The written record
Read the transcript
Read along with the recording · About 21 min to read
The correct time is 8:30 p.m. This is a presentation of the Rio Grande Oil Company. Some high-priced fire equipment must be powered with the finest gasoline obtainable. And remember that wherever Rio Grande cracked gasoline has been sold, it has been the police-preferred gasoline. Why should you be satisfied with any other? The cracking process, my friends, has revolutionized the manufacture of gasoline. It gives you the extreme refining method. You get a gasoline which actually responds instantly to your throttle, which actually gives more power per drop, more miles per gallon. Spectacular rise in Rio Grande sales proves the truth of these statements. Thousands of new Rio Grande gasoline users in the Southwest know what performance really means. And now here is good news for the motorists of Northern and Central California. Within a few days, you too can have the same police car performance in your community. See Rio Grande in your car. Give it a pair with any other.
Ladies and gentlemen, we are very glad to welcome back to this microphone Chief James E. Davis of the Los Angeles Police Department. Police fans who wonder how the police discover that a crime has been committed and how they often develop its investigation to a successful conclusion with a seeming psychic power. Many of our startling crimes have been discovered through the alertness and coordination of the police. In just one month, we have been able to find the real source of the crime. A noteworthy example was the Ruth Judd case of Phoenix, in which had not an employee of the Southern Pacific Station been on the job, it might never have been solved, and mad Ruth Judd would today be a free woman. The story shows a completion of a necessary cooperation between the citizens and the law enforcement agencies and a cooperation between the Sheriff of Phoenix, Arizona, and your police.
The crime of Ruth Judd was an amazing, almost an unbelievable one. The way it was unraveled was equally as astounding. Frederick Linsley will begin the story.
Thank you, Chief Davis. At 7:45 on the morning of October 19, 1931, train number three rolled into the Southern Pacific Station from Phoenix, Arizona.
This lady's calling for those trunks. You know the two. There's something wrong with them.
Something wrong? Anything? Why, no. What do you mean? Strange odor? Why, yes. Now that you mention it, I think I do. What's in those trunks, Ruth?
Well, I have no idea what could smell like that, Burton.
Well, I'm sorry, ma'am, but you'll have to unlock the big trunk before I can let you have either of them.
Well, that's a little silly.
Can't help it, ma'am. This is mighty suspicious. You ain't been hunting deer, have you?
No, I haven't been hunting deer. But I haven't any keys with me. Perhaps I can find a key to fit the trunk.
Oh, I wouldn't do that. It might embarrass my... Well, I'll have to get the keys for my husband. I'll be back later in the day.
Does not reappear for the trunk. Van De Mark, Special Investigator for the Southern Pacific, telephones the Detective Bureau. And Detective Ryan is dispatched to the station where he hears the story from Anderson and Van De Mark.
That's about all there is to it. I never showed up again.
Well, where are the trunks?
I had to move them out on the platform.
Let's look at them.
Oh, this way.
No deer meat ever smells like that.
Detective Ryan searches through hundreds of keys at the baggage office until he finds one that will open the locks of the two trunks. When the lids are raised, a stifled gaze of the officer, the body of a woman shot through the head. In the smaller trunk is the inexpertly butchered body of a second woman, minus a section of the torso. Also found in the trunk are letters, postcards, and snapshots. Officers are able to identify the victims as Agnes Ann LeRoi and Hedvig Samuelson of 2929 North 2nd Street, Phoenix.
Ryan immediately phones Phoenix Police, giving them a description of the man and woman who called for the trunks. And the name and address is found with the body. An hour later, Ryan receives a call.
Homicide detail. Ryan... Just a moment, Lieutenant. Phoenix is on the wire. Go ahead, Phoenix.
What'd you find out?
I guess they're the victims, all right.
Yeah.
Well, we've got an almost positive identification. An identification of the Samuelson woman from the snapshots. But we can't be so sure about LeRoi. She's pretty badly messed up.
Find out anything else?
That checks. Somewhere now. Thank you very much. They tell me that our description matches that of Mrs. Ruth Judd, who left Phoenix by number three Sunday night.
Well, that's verified by this wire I got from the SP while you were talking. They say that those trunks were checked by a woman who gave her name as Mrs. McKennell. But the same woman bought her ticket under the name of Mrs. Judd.
I get it.
Homicide detail. Inspector Davidson speaking.
Oh, I've been tracing down the license number of the car that woman came to the station in.
Yeah? What'd you find out?
Well, the woman is from New Hampshire. She told him, and he said he sold it to Brayton McKennell.
McKennell? That's the name those trunks were checked here.
Ah, well, this McKennell lives in Beverly Glen. We're out at his house now.
Anyone home?
No. Might have been bought for this Judd woman. Pick up anyone who returns to the place.
Yes, sir.
Well, this McKennell, whoever he is, ties into the case, Ryan.
Oh. That car, this one. The woman used when she gave the trunk to long. The young man with her was McKennell. I've got Tories staking the joint. I hope somebody goes back there. It's our only clue.
Oh, no, it isn't, Inspector.
What do you mean?
I didn't get a chance to tell you before, but this Judd woman has been communicating with her husband. Uh, Dr. Judd at 654 13th Street in Santa Monica. Here, there's the dope.
Say, that's swell. Plus, go to this address in Santa Monica and talk to this Dr. Judd, and find out what he knows about this murder.
What is it? Where Dr. Judd lives?
Yes.
I'm his sister. Is he home?
Yes. Do you want to talk to him?
Well, come in, please. Thank you.
Where are you?
I'm from police headquarters. I thought you'd be here. I've been expecting you. Who's this young man with you?
That's my brother-in-law.
What's your name?
Burton McKennell.
Burton McKennell, huh? That's brother?
Yes. Were you with her when she went to the Southern Pacific Station to claim some trunks this morning?
Yes.
What happened, Dr. Judd?
Frankly, if I did, I wouldn't tell you. You can't blame me for that. Can you?
We want to know everything you know about this.
Well, I don't know where Ruth is.
Well, exactly what happened this morning?
Well, when I came out of my 11 o'clock class at the university, Ruth was waiting there for me. She said she wanted me to drive her down to the station and get some trunks and to hurry. When we got there, we couldn't get them. The baggage man said there was something wrong with them. Ruth seemed to be awfully nervous, but when I asked her what was wrong, she wouldn't tell me. She just said something about being able to justify herself later. Well, anyway, she wanted to go to 7th and Broadway, so I drove her there. Gave her $5, all the money I had with me, and she left me. And that's the last I saw of her.
Well, when did you come out here to see Dr. Judd?
About a half hour ago, fully expecting to see officers waiting for me, but there was no one here. I asked the doctor if he'd heard from Ruth recently, and he said he'd had a letter this morning, but he hadn't received any phone calls or anything. And I showed him the newspaper. It was a terrible shock to him.
Yes, it was, Lieutenant. I can't believe that Ruth was guilty. She's not a criminal type. She was never even flighty or... She was a sweet, steady girl in a beautiful way.
Do you know of any trouble that your wife had with... any disagreements they had?
Did your wife own a gun?
Yes, she had a Colt Automatic. I gave it to her several years ago when we were in Mexico, but... but she was always afraid of it.
Do you know of any friends that she has in Los Angeles that she might communicate with?
No, but if she did have any, I... I feel sure that I'd know about them.
Dr. Judd, will you help us locate your wife?
Yes. Yes, I'll do everything I can to persuade her to give herself up. I say this because I'm convinced that if Ruth did this thing, she had... she had good reasons for it. Of course, I can't do anything unless she gets in touch with me, and when she does, I'll ask her to give herself up. I know she is innocent. She couldn't have done this horrible thing. She was always so sweet and so kind. She couldn't have done it.
That night, the missing section of Hedvig Samuelson's body is found. Jammed into a suitcase, which had been left in charge of the matron in the lady's restroom at the Southern Pacific Station. The matron's description tallies with the other descriptions of Ruth Judd.
The following morning, Chief of Detectives Joseph F. Taylor takes personal charge of the search for the accused murderess. He holds counsel of war in his office.
Looks to me as though she couldn't get far if she's only got the five dollars her brother gave her. My hunch is she's somewhere in this town right now. Nevertheless, I want men to watch every railroad station, steamship dock, airport and bus line, in case she tries to duck out. Take care of that, Inspector.
Yes, sir.
And Inspector.
Yes, sir.
Ask the immigration officials to watch for her at the border. She speaks Spanish fluently, and she might try to get over the line to Mexico.
Yes, sir.
Autry.
Yes, sir.
Put her description on the state teletype to all points, and broadcast it to all radio cars.
Yes, sir.
Also broadcast direct to citizens, asking them to report all women hitchhikers.
I'll do that, sir. And I'll get the law. Go to the local radio station.
Go up, mate. That's fine. Now, boys, you realize we're going to get a lot of crank tips on this case. We always do. But I want you to run down every one of them, no matter how vague it is. I'm not going to give any of you any rest until Ruth Judd sits across this desk from me.
Mrs. Judd, Dr. Judd and Burton McKennell are kept under constant surveillance. While an officer is stationed in the house of Dr. Judd's sister in Santa Monica to investigate every telephone call, while newspapers scream headlines characterizing Winnie Ruth Judd as a velvet tigress, three long, fruitless days go by, during which nothing develops but a tangled welter of statements from Phoenix acquaintances of the principals of the crime that makes the motive for the crime more and more obscure. While the woman hunt continues, public interest rises to a fever heat. The man in the street discusses nothing else, and eagerly buys each edition of the newspaper in hopes of further news of the engrossing mystery. The Herald-Examiner offers $1,000. $1,000 reward for information leading to the apprehension of Ruth Judd. On Wednesday morning, the Times offers $1,500. The afternoon papers carry a public message from Dr. Judd. It reads, Ruth, come back. Please surrender. Come back and tell your story. You couldn't have done these things alone. Don't try to protect anyone. On Thursday, Dr. Judd states that if he could have but five minutes alone with his wife, he could persuade her to give herself up, whether she is right or wrong. Friday, the tension grows. As men start to discuss the case on the street, as housewives chat with neighbors about this amazing member of their sex, across the entire city, streets are feeling that something has to happen.
Then, shortly afternoon, in the office of the attorney retained by Dr. Judd, the phone rings.
Hello?
Not right now.
Who is it?
This is Ruth Judd.
Oh, yes. I must speak to the doctor.
Well, I can't talk right now. There are too many people around.
You call Mutual. 8-3-3-1. In an hour, and I'll have you there.
The attorney rushes to the Hall of Justice, where Dr. Judd is attending an inquest on the bodies of the two victims. Together, they return to the office to wait for the call. One o'clock. One-thirty comes and goes. The hands of the clock slowly approach two. Dr. Judd feverishly faces the silent telephone, and then...
Hello? Hello? Where are you?
I'm afraid to tell you, Doc. Please forget me. I'm afraid. I'm afraid.
But, Ruth, honey, if you tell me, Mr. Russell and I will come and get you, and we won't bring the police.
Come with, Doctor?
Of course.
Are you downtown?
All right. Do you know where the Biltmore Garage is? Well, you go there, and we'll meet you there in just a few minutes, dear.
The cell arranges with a friend of his who owns an undertaking parlor on Bunker Hill to meet them with a car at the Biltmore Garage and take them to his establishment until he can question his client. Then the doctor and the attorney hurry down Olive Street, the 5th, and up 5th to the Biltmore Garage. Dr. Judd recognizes his frightened wife and gestures to her to enter the garage. Then he goes in by another entrance and motions her to get into the funeral director's car. He follows her a moment later.
Oh, Doctor, don't let the police get me. Don't let them get me.
Don't you worry, darling. You'd better crouch down on the floor, Mrs. Judd.
All right. Okay, Dave, let's go.
You won't let the police get me, will you, Doctor? You won't let them, Mr. Russell, will you?
You'll have to talk that over, Mrs. Judd. First, let's get you out of sight.
At about the same time in Chief Taylor's office in the city hall, a tense group of cigarette-smoking reporters wait. Their eyes hollow from three sleepless nights on the job.
Well, if you ask me, she'll come drifting in on the beach one of these days. She was going to throw those punks in the ocean. She's probably done the same thing with herself by this time.
No, I think you're all wrong there. Now, my theory is that she...
Hey, hey, quiet down. Madeline's got a call.
Chief Taylor's office. Yes, he's in his office. Just a minute, please.
Sounds hot. Who was that, Madeline?
Just a personal call.
Oh, come on, Madeline, don't hold out.
Yeah, would you break down?
Well, if you must know, that was the chief's wife wanting to know if he'd be home to dinner.
Whose call is he waiting for, Madeline?
I told you, boys, I don't know. And we thought you were our pal.
Sure I am, but I don't know any more about this than you do. Wait, wait a minute, maybe this is it.
Chief Taylor's office. Just a moment. For you, Al.
Oh, thanks. Hello? Oh, yeah? Oh, yeah. Yeah. Okay.
Well, what was it?
Oh, nothing. The desk just phoned to be sure that I was here.
They got your number, all right. Checking up on you, huh?
Yeah, well, I guess I'll be running along.
Running along. Where? Do I have to raise my hand?
That doesn't sound right to me. I'll bet he's got a tip.
Chief Taylor's office. Yes, just a minute, please. For the chief?
Yes.
Well, who was it this time? His grandma?
Miss Hannah? Yes, chief. Come in, please.
Yes, sir. Close the door. I want you to phone the Alexandria Hotel and tell District Attorney Andrews to come down here and wait for me. He was returning to Phoenix tonight. Tell him to cancel his reservation. Said he used his phone in here.
Had they found her?
Yes. And I'm going over to get her right now.
Now, what's the word, chief? How about a statement, chief?
Nothing new yet, boys.
Well, where are you going?
Me? Oh, I'm just going out to get some cigarettes.
Well, boys, maybe we all better go out and get some cigarettes.
While Chief Taylor rushes to the undertaking establishment where Ruth Judd has been taken by her husband and his attorney, the haunted woman is being treated for a wound in her hand by Dr. Judd.
Oh, Dr. Donnie. Oh, that hurts.
Now, please be patient, Ruth. I've got to get the bandage off. It's all stuck.
That's the only reason I gave myself up. I was afraid of lockjaw.
Now, dear, this is going to hurt. Now, sit. There, now, there, now, now. Well, that is a very nasty wound.
Oh, what?
Hedwig did it. Hedwig shot me in the hand. I shot myself in defense, Dr. Deer. Mr. Russell, I shot myself in defense.
Yes, Mrs. Judd. But now you must be quiet. You didn't have to call the police, Mr. Russell. I don't see why you did that. I'm innocent. There's nothing else I could do, Mrs. Judd. If I hadn't informed the police, we'd all be open to prosecution for harboring a criminal.
Harboring a criminal, huh? So I'm a criminal. You're afraid for yourselves, is that it?
Now, please, Ruth, please, you must be quiet. Nobody has called you a criminal. We all believe that if you, if you did this thing, you were justified.
Of course I'll be justified. I sharpened self-defense. Oh, Dr. Donnie.
Now, I want to... I won't hurt you anymore. Now, this bandage will do until we get you to the hospital. Come in.
This is Mrs. Judd?
Yes. I'm a police officer, Mrs. Judd. I have here a warrant for your arrest on a charge of murder.
Yes. Will you come with me, please?
Yes. Oh, you've been injured.
I've been shot through the hand.
Then I'll send for an ambulance.
Oh, no. Please. I can go to the hospital in a car.
Very well. You'll come with me, please. The car is waiting downstairs.
Her hand dressed, Ruth Judd is escorted to police headquarters, but on advice of counsel, refuses to answer any of the police officer's questions. However, the next day, the detectives find the torn bits of a 16-page confession she had written to Dr. Judd, and then attempted to destroy in a drain of a lady's restroom. The torn bits are fitted together. Then Ruth Judd talks freely, although all her statements, as well as the content of the letter, are apparently designed to develop a plea of self-defense.
On October 29th, Ruth Judd is removed to Phoenix. And on January 19th, 1932, she goes on trial for her life. A trial which is highlighted by the alternate moodiness and hysteria of the accused, and by the battles of alienists on both sides in an attempt to build up and tear down an insanity plea.
On February 8th, the prosecuting attorney opens the argument for the state.
Gentlemen of the jury, you have heard the arguments of a distinguished... You have heard the arguments of a distinguished case. You have heard them testify to the alleged glandular disorders of the defendant. This is absolutely ridiculous and absurd, and it's the rankest nonsense. Ruth Judd knew what she was doing. Early in the game, her plans went wrong when she was faced with the necessity of changing the bodies from one trunk to two in order to get away with the shipment. And she did this. Yes, although she insists she'd been shot during the argument and at the time had a bullet lodged in her hand. I ask you, gentlemen, if this is possible. No, gentlemen, it is not. Ruth Judd did not have a bullet lodged in her hand on Friday night, nor yet on Saturday morning. You've heard the series of witnesses who saw that hand unbandaged on Saturday morning. Ruth Judd, gentlemen, shot herself in the hand sometime after Sunday morning or Saturday morning in an attempt to prove a defense plea. In doing this, she showed more sense than you or I would under similar circumstances. Gentlemen, if this is insanity, then we had best build a fence around the whole of Maricopa County and make an insane asylum out of it.
In a ridiculous farce, a weak attempt on the part of colleagues, the parliament of the jury, does not even prove that Mrs. Judd has committed this crime. The state has failed to show that Mrs. Judd was even at the murder apartment. You have heard the testimony regarding the pitiful delusions of motherhood suffered by the accused. You've heard of her unbalanced nature, poor creature, a victim of a hereditary strain of the body, and a victim of a hereditary strain of the body. She is not, at all times, responsible for her acts. I ask you, gentlemen of the jury, deal with her as you might with an erring sister. Understand her as you might a sick child. I ask you, gentlemen, to bring back a verdict of not guilty by reason of insanity and let the state take care of this woman as a sick person and not as a corpse.
That was near the murder. The apartment on October the 16th. You've heard the testimony of E.W. Jaggers, the streetcar conductor, who stated that he had seen Ruth Judd alight from his car near the bungalow where the crime occurred at 10 o'clock on either Friday or Saturday night. Well, gentlemen, it had to be Friday night because we have conclusive proof that at that hour on Saturday, Mrs. Judd was in the company of Mr. Schwartz, the transfer man who had been called to move the trunk containing the body. This woman, Ruth Judd, is a cold-blooded murderer who attained her end. Now, when we qualified you as jurors in this case, you told us you believed in the assessment of the death penalty in the process, that you thought the death penalty was written on the statute books of the law. I thought the state of Arizona was a good law. If this is not a proper case for the assessment of the death penalty, then I know of no such case.
In behalf of the defense, Mr. Curtis, we have your honor. I am the defendant. First-degree murder. I accept the penalty.
The date set for her execution was filed again with a plea of guilty by reason of insanity. Her second appearance before the Bar of Justice resulted in her escape from death, to incarceration in the Arizona State Hospital for the Insane, where she is still held.
A human life might be lost if a police car should be but one second late in responding to an emergency call. That's why so many police departments specify the gasoline that has reserve power for emergencies. Rio Grande Cracks Gasoline. Cracks Gasoline cannot fail to ignite instances. It creates instantaneous power that saves precious seconds in emergencies. When you hear police sirens screaming, remember, you can get police car performance in your own car by filling up with Rio Grande Cracks Gasoline at an independent service station. And remember that this fine gasoline will soon be available in Northern and Central California.
Police calling all cars. Attention all cars. Cancellation broadcast 43 regarding a trunk murder. Suspect in this case now in custody. That's all.
This is Frederick Lindsley saying goodnight for the Rio Grande Oil Company.
