Skip to content
On Air
All channelsAll
Broadway Is My Beat artwork

From the Broadway Is My Beat collection

The Shorty Dunne Murder Case

Episode 055November 24, 195028 min 41 secTranscript

The written record

Read the transcript

Read along with the recording · About 21 min to read

The circle, the gaudiest, the most violent, the lonesomest mile in the world. Broadway is 5B with Larry Thor as Detective Danny Clover.

November night slips down on Broadway, a gust of blackness, and at once Broadway is a neon-lighted revival meeting that screams for the joy and the salvation. Then the happy trumpet yells and makes the music of the nighttime, ebbs into the darkness, drifts and dies. From my window at headquarters I watched it, watched a man detach himself from it, turn and stand for an instant in the shallow pool of light from a street lamp, and consider it. Turn again and up the steps, and in a little while open my door, because you've been told to see me.

Mr. Clover? Come in.

You know all about me, don't you?

Not a thing. Who are you?

What do you mean, not a thing? I'm Mr. Bryant. And?

Well, you know about me, about my wife. Why do you think I was in here yesterday? Told your people a bunch of lies?

You talked to someone else. I didn't know a thing about you.

My wife, she didn't come home. She hasn't come home, Mr. Clover.

I see. You reported a day ago.

Yes, Clara went out the other evening. I waited for her. Billy's been waiting.

Billy?

Three and a half, going on four. The second one, really. Our first child didn't even get born. You see, why did you come to see me, Mr. Bryant?

The man in the other office told me. Please find, please find Clara, Mr. Clover. You've got to come home, Mr. Clover, because the man in the other office said to show you the letter. Here, open it and read it. As you see, the man who wrote the letter says he knows where my wife is. He says his name is Shorty Dunn, and he says, come to the Apollo Hotel. What does that mean, and bring money?

That's strange. It says, come to the Apollo Hotel, but it's written on Mission House Stationery. And bring money. That's why I came to the police again. Although I am worried about my wife, I have my head above me. You, the police, you find her, Clara, and she'll come home to us, then. You fellas are good. Find her. Find her. Find her. Find her.

Suddenly, the spill of words stopped flowing from him. It became a moan. It became the whisper of the helpless. Its component parts, defiance and shame. This was the universal currency of men who must beg, to appease hunger, to barter dignity, to blot out the sudden emptiness. I told him I'd check on it, try to find his wife for him. Talked to the man who had written the letter. He accepted the alms I had given him. Went away.

The Apollo Hotel stands on a corner of the Bowery and sells men's sleep at fifty cents a night. You walk up a flight of stairs, the grit under your feet preaching your presence. And at the landing, a desk moist with the sweat of hands that have bargained across it. In back of it, the man with the green eye shades, the broken, restless fingers, the vendor of sleep.

Go away. We'll fill up every bit in the house.

I want Shorty Dunn. Is he here?

You talk like you've got a right to want somebody.

Police.

Yeah, I know. You know how I know? Because I'm sensitive to the sound feet make on my stairs. Without looking up, I can tell he's a rummy, a wino, a bar. A bum. A cop. You want Shorty, huh?

Yeah.

Imagine that. Shorty finally made it. Somebody wants him. Come on. Bed twelve.

Stressing, ain't it, policeman? The way a man comes in here for four bits worth of sleep and something won't let him. It bothers him?

You'd be astonished how it bothers me. Bed twelve.

Shorty Dunn. Hey, Shorty. Hey, wake up. The Day of Miracles is here. You got a visitor.

Asleep.

Shorty? Well, what do you know about that? He can't hear you, Timmy. Look at him. Like a baby. The jackknife in his heart finally brought it to him.

Yeah. You wanted him, policeman. Take him away so I can sell his bed all over again.

That's how it was that a stir was created in the Apollo Hotel. Jerry Wino was murdered and a respectable housewife disappeared. What element is common to both? Consider now the letter to Mr. Bryan written on Mission House Stationery, 10th Avenue. Go there. And the man is standing there smiling and waiting for you.

I'd like you to come to him. My name is Paul Foster. You're welcome here.

Thanks. I'm Danny Clover, police. I hope there's no trouble. I'm trying to get some information about him.

So many men come in here for a hot meal or a shoe. Friendliness when we feel it will be accepting. A newspaper, little thing. Sometimes even a job. Mostly we try to give away dignity.

You people do wonderful things. What man did you want to ask me about?

Shorty Dunn.

There's nothing I can tell you that's darkening about Shorty. Of course, I can show you a written record on him. He's been rehabilitated about seven times, which is about normal. When did you see him last?

Last night. It was very late. We had no bed for him. He slept at the Apollo Hotel. I'm glad he did. I'd give him a half a dollar to find himself a bed. I'm glad he used it for that.

He was found stabbed to death.

And so that when I hear of death, the lives of these men are repeated. They're dying. I don't know what to say anymore.

He wrote a letter before he walked out of here, didn't he?

That's right, he did. He told me it was very important and I'd give him the stationery and enough stamps to send a letter special delivery. Know anything else about him?

Not much. There's a bar down the street, Goldie's, it's called. Shorty swept out and whatever else needed to be done. Places like that.

And I speak as a lady who's had lookers look at her before. You're Goldie? The one and only.

Since Goldie. You're the one and only. See? But Goldie told me that 'cause I got a heart of gold. And teeth to match what's left of them. See it? Pure gold. My dowry to some lucky gent.

Goldie, I...

You wanna marry me, looker? I've been searching for the likes of you. Told me it's a mission how Shorty Dunn worked here sometimes.

Goldie...

Shut up, lover. Listen. That is our song.

So it is mine. Many a paper reading. When your paper reached up to that?

His dad called it. Murdered. You didn't need to tell me that. I knew about it. The gents brought me word. The lap of my beer and give me the world. Tell me about him.

Your relative?

Police. Danny Clover. That makes your relative. Shorty was an old friend of yours?

My fiancé. Many days stood right there at the bar rail, just where you're standing. He proposed to me on bended knee.

But you didn't marry him?

Shorty? That no good? I take it back. I bite my tongue. There were a lot of nice things about Shorty. Like what?

Like the way he'd buy me a little present sometimes from the empties I gave him to sell.

He worked for you? You paid him?

That wasn't work, relative. To Shorty, it was a labor of love. I had to force my empties on him. That's how he lived. Bought a place to sleep, something to eat. Oh, my. Shorty had other sources of income.

Like what?

Like Joe, the junk man. Shorty sold him things he found in trash cans. You'd be surprised the things people throw away, lover. Where do I find Joe?

Over on the night, toward the river. Have one on the house, Danny. While Goldie goes in the back room and cries.

Same, Joe. Who are you?

You're open pretty late, aren't you, Joe? It's almost 11 o'clock.

They make junk at all hours. They stay in the back room. Stay here and sort it out. Now, who are you?

Danny Clover, police. You got junk?

On your feet, Joe. I'm busy.

On your feet. Stand up. I want to talk to you. You get your 11 o'clock jollies this way? People got to stand when they talk to you?

Want to talk in your backyard or mine?

Talk.

Did you know Shorty Dunn?

Did I know him? I know him. He's been murdered.

So?

You know anything about it?

Look, to me, Shorty was bottles. He brought bottles and I paid him. That's all it means to me that Shorty is dead, that I'm going to have to find someone just as good with bottles. That's all, huh? What do you want from me? What I got here is junk. And who brings it here is junk.

Where did Shorty hang out?

A question. He held out his hand on corners. Who knows what corners? He slept in doorways. He slept at the mission house. He slept in those tenements over there.

Over where?

Two of them, right over there. You can see them if you stand on your toes and look over the fence. Deserted. Condemned. You know, our tenements get like people get.

Over here, Mudwin. If you hadn't answered, I wouldn't have known it was you. A shape, a shadow, something left over.

Let's go.

You looking for something, Danny, in this tenement?

That's why you called me?

Uh-huh. If it's not asking too much.

Something that'll help me find Shorty Dunn's murderer.

The problem?

Something he may have left. Slept here sometimes, the man told me.

Look for it, Mudwin.

Okay, Danny. You take these rooms. I'll go on down the hall.

Yeah.

Not what you expected, huh, Danny?

No. She was strangled. See the flash? Showed up the marks on the throat. I'd say she's been here a night.

A night? Maybe more.

Anything else?

Yeah, there's a purse I found laying beside her. Open it.

Yeah. Compact. There's no money. There's a picture of a little boy. Identification card says Mrs. James Bryan, 1946, wrist 146. In case of accident, notify James Bryan. Isn't this the Mrs. Bryan who was reported missing, the one her husband?

Yeah. That one. She was here all the time. What do you know about that? What do you know?

You are listening to Broadway is My Beat. Written by Morton Fine and David Friedkin and starring Larry Thor as Detective Danny Clover.

There's a time on Broadway when the street has not yet come into its own. The empty hours. The useless hours between dawn and noon. Broadway scrubs its sidewalks. Tries to sweep the hours away to pile them in a gutter. It eyes the unlighted neon. Checks the sleeping masses of the spectacular. Longs for the time of darkness. But the daylight clings. You must find a way of rejecting it, I kid. Brush it. Because what kicks are there when the sun shines down? Except this item, maybe. The item in the paper you picked out of the trash bin. Missing woman found, it says. In condemned tenement. Murdered. And this one. Derelict. Stabbed to death in flophouse. That'll hold you, I kid, to a nighttime. Sure it will.

And at headquarters, a man comes in. Oozing with information. You know that because he tells you.

I'm oozing with it, Danny. Danny? The bits and pieces I got for you.

Why, you'll give them to me, huh?

Naturally. But piecemeal. First, Detective Muggerman has even now picked up Mr. Bryan. They are on their way to the morgue. To identify the deceased.

Well, tell me the rest of the way there, huh, Detective?

If you promise to let me keep up with you.

I promise.

Second, on the person of the deceased Shorty Dunn was found $20. Undoubtedly from the purse of Mrs. Clara Bryan. Go on.

Thirdly, our boys have checked with the manager of the flophouse. He tells them a guy he could never describe bought a bed. Is he? Felt. Registered as Joe Jones. Slept for a while next to Shorty. Got up, walked away. Nobody knows where, nobody cares. Except us, huh, Danny?

Well, what else?

Hey, Danny, not so fast. What else is fourthly?

A list was found in Mrs. Bryan's purse. It appears to our experts to be a shopping list. It so appears to me also.

You got it?

Naturally.

Give it to me.

I had so intended.

It's not necessary for me to go in with you, Danny, into the morgue. It spoils my day. You can go back.

Uh, I can't. Not to me. Not to me.

On a flat, lit by a single bolt. The chill wind that's built into the morgue rocked the light gently. And they appeared each in his turn. A policeman. A dead woman. Her husband. Stark. It needed another quality. Not another spectator. I left.

Now there was a list. Mrs. Bryan had intended to visit four places. Ten-cent store on a side street off Upper Broadway.

A lending library close by. A place called Mildred's Beauty Shop. And a Dr. Johnson. Whether she had gotten to these places or in what sequence, I didn't know. I had to find out.

Yes, sir.

Something I can do for you?

My name's Clover, Mr. Libby. I'm from the police.

Police? That's right.

Why? I mean, why are you here? As a customer or...

I'm a policeman. Some information.

Oh, I'd be glad to, but what information would I have for the police?

Did you know Mrs. Clara Bryan? The woman who was murdered?

Yes. She was in here the other night. The night before last.

What time was that, Mr. Libby?

Oh, I couldn't tell you that. I don't know.

What did she buy?

Well, you can't expect me to remember that. Every item I have in the store, ten cents or twenty-five or a dollar.

You keep a tab from your cash register of your sales.

Oh, yes.

Get it. From the day before yesterday.

All right.

Clara, did you see every item? Ten cents or twenty-five? There's a sale for four dollars and ninety-eight cents. The last item on the tab.

All right. Oh, there. Oh, there. The toy bear. The mechanical bear. I bought a shipment for Christmas. I remember now. Mrs. Bryan bought one for her Billy. That's her son.

Then she must have been your last customer.

She must have been. I closed at seven, but I don't have any idea how near to closing time she left. Not any idea.

Get well, Cart. You run this place alone?

A little bit. Be some type. I asked you to... I got another one coming over. In the nose. Every fall, I clockwork. You'll pardon me when I take my insistence.

You, uh, asked if you ran this place alone.

That's right. Absolutely right. All alone. That matters.

Then you knew Mrs. Clara Bryan.

Not as well as I would have liked. Ever seen her. I mean, before. You've got a point there, mister. Yes, sir. You've got a point. Whenever Clara walked in, it filled the day for me. Maybe lend books to myself to read at night.

What did it do for her?

It was very personal, very adaptive.

Then you'll answer them because you like the way I ask them.

What did she say? What did it do for her, you ask? How would you know about a woman like Mrs. Bryan? I'd pass a remark. You know, they're kind of Mona Lisa-like. Borrow two books instead of one.

That was all?

I asked to give her a book once. Any one she wanted. Any price. She let me walk her home that evening. But didn't take the book. That was the night before last.

Don't crowd me. Not night before last.

But she was here the night before last.

Yes, to return the book. She didn't take another book out.

Did she have anything? Anything with her? A package? A mechanical doll?

Nothing. Just a book and herself.

She noticed. Of course, I'm Mrs. Bryan. I noticed the same. She walked in here.

Which one's your wife? I'll tell her.

I'm from the police.

A bully for you. Which one's your wife?

I want some information from someone named Mildred.

From me? What information?

About Clara Bryan.

Sure, I'll tell you about it. I read the morning papers. Your phone's strangled. You want me to tell you why?

That's right.

Clara was attractive. She was 35 years old, and her hair didn't need touching. Had a nice figure, and she knew it. She thought of it. Had a husband who worked too hard and came home too late.

How do you know all this?

I run a beauty parlor, and it's for women. You all listen to some of them right now? Mrs. Conley's in there telling her hairdresser why sometimes she's sorry she got a divorce.

Did Clara Bryan know any men?

You say it so gently. Women don't say it like that at all. Did she know any?

She loved her husband. What woman doesn't like a man? Look at her. What woman doesn't like to be insulted? But Clara always went to her husband and child.

She was in here the night before last, wasn't she?

Yeah, she was.

How long did she stay?

Just a few minutes. Long enough for me to tell her we couldn't take her. And then she wanted to wash and set.

Do you remember what time it was?

I came back from dinner about 5:30. A little after that. About a quarter to six.

And one more thing. Was she carrying anything?

I think she had a book with her.

That's right, she did. She told me it was a terrible book. Waste of time. And she was returning.

Did she have a toy with her? A mechanical bear?

I didn't notice. Maybe she did.

Do you want anything else? No? Will you pardon me? It's time to take Mrs. Westfall out of the oil.

Mrs. Bryan came for her appointment at six. She was only carrying a book. Nothing else.

Why did Mrs. Bryan have to come to you, a chiropractor?

Mrs. Bryan had trouble with her back. She'd been coming to me for some time now. Aches in her back. I did what I could. I gave her a temporary relief. But, uh, what are you trying to say? I cured the symptoms, but not the source of her trouble.

That doesn't tell me a whole lot.

Well, you understand I'm not a medical doctor. I'm a chiropractor. What I'm going to tell you is only conjecture. The trouble was here. Here in her head, not in her back. I mean, oh, there's a very good word for it. Psychosomatic. But really, she was tired of routine. She'd reached a point in life when she recognized the fact that what she had was all she could do. It was all it was going to be. As far as her life was concerned. She was restless in her mind.

Men, Clara didn't have the heart to do anything like that.

Clara didn't. To call her by her first name. To confess it to her. She knew I was attracted to her. When she left here, she touched my cheek. She would have let me. I would have tried to make her happy.

Excuse me, Mr. Clover. She wouldn't let me. That ended that.

These were the four places Mrs. Bryan had visited before she died. When she had died, she had been in the hospital. When she had died, she had been in the hospital. When she went on to the beauty shop, she had a book. She left there with it. Had gotten rid of it at the next stop, the lending library. Then the six o'clock appointment with the chiropractor. The chiropractor was certain she didn't have the mechanical toy with her. And the man at the ten-cent store was certain he'd sold her one. So the store had been the last stop on the list. Go back there.

Hello there. I see you came back.

That's right.

How are you coming?

With what?

Well, you know, with the murder case. I was reading the papers. I see where you boys found it. You found a bum in the Bowery stabbed to death. This happened while you were looking for Mrs. Bryan, didn't it?

Uh-huh.

You sound tired.

Mind if I look around for a while?

Mm-hmm.

Toy. Quite a collection.

Do you have titties?

Have you made any progress on the case?

Some. Nice toy. Take it with you. Maybe you've got a nephew.

No. No, not a... What do you think the connection is between that bum and Mrs. Bryan?

Pretty obvious.

Obviously, you boys. Not to a ten-cent store man like... Like this. Our technical boys tell me Mrs. Bryan wasn't strangled in the tenement. It's some other place. He was killed and then brought to the tenement.

You figure the bum killed her, huh?

I read where he had $20 in his pocket. Motive was robbery, hmm?

No. What happened is... I see you're staring at my $4.98 item. Those mechanical bears. You like them?

What happened is this. Our bum, Shorty, was about to bed down for the night in the condemned tenement. He found Mrs. Bryan. Mrs. Bryan's body. Opened her pocketbook. She was. Took her money and ran.

You boys. The letter had just flipped, Mrs. Bryan. He watched Shorty do all that. Followed Shorty the rest of his life. Saw him write a letter at the mission.

A letter? I didn't read anything about that.

The killer must have seen that the letter was addressed to her husband.

Hmm. Well, how did you figure that without seeing what happened and all?

It's the only way it makes sense.

Gee, I don't know. I picked my theory. I still think the bum killed her.

Oh, you're wrong, Mr. Libby. Shorty didn't kill her. The killer followed Shorty to the Apollo Hotel and killed him because he thought that the reason Shorty had written to Mr. Bryan was to tell him he knew who had murdered his wife.

He really didn't know this.

Everybody else knows.

I didn't. All the attention I pay the people is what they buy. I have a living to make.

How many of these $4.98 mechanical bears did you order?

Uh, six.

There's still six here on the shelf.

What's that got to do with anything?

He sold one to Mrs. Bryan. Remember?

What?

But he stored it. After you killed her, you put it back on the shelf.

She looked promises at me. When I grabbed her packages for her, she'd stand close to me. And when I looked at her, she'd turn around and walk away. The other night, the other night she looked tired. I invited her in the back for coffee. She said, all right. She went back and slouched down in my chair. I looked at her. I brushed her hair back. From the cheek, she tottered a scream.

Something happened. The hunger complete with eight beats of rhythm and spinning. Grab yourself a dream and dance a while. Close your eyes. Make believe you've got your arms around something good. You can close your holding as Broadway, the gaudiest, the most violent, the lonesomest mile in the world. Broadway.

You've been listening to some of the best in radio drama. With Deborah McGee and Molly, and Broadway is My Beat. Join us again Monday evening at the same time, 9:05, when FDN presents Dragnet and Escape.

End of transcriptBack to the beginning ↑