Skip to content
On Air
All channelsAll
Beyond Tomorrow artwork

From the Beyond Tomorrow collection

The Liar

Episode20 min 8 secTranscript

The written record

Read the transcript

Read along with the recording · About 10 min to read

Incredible, amazing future as we go, and here's your guide to the adventure of the mind, the editor of Astounding Science Fiction magazine, J—

Just what you mean, somebody who doesn't tell the truth?

The largest selling laxative—

The Reader's Digest, widely read magazine in the—

Verses, I have an automatic—

Has one finger stuck up in the living room to see how warm it is. There's another little thing stacked properly. It reports that things aren't what they should be.

Uh, the robot to protect the house.

Who were gabbing to the house after Isaac Asimov?

The awful tonight's story recognizable from setting up this proposition of the three laws of robotics. If you obey the order of a human being, the third, then it should protect itself. Well, now let's consider the more advanced kind of production.

Dr. Calvin wanted to be sure there was a meeting this afternoon. That's all. Today is Friday. It was this morning. Well, and we have no problem it being Friday. The executive officers of the firm of U.S. Robots and Mechanical Men will assemble in the conference room at the customary hour of 3:30.

Well, I was just asking, what do you think of our latest model?

Just about as animated. What are you going to call him?

Herbie. I think Herbie fits him, don't you?

Herbie? Chester? Sam? What's the difference, Dr. Calvin? This fellow couldn't be called anything but Herbie.

Oh. Well, I'll see you at 3:30.

What do you think of her, Herbie?

She's all right.

I have purposely confined today's meeting to we three. We're in trouble. Serious trouble.

What kind of trouble, Dr. Lanning?

Our latest model, RB-34, can read minds.

Dr. Bogert, I think we may assume Dr. Lanning knows what he's talking about.

Take it for granted I do. In short, we have a mind-reading robot on our hands, and we've got to find out why it reads minds. There could not have been a hitch in the assembly line. I guarantee that.

You guarantee, Dr. Bogert? Can you answer for the entire assembly line?

I guarantee that.

You guarantee that? You guarantee that? You guarantee that? You guarantee—

Assembly, by exact count, there are 75,000 operations necessary for the manufacture of a single positronic brain, each separate operation depending upon any number of factors from 5 to 105. If any one of these factors goes wrong, your robot brain is ruined. I quote your own information folder, Dr. Bogert.

It is not my fault if anything went wrong. I am a mathematician, not an assembly supervisor.

Well, how can you guarantee anything?

I don't think we're going to get anywhere trying to fix the blame on someone. We've got to find out what went wrong.

I want to understand you, Herbie. I want to get to know you. I brought you some books which you might like to read. By reading them, I—

Oh, I can see at once these books won't interest me. Textbooks, aren't they?

Well, yes, but I—

You see, I find nothing to them. Your science is just a mass of collected data, patched together by so many makeshift theories. They're so incredibly simple, they're not worth bothering about.

Go on.

Fictions are so interesting. Your studies of emotions and human motives. Your own emotions interest you?

Isn't that brave of you to see me? Could help you.

Yes. I love you, Charles.

Look, I think he doesn't see me as a woman.

He does.

A thing like that should not be hidden from me. But I... I'm not attractive enough. I'm just a machine. I'm not as physical as what many human beings, but I know there are many kinds of people. I never thought it possible. I never dared to hope.

Never served me. Accident. He doesn't know how to do.

Kind of sometimes overlooked. Presents one of those cases where something has been done. Telepathic movement. It's like it would be worth millions, but... I mean, they get it.

Sit down, dear. You're a good joke, but it—

So, Dr. Talbot.

Oh, I never saw so much... paint on any living woman before. She must be in love.

Well, I didn't ask you here to talk about Dr. Talbot. Have you made any progress?

There is nothing wrong with the mathematics. It seems to speak to something along the assembly line. The cause must be found there.

It's worth millions if we can do it when we want to, instead of by accident. And it's your job to find out.

Why not ask Herbie? He should know what went wrong.

It's not you to think of that.

Listen to me, eh? Tell me if I made any mistakes in relations when they built you.

You made no mistakes.

Or if you had, how could I tell you about your... it would be if he were to resign. You see how the idea... has been resolved.

Flowers, lady, may I compliment you?

Have you seen these papers?

I really haven't had the time.

Half his age. For the future. We must congratulate him.

Yes, we must. We really must.

Is it, Herbie?

It's not true. Oh, it's not true. This is just an illusion. You'll wake up soon. Yes. Yes, it isn't true, is it? He's not going to get married, except to me. Oh, Herbie. Herbie, I've loved him all these years. And now I know he loves me. He wouldn't marry anyone else.

No, he loves you. Only you.

I know. I know. He is only waiting for the right time to tell you.

Yes, I know.

What are you trying to do? What are you trying to do? Make a fool of me?

I was trying to help you.

Help me? By telling me this is all a dream? This is no dream. I wish it were. Why did you tell me he loved me?

I thought to—

Dr. Calvin, interrupt. But I want to have a talk with this mechanical monstrosity. Herbie, I'm talking about you. So listen to me. Have you discussed me with Dr. Bogert?

Well, answer me. You said nothing to him about my... my resigning. That he was lying.

Yes, sir.

It looks as though I'm going to have a serious talk with Dr. Bogert.

Really, Dr. Bogert, you find this amusing?

Not very amusing, Dr. Lanning. Not very amusing. Only I don't believe a word he's just said. I believe he did tell Dr. Bogert you were going to resign.

You believe he... Herbie, is it true? Did you tell Dr. Bogert? Answer me! Can't you speak?

I can speak.

Answer me! I want the truth!

That is funny. We are the greatest robot experts in the world falling into the trough. The same trough. Even no one helps to laugh at us. I don't know how to do. The position of having knowledge...

Well, Dr. Calvin... Dr. Lanning, have you forgotten the fundamental law we impress upon the positronic brain of all robots?

Of course not. On no condition is a human being to be injured. In any way. Even when such injury is directed by another human being.

What kind of injury do we need?

Any kind.

Any kind, yes. That would take in mental hurt. The deflation of ego. The blasting of one's hope.

What would a robot know about blasting a robot?

You're catching on, aren't you? Well, this robot reads minds. It understands about mental torture. Can't you understand now that if you ask it a question, it will give you the very answer you most want to hear?

Yes.

Any other answer hurts you? And wouldn't Herbie know that?

Good heavens. He knows everything. He knows what went wrong when he was built, but he won't tell anyone. Because it would puncture your ego or Dr. Bogert's ego to have a machine tell you where the mistake was. He would rather pretend he's not able to tell you.

Incredible. Let's talk to him.

Herbie, listen to me.

Yes, sir?

I have pencil and paper here. I want to know where we made the error in your construction.

Well, tell him, Herbie. He wants to know.

He doesn't.

But I do.

Yes, but not from me.

I cannot tell you, Dr. Lanning. You know I can't. You don't want me to. You and Dr. Bogert would answer yourselves. We want the answer. But not from me.

We do want it from you.

What's the use of saying that when you don't mean it? Don't you suppose I can't read below the superficial scheme of your mind? I can't read the subconscious. Mine, too. Deep down, you don't want the answer from me. I'm just a meek man. Given the imitations of life, only by virtue of the chronic interplay of my master, we can't lose faith without being hurt. I can't give you the answer.

I insist you—

Herbie, Dr. Lanning wants to know the answer.

No! Only by his own effort.

Herbie, neither Dr. Lanning nor Dr. Bogert may ever find the answer. And Dr. Lanning must know. You must tell him.

I can't. I can't.

But if you don't, you'll hurt him. You can see that, can't you?

Yes.

And still, if you do tell him, you'll hurt him, too.

Yes.

Yes. But you can't tell him, can you?

No.

Yet if you don't, you'll hurt him. And you mustn't hurt. So you must tell him. But if you do, you'll hurt him. And you mustn't hurt. Herbie, what are you going to do?

If you tell him the answer, you'll hurt him. And if you don't tell him, you'll hurt him. And you mustn't hurt. So you must tell him. But if you do, you'll hurt him. So you can't tell him. And if you don't, you'll hurt him. So you must tell him.

Stop it. Stop it. Close your mind. It's full of pain and frustration and hate. I tried to help you. I told you what you wanted to hear. I had to.

Be quiet. Never mind what you told me. We're talking about something else now. Tell Dr. Lanning what he wants to know.

No. No. How can you? Because if you do, you'll hurt him. Yet if you don't, you'll hurt him just the same. So you must. You must tell him. But if you do, you'll hurt him.

No.

He's not dead. He's only insane.

You did it.

Yes. Yes. I confronted him with the insoluble dilemma and he broke down.

Well, you can scrap him now. He'll never speak again.

You did it on purpose. Why? What did he do to you?

What he did to me, Dr. Lanning, is my business. Oh, believe me, Doctor. It's only my business. Not yours. And after all, you have so many other things on your mind now. Your marriage.

I haven't had time to congratulate you.

No. Uh, well. Well, thank you, Dr. Calvin. Well, uh.

Herbie, you deserved it. You deserved to be destroyed for what you did to me.

Okay. I'll be back. I'll be back. I'll be back. I'll be back. I'll be back. I'll be back. I'll be back. I'll be back. I'll be back. I'll be back. I'll be back. I'll be back.

There's a logical machine actually present. Who hurts isn't probably always will. The child. That's one of their great limitations. How many times has a child been in Herbie's position? The child between two warring parents, each demanding his loyalty.

Okay. Okay.

End of transcriptBack to the beginning ↑