Skip to content
On Air
All channelsAll
Broadway Is My Beat artwork

From the Broadway Is My Beat collection

The Grace Cullen Murder Case

Episode 140November 22, 195228 min 0 secTranscript

The written record

Read the transcript

Read along with the recording · About 19 min to read

The most violent, the lonesomest mile in the world. With Larry Thor as Detective Danny Clover.

The night that begins to curtain Broadway in late November is a thing of gauze, gray stuff that touches autumn to December. And the moon pocks the shadows with a frosty light. The time of the three-coffee dinner, of the sweater and the vest under the coat. But the plucked birds hang high, and there, shocks of corn and wheat. And in shop windows, tableaux of settlers and friendly redskins biting dusty pumpkins. Holiday time. Everywhere, everybody will be eating turkey, it says.

And uptown, far uptown where I was, only night wind and the near pattern of campus lights in back of the student union building, and Detective McGovern, and the woman, dead.

May Watchman was making his rounds, caught her in his flash, phoned it in.

Identification? Yeah, handbag. Here. Nineteen... This is it, says. Yeah, thank you very much. 1903, West 160. That check with your observations, McGovern?

Okay, okay. Hey, she looks a little oldish, huh?

Oldish for what?

Well, college campus, nighttime. Still, kind of pretty. About 37 or 40, I'd say.

Well... Yeah, you stick around for technical, McGovern. See you later.

What do you want?

Police, open up.

The length of the latch chain and the tip of my nose through the slit. That's as far as I get with late dates.

Show me your policeman.

Yeah, see? You're dealing with a sleepy child, and I'd better turn the porch light on, so I'll know it's not just a recurrent dream. Hmm. True badge. And you've wakened me, and you've proven your point. What next, policeman?

It's about Mrs. Grace Cullen. She... Normally, other nights, Grace would have opened the door to you. But as Grace is not at home, and she's heaven knows where...

She's dead. Murdered.

That did it. I'm awake now. You can come in. I'll turn the lights on in the parlor. It's where Grace and I receive our dates. You going to come in and tell me about it, or are you just going to stand there in the hall?

You related to Mrs. Cullen?

Oh, that's it. You thought I was her daughter or something like that? No. No tie of blood between Grace and me.

Then... Grace ran an ad in the college paper. Room and board for girl student in return for light housekeeping. Look how nice I keep it. You can try for dust anywhere you choose. Maureen Hill, sophomore in light housekeeping. Now, what's this about Grace?

We found her on the campus a little while ago.

Grace is a widow.

Oh? She's 41. A widow 12 years. She told me she... When she was 37, I scouted around. I found out she was 41. Look, girl... Any way you look at it, she's a widow.

I know. You told me. And there was a rapport between her and football players. She understood their sorrows and problems. Observe the footballs lining the mantel.

She have a date with one of them tonight?

Boy was here earlier tonight. Left end type boy. His eyes were glazy and his manner was hazy. Big game today and we lost and the boy was drunk and came calling.

Who was the boy?

Left end, weight 197, 6'3". Like a swift dreamer, he was on a playing field and in the headlines his name was Lloyd Keeler. He was here for a while and he went away. And after that? After that, I wouldn't know. I said goodnight to Grace. It curled up in my downy. Reminds me it's where I should be now. Nighty night, policeman.

And outside, the streets have given up to midnight. Stone facades against darkness. Older doors. And only here and there the pencil line of light beneath drawn shades. Section of city asleep. Properly, respectably. Not your own. Two key type. One key for the front door, the other for the rented room and bath and kitchenette. And sleep, the rented sleep.

And morning. New day, so get ready for it. Then call headquarters and give your route for the day. Ride uptown, the college. Inquire at the registrar. Get the name and address of the fraternity house of Lloyd Keeler. Go there. The boy who answers the door for you is disappointed you're not an old grad or something, thus leaving empty his handshake of curled little finger and vertical thumb. But his answers are bright and quick. Lloyd Keeler is not there. Wasn't in last night. Haven't seen him. Don't know where he is. Tried the gym he offers? Coach? Red Price? Old Red? I don't know. Anytime at all he leaves you with, fella.

So across the campus, the sad sunny paths of branch shadows and young people. And into the coach's office. And Old Red looks just like his pictures in the paper. Except no hair.

Have a seat.

Thanks. I think the Cougars are too deep down the center of the line. If it rains, we're dead. What with our stellar tailback Prebick temporarily on the sideline with a fracture.

I'm a policeman, not a reporter. Trying to locate Lloyd Keeler.

He do something with a bucket of red paint in town?

For questioning about murder.

Practice at three. Maybe then.

Tell me something about him.

He passes last week. Shifty in the clear. 197 and shifty. Where the scamp is. Good day for the college when he entered our ranks. He's a good guy. He's a good guy. Shifty in the clear. Even if he fumbles, forget about him. Just mark at the end. He should just mark right where he should mark. He's going to block, look. He's not gonna... Never moving for the little motions. He's a nice little boy, too. Okay, seen some good money, Tart. It does get his over here, you sure. Yeah, he's doing very well. Okay, we gotta go. Get up now.

Rather a mess, isn't it? At least that's how I feel about it. That woman, woman of middle age, found like that on a college campus, and a boy of 20. Sordid, not pretty.

That's how it happens, Mrs. Davey.

Doesn't it, though? One thing I'll never understand.

What?

I've read of such things in newspapers. I, uh, I buy sordid little paperback books, read myself to sleep with such things, but I never thought I would walk into my home and breathe so close. That boy mixed up in it, Lloyd Keeler. I was told your husband is sending him through college. Is that our guilt, Mr. Clover? That we were nice to an athlete?

Where is your husband?

In his study. It's where he retreats after lunch. Charts, football plays. I hardly think it worthwhile disturbing him.

I do. Disturb him, Mrs. Davey.

And then you'll be nice and go away. And we can write this thing off. Get him.

Oh, Don. Donnie. Claire, how many times did it take to get through? Don't. Oh, dear. I have a terrific reason. There's a policeman in our home.

I can't do that, dear, because he's brought us a murder.

Coming, dear? My husband, Mr. Clover. And he's irritated and angry because you've intruded on, uh, on what play this time, dear? Fifty-four? Play fifty-four?

Claire said murder. You must have read about it. She was found on the campus of your college. The woman was Mrs. Grace Cullen.

Twenty years ago when I was big on the college team, I knew a Grace Cullen. Don't tell me this is a murder.

I'm not a murder. She's the same one.

Oh, get sad. Real sad how the years stand still. Maybe she's the same one. But this year, she's been going out with a boy named Lloyd Keeler. The years sure stand still, don't they, fella?

You know where Lloyd is?

Well, Don had him pledged to Don's fraternity. Why don't you try there, Mr. Clover?

He's not there. Do you have any other ideas?

Oh, we do a sponsor. And that doesn't make Claire his mother. Doesn't make me his father. And you don't know, is that it?

When I was a lad, I sometimes broke training and nobody could ever find me either. Sometimes for days. That's the way it was, fella. Sorry.

And the four o'clock lunch. Blue plate special of pre-holiday drumstick and paper cup of coleslaw, smaller one of cranberries and coffee that looks yellow under the overhead light. Ride through afternoon streets festooned with plaid mufflers and red mittens. Turn left where the Doberman in a hip-length knitted overcoat breathes steam up with a maiden in coat to match. Crowd dwindles. Then a right turn. Headquarters. Down the corridor lined with bulletin boards and bulletin boards.

I'll give you a little tips on courtesy. Don't quite make your office.

Hey, Danny. I tried to get in touch with Mr. Davey. He just left. What's the matter? Where you been?

I got hungry, Muggovan. I ate, you mind?

Well, just listen, will you?

Sure. What's the...

That kid, that end on the college football team, Lloyd Keeler? What about him?

In the morgue.

What?

Found him in an alley, shot to death, murdered, Danny. You're lucky you had time to eat. I haven't.

You are listening to Broadway Is My Beat, written by Morton Fine and David Friedkin and starring Larry Thor as Detective Danny Clover.

And late November touches Broadway's cheek softly now, whispers the traceries of winter. One chrome will be veiled with frost, also windows, also the lips of women. And the autumn memories, barren, leafless, stripped. But there are minutes left in the autumn twilight, so breathe them deep, walk them slow. There's still time before neon and the long night. There's sunset, the flame of autumn color on the concrete slabs. There's the twilight passage of the twilight women. And fury is not yet. Only this, the dying of November.

And at headquarters, the awe and the wonder of the man, Sergeant Gino Tartaglia.

Danny, you haven't been listening.

Uh, I'm sorry, Geno, I was just...

Rule gathering is the phrase that comes willy-nilly to my mind. I'm sorry, what were you saying?

I was merely relating to you the far-flung exploits of one Mike Schreck, who just happens, just happens to be the miracle detective from Pittsburgh, P.A. That's right. The last time you told me about him, he lived in Philadelphia.

Cleaned up, Philly. Now graces the avenues and citadels of Pittsburgh, P.A., and a good thing, too.

Huh?

It was in the smog there that he fell upon plastic memory.

Huh? What was that, Geno?

I'll explain to you. The weapon that did in Daphne Fenstead backstage at Carnegie Hall, which was found lying beside her, was thought at first to be merely a bloody shoehorn.

Geno...

After dusting the fingerprints on the murder weapon, Mike, with his customary genius, plunged the shoehorn into a pot of boiling water, which never leaves his side.

He did what?

And in a few minutes, there, clutched in his blistered fist, instead of a shoehorn, a plastic dagger. Plastic memory, Danny. I'll explain to you. It is the custom of plastic to return to its original shape...

You through, Geno?

Oh, I wished only to clarify for you...

Yeah, I'm through, Danny. And that's all you have for me, huh?

No, I have other items. You'll tell me, huh? It goes without saying. From the medical... From the medical examiner, Dr. Sinskey, this report, which states that Lloyd Keeler, late of college football, was shot and wounded fatally, perhaps an hour after the death of Mrs. Grace Cullen. I place it on your desk.

That other paper in your hand, Geno.

A P.S. to the report from Detective Muggovan, stating that the murdered boy was found in the alley back of the home of the college widow, Mrs. Grace Cullen.

I place it on your desk. And these elderly college girls, Danny...

All right, Geno, you can go now.

If such is your pleasure, Lieutenant. You must admit one thing, though, Danny.

What?

That in the case of Daphne Fenstead, Mike Schreck merits an orchid. Good evening, Danny.

So consider now the elements. Set them down on paper. Neat. Crisscross lines from names to events. Switch the swivel chair. Look out the window. Attitude for thinking. But somehow the swift curve of newspaper page wind-trap blowing down the street intrudes. And the race between pedestrian and taxi. And the winner's gesture. And the first dart of light through beginning evening. Leave it.

Turn back to the desk. Items to be thought about. A woman murdered. Woman, friend of the college for 20 years. A football player murdered in back of her house. Football player, a boy whose talents were subsidized by an old grad. Old grad, erstwhile hero. Old grad, man who should be talked to some more. Squad car again. And ride through evening streets. Park Avenue. Park the car. Evening.

Hello. What is it?

Well, you remember me, don't you?

Yes. Mr. Davey, I... I remember you. What is it?

More questions. Mind if I come in?

Want to talk to my wife again?

Your wife, too.

She's not in. She's being fitted.

I'm happy for her. Now, you want to talk inside your place or inside mine?

Fella. Fella, come in. Come in by all means.

Thanks.

In here, my den. You have a seat.

Thanks. I'd rather... trophies.

Yes. Yes. Quite a few. Were you an All-American, Mr. Davey?

Uh, Don. Who are you, Don? One sports editor in Baltimore. Two more in the Middle West named me. Mostly second string All-American.

Oh, see, you've got your old jersey.

Yeah. And I'm wearing this watch. You could... Here. I'll take it off.

No, don't have trouble. Here. Look at the back.

The greatest kick blocker of them all. Fellas gave me that after the last game with Tech. You must have heard of the time I... Don. I said to myself, it's up to you, Don. Boy, we've got to win this game. We've got to block this kick. And I did. I tore through the secondary.

Let's talk about Lloyd Keeler, huh?

Glad to, fella. I scouted him myself. He was playing for City High. I called at his... his house. Offered to send him to college. He accepted. Great boy. Lots of pride. When he loses that habit of his of rubbing his hands together sometimes before an end around...

He's dead.

He... Didn't you know that? Didn't you see the papers?

Mark? Well, I'm trying to... Who? Who murdered?

You. Fella. Where were you last night, Don?

You've got a law that says no, fella. So the friend can remember to drink to it.

What friend?

Played with me. Three years first string. Had me tackled. I know who that is, don't you?

No.

Johnny Harris, fella. Who else? Ask him. Oh, Johnny's got a business now, so it's easy to find. The plant store in Lexington. Ask him, why don't you, fella?

Man, just about to close up, mister, but you're welcome to browse around. Find any item that hits you, just yell out.

You Johnny Harris?

That's it. So you don't have to worry about a salesman's commission. I'm all there is.

You, uh, find what hits you. I'm always willing to talk business. Fine stock. Electric floor waxers by Hoover. Be glad to demonstrate.

I'm from the police.

I'm in electric appliances, so we two have got what to hold our heads about, huh, mister? Nothing to hide, huh, you?

Me? I just left Don Davey.

Don, huh? He, uh, show you his gold watch from after the Tech game?

Huh? It was me who got the boys to buy it for him. I didn't have fat on me then like I got now.

You've stayed friends with him since college?

Yeah, yeah, let's call it that. Don was a likable boy, never quite made man. But, uh, then you could say he was up against tough opposition.

Like what?

You meet his wife? You get to meet Claire Davey?

What about her?

You said you were with Don a little while ago.

Don. String, All-American boy preserved in wax. That's what about his wife, Claire Davey?

I don't understand.

I don't blame you. It's hard to. The way I figured, it's like this. Claire's a rich girl. She bought herself a one-play hero, a second stringer who once won her Saturday afternoon. She'll never let him go. That's why she, uh... indulges him?

Yeah. He's sponsored. He's got a marriage scholarship. She pays the bills. He works out football plays. Funny thing about him, whenever things get rough, he tucks the pigskin under his arm and runs up and down the football field. Funny, eh?

Tell me why I should spill like this to you.

Two killings. Grace Cullen, Lloyd Keeler. And you came right from Donnie to me.

That's right.

Read in the paper about him. About, uh, Mrs. Cullen, I, uh, haven't gathered any feeling yet. About the kid, about Lloyd.

What about him?

Sorry for him. Sorry for Don.

Why for Don?

Yeah, I'm not big with words, mister. All I can say is, lately, Don's whole life was wrapped around that football kid. All he ever talks about now. Don't even booze so much anymore. I don't know what it is. The kid meant something real deep to Don. Maybe in the boy he saw himself when he was a kid. Maybe he thought he could make a man out of the kid, the kind of man Don never was. I don't know. I ain't that deep.

Not that, huh?

I told you, I don't know. I ain't that deep.

Don said he was with you last night.

He did? He said he sat with you and drank and remembered. He said all that, huh?

Well, uh, oh, excuse me, mister. Johnny Harris speaking. Yeah, yeah, I'll pay. No play, kid. I remember. Yeah, it was very glorious how we trimmed Tech, but that was 20 years ago. Now, you listen to me. Before, when you called, I was ready to run along with a gag because we're college chums, because I feel sorry for you sometimes because it happens to a guy. Not now, kid. No play.

You heard?

Uh-huh. It was Donnie, boy. About last night, mister.

What?

I didn't sit with Don. I didn't drink with him. I didn't sit with him. I didn't remember with him. I was to a movie with my wife. I paid for the tickets.

Thanks, Mr. Harris.

Bad for Don. Where to find him?

Danny?

Yeah.

Guy's nuts, huh? Must have been kicked in the head. Look, look there. Muggerin over there.

This is Detective Muggerin, missus.

You cold sitting up here, Mrs. Davey?

Gentlemen care for a drink? There's still some in the famous bottle.

Jim?

Why, yes. Help yourself.

No, thanks.

See, don't care for anything.

Please sit down.

Mrs. Davey. First, I want to tell you this. When Don comes off the field, tell him he was very good. Tell him better than ever.

Are you kidding?

Sure we will. You were about to ask me, Mr. Kroger?

About all that's happened.

Wave. Wave to him. He's looking.

All that's happened, Mrs. Davey.

I... Lieutenant means about a couple murders, Mrs. Davey. A woman named Grace Cullen. A kid named Lloyd Keeler.

I know.

Well?

An explanation, you mean.

Or a confession, Mrs. Davey. One or the other. Or both would be nice.

Is he so difficult to tell you? Let me help you.

You?

About Don. What you did to him.

I suppose you could say it that way. It's brutal, but it's true, I suppose. It's over now, isn't it? All of it?

Yes.

What you did to him, Mrs. Davey. Bought yourself a second string husband and wrapped him up and never let him go.

Thirty-five. Ninety-three. Look at him. He's gotten old and fat and slow. And the only way out he knew. Footways mapped out in his study. And then that kid came along, the football kid, Lloyd Keeler.

Yes.

Then I lost my husband. Everything your husband knew he wasn't. He saw fulfilled in that boy. The old college try. The time when he most nearly became a man.

You're so right.

So you killed the boy.

You see, it's been twenty years. And I've owned Donnie. And suddenly I didn't own him. That boy. Yes, I shot him. Grace Cullen, too.

No. Eighty-six. No. Fourteen. Twenty-seven. I tell you that because if it's over for me, then it's over for Don. He got away for a little while. Now we'll both suffer for it.

Then here's what. You shot Lloyd after he'd seen Grace.

Ask him. Leave him alone. I think we need to ask him anything, not now.

Don came to see Grace, saw Lloyd walk out of there drunk. Don went for a walk with her. Then he killed her.

Why? Can you tell me that?

Don must have figured Lloyd lost the game on account of Grace.

Oh, Don. Breaking training.

You want a drink, dear?

You were ready to go with us, Don?

I saw you come here. I knew you were. When you waved, I knew Claire told you to. I was going to run, but it was about 20 years ago. Turned out the way you wanted. It'll happen to me. It'll happen to you. Happy, dear?

It's the happy time on Broadway. After the movies time. And nobody wants to go home. It's a place strung against the night like a phosphorescent alley. Bright-eyed kid. Broadway is my beat.

Stars Larry Thor as Detective Danny Clover. With Charles Calvert as Tartaglia. And John Crucian as Muggerin. The program is produced and directed by Elliott Lewis. With music composed and conducted by Alexander Courage. In tonight's story, Paula Winslow was heard as Claire and Lou Merrill as Don Davey. Featured in the cast were Joyce McCluskey, Eddie Fields, and Tom Tully. Bill Anders speaking. My beat has come to you through the worldwide facilities of the United States Armed Forces Radio and Television Service.

End of transcriptBack to the beginning ↑