Skip to content
On Air
All channelsAll
Calling All Cars artwork

From the Calling All Cars collection

The Cut Rate Murder

Episode 020April 11, 193432 min 14 secTranscript

The written record

Read the transcript

Read along with the recording · About 13 min to read

The police in California and Arizona know all too little about the stupendous task successfully achieved each day by the police of our large population centers such as Los Angeles. The public learns through the press and by radio of but a few of the exploits and workings of a large body of men and women whose duty and responsibility it is to enforce the law and protect our citizens against the loss or injury of persons and property naturally attracts a great deal of public attention. It is therefore fair and almost a necessity for all of us giving information concerning the work of our law enforcement agencies to stress the fact that being given wide information constitutes but a small fraction of the work done by your police department. The story I have chosen for you tonight illustrates how necessary it is for our men to be trained and experienced and alert in the investigation of crimes, particularly those who have but few clues to the identity of the person committing them are available for the police to work upon. The crime we are to portray for you tonight was one of the most brutal and cold-blooded in the history of our local police work. The man that conceived it worked carefully and almost successfully in building up an unbeatable alibi. The man who actually committed the crime as a tool of the man who planned it was by circumstances far removed from any suspicion and may not have been a criminal. And might have evaded justice were it not for the intelligence established in the case by Captain Bright.

How can you do not to take highul the man? What do you do on here? What's the matter, child? Why are you crying? How about you? What's this? What is this? What is this? What is this? What is this? What is this? What is this? What is this? What is this? Where can we find him? I'll go with you and found the weapons at L's house. Exactly what you did yesterday from the time you got up until you went to bed. The day begins at 6 o'clock in the evening. I found my mother's ass for a few bucks this morning when I went home. Can you prove that? Sure. All you gotta do is ask Harry Hancock. Killed sometime after midnight. Are you sure you didn't leave the cafe at any time during the night? Of course I'm sure. Besides, why should I want to kill my wife? She's not my wife anyway. We're divorced. It sounds like you threatened her life on television. That sounds like Herman Cannon talking. Well, it ain't so. Sure, we had a share of arguments. Like anybody else, that's all. I'll tell you, you got the wrong guy if you think I killed her. I can prove where I was all day and all night yesterday. And what more do you want? The truth. You had a possible motive for wanting her out of the way. True, isn't it, that you kidnapped the baby after the court gave your wife custody of it? I took her into Arizona with me. Then he got sick and I brought him back to his mother. Listen, you guys are all wet on that score. I get to see my baby whenever I want to. But you're barking up the wrong tree. I didn't have any motive for wanting to bump Merle off.

That's enough for now. Take him out, Sergeant, and bring in his brother.

Yes, sir. Cool about the whole business.

Yeah, and so is his brother. And he asked me if the gun we found, and I told him it was being examined for fingerprints. And he laughed and said, well, that'll tell you who the murderer is.

Hmm, there are a couple of them who do cotton to me.

Flankin' Marounds, what do you mean making your rounds? I'm a deputy constable out in Maywood. Listen, I spent a night patrolling my district. Who do you think killed your sister-in-law? How should I know? Why did you laugh this morning when I told you that the shotgun was being examined for fingerprints? Did I laugh? Fingerprints were found on the gun. Is it possible you knew that the murderer was gloved? I don't know anything about it. Take him back to his cell, Sergeant.

Yes, sir. He's got my goat.

You've been living with the Ells boys, haven't you?

Yes.

Well, how come?

Well, I've been out of work, so they let me stay in the garage and eat with them and return for doing odd jobs around the place. Where were you? I saw you yesterday and last night. I rode around with Alfred in his car before he went to work. Bought some groceries and then went back to the house. I didn't leave again all evening. Did anything unusual happen during the evening? No. No. I sat up with Donald, Ells' kid brother, till about one o'clock, listening to some hillbillies on the radio. Did he come in? No. What do you know about this murder? Nothing. Honest to God, Inspector. I don't see what you're holding me for. I've got nothing to do with it at all. Did you ever hear him say he wished Merle was dead? No. Oh, I never heard him say anything. I don't know anything about it. Because I don't know anything about it. And he hasn't the guts to hold it back long. Either he did the job or he cracked the whole arm.

The identity of the king feels that Emery L., a hard alibi, substantiated by testimony of his employer, still can be broken. And Emery is proven to be the slayer. They feel that Alfred is a knight to commit the crime, although a motive for Alfred seems to be lacking. In contrast to the cruel self-assuredness of the Ells, their testimony is revealed, with all of the explanations of the Ells brothers regarding their whereabouts on the fatal night seeming to eliminate them as suspects. Emery Ells had been heard to remark that he would hire somebody to kill his wife. Following this stringent bit of information, the officers heard a murdered woman.

Yes, Inspector. Merle has told me several times that she feared Emery would kill her.

Why? That he threatened her life?

Yes. Well, that is, I've heard him tell her that he'd get her sooner or later. And I've seen him strike her. When was that? Well, last summer, Merle and I were running a hot dog stand down at the beach. And one night, Emery came down there and told her he wanted her to take a walk with him so that he could talk to her. I heard him say, come on, so I won't have to hurt you. A while later, she came running back crying. And she told me that he'd tried to push her over the palisade. She was off to Drew. She was fighting him off. And then later in the evening, he came back and tried to drag her off in his car. Then we called the police. And they took him away.

Why should they always... Well, he wanted to get her out of the way because she knew too much about some of the jobs he pulled.

What do you mean, jobs do you mean? You'd better tell us what you mean.

Oh, listen, Lieutenant. I don't want to get into any trouble. Just leave it at that. I don't know any more about Emery. And I don't want to.

A black flashlight was found in Alfred Ells' automobile. He had missed ownership of it. The blood spot on the clothesline behind the Ells house was found a pair of fresh shoes. Free blood. This evening, another officer is at...

Now, look here, Morton. You've admitted those trousers are yours. And that brands you as a murderer because the stains on those trousers are blood.

Oh, no, you're crazy. I told you they're grease. Just grease spots from the last time I worked on Alfred's car.

Morton, you're lying. I swear I'm not. You know more about this case than you're telling us.

No, I don't. Honestly, I don't. I don't know anything about it.

You'd better come clean because that's the only way you're going to save your own neck. I tell you, I've got nothing to confess.

The blood's thicker than water. Those Ells boys will stick together. Show yourself in the hot spot before you get through with it. Those trousers are being analyzed right now. And we'll soon know whether you're telling the truth.

I had nothing to do with you. Do you know who did it?

No. No. No, I swear to God I don't.

Truth?

Yes. Well, you know, I'm kind of glad that you're not the man. And I need one. This is a Democratic administration. That'll fix things up. A Democrat... No, sir, I know what I'm talking about. A Democrat in the White House? Who? Killed Merle Ells. Filcus, I told you I don't know anything about it. You do, Bolton. Now stop holding out on me. Maybe I do have my suspicions. He traveled with some pretty tough... I don't know his first person along with me. It was his responsibility. Was it Brown or wasn't it? Well, it... Was it or wasn't it? ...talking one time, and this fellow Brown said he was a gunman, and that he knew how to handle a machine gun. And then later, Emery and I went down to the riverbed and fired out Emery's old 12-gauge shotgun. But mind you, I'm not saying he did it. Just the same. Let me in. I'll get you there until I get something on. Okay. Make a move, Brown.

Fiction of murder. ...was the house and... I don't know a thing about it. Look me in the eye, Brown. Now, if you tell all the lies, you can tell the truth. Why, what do you mean? What about the time that you and Emery Ells were over at his house planning that hunting the fox feed? What about the murder of Merle Ells?

All right! Emery hired me to do the job. You see, we talked about the deal for a long time. A couple of months, I guess. Then Emery told me finally the other night that I'd get two girls... for the job. Well, he took me over to the house on 99th Street and showed me the layout. He pointed out the porch where the Dane slept. When we were all set, Emery gave me the gun and the flashlight. And I stole a car and... the lead pipe... See? So I snuck up to the sleeping porch and looked in. There was a woman with a kid sleeping right beside her. Gee, I hadn't figured on them being so close together. And Emery had told me that he'd kill me if I hurt the kid. Finally, I figured if I got the danger set up, I wouldn't hit the kid when I... when I let her have it. So I flashed the light in her face and said, Merle, wake up. Emery had told me her name was Merle. Well, she opened her eyes kind of snooty-like and said, what's the matter? Then I lost my nerve. Yeah, I didn't have the guts to... to shoot her. It was too easy. So I beat it back to the car and drove off. I guess I rode around for about an hour. Oh, half an hour, trying to dope out whether I should do it or not. Then when I felt like I could go through with it, I went back. But I lost my nerve again. Gee, she looked so young and sweet, like a little girl sleeping there. Well, I rode around some more. And I... I called myself all sorts of names and I drove like the devil, almost hoping I'd wreck the car and kill myself. And suddenly, something inside of me snapped. It snapped. Everything went red and yellow behind my eyes. And I went back and... Oh, thank God I didn't hurt the kid.

Did you get the $2,000 for the job?

No. And they double-crossed me. Just before the bump-off, I told them I was broken. They gave me 22 dimes. Ticks, I suppose. That's all I ever got. $2.20. It'll cost you who you're next. Oh, I was brought into face with the fact that I was and the confession has entangled him in the nature of the hideous crime. As he enters the room and sees him pass his feet.

Well, you've met this man before, I believe.

Not that I know of. Service a few nights ago. I never saw him before. I don't know what you're talking about.

No? Kid, not because of what she had on you.

Oh, she didn't have nothing on me. Enough to send you up.

Despite of their fine confession, not guilty when brought to trial. And Brown thinks not guilty and not guilty by reason of insanity. Hell, just by purse. His opponent jumps to his feet, when Emory... I move that that statement be stricken from the record. What grounds do you base your motion? My client was tired, sick, and beaten over a period of four days in order to sweat that confession out of him. This is no document of truth. It is a scroll of poverty. Are you prepared to prove your statement? I am, your honor. January the 8th, found guilty of first degree murder by a jury which recommended life in prison. On January 12th, 1931, he was sentenced to stand for life.

Brown, although he threw himself on the mercy of the courts with a plea of guilty, received the death penalty on January 16th, 1931. And on July 14th, that same year, he was hanged by the neck until dead.

Now, here is another case from the police files of Southern California and Arizona.

Now is the time to enjoy your car. But be sure that your car is properly conditioned, properly fueled, and lubricated. Why not rely on the proven performance of Rio Grande Crude with Tetra-Ethyl, the official gasoline of the police and fire departments? You'll enjoy those even, steady pick-ups that come with high test power.

Lubrication is very important now. Why not try Rio Grande Crude's companion product, the new Clearopaline motor oil? No more than ordinary oil in price, with superior quality because it has been subjected to a certain refining process.

End of transcriptBack to the beginning ↑