Skip to content
On Air
All channelsAll
The Black Museum artwork

From the The Black Museum collection

The Tan Shoe

Episode24 min 27 secTranscript

The written record

Read the transcript

Read along with the recording · About 20 min to read

This is Orson Welles, speaking from London. Here in the grim stone structure on the Thames, which houses Scotland Yard, is a warehouse of souvenirs. Where everyday objects, a broom, a vase, a lampshade, all are touched by murder. Now this tan shoe, it's a brogue, good leather, expensive make, but the dark stain near the heel wasn't put there by the manufacturer. The tan shoe, sir, left foot. Well, what do you make of this stain? It looks to me like blood. Today that shoe can be seen in the Black Museum. From the annals of the Criminal Investigation Department of the London Police, we bring you the dramatic stories of the crimes recorded by the objects in Scotland Yard's gallery of death, the Black Museum.

Well, here we are in the Black Museum, Scotland Yard's museum of murder. Here lies death, violent, unexpected death. Here in the objects that line the shelves and fill the room are the stories of murder. Here's a birthday card, to Margaret, with love. A present went with the card, of course. The present was dead. A man was drinking from it when he died, most unnaturally. The glass fell from his hands. The murderer jumped forward instinctively to catch it. He caught it and left a fingerprint that sent him to the gallows.

Here is the tan shoe. A left-foot shoe. The darkish stain near the heel, inside and out, couldn't be disguised with polish. But there was no stain on it that morning of May the 20th, 1930, when the two men, one wearing this particular shoe, walked along the platform at Newcastle Station. It was a few minutes before train time, so they made their way along the platform.

I tell you, John, my firm regard me most highly.

I'm sure they do, my dear chap.

It's not that I care to boast, but their attitude speaks for itself.

In what way?

Well, as you... Well, as you... You know, they allow me to travel with a colliery wages each Friday.

Huh?

From the bank in Newcastle to our office at Almond. Oh, it's a very responsible task.

Come, my friend, admit the truth.

What truth, John?

Well, they really don't allow you to travel unescorted with so much money in that black leather bag.

Oh, yes, they do.

But there's no guard cunningly pushed in someone else on the train to watch you?

None whatsoever. You see, they place great trust in me.

They do indeed. Mark my words. I'm in line for a colliery. I'll be in managership one day.

And you deserve it, my dear chap.

Yes, it'll be a fine reward for 20 years' work.

Oh, morning, Collins.

Oh, good morning, Bernie. Fine, chap. He's a clerk with a neighbour in colliery.

Now, come on, John. I think this is our carriage.

Oh, it seems to be empty.

Splendid. We can have a good talk during the hour journey to Almond. Now, come on, sit down and make yourself at home.

And with these few words, the friends smilingly took their places in the empty railway carriage. It was quite a change for them. It was quite a change for Mr. Bennet to have someone to talk to on his usually lonely courier service, more often than not, he was alone with his small black bag, for it was not his habit to trust strangers when carrying a large sum of money. But this chap seemed a decent sort.

And, John, you simply must come on to dinner and meet the wife.

Oh, that would be very nice, old chap.

That's good. Well, shall we say Friday night?

Delighted.

Yes, a very decent sort. Bennet didn't take easily to people, but this chap seemed to be his kind. He'd only met him in Newcastle a week ago, but he'd warmed to him at once, and in a way he did with few people. So the train sped along the northeastern line. Eaton, Stannington, Morpeth, small station stops along the line. At Morpeth, the train took up water. Few people got out to stretch their legs. Some passed through the barrier and gave up their tickets. Among them was a man in a grey overcoat.

Tickets, please. Tickets, please.

Say what? Oh, say, say, your tickets for Arnold.

Oh. Yes, I've changed my mind. I'm getting off here.

Thank you.

Tickets, please.

Four minutes later, the train left Morpeth and went on its way to Almuth. There the passengers alighted. The journey was over. A porter then proceeded to clean the train, as was usual. But in one of the empty carriages, he made a gruesome discovery.

Hey, what's this? Blood in the floor? A stream of blood running from under the seat. He bent down to look and found the carriage not so empty. As he'd imagined.

Help, please. Somebody's been murdered.

They had indeed been murdered. And the next logical step after the local police had been hurriedly brought to the scene of the crime was to send for Scotland Yard.

Inspector Morton, sir, from Scotland Yard.

Oh, Inspector, come in. Glad to renew your acquaintance.

Aye, sir.

Oh, thank you, sir. It'll be all.

Yes, sir. Sit down, sit down. Well, in answer to your question, I'm worried.

You sit worried.

About the murder, sir?

Yes. They all come to the chief constable of the county.

Who?

The railways, telling me that no one will travel by train unless the killer's caught.

I see their point.

Yeah, but that's only one of them. Then there's the colliery, insisting that we find the murderer of their employee and the man's wife, of course.

Yes, I know. Well, you can hand all that sort of thing over to me now.

And I can't, sir. I'm sorry. First of all, sir, would you supply me with some preliminary facts? How much do you know about the murdered man?

The chief constable? The chief constable explained it all to the London detective. The dead man's name was Wallace Bennett, a meek and faithful little man. For the past 20 years, he'd worked with a leading colliery in the district. For the past five years, he'd been their paymaster, traveling with his cash bag to pay the miners' wages each week in Olmstead.

Well, there it is, Inspector. He took the train, as usual, this Friday, but he arrived in Olmstead dead.

And the bag in which he carried this money, sir?

It was missing.

The inspector wanted to know what he was doing. He wanted to find out first about that missing bag. Most of all, how much money it contained. He went to the colliery manager.

Now, sir, I'd like to have your help and connection with the murder of Bennett.

Well, anything I can do to help her, you can count on me.

Well, first, I'd like to find out how much the bag he was carrying with him contained.

Well, the person who can answer that question is Miss Robertson in our accounts department.

Well, Miss Robertson, I expect you have a record of the amount that Mr. Bennett drew from the bank on the morning of his death.

Oh, yes, Inspector. I have a note of it here. The amount is exactly 400 pounds, 8 shillings, and 4 pence.

And how was the money made up?

In various denominations, Inspector. You see, it was required for paying the men at the colliery, but the greater part in pound notes. And, Inspector, I thought that you'd be making inquiries, so I was in touch with the bank this morning.

Yes.

The money was paid out in used notes. And the bank has no trace of the numbers.

Oh, bad luck. Well, thank you, Miss Robertson. You've saved me a disappointment and a wasted visit.

Now, there were other things, other people to see. Among them, the doctor.

Inspector, I was called in by the local police when the body was discovered.

And what did you determine as the cause of death, Doctor?

Well, there were four bullets in the body, one of which entered the left lung and one the heart.

Yes.

The other two were lodged in the brain.

Hmm. Well, a killer took no chances.

Hmm. None at all. The skull was also fractured by a heavy blow, such as might be made by the butt of a revolver.

I see. Well, thank you, Doctor.

The motive was clear enough. Somewhere was a bag and 400 pounds. And there also was a murderer. But where? Who was it? I hadn't found it hard those first few days. Hard because there were no leads. There was a body, a missing cash bag, and four bullets. That was all. The bullets were duly tested and traced.

Nickel-capped bullets, sir. Unusual style. Five from a .32 revolver.

Any hope of tracing that gun, Morton?

Well, we're working on it now, sir. The train was thoroughly searched. No sign of the gun, but I'm having a very thorough search made along the railway track to see if we can uncover anything there.

Good. I should think it likely that the killer might have thrown the gun out of the window.

Well, let me know as soon as you're in to report, will you?

Inspector Morton.

What's that? You found the gun. All right, send it along as quickly as possible, and we'll have it examined by the experts.

Yes, sir. It's the murder weapon, all right. I've compared it with the bullets, and they were fired from this same revolver.

I suppose there's no means of identification on the revolver. Number removed, and all the usual precautions?

Oh, no, sir. The number can be distinguished. What's more, I've made inquiries, and we've traced the owner.

Good. Sounds a little too simple, though. Where is the owner?

Well, he's a foreign gentleman, sir. Living here in Newcastle. They are getting hold of him now.

Now, Mr. Rossini, I want you to identify this revolver. According to the gun license, it's one that belongs to you.

Let me see. Yes. Yes, that's my revolver, all right. Oh, I can't tell you how grateful I am to you, Inspector, for getting it back. Oh, my wife will be pleased. I never expected to see it again.

You mean it was stolen?

Yes, over three months ago. I must phone my wife and tell her it's back. Oh, she was so upset, poor Annunziata. You see, my house was burgled, and this was missing, among other things. I reported it to the local police.

I see. Just one other question, Mr. Rossini. Can you give me some indication of your movements during the last seven days?

Oh, that's very simple, Inspector. I only arrived home this morning on a business trip from the continent. You see, I've been in Paris for the last fortnight, but please don't let my wife know that. If you want any witnesses, that's very easy. I've been working in the Paris office of my company all the time. Don't be suspicious of me.

All right, Mr. Rossini. Just as a matter of routine, we'll check your statement, but I don't think we'll need to see you again.

Dead ends. Wherever they looked, dead ends. With the inquest pending, it looked as if a verdict of murder by a person or persons unknown would be certain. And yet that was not to be. A twist of fate, a new chance witness was to revive the investigation, set it back on the trail which led to the murderer and the bloodstained shoe, that same tan shoe which can be seen today in the Black Museum.

The witness came in on the third day, the morning after the funeral. He was a short, dark-haired man whose name was Collins. He asked to see the inspector in charge of the case.

Come in here, Mr. Collins. We can talk without interruption.

Thank you, Inspector.

Now, what was it you wished to see me about?

Well, uh, about Bennett's, uh, uh, about his murder.

Yes?

I met him on Newcastle Station that morning before he boarded the train.

You saw him then? Was he carrying his cash bag?

Uh, yes, he was. I've seen Bennett travel down to Ormuth every Friday for years, but this morning I particularly noticed him because...

Why?

Because he usually traveled alone. Wasn't he alone last Friday?

No, he had someone with him. They were walking along. They were walking along the station together. Uh, I saw them get into the same compartment.

Now, for the first time, Bennett's train companion entered the case. Inspector Morton wanted to know more, a lot more. Was the man a friend of Bennett's? Did he, Collins, know him?

No, uh, I didn't know the man, Inspector. He was a stranger to me.

Then it's unlikely he'd be a close friend of Bennett.

I think so. Of course, his wife, uh, I mean, uh, widow, would be the one to tell you about that.

I'll check. Now, Mr. Collins, you've been very helpful, but can you help a little more?

Yes, uh, how, Inspector?

Can you give me a description of this man?

Well, uh, I noticed he was shortish, uh, about my height.

That's, uh, five foot seven. Yes. Anything else? Uh, he was fair, uh, small moustache. Good. And his clothes? He, he was wearing a gray overcoat, a gray soft felt hat, and a dark gray suit. At least, uh... I could see his dark gray trousers, a red tie, I think, oh, oh, yes, and, uh, tan brogue shoes.

You're very observant, Mr. Collins. Did you by any chance notice when he left the train? Uh, yes, at Morpeth. You're sure of that? Uh, certain. Uh, I got out to stretch my legs, uh, when the train took up water there. I saw him go through the barrier and give up his ticket.

Out of the blue, a witness and a lead at last. It happens that way. A person remembers some incident, some unusual detail. And the train goes off. The trail begins.

Mrs. Bennet? Yes? I'm from the police. I'm sorry to trouble you at a time like this, but, uh, Inspector Morton, I'd like you to answer a few questions. I'll do it. Thank you, Mrs. Bennet. Now, uh, your husband left home at the usual time on that particular morning? Yes. Carrying the black bag containing the money? Yes. I was always worried about that bag. Yes. Uh, do you recall on this particular morning, whether or not he left the train? Yes. Whether your husband was planning to meet a friend, or anybody in particular? Well, if he, if he was, he never mentioned it to me. He always traveled by himself, as far as I know. Ah. Well, amongst your husband's acquaintances, is there any man you can recollect, uh, shortish? Five foot seven? Fair hair? Small mustache? No. No, I can't think of anybody like that. He definitely wasn't a close friend of my husband's. Of that, I'm sure.

Inspector Morton hurried to Morpeth and interviewed the ticket collector.

A man in a gray overcoat. Last Friday, he said, sir. Yes, a short, fair man, dark gray suit, and a small mustache. Do you remember him? Oh, yeah, I do remember. He, he had a ticket to Alnmouth. But he gave it up here. Yes, sir. I remember.

A man who had traveled in the same train, according to a witness, in the very same compartment. All we had to do now was find him. The thought was not too comforting. Find one man who might be anywhere in England, one man who had left almost no trace behind him.

And then fate, strange, incredible fate intervened. Or was it fate? Perhaps it was stupidity or the unconscious urge to brag that lies hidden in every murderer. Anyway, it happened that same week at a hotel bar in London.

Come on, have another, George. No, no, thanks, matey. I've got to be going. Come on, I'll pay. But you've already paid for three. What's that matter? I've got money. Look. Blimey. One pound notes. Hundreds of them. I tell you, I'm rich. Come on, have another.

Two men drinking in a bar, two casual acquaintances. It might never have happened, but it did happen. And when one of them, his mind filled with misgivings and doubts, went to the police the next morning, Scotland Yard was speedily informed.

Now, let's hear the story. Your name's Blakey, is it? That's right, sir. I'm a bus driver. This fellow I was drinking with, he used to work for our company once. Do you know him well? Well, no, hardly at all. I met him in the pub last night and he kept on buying me drinks. Then he brought out this great fistful of money. How much money would you say? Oh, two or three hundred quid, I should think. Well, maybe I misjudged him, sir, but you're right. I'm a bus driver. Well, I heard about the murder in Newcastle and the money being pinched. You did the right thing, Blakey. Don't worry about that. What's the man's name? Linkman. John Linkman, I think it is. Do you know where he lives? No, I've not the faintest idea about that, but you'll find him most nights down at the Roundhead Arms, sir, in the bar there.

The Roundhead Arms, a small pub on a London side street, a long way from the scene of the murder. But here, that same evening, went Inspector Morton.

What'll it be for you, sir? I'll order in a minute, Miss. Thanks. I'm waiting for a friend. OK. You might happen to know him. He's one of your regular customers, John Linkman. Johnny Linkman? Oh, yes, I know him. Funny thing, I came in here last Friday to have a drink with him and seemed to miss him. Oh, that's no wonder you should have asked me. Johnny was away. He was away about a week. Oh, that explains it. Yes, some business trip, he said. Must have done all right, too, because he's pretty flush now. Nice to hear of an old friend doing so well. There he is now, just coming in.

Hello, Johnny love. Hello, Ruby. Find it bitter? Better make it, too. You've got a friend waiting for you. Oh?

Never mind the drinks, Miss. John Linkman? Yes, who are you? Inspector Morton, from Scotland Yard. Scotland Yard? What do you want with me? One or two questions I want to ask you. Outside.

With a firm grip on his quarry's arm, Morton left the hotel bar. Outside, a car was waiting.

In here, Mr. Linkman. My dear Inspector, you must be out of your mind. What's the meaning of this?

Where were you last Friday, Mr. Linkman? Minding my own business. Oh, come, sir. That attitude's only wasting our time. Oh, I was on a business trip, if you must know. Where? In the Newcastle district. I'm a salesman. What firms did you deal with there? And what firm do you represent? I'm a private trader. I saw no firms while I was there. None? No, my trip was a failure. Then where did you get the very large sum of money you've been carrying with you lately? Money? What money? I think you know to what I'm referring. May I see the contents? Of your pocket? Certainly not. Then you'll force me to go through the formality of a search warrant. Oh. Oh, all right. Here. A pen. Yes. Some silver. And this. One pound note. At a guess, about 300 of them.

Linkman was held in custody. Meanwhile, Morton and a sergeant went to search his home.

I'm sorry, ma'am, but we have a search warrant. Shall I start on the bedroom, sir? Yes, sergeant. But what has my husband done? Why? You hear? We're just making a preliminary investigation, ma'am. There's no cause for alarm yet.

They searched the bedroom, a cramped lounge room with its fading wallpaper, the bathroom, the kitchen, pursued and harassed by a distraught Mrs. Linkman. Then, in the second bedroom.

What has he done, Inspector? You've got to tell me. I'm sorry. There's nothing I can tell you yet, Mrs. Linkman. This is awful. Awful.

I've got something, Inspector. A tan shoe, sir. Left foot. What do you make of this stain? It looks to me like blood. We'll take it back with us and have it tested.

In the laboratory at Scotland Yard, they found out it was blood. The bank in Newcastle identified the notes. In a police line-up, Collins identified Linkman as the man who had shared a compartment with Bennett that fatal Friday morning. And then the game was up.

Well, Mr. Linkman, have you anything to say? This is all a ridiculous mistake. I can explain everything. Can you explain this? Why, yes. You must have found it in my flat. It's one of my shoes. And can you explain the stain? Here, just by the toe cap. Somebody seems to have been trying to cover it with shoe polish. Not very successfully, I'm afraid. Oh, come along, Mr. Linkman. Can you explain that? Well, I've never noticed the stain before. It's probably some oil or something. No, Mr. Linkman, it's not oil. I have the laboratory report here. It's a blood stain. All right. You know everything, don't you? Not everything, Mr. Linkman. I've got the laboratory report. But enough. Would you like to make a statement now? Very well. I'm glad it's over. Glad I can tell somebody the truth at last.

Confronted with all this and the evidence of the stain on the shoe he'd vainly tried to cover up with shoe polish, Linkman confessed to his crime. And today that same shoe can be seen occupying a place in the Black Museum.

Orson Welles will be back with you in just a moment.

The trial was held at Newcastle with an eminent counsel retained to defend the prisoner. But inevitably the sordid details of the crime emerged. Linkman being out of a job and needing money, a chance to make the acquaintance of Wallace Bennett in Newcastle. Learning his new friend carried large sums of money by train every Friday, Linkman carefully planned his crime. But he learned, much to his eternal sorrow, that care must be preserved both before and after murder. A moment's lapse, a few drinks, and it meant the thirteen steps and the rope one morning not long afterwards. As the Lord Justice said in sentencing the prisoner, the scales of justice are now balanced.

And now until we meet next time in the same place and I tell you another story about the Black Museum, I remain as always obediently yours.

End of transcriptBack to the beginning ↑