Skip to content
On Air
All channelsAll
The Campbell Playhouse artwork

From the The Campbell Playhouse collection

Counselor-At-Law

Episode 013January 6, 193956 min 48 secTranscript

The written record

Read the transcript

Read along with the recording · About 51 min to read

The makers of Campbell Soups present The Campbell Playhouse. Orson Welles, producer. Good evening, listeners. This is Ernest Chappell speaking. Tonight, The Campbell Playhouse presents Orson Welles in his own radio version of Counselor at Law. Heading the cast are Eileen McMahon of the theater in Hollywood and Gertrude Berg, who leaves her role as Molly Goldberg on her own program, The Rise of the Goldbergs, to appear on another broadcast for the first time.

Let me ask what comes to your mind when I mention chicken for dinner. I think I know. You visualize a fine, plump chicken, sizzling brown and falling into tender slices under the touch of the carving knife. And you recall the eager anticipation as the plates were passed from place to place. A grand dish, chicken. A special occasion treat that's always welcome. But remember that between these special occasions, your family can still enjoy the good taste of chicken soup. Because just as sure as you like chicken, you'll like Campbell's chicken soup. You'll see how chicken-rich it is in the very first place. You'll taste the very golden glisten of it. You'll taste deep-down chicken flavor in every tempting spoonful. What's more, you'll find pieces of tender chicken meat in it and fluffy, snowy rice. I know you'll agree that Campbell's is the real old-fashioned kind of chicken soup. Why not keep several cans of Campbell's chicken soup on hand?

The Campbell Playhouse, as I've already mentioned, is a radio show and not a broadcast from the stage. Our stories are addressed to you in your homes and not to an audience that we can see. And only on special occasions are inhabitants of the outside world admitted to the mysterious privacy of the studio from which these words are originating. Tonight is such an occasion. But tonight our story is about courtrooms and judges, laws and lawyers, and nobody knows less about these things than I do. And nobody knows more than my good friend, Mr. Samuel S. Leibowitz, who has been kind enough to come up here and check my script for inaccuracies and to advise me on points of legal procedure. Under the circumstances, the legal procedure is in place. The least I could do was to ask him to stay for the broadcast. For Mr. Leibowitz, as everybody knows who can spell out a headline, has been prominent in more celebrated trials than you could shake a docket at. It is hardly necessary to remind you of the Irwin case, the Vera Stretz case, the Scottsboro trial, the Breadknife murderess, the Mother Honor Slayer, the Vendetta Woman, or the Gigolo murder. With this enviable and unprecedented career behind him, I am fairly sure that Mr. Leibowitz examined my case very thoroughly before he took it on. I can hardly hope that he will defend my performance of Counselor at Law. I can only hope that our broadcast will not detract from his record.

Ladies and gentlemen, may I present Counselor at Law's Counselor at Law, my legal advisor for tonight, Mr. Samuel S. Leibowitz.

Thank you, Orson. I'm very curious to see what you're going to do with one of my favorite plays. As you know, the original author, Elmer Rice, was a law student, so his legal details are mostly authentic. As far as I can see, there's nothing in your script that would be ruled out of court.

I hope you're right, Sam. And I hope you like our show. And now, if you'll just sit over there with Mrs. Leibowitz and pretend you're the jury, Allie McMahon, Gertrude Berg, and the rest of us of the Campbell Playhouse will present our case to you, and I promise you, we'll all be very interested to hear your verdict. Ladies and gentlemen, and Mr. and Mrs. Leibowitz, Campbell Playhouse presents Counselor at Law by Elmer Rice, and remains obediently yours.

With all the tender emotion that a woman can lavish upon a man, the finger that will trigger was the depredation of a loving heart. I know, gentlemen, as you look into the face of this poor widow, oppressed with grief and remorse, you will not find it in your heart to condemn one whom heaven has already punished for no other crime than that she loved not wisely, but too well.

Yes, I'll put you through. Coming into desk, go. Calling, please. Mr. McGee? Mr. McKee? Taylight and Kitty? One moment, please. Mr. McKee of Bartlett-Bartlett-McKee calling Mr. Tedesco. Oh, Henry. Yeah, what is it? Hey, Henry, will you distribute this mail? Oh, gee, I gotta get out these notices at trial. Can't you even sort it? Say, who's the office boy around here, you or me?

Simon and Tedesco. One moment, please. Hello? Simon and Tedesco. Hiya, Missy. Oh, so it's you, is it? I thought you was dead and buried. You in on it? No, I don't look so good in black. You made? Yeah, sure, I missed you. Did you, Missy? Yeah, like booze. Miss Lincoln. Gee, I'm glad I'm wearing long sleeves so that I can laugh in them. Oh, you do, too. All right, now I'll tell you one. Wait a minute.

Simon and Tedesco. Yes, who's calling? One moment, I'll give you Miss Gordon, his secretary. Bookman is all calling Mr. Simon. Here's Miss Gordon, Mr. Simon's secretary. All right, go ahead. Hello? Yeah, you had another call. I can't tonight. Say, you must have your hats made in a barrel factory. You better call me back later. I'm busy now. Hello? Simon and Tedesco. One moment, please.

Who did you wish to see, madam? I'm busy, please. Yes, he is. Would anybody else do? I'll wait for him. Well, he may be busy for quite a while. Oh, that's all right. I got plenty of time. All right, take a seat. Thank you.

Hello? Simon and Tedesco. Who's calling, Miss Simon? I'll put this through to Miss Gordon, his secretary. Hello, Betty. Betty. Tongue on Ryan, chocolate mountain. Oh, thanks, Charlie. 30 cents and here's your change. Is it home to put a lot of Russians? Would you like some, madam? Yes, smeared it on thick.

Simon and Tedesco. Hello? I'm Mr. Tedesco now. Mr. Bellini calling Mr. Tedesco. Excuse me, ma'am. Yes? What is it, please? Ain't you Mr. Simon's mother? Sure, I'm Lena Simon. I thought I recognized you. I guess you don't remember me. Well, I think I saw you somewhere before. I'm Charlie McFadden. Used to be the helper to Barney O'Rourke, the plumber on 3rd Avenue. When you and your old man had the bakery shop and George was selling... Oh, shoot. Then we lived on 86th Street. Yeah. I'll say you're looking great. Well, you don't look a day older than the last time I saw you. Well, I have my health in God. My boy gives me everything. More than I want. Why shouldn't I look well? Well, you sure got reason to be proud of your son, Mr. Simon. He's a prince among men, that's what he is. Yes, that's just what he is, Mr. McFadden. Well, he gave me a new start in life. That's what he did. You know, I was... I was nothing but a jailbird. You're working here for George? Yeah, nearly four years now. Process server. Now and again, I do a little private detective work for Mr. Simon. You see, I got ways of finding things out. He's a good, good man, my George. He always worked hard. Since he was a little boy, he's working hard. Always working and studying and trying to better himself. I'm sure. That's how he made his success. Well, I'll tell you yes, you're here, Mr. Simon. No, Mr. Simon. No, Mr. Simon. No, Mr. Simon. No, Mr. Simon. No, Mr. Simon. Mr. McFadden, I'll sit and wait for George. It's all right. He's so busy, and I have all day.

Hey, everybody. Morning, Betsy. Well, congratulations, Mrs. Chapman. Thanks, Charlie. Well, you sure must be feeling good this morning, Mrs. Chapman. I feel just like a new woman. That's how I feel. Yeah, I'll bet you do. After all you've been through. Of course, after Mr. Simon talked to the jury, I had a feeling that everything was going to be all right. Why, do you know, I just sat there and cried like a baby. And when the acquittal came, would you believe it? I was out like a light. I was out like a light. Oh, gee, I wish I could have heard Mr. Simon speak. Betsy, will you tell him I'm here? I sure will. Oh, Miss Gordon, Mrs. Chapman's in the office to see Mr. Simon. All righty, I'll tell her. Mr. Simon's on long distance. Miss Gordon says he will please take a seat. Wait a minute, Mrs. Chapman. Okay, I'll be on later. Too long. Simon, introduce yourself. Oh, good morning, Mrs. Simon. Oh, uh, Mr. Simon's on long distance just now, ma'am. And Miss Gordon is talking on another wire. Do you want to hold on? All right, Mrs. Simon, I'll tell him you're calling. Goodbye.

That was Mrs. Simon. Does she come around here a lot? Oh, well, not so much. They live up in Westchester. Yeah. She's one of the 400, you know. Her father was the governor of some state. Kind of ritzy, huh? Well, you know the way those society dames are. They never wear the same dress twice. Yes, Miss Gordon. Mrs. Simon will see Mrs. Chapman early after the step-in. All righty. You can go right in now, Mrs. Chapman. You know the way? Yes, I know the way.

Hello, George, darling. Now. Thank you, George. Pretty busy's the door. I'll tell you mine. Anything special? I've got clients waiting for me. Oh, well, let them wait. George, darling, how can I ever thank you enough? You thanked me last night. It's my business to help people when they get into trouble. And hereafter, don't keep any firearms around the house. It might not turn out so well next time, you know. Oh, George, you were so wonderful when you talked to the jury. All those beautiful things you said about me. See, it made me feel that you were the first man that ever really understood me. Well, anyhow, I understand juries. It's very nice of you to come into the door. Anytime I can be of any further use to you, I'm very glad. Why are you so cold to me, George? George, don't you know how fond I am of you? Oh, George, dear, I've learned to grow so fond of you. I realize you're a married man. Listen, listen, Mrs. Chapman. I was engaged to defend you on the charge of murdering your husband. There's nothing in the retainer that requires me to fall in love with you. Well, of all the darn nerves. This is the way out, Mrs. Chapman. Come on. That's what it looks like. Goodbye, Mrs. Chapman. Hey, Bessie, if that woman comes in or calls me, I'm out. Do you understand? Yes, Mr. Simon. They'll help me. That's the last of those female murder cases I'll ever handle.

Hello, George. Mama. Mama, I didn't know you were here. That's all right. How are you? You've been here long. Bessie, why didn't you tell me my mother was here? Only a few minutes, George. Oh, I'm sorry, Mr. Simon. I didn't know the lady was your mother. What do you mean you didn't know? Don't you ask people who they are when they come in? George, please. I got plenty of time. If my mother calls, I want her announced right away, no matter who's in the office. Do you understand? Yes, Mr. Simon. Come in the office, Mama. Have your lunch? Sure, sure. It's been a long time already. Sit down. Sit down, Mama. Make yourself comfortable. Well, Mama, I decided to go to Europe with Cora next week. That's good, George. That's good. You need a good rest. You work too hard. I don't need any rest, but... Well, hard work's good for me, Mama, but I promised Cora that we'd celebrate our fifth anniversary by taking a trip together. You know, I haven't really had a chance to be alone with Cora much. That's what you should do, George. A man and his wife should be just as close together as possible. Especially when a man has a wife like Cora. She's a wonderful, wonderful woman, Mama. Yes. She has a good husband in you too, George. Yes, of course. According to you, nobody would be good enough for me. It's wonder the King of England never asked me to become his son-in-law. No, I'm sure his daughters couldn't do any better. Mama, you're a sweetheart. All right, laugh, laugh. My opinion, you don't say. George, I want to talk to you. Is everything wrong? You feeling all right? Oh, I'm feeling fine. About me, you mustn't worry, George. What's the matter then? What do you look so serious about? George, you mustn't be angry.

I'm not going to be angry. What is it?

George, your brother David called me up this morning.

Well?

He told me you wouldn't be angry.

I'm not angry, Mama. Go ahead.

He needs a little money.

Money? What does he need money for this time?

A check came back from the bank.

You mean he gave somebody a bum check?

A little. A little mistake in his balance. He's definitely making his balance.

He's a crook. That's what he is.

George, is that a way to talk about your brother?

Yes, brother. A fine brother he is. But I'm through with him. He can get himself out of this one.

George, be a good boy. It's the last time. He won't do it again.

Yes. How many times have I heard that one before? I'm through with him, I tell you. I'm supposed to be an important lawyer around here. I'm mixed up in more front page cases than any lawyer in New York. People from whole families come in and think I'm doing him a favor if I accept their retainers. I don't happen to like a millionaire's looks. I throw him out of the office. But, yeah, it's fine for me, isn't it, to have a brother going around getting himself pinched in gambling raids and handing out rubber checks. It's great, isn't it?

George, please. For me, do it. Not for him.

Oh, no. I don't always ask you for something, George.

All right, then, Mama. Put it that way. Rexy, you come in.

Thanks, George. You're a good boy.

Is that Mr. Simon? Oh. Oh, hello, Mr. Simon. How are you?

Can't complain. Thank you, Mr. Gordon.

Rexy, make out a check. My brother for... How much is it, Mama?

Uh, $450 now.

$450 cash for the mail tonight.

Yes, Mr. Simon.

Oh, Pete Malone from the county clerk's office is outside. He says it's important.

A few minutes. Can't be that important. He can wait.

Yes, sir.

A nice girl, George. Except Miss Gordon.

Yeah, she's a wonderful secretary. Couldn't get along without her.

How is it such a nice girl like Miss Gordon? Don't find herself a husband.

I don't know. Well, something she's interested in, ma'am.

Well, George, uh... I see you're busy, and I think I'll go home now.

All right, Mama. Take a taxi up to home.

Oh, the bus is all right, too. The bus is good enough. And, uh, thank you, George, for... for David. And from now on, I'm sure he'll be a good boy, like you. And every night, George, I... I say a prayer for you and for him. Bye, George. Just take care of yourself. Goodbye.

Rexy! Rexy!

Yes, Mr. Simon?

Rexy, how much did I tell you to send a bill to Mrs. Rickson?

Oh, uh, $5,000.

I'd better make it $6,000. And send it to her as soon as the separation agreement is signed. I want her to get it while she's still grateful.

Yes, sir.

Oh, uh, Mr. Simon.

Yeah, what is it?

Motion to dismiss Palin against White National comes up this morning. Get an adjournment. And, uh, here's a money order for $50 from Mrs. Moran in that accident case. Send it back. She can't afford to send me $50.

Okay.

Mr. Simon's office. Miss Gordon speaking.

What is it now?

It's Mrs. Simon.

Hello, darling. How are you?

I'm fine. I was talking to Washington.

No, no, the jury didn't come in until after midnight. By the time I got out, it was nearly 2.

George?

Oh, yes, darling. On the Paris.

Say, why don't you have lunch with me?

Oh, I see. All right, that's all right, darling. I'll see you this afternoon around 3. Goodbye, sweetheart.

All right, anything else?

Well, Pete Malone's still waiting to see you. Oh, and there's a wire from Washington. I don't understand it. All it says is yes, and it's signed XYZ.

Let's see it. Well, get Joe Fisherman of Fisherman & Company right away. Time to buy 5,000 shares of Gulf Coast Utilities in the market.

But, Mr. Simon, you said only last week—

I know it's a lot. It's a lousy stock, but that wire's a hot tip. The court's going to dismiss the complaint against the company, and the stock's due for a little whirl. Go on, hurry. What are you waiting for?

Do you know what I tell you? I'm sending Pete Malone.

Yes, Mr. Simon.

Bessie?

Yes, Miss Gordon?

Mr. Simon, we'll see Mr. Malone.

Yes, Miss Gordon. Oh, and Mr. Simon, before you go out, Mr. Dreska would like to have a word with you.

Hello, George.

Oh, what's on your mind, Malone?

Why, hey, George. I'm afraid it's not good news.

Sit down, still it.

You know my brother Ed, the warden up at Elmhurst?

Sure, I know him.

He set me off to something I think you ought to know.

All right.

Do you ever remember handling a case for some fellow named, uh... Oh, wait a minute till I think of his name. It's some Dutch or Hebrew name, something or other. Stein. Wait, I think I wrote it down somewhere. Yes, here it is. Breitstein. Johann Breitstein. Remember him?

Yeah, I remember. Johann Breitstein. German boy. I defended him on a larceny charge about eight or nine years ago and got him acquitted.

What about it?

Was there something about him? Alibi?

Yeah, he had an airtight alibi. That's why the jury acquitted him.

Yeah, well, it seems there was another guy who was mixed up in the case.

Is that right?

Yes, he established the alibi for us.

Right. That's it.

Well, this bird's doing a stretch up at Elmhurst, and it seems he had a session with a friend of yours who's a member of the parole board.

What are you talking about?

A man by the name of Francis Clark Baird. Ever hear him?

What about him?

Well, this bird's been giving Francis Clark Baird some song and dance about that alibi being framed up.

What do you mean, framed up?

Well, I'm just telling you what Ed told me over the phone last night. This guy Baird on the grievance committee of the Bar Association, too?

Yes, sir. Well, that's what Ed said. He says he's got a hunch that Frank... Francis Clark Baird would like to get something on you, George. I guess that's right, too, ain't it?

Sure he would. I licked him to a fare-you-well in half a dozen cases.

Well, that's what I said to Ed. There's nothing to it, Ed, I says. George is too smart a boy, I says, to let himself get mixed up with anything like that. Only, I thought I'd better tip you off.

Thanks, Peter. It was well of you to let me know.

Hey, what do you think of those silk stockings trying to pull a thing like that on me?

Ah, well, you know how it is, George. These guys that came over on the Mayflower don't like to see the boys on Second Avenue sitting in the high places. We're just a lot of riffraff to them.

Yeah. Rexy, come in, please.

Yes, Mr. Simon.

Well, I've got to be getting back to the office. So long, George. I'm around the club some night.

Yes, you will, Pete. Thanks for the steer. Thanks for the chance.

So long.

So long, Pete.

Yes, Mr. Simon.

Listen, Rexy, I've got a job for you. It's important.

Yes, sir.

About eight or nine years ago, I defended a fellow named Johann Breitstein in General Sessions. I want you to get a hold of Breitstein right away. Let everything else go until you locate him, understand?

Yes, I certainly will. And get me all the papers out of the files and have them here for me this afternoon. People against Johann Breitstein. Out to General Sessions and order a transcript of the stenographer's minutes of the trial and locate Breitstein. And ask Mr. Tedesco to step in here right away, and I don't want to be disturbed.

Yes, Mr. Simon.

OK. Is Charlie McFadden out there?

He's gone to the bank.

All right, then. As soon as he gets in, I want to see him.

Hello, John. What is it, George?

You want to see me?

John, you're my partner. Got a right to know this before anyone else. This is Clark Baird.

Baird? Yes, I heard of him.

He's got something on me, and he's going to break me.

What do you mean, he's got something on you?

Well, you think I'm crazy when you hear this. Maybe you're right. I once helped to pull out of a jam by putting over a fake alibi.

Subornation of perjury?

Yeah, that's right. They can't get me on a criminal charge. The statute of limitations has run, but they can disbar me, and they will. This is bad, John.

George, how did you ever get yourself mixed up in anything like that?

Oh, don't ask me. I was just a fool, that's all. I'll tell you how it happened. Nine years ago, a kid by the name of Breitstein had stolen $12 out of a locker in a bathhouse. Well, I advised him to plead guilty and get off with a few months. Then I discovered that he was a fourth offender, and that a conviction meant a life sentence. Well, I didn't know what to do about it, so finally, Breitstein said he could get a fellow to swear that he was in his house in Jamaica the day the robbery was committed. I couldn't refuse, John. I'd known the kid and his family. I knew he'd go straight if I got him off, and he has, too. I just couldn't get to see that kid get a life sentence, so... I went into it, and now the chickens are coming home to roost.

But, uh, has this fellow Breitstein been squeezed?

No, the guy that fixed the alibi's been talking, making a play for parole, and of course, Francis Clark Baird has to be on the parole board. It's funny, in a way. For years, that Yankee's been trying to get something on me. Every time he's drawn a blank, and now this one thing that was dead and buried and forgotten falls right into his lap, and it's as good as if I'd misappropriated a million dollars.

Well, don't you bluff it out, George.

Oh, maybe yes, maybe no. Trouble is that the case won't bear any investigating.

Oh, good Lord. What am I gonna do, John? I'm gonna be disbarred, that's certain.

I guess there's not much use going to Francis Clark Baird with the whole story.

That's a laugh, John. Might as well throw a biscuit into a cage of a man-eating tiger.

Well, I'm no son. There's some ways that you could get him that would put an end to his funny business forever.

John, listen, we're a long way from Sicily, boy. Put it out of your mind. You'll make me sorry that I told you in a minute.

Well, what good is a rat like that? He's out after our scalps, isn't he? And why? Because we came from the streets, and our parents talk with an accent.

Oh, what's the good of talking about all that? He's technically right, and he's doing his duty.

Well, you're not licked yet, George. We'll pull all the wires we can.

Thanks, John. I know I can count on you to the last drop of blood. It's one bright spot in the picture. Got you and one or two other friends to stand by, and a wife that's 100%. That makes it worth fighting.

That's the boy. You know, maybe I'm building this thing bigger than it really is. See how it works out. I just wanted you to know about it, John. That's all.

Yes?

Charlie McFadden's coming, Mr. Simon.

Send him in right away.

Well, I guess I'll be going, George. I'll see you later.

Come in, Charlie.

All right, John, I'll give you a call when I come back for lunch. Thanks.

All right, George. Keep your chin up.

Okay, John. Thanks.

You want to see me, Chief?

Yeah, Charlie. Sit down. Listen. Charlie, I'd like you to do something for me. It's pretty important.

Okay, Chief.

There's a lawyer by the name of Francis Clark Baird.

Sure, I know him. He's right across the street in the French building.

Yeah? What I'd like you to do, Charlie, is to see what you can find out about him.

What, him shattered? Is that it?

Yeah. Well, Rexy, come in, please.

Yes, Mr. Simon.

Yeah, Charlie. I want you to know how he spends his time and who his friends are and where he goes nights.

I get you.

I don't suppose it'll do much good, but you might try.

Leave it to me, Chief. I got lots of ways of finding things out.

Yes, Mr. Simon.

Listen, Rexy. All right, Charlie. Thanks a lot. So long, boss.

Rexy, did you locate Breitstein?

Well, I found out where he works. He's out on a job, and we're trying to get him.

Well, have him come to the office the minute you find him. All right. I've got to go to court now on that Wheelock case. I'll be back in an hour. And you better get something to eat.

I'm not hungry.

Oh, Mr. Simon.

Yes, Rexy, what is it?

Mr. Simon, is there anything wrong? Oh, there is, isn't there? Of course not.

Why is there anything wrong?

Well, because if there were anything that I could do, Mr. Simon...

No, you can't do that.

You can't mind your own business. That's what you can do. Here, Betsy. Drink this.

What is it?

Well, it's just some bromides to quiet your nerves. Now, go on, drink it.

Does it taste bad, Miss Gordon?

Oh, no, no. It's nothing at all. Go on, take it. It'll make you feel better.

I hate taking stuff. And what will Mr. Simon say if he comes in and finds me laying on his couch?

No, I'll take care of that. And if you don't feel better, I'm going to send you home in a taxi.

Oh, no, I don't want to go home. Honest, I don't, Miss Gordon. I really don't. I think I'll be all right in a minute. I think I'll go back to the switchboard. Oh, gee, here's Mr. Simon coming now. I'd better go in.

What's the matter? Anything wrong?

Well, it's nothing, but Betsy had a little shock just now and it upset her. She's all right again. You'd better jump in the cab, Betsy, and go home.

Oh, no, I'm all right again, Mr. Simon. Honest, I am. I'm going back to the board right now.

Now, listen, if you're not feeling all right, I want you to go home.

Oh, I'm all right, Mr. Simon. Thanks ever so much.

Hey, what's the matter with her?

I saw somebody jump out of the window of an office building and it gave her a bad shock.

Where was it?

Well, I suppose if you're tired of living, it's as good a way as any to end it.

What, jumping out of a window like that?

Well, why not? A few seconds and it's all over. I guess people don't do it unless they have a pretty good reason.

What the devil are you so morbid about?

I'm not morbid. Only we don't ask to be brought into this world and if we feel like leaving it, I don't see that it's anybody's business but our own.

What's the matter? Don't you feel well or something?

Oh, yes, of course. Just talking a lot of nonsense, that's all. Good. Brightstein yet?

Yes, sir. He's waiting outside.

See him right away. Wait a minute. He didn't get me Francis Clark Baird. Yeah, I'll try him again. Bessie, try Mr. Baird again at his office. Is there anything important in the mail?

Well, a check came in from the Murray Packing Company.

How much?

$10,000 plus $200 and some odd dollars for disbursements. I forget the actual amount.

Oh, hello. Oh, I see. Thank you. Now, Mr. Baird isn't in.

Oh, I didn't expect it. Wait a minute. Is that his secretary? I'll talk to him myself. Hello? Is this Mr. Baird's secretary? This is Mr. Simon speaking. Mr. George Simon. Do you know when Mr. Baird will be in? Oh, I see. Well, do you know where he can be reached? Well, he's in town, isn't he? Do you think you're likely to hear from him during the day? Yes, it's all pretty indefinite, isn't it? Well, okay, if you do hear from him, will you tell him that I called and ask him if he'll be good enough to call me? Yeah, thank you very much. Goodbye.

I think that Baird could afford to employ a more convincing liar than that. All right, I'll see Brightstein now.

Okay.

Yes, Miss Gordon.

Mr. Simon, we'll see Mr. Brightstein now.

Yes, Miss Gordon. All right, and I don't want to be disturbed. Any engagements?

You've a date at 3.30 with Mr. LaPorte.

Yes, I must keep that. I'll put off all the others. Oh, Mr. Brightstein, would you come right in? Come right in, Brightstein. Sit down. Rexy, see that I'm not disturbed, will you?

Oh, Brightstein, glad to see you again.

Very glad to see you, Mr. Simon. How have you been?

Oh, I've been fine, Mr. Simon. I got a good job now.

You have? What are you doing?

I'm assistant cameraman for General Newsreel.

Is that so? Yeah. That's great. Listen, Brightstein, has anyone been talking to you lately about that case of yours?

No, Mr. Simon, they haven't.

Nobody's approached you or asked you any questions?

No, sir. Why?

Well, it seems the fellow that fixed that alibi of yours has been doing some talking.

Well, in most of it, Mr. Simon, does that mean that they're going to come after me again?

Yes, they're likely to.

Holy smoke, Mr. Simon, what am I going to do?

Well, don't get excited anyway, Brightstein. I think maybe everything will be all right. You do just what I tell you to.

Well, sure I will, Mr. Simon. Be with, I've got a wife and family, and I don't know what I'll do with it.

What you've got to do is to stick by that alibi story. Do you understand?

Yeah, yeah, sure, Mr. Simon, whatever you say. Besides, Mr. Simon, everything I got I owe to you. Jimmy, if it wasn't for you, I'd be in for life. I'd go through fire and water for you.

All right, Brightstein, all right, thanks. Just keep all this under your hat, and if anybody questions you, just stick to your story and act dumb.

Gee, you betcha. You think everything's going to be all right, Mr. Simon?

I hope it is.

Why, don't you?

Oh, yeah, sure, oh, yeah, just thinking.

What?

Well, I was thinking in case they should look up the hospital records.

What hospital records?

Well, the hospital records of this fellow that fixed the alibi.

What are you talking about?

Well, you know, the day it happened, the day he said I was in his house. Well, he was in the hospital.

You mean to say that the day you robbed the bathhouse, this man was in the hospital?

Yeah, he used to have fits, and they took him to the hospital.

Are you sure of this, Brightstein?

Oh, yeah, sure. That's why I had to pay him $200 to testify. He was afraid they'd find out about him being in the hospital that day. I thought you knew all about it, Mr. Simon.

First I ever heard of it.

Gee, I hope everything's going to be all right.

Yeah, so do I.

What is it, Rexy?

Goodbye.

Goodbye, Mr. Simon.

Goodbye, Brightstein. You, um...

Yes, Rexy, what is it?

You rang.

Yeah, did I? I rang? Hmm. Well, I forgot what I wanted. Hmm.

Yes?

Yes, Rexy?

Mr. Simon is here.

Oh, I asked you to come right in. I don't want to be disturbed, Rexy, no matter what it is.

Yes, sir. And keep trying to get there. Try him at his club.

Yes, Mr. Simon.

Hello, darling.

Hello, George. You're looking wonderful.

Well, what is it, George? You were so mysterious on the phone.

I have to tell you this. The European trip is off.

I've pointed to you, and I've never in my life looked this so much. Something has come up. I can't get away.

You were so certain only yesterday that nothing could keep you from going. Why? What is it? Another $100,000 fee?

Oh, I wouldn't have called off our honeymoon, darling, if I had retained it from the United States Steel Corporation.

Well, it's not business, detaining you.

Well, it is and it isn't, yeah. I don't know just how to tell you.

Well, tell me, George, what it is. It doesn't help matters to pile up the suspense.

No, I guess you're right. Well, darling, I'm in trouble. The worst trouble I've been in my whole life.

Well, tell me.

Well, I'm threatened with disbarment.

Oh.

Oh, how perfect it does.

Yeah, I knew it would shock you. It's been a shock to me, I can tell you. I don't understand. I don't understand it. Disbarment? Why, I thought, doesn't disbarment imply...

Yes, it does more than imply. It establishes that a man is guilty of conduct which makes him unworthy to practice his profession. That's what I'm faced with this very minute.

Then, I mean, I'm quite bewildered. 18 years, 18 years. I've been a full-fledged lawyer 18 years. Nobody's ever had anything on me. And then this one thing, this one little thing that was dead and buried comes up. How'd I go like a candle?

What is it you did, George?

You know what it means to frame up an alibi?

Yes, I think I do. Getting someone to testify falsely. I don't know much about these things, George. Wasn't that a dishonest thing to do?

Well, it was conniving at a lie to save a poor kid from going to prison for life to prevent a conviction that nobody wanted, not the judge, nor the district attorney, nor the jury, but that the law made inevitable.

But why do you have anything to do with such people? Thieves, criminals?

Well, I'm a lawyer, darling. Somebody's got to defend people who are accused of crime.

Was this boy guilty?

Guilty of stealing a few dollars. Yes.

And now someone's found out about the alibi and they're going to disbar you. Is that it?

Yes, someone's found out. A man who's had it in for me for years, a gentleman by the name of Francis Clark Baird.

Francis Clark Baird. Why, he's a very eminent lawyer, isn't he? I think I've heard father speak of him. Isn't he one of the Connecticut Bairds?

He may be, for all I know, but that doesn't mean much to me. All that I know is that he's got the dope on me and he's going to make me pay through the nose.

Why do you always put things on a personal basis, George? Isn't it the duty of a man like Mr. Baird?

No man has to break another man unless he wants to.

Darling. You're not fighting with Baird, are you? I really don't know what to say, George. It's most distressing. I know how you've had to struggle and it's all very admirable, but it's made it possible for you to accept things that are rather difficult for me to accept.

Well, what things, darling?

Oh, I don't know. There's something distasteful about the whole atmosphere of the thing. Its association with thieves and perjurers. And now this scandal. It will be a scandal, I'm sure. Newspaper publicity and all that.

I'll try to spare you all I can, darling.

What are my friends going to say? How am I going to face them?

Do they mean more to you than I do?

That isn't the point. Best thing for me to do is to go to Europe on Tuesday as I'd planned. If this thing blows over, and let's hope it will, you can join me abroad later. If it doesn't, well, there's time enough to think about that.

You mean you're...

A crude way of putting it, George. Very unfair to me, too. It isn't as though I could do anything for you.

I could either. I'd be glad to stay, but you've said yourself there isn't anything now, haven't you?

Yes, I guess I did. But at a time like this, I thought I'd like to have you around, that's all.

Isn't that just a little selfish, George?

Yes, I guess you'd get at it in that way. I just thought... I just thought, Cora, that maybe you'd want to stay.

Oh, please don't misunderstand me, George. Please don't think I'm unsympathetic. Would you like me to ask Father to intercede with Mr. Baird?

No, I don't think you'd better do that.

Well, whatever you say. I do hope everything will turn out for the best. Oh, well, I've really got to run now. And ladies and gentlemen, I'm meeting Roy Darwin for cocktails at 21.

Who?

Roy Darwin.

Oh, uh, George, will you be coming out to the country tonight?

Well, I don't know whether I'll be able to make it or not. I'll phone you if I can.

Yes, do. Au revoir, George. I do hope everything's going to be all right.

Goodbye, sweetheart.

Don't bother. I know the way.

What's up with that Baird call? You know, I called his club. They said he wasn't there.

Sure they did. Well, I'll show you where it is, and he's ducking.

Mr. Simon, it's time for you to leave for your luncheon appointment with Mr. LaPorte.

What? Oh, oh, yes. Is it time to leave?

Yes, sir.

All right. You know, Rexy, maybe that guy wasn't so crazy after all.

What do you mean, Mr. Simon?

The one that jumped out of that window. Maybe he's better off that way. Troubles are over.

But I... I know I did.

Maybe I was wrong. What's the matter?

Nothing.

What are you crying about?

I'm not crying.

What's the matter with you lately?

Nothing the matter with me.

Don't you feel well?

Yes, yes, of course.

Maybe you've been working too hard. Maybe you ought to have a little vacation, huh?

No. No, I don't want any vacation.

Well, maybe I'll be going away myself soon, and you'll get a good rest.

I don't want a rest.

I'll get a cab for you now.

No. Never mind. I'll find one. If anyone calls me, I'll be back in an hour. And get me a reservation on the four o'clock plane to Washington.

Yes, Mr. Simon.

In just a moment, we will continue our Campbell Playhouse presentation of Counselor at Law. This is the Columbia Broadcasting System.

This is Ernest Chappell speaking. We welcome you back to the Campbell Playhouse presentation of Counselor at Law starring Orson Welles, Aline McMahon, and Gertrude Byrd.

This is, frankly, an interruption, but a very brief one. In our first performances of the new year, we wish to... We wish to thank you for your ever-increasing use of Campbell Soups, which make these programs possible. Last year, 1938, you bought more Campbell Soups than in any previous year in our history. Naturally, we appreciate it. In these Campbell Playhouse programs, we are making our talks about soup quite short so that they will not interfere with your enjoyment. From time to time, we shall suggest that you try a certain soup that may be new to you or one that you're not using often. All we ask you to do is to try these various Campbell Soups and see for yourself how good they are.

We now bring you the second half of Counselor at Law starring Orson Welles, Aline McMahon, and Gertrude Byrd.

Simon and Tedesco. Mr. Tedesco, who is calling, please? I'll give you Mr. Tedesco. One moment, please. Mr. Simon's out of town. It's almost five now. You'd better call back in the morning. All righty.

Simon and Tedesco. But I'll give you Miss Gordon, the secretary. One moment, please.

Simon and Tedesco. Yes, this is Mr. Simon's office. Miss Gordon speaking. No, I'm awfully sorry. Mr. Simon's out of town. He left last night. Oh, yes. I'll tell him.

Oh, this is Mr. Simon's office. Oh, no, Mr. Simon. No, he's not returned from Washington yet. Are you at the pier now? Well, of course, you might have gone from the airport to the pier. How soon will you be at the pier? Right, I will. I hope you have a pleasant trip, Mr. Simon. I hope you fall overboard, Mr. Simon.

Yes, isn't that kept? No, Mr. Tedesco. That's almost fine. I think he may have gone right to the French line, but here, Mrs. Simon's boat sails at six to Paris. Oh, I forgot to send out a telegram. Do you want me to take care of it for you? Yes, if you don't mind. All right, I'll send it right away.

Hello, John. Oh, good afternoon, Mr. Simon. Hello, Rexon. Well, Mr. Simon, your wife just called up. Yeah? Well, call up the pier. No, never mind. I'll be down in a few minutes. Have a taxi ready for me in about 15 minutes. Yes, sir. Well, did you arrange about the books and flowers? Yes, sir. Uh, you know, fresh flowers every day? Yeah. Do they undertake that? Yes, is that all? Yeah, that's all.

Well, John, Pete Malone and I just got back from Washington. Well? Might just as well have saved ourselves a trip. What did he say? Oh, he handed out the usual line of bull about what a great guy I am, how he loves me like a brother, about what a tough break it is if this thing has to come up. Yes, well, is he going to do something about it? Not a thing. Pete tried to get him to make a personal appeal to Baird, but it wasn't a bit of use. Oh, the yellow rat. Why didn't you tell him that if it hadn't been for you, we never would have got the nomination? Oh, it's no use. He knows it already. It's because he doesn't want to know it. I don't blame you for being good and sore, that dirty little snake. I know, but what do you expect? This is a cutthroat game we're in. It's every man for himself.

Well, John, I'm about at the end of my rope. Tomorrow morning at 10 o'clock, the grievance committee meets, and once it gets before them, I can kiss my little career goodbye. Now, you're crazy. We're going to fight, and we're going to get you out of it. I don't want to see you talking that way, John. You know better. I haven't got a chance. I'm through. Now, listen. Take my advice and get some sleep tonight. I guess you haven't been sleeping much, have you? No, not much. Well, that's what you need. A good sleep. Why don't you lie down and take a nap now? No, I've got to go down to the boat and say goodbye to my wife. Is there anything I can do?

Mr. Simon. Yeah? I forgot to tell you, Charlie McFadden wants to see you about something. Wait till tomorrow. Are you getting me a cab? Yes, sir, right away. Yeah.

Excuse me, Chief. Can I see you for a minute? Not now, Charlie. I've got to go down to the boat to see Mrs. Simon off. Well, I've got some news for you, Chief. I'm sorry. You've got some... What kind of news? It's about our friend across the way. Oh, Baird? That's him. Let's have it. Come on, Charlie. Do you want to know something about him? Well, I'll say I do. Well, what is it? Well, Francis Clark Baird is leading a double life. What do you mean he's leading a double life? Well, wait till I tell you now, Chief. Remember me telling you I found out that he's always making business trips to Philadelphia? Yeah, well... Well, yesterday Alfie goes to the Pennsylvania station and boards a train for Philly with me right behind him. Well? He gets out of the station and hops a taxi for Germantown. Germantown. So he grabs another hack and tells the driver to follow him. Yes, go on. Well, we're going along great when all of a sudden he gets into a traffic jam and by the time it gets straightened out we lose him. Well, is that all? Oh, Lord, no. That's just the beginning. He goes back to the station and hangs around waiting to see if the other taxi is going to come back. Well, after waiting for about three hours, sure enough, back it comes. Was Baird in it? No, sir, it wasn't. Well, go on, go on. Well, I gets talking to the driver and asks him if he remembers. He says he does. He takes the same man out every week to visit his niece in Germantown on Sycamore Drive, number 1217 it was. So, I drive out to 1217 and it's dark by now. So I look through the window and there's a girl. A good-looker she is, too. A good-looker she is, too. And there's a photograph of Baird over the mantelpiece. Was Baird there? No, sir, he was not. Oh, what is all this? What proof you got that he ever was there? Wait a minute, chief. I ain't done yet. I says to myself, that little lady don't look like no niece to me. Is that what you call evidence? No, sir. Well, go on. Well, there's nothing to do till everybody's in bed. Then I goes back to 1217 and takes a look into the house. What do you mean? You broke into the house? Well, I wouldn't want to admit that, chief. I'd be liable to arrest and imprisonment if I did. Are you crazy? What'd you do a thing like that for? Now, don't worry about me, chief. It was an easy job and I ain't so much out of practice as I thought I'd be. Well, what'd you find out? Well, I figured there'd be letters from him and there was. You found letters from Baird to this woman? Yes, sir. A whole stack of them. Where are they? What do they say? They're right here, chief. They're all about how much he loves her and adores her and about how she don't have to worry about her future. If she'll just lie low and keep her mouth shut.

Darling, you don't know what you've done for me. Well, it's the least I could do, chief. After all you've done for me. Say, Rexy. Yes, yes, Mr. Simon. Get me Francis Clark Baird on the phone right away. Yes, sir. Give me a line. Rexy, I think we've got Mr. Francis Clark Baird just about where we want him. And say, Rexy, take the case. Yes, Mr. Simon.

To my wife. Darling, darling, don't sail. Get right off the boat. Everything's going to be all right and I'll be able to go with you in a few days. Phone me the instant you get this. All my love, sweetheart.

Calling, please. I'm sorry, Mr. Tedesco's gone for the day.

Simon and Tedesco. One moment, please. I'll give you a secretary.

Oh, uh, Bethany, Mr. Simon's not to be disturbed. He's having an important conference with Mr. Francis Clark Baird. If any calls come, I'll take them out here. Okay, Miss Gordon.

Oh, good evening, Mrs. Simon. Uh, Miss Gordon, is my son here yet? Well, there's somebody in there with him and I think it's kind of important. I want you to sit down. It won't be very long. It's all right. I'll wait. I got plenty time. How are you today, Miss Gordon? Oh, I'm all right, thanks. And you? Oh, I can't complain. You know, Miss Gordon, every time I come in the office here, I always think of the first place my Georgie worked. Oh. What a street. Yeah. She was 13 years old. 13? She was an awful little girl. She was an awful little boy already for Haitian Rosenthal. Mm-hmm. For $4 a week. Oh, well. Yeah. $4 a week it started. Yeah. And today he's the biggest lawyer in New York. It is. Mm-hmm.

Uh, Miss Gordon, uh, is he feeling all right? Is he, uh... Yes. As far as I know, now, why? I don't know. Every day this week when he called me up, he sounded so blue. Oh, well, if there was anything wrong, he'd have told me.

Hello, Georgie. Uh, Mr. Baird, I want you to meet my mother. How do you do, Mrs. Simon? How do you do? You know, Mr. Baird, she's a regular old shrew. If I don't behave myself, she comes after me with a broom pin. Georgie, how can you talk such foolishness? I'm afraid I really must be going. Oh, must you? I'm very sorry. All right, Mr. Baird, thanks for coming in. Why don't you drop in someday and have lunch with me, Mr. Baird? Thank you very much. Good day, Mrs. Simon. Bye. Goodbye.

My pal, Mrs. Clark Baird, he's one of the handsomest, blue-blooded, stuffed shirts I ever met. What's the matter with you, Georgie? Nothing's the matter with me. I'm just feeling good, that's all. Can't I feel good if I want to? I'm glad you feel good, Georgie. I'm feeling fine, Mama. I've never felt so fine in my life. Say, how about a little dance? Come on, come on. Give us a dance. Georgie, are you serious? You're a fine dancer, you are. You have to give me a few lessons. Now, come on. Give me a few lessons. Come on, Mama. Is that a new hat? Oh, God. Two years ago, it was new. I never saw it before. Here, Mama, buy it. Buy yourself a new hat. I don't want a new hat, Georgie. I want you to buy yourself a new hat. Come on. Georgie.

Hey, Betsy, go home. I won't need you anymore. Oh, you're expecting Mrs. Simon to call. That's all right. I'll take the call myself. Go on, Betsy. Beat it. Yes. Doing your book. Thanks, Mrs. Simon. Good night. Good night.

Hey, Rexy. Rexy, you can go home, too. Oh, I'm in no hurry. Go on home, I tell you. Don't you know there's a law against night work for women? Oh, is there? Are you sure you don't need me? Listen, if you don't go right away, I'll drop you out of the window. Go on, run along. I don't get my things. Well, good night. Good night, Mrs. Simon. Good night, Miss Gordon. Good night.

George, why do you act like a crazy? I don't know. I'm just feeling good, that's all. Would you like to see me feeling good, Mama? Well, I didn't think you were feeling good, Georgie. That's why I came to see you. Over the telephone, you sounded so blue. I was worried about you. Oh, I decided to stop worrying, Mama. I had one or two important things on my mind, but everything's all right now. I think... Oh, everything's fine. I feel great. I knew there was something wrong. It's all over now, I tell you, Mama. Now, wait a minute. That must be Cora. Let me speak.

Listen, sweetheart. Sweetheart, I've got some wonderful news for you. Listen, everything's all right. Everything's all right, honey. You know, the Baird matter. Well, it's all fixed up. You would be. And listen, darling, get right off the boat. We've only got ten minutes. Why, didn't you get my note? You still got time to get off. Honey, we'll have a little celebration tonight. You know, it's all right. Just the two of us, you and I. But, darling, it's only... it's only postponing it a few days. You shouldn't do anything on my account. Oh, it's all right. I...

Anything wrong? Why don't you tell me, Georgie? Leave me alone. Leave me alone? Yes, Georgie. Only if I can help you. I don't want any help, Mama. Help me by going home. That's all you can help me. All right. All right, Georgie. Do you want me to go? I'll go. I wish you would. I have some work to do. Bye, Georgie. Please take good care of yourself. Goodbye, Mama. Bye.

He's out? He left for Europe. Do you have to know the boat he's sailing on? You're spying on me. That's... Oh, no, I haven't. Honest, honest, I haven't. Don't lie to me. You've been spying on me.

Oh, I couldn't go home. I was so worried.

Shut up! Shut up, you hear me? I'll break every bone in your body, and you better start looking around for another job. I'm leaving this business. Oh, I'm finished. Work yourself to the bone, and for what? Every snob in town can...

Hello? Yes, yes. Well, I'll see if he's still here. He's calling, please. Mr. Theodore, Mr. Wingdale, the president of the American Steel Company.

Tell him to go to the devil.

Well, I say you're not in.

I don't care what you say.

Well, I'm afraid he's gone, Mr. Wingdale. Is there anything I can do? Oh, this is his secretary speaking. No, I don't. Oh, well, just one moment. He says it's a matter of life and death. Oh, I can't. Tell him... Say, is that Wingdale himself?

Yes, sir.

Well, tell him... Oh, wait a minute. I'll talk to him myself. Hello, Mr. Wingdale. This is George Simon speaking. Yeah, my secretary got me just as I was getting the elevator. What's the trouble? Oh, I see. Oh, is that so? Oh. Oh. Oh. Oh. Has the police been there? That's Wingdale. Have you made his statement? Oh, that's right. Don't say anything. I'll be right up. Goodbye.

Wingdale's son had a fight with his wife this afternoon. Shot her dead.

Oh, that's... Hello? Say, she was the richest girl in Texas. Can you imagine what a case like that's going to be? We've got to get right on the job.

Well, I'm ready.

You're always ready, Rex. One thing I can count on. Nothing else. Have a sandwich on the way up.

What are you waiting for?

Nothing, Mr. Simon.

Come on. You don't need a hat. Come on.

Yes, Mr. Simon.

Say, Rexy.

Yes, Mr. Simon.

Rexy, I'm sorry I bawled you out this afternoon.

Oh, that's all right, Mr. Simon.

Well, I... Rex, Mr. Simon, let's get...

You have just heard Orson Welles in his own Campbell Playhouse production of Counselor at Law by Elmer Rice. In just a moment, Orson Welles will bring you his guest of the evening, Mr. Samuel S. Leibowitz, noted trial lawyer, and the leading players of tonight's cast, Eileen McMahon and Gertrude Berg. But first, as I said a little while ago, you and your family can enjoy the good taste of chicken any time just by serving Campbell's chicken soup. You see, it's made the good old-fashioned way. Campbell's chefs use all the meat of government-certified plump chickens. Then they simmer the broth long and slowly until it positively glistens with golden richness and delicious chicken flavor abounds in every spoonful. They add snowy rice and pieces of chicken, chicken so tender it almost melts in your mouth. But after all, the proof is in the eating. So why not have it this weekend? Because just as sure as you like chicken, you'll like Campbell's chicken soup.

Now, here is Orson Welles.

And here is Mr. Leibowitz.

Well, Orson, the jury requires no deliberation. Mr. Leibowitz and I have reached our decision. We find you guilty. Guilty of a good show in the first degree.

Well, Sam, I won't appeal that. You know, this isn't the first lawyer you've played on the radio.

Yes, I remember you used to be quite famous for your impersonations of me on news broadcasts. For a while there, I thought it was I.

Sam, I'd like you to meet the accessories before the fact. Eileen McMahon, please take the stand.

Your witness, Mr. Leibowitz.

Miss McMahon, I followed you on the stage and in the pictures.

Oh, thanks, Mr. Leibowitz. I followed you in the headlines. And I'd like to tell you how much I've enjoyed your performance of Regina Gordon tonight.

Is that the whole truth and nothing but the truth?

So help me.

Call Gertrude Berg.

Mrs. Berg, is it not true that during numerous 15-minute periods from Monday through Friday, you are known to millions of radio listeners as Mrs. Goldberg?

Yes, Mr. Leibowitz.

And is it not true that... That tonight is your first appearance outside that radio series?

I must remind you, Gertrude Berg, that anything you say may be held against you.

Yes, Mr. Leibowitz. And it's been so very pleasant working with Mr. Welles that I hope it won't be the last.

I must caution the witness that it won't be if I can help it.

And now, Orson, as to your performance as George Simon...

As your legal advisor, Orson, I urge you not to object to what I'd like to say.

Objection sustained. Such references are irrelevant, immaterial, and calculated to prejudice the radio audience.

Thank you, Sam, anyway. And thanks, Eileen and Mrs. Berg. Case dismissed.

Well, next week, I'm taking you out of doors and out to sea for a sea story, a true sea story. For all of the wild yarns that are spun about ships and sailors, the hardest to believe is the thoroughly authenticated adventures of the crew of the HMS Bounty and her master, Captain Bligh. Nordhoff and Hall have retold these adventures in three bestsellers. The name of the first of these was the name of a great movie. It is also the title of next week's broadcast. Until then, until Mutiny on the Bounty, until next Friday night, the Campbell Playhouse is obediently yours.

Heard on tonight's program was Manhattan Serenade by Louis Alter.

This is the Columbia Broadcasting System.

End of transcriptBack to the beginning ↑