The written record
Read the transcript
Read along with the recording · About 19 min to read
is a copyrighted program created by Rio Grande. He's calling all cars, attention all cars, broadcast 298 regarding a murder. Assist Lincoln County officers. That's all.
More than six years, Rio Grande Crack Gasoline has powered more police cars, fire engines, ambulances, and other emergency equipment wherever it has been sold than any other brand. Folks, this statement is significant. Significant that Rio Grande Crack has always been a superior gasoline, one of the best sold on the market. But our engineers felt they could produce a better gasoline, and after a month of experimenting, perfected a new and different gasoline. Instead of the three ingredients found in ordinary gasoline, the new all-purpose Rio Grande Crack contains six ingredients, perfectly blended to give you more power, more mileage, more speed, and better performance. I realize that so many extravagant statements are made about various products, but you might think this is just another claim. But friends, I assure you that this is not the case. To prove it, will you do this for me? Next time you need gasoline, drive into a red and white Rio Grande service station and fill up with new all-purpose Rio Grande Crack. One test in your own car will prove there's virtually liquid dynamite.
From the confidential files of the State Police of New Mexico, we have therefore asked Chief Tom Summers to prepare a foreword for our program.
A person. Thanks to New Mexico, he has liked us to visualize vast stretches of uninhabited deserts. He has been led to believe the entire West is like that. Such, however, is not the truth. New Mexico considers itself one of the more fortunate states, especially as it's true when it comes to scientific crime detection. Test tubes and microscopes now make it virtually impossible to mistake the identity of a person who has left the country. They have been left as trademarks at the scene of a crime. Even the master criminal has failed to produce the perfect crime, the one in which no clue is left behind. It is these tell-tale traces that the modern detective uses to make his deduction and unerringly, as well as inevitably, he brings home to the lawbreaker the lesson of the losing nature of crime. As our program progresses, we shall learn how this science of crime, crime detection, helps solve a baffling case.
On the morning of July 23rd, 1938, Captain Jack L. Nichols, in charge of the state police at Roswell, New Mexico, received a telephone call from Sheriff F.E. Grison of Lincoln County.
Yes? Hello. Three hours, anyway. Well, finding me, did you? Well, not in the town of a couple of days. I can see the crowd gathered around here. Yeah, there's quite a few folks hanging around the place. My boys have seen they didn't disturb anything, though. This is where they are. This is where they are. You don't think killings happened, is it? Yep. You can see it's a combination of service station and grocery store. Who owns the place? Frank Hawley. He's one of the men that was killed. I see. And who was the other one? Bill Fletcher. He's the young fellow that worked for Hawley. What was the motive, Sheriff? Robbery? Looks like it. But come on, have a look for yourself. The bodies are around back.
You kept the crowd away from where the bodies were found? Oh, sure. Hawley lived here in the store, I suppose. See it now. Just three pretty clear ones, too. Two more got tamped. He was milling around here earlier, before my boys did. They're pretty clear at that. Good. Well, that's a good idea. Why don't you police officers fool around here and get Pedro Sanchez? He's the bozo who's done it. What's that? That fellow just hollered at us, Sheriff. Him? Oh, he's just one of the crowd. Some of them's got the notion Pedro Sanchez is mixed up in this. Seems to me I've heard of Sanchez. Isn't he the local bad man around here or something like that? Well, he's a pretty tough customer, all right. But I don't... I don't think he had anything to do with this kill. I can see he's got an airtight alibi. Well, what gives some of these people the idea that Sanchez is the killer? Well, anything that goes haywire around here, folks right away blame it on to him. Not a very choice reputation, is he? Nope. Something there that we overlooked.
Okay. When we first got here, the boys and me, both this screen door and the side door were locked from the inside. Well, whoever killed Hawley never got in the place. His body lying across the bed there. He was shot, too, huh? Yep. A bullet come through the screen, and the glass people looking at the holes in the outside window and the back door. Hawley came to the door and answered to the killer, sir, what's his body doing on the bed? Well, that had me stumped right at first, too. But then I figured the impact was onto the bed. It's in the body. That gun down there on the floor by Hawley's feet, the way it was when you found him? Yep. But he'd been into it, though. We could only find a five automatic. And I think it held the bullet that killed young Fletcher.
Is he anywhere around? Come inside. I want to talk to him. Back there? Come here, will you? I want to talk to you. I want you to answer my questions truthfully, Consuela, and tell me everything you know about this. Don't try to hold anything back.
Si, senor. How long have you worked for Mr. Hawley? About two years, senor. Do you? Well, there were two brothers, senor. Their names, I think, are Engels. Sometimes these men, they would quarrel with Senor Hawley. What about, you know? They had trouble over a piece of ground. A piece of ground? What do you mean? I don't know exactly. I think it was about what you call... Right away, something like that. You mean they ride away over some piece of property? Si, senor. Maybe you are right. Did they become very angry? Were there ever any fights? Fights? Oh, no, senor. Sometimes I think there will be and I get all excited. But no, they cool off and get over their mad play a little while. It was very disappointing. I see. And you don't think it was serious enough for children to kill in all this? Oh, no, senor. If it was not worth a punch in the eye, it was not worth... Is there anything else you might tell me? Anything that would give me a clue as to who committed this murder? I don't think so, senor. Only it wasn't me. No, no, I think we can be reasonably certain of that, Consuela. Gracias, senor. That's all that you can think to tell me. Let me go now. Si, senor. But if you should think of anything you feel we ought to know, don't hesitate to get in touch with either Sheriff Grison or myself at once. Si, senor. At once.
The foreigners come after the bodies like you ordered, Nichols. They're taking them into Corozoza. Corozoza? Sure, and so it's too small to have a coroner of their own. Dr. Kelly acts as coroner for this part of the county. Oh, yeah, sure. I know Dr. Kelly. He thinks he'll have a report for you sometime this evening. Fine. Meanwhile, I'm going to check around these parts and find out if anybody's bought a .45 automatic recently.
Is that it, Dr. Kelly? I'm certain of it, Captain Nichols. Chances are, Hawley's had the light on in his room. That would make him stand out as a target when he came to the door. So we can reason from that, that the killer or killers were dead shots. Now, that's not so unusual in this part of the country. And personally, I think everything points to there being two killers involved. My report agrees with that of the ballistic experts. Each of the men was shot by a different caliber. Hawley was a bullet from a .30-30 carbine. The problem now lies in finding those two guns. Once we have them, I think the case will be solved.
And that don't look like it's going to be so easy. I spent the whole afternoon getting around to the stores and trying to find out if anybody's bought a .45 automatic with a shell for one. I sold a .45 automatic and some shells for it only a week ago. That's what I understand. Do you remember who you sold it to? Randall Mixon. He's a young fellow with a ranch up near Anshul. Randall Mixon, eh? Now, what do you suppose that young scamp wants with a .45 automatic? He does all his hunting with a rifle. Oh, you know him, do you, Sheriff? Sure. He and his old man homesteading. He has a brother, Louie, homesteading not far away from him. Well, I'm not so sure it won't be worth that while to take a run up there. I'll go out in the morning and have a talk with young... No, I don't reckon it'll be a lick or miss. Anyway, we've got to do something pretty quick. Public sentiment's getting higher all the time against this Mexican, Pedro Sanchez. Well, Sanchez is a pretty bad egg. I know. Get a hand in this, and besides, we don't want any lynchings here in Corazona. Why? You think the crowd's out of hand enough about this Mexican to try anything like that, Sheriff? You can't tell, but I'll feel a sight easier about things after we make an arrest.
The ranch isn't far from here. He and his dad live up the road a few miles. While we're talking to Louie, keep your eye peeled for any guns around the place. Remember, we're looking for a .30-30 carbine now, as well as a .45 on the way. Yeah, I know. Well, here we are. That's why we're here, Sheriff. Been home? Why, no, he isn't, Sheriff. Could you tell us where we can find him? Yes, he's over at his father's house hitching up a team. I see. On the wall over there. He had done with it. From his hold of that... Very long, maybe a couple of weeks. No, I don't. Unless Louie's pa has it. There wasn't long. Who's the saddle gun? Do you know if Mr. Mixon's seen his son Randall in the trivia any longer? That's all right. Well... Bye, Sheriff. It's about a .30-30 we shot in the dark. But it worked, by golly. Yep, it did. Now the only question is, is it... Something we'll have to find out later. Well, we might as well get along up to Randall Mixon's place now. Well, good luck. Maybe we'll find the guns up there. Let's talk to him before... Before we go up to the house. Well, he had a dollar note that was... Tell him, tell Noah. What held him up? The answer's around here. Is she at home? Yeah, she's in the house. Okay, thanks. I want to talk to her a few minutes before I leave. Ain't nothing wrong with you, Sheriff. Not so.
Sheriff? I saw you standing out here, so I thought I'd come out and say hello. Yeah, howdy, Mrs. Mixon. We come by to ask a few questions. Yeah? What about, Sheriff? Well, for one thing, we want to know where your husband and Randall were. What about the day before? Yesterday. They was home all day that day, too. What do you make of that, Sheriff? I'd say a couple of stories don't fit. Well, what do you mean? There's been some trouble at Anchor, Mrs. Mixon, and we're making investigations. Well, I'm afraid you'll have to come along... I'm not trying to be unreasonable or anything, but I wish you'd tell me why you're taking me back to Corsover with you. You'll find out when we get there, Louie, and I'll just take it easy. For what have I done? As far as I know, you haven't done anything that'll get you into trouble. The worst you can do is... The worst you can do is... The worst you can do is... You have to look forward, too, for the present at any rate. Yeah, but I don't... There's Dad and Randall coming up the road. You mean those two men on horseback? Uh-huh. Sure enough. That's Ben and Randall, all right. Hey, Ben, do you and Randall mind riding over to the car? We want to talk to you a minute. Howdy, Sheriff. I see you got Louie with you. Yeah, Dad. I've been lying telling me. Where you been? Dead now on the way home from Corsover. Yeah? What was the reason you went to Corsover? Well, I... I owe the bank a hundred dollars, and I was trying to borrow the money. Yeah. Did you get it? No. Not yet.
Your name's Randall, isn't it? Randall Mixon? That's right. What did you do with that .45 automatic pistol you bought from Dr. Kelly a few weeks ago? I sold that gun to a fellow named Fred Spears quite a while back.
You did, huh?
Sure. And you, Mr. Mixon, what happened to that .30-30 carbine you borrowed from your son Louie?
Well, I... I bet he's... Uh-oh. Uh-oh. I lost it off myself. Yeah, it was two or three weeks ago.
Hmm. You two don't keep guns in your family very long. Those horses, both of you. You're going into Corsover with us.
Yeah, but, uh, what about...
We'll find somebody to get your horses home for you. But in the meantime, we're going to have a little conference over in the county jail.
Corsover, Louie, Randall, and the elder Mixon were questioned separately by Assistant District Attorney Cuba Clayton and Captain Nichols.
Louie, did your brother Randall ever show you a .45 automatic that belonged to him?
Yeah. A few weeks ago, he showed me a gun like that. He said he bought it from Dr. Kelly here in Corsover for $15.
Was the gun loaded?
I think it was, yeah.
Did Randall mention whether or not he'd ever used the gun?
He said he'd kill a rabbit with it. He said it was a very good gun.
Did Randall or your father ever borrow your .30-30 carbine?
Randall did. We went hunting together one day, but instead of returning the rifle, he took it on home with him.
What for?
I don't know, Mr. Clayton.
Did you ever see the rifle after that?
Well, yeah. About a week later, at my pa's house.
And that's the last time, huh?
Uh-huh.
Did you see your father or brother last Friday? That is, on July 23rd.
I went by their place and saw them all, but did you see them on the following day?
Yeah, they came over to my house early in the morning. They had one to use a saddle of mine, and I told them to go ahead. I didn't see them again until we picked them up on the road a while back.
Did you ever know a man by the name of Fred Spiegel?
I saw a fellow by that name once in Lima, Oklahoma. That was about 1925, though.
What did he look like?
He was a big, broad-shouldered fellow. Very dark-complected. I judged he was middle-aged. He had black hair that turned gray.
All right, that's all for the prison, Bowie. Sorry we have to hold you like that. See you later.
Randall makes him.
Yes, sir. Sit down. I want you to tell me all about how you happened to buy that .45 automatic, Randall, and why.
Well, like I told you, I met this fellow Fritz. He wanted to trade me a shotgun for a pistol. So I decided to buy one. He showed me one he had for $15.
Is your father with you? When you... You bought the gun?
Yes. I turned over the gun to Fritz.
Did this man Spears give you the shotgun at the time?
He was with me a little later, and he never did show up, and I never saw him again.
You were kind of a sucker, weren't you?
Yes, yes, I suppose I was.
Did you ever have this gun at your home, or did you ever show it to your brother, Louie?
No. I told Louie about buying the gun, but I never showed it to him.
Where did you meet Spears to give him the gun?
From the bank. And the gun was never out of your possession from that moment until you... You brought it around and turned it over to Spears?
That's right. I came straight from the store and gave it to him.
Did you ever borrow Louie's .30-30 carbon for any reason?
No. When Louie came here first, about 18 months ago, he had the rifle with him. He left it at our house. It's been there ever since.
Where is it now?
Two or three weeks ago, Dad came back from a ride and said he'd lost it. He never went back to look for it.
How did you put in the day last Friday?
Well, I worked around the place all morning. In the afternoon, Dad and I went out looking for a stray cow, Louie's. He didn't get home until between 9 and 10 o'clock that evening.
What did you do then?
We went right to bed.
What about the night?
He borrowed a saddle from my brother, and we rode around to some of the ranches. We knew, trying to sell a couple of horses.
Did you come in the car?
Coming back from there when you arrested us.
Can you describe this man, Fred Spears, for us?
Tall fellow, about 35 years old. Tall and hairy. Wears a little red mustache.
That's all for the time being, Randall. Am I free to go now?
No, I'm afraid we'll have to hold you. But I'll talk to you later, Randall.
Mr. Clayton, what do you make of things now?
I don't think there's any question that Randall and his father are the killers.
That's the way I look at it, too. Randall's and Louie's stories conflict in nearly every regard. The old man tells a story enough like Randall's to convince me they must have rehearsed it.
That was my impression, too. The only detail in which the old man's story differed from Randall's was in the description of Fred Spears.
Fred Spears? Mixon described the same man to us that Louie did. A man he'd known years ago and hadn't seen again until Randall gave him the .45. Personally, I don't think there is such person as Fred Spears. At least not the one that Randall told us about. He probably remembered the name from hearing his father and brother talk about a Fred Spears they'd known in Oklahoma.
Well, Sheriff Grayson hasn't been able to locate anyone like that. Our problem now, Nichols, is to find those guns. And the sooner the better. I'm going back out to the Mixon ranch and have a good look around. I've got a hunch.
You'll find something, Clayton. And I'd like to get straight. You told us your husband and your son had been at home all day, both on Friday and on Saturday. They claimed to have been away from the ranch on both occasions. Weasel, uh, about a season, they wanted me to cover things up for them in case there was any trouble.
I see. It won't get me in trouble.
It won't get you in any trouble, as you know how. Do you remember whether or not they were warned by the men last Friday?
Yes, sir. I'm sure. You brought in the making of the killing. No question of doubt. If we can only find those guns.
We're supposed to be looking for Louis Strait. Touch with him right away, will you? He's for us yet. And horses for miles. They win when they... To give Hunter credit for keeping those tracks in sight, lost them a dozen times. I don't know anyone that's any better, Indians included. Begins to look like no gain.
See there? Hunter's led us almost to the pasture of the Mixon ranch. If they were going to get rid of those guns, they'd have done it before they got this close to home.
Yeah, I guess you're right. And it's a darn shame, too. I'd sort of pinned my hopes on the... Hold on, boys. I think I found something.
What is it, Ab?
Well, one of them dismounted here. There's the prints of his feet in the soil.
See anything else?
Oh, wait a minute. These footprints lead into that clump of small cedars.
Hold your breath, Sheriff. This may be it.
Yep. Yep, I can see where the brush has been disturbed.
We're right behind you, Hunter. Now, if anything's been... Yep, here it is. Here's something, boys.
What is it?
Well, there's a roll of gunny sacks in here. Now, wait a second. I'll unwind them. There.
Well, look at that.
Guns.
Yep. A .30-30 carbine and a .45 automatic. There's our case, Sheriff. Signed, sealed, and delivered.
In just a moment, Chief Tom Summers will give you the concluding facts regarding tonight's story. You will find that our new all-purpose Rio Grande crack gasoline gives you more power, more speed, more mileage, and smoother performance because it is scientifically made of six important power-producing, using ingredients instead of the three found in ordinary gasoline. Fill up at a red and white Rio Grande service station in the morning. Experience the thrill of police car performance.
The search made test that the guns found by Hunter were the ones used in this murder. Dr. Kelly identified the automatic as the one he had sold to young Mixon. Both men were found guilty and sentenced to death. Their sentences, however, were later commuted to 99 years imprisonment. There is indeed a story that proves crime cannot pay.
Thank you, Chief Summers. ...regarding the murder. The case is now in custody. Frederick Lindsley, bidding you good night for Rio Grande. At this time, Rio Grande will present the case of the man with the iron pipe.
This is the Columbia Broadcasting System.
