Skip to content
On Air
All channelsAll
Calling All Cars artwork

From the Calling All Cars collection

The High Tower Case

Episode 078May 21, 193532 min 23 secTranscript

The written record

Read the transcript

Read along with the recording · About 23 min to read

This is an opportune time for Rio Grande to express appreciation to Northern California motorists for their enthusiastic reception of Crack's Gasoline. Only nine months have passed since Crack's Gasoline was first introduced in Northern California. Yet in Northern California alone, it has been necessary for Rio Grande to build 19 new gasoline wholesale distributing plants to supply the demand. Sales and distribution have made spectacular increases. Thousands of motorists, curious to know what Rio Grande's exclusive cracking process does to gasoline, have experienced the thrill of police car performance in their own car. And now, ordinary gasoline failed to satisfy them. Among these many thousands of new users, Rio Grande is proud to list many of the leading cities in Northern California which have officially adopted the same Crack's Gasoline, specified by so many cities and counties, wherever Rio Grande Crack's Gasoline is marketed. Today, it is more true than ever before. Wherever it is sold, Rio Grande Crack's Gasoline powers more police cars, fire engines, ambulances, and other emergency equipment than any other brand.

And now, it is our pleasure to introduce James J. McGrath of San Mateo County, who will speak to you from the studios of station KFRC in San Francisco.

James J. McGrath.

Crime prevention and deterrence is one of cooperation here in the San Francisco Bay District. It is only the officers of one community. Our cities are so close together here that invariably the criminal will hide away in a neighboring community. So we Bay District enforcement officers have had to learn the lesson of cooperation. In the case you are about to hear, although the crime was committed in my jurisdiction and the body discovered in San Mateo County, we have seen the invaluable persistence of the San Francisco police. They located the suspect and turned him over to us. Once we had the suspect in custody, then our work of developing the case against him began. Together, the San Francisco officers and the men of the San Mateo Sheriff's Office were able to build a powerful case that sent the prisoner to San Quentin for life.

Years ago, in the little town of Colma near San Francisco, a stranger stands at the door of a parish priest.

Here's what you'll be wanting at this hour of the night. And why can't you come back tomorrow?

The father is in his study.

Very important. I've got to see him.

And what's it about?

A friend of mine, he's dying. He has to have a priest over him. Extreme unction, he calls it.

Well, why didn't you say so? Just a minute and I'll be calling Father Heslin.

Hurry, Father. I've not much more time to live.

Very well, just as soon as I get into my coat.

Oh, not too very far, Father, but hurry.

I'll have a cup of tea brewing for you when you get back, Father.

But Heslin does not return. Father Heslin bought no cup of tea that night. And the following morning in the study of the Archbishop of San Francisco...

Please pardon the interruption, Your Grace, but I think I should call this message to your attention.

What is it?

It carries no signature and it's typed. With me it reads, "Your Grace, if the Mother Church ever wants the services of Father Heslin again, you must pay me $6,500. He's unconscious now, and if you refuse to pay this amount, Father Heslin will be done away with, and you'll never even find his body. Let him have decent burial. Don't mention this letter to anyone, and don't try to notify the police. Get the money, and I will send you another letter in a few days, telling you how you must pay the money." And here's a postscript written in ink. "If you or the people you send with the money try to capture me, you will all be blown to pieces by an infernal machine."

May God have pity on such a miserable sinner. What are we to do?

Oh, perhaps a practical joke, some thoughtless...

Never mind, I'll answer. He didn't return last night, but I'll take care of it.

It is no joke, brother. Father Heslin's housekeeper, and he did not return home last night.

With the news of the abduction of a Colma parish priest, public indignation flares. The citizens of Colma offer $1,000 for information leading to the arrest and conviction of Father Heslin's abductors. The priests of the San Francisco Diocese offer a reward of $5,000 for the return of Father Heslin, dead or alive. San Mateo County adds a $1,000 reward for information concerning the kidnappers.

Deep in a hotel in San Francisco, a man pores over the screaming headlines, thinking aloud.

$11,000 reward. And $6,500 ransom. $500 difference. My ten percent anyway. That's the state of my business. Why, I got a tip on the kidnapping of...

Captain, there's a man out here who says he knows something about the disappearance of the Colma...

Good afternoon. Have a seat.

Thanks.

June to Salada.

Stay down. Not June. It's Salada Beach.

What's your... William A. Hightower.

What's the girl's name?

I told you this. Uh, Ella.

Where does she live?

Where do you live?

At the Tenbro Hotel.

Did I get the reward?

Well, we'll see about that after we've checked your story.

Oh, my story's straight, all right. Come along with me and I'll show you.

You will lead us to the grave?

Sure. You'll give me the reward?

Well, nobody else has claimed it so far, and that's all I can say now.

Accompanied by newspaper reporters, the officers follow Hightower out to the lonely Salada Dunes. Half a mile they trudge through the deep sand, and then, as they approach the beach...

Hey, there's a sign with a miner on it. Is this the place?

Yeah. If you dig here, you'll find him, according to the foreigner.

Hold that pose. Pointing like that, Mr. Hightower, I want to get a picture.

Thanks.

Okay, boys. Start digging.

What did this foreigner look like, Mr. Hightower?

I didn't talk to him, you understand, but Ella said that he was short and dark and drunk.

That's not much of a description.

Women are. They don't notice much.

Not my wife.

Got enough shots of the place, Ben?

Yeah, I guess so. We better get back to town if we're going to make the Bulldog.

Yeah, let's go.

Hey, wait a minute.

What?

Here are a couple of tent stakes by the grave.

Well, whatever. Maybe nothing.

But look at this fish line tied around one of them. And here's a timber with fish lines tied around it in the same kind of knot.

Yeah? That's not mysterious.

Maybe not. And then again, maybe it's a clue.

Oh, you've been reading too many Sherlock Holmes stories.

Well, just the same, I'm going to take them in and turn them over to the police.

Meanwhile, back at headquarters...

Captain, I show you the body. I get the $7,000 reward now?

What's your hurry, Mr. Hightower? A few questions I'd like to ask you.

Sure. All right. If there are any questions you'd like. But... I've already told you everything I know.

Well, not everything. Where were you on the night of August 2nd?

August 2nd?

Yes. The night that Father Heslin was summoned from his home.

Captain, you don't think I have anything to do with this, do you?

I'm asking the question. Where were you on that night?

Well, on the night of August 2nd, I was out riding with a lady friend of mine. We drove down to San Jose, in fact.

How are you so sure of the date?

Oh, I just remember. It was a week ago yesterday.

Oh. What was the lady's name?

You just tell me. Where did she live?

The Berkshire Hotel.

Well, Edith Stanley. Berkshire Hotel.

Whose car did you ride in?

I rented it.

Where?

At Tommy Carroll's Garage on Golden Gate Avenue.

I see. Just a minute, please. Send in Martin and Brannigan.

Yes, sir.

Bring in Edith Stanley, who lives at Berkshire Hotel.

Yes, sir.

And, Brannigan, you check with Tommy Carroll's Garage on whether Mr. Hightower rented an automobile there on the 2nd of August. And, uh... Oh, yes. Tell Kelly to take a man and search Mr. Hightower's room at the Tenbro Hotel.

Yes, sir.

Now, look here, Captain. You think you're exceeding your authority?

I do not.

Yes, sir. Who else you want?

Not for the moment.

I'm free to go.

You are not. You're still in technical custody until I check your story.

While Detective Martin searches for Edith Stanley and Brannigan checks with the garage, Detective Kelly and his partner search Hightower's room.

Well, let's see what's in this closet.

Look, a tent. Help me get it out of here.

Here. Look. Stand on it.

Ah. "Tuberculosis" written across the side. What the devil do you suppose that's for?

It's me. I think we'd better take it in.

All right. Anything else in there?

Yeah. Funny-looking box. Look. Let me see. Looks like a bomb or something to me.

There's a rifle in the corner.

Yeah, and look over here at this desk. A .22 pistol and some shells from a .45 automatic.

And Father Heslin was shot with a .45.

Well, it looks like we're getting somewhere, partner.

It sure does. Only watch how you handle that box. I don't like the look of it.

Is there a registered here with an E. Stanley?

No, she checked out.

When did she check out?

On the 3rd of August.

On the 3rd of August. Where'd she go?

I don't know.

Ah, don't give me a runaround. I'm from police headquarters.

Oh. Oh, that's different. You see? She told me not to give out her new address.

Okay, but you're going to give it to me.

She moved around the corner to the Alcatraz.

Thanks.

Is William A. Hightower in the car here on August 2nd?

Hightower. Hightower. Let me look through the book.

Yes. Oh, of course. I remember. I remember him. He left some tent poles here.

Tent poles? What for?

Well, asked me to take care of them.

How long did he have the car?

Well, he took it out around 6 o'clock and brought it back around 2 a.m.

What kind of a car was it?

Ford.

That's fine. Mind showing me those tent poles?

Why, they're Mr. Hightower's property. I don't think I should.

I'm from Central Station. I'm going to take these tent poles in for evidence.

So, just to be sure, I brought the stakes in with me, Captain. Here they are.

Well, tent stakes aren't unusual things to find on the beach, you know. Lots of people camp out.

Yeah, I suppose it was foolish of me.

No, I appreciate your interest, and I'll keep them around in case they tie in with anything.

Oh, hello, Kelly. What did you find in Hightower's room?

Plenty. A rifle, a .22 revolver, and some .45 shells.

.45 shells?

Yep, and a suspicious-looking box. Eddie took it out to the ballistics man.

But here's the one thing we found that doesn't make sense.

Say, what's that?

Look. Tent with the word "tuberculosis" written on it.

That's right. There's some of that same fish line tied through this ring here. And it's tied in the same knot as on these stakes.

Right, well, you're right. There's sand on the tent, too.

Harry, those stakes you brought in are an important link. I'm glad you reporters make yourself useful sometimes.

Oh, what do you mean, sometimes? Why, you coppers couldn't stay without us. Sometimes, I wonder.

Well, Captain, Hightower rented a car from Carroll, all right. From between 6 in the evening and 2 a.m.

Fine. What the devil are you carrying?

Oh, these. There's some tent poles he left with Carroll.

Well, I'd bring them in. They'd come in handy.

They do. Now, boys, we're getting somewhere. You got the stakes, the poles, and the tent, which was pitched by Father Heslin's grave.

Oh, we need to find him when we go camping.

Need circumstantial evidence, Captain, but don't forget Hightower's alibi.

Don't worry. We'll check on that.

Well, Kelly, it was an infernal machine, all right.

Hey, hey, don't point it at me.

Don't worry. The ballistics man took the shells out of it.

An infernal machine, huh? Is that the one you found in Hightower's room?

Yes, sir. It was rigged with ten shotgun shells to go off when you released the trigger. On the ransom note... Hightower threatened Archbishop Hanna with an infernal machine if he didn't come across.

Fine, yeah, bring her in. Now, that's Martin. He's got Hightower's alibi with him. Mind if I stay while you question her, Captain?

No, I owe you something for those ten steaks.

Thanks. Right this way, Miss Stanley.

Stanley.

How do you do? Won't you be seated, Miss Stanley?

Thanks. Do you have a cigarette?

No, thanks. Miss Stanley, are you acquainted with William Hightower?

Yeah.

Did you see him on the evening of August 2nd, a week ago yesterday?

Yeah, that's the last time. That's the last time I saw him.

You were not on my watch, all right, when there was something like that that night. Is that true?

It is not.

But you did see him that night?

Yeah. What were the circumstances under which you saw him? He called for me about six o'clock and drove me downtown. That's all.

What did you do for the rest of the evening?

I had dinner by myself, went to a movie, and came back to the hotel and went to bed. Then about two o'clock in the morning, Mr. Hightower came up to the room. He wanted to talk to me. He said I wouldn't let him in.

He moved five times during the past five days, Captain.

That's good. Explain that.

I had to follow him to the hotel. I was trying to get away from Hightower. I'm engaged to be married to another fella. Mr. Hightower kept running after me. That night, after he tried to make me let him in at two in the morning, I made up my mind to hide from him. I knew I'd get into trouble if I had anything to do with that guy. Now look at the mess I'm in.

You're in no mess, Miss Stanley. We're not accusing you of anything.

We can't, because I'm out. You convinced me of that, and you've been a great secret. Oh, may I go now?

I have to be more to question you further.

Very well, Captain. I will. All right, thank you, Miss Stanley. Good night.

Bye, Matt. Good night.

Well, there goes Hightower's alibi higher than a kite.

Yeah, it looks like it. I'm going to put that guy where he belongs. Get me Constable Landini of Colma.

Thanks for letting me in on this, Captain. I've got to place the city room now, and I want to get a picture of that Stanley Dane.

Okay. Hello. How, Constable? Well, I've got the murderer of Father Hesselman. Yeah. Sure, I've got the evidence. Well, it's circumstantial, but it's a fact. Well, it's circumstantial, but it's a fact. Well, it's circumstantial, but it's a fact. It's sufficient to hold him to ransom for murder. Okay. And bring the warrant with you.

So, on the 13th of August, Constable S.A. Landini formally charges William A. Hightower of the murder of Father Hesselman. The suspect is moved to the San Mateo County Jail in Redwood City, where Sheriff Michael Sheehan questioned him further.

When attacked the plot, Hightower, we have enough on you to hang you. Why don't you make our job easier by confessing? Well, you might get off as life imprisonment.

How can I confess to this murder when I didn't do it? You can't barb it a confession out of me.

No, nobody's trying to barb it, you Hightower. Has anyone laid a hand on you?

No, but you would if you weren't afraid of my influence. I know you'll cop.

Don't you think that remark's a little silly? Now, look here. What were you doing camping out at Salada Beach?

I wasn't camping out there.

Oh, come on now. We have the tent stakes found at the grave. We have the tent found in your room with the same kind of knots tied to the same cord.

My lie about it. Well, I have camped out there, yeah.

Why?

Well, during the day of the fire in 1960, I said, I had a trunk full of valuables out there in the dunes. I've been trying to find them ever since. I'd walk there sometimes for a couple of days and dig for them.

That's a pretty weak story, don't you think, Hightower?

That's the truth.

Oh, all right. What about that word, tuberculosis, written on the side of the tent?

Oh, that. That was to keep people away. I don't like people.

To keep people away while you had the body of Father Hessel in your hand?

I never had his body, Mr. Hightower.

Not even while you were digging the grave?

No. I'm innocent.

Hightower, you killed Father Hessel.

No.

You killed Father Hessel. Confess. Confess your sin. You killed Father Hessel.

Now, listen. I'm as smart as you are. You can't break me down. What do you have in a cooked-up story? Has anyone who can identify me?

No.

Wait a minute. You ever seen this man before?

That's him. He's the one who called for the father that night. Said that a friend of his was dying. That's him.

Oh, you skipper. You murderer. You murderer.

Just a moment. Take her out, Sergeant.

Well, Hightower?

Nah. Paid with. She never saw me before. She said the man was a dark foreigner. Now she's changing her story. Do I look like a dark foreigner?

In the shade of Father Hessel's porch at night, you might.

Ah, rubbish. Ah, what's the dope, Sheriff? Trying to make a bid for re-election? Is there a way to get a railroad coming for this murder?

That isn't even funny. So you won't confess?

I have nothing to confess to. I'm innocent.

You know an awful lot about the location of Father Hessel's grave for an innocent man?

I don't care, Sheriff. Let me ask you this. Who think I'd have led the officers to that grave if I'd been guilty? You're a sufficient. You're a sufficiently shrewd man to think that you're very daring with those suspicions away from you. And of course, there's no reward. I acted with the best intentions as a law-abiding citizen. I tried to help the police, and now look at the fix on me. It's ridiculous. All I know about this little thing is what that dark foreigner told Ella Howard at the corner of Ellersen Mission that night.

Well, I'm willing to play with your story. I'll give you a break. Where's Ella Howard? I'll question her.

Why question her? Find the dark foreigner. He's a man that murdered Father Hessel.

Let's start with Ella Howard. What does she look like?

Oh, she's pretty.

Blonde?

I think so.

I suppose we have a mug of her hair. She ever been arrested?

Might have been. I've been too careful about the company she keeps.

All right. Let's take a look through this book. Anything like her hair?

These are forges.

No, she ain't there.

She's not there.

Well, let's look at the pickpocket. Is Ella Smith's purse there?

Yes, she might.

Is she around this page?

Turn over.

Yeah, positive. This one is Sally Lawrence.

Well, Ella might have used an idiot.

Yeah, but you see, Hightower, here's where you're mistaken. Because Sally Lawrence, according to this record, is still in San Quentin.

Think she must have broken out.

No, that won't do, Hightower. I'm going to send you back to your cell until you decide. I have come to me. I don't believe it. But I'll give you as much rope as you want. And I'm going out and get Ella Howard, if there is such a person. And I'm going to see what she has to say about the dark foreigner.

The word goes out to the Bay District Police to bring in Ella Howard. Blonde and pretty. Finally, the enterprising newspaper reporter finds a blonde girl whose name is Ella Howard, working as a waitress in the Market Street restaurant. She telephones Sheriff Sheehan, plans a trap, and then drives the bewildered girl out the Bayshore Highway to Redwood City.

Say, look here, Mr. Buckley. I don't get what this is all about. I've been trying to tell you that you're the star witness in the Hightower case.

What are you talking about? What were you, where were you on the night of August 2nd?

Oh, waiting tables at the restaurant.

Can you put... Say, listen, if you get me into any trouble...

I won't get you into any trouble. Like I told you, you're going to get your pretty pan smeared all over the front pages of the evening newspaper.

Oh, gee. And all you have to do is take a ride out to Redwood City with me.

That sounds fishy.

It isn't. Did you ever know William A. Hightower?

Never heard of him until that priest was murdered.

Ever know any dark foreigners?

Well, I knew a Mexican boy down in Los Angeles once, but he left town on me.

He wasn't drunk on the corner of Ellis and Mason the other night, was he?

Say, what are you talking about? What are you trying to do? Make Hightower out a liar. Hon, if you're the craziest guy...

The more I talk to you, the more I think I am.

Well, Sheriff, fella Howard's waiting outside.

Good. Now, boys, don't watch me or Buckley here. Just keep your eyes on Hightower and the girl. See if they recognize each other.

Okay, Buckley. When I push the buzzer, bring her in.

Ryan, get Hightower.

Yes, sir. I'll feed it outside and be sure my little bird hasn't flown the coop.

Okay. Hon, Sheriff, she wins the grand prize. William. I see this little bundle of stupidity. Boy, I must love my work to ride all the way out here with that number. All right, beat it before Hightower gets here.

Right. Now, don't forget, boys, keep your eyes glued on this bird.

Sit down, Hightower. You made up your mind to confess?

I have nothing to confess.

All right. You ever been arrested before, Hightower?

No. No.

You ever pulled any jobs before?

What do you mean?

Burglaries or holdups?

Of course not.

Well? I want to release you just to make sure. I want to release you just to make sure. I want to release you just to make sure. I want to have some victims of recent holdups take a look at you. Well, don't mind, do you?

No, so long as you'll let me out of here.

Well, we'll see about that. I'll have the first victim brought in. Come in, miss. Now, is this the gentleman here? The one who held you up?

Well, I've never been held...

No. Never seen him before?

No. Come on, that's all he said. And do I get picked you in the paper for that?

Yeah.

For that?

Yeah.

Bram. Hey, what's your idea of making a train steal out of me? Never seen that girl before?

Never seen that train steal out of me. Never seen that girl before?

No.

Positive?

Positive. That's all I wanted to know. Now, inasmuch as you don't recognize her, Hightower, it may interest you to know that that girl is Ella Howard, your lady friend whom you claim heard from a dark, drunk foreigner about the grave of Father Haslam. Now, both of your alibis have been broken down. We have enough circumstantial evidence to put you away for good. Now, why don't you confess? You murdered Father Haslam and you buried his body at the Lotta Beach. Isn't that the truth?

No, it's a lie. I'm innocent. You can't prove a thing. You're framing me. Go ahead and try me for murder. I'll beat your case. You'll never send me up.

In the mysterious disappearance of Father Haslam, William A. Hightower went on trial for his murder. In addition to the circumstantial evidence procured by officers and reporters, the state proved that the handwriting on the ransom note was Hightower's and that the murder was a crime. And that the murder was a crime. But timbers found at the grave stained with human blood proved Hightower's guilt more convincingly than his inconsistent defense argued for his innocence. And so on October 13th, the defendant was found guilty and was sentenced to life imprisonment in San Quentin Penitentiary, where he still is today. No longer William A. Hightower. No longer William A. Hightower. He's merely convict number 34458.

Have you wondered why Rio Grande called its leading gasoline crack, that unusual name accurately describes a patented refining process developed after years of research and the expenditure of millions of dollars by the worldwide Sinclair refining organization of which Rio Grande is the western subsidiary. Only Rio Grande is licensed to crack gasoline by the Sinclair process in the West. And so only in Rio Grande Cracked Gasoline can you get a gasoline refined by the Sinclair process in the West. In Rio Grande's new cracking plant, the finest plant of its kind in America, the costly cracking process produces a gasoline that averages a 10-point higher anti-knock rating.

A gasoline that so excels all others in fast starting, acceleration, speed, power, and mileage that it has been chosen through competitive tests to power the police cars and emergency engines of the West's leading cities. Yet with all its advantages and superiority, you can get this same Rio Grande Cracked Gasoline from your neighborhood independent dealer at no extra cost. Those of you who have enjoyed Calling All Cars but have not experienced police car performance in your car, may I personally ask that you try Rio Grande Cracked Gasoline tomorrow.

Attention all San Mateo County Sheriff's cars. The cancellation of broadcast 78 regarding the disappearance of Father Heswood. His body has been found in the surveillance room. The suspect in this case is now in custody. Frederick Linsley. Good night.

End of transcriptBack to the beginning ↑