Skip to content
On Air
All channelsAll
The Black Museum artwork

From the The Black Museum collection

Thesheathknife

Episode29 min 12 secTranscript

The written record

Read the transcript

Read along with the recording · About 20 min to read

this is orson welles speaking from london the black museum a repository of death a repertorium of violence here in the grim stone structure on the thames in tower street scotland yard is a warehouse of homicides for everyday objects carpenter's saw a manicurist's orange stick a ten penny nail all are touched by murder now this sheath knife it's a familiar object maybe your son if he's an outdoor sort of kid has one you may have one if you enjoy wood carving at odd moments it's a handy tool a sheath knife and if a sailor is a truckman or killer's nasty

hey doctor very nasty inspector six of them any one could have been fatal all very deep through clothing and overcoat then we're looking for a man doctor a man with a lot of strength and a knife

well today you can find that sheath knife among other honored exhibits in the black museum from the annals of the criminal investigation division of the london police we bring you the dramatic stories of the crimes recorded by the objects in scotland yard's gallery of death the black museum

in just a moment you will hear the black museum starring orson welles orson welles the black museum scotland yard's black museum was half museum of murder a functional place with its shelves and cabinets its glass top exhibit tables and the neat white cards identifying time and place and killing yet over the whole thing a kind of aura mystery as if the manipulators of these weapons still waiting to pick them up just beyond the shadows here lies death a hundred deaths seven hundred and fifty here lies death a hundred deaths seven hundred and fifty

in his presence life and so with 2018 ind accepted for the fiscal system as the honor of today we have dr truce's lawyer house that includes all the moral from you will come and be prepared we can't forget to take any of imo's plan to run the argument hearing from him and the faculty committee isn't that plays and he'll throw the tram as a police lawyer he'll play the

in fact collected over several generations would you call this a weapon look here it's a boot a leather riding boot obviously made for a gentleman who rode behind the hounds but another gentleman's pink hunting coat was stained with blood when this boot became a bludgeon that seems obvious it's a hypodermic needle it was once filled with poison here we are here's the sheath knife i was telling you about leather sheath sheffield steel bone handle it's a pretty instrument in its way but the story connected with it isn't quite so pretty

it begins one coldish night in november as a suburban train drew into the dark station at evelford a short distance from london two men rose to shrug on overcoats in the same car a man and woman rose too evelyn and fred winters shipping clerk and his wife returning to the little house in evelford

you might go first even if you are married too huh oh yeah yes of course all right evelyn come along now

the train will take you on with it you'd like that i expect no we had a nice evening you're tired now you wouldn't talk like that well let's walk i'm a trifle chilly

as patient a man as fred winters he always manages to find excuses for his wife's nagging but then evelyn's a bit younger than fred and quite good-looking in a rather daring manner you know with a tall vividly colored girl's excellent figure which she displays to advantage of course all this was lost on the two men who left the train at the opposite end of the car from the winters they stood on the platform for a minute or two stamping their feet and the winters disappeared up the tree-lined street for a moment or two the two men followed apparently they'd come to a decision whatever it was it doesn't matter fred never carried it out

they heard and they ran up the street in the dark past a single streetlight to where evelyn winters stood and fred winters lay in the driveway fred all over black he's dead

oh he was dead all right quite thoroughly dead as inspector bell put it it's the man scotland yard placed in charge of the case

nasty wounds eh doctor very nasty inspector six of them any one could have been fatal all very deep through clothing and overcoat then we're looking for a man doctor a man with a lot of strength and a knife

now it begins the long slow painstaking piecing together of a puzzle someone with a good deal of strength wielded the six-inch knife step one so far so good step two

yes i'm inspector bell mrs winters we met last night near the station yes i remember come in won't i expect you'll want to ask some questions

the questions they all begin as soon as the widow and the detective inspector are seated it's a tiny front room a shabby little semi-detached house the inspector glances around sees no wealth here that's certain dismissed money as the motive

what did your husband do mrs winters do oh i see he was a shipping clerk how old was he he said 48 i think he was closer to 52 did he see service home guard he was too old for the ground troops and he had no skills for any of the technical services did mr winters have any enemies that you know of freddy enemies of course not he never hurt a fly an excellent quality gentleness gentleness oh no inspector fred was meek meek and mild as the old saying goes but he loved me in his way

there was more of the same lots more but nothing to indicate a reason for willful murder finally inspector decided to call it a day well i won't bother you any longer today oh yes if you decide to go away or anything like that let us know when and where won't you mrs winters

a considerate man inspector bell and wise he had long experience he never rushed a case or a situation he knew well that there was any use in that he returned to the local police station and there he found a woman and a man waiting for him

the murder took place right in front of my house sir did you see anything ma'am no no it was too dark our street is very badly lighted but i heard running in my driveway and then it sounded like scuffling out front i went to the window and heard a woman well half-whispered oh don't oh don't

then she was frightened no sir how's that it wasn't fright sir it was like she was begging someone she knew not to do something then i heard running away again going away and after that the screaming

you're certain the woman was not frightened i'm positive sir if i felt she was

a tiny bit of testimony very tiny would it stand up in court how would it impress a jury what would a good defense counsel do with her on cross-examination none of it was weak but it was interesting quite interesting

and there was a man waiting at the station house for inspector bell with a woman the man introduced himself

i'm sandy winters inspector fred was my brother i don't want to get anybody into trouble sir but there are a few facts my sister my sister-in-law may forget to mention women are like that at times

facts such as mr winters there's a man who disliked my brother intensely a ship steward james davis the cause of this dislike my brother threw him out of the house for what reason fred thought that this davis was well making passes at evelyn fred mentioned it to me once or twice your brother must have been fairly sure to take that action incidentally what was this davis doing in the house in the first place we knew evelyn's family as a boy he was quite friendly with fred and evelyn at first went off on a holiday with them to brighton between sailings it was then he moved in fred had a spare room and could use the money after a while fred didn't like davis's attitude towards evelyn so he threw him out

is there anything else mr winters nothing i can think of sir this was just a point i thought you ought to thank you mr winters we'll probably be in touch with you good night good night

sergeant yes sir pick-up order sergeant for james davis ship's steward check crew lists of all lines carrying passengers or using stewards and don't let mrs winters learn that we know about this davis not yet at any rate beg pardon

new james davis steward aboard the morania i am so what i'm from scotland yard my credentials what do you want with me i'd like to have a talk with you before your ship sails sailing date's three days off we understand that's right what do you want to talk with me for a friend of yours a friend of yours has been killed name of fred winters freddy dead how where the inspector will tell you all that shall we go now davis i've seen your first officer already he knows what's going on

this is james davis inspector how do you do mr davis not so good what with the news and all who killed freddy inspector we'd like to find out perhaps you can help us sit down won't you thanks and yes sergeant take care of mr davis's overcoat hang it up in the outer office for him yes sir thank you it is a bit warm in here and sergeant deliver this note to dr arnold will you

now then mr davis perhaps you'll tell us yes mr davis perhaps you will tell us where you were last night between 10 pm and 2 am i was with evelyn's family i've known them since i was a boy well that fits with sandy winters's story doesn't it what about evelyn winters and fred mr davis you knew them well didn't you matter of fact inspector i had a room with them until poor old freddy got the idea that evelyn and i were a bit too friendly it wasn't true naturally sir but i figured it'd be better all round if i cleared out so i did perfectly natural don't cause your childhood friend any trouble her husband is jealous live somewhere else so simple so proper

it was just about then that the telephone on the inspector's desk added its voice to the situation

inspector bell here bill you've got holloway he is here with a fellow he gave me your note i made only the first test but no doubt in my mind stain you spotted on the sleeve it's blood all right no question about it

well today you can find that sheath knife among other honored exhibits in the black museum

in just a moment we will continue with the black museum starring orson welles

would you care for a touch of international chicanery orson welles portrays the roguish crook harry lime a clever thief continually in the middle of an international hijinks be with him each week as he darts back and forth across the line of the law be in on his sophisticated plans which always end with someone getting conned join kuow thursday evenings at 9 30 as we present the lives of harry lime but hang on to your radio you may have that by friday morning

now we continue with the black museum starring orson welles

they kept what they knew from jimmy davis and from evelyn winters scotland yard has a habit of not breaking news until there are certain effects and blood on the cuff of an overcoat is only one fact the rest was guessing that's not enough they drew other items from jimmy davis that day before they finished with his overcoat and with him

as i said inspector i spent the evening with evelyn's family i've been doing that during my time ashore for years i left them about 11 o'clock it was something of a problem getting back to london the trains out manor parkway aren't very frequent after 11 when i finally made it back to victoria station the last train out my way was gone i didn't have the cab fare so i walked all the way home didn't get in until after 2 in the morning

quite straightforward very logical honestly told to inspector bell it seemed well just a little too honest he asked jimmy davis to wait around a bit then he consulted with sergeant holloway

a railway map sergeant here's the line that runs out to manor park

He was there, sir. Mrs. Winter's family confirmed that. And the time Davis says he left them. If there were anything to our idea, he'd never tell us about it if they couldn't confirm it. But he must have known it was a problem as he said to get back to London. Well, how does that fit, sir? He could have left a little earlier, but he didn't.

Now, look here, on the map. Yes, look closely, Sergeant. What do you see?

That Inspector's quite a... Ilford! The next stop after Manor Park, going toward London.

Oh, I see what you mean, Inspector. It might be quite simple. Board a train at Manor Park with a ticket for London, hop off at the next stop, Ilford, knowing that Fred and Evelyn Winters will be on the midnight train down from London, wait in a dark driveway. Yes, it might be quite simple.

The Inspector thinks so, too. I think we'll ask Davis to stay here a day or two. His ship doesn't sail until the day after tomorrow. Meanwhile, Sergeant, we'll get ourselves a warrant, and you can give his lodgings a thorough going over.

Sergeant Holloway took three men with him and gave Jimmy Davis's furnished room a very thorough going over.

Take everything apart, men. Put it all back together again, says the fellow won't know we've been here. We're looking for any article of clothing with a trace of blood on it, and for a knife about six inches long. Also, what's for evidence of Davis's associations with women? Three points. Blood, a knife, and women. On point one... Everything's clean. We must have missed the staining Inspector spotted on his overcoat. On point two... Nothing. Nothing. Absolutely nothing to indicate the man ever touched a knife. And as for point three... It's a goldmine, Inspector. Davis had a special box full of letters. I didn't take the time to read them. One look at the signature on all of them was enough. Ever yours.

Interesting reading. Not nice, but interesting.

Darlingest, I can't explain it. I looked up digitalis in a medical dictionary at the library. It's a cumulative poison. Put it in Freddy's tea, but it had no effect. He just complained that it tamed his blood. I've given it to him for a week now. I'm afraid to make the doses any larger. But I'll think of something else, because I cannot believe what I saw there. I took an electric bulb and broke it and powdered the glass. Freddy likes lots of sugar, and I never use sugar. Maybe this will work. I think he suspects I'm up to something.

The glass didn't work either. Be patient, darling. He'll never give you a divorce. But I find a way. No one will ever suspect. There must be a way. We've got to be together, and we shall be as we were once, only without fear. Ever yours, Evelyn.

Nice girl, wasn't she? Poison. Powdered glass. Ah. Ever yours, Evelyn.

Inspector Bell called in Sergeant Holloway.

Yes, sir?

The letters. They'll go find... In court, after we've put the two of them together someplace, and after we've found the weapon. Davis says he hasn't seen her in months, and she insists on the same thing. In one of the letters, she mentions meeting him at a tea room in the city. I'll cover that. You get down to Southampton, to the Morania. Talk to the crew. Get everything you can on Davis. Check?

Yes, sir. Check.

In the tea room, Inspector Bell found an obliging waitress with an excellent memory.

Tall, you say, sir? Auburn hair, greenish eyes. Well, now, let me think a minute, sir. Uh, yes, there was a woman comes in here. Very good looking. Hmm, if you like that kind of colouring. Many men do? Well, one man does. The one that comes in here with this woman. Afternoons, mostly, from the early tea. He's young. Oh, younger than she is, that's my guess. Very nice looking. Have you heard any names? Once, it was... Yes, once, I heard her call him Jimmy, darling.

I see. Uh, tell me, have they been in here recently? Say, in the last day or so?

Oh, I think so. I seem to remember. Yes, the day before yesterday it was.

Do you think you know them again? In a crowd, perhaps?

Yes, sir. I'm sure now. Why, sir? Are they in trouble with the police? I wouldn't want to put nobody in trouble, not like a...

In trouble with the police? Well, a little. Just a little. If you call a growing sum of evidence in a murder case trouble, and it was growing.

Sergeant Holloway went to Southampton.

I gather from some of the other men that Davis was never too sociable, right? Ever show you any of his hobbies?

Well, he didn't have any that I know of. Not, say, wood carving or anything like that?

Oh, I never saw him use a knife on wood. Oh, he owned a knife. Oh, yes, a slick looking blade it was. Carried it in a sheath on his belt. He liked to keep it pretty sharp too.

I see. Well, thank you, Carter. Thank you very much.

But there are two themes here. They must be resolved together. A woman who followed the pattern of a sly, careful poisoner. A man who once owned a sheath knife. The planning of a careful crime. The execution of a crime of violence. Did the two themes come together on that midnight street in Ilford? Was Jimmy Davis waiting behind the hedges? Did Evelyn Winters know he was there? No. That she was leading her husband to his death? There were answers to these questions somewhere. Inspector Bell went quietly and methodically about the business of getting those answers.

I'm glad you will come in to see us, Mrs. Winters. I've been hoping you'll be able to help us.

Is that so, Inspector? I wish I could help you. My office is just along this hall. Yes, we're rather up a tree. A difficult kind of case. Unless we can find someone with a motive somewhere, it may go unsolved. Oh, there's Sergeant Holloway.

Sergeant Holloway? Yes, you remember. Yes. He's, uh, working with me. Uh, he may have a question or two. There he is, um, in this office with the glass panel door, uh, talking to someone. Um, come in a minute, Mrs. Winters.

No. No, I won't. I know the man Sergeant Holloway is talking to. He knows me.

Yes, Mrs. Winters. Uh, we know he knows you. Jimmy told you?

I asked the question, Mrs. Winters. Are you in love with Jimmy Davis? Did you plan to kill your husband that night in Ilford? Oh. We know a lot, Mrs. Winters. We want to know. If you held your husband while Davis stabbed him, did you decoy your husband? Did you tell Davis to be there? How long have you been in love with him? How long have you cried...

Questions, questions. They came sick and fast. Now, the inspector took her into his office. The stenographer waited. She was warned, and the questions poured out around her. She sat there, pinioned by the inspector's quiet voice. Until...

I'll tell you. I was in love with Jimmy, but I didn't plan the murder. Jimmy did that. He did it on his own. He jumped out of the driveway and struggled with poor Freddy. Fred fell down.

A nice girl, a really nice girl with willpower. They showed her the letters in her own handwriting, but she stuck to her story. Nothing to do with it. Nothing. And Jimmy Davis, still in love with this woman. Jimmy denied the letters, too. Evelyn didn't know a thing. I waited for them. I wanted to make Fred give her a divorce. He tried to hit me, and we fought. I used the knife. It was self-defense, but I got scared. I threw the knife into the sewer grating and ran away. Evelyn didn't know a thing. We didn't see each other for months.

What about the waitress who will identify you, Jimmy Davis? What about your buddy and his story of the sharpening of a knife? What about the letters? What about the woman? Is she worth it?

Evelyn didn't know a thing. She had nothing to do with it.

Sorry, Davis. It's no use. You'll be tried together, and the chances are, you'll hang together.

Well, that's the story. That's how they wound up the case. And today, in case you're interested, you'll find that sheath knife in the Black Museum. Orson Welles will be back with you in just a moment.

It's always ugly. And in this case, the motive was heedless, reckless passion. And the ugliness was amplified by the long planning, the cruelty, and finally, by the end of the story, Evelyn Winters died badly, unable even to manage the numbness of fatality which comes to so many murderers on the scaffold. She collapsed. Had to be carried to the gallows. Supported there by two jailers. The hangman, by the way, resigned his job shortly afterwards. And to the end, despite the letters, despite the evidence, Jimmy Davis tried to take all the blame on himself. But justice and death both were equal in this case. And the sheath knife remained in its customary place, in Scotland Yard, the Black Museum. And now, until next time, till another story about the Black Museum, I remain, as always, obediently yours.

The Black Museum, starring Orson Welles, is presented by arrangement with Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer Radio Attractions. The program is written by Ira Marion, with music composed and conducted by Sidney Torch. Produced by Harry Alan Towers.

End of transcriptBack to the beginning ↑