Skip to content
On Air
All channelsAll
Box 13 artwork

From the Box 13 collection

The Perfect Crime

Episode26 min 33 secTranscript

The written record

Read the transcript

Read along with the recording · About 21 min to read

<!-- kimi_cleaned -->

He eats the same food. He's a creature of habit. And that makes him the perfect victim.

Why?

Because when he disappears, no one will be surprised. They'll think he just changed his routine.

You're wrong there. The store he works for, his landlady, they'll all be looking for him.

But they won't find him. Or his body.

And that's the end of it?

No. Then I shall confess to the murder. And no one will believe me. Just as no one has believed me all these months.

And you think that will be the perfect crime?

I know it will be.

Well, we left the restaurant and Dr. Dobbs took me back to the hotel. I didn't sleep much that night. The next morning I got up early and went to see Alexander Ferris.

Mr. Ferris?

Yes?

My name is Dan Holliday. I'm a writer. I'm doing a magazine article on buyers for department stores. I wonder if you'd give me some information.

Well, I don't know. I'm pretty busy.

It won't take long. And I can pay you for your time.

Well, all right. What do you want to know?

Just the routine of your work. How often you travel, where you stay, things like that.

Oh, that's simple enough. Once a month I go to the city to buy for our store here. I stay at the Carlton Hotel. I always take the 9:15 train back home.

Always?

Yes, I'm a man of habit, Mr. Holliday. I find it saves a lot of trouble.

I see. And when do you go again?

Tomorrow.

Tomorrow?

Yes. Why?

No reason. Just getting my facts straight. Well, thank you very much, Mr. Ferris.

Not at all.

I went back to the hotel and found Dr. Dobbs waiting for me.

Where have you been, Dan?

Out for a walk.

You went to see Ferris, didn't you?

Yes.

Why?

To warn him.

And did you?

No. I couldn't. He's such a harmless little man. He doesn't know what's going to happen to him.

But you didn't warn him?

No. I told you, I couldn't. It would sound so fantastic. He'd think I was crazy.

Good. Then our game is still on.

Dr. Dobbs, I'm going to stop you somehow.

How? You don't know when or where or how I'm going to do it.

I know when. Tomorrow. When Ferris takes the 9:15 train.

Ah, but which 9:15 train? There are two, you know. One at 9:15 in the morning, one at 9:15 at night.

I didn't know that.

No. And Ferris always takes the morning train. Or does he?

What are you trying to do, confuse me?

I'm trying to win our little game, Dan. Remember, you promised to checkmate me.

All right. I'll be at the station tomorrow morning. And I'll see Ferris get on that train safely.

Will you? And what if he takes the night train instead?

Then I'll be there in the evening too.

Will you? What if he doesn't take either train? What if he takes a bus? Or a plane? Or what if he's already dead when you think he's still alive?

You're bluffing.

Am I? We'll see.

I spent the whole day watching Ferris. He went to work, he had lunch at his usual place, he went back to work, he had dinner at the boarding house. Nothing unusual. The next morning I was at the station early. The 9:15 train came in, Ferris got on it. I saw him with my own eyes. I even followed him to the next stop and made sure he was still on the train. Then I went back to the city and called Dr. Dobbs.

Well, Dan?

You lost. Ferris is on his way home, safe and sound.

Are you sure?

I followed him myself.

Did you? How far?

To the next stop.

And then?

I came back.

I see. And you think Ferris is still alive?

I know he is.

Do you? Then perhaps you'd better read this evening's newspaper.

What?

The late edition. It should be on the streets now.

I bought a paper. There it was, on the front page. "Alexander Ferris, department store buyer, found murdered in Carlton Hotel. Body discovered by maid at 11:00 this morning."

But that's impossible! I saw him get on the train!

Did you? Or did you see someone who looked like him?

But... but the body was found at eleven. I saw him at nine-fifteen.

Yes. The body was found at eleven. But when was he killed, Dan?

I don't know.

Shall I tell you? He was killed last night. In his room at the boarding house. I killed him, Dan. And then I took his place.

You?

Yes. I wore his clothes. I imitated his walk. I even had a false mustache made to look like his. You saw me, Dan. You followed me. You thought I was Ferris.

But... but why? Why go through all that?

To establish the perfect alibi. You see, I took the morning train as Ferris. But I got off at the first stop and came back to the city. Then I went to the Carlton Hotel and registered as myself. I asked for Ferris's room, saying I had an appointment with him. The clerk told me he had checked out. I made a scene, demanded to see the room. The maid found the body. And I was there, a respectable professor, demanding an investigation.

But the body... you said the body would never be found.

And it won't be. Not for long. You see, I arranged for the body to be cremated. I paid the funeral expenses myself. As a public-spirited citizen, shocked by the murder.

That's monstrous.

Is it? The body will be ashes in a few hours. And there will be no autopsy, no examination. Just a simple case of a man murdered by person or persons unknown.

But the police...

The police will investigate, of course. They'll find that Ferris was a bachelor, that he had no enemies, that he lived a quiet, routine life. And they'll find that I, Dr. John Dobbs, was in another city when he was killed. I have witnesses. The clerk at the hotel here, the conductor on the train, and you, Dan. You saw Ferris get on the train. You'll testify to that, won't you?

I... I don't know what I saw now.

Exactly. And neither will anyone else. The case will remain unsolved. And I will have committed the perfect crime.

But you'll confess. You said you would.

Oh, yes. I'll confess. And no one will believe me. Just as no one has believed me all these months. I'll be laughed at again. Perhaps they'll put me in an asylum. But they won't convict me. There will be no evidence. No body, no witnesses, no motive. Nothing.

You're insane.

Am I? Or am I the only sane man in a world of fools? I've done what I set out to do, Dan. I've committed the perfect crime. And you were my audience.

I left him there. I didn't know what to do. I went to the police and told them everything. They listened politely, checked my story, and found that Dr. Dobbs had indeed been in another city when Ferris was killed. The body had been cremated. There was nothing they could do. The case was closed.

But I couldn't let it rest. I went back to see Dr. Dobbs.

Well, Dan. Have you come to congratulate me?

No. I've come to tell you that you didn't commit the perfect crime.

Oh? And why not?

Because Ferris isn't dead.

What?

That's right. The man you killed wasn't Alexander Ferris. It was someone else. A tramp, perhaps. Or a man you hired. Ferris is still alive.

You're bluffing.

Am I? Then why don't we go and see him? He's at the Carlton Hotel right now. Room 312.

You're lying.

Shall we go?

We went to the hotel. I knocked on the door of 312. It opened. And there stood Alexander Ferris, alive and well.

But... but how?

It was simple, Dr. Dobbs. I warned him after all. Not directly, but through his employer. I told them there might be an attempt on his life. They sent another man in his place. A man who resembled him. You were so busy planning your perfect crime that you never stopped to check your victim.

But the body...

Was cremated, yes. And now there really is no evidence. But not against Ferris. Against you.

I don't understand.

You killed a man, Dr. Dobbs. You may never know who he was. But you killed him. And I witnessed it. Not the actual murder, but the planning, the confession, everything. I have enough to send you to the electric chair.

But... but you said... the perfect crime...

You wanted an audience, Dr. Dobbs. You got one. But an audience can also be a witness. You forgot that.

He stood there, staring at me. Then he began to laugh. Softly at first, then louder and louder.

Checkmate, Dr. Dobbs.

Yes. Yes, I believe it is. I underestimated you, Dan. I thought I was playing against a novice. But you're a master.

And now?

Now? I suppose I shall have to pay the penalty for my... my imperfect crime.

He turned and walked to the window. He stood there for a moment, looking out. Then he opened it and stepped out onto the ledge.

Dr. Dobbs! Don't!

Why not? I have three months to live anyway. Why spend them in prison?

He jumped.

I tried to catch him, but I was too late. He fell four stories to the street below. When I got down there, he was still alive. Just barely.

Dan...

Yes, Dr. Dobbs.

I... I want you to know... it was almost perfect... wasn't it?

Almost, Dr. Dobbs. Almost.

He smiled then. A strange, peaceful smile. And then he died.

I never found out who the dead man was. The police investigated, but there was no way to identify him. Dr. Dobbs had chosen his victim well. Too well, perhaps. In a way, he did commit the perfect crime. No one was ever convicted of that murder. And Dr. John Dobbs died a free man.

But I think of him sometimes. Of his books, his brilliant mind, his strange desire for excitement. And I wonder if any crime is ever really perfect. Or if the only perfect crime is the one that never happens at all.

This is Alan Ladd. Next week, same time, same station, Box 13 will bring you another exciting adventure. Until then, good night.

Box 13 is produced and directed by Vern Carstensen. Original music is composed and conducted by Rudy Schrager. Featured in the cast were Sylvia Picker, Edmund McDonald, and Alan Reed. This is CBS, the Columbia Broadcasting System.

Uh-huh. Now, suppose I should walk over to Mr. Ferris and tell him that a madman is going to kill him.

Go on. Try it. You know what he'd do.

Ah, yes. I think I do.

Of course. He'd look at me as though I were the madman. Then he'd call for the police and I'd be stuck in a nice cell until about... the police decided I was not.

Exactly. All right, Dan. We're finished here. You've seen the victim. Now we'll go back home and I'll let you know when the game begins.

Oh, just a second. Mr. Holliday, it's that man again.

Dobbs?

Uh-huh.

Okay, give me the phone.

Here.

Hello. Look, Doctor, let's call off this race. I'm getting tired of it.

Mr. Holliday, Mr. Ferris leaves his town this afternoon. He will arrive here at 7:30 this evening on the Lakeshore Limited. He will go to the Barrett Hotel. He will never leave there alive.

Hello. Dobbs. Hello.

What'd he say this time?

Same thing, still harping on the perfect crime.

Do you think he means it?

I... he's got me over a barrel. I don't want to believe him. Sometimes I don't, but...

But what?

There's something earnest about him when he talks about it.

Well, I can't take a chance. I'm going to keep my eyes on Alexander Ferris.

I decided to warn Ferris, so that evening I met the Lakeshore Limited. I tried to get to him, but... before I could, he hurried into a taxi. I grabbed the first empty cab I could find and went to the Barrett Hotel. Ferris had already registered and was disappearing into an elevator. I ran across the lobby, but the elevator door closed and Ferris was gone. I got his room number, 708. Took an elevator. We were just passing the fifth floor when...

Those were shots. And they came from the seventh floor.

I missed my guess. I didn't miss it, because on the seventh floor...

All right. All right, back to your rooms. Go on, everybody. Go on. You too.

You're the house detective?

Yeah, who are you?

My name's Dan Holliday. Did those shots come from this room?

Yes, they did.

Dobbs.

Hello, Dan. What's happened?

Look, I'll take care of this.

Of course, but the shots came from that room. I know, because my room is next door.

You? You're next door?

Yes. Since I left the university, I've been living here. The house detective will verify that.

Sure.

Well, that's got nothing to do with this. Hadn't you better get inside the room and see what's happened?

This is my job. But since you stuck your nose in, stay right with me. You got a passkey?

Yep.

Hmm. You can still smell the powder from the shots.

Yeah. And where's the guy that came in here?

Look in the back. Close that door. Now, you two stay right there. I'm going to give this place a look-see. Something fishy here.

So, your curiosity got the better of you, eh, Dan? You're next door, huh?

Yes, convenient, isn't it? Where's Ferris?

He's dead. You shot him, I suppose.

I killed him, yes. I saw him get on the elevator and come up here.

All right. You saw that. What then?

Where is he? I don't get this. There ain't a sign of the guy anyplace. But there's his hat, top coat, and valise on the bed. Which proves he came in here. The bellboy will verify it if he came in here.

All right. Let's ask the bellboy. I'm running this until the police get here.

Well, by all means, call the police. Dr. Dobbs, would you mind if your room was searched?

I was going to suggest it myself.

There ain't no fire escape. Nobody fell out the window. And nobody's here.

Oh, please. Please, let's look in my room. Then you can question the other guests on this floor.

Okay. Come on, you two. Out of this room.

Well, Dan, what do you think now?

I don't know. Maybe I've stopped thinking.

Well, the case was a sensational one. Two shots fired. No body and no Alexander Ferris. Two days later, Dr. Dobbs visited me in my apartment.

Well, Dan, have you made any headway?

I'm not trying.

Oh, yes. Yes, you are. It intrigues you, doesn't it?

It's a hoax. The whole thing is a hoax.

Not the whole thing, Dan. I give you my word of honor that I killed Ferris.

Will you tell the police that?

I already have. I confessed.

You what?

But they laughed at me. You see, I'm known now as a crank. I confess to all murders. Where is Ferris's body, Holliday? How did I get it out of the room?

You didn't. You couldn't have. The other guests rushed to the doors after the shots. The only stairways are at the ends of the corridor. You couldn't have carried his body without being seen.

Correct. And the bellboy verifies the fact that Ferris entered his room next to mine. And yours was empty. So, what have you got?

Dobbs, I... I don't believe you killed Ferris.

All right, then where is he?

I don't know.

So, I fulfilled two of the conditions we talked about our first night. Remember what they were?

Yes, the victim had to be a stranger to you, and the body had to disappear.

And the third condition, I escaped detection and punishment. Dan, why don't you tell the police about me? What you know, what I've told you.

They wouldn't believe me.

No, they wouldn't. But, Dan, I swear to you that I killed Ferris. If you figure out how I did it, I'll admit it and take my punishment.

I am not the police.

No, no, you're not. But you know more about this than they do. I swear to you again, Dan. You have the whole solution in your head. All you have to do is put together the pieces of the puzzle. It's really very simple.

Well, goodbye, Dan.

Mr. Holliday.

Mr. Holliday. Hmm? Hmm?

Oh, I'm sorry, Susie. I was daydreaming.

About Dr. Dobbs?

Dobbs. Gee, I think it's some kind of a joke. There just isn't anybody that they've been looking for almost a week now.

That's what bothers me. Ferris is missing. He left his hometown, took the train, came here. I saw him, Susie. I saw him, then... no Ferris. And the police won't believe Dr. Dobbs. Or me. Kling thinks I'm in the same class as Dobbs.

I know. Oh, well, thanks.

There's got to be an answer, though. No one, not even an admitted genius such as Dobbs, could kill a man and do away with his body. But there isn't a trace.

Look, Dobbs had about 15 seconds to kill Ferris and then hide the body.

Yes?

What were you going to say?

I'm not sure. Dobbs said I had the whole solution in my head. Susie, ever see a magic act?

Magic act? Oh, you mean a magician?

A magician? Sleight of hand?

That's right. Sleight of hand. Illusions. Now you see it, now you don't. Watch the little lady disappear from under your very eyes. Keep your eye on the magician and miss how the trick is done.

I don't know what you're talking about.

I'm not sure I do, but I've got an idea. Susie, we're going to send a telegram.

Where to?

To Alexander Ferris's hometown, to the chief of police.

But that's been done. You know that.

Sure, sure I do. But the other telegrams were about and concerning Ferris.

Well, what's yours going to be?

About a perfect stranger.

Well, I was shooting in the dark, but I hit. The answer I received to my telegram made me sure I had the solution to Dr. Dobbs's illusion. Smart police work in Ferris's hometown proved it. So that night I went to see Dobbs.

It's nice of you to come to see me, Dan. I was wondering if you'd forgotten me. Everyone else seems to have done so.

No, you're not forgotten, Dr. Dobbs. Quite the contrary.

Oh? How do you mean that?

Just the way I said it. May I sit down?

Certainly, please. Please do.

Thanks.

May I offer you a drink?

Oh, no, thank you.

Mind if I have one?

Please do.

You've come to see me for a very special reason, haven't you?

Yes, I have. Read this telegram. It's from the police in Ferris's hometown.

Huh? Hmm. Did you guess or did they?

I did. I'm glad. Glad you were my audience. It was fun playing to you.

Yes, you were the magician. I was the kid in the audience with his mouth open and his mind closed.

Magician? Not quite.

Oh, yes. Like the trick where the magician shows the audience a nice big red ball. He gets them used to seeing it. He conditions them to its size, its shape. Then he covers the ball with a handkerchief, makes a mystic pass, and the ball is gone.

Go on. What then?

Ah, but the ball never disappears. It never goes under the handkerchief. All the audience sees is a similar shape outlined under the silk.

Yes, I'm very happy. I'm very happy I chose you as my audience.

I'm not. I don't like to be the one to catch you.

Why not? I took the risk. Ferris never came to the city. You got off the Lakeshore Limited that night.

And what else, Dan?

You called me and told me Ferris would come here. That day in his hometown, you pointed him out. You made me take a good look at him, about your height and build. I even mentioned that, I think.

Yes, you did. Go on.

Before he left, you came here. You intercepted him, killed him. In his own hometown. You took his top coat, hat, and valise. Then you dressed him in entirely different clothes. Took his body to the freight yards. That telegram from the police there verifies that an unidentified man was found dead.

Yes, unidentified because the police weren't anxious to identify that body. But they did this afternoon. Dental work proves the man to be Ferris. You see, Dobbs, there's always a clue. Always. There is no perfect crime.

But just a moment. There were three conditions. The first is the actual committing of a perfect murder. Now, I fulfill two. Now, the third. I must escape detection and punishment. How is anyone going to prove what you've just said?

By your admissions, Dobbs. The police are in the next room and outside in the hall. They've heard every word.

Oh. There are still a few things to clean up, but there isn't time, is there? I still have to escape punishment. I'm sorry, but you can't.

Okay, boys, come on in.

Well, well. The police. But, Dan, I still say I've fulfilled the last condition, to escape punishment. It's a good thing you didn't take the drink I offered you. I knew as soon as you came in that you had me. Dan, explain how I did it. It's no fun doing something clever if no one appreciates it.

Dobbs. Dr. Dobbs. So long, Dan. Don't forget to explain the rest. It's been a wonderful... chess game. Now, checkmate.

How did he kill Mr. Ferris in the hotel?

I told you. He didn't, Susie. He killed Ferris in the man's own hometown. You see, I thought I'd followed Ferris to the hotel from the station, but I had followed Dobbs.

And then?

Very simple. Dobbs had reserved a room next to Ferris's. Then, disguised as Ferris, he went into the room Ferris had reserved. Dobbs took off the top coat, hat, put the valise on the bed. Fired two shots. Two shots. Blanks. Then, slipped quickly into his own room.

Do you see?

Oh, sure. Leaving the other room empty.

Right. So, everyone was looking in the wrong place for Ferris. Everyone assumed he'd really come to this city. Like the old trick with the ball, Susie. You think you see it, but you don't. So, you look in the wrong place.

Gee, he was really smart, wasn't he?

Susie, just remember this. No matter how smart you are, there's always somebody who'll trip you up. Everyone makes mistakes.

But, Dr. Dobbs didn't.

Oh, yes, he did. He made the same mistake I did. He looked in the wrong place.

What do you mean?

You see, I had to trap him into a confession. He assumed that dental work would identify Ferris's body. But the man found in the freight yards had perfect teeth. And no dental work.

Good night, Susie.

Listen in again next week when, through the courtesy of Paramount Pictures, Alan Ladd stars as Dan Holliday in... Box 13.

Box 13 is directed by Richard Sanville. And this week's original story was written by Russell Hughes. Original music is composed and conducted by Rudy Schrager. And the part of Susie is played by Sylvia Picker. Vern Carstensen is in charge of production. Box 13 is a Mayfair production from Hollywood. Watch for Alan Ladd in his latest Paramount Picture.

End of transcriptBack to the beginning ↑