Skip to content
On Air
All channelsAll
Broadway Is My Beat artwork

From the Broadway Is My Beat collection

The Charles Ralston Murder Case

Episode 144December 20, 195227 min 26 secTranscript

The written record

Read the transcript

Read along with the recording · About 20 min to read

The gaudiest, the most violent, the lonesomest mile in the world. With Larry Thor as Detective Danny Clover. Squeeze the Christmas carols through sequined loudspeakers on Broadway to get all the happy out. And the crowd walks in holiday cadence, conditioned by age, measurements, and the size of a pocketbook. And it's all there in the shop windows. Mechanical clown, thin man dancing a jig on a tin box. And toy army, precisely to scale, mechanized. Some with parkas and skis for the difficult terrain over the raw cotton battlefront. And eyes are bright with hope and desire. And the wish made on a neon star.

But in the place where I was, holidays coming is marked only by the rise of empty liquor bottles in trash cans. Alley off of 3rd Avenue. And this winter's late night marked by horn of moon stuck through clump of cloud. And this, the boy lying unconscious, and Detective Muggerman.

Name's James Barton, Danny. Here, his wallet.

Thanks. Lots of benefits. Vacation here. Address lives on East 58th, 1212. Hold your flash over here, Muggerman. 19 years old. Whoever did it to him was pretty systematic, Danny. Worked him over real good.

Who reported it?

Officer Farm called. He didn't walk in his beat.

Danny.

Yeah?

Christmas season. A kid, 19, beaten in an alley. What's on your mind, Muggerman?

Well, whoever did it wasn't a mugger. The kid's got maybe 60 bucks in his wallet. He wasn't beaten for money. What happens when a kid this age gets dragged into a sewer like this and worked over?

Nice looking boy. Why is he...

Yeah. Sure. Amethyst ought to be here in a second, Dan. Think the kid'll live?

The winter-spilled city and chill splay of wavering reflected night lights. And a boy's part of it. Beaten, flung against alley litter. Skyward, the fleet curve and fall of a December star. The sounds of night fury are muted now into soft keening and whirl of river wind. And not too distant, the clack of a woman's heels on pavement. Slow walking. Then running. Then lost in a sudden cry of wind.

It's called for. Laid gently on the stretcher. Received into drifting night. Carried away. So leave there. Furnished room. The remnants of sleep. The half-dream. And in the morning, they're called to headquarters.

The report on the boy. Jimmy Barton's still in shock. You'll be notified when it's all right to talk to him. So go to a place. The boy's address on East 58th. Show a badge. Get a door open. Walk in. And Jimmy Barton's apartment is early December sunlight on ceramic vases of cut flowers. His bed. Neatly folded down and arranged for sleep. Is this. A basket of fruit. An open box of candy on nightstand. Another unopened on shelf below. And in bureau drawers. Knitted things. Heavy woolen sweater complete with design of stag with antlers. Woolen socks. Argyle. Arranged neatly as the pattern and color. Shirts. Monograms. Handkerchiefs. Lemon. Hand roll.

Naughty. Terribly naughty what you're doing.

What?

Jimmy's such a neat type. He'll have a spell when I tell him a thief. He's mucked up his things. The child of Smith. Who are you?

A girl who leans against doorways languidly like this and chats brightly with thieves. Can't you tell? I'm from the police.

I, uh, also chat brightly with policemen. Try me. Who are you?

A girl across the hall type. Will stick my nose into any of my neighbor's affairs. Lately, mostly Jimmy's. And my name is Ina Small. And a German fellow, kick I was once on, used to call me Ina Kleiner. Like a knight in. Cute, huh?

How long have you known Jimmy?

Long enough to be concerned about the child. Jimmy did a prank. Which you must consider the boy's 19. We found him in an alley last night. Beaten. Unconscious.

It'll take me a minute to get out of this. How shall I address the call on Jimmy, policeman? Black?

He's badly hurt. We don't know for a while. How long you've known him?

He moved into this apartment maybe five months ago. July. I was navel-y. I brought him bread and salt for his new home.

He lives here alone?

No, alone. And across the hall with me. His clothes, his things, they're nice, expensive-looking.

Well, he's a nice boy. He deserves expensive things.

Know where he works?

Works? Jimmy works? Not ever on my time. Other times, I wouldn't know.

Anything else you can tell me about him? Like who hated him enough to beat him up like that?

Well, Jimmy was hurt before, you know.

I didn't know.

Yeah, some automobile accident. In March, I think he told me. Something to his legs. For a while, we had to sit out dancing. He looked great. If Jimmy's dying, I want to be there.

We'll let you know, Miss Small. Thank you.

Nichols? Officer Nichols?

There's a bench to rest your troubles on, lad.

Oh, you, Danny lad. If I'd have known it was the lieutenant himself.

How are you, Nichols?

Beautiful. And you, Danny?

Okay. There's something you ought to know, Danny lad. What?

There was a debate here amongst the boys. On record, should we put lieutenants with their pay and all on our Christmas list? It was touch and go, I can tell you. Also, I took the affirmative side of the bitter controversy.

Thanks. I thought it was something you'd want to remember. Now, what else can I do for you, Danny lad?

A report on an automobile accident last March involved a boy named James Barton.

Barton, last March of an automobile. Anything you want, lieutenant. I mean, just as you said, lieutenant. Let me see it, huh?

Accident, intersection, 93rd and Lexington, 129 AM, 8 March, 1951. James Barton, 19, hit by club coupe, compound fracture of both legs, possible internal injuries, coupe driven by a Charles Rossman of 18, 40, 60, 62. Is this the one you want to look at, lieutenant?

Never mind, Nichols. I'll take it with me. Anything you want, lieutenant lad.

Mrs. Ralston?

That's right. I'm from the police. My name's Clover.

Yes?

May we talk inside?

Yes. If you believe we should, of course. Please come in.

Thanks. Now, what is it?

About a boy named James Barton.

Oh, please. What?

I just refuse to talk about it anymore.

Oh?

For months after it happened, newspaper reporters, insurance adjusters, traffic safety engineers, now you.

Now there's a difference. James Barton's been hurt all over again.

Well, what do you want me to do?

I don't want you to do anything, Mrs. Ralston. The boy's been hurt, and we're trying to find out why. The way we do things like this is to... Take up the threads of his life and hunt him. Hunt for clues. I know, I know.

I'm glad you do. Let's get on with it. As if you already don't know. All I'm asking you is your version of that accident.

My husband and I were coming home from the evening. My husband was driving slowly, but fast enough to break that boy's legs when he stepped in front of our car. We took him to a hospital. He admitted that he was at fault and absolved us. I haven't heard from him since. Now what?

How about your husband?

What about him?

Do you know whether he's seen or heard from James Barton since the accident?

Well, let's call him at work and find out, shall we?

Well, never mind. I can go back to...

No, no, no. Let's call him. Let's get rid of that boy's name around here once and for all.

Charles? No, no. I'm all right. Listen, Charles. There's a policeman here. About that boy James Barton again. Well, he's had another accident or something. Well, anyhow, the policeman wants to know whether you've seen or heard from that boy since. That's what I told him. Well, goodbye, honey. See you tonight. What? All right.

Well, does that answer your question, Mr. Clover?

All right. Thanks a lot, Mrs. Charleston.

Back to headquarters now, through the time when afternoon stands still for two hours. And when you get to where you're going, it's suddenly dark. And to the office for the details and paperwork and the cigarette on the edge of the desk. Coffee sent out for and drank. Reports to make and the quiet policeman talk at day's end.

Latest report from the hospital, Danny. James Barton might not die.

Uh, Danny.

Yeah?

All that loot in that kid's room. What do you mean, his clothes? Such expensive stuff. And as far as we can find out, the kid didn't have a job. That makes it loot.

Thanks, Muggerman. Now I know him. You think maybe the kid's a thief, a young hoodoo?

Danny?

Yes?

The report just came in communication.

Thanks, do you know? Charles Ralston.

Who?

The man who was driving the car that ran into the Barton boy last March. Charles Ralston. Where'd he buy it?

Around the corner from his office, in the alley. That's where he was just found, shot to death.

You are listening to Broadway's My Beat. Written by Morton Fine. And starring Larry Thor as Detective Danny Clover.

Until December when the year moves swiftly to the place of its dying. And Broadway arranges its emotions for the occasion. On Translux, the current emotion, suitable for Christmas past, Christmas present, Christmas future. And this, in high places, strategies are being shaped so that Santa will not bypass the boys. And Broadway walks by, glances up, hurries to buy the last minute gift for the last minute girl. The time is short, kid. Think fast. There must be something no one else has thought to give her.

And at headquarters, new winter day. The patter of tired feet. The sound of manly giggles as ribbon packages are stashed away in lockers. And in my office, Sergeant Gino Tartaglia with a suggestion.

Take off your shoes, Danny.

Huh?

Don't fight me in this, Danny. Simply do as I say. One shoe off will be sufficient, if modesty insists. I have tape measure to hand.

What is this, Gino?

Oh, please, Gino, tell me. My eldest, Christina Tartaglia. She made me promise I would get your foot size unbeknownst to you. I chose this method.

Oh, tell Christina size 11 and a half, Gino. I know, I know, Danny. But we must take into consideration the Christmas present my eldest is knitting for you is a pair of space socks.

Space socks?

Therefore, in revealing to her your size foot, I must also take into consideration the layer of air which must be knitted in to offset the forces of cosmic energy. With their nutrients and protons.

Gino. Such were the instructions I received from Space Cadetess 3ZXL Tartaglia. Danny, I must...

Later, huh, Gino?

Well, if you wish to thwart the progress of the scientific mind. Well, to work, shall we, Danny? You may measure me, Gino, but later, huh?

Perhaps later. Now, to work. In the matter of Charles Walton, deceased of a .38 caliber bullet in an alley back of his office, these items from sundry investigation. These items from sundry investigation. These items from sundry investigation.

Gino. Gino.

That he was a man respected in his line of business machine tools. That his bank account was commensurate with his tight income. Neither too large nor too small, but tidy. That his life insurance was placed with the firm Adler Insurance Brokers on Madison. That he...

Danny Clover speaking.

Muggerman Danny, two things. Just got word from the hospital the kid Jimmy Barton's fine. He's sitting up. And the other thing, that girl, Ina Small, you know, lives across the hall from Jimmy... Yeah, I know. What about her? Emergency hospital visit. Turn it up, boy. I thought maybe you... Yeah, right away.

Anything else, Gino?

Nothing. I had finished. I may go now.

Well, don't poke, Gino. I'll be back. You can measure my foot.

We shall see what we shall see. Don't forget your muffler, Lieutenant.

Just let me prep this pillow a second. There we are. Now you just lie back, Gino.

This boy looks boyish, doesn't he, Mr. Clover?

How do you feel, Jimmy?

Don't take your fingers away from my cheek, Ina.

Mm-hmm. Real good. That's how I feel, Clover.

Who beat you up?

Now, don't you make him think of it. Pleasant thoughts is what my Jimmy needs.

Yeah. Who beat you up?

I better tell him, honey. Then you go away. I guess.

I don't know who beat me up. I was attacked from behind. I never saw him.

Oh, poor Jimmy. Oh. It was awful.

You remember a man named Charles Ralston, Jimmy?

Sure. What about him?

Once he hit me with a car. It was my fault.

Wet night all over.

I stumbled into his car. What are you building? Since the accident. Have you seen him? No. Did you know Mr. Ralston was dead? Dead? Last night, he was murdered. How about it, Jimmy?

Ina. Yeah, baby. Peel me one of those oranges you brought. Sure, honey. Mr. Ralston murdered, huh? And you beaten up. And once the two of us had an accident together. Now look at us. That's what I mean, Jimmy. Another thing. What do you do for a living? Well, he saw the pretty stuff in your room, baby. Don't worry about me, Clover. How long has it been since you've had a job? Well, since that car accident last March. Used to work in a filling station before that. Now I can't face it. Here, Jimmy. Thanks, baby. I really need an orange or something. This fellow's upsetting me terribly.

The girl trails her hand gently through the boy's hair, bites her lip, muses over his problem. Then comes up with a solution. The box of candy she had brought. Opens it. Makes a decision. Bites into it. Takes the orange out of his hands. Feeds the candy to the boy. You're a blast, son. Believe the happy convalescent.

And into December Street. Walk it. And against background of wind-frayed tinsel, wind-frayed crowd, pose the violence. The murdered man, Charles Ralston, the man who in March of last year had run down the street, had run down a boy. Boy, Jimmy Barton, who used to work at filling station but couldn't face the thought anymore. Nineteen-year-old boy with nice apartment, expensive things to wear, to touch. Boy found beaten and $60 in his pocket. Boy with girl, Ina. Boy without job. Run down nine months ago by Charles Ralston. Beaten two nights ago. Assailant unknown. And enjoying every minute of it.

So go now to a place to ask a question. Adler, insurance brokers in Madison.

Mr. Adler is highly pleased to meet you. And won't you have a seat? His face will only take another minute. These shavers, electric and all, a boon. A boon, Mr. Clover, to the male civilization. I must relay to the Remington people my thoughts on the subject. Here, feel this. Come on over here and feel my cheek.

Look, Mr. Adler, I didn't move. I can tell you. When I get through with her, Mrs. Crummett will tell you the same thing I did. What? Adelaide Crummett, our newest widow. Husband tripped in the shower bed this morning. Died on the way to the hospital. That's why I'm primping my face. I'm on my way right now to tell Adelaide. Poor Mrs. Crummett. Husband's insurance, all hers. It'll perk her up. Best baseball with the newly rich widows, huh, Mr. Clover? You're through now? What's your problem, Mr. Clover? Charles Ralston. Hello. Murdered, I read. You want to check on his insurance? See, I'm way ahead of you. All right, tell me. My opinion is you should bark up another tree, Mr. Clover. All Ralston carried was 10,000. 20-year life. These days, 10 grand is hardly worth killing for, isn't it? But his court costs. Et cetera, et cetera. Is his wife a beneficiary? Why don't you think about that? Tell me. A year ago, she wasn't. Four months ago, she wasn't. Now she is. Go on. The Ralstons had a boy, 18, Charles Jr. He was a beneficiary. A year ago, it happened to him in Korea. Right away, Mr. Ralston wanted to change the beneficiary to his wife. She wouldn't hear of it. She said keep it for his son. What? Mothers in my business do that sometimes. They don't believe their boys are really killed. They're just lost, not dead. Three months ago, Mrs. Ralston came around to the War Department's way of thinking, and the husband. So she let her husband make her beneficiary.

Ralston carry accident insurance liability? Oh, you mean about when he ran down the kid, James Barton? That's right. Yeah, he carried. But we didn't pay a red cent. Mrs. Ralston wanted us to pay, but I outlined to her how the boy swore up and down it was his fault. So, being foolish. It didn't really penetrate, though. No? No. I hear she paid off all the boy's hospital bills, sent him books, California fruit, things like that. Well, look, Mr. Clover, if you knew how anxious a widow gets, how she hates to be kept waiting. Yeah, you told me. Have fun, Mr. Adler.

Dr. Penske? Come in, Danny, come in. Have a chair. Now, what can I do for you this evening? How long has it been since you were at the hospital to see Jimmy Barton? Five this afternoon. He told me you were in this morning. He said you upset him. Upset him. I have a theory about that boy. What? Someone could beat him over the head with a baseball bat, and he would become unconscious. As far as beating him over the emotions, he would only grin at you. The layman phrase for it is, uh, tough cookie. A real hard boy, Danny. How badly was he hurt? Contusion. A bruise. He'll be released tomorrow. Could it be done tonight? I think so. Well, think about it right now, doctor, and tell me. All right, I'll release him. Good. Use your phone, doctor? Help yourself.

Danny Mugovan? Yeah? Jimmy Barton's going to be released from the emergency hospital. Tell him. Right, where? Waiting to hear from you, in my office. That's right. I'll turn up the heat and think about you, Mugovan. Thanks, doctor.

The word was warm. The office. To look through a window out on the word was cold. City seemed through beads of moisture. Crowd fleeing to a thousand places. Winter lights that speckled winter sky with colors and fleeting shapes. Winter building gray and stark. All of it framed in a patina of wet. Look at it. Wait for it. Wait. And it happened.

Danny Clover. You can come out now, Danny. The lady's apartment. Be right there. Kid left the hospital. Made a phone call. Came out over here. Let's go in.

Hello, Mrs. Ralston. Mind if we come in? Yes, I do. Oh, that's too bad. Uh, we wanted to tell Jimmy how glad we are he's up and about your apartment. What are you talking about? You got another way of saying it, Danny? Just let's go inside, Mrs. Ralston.

Who was it, Claire? Some men. They're here. Police. Hi, fellas. Make yourself at home. How do you feel, Jimmy? Claire says I look awful. He does. Claire was gonna make me a poultice. Isn't that what you call it, Claire? A poultice? Mr. Clover. Yes? Uh-huh. Uh-huh. Uh-huh. Uh-huh. Uh-huh. Mr. Clover. Yeah? He's been through so much. Yeah, we were worried. Yeah. That's right, Jimmy. Worried why a 19-year-old boy gets beaten up, lands in a hospital. That's civilization for you, isn't it? What are you doing here, Jimmy? I'm gonna tell you something I really don't know. Honest. Jimmy. Honest, Claire. I got out of the hospital and I figured it was what you'd like me to do. Call you, come over here. But I gotta tell you, too, I'm not gonna do it. I'm gonna go to the hospital. I'm gonna go to the hospital. I'm gonna go to the hospital. I'm gonna go to the hospital. I'm gonna go to the hospital. I'm gonna go to the hospital. I got out of the hospital and I figured it was what you'd like me to do. Call you, come over here. But I gotta tell you, too, I don't know why. The presents, Jimmy? The monogrammed shirts? The knitted sweaters? Part of it. Not all. Jimmy. I think you'd better go home. Why? Just go. Stick around, son. Why do you want me to go home, Claire? Boy. She doesn't want you to be hurt. I'm not gonna be hurt. That's all over. You wanna tell us who beat you up now? No. Well, it keeps eating you guys, don't it? Not especially, Jimmy. We know. Well, huh? Listen, you two. It's got to end now, Mrs. Ralston. You can't protect him anymore. And it started ending when your husband beat him up. Claire. What? They figured it out themselves. I didn't tell them. That's what worried us, son. A kid gets beaten up by an older man, normal procedure is to come running. Why didn't you? It would have spoiled a good thing. What are you talking about? I'm old enough to be. I'm old enough to be. I'm old enough to be. I'm old enough to be. I'm old enough to be. I'm old enough to be. I'm old enough to be. His mother. Yeah, his mother. Is that what it is, Claire? His mother? Substituted this boy for your son who was killed in Korea. What is it? You lied to us, Jimmy, when you said you hadn't seen the Ralstons after you walked into their car. Well, after all, well, I figured I owe this lady something. This. This lady. This lady. Oh. Oh. Oh. Oh. Oh. Oh. Oh. Oh. Oh. Oh. Oh. Oh. Oh. Oh. Oh. Oh. Oh. Oh. You got a blast giving me presents, taking care of me. Why shouldn't I do something you ask me? Like lie to cops. Even when it had murder in it. I didn't kill anybody. She did. I still got presents. And that's all that counted? Sure. I'll just see what's happened to me. All I know is Claire gave me an allowance that made her happy. But not her husband. He got sick of it. Beat you up, told you to stay away. Claire? What, Jimmy? Is that what you wanted? To be my mother? Yes. That's a fresh one. Jimmy, are you sorry for me? What happens to that insurance you're supposed to get now? Do you think you'll get it? Knocking over Mr. Ralston and me? No. I could sure use it. I just thought I'd ask. Forget it.

The hour without color. The six o'clock hour. The time of going home. But in a while, the night will dip down and touch the sky. The street, and there'll be fury again. And rack, and roar, and crowd. The puppet dance into the furnace of light. The most violent, the most...

Broadway's My Beat stars Larry Thor as Detective Danny Clover, with Charles Calvert as Tartaglia, and Jack Kruschen as Mugovan. The program is produced and directed by Elliot Lewis. The musical score composed and conducted by Alexander Courage. In tonight's story, Paula Winslow was heard as Claire Ralston, and Sam Edwards as Jimmy Barton. Featured in the cast were Alvina Temple, Steve Dunn, and Tom Holland. Bill Anders speaking.

End of transcriptBack to the beginning ↑