Skip to content
On Air
All channelsAll
CBS Radio Mystery Theater artwork

From the CBS Radio Mystery Theater collection

Bury Me Again

Episode 169November 4, 197452 min 52 secTranscript

Writer: Himan Brown

The written record

Read the transcript

Read along with the recording · About 35 min to read

Your news and sports radio network. And now WBEN Buffalo, broadcasting at 930 kilohertz, begins another day of service to the Niagara frontier. Our studio-to-transmitter link, WEF90, operates at 949 megahertz.

Tonight's mystery theater is brought to you by AM&A's, at downtown, and six suburban stores, including the new Lockport store. The CBS Radio Mystery Theater presents...

Come in. Welcome. I'm E.G. Marshall. Won't you join me? It's dark and cozy inside here. A perfect place to curl up and listen to another tale of suspense and danger. This time, it's the story of a very unusual get-rich-quickness. But even though our story is educational and instructive, we don't want you to listen in the hopes of duplicating our hero's plan for instant wealth. You may find it difficult to begin where he begins, by dying a violent death. Because, after that, what do you do for an encore?

I am getting away with it. No. They'll never catch on. And before I'm through, I'll be the richest dead man in the world.

Our mystery drama, Bury Me Again, was written especially for the Mystery Theater by Henry Slessor, and stars Michael Tolan. It is sponsored in part by Buick Motor Division and Contact, the 12-hour cold capsule. I'll be back shortly with Act One.

You've seen the Budweiser commercials on television, and maybe you've wondered how long people have been putting that famous Bud label on things. Well, not as long as the brewers of Bud have been putting things on the label. Things like a list of Bud's most important ingredients. Quote, brewed by our original process from the choicest hops, rice, and best barley malt. And things like the following statement. This is the famous Budweiser beer. We know of no brand produced by any other brewer which costs so much to brew and age. Our exclusive Beechwood Aging produces a taste, a smoothness, and a drinkability you'll find in Budweiser. And you'll find in no other beer at any price. Unquote. Yes, brewing beer right does make a difference. Read the Bud label, taste the king of beers, and you'll agree, when you say Budweiser, you've said it all. Anheuser-Busch, St. Louis.

Gracious, elegant, luxurious sterling silver for radiant holiday tables. Join AM&A's fantastic Silver Club plan for stupendous savings of 25% to 50% on flatware from the finest silversmiths. No down payment, no finance charge, and up to 25 months to pay. 24-piece sets from Gorham. Services for 4, 8, or 12 by International. Lunt three-piece place flooding. Heirloom sterling patterns by Oneida Silversmiths. 16-piece starter sets from Reed and Barton. Trade in your present silver for savings on all patterns by Towle. Choose Wallace Sterling, 24-piece service for 8, and get a chest free. And save on all open stock pieces from these famous companies. For gift giving, or for your own. The elegance of sterling silver at low, low prices. Join AM&A's Silver Club plan now. No down payment, no finance charge, and up to 25 months to pay. At all seven AM&A stores.

Some people think that the sound of a train whistle, fading into the distance, is probably the most melancholy sound in the world. But the people aboard those trains, which crisscross the country, can be melancholy too. As the cracked Chicago Express streaks into the dark stretch of track between Union Station and the town of Fairmont, one of those passengers is staring gloomily into his own reflection in the suit's darkened window. It may be interesting to follow his thoughts.

Minus $10,000. $10,000. Minus $10,000. That's where I'm at after 36 years of living. 36 years of working, and sweating, and dreaming dreams that never had a prayer of coming through. I owed McGinnis the same six grand I'd owed him for two years, even after making him payments amounting to twice that much. Then there were the bills, the dentist, the credit card company, the automobile dealer. No. No, I could scratch that one. The car had been repossessed just the other day. That's why I was taking the train instead of driving to Fairmont. Not that I expected it to do much good. The chances of hitting my maiden Aunt Hilda for money were pretty slim. But when you're down, you'll try anything. And with the thought of McGinnis and his goons coming around for payday again, I was ready for anything at all. But maybe not ready for what happened.

Pardon me. Is this seat taken?

Huh? Oh, no. No, no. It's all right. Sit down.

Oh, thanks. You know, I haven't been in a dining car in years. I didn't know they still have them.

Heck, some people don't know there are still trains running.

I guess that's so. Everybody thinks in terms of flying these days.

I don't like to fly myself. Heck, for most trips, you don't save any time anyway. About time you'd get to and from the airport.

Yeah. I suppose so.

You do a lot of traveling?

Not if I can avoid it.

Well, I can. Nah, I can't, unfortunately. I'm one of those traveling salesmen you hear about. But you know something? I never met a farmer's daughter in my life. How do you get a drink here? I've been wondering that for the last 15 minutes.

Well, it looks like you've got a drink.

Oh, sure. That's my own private stock. I always carry a pint bottle with me on these long train trips just to break the monotony.

Yeah. Come on. Give me your water glass.

Yeah, that's very kind of you.

My pleasure.

No, thanks.

Well, here's looking at you.

Right. And here's to the farmer's daughter. Maybe you'll meet her this trip.

Just hope my wife doesn't find out.

He wasn't the most scintillating conversationalist in the world, but he was company, and I guess I needed that. I also didn't mind the private stock he carried. Every drink aboard that train cost a buck and a half. So when he told me that he had still another bottle, I suggested we continue our talk in the club car. The only thing wrong was that he did all the talking, and the more he drank, the more he talked.

Money, my friend. M-O-N-E-Y. That's the answer to the whole darn thing. You take my word for it.

Tell me it gives you that happiness baloney. You just walk away, pal. Walk away.

You don't have to convince me, brother. I've already been convinced.

Listen, listen. You ever figure it out? I mean, figure out one of those things like accident and life.

Liability? That's all I've got, liability. You know what I mean. Like how much you're worth. How much you're really worth.

Well, I can tell you. You, me, everybody else, we're worth more dead than alive. Am I right? Am I right?

Yeah, you're right. You betcha.

That's what insurance is all about. You betcha. That's what I mean. That's what insurance is all about.

You're not an insurance salesman, are you?

Oh, not me. No, I'm not a liquor salesman either.

Too bad about that. Hey, bottle's almost empty.

Don't worry, friend. Don't you worry. There's more where that came from.

More whiskey, plenty more talk. Till something happened that sobered up the evening fast.

How long I was untouched. Judging from the things that were happening around me, it seemed to be more than a few minutes after the crash. After the express had plowed into the freight train and somehow been switched into a fast. I felt lousy, but I was still in one piece. When the intercom rang, the impact came, I fell against another sofa and it toppled over me. When the hard stuff came down, I had a built-in bomb shelter. Nobody else around me was so lucky. I saw the traveling salesman and I knew he was never going to meet that farmer's daughter. Then, I saw something else. The money that peeked out of his wallet, still nice and green. I had the sense to grab the wallet before I crawled out of the overturned car. I stood up as soon as I felt cold air on my face. Within seconds, after I left the wreck, the tiny fire that had been burning all around got together in one giant ball of flame. Such a hungry fire in my life. I knew there wasn't going to be much less than anything or anyone.

And then I saw the people. They were all over the place, dozens of them, flashing searchlights, shouting to each other.

Hey!

Yeah? What is it?

Are you okay?

Yes, I'm all right. I just a little shook up.

Well, they're putting up a first aid station down this line. Want me to help you over there?

No, no. I'm all right, thanks.

No, I'd better take you there.

Oh, well, okay. Thanks. Hey, listen. What town is this?

We're just outside of Hopkins Falls. We heard the crash all the way to town. Sounded like a bomb went off.

We're at a first aid station, and a guy in a dirty white uniform helped me inside.

What's your name?

I, uh... I can't think. I'm all mixed up.

Yes, well, maybe you'd better lie down for a while, mister.

No, no, no. I'm okay.

We're setting up a hospital station. We'll have a car take you there if you like. It'll be a while before the ambulance gets here.

No, I'm not hurt. I'm just... I'm just mixed up. Is it far to town?

You're really in no condition to walk.

Just tell me how far it is.

Well, about a quarter of a mile in that direction.

That's all I want to know.

Well, Hopkins Falls wasn't much of a town. There were a bunch of frame houses leaning on each other for support. And the only electric sign in the place was the one I wanted. It said hotel. It took me quite a while to find the desk clerk lurking behind the rubber plants in the lobby. He looked at me curiously and spun the register in my direction. I chuckled when I saw the empty page. When I asked for a room with bath, he almost swallowed his store teeth. I signed the register Benedict Arnold and went up to the shabby room on the second floor. When I closed the door behind me, all I could do was head for that bed. The springs gave in with a rusty sigh. But I couldn't care less. Sleep hit me like a TKO.

I woke up the next morning with a pain in my hip. At first I thought I'd broken a bone. But then I realized it was only the bulge of a wallet in my trouser pocket. I counted the money. A hundred and ten bucks. It would be enough for a little while. Then I picked up the phone.

Uh, hello, this is Mr. Arnold, room 202. You got any room service in this place?

Yeah, breakfast.

Yeah, that's exactly what I want. Fried eggs, bacon, toast, coffee. Oh, um, how about the morning paper? The paper in yet? Any, uh, news about the wreck? Fine, good. Be sure to send that up, too.

The breakfast was no better than I expected. The toast was soggy, the coffee watery, and the eggs almost inedible. But the local paper, that was something else. The train wreck had taken over the whole rag, all four sheets of it. It was probably the biggest news that ever hit this whistle stop. I turned to the casualty list. It wasn't complete, but it had what I wanted. So I grabbed the phone.

Um, I want to make a call, long distance. Hello, operator? I'd like to place a call to Chicago, person to person. Mrs. Gerald Horton, 1240 Lafayette Street. I'm in room 202. The name is Ger... No, I mean, uh, Arnold. First initial B.

Is that you, Myrna? Is anybody with you? It's Jerry. A town called Hopkins Corner or something like that. Listen, are you alone?

Well, yes, of course we are. Because this hotel has walls like tissue paper, that's why. Myrna, did you read about the wreck? The train, the Chicago train. It hit something, a stalled freight train. Dozens of people were killed.

Okay. Quiet. Yes, I'm okay. I got a little banged up. Nothing serious. Oh, hospital. I don't need a hospital. I told you, I'm not hurt. I'm just... dead. You heard me. I'm dead, honey. Myrna, listen carefully. There's been a mistake out here. A big mistake. And we're going to make the most of it, understand?

How?

Well, listen, and you will. They got me down on the local casualty list. They think I'm dead. Do you get what I'm saying? They've listed me as dead.

Well, I must have helped it along a little.

I switched wallets with a guy. His was fatter than mine, but he had no use for it anyway. But then the whole train caught fire. He must have been burned beyond recognition. But the wallet was okay. No, I don't have to tell him a thing. Why should I? What for? Myrna, listen. What's the only valuable thing we own? You know about the insurance policy? Yes. $75,000. $75,000. More money than we could save in a lifetime. But we can't collect it. You're alive. I'm going to stay dead, Myrna. Understand? Jerry. You're going into mourning for me. Then you're going to get a check for $75,000 from the insurance company. You're going to slap that money into the bank. Then we're going to wait a while and leave town. You and me and the money makes three. Now do you get it? Legal. What do you mean illegal? We're only ripping off an insurance company, honey. That's what I call fair game.

Well, we've just heard an old adage disproved. That dead men tell no tales. Obviously, here is one dead man who is doing exactly that. A tale of deceit and deception. And very possibly, danger. We'll find out how good a job our friend does of staying dead when I return shortly with Act Two.

If you take a look at the new 1975 cars, it doesn't take long to notice the European influence is strong. And to be sure, there are some new American cars that rival the Europeans. One being Buick's new Skylark SR. But don't consider a Skylark SR because of its touring car interior or its rather rakish profile. Consider it because it's a Buick. Possessing many of Buick's nicer innovations. Like the new Buick V6. A peppery little engine that spits out a plentiful amount of torque while sipping a surprisingly small amount of gasoline. And if you wish, Skylark SR can abound with creature comforts seldom found on cars this size. With available items like cruise master speed control, AM FM stereo. But you've heard enough. Now you need to see and drive a Skylark SR. And try to remember. It's not a European touring car. It's a Buick. Buick. Dedicated to the free spirit in just about everyone.

I was walking home. It was almost dark. And then I saw someone. A woman struggling to change a tire. I stopped. She stiffened. I think she was afraid of me. And then a strange happened. We talked. There by the roadside changing a tire. She told me how scared she was. She wanted help. But was afraid of the kind of help she might get. I told her I had fears like that too. And I think she understood. And then she drove away. And I didn't even get her name. But I listened to her talk. And she listened to me too. And you know, that made me feel good. A word for active listening from the Mennonite churches.

Gary Horton didn't get to see much of the town of Hopkins Falls. He spent the next few days in his room. Thinking. Drinking. And making plans. It was a pity. The quiet, rustic atmosphere and the countryside might have soothed the savage temperament of the man. But Jerry Horton was far too excited by an image of the future. However, since this is Jerry's story, we'll let him tell you the rest.

The 110 bucks lasted me five days. It bought me a new suit of clothes at the local emporium. My room and meals. And a bus ticket back to Chicago. I bought myself a cardboard valise too. I figured a traveling man with a suitcase was less obvious than a crowd. On Friday morning, I put the local phone book, the Gideon Bible, and a couple of hotel towels into the valise. And said goodbye.

A long bus ride. But it seemed short to me. I had all kinds of things to think about. Plans for spending that money. Thinking about McGinnis' face when I finally handed him the six thousand I owed him. All in one neat bundle. Hey, that was an idea. I put it all in one dollar bills and make him stay up half the night counting it. And if I know McGinnis, that's exactly what he would do.

And then I was back in Chicago. Ready to call good old Myrna. Good old Myrna.

Myrna? For God's sake, don't say my name. Are you alone? At the bus terminal. What for? What's been happening? Great. Was it a nice crowd? You didn't tell her anything? Never mind that stuff. We've got more important things to worry about. Living things. I don't know yet. I'm broke. I don't even have enough money for a hotel room. I know I can't come there, but I've got to eat. So you've got to help me. Look. You put about $300 in an envelope and address it to John Nolan, care of the Montgomery Hotel. Did you get that name? Don't write it down. You can remember it. Yeah, John Nolan, care of the Montgomery. I'll check in there this morning. Don't try to reach me. That's just asking for trouble. You got it? Don't worry about it. You know the Montgomery's out of our class. But try and make it small bills, okay? No use attracting more attention than I have to. Okay? You'll see how right it is when that money comes in, Myrna.

I spent that night in the bus terminal. I hunted out the softest bench and stashed my things under it. When I woke up, I had 19 bones out of place. But I was still feeling chipper. I went into the terminal lavatory and washed up as best I could. It was a fine, sunny day out. And the weather suited my mood. You know how it is. Some days, everything goes right.

I walked a dozen blocks to the Montgomery Hotel. It was out of my class, all right. Was, that is. A chunk of white sandstone rising 40 stories from the street in straight, clean lines. Ringed by a fence of evenly spaced trees. The doorman looked like he'd won every decoration from the Congressional Medal on down. It felt good walking on the wine-colored carpet that led into the plush lobby. Knowing there was money and a hot shower waiting for me inside. I walked up to the desk like a bored millionaire and scratched my unshaven cheek in a kind of wry manner like I was a playboy who was out on the town all night.

Yes, sir. May I help you?

I'd like a room, please.

Did you have a reservation?

No, I don't. But can you fix me up with something anyway?

Yes, sir. I'm sure we can. If you'll just sign the register. I believe you may be holding some mail for me. I told some friends I'd be stopping here.

What name, sir?

Uh, Nolan. John Nolan.

Well, let me check. No. No, I don't see anything for... Oh, wait a minute. Here it is.

Oh, uh, thank you very much. Front.

My room at the Montgomery wasn't fancy. Just a nice room with not much of a view. But I liked it better after a shower and shave. And when I flopped on the big sofa bed, I opened the envelope, lit a cigarette, and counted the money. There were 240 bucks in it, and a note that said, sorry, all I could get, M. Well, it didn't really matter. It would be enough to take care of me for a few days. Then the insurance agent would be around to see Myrna. And money like this would be only car fare. I felt so good that I decided to spend some of it on the best meal I could buy in the hotel restaurant.

I was just finishing up when my luck threatened to turn.

Well, for Pete's sake. This is Lefty. Is this Lefty? You're in high school, right?

Uh, I'm sorry. I think you must have the wrong guy.

Hey, did I change that much? Yeah, I guess maybe I have. I don't know where all the hair went. Down the sink, I guess. Douglas is the name, remember? Kenny Douglas.

No, I'm afraid I, uh, I'm afraid I don't.

Oh, well, I can't be that wrong. I've got a good memory for faces. Not so great on names, maybe. But they, uh, called you Lefty because of the baseball team.

I'm sorry, mister. I must look like this friend of yours. But I'm not him. I never went to Union High. I never went to any high school, as a matter of fact.

Well, I could have sworn. And as you can see, I'm eating with my right hand.

Yeah. That's right. How about you, George?

I'm eating with my left hand.

Yeah, but you sure look like the guy. Or the way he would look 20 years later.

I'm, uh, I'm sorry to have bothered you.

By the time the guy had left my table, I was covered in sweat from head to foot. Oh, I remember Kenny Douglas all right. I think I still had his monogrammed cigarette case in his shoebox at home. He was a snotty rich kid. It had been a pleasure to rip him off. But right now, it was a relief to see him leave. And a relief to switch the fork back to my left hand.

After the third day, I started getting anxious.

It's Jerry. Can you talk? Just be careful what you say. Just answer yes or no, understand? I hear you. Now just be quiet and listen. Has the insurance company contacted you at all? A man? Why are they sending somebody from the claim department? There's nothing to claim. I'm dead. Well, it might take a while before the payment was made. I don't care if he was tall, dark, and handsome. What's this baloney about it taking a while? Well, it's an awful lot of money. What are you talking about? Our policy was for 75 grand. It's a double indemnity clause, you see? I mean... 150? My God, that's a fortune. We're rich. We're really rich. Thing is, to make sure. Sure of what? He was so burned in that terrible... For Pete's sake, I was identified. I read my name in the paper on the casualty list. It better be all right. I'm running out of cash. I won't be able to afford the hotel bill. Do you need more money? All right. All right, then. But when you get that check in your hands, you better get on that phone right away, understand? Yes, I... John Nolan, Montgomery Hotel. Don't do anything with the money. Just wait for my instructions. I'll wait.

$50,000. I couldn't believe it. I couldn't imagine money like that. I kept seeing the way that check would look, that long string of numbers. I began to see visions of things I'd wanted since the day I was born. It was all I could do to keep myself from running down to the auto showroom and placing an order for the biggest, shiniest car in the window. I had to wait. The money wasn't there yet. There was still one more step to go. I was a little worried about Myrna's visitor from the insurance company. But I knew that things would work out all right. This was my lucky time of life and nothing was going to spoil it.

Then, just one day later...

Oh, Mr. Nolan.

Ah, yes?

There was a call for you while you were out this afternoon. It was a lady, Mrs. Nolan, I think.

Uh-huh. Thanks very much.

My hands were shaking so bad that I could hardly dial Myrna's number. When she didn't answer right away, I started to panic. She wouldn't be calling me unless it was all set. She must have the money in her hand. And I had to make sure that it went to the right place. It wasn't that I suspected Myrna of any hanky-panky. I had no reason to suspect her of anything. But who knows what someone will do when they're looking at a piece of paper that says 150,000.

Myrna, it's me. Oh, thank heavens.

I was getting so worried. Where were you? The phone must have rung ten times.

Well, I...

You went there to get the money?

They ate it.

Well, don't worry about it. You're the grieving widow. You're supposed to be upset.

They can't do that. It's against the law. Don't do it. Don't sign a thing. They can't force you to do such a thing. They're bluffing. They can't do anything like that. They've already identified that body as me and once is good enough. No, don't get a lawyer yet. Let me think. Let me figure out something and call you back. There's gotta be something I can figure out.

As Robert Burns once told us, the best laid plans of mice and men ought go astray. Even the plans of dead men, it seems. But I think we have a resourceful gentleman here who won't let a mere detail stand between him and his dream. Will the insurance investigators create a rude awakening? Or will our hero find some way to put the number 150,000 into his little green book? Just wait right there and I'll return with the answers shortly in Act 3.

Give your hand to a friend Give your heart to your love But give your cold to Contac The sooner the better

The common cold is a rotten thing. You miss so much. Sneezing, drips and congestion can drag you down. Then, ask yourself the Contac question. 6 or 3 or 1? You'd need 6 cold tablets, 2 every 4 hours, or 3 hours a day. Or 3 ounces of colds liquid, 1 every 4 hours, or just 1 Contac for up to 12 hours continuous relief of those symptoms. That's daytime, then nighttime relief. Both the others are things for aches and fever and the liquid, something for coughs. Not found in Contac. 600 tiny times, Bill. Give your cold to Contac. 6 or 3 or 1. Take Contac, only as directed.

Who knows what troubles lurk in the hearts and minds of consumers? From the Better Business Bureau. Irene, this new sofa is gone already and, and... Why, why what's that inside the creaking yarn? It's my hair in this crumpled newspaper. How did we ever buy a sofa like this? Can we do?

I'll tell you what to do.

Who are you, sir?

I'm the man from your Better Business Bureau. When you shop for furniture, it's what's inside that counts. Fancy coverings can hide a variety of shoddy workmanship. Read the law label that must be stitched to the furniture. It will tell you the filler material used and buy from a reputable dealer.

Oh, thank you, sir. We'll know better next time.

Not at all, ma'am. Just another tip from your Better Business Bureau.

It's a time of tension for the man in the Montgomery Hotel. Now every hour seems to stretch ahead interminably. The watch ticking on his wrist seems to have hands made of lead. But as he paces his hotel room, smoking endless cigarettes, downing pots of lukewarm hotel coffee, he seems to have arrived at no solution to his dilemma.

I told you not to call me direct. I said always leave a message with the desk clerk. I... All right. What's happening?

They got the order, Jerry.

Lord! There was no... Listen, you... You don't think they suspect anything. Those insurance guys are sharp, you know. I'm not just as if you really got killed. Everybody... All right, all right. Now just... just calm down. Maybe things aren't that bad. You didn't see what I saw after that train wreck. After the explosion. They have pictures in the local papers. The victims didn't look human anymore, I'm telling you. They were just like pieces of charcoal. Even if they open that coffin, they won't see anything but a handful of ashes. So stop worrying.

Jerry... I'm sure. At least I think I'm sure. I don't... Okay, so we lose the bread. The wrong man got identified. It wasn't anybody's fault, right? And as for me, I guess I'll... Well, I'll be just another runaway husband.

Jim... No, no, don't worry. You'll be seeing me again. Broke as usual. Unless our luck holds. Pray that it holds, baby.

Oh, don't call me baby anymore.

Never mind what I call you. You call me the minute anything happens.

The next couple of days were the worst of my life. There was nothing I could do but concentrate on that phone. Stare at it. Waiting for it to ring. After a while, I started yelling at it. Ordering it to ring. Like some kind of nut. But it stayed silent. It just stared back at me. Until I got so jumpy that I had to get out of the room. But I wasn't on the street for five minutes before I found myself heading back for the lobby. And demanding to know if there'd been any calls for me. The answer was always, no. And then, on the morning of the third day after Myrna's call, when I wasn't even thinking about the phone, it rang.

Hello?

I've been going nuts here. Why didn't you call me before?

You told me to call you when something happened.

Well, something must have happened by now. Did they assume the body?

They did.

Well, go on.

Jerry, it was just like you said. Ben told me about it. He said he felt awful grabbing it to me. He thought I should be told.

Thank the Lord.

No, it won't be all right until you've got that money.

What?

Okay. Okay, now listen close. Here's the way we're going to handle it. The first thing you do is deposit the check to the regular account. Deposit it. And then go to the Chemical National Bank. The one on Clover Street, near the arch. You know the one I mean?

Just listen and do what I say. You go to that bank and say you want to open a joint savings account. A joint. For you and your husband. Only now, you're Mrs. John Nolan. Understand?

When an account by myself...

Yes, you can sign all the papers there. And then collect the forms that I have to sign. Understand?

Yes, I see.

Put all the forms in an envelope and send them to me here at the Montgomery.

No, you can drop them off in person at the desk. The Montgomery is right around the corner from the bank. Leave it at the front desk for Mr. Nolan.

Let's see how that'll work.

Shut up and listen to me. This is the safest way to handle it. Once you have the money deposited in our regular checking account, you can write a check for the whole amount to John Nolan. There. Now do you get it?

You mean that the money counts?

That's just what I mean.

And after that?

Well, I'll let you know the rest of the plan. Have you got it all straight?

That's my girl.

It was cloud nine time. I felt like I was floating. Like I was drooling. Like I was drunk on expensive champagne. And it wouldn't be too long before I was. I was mentally throwing out every shabby suit in my closet and replacing them with custom-made threads. I was so stuffed with dreams that the next few hours passed by in a pink haze.

Hello?

Yeah, thanks. Send it right up.

Myrna had followed her instructions perfectly. I filled out the joint account application, signed John Nolan in a sweeping hand, and then took the forms to the Chemical National Bank myself. I wanted them to get a good look at me because they were going to be seeing me again very soon.

Ah, getting cool again, isn't it?

Yes.

Looks like it'll be a short summer, doesn't it?

Uh-huh. And now let me see. How much are you depositing initially, Mr. Nolan?

Well, my wife will be making the first deposit tomorrow morning.

Uh-huh.

It'll probably be a big one. We're buying a house, and so we're cashing in some, uh, stocks.

Oh, I see.

It's, uh, too bad we won't be leaving it in the account long enough to collect interest. I might have to withdraw most of it pretty quick.

Well, easy come, easy go.

That's right. Easy come, easy go.

She didn't know how funny that was. And two days later, when I strolled back into the Chemical National Bank, the joke was all ready for the punchline. I had the passbook in my hand and happiness in my heart when I walked across the marble floor to the teller's cage marked M-N-O. I caught a glimpse of the bank guard's dark blue uniform. He looked fat and lazy. I stepped up to the window and started to say hello to my girlfriend of the day before. But then I remembered I had a withdrawal slip to make out first. So I smiled apologetically and went to the glass top counter in the center of the room. I copied the number from the passbook and filled out the amount. $20,000. No, I wasn't going to withdraw it all. I was smarter than that. All that bread going in and out so fast, that would attract too much notice. I was going to chip away at it, a piece at a time.

Oh, hello. I see you didn't waste any time.

Nope. I gotta get that deposit down today.

Uh-huh. $20,000. Well, I'm sure you want a bank check for that, won't you?

Uh, yeah, I'd better. I wouldn't want to walk around with that much cash.

Oh, one moment. I have to see an officer.

Take your time.

Mr. Nolan?

Uh, yes?

I'm Bill Harkness, assistant manager. Would you mind stepping into my office a moment?

What for?

Oh, it's just a technical matter regarding your account.

Why, what's the matter with my account? The money's on deposit, isn't it? It says so in my passbook.

Oh, yes, yes. Everything's in order. But you see, when any large withdrawal is made, we're required to fill out certain forms.

Well, I never heard of anything like that.

It won't take long, I promise.

Well, okay. This way, please.

Now, if you'll sit right here, I'll have the form in just a moment.

Waited almost a month already for this, so I figured I could wait another few minutes. The only thing is, I didn't realize what I was really waiting for until the door opened and Harkness returned. This time he had another man with him, and a woman who I supposed was his secretary.

Sorry to have been so long, Mr. Nolan.

Well, that's okay. Just, uh, just let me get my check and get out of here. I've got things to do.

What sort of things, Mr. Nolan?

Oh, I didn't, uh, I didn't get your name.

I'm Lieutenant Whalen.

Police?

Police? Now, wait a minute. Are you implying that I'm doing something illegal by withdrawing money from my own account?

You're doing something illegal, all right, Mr. Nolan. So, why don't you tell us all about it?

Listen, if this is an arrest, I'd like...

Sure, sure, sure, I know. You've got rights. You don't have to say anything to incriminate yourself.

Well, I've got a few things to say, let me tell you. And who are you?

What's the matter, Jerry? Don't you know your own wife? Your own baby?

Hey, now, wait a minute. My name is Nolan. John Nolan, and I can prove it. I've got a driver's license here. Look at it.

And I'm Myrna, your own loving wife, Jerry. How come you don't recognize me?

I know why, Mr. Nolan. Because you really are John Nolan, and the real Jerry Horton is dead, killed in that train wreck. I should have guessed it the first time you called me. You imitated Jerry's voice, okay, and you always talked low. But I should have known you weren't my husband. You took his wallet. That's how you knew how to reach his wife. Mr. Horton must have told you about his insurance policy. But how did it happen? How did you find out?

It was the autopsy. It was when they dug up the body again and proved that it was my husband. It was the teeth that did it. And that's how we identified the body, by the dental work. As soon as the insurance people paid me that money, I knew that it had to be Jerry in that coffin. And that it was going to be somebody else in this bank. We told Mrs. Horton to go along with you until you actually wrote that withdrawal slip. And that's all the evidence we need, friend.

Can't blame a guy for trying, can you? So I guess the money is all yours, Mrs. Horton.

Myrna, congratulations.

Listen, you may not believe this, but I'd give half this money to have Jerry back.

Of course, the moral of our story is that crime doesn't pay, even if the insurance companies do. And now you see why we don't recommend our hero's method of getting rich. Because now, Mr. Nolan is going to be going somewhere that boasts no champagne, no fancy cars, and very little change of wardrobe. I'll be back shortly.

Go on a picnic. Go on a vacation. Face it. In today's America, family fun is hard to come by. And with busy schedules, just getting the family together is not an easy thing to do. How would you like to have a little family fun every week?

How would you like to learn together? How would you like to grow together? And how would you like to help your son get an edge on growing up? Cub Scouting is helping families like yours be a family. It's your help to ours. Today's Cub Scout program is just as much for families as it is for boys. So when your son wants to join a Cub Scout pack, remember to take along the whole family. That's what Cub Scouting is all about. For the Cub Scout pack nearest you, call the Boy Scouts of America. They're in the white pages of your phone book.

You have to admit that there's something fascinating about confidence games. They say that the essential ingredient of a good swindle is to play upon the greed of the victim. The next time someone offers you a way to make an easy dollar, make sure you're not dealing with the wrong man. Our cast included Michael Tolan, Vicki Vola, Gilbert Mack, Mary Jane Higbee, and Robert Dryden. The entire production was under the direction of Hyman Brown.

And now, a preview of our next tale.

What have you in the pet carrier box?

I hate to tell you, but... Oh dear, not again.

I'm afraid so. You are so careless with pets, Hugo. There's four cats dead already this year. You'll want to bury this one out by the Rose tomb.

If I may. It's getting a wee bit crowded, but I'm sure you'll find a nice little spot.

What happened to that pussycat of yours, Hugo?

She had an accident.

Oh. Oh, what sort of accident?

To tell you the truth, she sort of lost her head.

Oh. You leave your door open and your poor little cat rushes out into traffic, particularly on that busy street you live on. What do you expect?

Well, dear, you'd better hurry. It's getting dark.

Yes, that's what I was waiting for.

Radio Mystery Theater was sponsored in part by Anheuser-Busch Incorporated, Brewers of Budweiser. This is E.G. Marshall, inviting you to return to our Mystery Theater for another adventure in the macabre. Until next time, pleasant dreams.

Tonight's CBS Mystery Theater has been brought to you by A.M. and A's, downtown and six suburban stores, including the new Lockport store. This is WBEN Buffalo.

End of transcriptBack to the beginning ↑