The written record
Read the transcript
Read along with the recording · About 23 min to read
CBS Radio Mystery Theater presents... Welcome. I'm E.G. Marshall. There's a phrase going around nowadays, used promiscuously by various people: meaningful relationship. Relationship means connection. Meaningful doesn't mean anything at all. It's not even in the dictionary. Meaningless is there, but not meaningful. It's a word devised out of desperation. Not because our richly endowed language has need of it, but to avoid facing the possibility that all life threatens to become meaningless.
You did?
Sure I was. When was that?
Quite a long time ago.
What was it like?
To remember. Our mystery drama, Answer Me, was written especially for the Mystery Theater by Elspeth Eric and stars Larry Haines. It is sponsored in part by True Value Hardware Stores and Buick Motor Division. I'll be back shortly with Act One.
You look at the people you pass on the street. Or do you simply walk on by? Do you smile sometimes? Or stop to pet their dog? Do you say, nice day, or some weather? If you do, you've made a connection. A relationship. It may end right there. You've made it.
The story we're about to bring you begins with a lone man walking down a street in a large western city.
Pretending to check in my nice black. Now then I turn my head to look at my reflection. I see a reflection in a store window and I think I recognize myself. I'm not positive. Anyone who'd speak firmly enough could persuade me otherwise.
Every red light I wait patiently for to turn green. A grubby little place with no urgency. A fierce man before the usual bartender, glasses wiping.
What'll it be?
Uh, red? No, no, whatever, any kind. Uh, I guess water.
Yes, I want it.
You don't have to drink it, you know.
Well, I have to do something.
You're not used to liquor, are you?
Oh, I've done some drinking.
Why don't you go on home?
Five years ago, three weeks after we were married, she came down with polio. You know, she lived for ten years and then she died.
How were the ten years, if you really want to know?
I can imagine.
Oh, there's the customer. Hey there, Mr. Vincent.
Yeah, that's all. How's everything with you, Mr. Vincent?
Alan's face twisted. I hear her screaming. Me and me screaming.
Good with people these days. I appreciate her. You see, I wrote a book.
You did?
Yeah, it was published actually, yes.
Yeah, wish I could write.
But it wasn't reviewed.
You mean like in the papers?
No place. No, nobody paid any attention to it. They ignored it.
Well, how can they do that?
Well, there's only so much space and hundreds of books.
Significant or not, any space.
Depressing?
Well, what other way is there to tell?
I don't know. I'll tell you what. It's just a suggestion. Why don't you get the heck out of town? There's any place. Mexico, Hawaii, Canada. Just go.
And do what?
How should I know? Just go. It's something to do. Better than sitting in some bar, the state you're in?
Sure. Why not? You got some money?
Yeah, some.
So go. But watch out for the tequila down there.
Myself on this road. Decided I'd walk to Mexico. The idea of sitting still on a plane. And the effort of putting one foot after the other makes me feel somewhere new. Every so often the truck drivers refuse. Politely. I'm a little grateful that someone who does me that slight courtesy pays me.
How far are you going?
What?
You going far?
Uh, Mexico. By the ways from here.
I'm not going that far, but I could take you for a mile.
Uh, no, thanks.
You're tired, aren't you?
No. I'm all right.
You're sure you won't ride for a mile?
Thanks for the offer, though.
You're not just tired. You're frightened.
Well, I, I...
You're desperate. I can see it in your face.
No, no, I...
You're haunted.
Did it have to be this woman who...
I'm running down the road fast as I can, breathing hard. Trying to call out to her. Once I see her car, it stops by the time I see her get out. Dressed in yellow. Looking as I get near her.
Changed your mind?
It's all right. Get in.
Come on, shove over.
Yeah.
I knew you'd reconsider.
Oh, how did you know?
The way one does sometimes.
Only you don't know me.
You feel like telling me your name? Mine's Sylvia.
That's not conversation for now.
It's hard for you, isn't it?
Well, you're the first person, right?
You don't seem to me to be a drinking man.
Well, he's the only bartender I've ever talked to.
I won't ask you any more questions. Instead, I'll tell you all about myself, all right?
Yeah, all right.
Uh, my name is Sylvia. I'm 38. And I have a daughter named Susan. She's 18. We live in the Free Life Commune, not far from here. We moved in there when my husband left me 10 years ago. I write poetry when it occurs to me to do so.
Otherwise?
I begin to drink in the words as though my soul... I can hardly believe it. I don't want to believe it. We're coming back to life.
Well, this is it. This is where I live. Up the hill there. That's where the Free Life Commune is.
Oh, well, I'll get out.
Oh, no, no, no. Don't do that. Come with me. See what it's like.
Well, there'll be a lot of people.
Oh, you won't have to meet them. My daughter and I have a cabin. We can have something to eat. We don't have to go to the communal hall. Susan won't expect you to talk if you don't feel like it. Lots of times she doesn't feel like it either. Lots of times I don't.
Really?
We're all looking for the free life. That's why it's called the Free Life Commune.
...rendered. And nothing in me resists as she turns the car into the side road and goes up the hill and turns again down another dirt road then another and then another. Not to an expert. Honey, there's nothing and neither do I as we go.
Hungry?
Uh, no. I, um, I know you're not a drinking man, but I think a glass of wine might be a good thing.
Yeah, it might. And I want you to meet my daughter. We'll all have a glass of wine together.
Can I help?
No, you just sit there. A white wine or red?
Uh, I don't know. Red.
There we are. You wanted me, Mother?
Yes, dear. I, um, I want you to meet somebody. This is Paul. Paul, this is Susan.
Hello, Paul.
Hello, Susan.
What are you having at a thing in this house to munch on? Paul's not used to drinking, and if he doesn't get something into his stomach, he...
Oh, you want me to run down to the commissary?
Oh, no, no. You stay here. I'll go. I want to get something for dinner anyway. We're eating in the cabin. Just the three of us. Be right back.
Um, you want to pour the wine?
No, you do it.
Okay.
You're very pretty.
Thank you. You're 18, your mother said.
Uh-huh.
Here's your wine. It's, uh, cheap, but good.
What is it I don't... It's in... You're not drinking your wine. What are you thinking?
Uh, how did you get here?
I live here.
No, no, no, no. I, I... I mean just now. I mean when you showed up just now. How did you get here?
Well, through the woods. There's a path.
No, no, no. How did you happen to walk in at just that minute when you did?
My mother called me.
No, no, no. She didn't. She didn't. I was here. She didn't call you.
No, she just said she wanted me to meet you. And the next thing I knew, you walked in.
She didn't call you at all.
Oh, you mean...
She didn't say, Susan, come here? She didn't say anything. I know I was here. Mother never calls me that way.
Well, there's no other way.
What other way is there?
She thinks it, and I receive it.
Are you, are you talking about telepathic communication? I've heard of that, but...
If you have to give things names, I, I, I guess that's what it is.
Come on, drink your wine. Mother's on her way back.
Have you ever felt that your telephone was going to ring a split second before it actually rang? Well, it's happened to me and to some others I know. Was this because you ardently wished that it would ring? Or was it because some faint electrical impulse in the wires reached you? Or was it because the caller was thinking intently about you as he finished dialing your number? Frankly, I don't know. Perhaps it was for none of these reasons.
I'll return to you shortly with Act Two.
Our protagonist's name is Paul. Prayed upon by a grief too deep for comprehension. Obsessed with the feeling that he is only pretending to be alive, he has decided to follow the advice of a chance-met bartender and hike to... On his way there, he has accepted a ride from a woman called Sylvia, who lives with her daughter Susan in the Free Life Commune. Paul has passively consented to accompany Sylvia to her cabin. A few minutes later, young Susan, at her appearance...
How did you get here just when you did?
Mother called me.
No, she didn't. I was here. She didn't call you at all.
You mean she didn't say, Susan, come here?
She never calls me that way.
She thinks it, and I receive it.
Come on, Paul. Drink up. It's not very strong wine.
Cheers.
Yeah, yeah, cheers.
You know your mother, son-in-law. She is.
Well, she'll be here in less than a minute.
Well, did she... Did she send you some kind of message? Uh, telepathically, I mean?
She must have. Otherwise, how would I know?
Yeah, well... Well, I suppose she doesn't come back in less than a minute. But she will.
She's here now.
No, she's not. She...
All I could get for dinner was chipped beef.
All right.
Oh, fine.
Paul?
Uh, what?
You like chipped beef, don't you?
And we have some apples and cheese, I think.
Uh, anything, yes.
Huh. Is this my wine?
Oh, I'll pour you some, Mother.
That's Paul.
Uh, Sylvia.
Yes, Paul.
When you were at the commissary, Susan and I were talking. I couldn't understand why she came back. You hadn't called her.
Called her?
Not really called her, out loud.
Oh, that. Yeah, and she said there was some kind of telepathy between you. Telepathic communication.
Susan said that?
I didn't say that. He said that.
Oh, yes, yes, that's true. But there has to be some kind of explanation, doesn't there? And, uh, later on, she said you were on your way back from the commissary. You'd be here in less than a minute. And in less than a minute, you walked in.
What of it?
Well, you, uh... You send... You send mental messages to each other, is that it?
But I guess... Yeah, well, how... How was that done?
I don't... Well, you must know. You must know.
Why must I know?
Well, because... Haven't you thought about it? Don't you wonder about it?
Look, Paul, when Susan's father up and left us, I had to go to work. Susan wasn't able to look after herself, and I couldn't afford someone to look after her, so I... I had to do it myself. I couldn't take her to the office with me or the bookstore or the library, wherever I happened to be working. So I had to look after her, and I felt another way. And that's how it came about. Whenever I felt she was doing wrong or was in some kind of danger, I... I sent her a message.
And you told her what to do?
Mostly what not to do.
And she always knew? I mean, she always got your message?
No, not at first. But when I got home at night, I had to scold her or punish her in some way, and pretty soon, it started to work, and it's worked ever since.
Hey, let's have some more wine. What do you say? And let's open up a jar of olives. The good Spanish. Okay?
Life appears patched, so dim, us coming through clearly. It's like a gradually developing picture in a dark room. I feel my body. I hear my voice. I want to say things, and I don't care if I say them badly. I go back. I repeat myself. I don't mind. They don't mind.
Well, in all, you wrote it.
Yes, yes, but... Well, that's more than most people do.
Yes, I know. Was it... Was it hard?
Yeah, sometimes.
Was it fun?
Sometimes, yes, sometimes.
Well, then... And it was published. It even sold a few copies.
That's nice.
I'm starting to remember all the moods living up in my life. I've lived through olives that haven't... Just the age Helen was when I married her. They look nothing alike, but... I don't know what it is. Youth, maybe. But more than that, much more than that, the feeling...
Sylvia, do you mind if Susan and I take a walk someplace, Susan? Do you mind?
I don't mind.
And leave me to do the dishes?
I cook the dinner.
Big deal.
What, just a short walk?
I should think you've had enough walking by now.
I could show Father Wood. You know, it's... so long. So long since I've taken a walk with somebody. Maybe you'd like to come, too.
Uh... no. No, you two run along.
Like I'm sixteen and out on my first date. I swing out freely instead of...
Want to sit down for a minute? Do you?
Yes.
There's a rabid woodchuck in these woods somewhere.
Rabid?
Crazy. Berserk. Freaked out completely.
You don't say.
You're not afraid?
Well, I don't know. I never knew till this second that woodchucks went mad. You know, it's interesting. It's really... it's so long since I have been interested in anything. Here I am fascinated by the idea.
You could write a story about it.
I might. I might just do it.
You don't know anything about me.
Well, I know that your father went off and left you.
Yes, that happened. And you and your mother developed this communication so that she could take care of you.
Oh, we've always had that.
You mean even before your father... before he split?
Oh, yes. As far back as I can remember.
Did it make you very unhappy when he split?
I guess it did. It was ten years ago. I don't really remember too well. All I remember is I'd like to talk about it. No, please, please. You know, I've been talking my head off all evening. You and your mother listened to me and now...
What is it?
What I remember is how sad he looked.
What was he sad about?
I don't know.
Was he unhappy with your mother?
I don't know. It was ten years ago. I don't remember. They got along. I guess they were happy. Sometimes I... sometimes I think that he... that he was unhappy with me.
Oh, no, no. He couldn't have been unhappy with you. Why, you must have been the sweetest little daughter a man could want. No, that couldn't have been it.
Oh, it's just a feeling. Maybe he wanted me to be a boy.
No, I don't think so.
You don't?
No. Men talk a lot about wanting... oh, you know what I mean.
Of course I know what you mean. You're a very remarkable girl, Susan.
No, I'm not.
Yes, you've seemed that way to me right this... oh, wait till morning. I'll seem absolutely ordinary, which I am. And that reminds me, are you going to stay all night?
Well, I don't know. Is there a motel or something near here?
Oh, you could sleep in the cabin. We could put a sleeping bag down on the living room floor. Could you do that?
Of course. Why not?
Well, it's getting dark. Maybe we'd better be getting back, huh?
I guess so. Here, give me a hand. I'll pull you up. Okay. There.
Yes, Paul? You do? No, no. We have to go back. Let me go. We have to get back to the cabin. Come on, hurry up.
Susan, Susan, what is it? Hurry.
What is it? What did I do?
Susan? Hurry, hurry.
Relief from deep depression is greater than relief from the grimmest physical pain and a thousand times harder to achieve. Indeed, it cannot be achieved at all if by achievement we mean conscious effort, contrived artifice. It comes, or seems to come, or seems to by chance, by a miracle, as though from heaven. I shall return shortly with Act Three. Our leading character in the course of an aimless pilgrimage to Mexico has been befriended by two women, mother and daughter. In the course of a few hours, he has told them a good portion of his life history and his peace of mind is being restored. Resting and talking in the pine woods to the daughter, eighteen-year-old Susan, he has attempted to kiss her with a startling consequence.
I need to kiss her. Let me go. We have to go back.
Susan, what is it? Oh, hurry.
What is it? What did I do? Hurry.
I get back to the cabin. I had no sinister intent. I wanted to kiss her with an impulse of pure gratitude and affection because she was young and uncomplicated, untangling the snarled threads of my life for me.
It's morning. Time to get up.
We, um, we get up early here.
Yeah, that's fine with me. Did you sleep well?
Yeah, like a puppy.
Where's Susan?
I sent her into town to the market.
Oh? When will she be back?
I don't know exactly.
Well, something happened. We were talking and it was so peaceful there and she was so sweet to me. I told her about both at dinner. She seemed to understand everything I said and a lot of things I didn't say.
Susan's a very sweet girl.
Yeah, well, all of a sudden I wanted to kiss her. Nothing, you know, nothing was serious. I wasn't trying to seduce her. I wouldn't try anything like that. I wanted to kiss her because I felt so, so, and it's been so long since I felt anything like that. At first I thought she understood. She let me put my arm around her and she was looking at me and all of a sudden...
All of a sudden what?
Well, she broke away from me. She said, we have to go back, and she ran for the cabin. Why would she do that?
Well, you must have some idea. She's your daughter. After all, Paul, you're old enough to be her father, aren't you?
Well, I guess I am, yeah. Even so.
Now, some people think everybody that lives in the commune is, you know, loose, free and easy. That's not so. This is a group of people who are serious. They're serious artists who are dedicated.
Well, I never even thought of anything like that. I never thought Susan was... I just never wanted anything like that. She knew I didn't. I'm sure she did.
Well, maybe she did and maybe she didn't. You never know with young girls, do you?
How far is it?
I don't know. Quite a ways.
Yeah, well, maybe I'll walk into town and try to find her.
Well, you couldn't do that. You had a lot of errands. You wouldn't know where to look.
Well, anyway, I think I'll try.
Paul.
Now, what'd she do? Did she walk to town?
She must have come back.
So soon?
Well, evidently, since the car's out front. I'm gonna look for her.
You don't know where she is.
Well, I'll look. Maybe the communal hall.
That's full of people. They'll all be having breakfast there.
Well, if she's not there, maybe she's in the woods.
Paul.
Simply waiting in the cabin. I said you'd gone into town, but the car was parked outside, so I knew you must be back.
Oh, I just went down the road to get some gasoline.
Well, I looked all over for you. I even went up to the hall where everybody was having breakfast.
Oh, did they give you something to eat?
No, no, nothing. You must be hungry.
No, I don't care about that. I want to talk to you about last night.
What about it?
Well, when I, uh, when I wanted to kiss you, uh, Susan, I didn't mean anything, anything except that you've done so much for me, you don't even know what you've done for me, you and your mother. I was a desperate man, and you brought me back to life. You made it possible for me to go on living. I don't know how or why, or maybe I'll never know.
Behind you! Run! Run!
Susan!
She's out of my arms, running like a wild thing through the woods. I had to say, or do, I open the door of the cabin and go inside.
Back so soon?
Young. Where did you go?
Oh, just here and there.
Did you find Susan?
Oh, yes.
Everything all right?
I don't know. She's very young, Paul. She's eighteen. That's young.
Yeah, you're probably right. I don't know, maybe she misunderstood me.
Probably.
Yeah, but you, uh...
In what way?
In, uh... what are you talking about?
You don't mean that.
Oh, yes, I'm thinking about it.
I am not.
Of course you are. How long ago did your husband leave you? Ten years? You've lived ten years with a growing child and no man. Why wouldn't you be thinking about it?
I don't like this conversation. Let's change the subject.
No, no, no, I won't. You know, you've done a wonderful thing for me, Sylvia, letting me stay here, letting me... I've carried such a weight on my heart for so long and now it's been lifted. You're carrying a burden, too, and I want to lift that if I can.
I don't know what you're talking about.
I'm going to come over the way a man kisses a woman.
Back to you every time a man...
Yes.
It's the day she was born. I can't...
Of course you can't. What would I do without my child? What else is there?
Oh, you'll think of something. A woman like...
Without saying goodbye to me?
Well, I, uh... I...
I'm sorry I acted the way I did in the woods.
You didn't really...
I thought I did.
No, there wasn't any... Maybe there never has been.
Well, anyway, I'm sorry. And I'm sorry you're leaving.
Well, it's time.
Oh.
Mm-hmm.
Do you know what I'd like? I'd like to kiss you goodbye. Come closer to the car. Stand right there. Like that. I want to put my arms around you and hug you and give you a big kiss. I love you a lot.
No.
That the only person I really want to see is the man who sent me off on my never-reach-Mexico-to-find-the-little-side-street-without-any-trouble-wiping-the-boredom-off-me-by-any-chance?
I don't know.
Well, you look familiar.
Yeah, well, I was in here about a week ago. You told me to go to Mexico.
Oh, yeah. Yeah. Well, did you go?
Uh, partway.
Well, how was it?
Oh.
It's a good thing you came in today because I'm closing up. This place is bad. Business is all right.
No, I just made up my mind to do something crazy, but I'm going to do it anyway.
Well, do what? Do you mind telling me?
I'm going to set out and look for my family. You see, I left them ten years ago. Just cut out. No explanation. No nothing.
Well, you must have had a reason.
I did. But it wasn't anything I could talk about. You see, my wife, she made me feel like, like an outsider, like I wasn't necessary. Not even important. Like I was, uh, in a way, really. We have a daughter, Susan. Closer than any two people ever were. And I was just, uh, hanging around. You know what I mean? It's hard to understand if you haven't been through it.
You know, what made you decide to go looking for her?
I don't know. The feeling I got all of a sudden. That, uh, things might be different. Because I love Susan and I love Sylvia, too. That's my wife.
You know, where are you going to look?
Lord knows. Maybe I'll head for Mexico the way you did.
If you do, there's, there's a place between here and there. It's called the Free Life Community. And, uh, it's a good place to stop.
But today, to change one's self is everything. To change one's address, clothes, occupation, or friends. All these things are easy next to changing one's inner self with all its complexities and contradictions. That is the difficult thing. There is always the chance that, difficult as it is, this has been a story about mind control. Not that I know how one mind controls another or even influences it. But no one can deny that all of us, all our impulses as well as our inhibitions, all our aggressions, as our retreat, all our resistances, our surrenders, all take form depending on the waves of thought from people we have loved and who have loved us. No man is an island. Our cast included Larry Haines, Joan Lovejoy, Rosemary Rice, and Dan Ocko. The entire production was under the direction of Hyman Brown. This is E.G. Marshall inviting you to return to our mystery theater for another adventure in the macabre. Until next time, pleasant dreams.
