Skip to content
On Air
All channelsAll
Calling All Cars artwork

From the Calling All Cars collection

Marks on the Bedroom Screen

Episode 041September 5, 193429 min 53 secTranscript

The written record

Read the transcript

Read along with the recording · About 21 min to read

Run brand of gasoline regularly and make that brand Rio Grande Cracked. Rio Grande Cracked will give your car the same dependable police performance demanded by the police and fire department of the Great Southwest. Smart purchasing agents demand the gasoline that delivers good mileage. Pay more attention to a fraction of a cent per mile what it costs to operate automotive equipment. Rio Grande Cracked will give you as many miles for your money as any gasoline you can buy. Do your tank tomorrow at your Rio Grande dealer for sparkling performance and dependable mileage. It will settle your gasoline problems for good. The quality never varies.

Now, we're going to introduce Captain Bert Mellis. That is, a homicide squad of the Los Angeles Police Department. I have a personal message for you.

Good evening, Captain Mellis.

Good evening.

Good evening, friends. Tonight, Chief Davis has selected a story which is somewhat the reverse of our usual procedure. Tonight, we will tell you how... how hard a police officer works to get a man out of prison.

Crime happens in the work of keeping the peace when cold scientific police procedure meets with heated and disheveling emotions. That mistake... police officer is locked on a case to see a man who, in her living room, on a quiet month, kicked in with a drink.

Come on, hurry up. We're impatient to pull this trigger.

I'll try to find him. One peep out of you and it'll be your last.

This is time to think. Let's see. Haven't got all night.

Lady, I'll give you just three counts to get those dollars. One. Two. Three. And come back here. Yes, you're just outside the door. Is anything the matter up the street?

Yes. Woman has just come. Won't go around here. She's not out here.

What happened, young man?

I don't know. I just saw a runner of flesh sticking out of your pocket.

In what? What's happening with the girl?

Henry, do you hear that? I'm sure I'll plug you too.

She's still breathing. Somebody get some water.

No, I'll go get some. And then even a handkerchief.

Oh, we've got to stop the blood. Give it to him, Sam.

Oh, thank God. On his way, Doctor.

Stand back there. Stand back there. The other half from there. Come on.

Yes, sir. Keep these people back.

Yes, sir. Now you're allowed to get back, folks. All right. Far. Move right down.

I did what I could for her, Doctor.

Oh, poor Mrs. Watson. It looks like the bullet pierced the lung. She was such a good neighbor.

Evans, we'd better get her in the hospital in a hurry.

Yes, sir. I'll stay here until the homicide men arrive, Doctor.

Very well, come on.

Now, what do you people know about this?

Hey, one minute. Just a minute. One at a time. One at a time.

Hey, you first, ma'am.

Well, it was about 7:30, and I...

Hey, just a minute. What's your name?

Why, Mrs. Reynolds. Mrs. Edward Reynolds.

That's true. Why, Mr. and Mrs. Watson.

Yeah, that was the victim's name, eh?

Yes. With him, or is her husband living?

Oh, he's living.

Well, where is he?

I don't know. I think it was his lunch night.

Oh, I see. What do you know about this?

Well, just as I was saying, I was putting Junior to bed about 7:30, and Mrs. Watson playing the piano. She plays so beautifully. And that tube went by about on our radio.

What?

It's the only music I get.

Yes, yes, yes. So do I. But what happened?

Mrs. Watson playing the bass drum. All of a sudden, she stopped. And she never stopped in the middle of a piece. Well, I remember the day Heinemann's butcher shop caught fire, and she went right on banging it.

What did you hear after she stopped?

Well, then I heard a man's voice speaking in a low tone, and I tried to listen for it. It wasn't Mr. Watson's voice. But Junior down and went right over to the window. But there was no night in the dining room, and I couldn't see very much.

Well, who did you hear?

Well, I couldn't make... Oh, anything, until I heard Mrs. Watson getting excited. And then she screamed for help, and there was a shot, and someone ran out of the house.

How did he look like?

Well, I... I just took a good look at him.

Is that all you know?

Yes, I guess that's about all.

Well, I know a lot more about this than Mrs. Reynolds, and I didn't have to speak to anyone signing to find out.

Now, look here, Mrs. Stanley. What are you making any of this about? You may think, ladies, that you're letting some trouble up.

Your name, Mrs. Stanley?

Yes. Mrs. McQuishmire Stanley. And this is my husband. Please, to make your acquaintance. After I heard the shot, I called Mr. Stanley out on the porch. Of course, he said it was a backfire, but I've learned not to pretend upon what he said.

Oh, no, ma'am, that wasn't...

Well, it was a shot all right. And just a moment later, a man ran up on the porch and told us a woman had been shot and asked to use the phone. He called the police, and just as I was asking him about it, I saw a gun sticking out of his pocket. And when I accused him of shooting poor Mrs. Watson, he threatened to kill me.

Oh.

How'd he look like?

Looked like... So dark, I couldn't tell.

I thought you knew so much about this, Mrs. Stanley.

And I do.

You didn't see him drive away in a Ford Roadster, did you?

A Ford Roadster? He drove away in a Ford Roadster? And he told the officer the license number.

Well, I didn't think...

You didn't think? Mortimer, are you going to stand there and hear me insulted by this... By this... Nobody? Nobody!

Well, look here, Mrs. Stanley, I won't... I'll have you know that... Well, you and anyone else can talk to me like that.

Is that so?

Yes, it is. Listen, Mr. Mortimer, do something. Something.

He finally restored. A nigger information gleamed from such witnesses as there are. The investigation had turned over to Howard Barlow, who closely examined Mrs. Watson's house for fingerprints.

Well, apparently he entered the house through this window here.

Yeah, the screw's been taken out. And by the look of this deep shoe print under the window, he left the house the same way. Now, let's take a look at this screen.

Not bad. I think we can get a couple of fair prints out of this thing. Might as well take a look. Get in the central and photograph a bit.

Okay, Howard.

The latent fingerprints found by Sergeant Barlow are not for him and are for the sheriff's office, which sends copies to the State Bureau of Identification in Sacramento. A search of the files in the police department failed to link these latent fingerprints with any on record.

And as soon as she is able to be questioned, Mrs. Watson receives a visit from an investigating officer.

Now, Mrs. Watson, can you give us any better description of the man who shot you than the one we have?

Well, Lieutenant, he had a scarf around his face. And it was difficult. He'd make out his features. There was one thing that impressed me, though.

Hmm, what was that, ma'am?

It was I. He drew them into slips when he talked.

I see. Do you think you would recognize him if you saw him again?

Yes. I believe I would.

Have you any idea who might have held you up?

No, I haven't. But it might have been Donovan Vance.

Hmm, Vance?

You see, Mr. Watson has been quite active in politics around the neighborhood and he's been responsible for quite a few criminals being sent to San Francisco. Apparently, several of them have been threatened today evening.

Oh, I see. Well, that is a possibility.

But several days go by and police are unable to connect the crime with any of Mr. Watson's political enemies or with any of the records on file. Then in a rooming house on Park Road Street occurs an incident which is dressed to have great bearing on the case.

I tell you, Mrs. Guinness, this has got to stop. I'm moving out.

Sure, and what is it now, Mr. Fitz?

Now, it's my pants.

Ah, sure, and the sense betrays. What's the matter? What's the matter with your pants? Do you want them patched, maybe?

No, I don't want them patched. I haven't got them to be patched.

Well, now, where are they, Mr. Fitz?

They've been stolen.

Stolen, you say?

Yes, stolen. And I know who did it. I know. It's that Christian fellow in room 105.

And what makes you think he took them?

Because I saw him wearing them this morning.

That devil, you say?

Yes. Well, I won't have bones on like that in my house. Now, you come along with me and we'll see about it.

What's he going to do?

Well, we're going to talk to Mr. Fitz about his travel.

How long now? I've never had him bring them back to me in my house. I don't want to have a pair of my sister's hands in my house.

Good afternoon, Mrs. Guinness.

Mr. Fitz, whose pants is them?

Why, they're mine.

No, they're not, young man. They belong to me. You stole them.

I did not steal them. I bought them from Jimmy Black. And they're my pants.

Well, I didn't know they were copper. I wouldn't have bought them.

Mrs. Guinness, I don't believe this young man's story.

Well, it doesn't sound straight to me either. I'm going to get to the bottom of it.

What do you mean?

Young man, I run a decent house here. And I don't want the likes of you into it.

Okay, I'll move.

That was my bad, John. I know you'll move. And it'll be in the police patrol you'll be moving. I've been missing things around my place, too. And I'm going to find out who's been taken. And I'll know the reason why.

So, Jimmy Preston is arrested and lodged in the county jail on suspicion of robbery. His fingerprints are dented back to mental. And police are related to receive a reply from the... Bureau of Identification that they bear a general similarity to the prints found on the screen at Mrs. Watson's house.

Sergeant Barlow immediately checks the prints and discusses his findings with a brother officer.

Why, it's ridiculous. There's no point of identity between the latents we found and this man's prints.

Yeah, but he might be the same man, mightn't he?

Not a chance.

Well, just this time I'm going to take him over to the hospital and see if Mrs. Watson can identify him.

You're just wasting your time.

Yeah, maybe, but it's worth it.

Now, Mrs. Watson, is this the man that held you up?

It's so hard to be sure. But then, you've always found his fingerprints are the same, haven't you?

Well, Sacramento reports a similarity.

Listen, lady, I don't know what this is all about, but I know this much. I never saw you before in my life.

Yes, Lieutenant. I'm sure now that this is the man. Notice the way his eyes draw down to slip. He's the one, all right.

Say, lady, you don't know what you're saying. You're railroading me. You're sending an innocent guy to the pen. I never done nothing to you. The other night that guy plugged you, I was in jail in San Diego.

I should think, young man, when you're thinking up a, oh, what do you call it? Oh, yes, an alibi, that you have enough pride not to lie about being in jail elsewhere.

What difference does it make where I was? I didn't do nothing to you.

This is the man, Lieutenant. There's no doubt about it. And men of his type should be in prison. I'll do everything I can to cooperate with you. I'll help in every way to see that he's sent there. For good. And I hope it will be a lesson to you, young man.

I've been found guilty of burglary, of robbery, and of assault with a... Therefore, James Preston, I hereby sentence you to serve from 11 years to life in San Quentin Prison.

Now, I tell you, Chief, this is one of the most outrageous miscarriages of justice I've ever heard of.

Ah, quiet down, Sergeant. Let me get the straight of this. Begin at the beginning.

This man spent... Preston's prints bear a general resemblance and outline to those I found on the screen at the Watson home. But they are not identical. There is not one single point of similarity. Why, Preston is no more guilty of this crime than you or I.

Well, I don't know what you can do about it. You've had your chance.

I had no chance, sir. The first I knew of his trial was on a Reddit this afternoon's paper that he'd been sentenced. I was never subpoenaed to appear.

You weren't?

No. They convicted that man on Mrs. Watson's general identification and the general similarity of prints.

Why, it's ridiculous. No way. He couldn't... Wait a minute, young fellow. Don't go off the deep end.

Well, it makes me burn. We've got to do something about it, Chief. We can't let an innocent man go to prison.

There isn't much we can do about it. Judgment has been passed.

Well, it isn't fair.

Well, there's only one thing for you to do now, then.

What's that, sir?

Find the man who left his fingerprint on Mrs. Watson's screen. If you can find the real criminal and convict him on your fingerprint evidence, then you can free Preston.

And in the meantime, Preston has to go to San Quentin for a crime of which he is innocent.

I'm afraid so, Sergeant.

Very well, then. I'm going to find the real criminal if I have to go over every single one of the 300,000 prints in our files.

For the next year and a half, Barlow, the police officer who works by exact science, rather than the undependable emotionality of witnesses, checks and re-checks his ponderous pile of fingerprints. Every burglar suspect brought in for questioning, his fingerprints are compared with the marks left on Mrs. Watson's screen. Still, nothing comes of the patient search.

Now, when he gets in the Ford, let him drive by us and then force him into the curb.

Okay. What if he starts shooting?

That's all I want. If he starts shooting, I'll let him have it. And the taxpayers are spared the expense of trying him.

What a vigilante you are. Rope in justice, huh?

Sure, why not? Policing rats like these guys costs the people too much dough.

Okay. Stole the frontier ideas. Here comes our guy.

12. He's getting into the car now. He's rolling. Let's go. Over the car.

What's up, you guys? Over the end. Reach. Keep him there.

What is this? Get up. Get out of the car. Get out.

Hey, keep your hands up. I'll open the door.

All right, frisk him, partner, while I keep him covered.

Okay. Huh? There's a .45 in his pocket. Uh-oh.

Well, a nice, shiny .45 and a leg holster.

Look here, you guys. I can explain this.

Yeah, I know. You were using these to hug goldfish.

Sure. Well, save your breath for headquarters. You'll have plenty of explaining to do down there.

The suspect who says his name is Carroll is brought in, fingerprinted, and booked on suspicion of robbery. Sergeant Barlow checks his prints against those found in the recent holdups and faces the man with these facts.

Well, Carroll, are you ready to confess?

Confess what?

Oh, you know that better than we do.

Well, maybe I do, but you guys are paid to find out things. Suppose you'll find out something about me.

Very well. We'll show you how far we've gotten. Barlow, suppose you tell Carroll what we know about him.

Well, Carroll, on December 29th, you burglarized the home of Charles McInnes on Glendale Boulevard. On July 4th, you broke into W. Barker's house on Western Avenue. And on January 2nd, you committed a burglary at 5012 Beverly Boulevard. Shall I go on, or are you convinced?

How do you know all that?

Fingerprints. You left a nice set of prints on every one of those jobs.

No?

Well, we think they do.

Yeah? Well, not a lot you know about them. If I told you what I know about fingerprints, an innocent guy would be sprung from San Quentin.

What do you mean?

Oh, nothing.

What do you mean?

What are you talking about?

Well, some guy that got mixed up in a robbery and a shooting a couple of years ago.

Who do you mean? Preston?

I've said all I'm going to say.

Well, maybe that was too much, Carroll. Maybe you're the man I've been looking for for a year and a half.

Barlow, at the end of his long search in sight, rushes back to his office to compare those window screen prints for perhaps the last time. Elated with what he discovers, he bursts into the chief's office.

Well, Chief, I found him.

I know.

Well, the man who shot Mrs. Watson.

Yeah?

Yes, sir. Yes, sir. Look at these prints. Identical, aren't they?

Yep. Exact duplicates. Twenty-five or thirty points of similarity. More than four times enough for a conviction.

Who is the man?

Name's Carroll, alias the Weasel.

Has he confessed?

No, he refuses to admit or deny anything. Now, Chief, how can we get Preston out of San Quentin?

It's going to be hard to do. We've got to have a tight case.

Well, what tighter case would you want than these prints?

Oh, true. But first, the victim should be convinced.

You mean Mrs. Watson?

Yes. Let's see if we can get an identification from her.

How? By pictures?

Yes. We'll go out to see her and take her half a dozen mugs of convicts. Ask her to pick out the one that looks like the man who shot her. Then see if she picks out Carroll's picture.

Okay, Chief. Let's go out right now, huh?

Mrs. Watson, I never bothered you about it before, but I've always felt that an innocent man was sent to prison in that shooting case of yours last year.

An innocent man?

Yes. I was never satisfied that Preston's fingerprints were the same as the ones on your screen.

Oh, but Mr. Barlow. That couldn't be. Why, I read in the paper that his fingerprints were the same. And naturally, when I saw him, I... Oh, well, maybe I was influenced by the story in the paper.

Well, the story in the paper was incorrect. Now, we think that we have the criminal in custody, and we want you to...

Why, of course. I'd be glad to help you in any way I can.

Very well. Now, here are ten pictures of criminals from our mug books. Do any of these men look like the fellow who held you up and shot you?

Now, wait until I put my glasses on. There. That's better. Now, let's see. No, that's nothing like him. Oh, no, not that one. No, that's not him. Oh, wait a minute. Here he is. Yes, I'm sure that's him. See how the eyes squint? That's just the way he looked at me.

You see that, Chief? She picked out the picture of Carroll.

Mrs. Watson, you're right this time. This man's fingerprints match exactly the prints left on your screen.

And you mean that the man in San Quentin is innocent?

Yes, Mrs. Watson, he is.

Oh, how terrible. Believe me, Sergeant, you can count on me to do anything I can to make up this terrible injustice to the poor man.

The superintendent of the State Bureau of Identification at Sacramento is asked to express an opinion on the Carroll prints and replies to Barlow that he is convinced that Carroll and not Preston is guilty of the attack upon Mrs. Watson. Barlow engages upon a voluminous correspondence with Preston at San Quentin, with the governor, and with the judge who sentenced Preston. The machinery set in motion for Preston's parole, Barlow appears in the office of the district attorney.

Now, I've sent you a statement of the facts of this case, sir. And now I'm prepared to ask you for a complaint charging Carroll with burglary, robbery, and assault with a deadly weapon with intent to kill.

You think you have a case?

Yes, sir. I've identified Carroll with six jobs, including the Watson job. The bullet taken from Mrs. Watson's body was shot from the same type of gun as found on Carroll.

What does Carroll say?

Well, he refuses to talk. And he's in the general hospital now for sanity observation.

I don't believe that he may be a victim of dementia praecox. But I think he's just faking to try to beat the rap for a stretch at Pat.

Now, I know this man is guilty. I have all the proof necessary to convict him, and I want you to prosecute him. Until Preston is freed from San Quentin, and Carroll takes his place, we can't claim to have any justice in this state.

Well, from what you've reported to me, Sergeant, I believe Carroll's guilty, all right.

Then you'll issue the complaint?

Yes, I will. And I'll prosecute the case myself.

A year and a half after he had entered the state penitentiary, the great gates of San Quentin open on James Preston, and he emerges a free man. He hastens to Los Angeles to meet Barlow, a man who has worked with such untiring effort in his behalf.

Gee, Sergeant, I don't know how to thank you, but any of any of those will do what you've done for me.

Oh, that's all right, Jimmy. I was convinced from the first that you were innocent, and I wasn't going to let you stay up there without fighting about it.

Maybe you don't know how it feels to be in my spot, to be free, out in the open again, to get a break. I don't know what to say.

Well, don't try to say it, Jimmy. I think I know what you mean. A great injustice has been done to you, and I don't know how we're ever going to make it up to you. But the boys in the department have made up a little purse. It isn't much, but maybe it'll help you get started. We want you to just accept it as our way of saying we're sorry you had to go up there.

Gee. The chief has arranged a job for you at the Ford plant. You can start to work next week.

Gee. And I used to think that coppers were rats.

The police tried to make some sort of retribution to Jimmy Preston. As to Carroll, he was found to be suffering from catatonic dementia praecox and was sent to Patton. Later, he was brought back and tried on charges of burglary, robbery, and assault with a deadly weapon with intent to commit murder. He pleaded not guilty by reason of insanity. At trial by four different juries, he was found sane at times crimes were committed, and he was sentenced to San Quentin Penitentiary for 50 years.

Calling All Cars is a presentation of the Rio Grande Oil Company. Rio Grande Cracked Gasoline is the police's preferred gasoline wherever it's sold. You can get police car performance from your car by patronizing your independent Rio Grande dealer. Sinclair Motor Oils are companion products of Rio Grande Gasoline. The American Automobile Association states that poor oil costs $40 million per year in damages and attendant repairs to American automobile motors and machinery. Why should motorists buy cheap bulk oil at $0.15, $0.25 per quart, not knowing how long it has been stored in dirty tanks? Sinclair Opaline is subjected to seven extra refining processes. It is made from Mid-Continent's finest crude oil and costs only $0.25 per quart. Sold only in sealed major tamper-proof cans. Don't gamble with your investment in your automobile when you can have positive motor protection with Sinclair Opaline at only $0.25 per quart at independent service stations.

KPFQ calling all cars, attention all cars, cancellation broadcast 41 regarding a holdup. That's all.

Calling All Cars is written and produced by William N. Robson. The orchestra is conducted by Frederick Stark. And this is Frederick Lindsley saying good night for the Rio Grande Oil Company.

End of transcriptBack to the beginning ↑