Skip to content
On Air
All channelsAll
Broadway Is My Beat artwork

From the Broadway Is My Beat collection

The Elaine Hill Murder Case

Episode 031April 21, 195029 min 28 secTranscript

The written record

Read the transcript

Read along with the recording · About 21 min to read

Broadway's My Beat, from Times Square to Columbus Circle, the gaudiest, the most violent, the lonesomest mile in the world. Broadway's My Beat, with Larry Thor as Detective Danny Clover. Broadway, it's a marketplace of the wanderers, the displaced, a glittering bazaar where the stalls are lighted in neon. And you can buy, you buy an identity or a reason or a memory that was stolen from you. You think it belongs to you, but you're wrong. The hawkers of the night sold it, but only for the minutes of the night. More you must buy all over again. It's Broadway, My Beat.

Your squad car stabs, tears, rips through the city, and its wail is a piece of broken glass that slashes across the city's face. And you see the terror, silent and quick, in the blur of the city making way for you. And finally you're there, in the place of the violent dead. It's an expensive room in an expensive hotel, and a dead girl lies sprawled on the floor like an exhausted child. And her dress makes a blob of crimson in the room. There are shadows in attendance, and one detaches itself and clutches onto you and screams.

You'll believe me, won't you, mister? I don't know who you are, but you'll believe me. Someone's got to.

Take your hands off the man, Mr. Jeffers. Don't pay any attention to him, mister. He's greedy. He just wants it all cut and dried. The girl murdered, and he says... I said take your hands off the man. Take your hands off the man. I'll sit down. See, I'm cooperative.

Just sit down and shut up, Mr. Jeffers. That's right. That's a good boy. You must be Clover. I've seen your face, heard your name.

Oh, and you?

Joe Graham, house detective. Don't get me wrong, Clover. I'm usually gentle as a kitten without paying guests. But Mr. Jeffers...

Are you from the police, Mr. Clover? I'm glad. I'll tell you exactly how it happened. I'll tell you everything.

Get back in your chair, Mr. Jeffers. I'll tell a detective.

I don't know. I'd rather hear it from Mr. Jeffers.

Oh, to each his own. Go ahead, Mr. Jeffers. Tell the man the way you told it to me.

I was taking a shower, Mr. Clover. That's all I was doing. I was getting ready to go out to dinner. I'm a salesman, Peerless Leather Goods Company. And I've been with the company for ten years. Badger of merit for my enterprise. Stick-to-itiveness.

You were taking a shower, Mr. Jeffers.

Oh, yes. Well, I dressed. I come out of the shower, and there she was. Just like that. Lying on the floor. Well, I was shocked. I tried to wake her, throw water on her. But she was dead. Choked to death.

How do you know she died that way?

What? The marks on her throat. The bruises. Didn't you see them? You must have seen them.

Who was she?

I never saw her before in my life.

May I? Thank you. Guess, Elaine Hill works in the perfume shop in the lobby. Won a prize for being such a good salesgirl. A week on the town, a plush room in this plush hotel. Everybody in the hotel has seen her and knows her. But not Mr. Jeffers. She's a beautiful girl like Elaine.

I never saw her.

Mr. Jeffers never... How did she get into your room?

The door was unlocked.

Oh?

Yes, well, that doesn't mean anything, does it? I left it unlocked because I'd ordered a drink.

It was brought to you?

Yes. And that's how I can prove I didn't do it. Just at the moment the bellboy brought the drink, he just walked in. Just at that moment, I was coming out of the shower. We found the girl together. Just ask him. That's all you have to do. He can prove I didn't do it.

The bellboy, Graham. Who was he?

Fred Chandler. He said you dispose of him any time you want him.

Keep him that way.

Where's the girl's room?

Down the hall. I'll go with you. Just give me the pass, Keith.

Then you'll believe me. You'll believe I didn't do it. You'll have to be taken to headquarters.

Oh, you can't! You can't do that to me! My reputation! My business! All the years I've worked!

It goes like that. Violent death produces its own afterimages. The people who are suddenly thrown against it are scared, they're cooperative, they're uncooperative, it bores them, depending upon their own attitude toward violence and their own conscience. Milburn Jeffers was screaming when the police let him out of the room. Joe Graham was grinning when he gave me the hotel pass, Keith. Me? The sense of sorrow for a dead girl is a luxury that a policeman allows himself in the moments in between. It took a moment to walk down the corridor to Elaine Hill's room.

She ain't here anymore, mister.

Yeah, I know. So bye-bye. On your feet, friend.

What are you doing here?

Gaze at me and you shall know.

I'm sitting here smoking a cigarette. You gazed? Now on your way.

Police.

Oh? A magic word? You see? I get up, I stand at attention. Have a whim. Go ahead, have one. I'll make it come true. Bellhops get paid for making whims come true. They stick you in this uniform and...

Yeah, and chomp me with your name.

Fred Chandler, bellhop.

Who is it? Fred? Who are you talking to?

Oh. Police.

My name's Danny Clover, Miss... Lee. I'm Anna Lee. I work here, you see? You're a maid?

Oh, no. The cigar counter's where I really work. Downstairs in the lobby.

Okay. I'm on my supper hour.

A supper hour. She's my girl, so she likes to be with me, so she's helping.

Yes, I'm helping Fred. Helping him do what?

Oh, I get it. You're collecting information to help you solve a mysterious crime. I'll unfold it for you. Helping me do what, you say? Helping me pack Miss Hill's clothes.

Who told you to do that?

Elaine Hill. She was checking out. She said, see that my clothes are packed. She give me a dollar. Puts me under obligation. Personal obligation. Now that she's dead, my work still goes on.

Leave her clothes alone. Officer Florio will take care of them.

One more thing, Fred. Quiz me?

Were you in the room when Mr. Jeffers discovered the girl, the dead girl?

Jeffers said that? He said that, huh? He fibbed. He told a big, big fib. I brought in his drink, and there he was, standing over Miss Hill.

Yes. Yes, that's the way it was, Mr. Clover. That's just the way Fred told me it was. Fred's telling the truth. He's not in trouble. Is he?

Fred's not in trouble, Mr. Clover.

Don't worry, Miss Lee. Fred's not in trouble. But keep an eye on him. Keep an eye on each other, huh?

The girl's hand touched Fred's sleeve, and he flicked it away. Then he crossed the room ahead of me, opened the door, and bowed me out. Around Elaine Hill's death, there already grew the fungus of lies, of half-truths. The weeds of a new violence. To tear them out, I needed to know more about Elaine. How she lived, how she worked. There was a man who could tell me part of it. A man named Nicky Laszlo, dealer in perfumes in the lobby.

All I know of Elaine, Mr. Clover, is beauty she was. Employee of myself, but nevertheless beauty. Sheer exquisitastic. In my spare time, I coined new English words.

Mr. Laszlo, I... Pardon me. I want this would be put in the official records.

You keep such records?

Of course you keep. In this country, everybody keeps. Mr. Laszlo... I want you should put in the official records. Put down salt. On the person of Elaine Hill, the perfumes of Nicky Laszlo smelled better than on person of any other person. That, you see, is my eulogy over my poor dead Elaine. Poor publication.

Touching. Change smelled to had more fragrance. That has more sorrow in it. Agreed?

Agreed. There could be sorrow in it for you too, Mr. Laszlo.

Is already. I deserve more.

If you don't answer questions. Directly, without coining new words. Agreed?

This is your country. I am only here on good behavior. Question me, Mr. Clover.

Think back. Did Elaine ever say anything to you? Do anything that might show that she was afraid?

Of being killed?

Of being killed. No. Not once. Except only once. But not, I think, of being killed.

Of what?

She didn't tell me.

Didn't tell you what? Answer me, Laszlo, before I get...

Before you hurt me? I tell you. Last week came call from room... Room 302. Wanted Elaine to exhibit perfume, personally. This 302. Elaine took quickly atomizers. Went and came back. With atomizers. But with tears in her eyes. I asked her, what? She told me nothing. Just cried and blow her nose. That's all.

That's all?

That's all, Mr. Clover. The whole thing. All.

It goes on. Elaine Hill had been called to room 302 to sell perfume. And she returned with a tear. I went back upstairs to the lobby and spotted... Joe Graham. I told him to find out who occupied room 302 last Thursday. It would take some doing, Joe Graham said, because the books were snugged away for the night. But he was just the boy who could find out anyhow, he assured me, because he had influence around here. I assured him that was dandy to let me know. He winked, and I went back to headquarters. I got as far as sitting at my desk.

I shouted you into your office, Danny.

I see you did, Tattaglia. Why did you?

To offer you the hand that helps.

All right. Help me, Tattaglia. Who killed Elaine Hill?

Huh? Who killed Elaine Hill? Danny, you're fighting me. You know, I have a new approach in the solution of, as it were, crimes. You want to hear?

Tell me.

Give out word to the newspapers that you will arrest the criminal at any moment. Only don't say what moment. This makes an emotional person like a criminal emotional. Nervous. And seeing that the die is cast and the vice is turning, he will give himself up... Pardon me, Tattaglia. ...or hang himself. What do you think of it?

Danny Clover speaking. You're sure? Like what? The shave. What are you talking about, Joe? But it's after midnight. The shop's closed. For the juicy news, huh, he said. And he hung up.

It took ten minutes for the squad car to get me to the hotel. In the early hours, the building stood like a sullen pile against the night. The nighttime was beginning to die in the lobby. The dimness had started. The talk more hushed. There was no laughter. Downstairs, the light bled through the lowered blinds of the barber shop. Downstairs, the light bled through the lowered blinds of the barber shop. Downstairs, the light bled through the lowered blinds of the barber shop. And somewhere far away in the world of the bar, a band had settled down to a waltz tempo. I walked to the door of the shop. Opened it. Joe Graham was standing there, back toward me, propped against a corner, a hand resting on a tray of tonics and towels and brushes.

Joe? What's the matter with you? Joe?

He'll never be fixed. The unfelt pain forever stamped on his face told me that. And the unseeing stare and the blood. Joe Graham was dead.

There's a thing about Broadway. At lunch hour, it takes its murder spliced between nibbles on a hot dog and washes them down with cream soda. The deaths of Elaine Hill and Joe Graham were spectacularly headlined, so Broadway nodded approval and reached for the onions. It's these usual things that gives Broadway assurance all's right with the world. The only thing Broadway has to worry about is the hours between now and quitting time.

In my office at headquarters, Sergeant Tattaglia stood in the center of the room, shifted his position a few times, cleared his throat, then asked me a pointed question.

What time is it, Danny?

Why?

Well, no particular reason. This question was just an opening gambit for the conversation which is about to ensue.

You tricked me, huh, Tattaglia?

But, Danny, I've been standing right here before you, trying to catch your attention for ten minutes as the crow flies.

Okay, what is it?

Reports gathered from hither and thither, and yarn into the hair. To wit, the boys from Technical are even now examining the clothes of Elaine Hill for possible clues as to the reason for her decease.

Go on.

In the matter of Milburn Jeffers, the leather goods salesman apprehended at the scene of the crime, also to wit, he is now under the excellent care of Dr. Sinsky.

Oh, what's the matter with Milburn Jeffers?

The occupational disease of all those who are arrested as suspects for murders. He's screaming to let him out of jail. He's screaming he ain't guilty.

He's screaming he's a victim of cruel fate.

So?

The other tenants are complaining about all this screaming. So, between Jeffrey's screaming and the others complaining, our pokey is indeed a veritable mishmash.

Uh-huh. Now, tell me what's news about Fred Chandler.

Of Fred Chandler the bellhop, I have the following report. Fred Chandler has been employed at his current place of business for nigh on to six years. No complaints. As far as can be determined, his story checks.

And his girlfriend from the cigar counter, Anna Lee?

To wit, Anna Lee is his girlfriend. Has enjoyed this status quo for nigh on to two years.

One more item, Tartaglia.

What about the owner of the perfume shop?

His name is Nicky Laszlo.

Tartaglia...

Then Laszlo spent his time amongst the perfume at the time of the crime. Check. But I know something maybe you don't know, Danny.

Like what?

Elaine Hill shared an apartment with a lady who ran the photography salon at the hotel. A lady named Millie Starr. Did you know that, Danny?

Goodbye, Tartaglia.

Tartaglia.

At the photographer's salon, they told me Millie... was on the hotel roof taking publicity stills. On the hotel roof, Millie was doing just that. A small camera dangled from her throat and her mouth was full of pins. A tall girl shivering in a swimsuit or rompers or something or other... had her back to her and Millie was pinning up something or other. Tuck here, tuck there. Three other models tried to arrange their photogenic little features... on the cold asphalt of the rooftop. They were outfitted for a summer in the city on top of a hotel. One strummed a badminton racket. The other waved a canoe paddle. And the third ran languid fingers through the hair of a wax dummy... dressed in McGregor clan shorts and McTavish clan dinner jacket. When the dummy turned out to be a man, I thought it was time to break it up. Which I did by tapping Millie on the shoulder.

Whoever you are, go away. We're busy.

Okay, Taffy, you look real sexy now. Go drape yourself on the legs and I'll shoot you from here.

I'm from the police, Miss Starr.

Take the pins out of my mouth if you want to talk to me.

Huh?

Yeah, pardon me. Thanks. That's good, Taffy. A little more, um, dreamy, that's it. That's it. Now keep it. You, take this reflector and hold it just like this.

Huh?

The reflector. The reflector, like this.

Oh, like this?

Be cheeky and you were born to it. Taffy, take a deep breath. Hold your stomach in. Good. Now relish it. Got it. Now dream somebody else.

Maybe you didn't hear me, Millie. I said I was from the police. Here, you get into your uniform and I'll take your picture. You can put the reflector down. Put it down now. Thanks. Elaine Hill, Millie, they tell me you shared an apartment with her.

Oh, Elaine. Take a break, slaves. You may smoke. That's right. It's just what you think. The law wants me for murder.

Want me for murder, Mr. Policeman?

Maybe, but first let's just talk. About Elaine? I've been trying not to do that. I've been trying not even to think about her.

Why, Millie? Tell me why.

Because you're a policeman. You think you understand? I can try.

Try hard, Mr. Policeman. How do I tell you what Elaine was to me? A child, like a daughter? Sometimes? You know, there's nothing written down anywhere that gives you the right to probe into me like this.

We want Elaine's murderer. You want that too, don't you?

That'll bring her back? You making me an offer? Catch the murderer and that'll bring Elaine back?

How long did you know her?

Not long enough. She came to me about six months ago, wanted to be a model. I wanted to help her. She liked my apartment and I invited her to stay with me. When she got tired of modeling...

Wanted to work steady, she said. So I got her the job in Laszlo's perfume shop. Maybe I shouldn't have done that.

Why do you say that?

She hadn't worked there a week when she started getting letters.

That's unusual.

Not for a beautiful girl like Elaine. You know the kind of letters. Anonymous. Words written in basic English. In some circles, I hear they call them love letters.

You saw them?

No. Elaine always burned them and washed her hands.

You didn't try to trace them? Didn't report them?

No. That was my fault. I told Elaine it wasn't important. Told her it was a kind of flattery. She was so lovely.

The postmark. You must have seen that. Where were they from?

From this hotel. On hotel stationery.

You think...

Call your slaves back, Millie, or you'll run out of daylight.

Danny!

Yeah?

Danny!

Danny!

Okay, okay, here I am. What do you want, Tegler? I'm in a hurry.

Woof!

Huh?

Woof! I'm catching my breath.

What?

I'm glad I caught you, Danny. John Gordon in Technical's been buzzing your phone all the time you are out.

Let's go find out what he wants.

Did he tell you what he wants?

No. Uh-uh. Just called. I answered the phone. He said, was you there? I said no. He hung up. I've been spending half the afternoon listening to stupid conversations like that. Come on.

Hello, Gordon. Something I can do for you, Lieutenant?

Tegler said you've been trying to get in touch with me.

Well, no.

Am I going to have trouble with you, Gordon? Why is it you're never around, Lieutenant? What do you do all day long?

You've been calling to find that out, huh?

I'll tell you why I've been calling. Here. Here. Oh, look at this. Go ahead. Read it.

So, it's an autopsy report from Dr. Sinsky on Elaine Hill. I've already seen it, Gordon. And I know it almost by heart, this part of it. Here. Right here. Elaine Hill was five foot three, blonde hair, no birthmarks, weight 119.

My congratulations on your memory. You really proved it to me. Then why did you send these dresses down here?

For usual reasons. Follow standard operating procedure, kid. Maybe you'll come up with an interesting fact that'll tell me why Elaine... Elaine Hill was killed?

These are not Elaine Hill's clothes. Somebody on your detail loused up, Lieutenant. I thought you should know. Somebody mixed up somebody's clothes with Elaine Hill's clothes. These dresses on my desk would fit a woman who weighed about 160, I'd say. Would be about 5'1", I'd say.

What are you talking about?

Don't make me repeat myself. These dresses cannot belong to Elaine Hill. Who brought these dresses back to headquarters, Mr. Tartaglia?

Officer Florio, Danny. Get him. Get him quick.

Tartaglia did. In ten minutes, Florio was standing in the middle of my office, wiping a crumb off his chin. He was just having a bite, he told me, at the hamburger stand across the street. Yes, he'd packed Elaine's clothes all himself. Neatly. No, he hadn't stopped anywhere for a bite or for anything. He brought the suitcase with the clothes right to headquarters, right to technical, as I ordered. I thanked him, sent him back to finish his bite. Got on the phone. Someone else had handled Elaine's clothes. I needed to talk to him. At the hotel, they told me he wasn't in. Try his rooming house. I did. At his rooming house, they told me... At his rooming house, they told me... They told me he wasn't in. Try Anna Lee's rooming house. I did. On the fourth floor landing, I heard the sobs that came from Anna's room. I knocked. No one answered. So I walked in.

You knocked, Clover. That was nice of you. But walking in? How do you know what can happen to you if you just walk in?

What's the matter, Anna? Why are you crying?

Because... because Fred...

I'll tell you because, Clover. Because I come to take her out. Dinner, a movie, dancing. Anything a little bit. My little heart desires. That's why she's crying. My little Anna's overcome with it all.

Not that, Fred. You know it isn't that.

I want you to look good, honey. I want to be proud of you. When I walk into a restaurant, I want to be proud. Too much to ask.

Get away from her, Fred. She's my girl, Clover. Makes you jealous I'm so close to her.

Get away from her.

With pleasure. Tell me why you're crying, Anna.

Because he wants me to look good. You know how, Mr. Clover?

Hmm?

He brought over a girl's clothes. He's not with me unless I put them on. He won't kiss me unless I put them on.

Don't come near her, Fred.

The clothes. Where are they, Anna?

Over there. On the bed. Wrapped in the newspapers.

Elaine Hill's clothes, Fred?

That girl's clothes!

Elaine's clothes, Fred? I bought them in a hock shop for my girl, Anna. Because Anna's my girl. I want her to look nice, to look classy. Like a dream. Like Elaine?

You couldn't get near Elaine, so you killed her. You wrote her. You wrote her letters, and she never answered, so you killed her. And Joe Graham, because he found out it was you who called Elaine to room 302. Was it like that, Fred?

You're frothing at the brain, Clover. That makes you a mad dog. And the clothes. You stole them after you killed her. Because that was all of Elaine you could own. You stole them and palmed some of them off on the police. They told me the girl was found in a salesman's room. I was there when they told me. You put her there. You strangled her and put her there. Because you knew the door to Jeffrey's room was unlocked, that he was taking a shower and couldn't hear you.

Anna! Give them to me! Your clothes!

Drop the knife, Fred! Drop it!

No more killing, Fred. No more.

You need me anymore tonight, Danny?

Go home, Tartaglia. Come have dinner with us, Danny. With Mrs. Tartaglia, there's always plenty.

Go home.

Yeah, Danny.

For the April evening sighs down on the city like a phosphorescent dream. You walk it slowly, because it's a twilight land. Then fingers claw at your elbow. The face leans close to yours. And the words it whispers are a shriek. It's suddenly night, and the world's exploded. It's Broadway. The gaudiest, most violent. The lonesomest mile in the world. Broadway. My beat.

Broadway's My Beat stars Larry Thor as Detective Danny Clover with Charles Calvert as Tartaglia. The program was produced and directed by Elliott Lewis. The musical score was composed and conducted by Alexander Courage. Included in the cast tonight were Virginia Gregg, Joyce McCluskey, Elliott Reid, Jack Kruschen, Ed Max, and Anthony Barrett.

End of transcriptBack to the beginning ↑