Skip to content
On Air
All channelsAll
Broadway Is My Beat artwork

From the Broadway Is My Beat collection

The Mary Trevor Murder Case

Episode 136October 25, 195230 min 36 secTranscript

The written record

Read the transcript

Read along with the recording · About 22 min to read

Broadway's My Beat, from Times Square to Columbus Circle. The gaudiest, the most violent, the lonesomest mile in the world. Broadway's My Beat, with Larry Thor as Detective Danny Clover.

The wind of October begins its departure from Broadway, scatters the brown leaves of regret before it, piles them high at this corner and that, and the mob turns up its coat collar, drifts the autumn street and looks for a friend. And looks, sees only the two-hour dream promised by the theater marquee, sees warmth on the other side of the plate glass windows, and sees this, the girl with the soft fur held close to her throat, covering her face right up to her eyes. And where she was is chillness. That was October, image and farewell.

Get moving, kid.

And an evening above it, the place of no seasons, Hospital Corridor, where I was, and Detective Marguerite.

What about it, Danny? Is she gonna live?

Dr. Sinski doesn't know. At least he says he doesn't know.

He knows. A girl stabbed like that, she hasn't got a chance.

Mind if we sit down here on this bench and smoke?

No. Just run it down for me, Marguerite. The subway guard, Times Square, said it was ten o'clock, give or take a couple of seconds, that he heard a scream. Local train had stopped, people getting on and off, rush, you know. So a girl screamed. Do you think the people stopped rushing to see what was the matter? No, they kept right on.

Come on, Marguerite, just tell me. The guard battled his way through to where the girl was. The girl screamed, she had a knife in her.

Yeah. Couldn't tell if she'd been on the train and was getting off or what. They called emergency ambulance, got her here about a half an hour ago.

No witnesses?

No, the usual crop. Each with a story of the way they figured it happened. Nothing.

Identification?

Lots of that. Wallet, usual stuff. Oh, here, wait a minute. Here, I wrote it down for you. Mary Trevor, 1212 West 37th.

What else?

She was carrying an overnight bag, Danny. She'd been away or was going away for a day, two nightgown underthings, slippers, you know the stuff. A novel to read, a couple of women's magazines.

She had a nice vacation, huh?

Who is it?

Police. Information. Talk. About Mary Trevor.

Plop yourself anywhere, mister, you'll excuse how I am. I was in the tub with a warm bath, reading the paper and listening to the radio. Tough day today, the warm tub relaxes me, music likewise.

I see.

Yeah, sure you see. So, okay, so now you killed it for me, what's with Mary?

She's in police emergency hospital, she's dying.

Mary got hurt? Hit by a car, what?

Someone tried to kill her.

Mary? She's on a subway platform at Times Square. Someone stabbed her, ran. We found this address on her.

You found this address on her because this is where she lives sometimes. This is her home sometimes. Sometimes she remembers I'm her father. Those are the times when she yawns, asks me how things are going, where I work, goes to sleep in her room. I can count the times on the fingers of my hands.

Tell me. What do you know about her, Mr. Travers?

What do I know about her? This is her private hotel, these three rooms. I'm not her father, I'm her desk clerk, her bellboy. I take messages for her, send out her cleaning press and rustle up night snacks for her. And you know what?

No.

She leaves tips for me on my dresser when she goes out.

Yeah, five or ten spots. You know something else? I take it. I use it for get-loaded money, forget money. Did I get more Father's Days than any father?

In the world.

Someone tried to kill her, Mr. Travers. Maybe you could...

Don't ask me too much about Mary. I don't know about her life, so I wouldn't know about her death.

Well, her friends, people she ran around with, men, girlfriends.

Doesn't get through to you, huh? Unbelievable, huh? Well, I'll lay it out for you. This girl stopped being my child maybe five years ago. After that, we couldn't find anything in common. We'd get lost in different worlds.

She had a bag with her when we found her, a traveling bag.

She ran in here a couple of nights ago, said she was in a big... He threw her things in a bag, told me she was going out of town, not to wait up. Don't question me where, mister, because I knew better than to ask her.

You said she left money for you, fives and tens. She must have a good job.

You could call it a job if you want.

Tell me about it.

Mary's got a rich friend. Rich girlfriend. My Mary does things for her, like sponge. I think the word is...

That's the word, sponge. You know who she is, where she lives?

Joan Hunt, Park Avenue. I checked once, found it in a phone book. Mary wasn't lying. There was such a girlfriend. Now, you do something for me, mister, the address where my kid's dying, I want to go to it. Maybe now I can get through to it.

So I leave there, out into the street. And the street is filled with the near midnight silences and pockets of yellow of the street lamps. Night street, a zone of almost black and a few swift-ebbing figures. And the sudden dart of car. The faraway lights were other people's laughter. And the street lights were other people's laughter.

So go to the apartment now, to the few intimate things among the furnishings that come with the rent. And this is home and sleep. And morning comes suddenly. It screams at you, open your eyes, and it blinds you. Morning happens every day. And some morning years from now, you'll be used to it.

Up now, the shave, the shower, the coffee, the street, work to do. Call headquarters and give Detective Mugavera my route for the day. First stop, Park Avenue.

This morning's Park Avenue. This morning's Park Avenue maid wears gray silk and white collar. And her curtsy is not much at all. But her smile is. Takes your name to her mistress, Joan Hunt. Comes back, takes you, leaves.

And Joan Hunt is in tailored slacks and tailored blouse. And her makeup is color geometry applied to the precise planes and arcs and ovals of her face. She sits erect and attentive. And the chrome of her wheelchair gleams circularly.

Good morning.

Good morning. Have you had coffee?

Yes. Yes, thank you. It's about Mary Trevor.

Yes?

She's dying.

That's a shame.

It happened on a subway. She was stabbed.

And?

Miss Hunt.

Yes?

The police are interested in finding out who did it.

You must know I realize that. I saw Miss Trevor's father last night. He told me there was sort of relationship between you two.

Precisely what?

He said his daughter sponged off you.

She did?

I'm sorry, Miss Hunt, but...

Like this, Mr. Clover. I was injured. Some years ago. It was a ski jump. Since then, there have been friends. Boys. Girls. They come to read to me. One after another. And we discuss. That's my life now, you know. I sit here and I discuss with whoever is current. Let me put it this way. I support whoever is current. It's all very smilingly brave and gay, but I pay for it. And the latest on Mary Trevor? This afternoon when the news gets out, my doorbell will ring. There'll be someone else. No comment. A college chum. A friend I haven't seen in years. Someone who's been here to a party last week. Someone.

I see. Perhaps I can help you, Mr. Clover. I've something of a story which may or may not attend what has happened.

I'd like to hear it.

Monday, Mary left with my fiancé.

Oh, not the obvious, Mr. Clover. I'm much too rich for anything like my fiancé's running off with someone else. You'll want his name, won't you? Robert Gray. Go on. They left for Lake Champlain Monday. They and another couple, a Mr. and Mrs. Nelson, to fix up my lodge, our honeymoon cottage. Shall I tell you about that?

Yes.

It has 20 rooms, four of which have been closed off to give the atmosphere of roughing it. It's near a small town with a stupid name, Rouse's Point, near the border. I will permit a honeymoon there, and I shall come back to this house and never leave it.

Have you seen your fiancé?

Neither him nor the Nelsons since Monday. Millie phone calls late yesterday that they were in town.

Now, what else do you want?

The Nelsons' address and Robert Gray's address.

I'll get them for you. And then, if you don't mind, will you please leave? Whatever it is you want of me, make it brief, hmm? Let's not make a crease of it.

Crease, that's crisis in case you don't know.

I didn't know.

You stated it simply enough. Mary Trevor is dying, you said, of knife wounds. And what do you want of me?

Just this, Mr. Gray. Did you try to kill her?

No. No, I wouldn't, you see.

Tell me about it.

I wouldn't, you see, because once I loved Mary Trevor.

And now you don't, and suddenly she's knifed on a subway platform. Tell me when you stopped loving her, Mr. Gray.

I could tell you the precise moment. Do that. Less than a month ago, I sat in a bistro in Paris. On the table before me was an aperitif. Amber. Amber in color. And my visitor's visa to America. I sat and sipped, and I culled through half-forgotten memories. High among them was Mary Trevor.

You said a visitor's visa.

Exactly. Thirty days have I in the country of my birth. Here, I'll show you. My papers, the visa, my birth certificate, my passport. French passport, as you see, because I'm a French citizen. Oh, look at them. It happened to me what they say in the travel. I saw Paris. I tasted of Paris. I went on my knees to her, begged for citizenship. Got it.

What brought you back, Mr. Gray?

A longing. In Paris, I lived on small articles to the Tribune about American tourist behavior and customs abroad. Now, here I shall live on small articles to the Paris Tribune, behavior and customs of the Americans at home.

Until you married Joan Hunt, that is.

You asked for the moment when I fell out of love with Mary Trevor. I called her when I arrived. We had cocktails and old remembrances. And then she took me to Joan to display me. I saw Joan. At that precise moment, I loved Joan and no longer Mary.

Miss Hunt is very rich.

Miss Hunt is helpless and lonely and crippled, and I love her, and I'm going to marry her.

Touché, Mr. Clover.

You went to Miss Hunt's lodge with Mary. To prepare, Joan's in my place of honeymoon. Clean it up.

With Mary. And with Dickie and Lucy Nelson. Very proper. Very corny affair. Dickie and Lucy are giddy idiots, but they're respectable folk. As was Mary. As was I.

When did you see her last?

When my cab dropped in Nelson's office apartment. Then Mary offered a subway station uptown. I kissed Mary's forehead, and our forever parting was graceful.

Now, if you...

Never mind, Mr. Gray. I'll get it. Hello? Yeah, Markovan, what do you want? I'm here at the hospital with Mary. All right, write down what she said. I'll get Gray. It's for you, Mr. Gray.

Who?

Mary Trevor. She wants to talk to you.

You going to take the call, Mr. Gray?

Yes. Yes, I am.

Mary? It's me. It's Robert. I'm deeply sorry, but... Mary? Mary?

Playful joke, Mr. Clover. There's no one there.

Give me the phone. Hello? Hello, Markovan?

Yes.

You are listening to Broadway's My Beat. Written by Morton Fine and David Friedkin. And starring Larry Thor. As Detective Danny Clover.

When you set about explaining how democracy works, the first thing you're apt to mention is that it's the system where everybody has his say on how things are run. It's pretty embarrassing, then, to be reminded that in the 1948 election, only half the eligible voters in this democracy went to the polls to say their say. For our own sakes, and to show the world in general that the democratic ideal can be fulfilled, let's do better this time. Vote as you please this November, but vote. See you at the polls.

October's dying is of gold and of an autumn leaf that floats a river spilling in the winter seas. And for Broadway, too, it is the gentle time, the slow curve of light that bends from brilliant summer glint, bows, dissolves into chill grays. Indian summer mists into autumn smoke. The time of the early afternoon stroll and the swift appraisal of winter's mannequins, the drawing of a picture of a man, the drawing of lots in the football pools, and the newest emotion, movies in three dimensions.

The good time, the gentle time. So walk the late October street, kid, before it's pulled out from under you. And the place where I was, high above the autumn city, 30 stories away from flow and sound of East River, the place of Dickie and Lucy Nelson, where there was fireplace, Grecian figurines, and where the talk was of a dead girl, Mary Trevor.

Tell him, Dickie. Tell him, sweet, how desolate we are over the girl.

Mary was a companion, Mr. Clover. A boon companion. Often made us laugh till tears, Lucy and me. Can you understand our sense of loss?

She made jokes and you'll miss them, is that it?

Now that you've asked, yes, we'll miss them.

Dickie?

Yes, dear?

Is it too possibly early for a martini? I feel the need of something. I don't quite know what.

You think, martini? The chap has a mission, dear. Later after he's gone.

Whatever you say, sweet. It's just that I'm so drained. That gay, gay frolic at Joan's place. Now the reaction's setting in. Drained.

Listen. Tell me about it, Mrs. Nelson. About what? The gay time you had at Joan Hunt's place.

Fake champagne was never lovelier. Sweet. Will you ever forget that odd little native fellow who helped us get Joan's place ready for a honeymoon? Will you ever forget that thing he said about the canopied bed?

Never. Never as long as I draw breath.

I'm going to try to explain something to you two.

Please do. Please.

A girl is dead. Murdered. The last few days of her life, you were with her. You can tell me about it here, or we can go downtown. There aren't many yachts there. I think you should know that.

The chap is quite right, dear. This is deadly serious. Get your things. We're going downtown.

No, no. It's quite simple, really. Don't get your hackles up. Look, Mary and that Robert Gray, the fortunate fiancé, and Lucy and I, early Tuesday we arrived at Joan's place. We got it in order for a honeymoon. Then Wednesday we celebrated. There was a jug, and Lucy and I got squiffed, and we communed with nature and had laughter together. And when we woke up Thursday, there was Robert and Mary with coffee for us, and our things all packed for the trip home. And Thursday evening, Robert rushed us off right over here. And that's the last we've seen. The last we've seen of either of them. Our oath. Our solemn word.

Dickie?

Yes, dear?

I had a thought. I had a funny thought. Let's open honeymoon palaces all over the world. We'll make it a career. Our life's work.

Oh, Dickie, the thought kills me. Honeymoon palaces.

Lucy, darling, you've outdone yourself. Honeymoon.

And they laughed, and they hit each other with their elbows, and they were happy. The jollity was too much for me. I felt left out and unwanted, and it struck me that perhaps the time to go was now. So I did. Back to headquarters and sit at the desk, a few minutes of thinking. Sergeant Gino Tataglia happened.

Danny? Come on in, Gino. Why the big grin?

Listen. You listening, Danny?

Yeah.

Tip a canoe and Tyler too. Tip a canoe and Tyler too, Danny.

What about it?

It does have a ring to it, doesn't it? My fourth-born, Donald, brought the phrase home from school with him last night. Tip a canoe and Tyler too.

Gino. Gino.

Huh?

You have anything for me?

Oh, hardly a thing. Nothing of note in Miss Trevor's background. Nothing of note in Miss Trevor's overnight bag. Personal effects. A novel entitled, let's see, titled The Caine Mutiny, in which was her birth certificate as a bookmark between chapter four.

Birth certificate?

As I have said. Now, if you wouldn't mind me, Lieutenant.

Thank you. Danny Clover speaking.

Muggovan, Dan, with the Trevor apartment.

Yeah, what's up?

Married father, Danny, just tried to kill himself.

What?

Yeah, just tried suicide. Stick with him, Muggovan.

Must have been out of my mind. I don't know. I went crazy. Suddenly it was the only thing I could do, kill myself.

Why? Why did you try to commit suicide, Mr. Trevor? Well, don't just sit there and shake your head. You plugged up the apartment and turned on the gas, so there must have been a reason. Leave me alone. Remorse? You sorry about something? Nodding your head won't do it, Mr. Trevor. Talk to us. Tell us what you're sorry about. Leave me alone.

Look, Mr. Trevor, your daughter was murdered. You don't like the kind of life she leads, so you kill her. Then you become very unhappy. You've done a very terrible thing, you tell yourself, so you make up for it. Flip on the gas. It doesn't hurt. You're dead real easy, and the whole thing's over with. That's the best you'll give us, huh? The bit with shaking the head?

Who called the police?

Smuggled them? Some woman saw Trevor break that window over there, give a yell, and fall down, called it in.

What are we going to do with him?

Book him, I guess. Let's go, Trevor. Didn't you hear what the lieutenant said?

That was crazy. Scared, too, huh? When you started getting a little woozy from the gas, real panicky, all of a sudden, you don't want to kill yourself. Like you killed your daughter.

What?

Like you killed your daughter.

No, I didn't do that. She's dead. I didn't want to live anymore because she's dead, but I didn't kill her. You see? What? Something happened to me. My baby dying, and she was going to get married, me being her father and loving her. That's all there was to anything I did, loving her. What could I do anymore about living? What could I do?

Who is your daughter going to marry?

There.

Huh?

In the table drawer where the phone is.

This letter?

Yeah. Let's see it.

We're here in Canada, Daddy, Bob and I.

She's going to marry me. I'll make him do it. Found her way. Signed, Mary. Take a look, Muggovan. The envelope, too.

Uh-huh. Bob. Robert Gray? Has to be. Envelope's postmarked Wednesday. Let's call Canada.

Yeah. Have Dr. Sinski look at Mr. Trevor, Muggovan. I've got a couple of stops to make.

So ride the late afternoon streets, uptown on 5th to 42nd, public library. Ask for an atlas and get it. And locate a town in Canada called Lacolle. Then know what you need to know. Leave there. Cross town to a place. A place you've been to before. To the apartment of Robert Gray. And no one answers your knock. And Robert Gray's door is locked. So downstairs be told by a man at the switchboard that Mr. Gray had left word he might be reached at this number. Check the number against the name and an address you have, and it matches. So uptown again to Park Avenue at dog walk time. And the doxies and the Spaniels leave their butlers on leashes. And today's maid wears today's gray silk, white collar, and a smile left over from yesterday. Go through the ritual and finally be ushered across the parquet floor to another room.

Come in, Mr. Clover.

Thanks. Robert and I were having tea. Will you join us?

No, thanks. Did you want to see me?

Both of you.

Joan, dear.

Yes?

Whatever Mr. Clover wants to say to us, I'm sure I can answer it. Now, why don't...

Don't act the gallant, Robert. Sit there. Speak when you're spoken to. Now, what is it, Mr. Clover?

Maybe Mr. Gray is right. Maybe just he and I...

If it concerns Robert, it concerns me. Isn't that right, Robert?

Robert?

Yes.

Robert says that's right, Mr. Clover.

All right, Clover. Let's...

Sure. Let me pose the name of a town, Mr. Gray. Lacolle. Lacolle is a town in Canada. It's about ten miles over the border.

Well, I know where it is. When I used to spend the summers at my lodge at Rouse's Point, we'd go right across the border into Lacolle for Canadian whiskey. But there's nothing there, actually.

There's a post office there. And as the sun slowly sinks below the post office at Lacolle, you will bid us a fond farewell. Take off, Clover. Listen to my man. Man.

What?

I'm proud.

Are we a handsome couple, Mr. Clover? Robert in his great red leather chair, me and mine. Of course we are.

A little while ago, I saw a letter from Lacolle. It was mailed Wednesday by Mary Trevor. Was Mary in Canada? Was she, Robert?

I'm talking to you, Robert.

She was there. And so were you, Mr. Gray.

Why didn't you tell me, Robert?

We went up to Canadian whiskey. But you should have told me. Nelson didn't mention anything about going to Canada.

I don't think they went.

Did they get loaded, Robert? Listen, Joan.

Did they get loaded, Robert? And did you lose them, Robert? And you and Mary went to Canada. Why?

Will you just listen?

All right.

It's just across the border.

That's right, Robert. Go on, Robert.

The Nelsons were drunk. They got dull. Mary and I...

He loved you very much, didn't she?

Well, what of it? Isn't that nice? Women fall in love with Robert. And blackmail him, too.

Joan, listen to me.

I've been listening. You've said nothing at all. Except that you got rid of your chaperone and went to a foreign land with a girl who was in love with you. Now, I've just gotten worried that she was blackmailing you. What a time you must have had, Robert.

I'm telling you, nothing happened, Joan.

It doesn't matter. You're an alien on a visitor's permit. You went out of the country. The law says you'd be deported for that. You couldn't let that happen. The blackmail, right, Mr. Clover?

That's right.

What did she want from you, Robert? Money? No, it couldn't be that. Then what else? You? That's what she wanted, Robert. She wanted to marry. She wanted to marry you, didn't she? You know what she did? She made me go. She had it all planned. She had her birth certificate along so she could get out of the country and in again.

Made you go? But, oh. She said, let's get away from the Nelsons. All I'd have to do is show my birth certificate and no one would know that I was an alien.

Let's get back to the blackmail, shall we? Mary could have had you deported. And deported, Robert, couldn't have me. And let's face it, my darling, my money. So you had to kill her to keep her quiet. Is that right, Robert? How did you do it, dear? Dear?

I dropped her off at home. I told her I'd meet her later. We met. We met and...

No suspense, darling. Just the story.

We met and there was all that subway crowd.

You planned to kill her, didn't you? You were carrying a knife, so you must have planned.

Help me. Help me, Joan. Mr. Clover, I'm... trying to phrase it so it won't seem obvious. My thoughts are how to buy Robert back from you.

Forget it.

If not money, then this. I told you. This wheelchair I'm in, I get lonely.

I'm sorry.

Robert.

What?

Goodbye, Robert.

Broadway's screaming now. It sneers and makes a big fist at the night. And the midway's boiling. It's yokel and clown and jack-in-the-box that leaps from dark doorways. And it's geek with no arms, no legs, and no heart. It's Broadway. The gaudiest, most violent, the lonesomest mile in the world. Broadway. My beat.

Broadway's My Beat stars Larry Thor as Detective Danny Clover with Charles Calvert as Tataglia and Jack Kruschen as Muggovan. The program is produced and directed by Elliott Lewis with musical score composed and conducted by Alexander Courage. In tonight's story, Betty Lou Gerson was heard as Joan and Ben Wright as Robert. Featured in the cast were Jeanette Nolan, Tom Tully, and Byron Kane. Bill Anders speaking. Remember, on most of these same stations every Saturday night, listen to Gangbusters as they bring you high-tension thrills. And remember, Eve Arden as Our Miss Brooks teaches you how to laugh Sundays on the CBS radio network.

End of transcriptBack to the beginning ↑