Skip to content
On Air
All channelsAll
The Black Museum artwork

From the The Black Museum collection

The Open Ended Wrench

Episode24 min 40 secTranscript

The written record

Read the transcript

Read along with the recording · About 17 min to read

This is Orson Welles, speaking from London. Black Museum. Here in the grim stone structure on the Thames, which houses Scotland Yard, is a warehouse of homicide, where everyday objects, an ink bottle, a child's raincoat, a sofa pillow, all are touched by murder.

Here's an open-end wrench. It's a familiar object. If you own an automobile, you own one of these. Or at least you've seen a mechanic use one. The steel shaft about eight inches long. The shaft bulging into a curve shaped like a horseshoe, which fits a bolt exactly. Simple tool. Almost beautiful in its slim efficiency. Well made, isn't it, Inspector?

We're familiar with these things, Doctor. They're quite common as a weapon.

Yes, of course. One's skull could be cracked rather efficiently. If this were brought down hard on it. And today, the wrench can be seen in the Black Museum.

From the annals of the Criminal Investigation Department of the London Police, we bring you the dramatic stories of the crimes recorded by the objects in Scotland Yard's gallery of death, the Black Museum.

Black Museum. Scotland Yard's Museum of Murder. Yes, yes. There lies death. Here in silent rows is the ordered catalogue of the violence wreaked by man on fellow man. Here's an empty cardboard match cover. Perhaps you've tossed one into your own wastebasket at this very moment, but not like this. It's hope. You know, from this one, the sulfur-headed matches were ripped to start a fire. A woman died in the burning building. Later, a man died at the end of a rope. Trapped. Trapped by the printed advertisement on this match cover.

Ah, yes, here we are. There's the open-end wrench. That's a common tool among mechanics, even among non-mechanical types, bookkeepers, clerks, teachers. No sign of violence or death upon it. Merely a bit of shaped, patterned steel produced for use in the manufacture and repair of modern machines. Look at it in ordinary circumstances and it'll evoke no thought of tragedy in you. Or even in the motorist who traveled an English highway. One quiet spring morning. Going at a normal speed, enjoying the fresh sunlight. The new clean green of fields and rising hills. The road curved ahead. White posts marked the edge of the embankment. The road heeled slightly, turning to the left.

Ah, quite a view. Gee gods, that's a nasty curve. If you're not awake... That fence! It's smashed. There's a car down there!

Minutes only until he's back in his own car. Beating toward the nearest town. Toward the nearest police station. There. There's a wreck. On the curve, about a mile south of here.

You have anything to do with it, mister?

What? No, no, no, of course not. I noticed the broken fence and saw the car down the hill. I say, there seems to be a woman in it. Look, you'd better come. Bring help.

Der, who was also the local coroner, needed little time to determine which of his functions were called for at the wreck. He's been past help for hours. Must have gone up the road during the night. I've notified the superintendent about the accident, doctor.

Yes? Well, you fellas will want to trace the car. Any identification on the body?

Nothing in the woman's purse, sir. There ought to be laundry or dry cleaners marks. It's pretty hard to stay identified these days, doctor.

Yes, of course. You can tell the ambulance men to take her to the hospital.

Hospital, sir?

Or autopsy. I can't just sign the certificate, accidental death, you know, constable?

Yes, sir. Very well, sir.

The ambulance drove off to the local hospital. Dr. Mason followed. In his own car. At the wreck, the constable saluted a newcomer.

Good morning, sir.

Good morning, Johnson. Turned turtle, I see.

Yes, sir. This is the man who discovered the wreck, sir. Mr. Frisbee?

Superintendent Foster. Oh, how do you do, sir?

Mr. Frisbee. Yes. You, uh, left your name and address? Hmm? Uh, with the constable, sir. Um, if I may, I have a business appointment.

Yes, you go ahead. We'll send for you if we need you for the inquest.

Oh, thank you, sir. Well, just let me know. If you want me, I'll be available any time, sir.

Anything extraordinary, Johnson?

Nothing, sir, so far as we've seen. No fire?

No, sir. I'll have a look at it.

Very good, sir.

Superintendent Foster poked around in the twisted metal. A point caught his attention. Johnson, any idea which way she was traveling?

Downgrade, sir. There are rather clear tar marks on the roadway leading to the break in the fence, sir.

Downgrade. Strange. The gear shift lever is in second position.

Second gear, sir?

Apparently. That grade isn't that steep. Just a point. Well, a woman driver, strange road at night. She wasn't in the driver's seat, sir.

Oh? Tossed over as the car fell?

Can't say, sir. I'd have expected, sir, that she'd have been pinned behind the steering wheel.

Yes. You may be right about that. Well, they'll leave things as they are. The insurance people usually want to see these wrecks. Oh, what's this?

Open-end wrench, sir. Probably a wrench.

Yes, constable?

I was going to say the toolbox, sir. The toolbox was locked. No other tools around.

Well, bring it along to the station house. No sense leaving it out here to rust. And usual routine. Trace the registration of the car, locate the owner or the next of kin, and check if it was the woman's car.

For another auto accident, another careless or sleepy driver, the usual telegrams were sent, the usual telephone calls were made, the same afternoon, Constable Johnston reported to his superintendent.

Yes, Johnston?

Papers on the accident, sir.

Yes. I see. Owner, Martin Beach. Avon Mews, London. Has he been notified?

Yes, sir. He's on his way down. The woman was his wife, sir.

Oh. Must have been a shock. I took the call, sir. He kept saying he couldn't understand what she was doing all the way out here.

Well, we'll deal gently with him. Dr. Mason, reported yet?

No, sir. Nothing on the autopsy as yet. Taking him a long time.

Well, let's see. Get me Dr. Mason, please. At the hospital. Did you make certain on the tyre tracks, Johnston?

We did, sir. They matched perfectly. The car was coming down, sir, on the side of the road away from the fence. It seems to have swerved suddenly, just above the curve, and made rather a beeline for the edge.

Are you suggesting she went over purposely, Johnston?

No, sir. It seemed like a point, sir. Most cars, at least, try to... I noticed you keep referring to the car, and not to the woman. She wasn't in the driver's seat, sir, when we found her.

Oh, stickler for detail, aren't you, constable?

Ah, you're both here. Good. I just put a call through to you, doctor.

Yes? Oh, yes, thank you. Yes, he's just arrived.

Well, what did you find, doctor? You asked that as if you knew.

Just a deduction. You don't usually take this long time on these jobs.

I didn't expect to, until I found alcohol in her stomach.

Oh. Drunken driver.

Oh, I wouldn't know about that. In any case, she wasn't driving when the car went through that fence. Johnston's been suggesting that rather stubbornly. He couldn't be more right, Foster.

Why not?

The dead don't drive.

Hello? Anything else?

Quite a bit. In the first place, death was not caused by the accident. She was dead well before the car went over.

You told us that.

You don't know how. Stangulation. Choked. Probably unconscious at the time.

Well, what do you base that conclusion on?

Four bruises. Four bruises. Four bruises. Four bruises. And a neck on it. Those, I thought, the accident...

Well, the dead don't drive and they don't bruise, Constable. Those marks were made while she was still alive.

I see. Definitely murder, Doctor.

Definitely. I'd like to see the body. Come along, Constable. Your instinct...

Three men enter the morgue at the small country hospital. Three grim faces betray no emotion as they view the woman's body. The doctor says...

You'll notice the marks. The strangest thumbs made there. The obvious bruise is here, just below her hairline, on her forehead.

The superintendent of police says...

I see. Interesting, the shape of that bruise. Almost like a small horseshoe. Differently, the constable clears his throat, inquiring glance from his superintendent. The young officer says...

We might try for actual size, sir. That kind of mark could have been made by that opening.

And today, that open-end wrench is to be seen in the Black Museum.

The doctor placed the bulged end of the tool against the woman's forehead. The three men stood there silently a moment. The constable spoke.

No question about it, is there, sir?

Not as far as I can see. Johnson, when this beach fellow arrives, say nothing about any of this. And I shall want a trunk call placed immediately.

Yes, sir.

The ponderous, inevitable juggernaut that is, police work began to move, gain momentum. A fast car brought Inspector Hall and Sergeant Williams from the yard before train connections permitted the arrival of Martin Beach. The inspector listened intently as Superintendent Foster outlined the details. Then, quietly, no fuss, no newspaper headlines. Detectives were dispatched to run a check. Shortly thereafter, a grief-stricken husband arrived at the station house in the company of Dr. Mason.

There's no question about my identification, Superintendent. Dr. Mason will bear me out. I knew her the moment that that is. Doctor.

Yes, it's Mrs. Beach. I can't understand it. I simply can't. She was a good driver, better than I. How did it happen that she was out alone? We lived a quiet life. Even moved in a suburb of London, really. She'd often take the car for a drive. I'd go to sleep. I had to get up early. My business is in the city. She said she wanted some fresh air last night. I didn't miss her until I woke this morning. I can't understand it. Why should she be so...

A simple story. Quite commonplace. Quite honest. One question seemed to puzzle her husband more than it disturbed him. Liquor? Whiskey, you mean? No. An occasional drink at a friend's place. That was all. Why? Why? Are you suggesting Louise was a... A drunken driver? No, they were suggesting nothing. Merely asking a routine question. Yes, they would release the body shortly. We... We had no relations. No one. We had only each other. I shall have to notify our friends. Yes, the police agreed sympathetically. And Superintendent Foster and Dr. Mason escorted him to his London train.

Meanwhile, on the Middlebury Road...

Your name, Carey?

Yes, sir. My name's William. C.I.D. My identification?

Yes, Sergeant. Something go wrong?

You, um, heard of the accident down the hill?

Yes, of course. How late do you keep this petrol station open?

Twelve, one o'clock. Depends on the traffic.

And last night?

I closed up about one. Locked the tanks and...

Any, uh, customers around that time?

Well, there was a dark sedan, man or woman.

You got a good look at the woman?

He was driving, bought five gallons. She was asleep at the front seat.

Any sign of whiskey?

Well, he had a breath on himself. Sergeant, seemed in a hurry, too. Edgy.

Now, look. This, uh, photo mean anything to you?

Yes, it looks a little... It's hard to tell at night. The light's bad. Is she sleeping there in the picture?

No. She's dead.

They call it backtracking. They try to trace the car along the road it traveled. The gas stations first. In this case, where whiskey was present, the taverns and the inns were checked as well.

You're the landlord here?

Yes, sir. My wife said you're the police.

Yes. They're trying to trace a man and a woman. This picture mean anything to you?

Yes, sir. She was here last night. Till closing time. Had a bit too much, I'm afraid, sir.

No. Was she alone?

No, sir. No, with her shortest fella. Dark, quiet. You know, no. Never thought of a sort of way.

I remember, because... Well, he wanted to buy a bottle, but I'd none to spare. But I rather thought what was driving and all. They'd already had enough.

That evening, Sergeant Williams gave the inspector his own reports from that of the men assigned to the railroad portion of the inquiry. They routed the conductor out of his bed. He remembers the fellow all right. Bought his ticket on the train. Complete stranger. Shortish. A dark fellow. Yes. She was with a man, all right.

Seems to me we'd better break the news to Beach.

Hmm. It won't be pleasant.

It wasn't pleasant. Martin Beach took it quietly. It would all be a shock.

Louise? With another man? Inspector, you can't be serious.

I'm afraid I am. Your wife's picture has been tentatively identified by a petrol station owner. By an innkeeper on Middlebury Road. They'll be taking her to the hospital to check. Tomorrow. And she was with a man.

No. It's not possible. No one could have been that secretive. Why? We just lived for each other.

Well, that's an old story to us, Mr. Beach. You're a busy man. Your wife was alone a good deal.

But when? How?

Well, you told us yourself. She used the car alone and quite often at night.

If I could get my hands on him.

Oh, what fools we mortals be.

We want him too, Mr. Beach. Now. Will you help us?

Of course, anything. Anything at all.

Then, uh, maybe search your wife's effects?

Of course, Inspector. Search the whole house, if you think it's...

They were quite thorough, of course. Very quickly, they were successful.

I found these in the, uh, stocking box at the rear of the bureau drawer, Inspector.

I see. Hmm. Letters. Mr. Beach. Do you know, uh, of Fred Hennessy?

No.

Well, may I, may I see the letters?

Might. Well, I... I think you'd rather not. And we'll be checking them with fingerprints, of course. They're all addressed to your wife. The last one makes the arrangements for a meeting place. With the car.

Is there... Is there a return address, Inspector?

There is. Good luck, Inspector.

Inspector and Sergeant Williams had luck. However, it was not exactly good luck.

Good luck. Fred Hennessy? No. There's no Hennessy living here.

Well, now, perhaps they used another name. A shortish dark fellow. With a flair for letter writing.

No. Haven't heard any shortish men staying here in months.

Well, this is 346 Greenville Street, isn't it?

Well, there's nowhere else, Inspector. Once more, I don't have any letter writers here. Every one of my men roomers, except one, works at the car factory. They're a tough crowd, Inspector, but they're nice enough to me. I take good care of them, I do.

And the one who doesn't build automobiles?

Oh, he's a constable, he is.

Now, what would you be paying for?

A good question. And a big disappointment. Still, the machinery ground on. The reports came in to the small bare office at the yard.

Here we are. Fingerprint reports, Inspector. Now, the prints on the letters match those they found on the gear shift lever in the wrecked car. The ridge patterns conform to the smudges on the wrench, too, sir. The conclusion is obvious. At the very least, it placed the maker of those fingerprints in contact with the murdered woman, in the murder car, with the murder weapon.

It looks so as if he pulled off the road, did the job, then started the car downgrade, and jumped.

Yes, probably. The unlocked door on the driver's side would indicate that.

But what about those prints I told you to try and get?

We have them, sir. Lifted them neatly. I was saving that for the last, sir. You see? They match.

Yes, very good. Thought he was clever. Well, murder's usual in amateurs. Crime isn't it, Sergeant?

What about the men to identify him?

They'll be in London in the morning, sir.

To Sergeant Williams, the case seemed complete. The Inspector was still somewhat cautious.

It will stick, sir, in any court.

I'll feel better if we have the motive, Sergeant. I'd like a complete case. Identifications have been upset before. And even fingerprints. Give them to me. If you find them, I'll give you a good motive. We'll hang the gentleman. In fact, we may be able to see he hung himself with his own cleverness.

Inspector Hall here. Hmm? I see. Very good, Davis. No. No, just keep your eye on the place. Williams and I'll be along directly. Get your head, Sergeant.

Very good, sir. Our quarry's gone calling on the lady. And so are we.

The police car sped silently through the London streets, out to a pleasant distance. The police car's gone on a pleasant passage into the southern suburb. It drove up to the curb near a small house detached from its neighbors, surrounded by a hedge and trees. A man stepped out of the shadows, spoke softly to the inspector. He subjected the car as the inspector and the sergeant walked to the front door of the house and rang the bell.

Yes?

Miss Jeffery? Miss Dorothy Jeffery?

That's right. My name is Hall, CID. I'm identification. May we come in?

Right here. What can I do for you?

Well, as a matter of fact, Miss Jeffery, we stopped by to see your caller, Mr. Martin Beach, I believe.

Inspector. Well, this is a pleasure to see you all the way out here.

Is it, Mr. Beach?

Of course. You know why we're here, don't you?

I assume you saw me come by. Wait a minute. What's going on here?

Don't you know, Miss Jeffery?

I know CID inspectors just don't drop in or come by. Martin, have you been up to something?

Stay out of this, Dorothy.

I'll not stay out of it. If we're to be married, I'd like to know.

We've dropped by to tell Mr. Beach about his wife.

Wife? You never mentioned a wife, Martin.

You're not arresting me, Inspector. I was home and asleep when she was killed.

The innkeeper says not, Beach. So does the petrol station owner. So does the conductor of the train you took back to London from Middlebury.

I say you're not taking me in.

You're not? You're not?

Inspector, there are French doors into the garden.

Your house is well covered from back, Miss Jeffery. You won't get far.

That's his warning. He'll stop running. He'll stop running now.

This is not the expected way to break an engagement to be married.

Yes, I understand, Miss. But you'll get over it. This manner of ending a relationship is far less permanent than the one your fiancé used to gain his freedom from his wife. You know, Miss, the chances are quite good that they'd have got away with it. If he hadn't written some fake love letters and forgotten behind a certain open-ended wrench.

And today, the open-ended wrench can be seen in its special place, in the Black Museum.

Orson Welles will be back with you in just a moment.

It's an old dodge, of course. May have worked many times. Commit a murder, wreck an automobile to cover its traces. It might have worked this time, if Martin Beach had known that dead bodies do not bruise. If he'd been really clever and had succeeded in burning the car and the body. Yes, yes. But he was not really clever. His cleverness failed him. Failed him at eight o'clock one morning in Dartmoor Prison. As for Dorothy Jeffery, she disappeared when she had come into the great anonymity which is London. And so until next time, till we meet in the same place, for another story about the Black Museum, I remain as always.

End of transcriptBack to the beginning ↑