The written record
Read the transcript
Read along with the recording · About 18 min to read
The Black Museum, the repository of death. Here in the green stone structure on the Thames which houses Scotland Yard is a warehouse of homicide, where everyday objects — a gold pitchbowl, an automatic gas range, files, a perambulator — all are touched by murder.
Here's a can of weed killer. It's a familiar object. Every suburbanite with a patch of garden uses this, or something very much like it. After a while, when pliers are pulling up the weeds, buys weed killer eliminates the backache. You know, I'm not certain, Inspector, whether the poison in weed killer deteriorates or becomes stronger with the passage of time. Any chemist could answer that. Some chemist will have to answer that.
Well, today that can of weed killer can be seen in the Black Museum. From the annals of the Criminal Investigation Department of the London Police, we bring you the dramatic stories of the crimes recorded by the objects in Scotland Yard's Gallery of Death — the Black Museum.
And here we are, the Black Museum, Scotland Yard's mausoleum of murder.
Yes, here I am. Death, here it is, preserved in artifacts which seem to reflect the horror of the crimes in which they played their parts. An arrow, four-feathered, tapered cleanly, steel-tipped. It's a great projectile made for flight and skill in an ancient art. Even in the act which brought us here, this weapon was thwarted. No arching bow was bent to print it on its way. A powerful hand thrust sharply in the dark, and this arrow turned dagger stabbed a knife forward.
Here's a chalice. It's jeweled, lovely. It's a work of art. It's a work of art. It's a work of art. It's a work of art. It's a work of art. It's a work of art. It's a work of art.
And now we continue with The Black Museum, starring Orson Welles.
A hammock between two wheels, on one of which stand the remains of an ancient Norman castle. An ideal place to live, one would say, as John Ashley very often said to his wife Helen and his daughter Joy.
Remember, Helen, how we used to wish for a life like this when we were struggling in London? Before you came to us, Joy, my dear.
I remember.
You've accomplished it for us, John.
You may clear the table, Sarah.
From all the stories you've told, Ed, I'll never marry a young lawyer.
Oh, you might do worse. You might do worse at that.
What's the matter, Helen?
Oh, that pain again, John. Oh, it'll pass as soon as I've had some tea.
I wish you'd see Dr. Gordon about this, Helen.
Oh, yes, a very nice place to live. And a nice family in the house on the slope of the hill. An occasional complaint, of course. Even an occasional disagreement, but everything quite normal.
Why he won't let his wife join our garden club, I never understand, never. And she doesn't... It's exactly as he tells her. The way she's under his thumb. No woman would permit it unless she was deathly afraid of something.
That wasn't to be interested in gardening, it was his books. Her husband sells the gardening tools and the terrain. He's interested in better trees and flowers.
I was her first friend in the village. I watched her just waste away. It must be his fault. You know, sometimes I believe he beats her.
It's a good thing. It's a worthy goal. If she read more books, perhaps she'd have less time.
Yeah, a bit too much. I heard just the other day that John Ashley...
Don't doubt it, not for a minute. Wait till Martha Gordon hears this.
Well, I'd like not to believe it, but if you tell me, dear...
No, I can imagine. All the best authority in my own eyes.
Climate of public opinion. At least on the distaff side, at the time of the Sunday luncheon. At the Ashley House, this.
Ah, an excellent luncheon, Helen, my dear.
It was a compliment, cook.
Oh, John. I think I'm going to faint.
Helen!
Mother!
Oh, the pain.
Helen, the wine.
Mother, let me get you some wine.
Joy, quickly. Get Dr. Gordon here, at once.
Oh, I dare, of course.
Helen, I'm getting you to bed.
Careful, hey, gently.
They took Helen Ashley up to her bedroom. The doctor came at Joy's urging, and even too.
Please, Dr. Gordon. My mother.
Stay good, cannibal. Please, please, hurry.
But the doctor wasn't half as alarmed as the family.
So I don't believe there's really anything to worry about. Gastric disturbances can be painful. But my prescription will ease her. In the meantime, company will take her mind off the pain. Oh, what's left would never hurt any woman. If you need me, I'll be available. And I'll...
However, the good Miss Goodson would not be...
That's right, it's the doctor. Actually, some 15 minutes and then I entered the living room to announce...
Of course, it's really not my business, except I've grown so fond of your wife since you've been living here.
What is it, Miss Goodson?
Well, since you ask, she's a lot more ill than you or David Gordon seem to think. I suggest a nurse at once.
Do you really think so? But the doctor...
I don't use words lightly. And I've been around illness all my life. I nursed my father for 10 years. I know sickness when I see it. And I know just the woman, Nurse Thomas. She's just a practical, but very...
Nurse Thomas came to the Ashley House at once and took charge of the patient. However, a little before 9 o'clock that evening.
I'm sorry to disturb you, Mr. Ashley, but I have to leave now.
Really, Nurse? I was under the impression you would stay overnight at least.
I can't. I have my children. They'll have had no dinner until...
Is my wife resting?
She complained that Dr. Gordon...
Oh, that means nothing. I'm sorry, but I'll have to leave. I'll be back first thing tomorrow.
The Ashley House will retire for the night. John left the nightlight burning in the bedroom. Looked at his wife. Then he stumbled to the door of Joy's room and knocked.
Dad, what is it?
Joy, I... Your mother is dead.
And Ashley passed away in her sleep.
We were mourning in the house on the slope of the hill. In the village below.
I knew it. I told him he was desperately ill. I told him.
Too bad. Such a nice little person.
Sweet. Could she have married that... That inhuman? I hope they find him out.
Never even...
In a civil good day to a person.
Do you really suppose there is something suspicious?
I wouldn't put it past him.
Why, Nurse Thomas. I felt something strange the moment I walked in the door. If I had any influence with my daughter, I'd have made him refuse to sign a death certificate. Heart disease. It was talk. Idle talk. Least it seemed so at first. But it had its effects. It accumulated as some poisons do. And it had a result. As some poisons do.
Here's another of these letters, Superintendent.
Any signature this time?
Yes.
Thanks. Who's it from?
It's signed by Nurse Thomas.
Signed with the other anonymous letters which we've already received.
All right, well, let me have a look at it.
Dear Sir. I have come to the conclusion that it is my duty to draw your attention to the rumors which are common knowledge throughout the neighborhood concerning the recent death of Mrs. Ashley. You can claim to have a personal knowledge of the case as I was the nurse in charge.
Huh. Now, will you make another pardon? There's certainly nothing anonymous about this, sir.
No. I feel that you should know my suspicions are shared by friends and neighbors of the Ashleys and that all of us consider that justice should be done. Yours truly, it seems.
Ah, that justice should be done. Oh, well, we shall see.
Yes, sir. I think we'd better have a little talk with Nurse Thomas.
Yes, sir. I certainly do.
There must be some reason. Where there's smoke, you know, Superintendent.
Nurse Thomas, may I remind you that I didn't get to the rank of Superintendent by listening to rumors. Have you any facts?
Well, I'm not a detective.
Well, tell me what you know, Nurse.
Sarah Freeman, she's the Ashley housemaid, swears that he didn't drink any of the wine at lunch. That was hardly his custom.
Go on.
I've been on a good many cases. This one was really peculiar. The doctor wasn't disturbed any more than that, but she died at two in the morning. The whole thing. Highly suspicious. And said things like...
Now, never mind the rumors, Nurse. However, I may make a few inquiries.
The superintendent knew his duty. He took the liberty of calling on Ashley to stop in and chat with him.
You realize, of course, Mr. Ashley, on an informal basis, I can think of no reason why it should be forced on you.
I think it's a very good thing. You'd like to set all these gossips up, because they're put on end to it once and for all. Nothing would be a greater relief to me. Have you any suggestions? Questions, Superintendent?
Yes, I have. It's drastic, but, well, if all is well, as I have every reason to believe, it may be unpleasant but effective.
What is it, sir?
Exhumation of your wife's body and a post-mortem, with your express approval.
As you wish, sir. I shall be glad to cooperate in every way possible.
The vital step. From now on, John Ashley was going to fight for his life. Much was stacked against him, and not the least, the tin of weed killer. Which can be seen today.
And now we continue with The Black Museum, starring Orson Welles.
They did not permit Helen Ashley to rest for long. The exhumation order was signed, and the post-mortem proceeded shortly thereafter. A coroner's inquest was held. The jury were all natives of the district, of course. All of them with some contact with the rumors, which seemed to grow wilder and more frequent as the secrecy continued.
There were three witnesses at the inquest. First, Dr. David Gordon himself.
Yes, I performed the post-mortem, and this was a coronary case.
What did you find?
My findings were confirmed by the analyst for the Home Office, to whom I transmitted them through the superintendent of police. To cover the necessary items for his...
And the report, doctor?
In Ashley's body, 18 milligrams of arsenic. Sufficient, indeed, to cause death.
Inspector Brook, purveyor of gardening tools and materials, being away on a business trip, Mrs. Brook took the witness.
Yes, when my husband is away, I run the business. I'm completely familiar with all his records.
Oh, you are, are you? What about it?
Well, less than two years ago, we sold a tin of weed killer to Mr. Ashley. The brand was that type, which contains arsenic.
The third and last witness was housemaid Sarah Freeman.
Mr. Ashley was in the pantry where the wine was kept for ten minutes at least that Sunday. I know, because he held me up setting the table and all.
Did she serve any particular item?
There was the wine. It was Mrs. Ashley's favorite brand. She always took a glass with a big meal of the day. The bottle was open in the pantry. And, of course, Mr. Ashley did not drink any. I offered it to him myself. He refused, and I poured some for the poor lady.
Here's a pretty kettle of fish. A coroner's court not only finding in favor of murder, but naming the murderer.
Nobody could say they were slow to come to a decision, sir.
On the contrary, sergeant. I only hope they haven't been a little too slow.
Well, we shall see. Meantime, thank goodness our responsibility is going to be a shared one from now on.
You mean it's a case for the...
No doubt about it. Put me through to London. I want to speak to Inspector Glenn at Scotland Yard. This is Superintendent Maxwell.
You remember the case I sent you the papers on last week, Inspector? The Ashley case?
Oh, yes.
There certainly are. If possible, I'd like you to come down here straight away. I'm glad Scotland Yard would come into this, Inspector. What were the verdicts?
We're hardly equipped for this verdict yet. We find that Helen Ashley died of acute arsenical poisoning, and that the poison was administered by her husband, John Ashley.
I've seen a few cases with more complete evidence.
So have I. But what can we do? Decide to arrest him and have him arraigned?
Nothing, I'm afraid.
Nothing at all? Well, he hardly seems the type to obstruct justice by running away.
Far from obstructing justice, John Ashley helped the authorities in every way he could. I understand. And, Inspector... What did you say your name was?
Inspector William Glenn, CID.
Yes, yes, of course. I assume you'll be looking for the weed killer there's been so much talk about.
Yes, we will.
Yes?
Well, you'll find it in the garage with the... It's in there somewhere. Exactly where, I can't tell you.
Thank you, Mr. Ashley. Now, if you're quite ready...
Yes, why not? If you'll just precede me.
It's quite warm out, I gather. I doubt if I need a top coat.
No, and my car's at your door.
There he is!
I'm sorry. I didn't know they'd gather out here. We could have used... on the back way.
Oh, no matter. I can face them. I won't do anything but call names.
John Ashley was formally charged with the next day for the next assizes. The case for the Crown was not remarkable for its completeness. Inspector Glenn was a witness.
The defendant admitted possessing the weed killer. In fact, he helped us to find it in his garage.
Have you uncovered any evidence, Inspector, to indicate that my client did, in fact, administer the poison?
Poison was almost always... always given in secret. Rarely has a witness to the... the coroner's inquest. There was no cross-examination.
Sarah Freeman, on the other hand, was the subject of quite intense questioning by the defense.
Why did you find it worthy of remark that Mr. Ashley spent some time in your pantry?
I'd never known him to be in there before.
I say to you that almost every Sunday before luncheon, he did go into the pantry from the garden to wash his...
No, he didn't.
Many, many times.
No, he always went upstairs. He was a long waiter... to the bathroom upstairs.
Not very. Do you realize that Mr. Ashley is in peril of his life?
Yes, sir, I do.
And you stand here swearing that it was unusual for him to use the pantry to wash his hands?
Yes, sir, I do.
Sarah Freeman, are you telling the truth?
I swore on the Bible, sir.
Are you telling the truth?
Yes, sir, I am.
No further questions.
Next in the parade of witnesses was Nurse Thomas. She told her story, her experience, and her suspicions. Once again, counsel for the defense took over.
You are a practical nurse, is that correct?
I am.
You are not registered. Your training has not been formal.
I know my job.
Answer the question.
I know my job.
But you are not a registered nurse.
I am a practical nurse.
When you left the Ashley house at nine o'clock, were you satisfied that the patient was in no danger?
I had to go home.
If you felt she was in danger, would you... for personal reasons?
My mother is past 80. My children needed their dinner.
I asked you, Mrs. Thomas, that a registered nurse would not have left.
Then you were satisfied that the patient was in no danger.
I had to leave. I told Mr. Ashley...
Did she ever complain to you about the medicine?
She complained to the maid. The maid told me.
What did you do about it?
I tasted it myself.
Did the medicine affect you?
Not at all.
What was the dose?
Two teaspoonfuls and a little water, three times a day.
Did you give the medicine before you left?
I did.
And you were satisfied there was no danger to the patient?
I was... I had to go when I did.
Very well. You had to go when you did. That is all.
With stubbornness, the slight irregularities in behavior of this nurse seemed to be having their effect on the jury. There was a feeling of impatience, even of doubt, in the courtroom as counsel for the defense called:
Miss Joy Ashley, please.
The girl, quiet, composed, took the stand in her father's defense.
Miss Ashley, I know you realize that your father is on trial here for his life.
I do.
Can you say without reservation that you are going to tell the absolute truth?
Yes, sir. I am.
If you had to tell the truth about his innocence, what would you do? Tell the truth?
My mother is dead. If I thought for a moment that my father had done it, even then I would tell the truth.
Very well. Now then, the three of you had luncheon together that day.
We did.
At the same time, from the same main dishes?
Yes, sir.
There has been some doubt cast on the contents of a certain bottle of wine. Your former housemaid has testified that the bottle was nearly empty at the end of the meal, that she threw the bottle away. Was this common practice, do you know?
It was.
I see. Now then, what do you recall concerning the serving of that wine that day?
Sarah, the maid, offered it to my father first, as she always did.
Did he accept?
No, he did not.
What did the maid do next?
She offered it to my mother. Mother took some.
And then?
Then Sarah offered it to me. I let her fill my glass. It was excellent. I asked for some more. I remember mother expressing her surprise that I should drink two glasses of wine.
Thank you, Miss Ashley. That is all.
It was dramatic, Lope. The Crown had no questions for Joy, and its defense rested. After a brief recess, he began his summation. Quickly, he reviewed the evidence presented, never denying the fact that Helen Ashley had died of arsenical poisoning. But he did conclude:
We have made no attempt to deny the scientific facts of this case. But I suggest to you, ladies and gentlemen of the jury, that at no time has my client's behavior even suggested guilt. More. I suggest that at no point has my honored colleague proved motive, much less the actual administration of the lethal dose. And I go on to suggest that there exists a reasonable doubt concerning my client's guilt in this matter. He has pleaded not guilty. I suggest that not guilty is the only proper verdict in the case of the Crown versus John Ashley.
The jury was out for three hours. The verdict was brief.
We find the prisoner not guilty.
John Ashley was a free man. But one thing he never learned, not to the day of his death, but privately, the jury sent this message in writing to the judge who presided at the trial:
We are satisfied on the evidence that Helen Ashley received a dangerous dose of arsenic on Sunday, July 16th. We are not satisfied that it was the immediate cause of her death. Nor does the evidence satisfy us concerning how or by whom the arsenic was administered. We cannot take a man's life when reasonable doubt such as this exists in our minds. We have therefore returned the verdict: Not guilty.
And still today that tin of weed killer has its place. In the Black Museum. This is Orson Welles.
Helen Ashley died of arsenic poisoning. There was no question about that. There was grave question as to how. The point was admitted. But whether it was in the wine or the food or the medicine, no one knows. John Ashley died some few years after his trial in poverty, a weary, broken man. In his case, the doctors certified his death and no question was raised, save by those who remembered the charges against him and the wagging tongues of the gossips in the kindly-seeming English village where he made his home. Those who remembered had cause for thought. Could it be said that John Ashley died by gossip? Certainly not by any other poison.
Until we meet next time, till we meet at the same place, I tell you another story about the Black Museum. The brain is always obedient to you.
The Black Museum, starring Orson Welles, is presented by arrangement with Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer Radio Attraction. The program is written by Ira Marion. With original music composed and conducted by Sidney Torch. Produced by Harry Alan Towers. There's the, uh, Black Museum.
