Skip to content
On Air
All channelsAll
Casey, Crime Photographer artwork

From the Casey, Crime Photographer collection

The Miscarriage of Justice

Episode 20529 min 44 secTranscript

The written record

Read the transcript

Read along with the recording · About 22 min to read

The Anchor Hocking Glass Corporation brings you Crime Photographer.

Peter Piper picked a pick. Peter Piper picked a pick.

What are you mumbling about, Ethelbert?

Well, I got a bet with Casey, Mr. Marvin. He didn't think I could say it three times running. Peter Piper pickled a pack, uh, Peter, see...

You know, it doesn't look to me as though you could even say it once, Ethelbert.

That's why I got to practice. Peter Piper...

Look, why not try an easier sentence, Ethelbert? You know, more useful, too.

Like what, Mr. Marvin?

Like, uh, Anchor Hocking is the most famous name in glass.

Good evening, ladies and gentlemen. This is Tony Marvin. Every week at this time, the Anchor Hocking Glass Corporation of Lancaster, Ohio, and its more than 10,000 employees, bring you another adventure of Casey, Crime Photographer, ace cameraman who covers the crime news of a great city. Written by Alonzo Dean Cleary, our adventure for tonight, Miscarriage of Justice.

Afternoon, a busy downtown street, a darkly handsome, flashily dressed woman steps from a taxi cab.

Mercedes!

Huh?

Mercedes. What's the idea of grabbing my arm? I don't know you.

You know me very well.

I never saw you before in my life.

You say that to me? Your husband's father?

You don't let me go? I'll call a cop.

No. I call for a cop. Police. Police. Police.

Stop that. Let's go someplace, you call.

No, you bad woman. Every day I pray I see you sometimes, and all my prayers is answered.

Let me go.

Hey, hey, what's going on here?

This crazy old man, officer. Arrest him.

He goes to jail, Mr. Policeman. But I'll tell you the truth. She's Mercedes Domingo.

I'm not. It's a lie.

Ah, now, hold it, all of you. Just who is Mercedes Domingo and why?

Ten years ago, Mr. Policeman, my son Carlos was sent to prison for the murder of his wife. Only he and I know he's not guilty. Now, the world knows. The world will know. Because this woman is the wife he did not kill.

All right. All right. I'm ready to issue a statement. We want an interview.

Yeah, we want pictures of her and the old man who recognized her.

That's right. Well, Casey, all of you newspaper boys and girls, later. But right now, I'm giving you a break with an advance statement. Ladies and gentlemen, some of you may be unfamiliar with the Domingo case. So I'll begin with a brief resume. Nearly ten years ago, a young laborer named Carlos Domingo was convicted of killing his wife, Mercedes.

On circumstantial evidence, Mr. Policeman.

Well, I, Casey, was not district attorney at that time. According to the testimony, Domingo had threatened her at various times. She disappeared. And he told inquiring neighbors that he believed she'd run off with another man, a waiter named Gonzales. Now, this waiter was unknown in the neighborhood, and Domingo's stories about him were extremely conflicting.

Oh, yeah. Then the body of a murdered woman was recovered from the river and identified as the missing Mercedes.

I saw that body, and it's been in the water a long time.

Carlos Domingo was brought to trial, convicted, and sentenced to death. Fortunately, his sentence was later commuted to life imprisonment.

After he spent nearly a year in the death house.

Well, now this man's wife has reappeared alive. She's been positively identified as Mercedes Domingo.

Well, what did she say about letting her husband be sent up for her murder?

Well, she claimed she didn't know anything about it, Miss Williams. She denies knowing any waiter named Gonzales and says she was working in a small town in Texas at the time Domingo was arrested and brought to trial. She says the papers down there didn't carry the story, and she may be telling the truth.

She's in the chips now. What's she been doing for herself while her hubby's been sweating it out in the big house?

She's done very well, Casey. Several years ago, she acquired a piece of land in Texas that later proved to have oil underneath.

Well, oil, what?

She's now worth a couple of million. And that's the whole gist of it. That's the story, except that Mrs. Domingo has also gotten herself another husband without bothering to divorce her first. He's a Texas racketeer named Alfred Jenkins.

Alfred Jenkins. Unfavorably known to the police as Al the Barber.

Well, this yarn gets better and better.

Yeah, but the biggest thing about it is, Mr. Prosecutor, how soon can you spring Carlos Domingo out of the pen?

Take this as a direct quote. My office will take immediate steps to arrange the man's release.

Mrs. Williams.

Ethelbert.

Hi. Here's your beer, Casey.

Thanks, pal. I suppose you and Casey are going up to Wallstock Prison tomorrow morning to see Carlos Domingo be let out, Miss Williams.

Mm-hmm. We are, Ethelbert. Yep, every paper in town's gonna give it front page coverage.

Poor guy. Ten years in stir for a wife murder that didn't happen. And, um, our impression of Mercedes Domingo is that murder couldn't have happened to a more deserving gal.

I guess she ain't much good.

Yeah, and all the D.A. really has to do is nail her. She has on her a bigamy charge, and that may not stand up.

Why not?

She married this Al the Barber guy while she had another husband.

Well, here's the gimmick, as I get it. According to a statute of limitations, if you don't hear from a wife or husband for so many years, he or she can be legally presumed dead, you see, which means you're free to marry again. She says her lawyer told her that.

Mrs. Domingo's second husband is sticking by her in all this, I read.

Hmm, well, why shouldn't he? Married a couple of million bucks, he hopes to hang on to her.

Mr. Jenkins is another sweet-scented character.

How did he get his nickname of Al the Barber?

Uh, there's a very complicated reason behind that, Ethelbert.

Yeah?

His first name is Alfred, and he used to be a barber.

Oh!

Yeah.

Did he know she was married?

Nah, she probably never told him what she'd done to her other husband, so all this has been quite a shock to the mug.

Oh, Annie, it's getting late. You've got to make an early start to that prison in the morning.

It's quite a drive. The walls suck.

Let's go home and get some sleep.

Who's going to pay that poor guy for all he's been through?

Well, the state will indemnify him by giving him a few thousand bucks, I guess. But even at that, he's been a poor guy for nothing.

Guess he's thinking plenty about that and is pretty bitter.

I'd be.

Well, in prison, guys learn to keep their thoughts and their feelings to themselves. So let's go, Annie.

There's Harris, Domingo's lawyer. There's Domingo's father. There's Domingo.

Say, you reporters, I'm going to shoot your questions, Annie. I'll grab camera mugs and some pictures.

Uh, Mr. Domingo, we thought we want to know what...

Ladies and gentlemen, ladies and gentlemen, please, please, ladies and gentlemen, my client is anxious to cooperate with the press, but one at a time.

Okay, Mr. Harris. Uh, Mr. Domingo, what are your immediate plans?

My only plan is to go home with my father here.

Carlos, at my house, you will see no more high wall, no more barbed wire.

Oh, my son.

Father.

Hold on, will you? Father and son, picture me a hug.

Yeah.

Mr. Domingo, uh, your wife's a rich woman now. Do you intend to bring a civil action against her?

Oh, excuse me, Miss Williams. That question should be addressed to me, not my client.

Oh, okay. What's your answer, Mr. Harris?

Well, civil action in this case must be an outgrowth of criminal action against Mercedes Domingo. The authorities are trying to establish a basis for criminal prosecution. But at the present time, I cannot reveal the extent of their findings.

Fair enough, Mr. Harris. Only, um, you can answer this one, Mr. Domingo. How do you feel about your wife?

Feel? I feel nothing, lady.

Well, you must. You'd be inhuman if you didn't.

Ha, ha. Since I was a very young man, I've been locked inside this prison. Once they came and shaved my leg and head to make me ready for the electric chair. All for a thing I did not do. Human? I forgot how a human being feels.

Ask me, this boy's father, how I feel about that woman. I tell you, for what she has done to Carlos, my son, I'd like to cut her heart out. I'd like to see her die.

Hey, I've finished that up, Annie. We're here so we can get out of this lousy city.

Yeah, I've got only a few more paragraphs to type, do you see? Rice is sure milking the Domingo story, Lawrence.

You're telling me. All the facts have been in print dozens of times since the story broke.

Hey, there's your phone, kid.

Oh, yeah.

Oh, I'll answer it, will you? I'm checking over this last paragraph.

Yeah.

Williams, that's Casey speaking.

I didn't see you there.

Oh, hello, boss. What? When? Where? Okay, we're starting right away.

Hey, what is it, Casey?

Well, there's something plenty new for your story, Annie. Mercedes Domingo has been murdered.

Oh, no.

Yes. Sometime last night with her own blade. Her body has just been found in a hotel room. She was slashed to death with a razor.

The story will continue in just a moment. And now, a word about how to enjoy beer at its best. Right out of a clean glass bottle. Yes, a clean glass bottle. Because glass and glass only can bring you beer and ale as the brewer wants you to enjoy it. Clean, clear, sparkling. Not affected by any foreign flavor. That's it. Beer that's brewery bright. And now you have a new kind of bottle. The Anchor Glass One Way No Deposit Bottle. One way means that when it's empty you dispose of it as you would any other refuse. You are the first and last to use it. No deposit means no empties to be returned. No deposit, no fuss. This bottle also saves space in the icebox. It's easy to open. And to drink from. And it protects the real brewery flavor as only clean glass can protect it. Yes, the revolutionary new Anchor Glass One Way No Deposit Bottle is sweeping America. For perfect flavor, demand beer in glass bottles. For extra convenience, demand your favorite brand in the new Anchor Glass One Way No Deposit Bottle. The clean bottle. A product of Anchor Hocking. Name in glass.

Whoever carved up Mercedes Domingo did a very thorough job.

I'll say it was a thorough job, Casey. Put the sheet back over that body, Cap.

I told you not to look, Miss Williams.

Did I say she was killed last night?

Yeah, about 11 o'clock.

What have you found out?

Not much so far. Floor clerk on duty. Can't remember anybody visiting with the Domingo woman last night. She was known here as Mrs. Jenkins.

Did you find the murder weapon?

No, we didn't find it. Doc says only a straight razor could inflict such wounds.

Razors? Barber's razors?

Yeah. But we did find $10,000 in cash lying on this table where the killer couldn't have failed to see it.

$10,000?

Anything else?

Yeah. They tore up a good-sized piece of blood-stained cardboard and burned it in that fireplace last night.

What kind of cardboard?

Oh, heavy, good-quality stuff with a linen-like finish. Like they used to make paper collars out of.

Paper collars?

Yeah, my old man wore them when I was a kid. You probably never saw one, Miss Williams.

Oh.

I sent the pieces down to the headquarters lab and... That's all I've got, Casey. Outside of a perfect suspect.

Yeah. Sure looks like a revenge killing. That adds up to Carlos Domingo. Or, uh, Carlos' father.

Do you know what he said at the prison, Casey, that he'd like to cut this woman's heart out?

Yeah, I know. I'm having both father and son picked up and brought down to headquarters.

Logan, you know, this adds up so easy, I distrust the total.

Yeah, frankly, Casey, I'm a little afraid of it. I'm having Jenkins and, uh, Elton.

You mean because the barber's razor was used?

No, Miss Williams, because with this woman dead, Jenkins has a swell chance of inheriting all her dough. And it's that darn razor that makes him an unlikely suspect.

Yeah, that fogs the picture.

Well, I don't see why.

He used to be a barber.

Okay, Annie, it isn't probable he'd use a murder weapon that ties up with his nickname and his former trade. He figured the cops would get ideas from that.

That's 100% correct, Miss Williams. But, Captain, use of that razor has given you and Casey the idea that Jenkins is an unlikely suspect.

Yeah, but... Huh? Hmm. Flutters. These women love him.

Yeah. I'm starting for headquarters. Carlos, his old man and Elk Jenkins had better have perfect alibis or else.

Yeah, well, I don't think that or else can apply to Carlos, though. He's already served time for the murder of his wife and been unconditionally pardoned. And a man can't be tried twice for the same crime, can he?

That's for the lawyers to argue out. I'm just a cop for the murder to solve. Let go.

At 11 o'clock last night, you were out walking, Carlos.

Walking alone, you say?

Yes, Captain. Walking alone. And you walked to Kyrgyzstan's hotel, didn't you? You got into a room and killed her.

If you think so.

You admit it.

I admit nothing. I deny nothing.

Give me a direct answer. Did you kill that woman?

Once I said, policeman, no, I did not kill. So I'm punished. Now I say, I do kill.

What happened? You had Carlos on the back?

I guess you know you haven't much chance in sending me out for a crime. And you've already paid for it. Captain, a very bad woman has been killed. Whether I kill her or another killer, he's dead. Now I say no more.

Domingo, your son says he was out between 10 o'clock and midnight. You can't prove you didn't leave the house, go to that hotel and kill Mercedes.

That's not true.

You did prove her. You did kill her.

That can you prove?

It was either you or your son.

You think so, eh? All right, I let you think. My son, you cannot make pay again for something you have safer before. And I pay too when you people said the Lord took my only son away. Me? You cannot make pay again. But I am old and have little time to live. I laugh at you, Captain. I laugh and say no more.

Were you in the lounge at the hotel Marbury at 11 last night, Jenkins?

I never left the place from 9 last night till almost 2 this morning.

Were you alone in the Marbury lounge or was somebody with you?

Two very well-known gents. I mean gentlemen were with me. My son, Mayor Tony, Louis West, and Lieutenant Brenner of your own headquarters police.

Lieutenant Brenner? He was at my table constantly from 10 o'clock till after midnight.

Okay, Jenkins. I'm afraid your alibi will be as good as you say.

Annie, come on, get in.

Yeah, okay. Huh?

Do you think Carlos or his father did the killing?

No. They're simply 100% behind anybody who did. Jenkins had a perfect alibi.

Yeah. Annie, wait. Hmm?

The floor clerk at that hotel didn't remember seeing anybody visit Mercedes' room?

Of course he wouldn't.

Why not?

Those caps of burned cardboard Logan found. They reminded Logan of the material used for paper collars.

So what?

Something else is made of the same material. Paper dickies, Annie. Dickies? Yeah, those false shirt fronts, the starch kind. When it gets dirty, you throw it away and stick a fresh one under the collar button. Waiters wear them, Annie.

Well, I don't see what that...

Waiters wear them, Annie. And who'd notice a waiter in the halls of a big hotel? But Logan said none of the employees seemed possible suspects.

Well, this waiter didn't have to work in the hotel.

Well, then any man could have put on a touchy-toe.

No, no, no. Not any man. He had to actually be a waiter to get by the way he did or to kill the way he did. He had to be... That Gonzalez.

Gonzalez? The waiter Mercedes left Carlos for ten years ago. She walked out on Gonzalez and double-crossed him as she's double-crossed every other guy she's known.

Yeah. We're gonna try to find Gonzalez, Annie.

Well, how can we? Carlos' chief defense lawyer, Harris, he's got a picture of Gonzalez.

He has?

Yeah. Harris let me make a copy of it a few days ago. Well, I thought that he definitely might want to run it.

Annie, we get that picture and then we go to work.

Walk-up building. I don't know, Annie. I don't know.

Well, so make the thirteenth agency we visited.

Well, our luck is bound to change.

Yeah. Get work. This is done. You two are waiters and a chef?

No.

Oh, no. Well, in that case, nothing for you today. Only thing open for a married couple is a waitress and a chef.

What, I? Cashier and counterbanker?

Neither, pal. Well, you don't look like dishwashers.

Oh, thanks. I guess you must be a bartender, pal. If I can tell you not a waiter, you ain't got the manner. And here are registry cards to fill out and give me 50 cents a piece.

Mister, let me say something.

Go ahead. Who's stopping you?

Well, we're not looking.

Oh, you want to hire people. Well, step into my office. Sit down. Make yourself at home. What do you want there? Help a restaurant? Hotel?

Look, we're looking for a waiter.

I've got thousands of them. But we only want one. A special one. Here's his picture. Look.

You don't want this waiter.

You know him?

Of course I do. His name's Frank Gomez.

Frank Gomez?

Yes. He'd be a fine waiter. He's unoffendable now and I lost two jobs I got him. You don't want him. He's just the guy we do want, mister.

Okay, I've warned you. Give me your address and I'll send him to you.

No, no. Give us his address. I don't do business that way.

No. What's that $20 bill for?

Gomez's address.

Well, I like to do business. Wait till I find his card. Say, that other fella must have been looking for Gomez.

Huh? Other fella?

Yeah, he was in here a half hour ago.

What did the guy look like?

A big fella. Well-dressed. That's all I noticed. Here. Here's his address.

Thanks, pal. Thanks for the double serve. Bye.

What do you think? Who do you think was looking for Gomez?

One of Logan's cops, Annie. That lug has figured those scraps of burned cardboard just the way I did. He's put his guys out to find Gonzalez. If we want an exclusive story, Annie, we've got to get to this address before Logan beats us to it.

This is a terrible old tenement case.

Yeah, pretty bad, isn't it? I think we're on the wrong track. No man who lives in a place like this would have passed up Mercedes $10,000. We'll soon find out. Here goes.

Guess he didn't. Let's try the door. It's unlocked.

Hey, a man who's on the top. A pleasant dream. Everything was over because I was once a man and she made me a dog. We took her away from Carlos Domingo. Yes. Crazy mad for her. I'm full. Has been because she say he back to her. Carlos is arrested for her murder. Think it's fine joke on him. We say let him go to prison or die. Then we will marry.

You and Mercedes?

Yes. I give her all my money and send her away. No more where people know me. Write me letters for a while. Send her letters down where she was.

Nice guy, weren't you? Didn't say a few words. Afraid and full of hate for the woman who had made me a coward and a fool. I read in the paper of how Mercedes is farmed. I found out where she lived. Yesterday I call her on the telephone.

You found her?

I tell her I've kept her letters. Letters that would send her to prison with her like a cat with a mouse. Say get $10,000. I will come for it tomorrow, but... I go to her last night. A waiter uniform with a pocket. Yes. I tell her who I am. She's afraid. She quick offer me the money.

Then?

Then my bad life should be ended too.

Mr. Gale, Mr. Gale. I'm here to protect my interest, Mr. Casey. We were both trying to locate Gonzales in the same way this afternoon. It wasn't a cop that man bought animals.

Who is this man who is pointing a gun at us?

Yes, you two should know each other. Gonzales, meet Mercedes' final boyfriend, Mr. Alf the Barber Jenkins.

Change that boyfriend to husband, wise guy. Make it husband and sole heir.

Yes, I'm beginning to get this straight now. Gonzales, hand over those old letters of Mercedes.

Hello? I guess she told you about that phone call from Gonzales, Alf.

Right after she got it. If Gonzales talked or showed those letters, you would be out as Mercedes' husband. The court would award everything she got.

Yeah. Gonzales, don't think I hold it against you for bumping off Mercedes. That's okay, fella. I want them letters.

Wait, Gonzales. Don't tell him. Even if he gets those letters, he doesn't dare let you live on Miss Williams and me. We've heard your story. He's come here prepared for a killing.

The letters are not here, Miss Barber. If you kept your trap shut, you might have lived a little longer. After this muggy who did it to the belly, he'll be anxious to talk and you'll get...

No!

I got his gun, Annie. He shot Gonzales. Feed it for a doctor quick and the cops. Quick, kid.

Gonzales, you walked right into that gun of Jenkins when he was going to give me the works. If you hadn't drawn his attention away with it...

I let innocent men go to prison and do not try to... El bueno Dios gave me a chance to shoot it.

I understand. Just a moment.

We've told you how much easier it is to prepare better dishes in Fire King oven glass. Now, let me tell you another reason why housewives prefer Fire King oven glass. Fire King oven glass is so easy to clean. Fire King has a special non-porous surface which is literally mirror-finished. It's almost impossible. For Fire King oven glass to absorb baking stains and odors. And that's why, unlike ordinary baking dishes, Fire King oven glass always comes clean, bright, and sparkling in a jiffy. Another of the many reasons it will pay you to insist on Fire King oven glass by name. Now, remember, there's only one genuine Fire King oven glass. Today, you'll find a wide variety of Fire King casseroles, high-plate, general utility dishes in all sizes wherever household glass is sold, and at amazingly low prices. Every Fire King dish is guaranteed for two full years against oven breakage. Fire King oven glass is a product of Anchor Hawking. Famous name.

Found them letters after Gonzales died, huh, Casey?

The cops did, Everburn. Those letters complete the case for Carlos Domingo, Mercedes' husband, only heir he'll get her in college. Which is a pretty small payment for all he went through.

Not so. Now I guess that Alphaboy Barber will get more than a sample of what Carlos went through.

Yeah, much more. He'll get the worst.

Some husbands of Mercedes don't have such a good time of it, do they?

She was what you call a femi-fatally.

Huh?

Well, that's a Greek word meaning, uh, female troublemaker. Uh, like Cleopatra and Helena Troi and Mrs. O'Leary's cow.

Mrs. O'Leary's cow? Do you know your history? That cow kicked over a lantern once and for all. And burned up most of Chicago.

Uh, a femi-fatally, Casey.

Annie, a femi-fatally. What's the matter?

Applebird, tell us more.

...Cotsworth as Casey is brought to you each Thursday by the Anchor Hawking Glass Corporation. Makers of Fire King Oven Glass, Anchor Glass Containers, Anchor Caps and Closures, all products of Anchor Hawking, the most famous name in glass. Photographer is goodbye John. And the program features Miss Jan Miner as Ann and John Gibson as Ethelbert. Herman Chitteson is the Blue Note Pianist. This is Tony Marvin saying goodnight for the Anchor Hawking Glass Corporation of Lancaster, Ohio with offices in all principal cities of the United States and Canada. Thursday night on CBS is the biggest show in town. So stay tuned for exciting dramatization on Reader's Digest Radio Edition which follows immediately over most of these stations. We are broadcasting this stuff.

End of transcriptBack to the beginning ↑