, Trav?

Yeah, sure. As soon as I brush a few photographers aside. Come on. I don't know why you want to look, though.

I expect her to tell me something. Our boy's out of the way.

There she is.

Yeah. Well, I don't hear her talking.

She's telling me plenty, though.

Like what?

Look at her wrists.

Interesting. You hadn't gone around to noticing details like that yet.

I expected them. Burns on her wrist and forearm.

Yeah. The kind that would result if you pressed lighted cigarette ends there. She was tortured before she died.

That's right. I'm leaving, Trav.

Uh, Barry, you know more about this than...

Well, it's not a police job. It can't be. If you'd only slow things up, there isn't time enough for that.

You sure?

I have to play it the way I see it.

Okay, Barry. Luck.

Thanks.

The thing was forming into a pattern. I didn't feel bright realizing it because the pattern was backwards. And I was a step behind, as I've been since the beginning of the case. Maybe a fatal step.

The 10-20 Club was open for business. I went around to the back. The green car wasn't anywhere, so I went inside.

Hold it, huh?

Hey, it's the pal with the 20 bucks. You still got it?

What's your name?

Wendell. Is that the name that wins the 20?

Mrs. Cole is dead, Wendell.

Mrs. Cole? This conversation is getting out of hand. Who's Mrs. Cole?

Janitor over on 29th Street. The house Stella Peterson stayed in for a while before ducking for cover.

Yeah, well, janitors don't lead. They lead healthy lives. Lots of them die.

Of strangulation?

Well, maybe she was cheating on her husband or not emptying the ash cans right or...

She was tortured before she died.

Tortured?

Yeah. The way I figure, whoever tortured her got what he was after.

How do you figure that?

He wouldn't have killed her otherwise. She was a lead. Maybe the only real lead he had.

That could be. Where's Stella?

Out on the island, a beach shack.

Phone?

No.

Neighbors?

Not for miles. Come on, we're in a hurry. A big hurry.

We made time. I didn't break too many traffic laws. Only one. The one that keeps your speed down. We were lucky. We didn't pick up any traffic cops on the way. Or were we lucky?

How much further?

Oh, maybe another ten minutes at this rate.

You carry a gun?

No.

Then don't try being a hero when we get there. You ain't expecting anything good, are you?

No. Who does the shack belong to?

Mrs. Cole. That's why you...

Anybody besides you and Mrs. Cole knows Stella is staying there?

I don't think so. But that was before they got to work on Mrs... Forget it. For now. Stella dropped into my office.

Huh?

She had some idea of forcing me to tell her who'd hired me and why. Once she found out I was looking for her.

I know.

Sure. You were driving the green car. The one that was tailing me.

Yeah. Stella took it to drive out to the...

The shack?

Yeah. After she ducked out of your place. Too bad you didn't know about Mrs. Cole then.

Yeah. Too bad. Better slow down. Shack is off a private road. Turning's right ahead.

Okay. You've run out of road another hundred feet.

Uh-huh. Come on. This time of year the beach is deserted. That's why Stella figured it was safe. It was for a while.

Got the shack?

Yeah. The lights on. The odds are against her being alone. Wendell, maybe you better get back to the car and...

Oh, no. I'm in this with you.

Okay. Stella's a good kid.

She must be. You get this kind of loyalty. Although, uh, would the fact she's inheriting Peterson's dough make a difference?

She's inheriting... But the old man said he was going to cut her out of his will.

That was when she left him?

Yeah. He said if she did...

He changed his mind.

Wendell. I'm an empty. The guy?

Yeah. He must have picked up another gun someplace. He may be jumpy. We'll have to handle this carefully. Is there a back door?

Yeah. Leads to the kitchen. You can see the kitchen door from here. Now, give me a count of 30. Then knock at the front door.

Count of 30. Okay. Think it'll work?

It'll have to.

Then I made the back door. Five. And I had it open. Crossing the kitchen without knocking over the pots and pans. It took eight. That gave me seven seconds. I used them in getting the door to the living room open a crack. And then I waited. Wendell knocked and I moved fast. Empty turned to the door. He heard me coming. But before he could get around, I...

Yeah. That's Wendell at the door. Open it for him, huh?

Yeah. Yeah, all right.

That was when I heard the sound of the car. I didn't hang around. I ducked into the kitchen.

Hiya, Stella.

Wendell.

Oh, Mr. Craig knocked the man out. The one who...

Mr. Craig? What happened to him?

I don't know. He was just here. He must have gone out the back way.

Oh, I, uh... I better get this boy's pop gun. He's coming, too.

I got it. He'll be all right. He'll be fine.

Mr. Stubbins. Mr. Stubbins. Drop the gun, you.

Me?

Yes.

Oh, I... I didn't know you meant me.

Empty? He don't feel good. The idiot. How he ever let you get the best of him, I... Well, never mind.

Mr. Stubbins, what are you going to do?

What do you think?

But why? What have I done to you?

It wasn't you, my dear. It was that blithering husband of yours.

I don't understand.

You left him, justifiably enough. He was turning into a senile idiot. You left him, and he threatened to disinherit you. You ignored his threat, for which my compliments.

Thanks, but I...

Of course, he tried to get you back. We did discover your address, the place you work, but I made no great effort. I was waiting for Peterson to carry out his threat.

But why did you care?

He planned to leave his money to various charities, of which I would be sole administrator. I, uh... I counted on that. As a matter of fact, I rather anticipated the event. I, uh... Borrowed some of the money. And then the, uh... Idiot decided he admired you for your courage in leaving him.

Oh, and then...

And he... He did not disinherit you after all. I faced jail, my dear. I kept hoping until the last moment, but then he died, leaving you his money. And if I die, too?

The money will revert to the estate. I can, uh... Arrange matters to my satisfaction there. That is why I persuaded Mrs. Cole to give me this address. Why I sent Empty on ahead to hold you. And why I shall now...

Oh, no!

Sorry, my dear, but it's oh, yes.

Wonderful kitchen you've got back there. Mr. Stubbins is all right. He'll live to die. There's not much explanation needed, so if you don't mind, I'll get it over with quick.

With Peterson's death, Stubbins had to move fast. But he didn't dare move without confusing the trail. That's why he hired me. If I could find out, fine. If I failed, there was always Mrs. Cole and torture. In either case, the trail would be confused. Why did it work? Why did I expect him to be the killer? Because he was the only one who could have sent Empty to my office.

I owe you everything.

Not really everything.

Well, enough so that I want to give you this.

Hmm. This is why I wanted to get the explanation over with quick.

You've been listening to William Gargan in another exciting transcribed mystery drama from the adventures of Barry Craig, confidential investigator. Tonight's story, The Corpse Who Was Wrong, was written by Lou Vittes. Next week, it's the strange story titled The Corpse Who Stayed for Breakfast, about which Barry Craig has this to say. Next week's story deals with at least two corpses, a house on the river, a midnight swim accompanied by bullets, and, oh yes, the corpse who came to breakfast didn't eat a thing. Good night, folks. See you next week.

The National Broadcasting Company has just brought you William Gargan, starring as Barry Craig, confidential investigator. Featured in the role of Mrs. Cole was Bryna Raeburn. Don Pardo speaking.

I'm Dinah Shore, and I'm here to tell you a little about our twice-weekly radio program on most of these NBC stations. We're on every Tuesday and Friday evening, you know, and we do our best to crowd each of our 15-minute programs with real entertainment. Why not make it a regular date to listen to our Dinah Shore shows every Tuesday and Friday evening on the NBC station. On the NBC Radio Network.

It's another exciting Dragnet adventure tonight on the NBC Radio Network.

End of transcriptBack to the beginning ↑