Skip to content
On Air
All channelsAll
Broadway Is My Beat artwork

From the Broadway Is My Beat collection

The Alice Mayo Murder Case

Episode 114May 24, 195227 min 46 secTranscript

The written record

Read the transcript

Read along with the recording · About 21 min to read

Broadway's My Beat, from Times Square to Columbus Circle. The gaudiest, the most violent, the lonesomest mile in the world. Broadway's My Beat, with Larry Thor as Detective Danny Clover.

In the soft night of May, Broadway's heart beats fast. The winds of twilight have scattered the street where their promises have drifted back into the river. And the avenue is glitter, and the throats of women are spangled with the quick jewels of night lights. Their perfumed walk is promise. The hawker is promise. That neon doorway, the muted trumpet, the frenzied drum that rides the trailing edge of twilight wind, promise. There is much to be said for that neon doorway. So dig deep for the buck, kid, and buy a May night. It's a chance in a lifetime.

And at headquarters, the time for the sifting, the recording, the cataloging of the day's violence. The time for the cigarette and the coffee, cold in the wax container. Then the time for going home. Stop at the open. I look out the window a moment to consider the glow and nuance of a May night, decide to try it, and not know where to start.

And Detective Mugovan poses a question.

Going home, Danny?

Well, not right away. I thought I'd walk around a while. It's a nice night.

Yeah, it sure is. You doing anything?

Dr. Sinski phoned a little while ago, said the night was made for pinochle. Said if we didn't have anything else, we were welcome. Want to go?

I don't know. I thought I'd walk around a while, grab a bite.

Mrs. Sinski puts out a nice snack table around midnight.

Yeah, she does. They're fine people. Only I...

Only not tonight, huh? Tonight's the night for walking the street you walked a million times before till you're ready to drop. That's how you're gonna rock yourself to sleep tonight, huh?

I feel like taking a walk, Mugovan. You gonna make a cause out of it?

No, I haven't got the energy. Me? Comes a night like this, I got a way figured to use it up. The Sinski cure. Pinochle.

I got it, Dad. Detective Mugovan speaking. What? Hold it a minute. Don't go away, Danny. Homicide. Yeah. Go ahead, mister.

Man murdered. 1237 West 18th Hotel. Second floor rear. Wait a minute. Mister, who are you? Who's making this report?

He hung up, Danny.

Come on, Mugovan.

The mister was obviously disguising his voice, Danny. He wouldn't tell me who he was.

We'll get to that later. Ten after nine on a May night and a man calls to tell you another man's been murdered. For you, no walk. Me, no pinochle.

Pull through the door, Danny.

45 to do that.

Yeah, it could. Open it, Mugovan.

Seated in the middle of the floor, a woman was there and the man who held her, his face gentle, his fingers trailing lightly through her hair, his voice...

Not to you, Alice. You're not dead.

...his voice gently pleading against the staff he held in her arms. I'll hold you close so you can get...

The woman he held in her arms. You won't be dead anymore. The dead woman. Alice, baby. Not dead. Okay. Alice.

You too. Who are you?

Police.

Police? That gives you the right to walk in like this?

And Alice, this way. Someone called in and said a murder had been committed. We figured that gave us all the right we need.

Someone called? That's right. They said a man was killed. They gave this.

A man. No man was killed here. Not at this address. Only my wife. Only Alice. He said you could let her go. She's my wife. This is Alice, my wife. She needs me now.

Maybe she did once. Now there's not a thing you can do for her.

No. No. There isn't, is there? Strangers in your town. Complete strangers. Just beginning to get acquainted with people. And what's your name?

Wouldn't mean anything to you. I made a lot of names for myself.

Want to tell us what happened, Mr. Merrill?

Go ahead, tell us. She'd have to stay there on the floor. Move her someplace where she would.

You were going to tell us what happened, Mr. Merrill?

We had our dinner. We were sitting around, listening to the radio. And what? Rang our bell. Alice went to the door. Before she had a chance to open it, there was this shock. All she could say to me was that over and over.

Your wife knows someone named Ernie, Mr. Merrill? Who is Ernie? Your kid? A friend? Who?

Ernie Britt. Alice and I met at the Regency Friendship Club. We were walking out of the park in Columbus Circle one night when we first got here. There was a sign. We went up. There was Ernie. He introduced himself and he danced with Alice. They danced real nice together.

And after that, they became good friends?

Friends? I didn't say that. I didn't say friends. Ernie's a guy my wife and I met that night. And she kept bumping into on the street, in the grocery store sometimes. When she came home, told me Ernie was sitting next to her in the movie. He bought her a candy bar. That doesn't make her his friend.

You know where this Ernie lives?

No. Why should I care where he lives? All I know is that he lives in the city. All I know is that he lives in the city. All I know is I met him at the club and he danced with Alice. Followed her around. She said his name when she died.

Ernie Britt, huh?

The drive through the night streets. Quiet at first, where its avenues are lined with brownstone and stoops and families. Silent and close. Touched by the May night of the city. And nearer to Broadway now, the beginnings of crowd and the fast walk and the colored shadows. Take a night and ride it. Into the funnel of people and noise and riot. The adventure. The adventure now of driving up Broadway. Ride the brake and defer to jaywalkers, sightseers and taxi cabs. At Columbus Circle Park. Get out. And find a place and open a door.

Not far. Short flight of steps. Walk through an open doorway. It's a jukebox. There were two card tables together. Festooned with a pink paper tablecloth and a cut glass punch bowl and a crepe paper sign tacked to the wall above it. Welcome stranger, it said. You're our friend. These and the dozen. These and the dozen dancers with their names printed on paper hearts pinned to their bosoms.

And the lady who seemed to be in charge of it all.

And the next dance will be a tag dance. Dance in couples and the men will tag one of them. The left over may tag any man of her choice. Please put a dime in the machine.

Good evening.

Oh, you're new. I haven't seen you before. You just go out there and tag away and later I'll be happy.

I'm the police. My name's Danny Clover.

That's quite all right. Thank you. Only I'm here on business.

Look, Mr. Clover. We've got the makings of a fine party going here tonight. The place is filling up, so don't blouse it. Just make your arrest of whoever you're looking for in a gentlemanly manner and get out.

I'm looking for a man named Ernie Britt. Is he here?

Uh-uh.

You mean he was here and he left, is that it?

Yes, sir. And he hangs around here a lot. You know.

No, I don't. He likes to meet people. He hangs around, thinks of games to play. You know.

Where'd he go?

Well, he dropped in to tell me, oh, I guess a couple, three hours ago he wouldn't be here tonight. He said he had a big date at nine o'clock. A girl named Alice. Nice name. Four people named Alice come here.

Ernie must have liked this Alice, all right.

You know where Ernie Britt lives?

No, I don't. But that Ernie must have liked this Alice, all right.

Oh? Indeed he. Called up a florist while he was here, ordered a bed of roses, said he'd pick them up at 8:30. Then he made another call. Made an appointment with a barber down the street. Oakley's two bucks for a bar. I tell you.

Yeah, you did. Thanks a lot.

Have a seat. I'll be with you in a minute. As soon as I finish Mr. Garson's scalp massage.

Oh. Police badge does it, mister. How can I help?

You know a man named Ernie Britt?

Sure. He was in a while back. Haircut, shave, shine.

Is that all I have to do? I just want to make sure he was here.

Oh, he was here, all right. Did he say where he was going?

Came in here with a big smile and told me to make him look desirable for Alice, whoever she is, date. He mentioned a time. Nine o'clock?

That's right. He was planning to do it up brown. Guess this Alice was something special.

How do you mean?

Flowers and all. Called the florist from here and said he wouldn't pick up the bed of roses. Send them to his place instead. Told the florist he wanted them there at no later than a quarter after nine.

You know where Britt lives?

Sure. Sure. I went there a couple of times to barber him. On 112th Street. 320, fourth floor back.

Is that all?

That's all. Thanks. Sorry to keep you waiting, Mr. Garson. Now, where were we?

Your name Ernie Britt?

Mister, it's midnight already. How come you're pushing doorbells at this time?

Police. What about it?

Am I interrupting anything?

I only asked because I just took a fast look over your shoulder. Flowers, wine.

Yeah, there used to be a party here. It's over. What do you want, mister?

You know a man named Fred Mayo?

What about him?

I got a phone call a few hours ago. An anonymous caller gave me his room number, said we'd find a dead man there.

I didn't kill him. I can...

I know you didn't. He said so himself. That part of it. He's not dead.

Well, that's right, Mr. Britt. He's in fine shape, not a scratch. Just grieving, that's all.

What are you talking about?

At a little after nine o'clock tonight, his wife was murdered. Alice Mayo is dead.

Al, you're lying. It couldn't have happened.

Broadway's My Beat, written by Morton Fine and David Friedkin, and starring Larry Thor as Detective Danny Clover.

What can you do with two cents? Not much? Don't you believe it. Because for two cents a year, you, as an American taxpayer, are helping to dissolve ignorance, prejudice, and intolerance throughout the world. You are doing this through UNESCO, the United Nations Educational, Scientific, and Cultural Organization. More than half of mankind, one billion, two hundred million men, women, and children, can neither read nor write. These are the people who are also poor, ill-fed, and have a life expectancy of under 30 years. And it is toward these people that UNESCO is directing much of its educational efforts. Because everyone knows that ignorance is not bliss. You are a part of the great work being done by this United Nations agency. And it costs you only two cents a year.

A rumor gets around that summer is almost here. Broadway is beside itself with glee. Somebody notices the moonlight of May, uses it as a backdrop to an early dream, tells a girl about it. Who tells a guy. And the word gets round. It drifts across town, causes reactions, closets open, as do chiffoniers. And the cotton dress and the sports shirt and the sandal constitutes the current uniform. And the poodle is clipped and sashed. The ankle is silken. The shoulder is soft and starting to tan. Also the boy in the crew cut who runs down the street screaming, I'm in love. It's May. It's the right time.

Except for some people. Those who at time had caught up with, conspired against, to make the sum total of all the minutes an instant of shock. This man, Ernie Britt in this room, shaking his head against it.

I can't believe it. I just can't believe it.

Let's go inside, shall we?

What's all right?

I made up my mind to just stand here until you get around to believing it, mister.

What for? Did you kill her?

I'll rephrase it so you can understand it better. Did you ring her doorbell? Then when you heard someone at the door, did you shoot through the door and kill her? That's the way she was killed.

You had a date with her tonight, didn't you?

How do you know?

You left word every place you were that you were going to see a girl named Alice tonight at nine. Mrs. Mayo's name is Alice. You met her at an introduction club. You followed her around. Tonight you had a date with her. Right here.

Yeah, she didn't show.

Which means you have no alibi for nine o'clock. Where were you at that time?

Right here. But without Mrs. Mayo, so you've got no way of proving it.

You knew she was married, didn't you?

I didn't.

A girl who knew her own mind. Forced myself on anybody.

What about the man who called me a few minutes after nine and said, and told me a man was murdered?

How many guesses do I get?

Just one. Try Ernie Britt.

I didn't call anybody.

Why did you kill her, Ernie?

You know something? She isn't dead.

...on town. Book him on suspicion of the murder of Alice Mayo.

Then walk down a corridor that leads into two o'clock of a May night on the threshold lightest cigarette. Then edge into it. The two o'clock time, the squalls of mist, the scarlet of neon bleeding into pavements wet with nighttime, the river sounds, and the tremble of earth as a subway train pierces it. And the man, sodden with loneliness who stops you, asks for a small loan, offers you the security of a name written on the two o'clock mist. Give it to him. Maybe he'll mention your name where sleep is.

The next morning, go back to the man on whom you'd intruded once before while he held death close and spoke softly to it. Go back to him.

When can I take her home, Mr. Clover? I've made all the arrangements with the railroad people. Now it's up to you people. But when are you gonna let me take Alice home?

We'll let you know, Mr. Miller.

What do you people want with her? She's dead. A bullet tore her open. What else do you want from her? What good is she to you? Tell me.

You through, Mr. Miller?

Yeah. Yeah, I'm through. Like you will never know. We need the report of the medical examiner, ballistics, laboratory technicians, police photographs.

Yeah, I know. Complicated. Must be real complicated the things you have to do about my wife.

We want her killer. Doing these things might help us find her.

Okay, I'll wait. I'll wait until you give me the word.

Tell me a little about yourself, Mr. Miller.

I got a wife that's newly dead. That's about me. When I get back to Baltimore, people are gonna stop me on the street to shake my hand. And they'll wipe a tear with a piece of tissue and then they'll throw it in the street. That's about me. That's about Fred Mayo. Baltimore was your home?

Born there. Grew up there. Alice lived in a fancier section, Forest Park, and I married her in spite of the fancy competition.

When did you come to New York?

When did... I don't know. Maybe three months. Three months ago. Maybe not. I don't remember. Yeah, three months and a week, maybe.

Why did you come here? Are you rubbing it in, Mr. Clover? You're gonna say to me, if we never came, Alice would...

It's a simple question, Mr. Mayo. Why did you come here?

The outfit I worked for transferred me to their New York office, Ruxton Enterprises Novelties. Alice got all gay about it. Big deal, New York, she told me. That's why we came. Big deal. And it was hard to make friends. You went to that social club. That's how gay it was. Tag dances, crummy punch, strangers with sweaty hands. It brought Alice down. So I sent her back to Baltimore for a couple of days at her mother's house.

When?

Over Mother's Day weekend. Out of her system. Try it again.

Now look, Mr. Clover, you'll give me the word as soon as you can, huh?

Soon as we can. You'll wait for it here, huh, Mr. Mayo?

Baltimore came through with flying colors, Danny. I salute Baltimore. Will you join me?

Whatever you say, Gino.

I say a salute and a flourish for the monumental city under Chesapeake and for their police force of like stature. And in the same geographical location they have responded to our desires post-haste.

With what, Gino?

With information that meant the couple Fred and Alice Mayo, that they were respected citizens, lived a life without a blemish, not once mentioned in the islands of the police blotter. No names to conjure with Mr. and Mrs. Mayo until this.

Until what?

Until this clipping from a Baltimore newspaper which was included among the other favors in Baltimore.

Hmm?

A loose photograph of an unidentified guest rescuing Alice Mayo from a blazing Baltimore in Inferno.

Let me see it.

Here, look on it, Danny. And consider how heroes are born on the minute by the minute. Consider the bravery of a man who, through smoke and flames...

Consider something else, Gino. The date.

May 12th.

Oh, Danny, I hold it in fond memory. This day was Mother's Day. A day on which I presented Mrs. T, the mother of my chick...

Then consider another thing.

There's more?

The man carrying Mrs. Mayo. I repeat, a hero. Presumably a husband.

Yeah, a hero. Only it's not her husband.

What? Danny, you said...

Do another thing for me, Gino. Call Dr. Sinsky. Tell him to meet me at the morgue right away.

Dr. Sinsky. What's this all about, Danny?

Doctor, how was Alice Mayo killed? Specifically?

That's right. A bullet of large caliber which entered the pericardial cavity, smashing first the sympathetic nerve...

All right, all right, all right. What killed her? Make up your mind how you want the question answered, Danny. I'll be happy to give it to you as medical examiner, as friend...

Let's take a look.

Danny...

All right, let's take a look. Enough of a look? You're sure this bullet wound killed her?

Yes.

All right, then. Look for a bruise. A what? Something, anything. Anything that would... made her unconscious before she was shot. Go ahead.

Danny.

Something?

Here, her scalp. Container's bleeding. It's...

Recent?

I'd say 15 minutes, a half hour before she was killed. I'm sorry, Danny. This would have turned up later. Maybe tomorrow, but I'm sorry.

You remember Detective Muggerman, don't you?

Hi. Come on in.

News for me?

Yeah. A lot of news. I can take Alice home now, huh?

I'm afraid not, Mr. Mayo. Something happened. A hitch. A great big one.

What's he mean, Mr. Clover? Baltimore's son, huh? Good paper. What's he mean, Mr. Clover? A great big one. A great big what? You subscribed to the son since we left Baltimore. What's he mean?

Here's what I mean. Look at this picture, Mayo. Never have nerve enough to go back to my hometown. You've seen it before, haven't you? He's caught up with me in New York, so... I'll move to California. That's all?

That's all the picture does to you, huh?

I'm ashamed of it. Is that what you wanted to hear?

That's not what we want to hear. We want to hear the man's name who's saving your wife's life. We want to hear what she's doing in that fire when she was supposed to be staying with her mother. You know, you know.

Ernie Britt, Mayo? That's who it is?

Well, he saved her life, didn't he? They love each other? Your wife and Ernie?

No! No, she didn't love him.

I've been thinking about it, Mr. Mayo. But I can't figure out a motive why she didn't love him. Why Britt killed your wife?

Yeah. A hero. Saved her life in Baltimore. Then shot her through a door. You know, Danny, maybe it was a mistake.

Yeah, it could have been. Mayo, did you know Britt had a date with your wife last night? At least that's what he spread around town. Florist, barber, introduction club, everybody knew. If I had a date with another man's wife, I sure wouldn't spread it around. Unless it's the custom nowadays, I wouldn't know.

I knew. She told me.

It's the custom, huh?

No, no. It wasn't that. The only thing I can figure is this, Mayo. Your wife set up a thing with Britt. Then she got sorry about it and made a confession to you. She was sorry. She was sorry about the whole thing, the way she carried on.

They were gonna kill you, weren't they?

He doesn't understand me, Danny. You ask him.

Like this, Mayo. Britt and your wife planned to kill you. They needed an alibi for nine o'clock last night. So Britt told everybody he was going to be with your wife at his place. That way, they'd alibi each other. An alibi that could have held.

I know all that. She told me all that. She told me. And I forgave. We were even going to leave New York and start all over again someplace. I even quit my job. You can check that.

But the point still bothers me, Mayo.

Yeah, that's the point that bothers me too, Danny. Your wife knew that Britt was going to shoot through the door at nine o'clock and that Britt was going to call the police to establish the time. Yet she answered the door at nine o'clock. And got shot to death at nine o'clock by Britt. He's facing a murder charge like you planned it. Your way of getting rid of both of them.

Listen to me. I'm a man who comes from a respectable family. I'm known in Baltimore, all over, got lots of friends. What do you think my friends said after they saw that picture? She told you everything. Apologized. You forgave her in your own way. You slugged her and propped her up in front of that door. Sure. Because what do you think they'll say now? That Fred Mayo, he doesn't mess around. His wife did a thing like that. You can't fool with Fred Mayo. That's what they'll say.

Yeah, Mayo. He'll be a big man in Baltimore. Let's go.

Minutes before dawn, Broadway lies huddled in a dreamless sleep. It's the time of no stars and a silent wind. But walk the streets, take the slow walk, and listen. It's there. Oh, that night time will never leave. It's Broadway, the gaudiest, the most violent, the lonesomest mile in the world. Broadway, my beat.

Broadway's My Beat stars Larry Thor as Detective Danny Clover, with Charles Calvert as Tortaglia and Jack Kruschen as Mugovan. The program was produced and directed by Elliot Lewis, with musical score composed and conducted by Alexander Courage. In tonight's story, Whitfield Connor was heard as Fred Mayo. Featured in the cast were Betty Lou Gerson, Lamont Johnson, and Joe Forte.

End of transcriptBack to the beginning ↑