The written record
Read the transcript
Read along with the recording · About 19 min to read
That's the truth.
Boris says otherwise.
Boris is a pathological liar. He's a notorious practical joker. He invited Rita to the party to cause trouble between Cora and me. He delights in that sort of thing.
But you and Cora patched things up. When was that?
At the party. Cora came up to me and apologized. She admitted she'd been unreasonable, jealous, possessive. She said she wanted to start all over again. I was very touched.
And Rita? What did she say to this touching reconciliation?
Rita was furious. She threatened to kill Cora. She said if she couldn't have me, no one would.
That's a statement you want me to pass along to the police?
I don't care what you do. I'm telling you the truth. Rita was insanely jealous. She was wearing a dagger as part of her costume. The Queen of Sheba always carries a jeweled dagger.
I remembered the ruby on her forehead. And the harem silk. But I hadn't noticed any dagger.
Where did Rita go after this scene?
I don't know. I left the party shortly afterward. I came home and began to play the piano. I always play when I'm upset.
Liszt. The Hungarian Rhapsody. Very appropriate for a grief-stricken widower.
I loved my wife, Mr. Craig. In my own way. We had our difficulties, but I didn't want her dead.
But you hired Gurko to forget his duty. That doesn't look innocent.
I was desperate. I knew how it would look. The young husband, the older wife, the other woman. A cliché, but effective in court.
I left Mark Wilmer playing his piano and drove over to Rita Romaine's apartment. It was one of those glass-and-chrome places that look like they're waiting for the furniture to arrive. She answered the door in a peignoir that probably cost more than my car. Her eyes were red, but whether from crying or the late hour, I couldn't tell.
Mr. Craig. The detective. Mark told me you might come.
He did? That was thoughtful of him.
He said you'd try to pin Cora's murder on me. He said you'd believe his lies.
What lies would those be, Miss Romaine?
That I threatened Cora. That I was jealous. That I killed her.
Weren't you jealous?
I was furious. At Mark, not Cora. He was using me, playing both ends against the middle. He told me he was going to divorce Cora and marry me. Then he'd tell her the same story about patching things up. Mark Wilmer is a very convincing liar.
But you went to the party with him.
I went alone. Boris invited me. Mark was surprised to see me there. Surprised and annoyed. He was playing his little game, and I was complicating it.
What about the dagger? The Queen of Sheba's jeweled dagger?
She laughed, a hard, brittle sound. She walked to a dressing table and opened a drawer. Inside was a theatrical prop, a rubber dagger with painted jewels.
This is my dagger, Mr. Craig. Would you like to examine it? I haven't worn a real weapon in my life.
I examined it. She was right. It bent like a noodle.
Then whose dagger killed Cora?
Ask Mark. Or ask Boris. Or ask that photographer who was taking pictures all evening. He saw everything and everyone. He was everywhere.
The society photographer. The unemployed diplomat in striped pants. I'd forgotten about him.
I found him in a darkroom in the basement of his boarding house. He was developing pictures from the party, and the chemical fumes made the place smell like a hospital corridor. He looked up when I came in, his eyes red and watering.
Who are you? How'd you get in?
The door was open. I'm Barrie Craig. I was at Boris's party.
Oh. The bouncer in the tuxedo. I remember you. Up on the balcony, looking down your nose.
I came down. You said so yourself.
What do you want?
Pictures. Of the murder. You were taking flash shots all evening. You must have caught something.
He turned back to his trays, agitating prints with tongs. His hands were stained brown from the chemicals.
I don't know what you're talking about. I was hired to take party pictures. Society page stuff. Not crime scene photos.
Cora Wilmer was murdered on that patio. You were there. You were everywhere.
I was not on the patio at midnight. I was in the kitchen, raiding the refrigerator. Boris's chef makes a foie gras that is simply criminal.
Convenient alibi. Got any witnesses?
The chef. Two waiters. And a very indignant cat.
I looked around the darkroom. There were contact sheets pinned to a line, drying. I could see tiny images of costumed figures, masks, the balcony, the dance floor.
What about the pictures you took on the patio? Before midnight?
He stopped agitating. His shoulders tightened.
I didn't take any pictures on the patio. Too dark. No flash equipment for distance shots.
Then what were you doing up on the balcony with me? You weren't just taking pictures of dancers.
He turned around slowly. His face had changed. The unemployed diplomat look was gone. Something harder underneath.
All right, Craig. I'll level with you. I wasn't hired by Boris. I was hired by Cora Wilmer.
Cora?
She suspected Mark was going to kill her. She wanted evidence. Pictures of him with Rita, pictures of him acting suspicious. She paid me five hundred dollars in advance.
And did you get what she wanted?
I got pictures of Mark and Rita arguing. I got pictures of Mark slipping something into his wife's champagne glass. And I got pictures of him following her out to the patio at eleven forty-five.
The champagne glass. What was in it?
I don't know. But Cora drank it. And twenty minutes later, she was dead.
I took the negatives. Gurko had his price, and this photographer had his. I paid him two hundred dollars for the whole set and drove straight to police headquarters. The medical examiner had finished his preliminary report. Cora Wilmer had been stabbed, yes, but she'd also been heavily sedated. Chloral hydrate in her champagne. Enough to make her sluggish, confused, easy prey.
I went back to Boris's mansion in the gray dawn. The party debris was still everywhere, like a battlefield after the army has moved on. Boris was in his study, wearing a brocade dressing gown and looking remarkably fresh for a man who'd been up all night.
Back again, Mr. Craig? You are indefatigable.
And you are under arrest, Boris. As an accessory before and after the fact.
He didn't even blink. He poured himself something from a cut-glass decanter.
Really? On what evidence?
On Mark Wilmer's confession. He talked to the police an hour ago. He killed Cora, yes, but you helped him plan it. You invited Rita to cause jealousy. You hired me as a blind, so no one would suspect an inside job. You even suggested the chloral hydrate, didn't you? Your special Mohammedan beverage from Istanbul. Only it wasn't coffee. It was a colorless, tasteless sedative that Mark could slip into his wife's drink.
Boris sipped his drink. He smiled, that cherubic smile that had fooled so many people for so long.
And the dagger? Did I supply that too?
No. Mark used his own. A theatrical prop, but real steel. He played Hamlet, remember? He knew how to use a dagger. But he couldn't have done it without you. You created the situation. You provided the opportunity. And you were going to split Cora's estate with him, weren't you? That was the real payoff. Not the thousand you paid me. The millions Mark would inherit.
Boris set down his glass. The smile was still there, but it had frozen.
You are very clever, Mr. Craig. Almost as clever as you think you are. But you have no proof of this conspiracy. Mark's word against mine. And Mark is a confessed murderer. Hardly a credible witness.
I have the photographer's pictures. I have the champagne glass, still in your kitchen sink, unwashed. I have the medical examiner's report. And I have your check to me, Boris. A thousand dollars for a bouncer at a party. That's excessive, even for a bon vivant. It looks like hush money.
The smile finally cracked. Boris reached for the decanter again, but his hand was shaking.
I want a lawyer.
You'll need one. And a good one. Because the district attorney is very interested in your French society columns. All those bon vivants and intimate parties. He's wondering how many other murders you've helped along. How many other young husbands with old wives. How many other daggers in the dark.
They took Boris away in a black sedan. I watched from the balcony, the same balcony where I'd stood the night before, looking down on his guests. The morning traffic was starting up, ordinary people going to ordinary jobs. No masks, no costumes, no secrets.
I thought about Cora Wilmer, fifty years old, chasing youth with a young husband and older dreams. I thought about Mark Wilmer, playing Hamlet, the melancholy Dane, playing it too well. I thought about Rita Romaine, with her rubber dagger and her real tears. And I thought about Badger Boris, who slept all day and stayed up all night, and who thought he could buy and sell anything, including murder.
A confidential cop enjoys a certain public popularity. He gets haberdashers circulars, anonymous threatening letters, and invitations to parties. But the parties he remembers are the ones where someone doesn't go home. Where the masks come off and the faces underneath are ugly and desperate and very, very human.
I went down to my office and poured myself a cup of coffee. Real coffee, not from Istanbul. I sat at my desk and waited for the phone to ring. There would be another case, another client, another story. There always was.
This is Barrie Craig, signing off. Until next time, keep your doors locked, your eyes open, and your champagne untampered with. Good night.
The National Broadcasting Company has presented William Gargan as Barrie Craig, Confidential Investigator. This is NBC, the National Broadcasting Company.
Why would Boris lie? Ask Boris.
I will. What made you reconcile with a wife you obviously, uh, would say disliked?
Huh. Futility. Cora couldn't be discarded decently in an adult way.
She had a way of insinuating herself. Taking hold and holding on. I couldn't stand up to the war against her. It was too, too wearing, too morbid. I realized that and gave up trying to win my freedom from her.
You gave up Rita Romaine?
I gave up dreaming.
But now with your wife conveniently dead?
My personal situation isn't improved, it's worse.
You mean jail?
I mean jail.
Not if you're innocent of murder.
That won't matter. I'll deny it, but I'll be condemned. The outlook is very black. I married for money, that's a count against me. I had violent scenes with my wife. I loved another woman, that will hang me.
Pretty fatalistic outlook.
I'm a realist. Hard luck has dogged me since I can remember. I'm never on top of a life situation. I've lived my life without a laugh, without a light moment. I'll cry the day after tomorrow.
You were Hamlet in costume at tonight's party.
Yes, I was. If you like. Here it is. The belt around the waist with the scabbard attached.
What about it?
The scabbard is empty. Where is the dagger that goes with it?
Dagger? I didn't know that there was it. Was that how Cora was murdered?
A dagger into the heart. I told you I'd deny it, but I'd be condemned anyhow. A missing dagger in my costume, it's typical of my luck.
Then you won't try to explain it?
I can't explain it, Mr. Craig. I can't explain it because I simply don't know.
And now back to William Gargan starring as Barrie Craig, confidential investigator.
A guy on the edge of becoming delirious, you leave him for another day, a calm of time. Besides, I needed sleep myself. I got into my car. I just pulled away from the curb when I got noticed with sleep. It was going to be a missing ingredient in my future. A try at murder number two, yours truly, the victim. I drove around the block and around again with my headlight down. Watching for a car somewhere to come to life. Start up and show the glow of its taillight. My car was the only way the rifleman could quit the area. The area was suburban, way off of the main hub. No taxis, no bus lines, and it was 4 a.m. Somebody had to try and escape by an automobile parked somewhere in the vicinity. All I had to do was cruise around and watch and hope.
When I saw it, I saw the taillight first. The car starting up a half block away, pulling away from the curb. I raced over to it. I cut across its path, trapping it. A lady motorist took offense at what I'd done.
Miss, you're in my way.
That was the understatement of the century. I got out to go hunt for a rifle.
Sorry to be so melodramatic, Miss. Romaine, isn't it?
Yes. How did you know my name?
Search me. It was the first name that popped into my head. I want a look in the back of your car, beautiful.
You have no right.
Don't please overplay the indignation, doll. I'm a detective. I'm at work.
Well, I don't find it.
Find what?
A rifle used on me a little while ago.
This whole thing is absurd.
Yes, isn't it? I'd apologize, only I found something even more exciting than a rifle.
You found something?
Right on the back seat, wedged into a car. A dagger, beautiful. More specifically, a blood-stained dagger.
We kept company, the Queen of Sheba and me, in a roadside diner. We split a gallon of black coffee down the middle while she poured out her sad tale.
I tell you, I don't know how to explain this dagger, Mr. Craig.
Mr. Craig? It's too early in the morning for stiff formality. Barrie.
What were you doing parked down the street from the Wilmer place?
I went to see Mark. How he was.
Just outside, starting up his walk, I thought better of it. It looked too compromising at that hour. I changed my mind. So I went back to my car.
You went to see Mark Wilmer hardly two hours after the murder of his wife?
Yes. I know it was terribly foolish, but I never made a secret of my feeling for Mark. So confess it to me. I'm desperately in love with him. It's not so shameful as it seems. You see, I knew Mark first, before Cora did. We were engaged to be married, we had wonderful plans. Mark was a great man, afraid of our poverty. We were surely defeated because of the desperate lack of money, he said. Our marriage could not succeed. He kept adding postponement, postponement, until...
Until Cora happened along. Rich, possessive. She played on Mark's weakness, his insecurity, his overvalue of money. She bought him. Mark never really broke our engagement. He just eloped with Cora.
Why would your recent party host, Badger Boris, try to throw suspicion on Mark?
To hurt me, through Mark. Boris, well, he fancies me. I've laughed at his advances, turned down his proposals of marriage, but Boris doesn't forget, or even forgive. He harbors grudges. He's a horribly twisted egoist.
Did you go to the party with Mark Wilmer?
No, I came alone. Mark came with Cora. And Boris did lie to me.
I now have three capital suspects.
Three suspects?
Mark, wanting out of his marriage, out with profit. You, to get rid of a rival who'd stolen your dearly beloved. And now, Badger Boris, to beat you over the head by framing the man you love.
Now, let's go, doll.
I'm under arrest?
House custody. Your own house, this is. The dagger was too conveniently where I could find it. I don't think you could be that careless about a murder weapon. Or could you?
While catching a snooze on my office chair, a visitor barged in. The private eye, Gurko. Just a little tipsy, like he'd been celebrating something. Celebrating his windfall was my idea, but I wasn't saying it aloud.
Barrie Craig?
None other.
Well, hello, colleague. Gurko's the name. I'm a private dick like you.
The assumption is debatable.
I don't get the crack.
It's a delicate question of morals, but skip it. What brings you staggering?
I'm here to say my piece about Mark Wilmer.
So say it.
Wilmer is an okay guy. He's a good, upstanding man, I want you to know. And very rich. That is, if he beats the electric chair. I investigated Wilmer, turned him inside out. Not a spot on him, not a blemish. The boy can look the world square in the eye. Goodbye.
I'm not finished.
You are. It's either out the door or through it.
Oh, you're unsocial.
I don't like investigators who talk glibly in their own cause. Out.
You know something? You're nuts. Now, why did I come talk to a nut? The way I keep knocking myself out, defending people.
I got Boris on the phone.
Boris?
Boris, this is Barrie Craig speaking.
Oh. It's noon. Time to rise and shine. What do you want?
Those party photographs I saw being taken last night. I want them.
Well, a lot of reasons. One of them is, uh, I want to see if Mark Wilmer wore a dagger and a scabbard on his costume.
I'm afraid I must...
Meaning?
I...
Come again?
Only phony.
Phony is a nine dollar bill. Goodbye.
I stopped in to see Badger Boris personally, without appointment.
You have no business molesting me.
I know. Home is your castle. The pictures and the negatives. I want them, Boris.
But I told you I destroyed them.
Yeah, you told me. The memory of last night is acid in your soul. So why preserve it?
It's cute ad lib. You've got a genius for evasion. Now, come across.
I'll have you thrown out of here.
We'll hit the sidewalk together. We'll ride downtown, arm in arm. So close, because we're handcuffed together. Let's, uh, measure your wrists for size.
You... You... You would dare handcuff me?
And arrest you. Suspicion of murder. You're sure going to look elegant penned up with a rabble.
Well?
Well... You argue resourcefully. You've uncovered my one weak spot. I am allergic to orders. I could never tolerate the reek of your prison rabble. The negatives, you'll find them in that cabinet there. The bottom drawer. Take them and go.
I'll take them and go, after you write a check for one thousand dollars. My agreed fee for last night's rhubarb.
Don't look so pained, host.
I had the negatives developed. Eight rolls of them. I had them developed with a prayer. A prayer that my hunch on the film would pay off. When I got a look at the developed pictures, I went traveling. Downtown to a Park Row office with a shingle on it that read the Gurko Agency. I let myself in with a skeleton key to wait for Gurko. I wanted to surprise Gurko with a bang.
Gurko rolled in at the stroke of three. I waited until his head showed. Then I came down on the target.
When he came to enough to stare up at me groggily, we got down to cases.
You slugged me, Craig. Why?
A precaution to take the fight out of you. I checked into your background a bit. What you did before you became a blackmailing shamus. You were a champ boxer, runner up for the light heavyweight title. I didn't relish coming to blows with you. I want my nose looking exactly like it looks.
What's your play?
An arrest. I'm arresting you for blackmail and murder.
I said you're a no-brainer.
No, I'm not. I developed rolls of film taken at Boris' costume party. Mark Wilmer never carried a dagger in his scabbard. I've got pictures covering the whole evening. No dagger ever in Mark Wilmer's costume.
So what?
Boris' guest list totaled 12, so Boris said. Boris was faking. It was actually 13, officially. He wanted me to think Cora Wilmer crashed the party and that Mark Wilmer came with Rita.
All over my head, Craig. Try getting up.
I'll crack down on you. I've got pictures showing that there was even more than 13 guests. That's excluding me. On one picture, I count 14. 14 guests. The 14th was the murderer. Boris knew it, but he tried to cover it up. Not that he wanted to spare you, Gurko, but because he preferred seeing Mark Wilmer take the rap. He hoped to frame Mark. Your turn to talk.
Craig, what kind of guy are you?
Try me out.
That's better. That's better. I didn't figure you'd be an angel. I didn't see any wings.
50-50. It was a bit of fortune. If I shut up about your murdering your own client, Cora Wilmer, so you could blackmail her widowed husband?
Yeah. Yeah, that was the play. Mark was a frightened pigeon. Forget Cora, Craig. Nobody cried when she died. It comes out fine for everybody. Mark and the doll, Rita, they get married. They got dough. And you and me, we got dough.
It still needs a fall guy.
Boris, we'll pin it on Boris. We'll switch it around. Boris was out to frame a guy he hated, Mark Wilmer. I'll think up a way.
Like you planted the dagger in Rita's car?
Well, I did that to confuse things, take some of the heat off Mark.
And that rifle shot at me?
Well, that was to scare you away. Only that.
Hang the frame on Boris. Make him the fall guy. I think I know a way, Craig.
Don't pick your brains too hard. The little gray matter you've got, Gurko, concentrate on how you can beat the electric chair.
Oh, it's like that, eh? You suckered me. No deal.
You're turning me in, huh?
That's right.
Why?
I could say for the honor of the profession, colleague. But, uh, that would be corny, wouldn't it?
You have been listening to William Gargan in another exciting transcribed mystery drama from the adventures of Barrie Craig, Confidential Investigator.
