Skip to content
On Air
All channelsAll
CBS Radio Mystery Theater artwork

From the CBS Radio Mystery Theater collection

Cool Killer Carl

Episode 828May 5, 197841 min 3 secTranscript

Writer: Himan Brown

The written record

Read the transcript

Read along with the recording · About 27 min to read

The CBS Radio Mystery Theater presents... Welcome. I'm E.G. Marshall. If you go by statistics, most murder victims are killed by people they know. A friend, a relative. And almost always, such violent death is the end to a quarrel. The fatal heat of the moment. Something quite different. Crimes without that hot blood, but in cold.

Are you... You're the man they... The man they call Cool Killer Carl.

Yeah, that's me.

Is, uh... Is this your wife?

What are you going to do to us?

I wish you wouldn't point those guns.

Well, you can't come in here like this.

Well, of course you can. You can... You can spend the night.

Julie, what are you doing? This man is a killer. He's a wanted man.

Don't care if he is. He's a human being, isn't he?

Our mystery drama, Cool Killer Carl, was written especially... Especially for the Mystery Theater by Gene Frederick Lewis. And stars Nathan Adams. Sponsored in part by Contact, the 12-hour cold capsule.

He marked for death accidentally. The pistol, the shotgun, the knife is pointed at someone else. Not you. If you live harmlessly, why would you be harmed? The question haunts us. The answer eludes us. So we don't like to think about it. Some of us, however, have to think about it and do something about it. What? Such person is Lieutenant Poletti of the Union City Police Force.

This case took us two years to solve. And if it wasn't for the action of one family who were threatened with certain death, who knows how many more lives he would have snuffed out.

Who was he?

I'm talking about Carl Hefner. Or as we used to call him at police headquarters, Cool Killer Carl. And man, he was cool. Take that April Fool's Day when Carl walked into a bar on James Street.

You're lucky I'll say that for you.

What?

I see you've got another customer, so guess I don't have to rush.

Oh, you mean him? He's been nursing that drink for too long. I can't make any money out of him. Hey, Kramer. Kramer, I'm closing down, pal.

Ah, but it's just as well go home and face the music.

What do you mean, Mr. Kramer?

Oh, and I get old, believe me. My wife's going to throw the book at me.

Yeah? How come?

This is the second pair of glasses busted this week. Then she's going to lay me low.

Okay, kid, what's on your mind?

What are you doing? What is it?

This is a gun. And this is another gun. Both are loaded.

Hey, put those away, young man.

Now, don't go sticking your nose where it isn't wanted, mister. Stay healthy. I'm a cop.

Off to... Don't reach for your gun. Kramer, don't. That's why I carry two of these. One for each of us. Please, Kramer, I hate giving you good advice, cop. Now, take it out. Slide your gun down the counter to me. Go on.

Kramer, please.

Okay. You were asking me what I'll have.

Sure, sure. You name it. I'll take whatever's in the cash register. With a... Don't. It's all, friend. It's not polite. It's unwise to be coming in here.

Any sign of him?

That kid must be an Olympic champion sprinter. To the streets, but nowhere. James in front, no one. Back down the other way to me. Not a trace. A crowd this time of night for him to disappear, and he's just fast.

You'll get him.

You darn fool. Me, a cop, and this happened. Oh, believe me, Kramer, I'm just as glad there was no shooting. Oh, boy. I'm glad he hears about this.

Who's that?

That... Oh, was that... That fella had the drop on you. You had no choice.

Yeah, yeah. Let me have my gun.

Oh, yeah. Yeah, yeah. Don't let it get you down, Kramer. I'm only out 60 bucks. Don't take more than that. Don't after him in 10 seconds, Lieutenant, but he disappeared. I... I didn't think... I didn't think anyone could run that fast.

What'd he look like, Kramer?

Well, clean-shaven, 5'4", thin, had on what looked like Army fatigues, you know, the fatigue service kind. Brown hair, brown eyes, muscular. He was fast on his feet. Oh, greased lightning. Up James Street and out of sight. And a very calm demeanor during the holdup.

Two guns, you said, huh?

Yeah, 44s, both of them.

I hate guessing, Kramer, but I'd say that's the same guy who's been keeping the other precincts jumping. Holding up neighborhood saloons since last Christmas. Now, how long is that?

Uh, four months. He waits till closing time and then he hits.

I feel so darn dumb.

Take a look at these reports, Kramer. Here, here. Here's one. Yeah, I'll bet on it. Here, listen to this. Male, 25. Same description. Held up Peretti's bar on Chestnut. Bartender described this sailor as very young, very calm, very cool. Unless he's got a twin, Kramer, it sounds like yours tonight.

I'll type up my report. And hey, thanks for being so, uh, benevolent.

Two weeks later, another stick-up of another bar. The same cool holdup man. The M.O. exactly the same. Not much money taken. Closing time. Only the address was different. McCloskey's Bar and Grill on Front Street. At 11:30 p.m., richer by $125 than he'd been five minutes earlier, a man ran out of McCloskey's, made a 50-yard dash up the street, and jumped into a cab parked at the curb.

Get going! Get going, driver!

The cab driver knew something was wrong. He fumbled with the ignition key and then froze. In his rear-view mirror, he could see a big man wearing a bartender's apron, running up the street toward his cab, yelling, Stop! Stop! Stop that man!

Come on! Come on! Let's go, chump! Please! You've got to help me! See, that man back there, look! See, I've been romancing a girl, and I only just found out that she's married. And that's her husband heading for us, and he's threatened to kill me!

The way we got the story later from the taxi driver, he thought he was doing his passenger a favor. We told him he sure was. A $125 favor.

Weeks went by, and I'm ashamed to say months. Our mysterious gunman racked up a total of $4,000, lifted from grocery stores, liquor stores, bars, and laundromats. Then, finally, that fateful Monday. We held our usual weekly quarterbacking at the station house, all hands on deck at 745. Patrolman Kramer, the only man on the force who had seen our elusive hold-up man at close quarters, had the floor.

Of course, I, uh, would have seen him better if I hadn't broken my glasses that day. But this drawing the art boys have come up with resembles him pretty well. Now, there are two known facts that we have to go on. One, this young punk is going to go right on rocking. He's too successful, and he's too cruel to stop. Our psychological report tells us we're dealing with a character of exceedingly high intellect. Fact two, for 22 months now, this man has pulled out two loaded .44s and not one threat. Now, one of these days, we'll go off. And it's one thing that comes to me. I mean, uh, identification that might help.

Yeah?

The man we're looking for has got a mole on his right cheek, almost under his eye.

It was 8:15 Monday morning. Patrolman Kramer took the subway to Union Avenue where he was detailed that day. At 8:47, Kramer stood up and went to the subway train door. Union Avenue. Sitting in the seat right by the door was the young man with the mole on his cheek. Kramer was certain who had robbed the bar on James Street.

Get up.

What's the matter?

I'm under arrest.

Well, for sure. That's not my job.

It is now. Come on.

You can't go around dragging ordinary citizens off trains just because you're a cop.

You're a suspect. I certainly can.

Out of the question.

Don't make a fuss if you know what's good for you.

I tell you, I tell you, if you're making a mistake, officer, I have done nothing wrong.

I will see if you stand there. You may be misled.

I tell you, you've got the wrong guy. I am. I got a picture here which says different.

Patrolman Kramer was killed instantly. His murderer disappeared.

I had said that it was only a question of time. Kramer's death was the answer. The slugs extracted from Kramer's chest were identified at ballistics and from there we got a line on the guns. Only a question of time before the guns and the bullets and the purchaser were identified. Now we knew who it was we were hunting. Carl Hefner.

Finding Carl Hefner presented the kind of problem that police find almost the most difficult of all to solve. He must have a family, friends. Apparently he had cut himself off from anyone who had known him. Operated alone. For a man for now he was no longer an ordinary stick-up man. Killed a cop and without doubt there would be other deaths. Entire country. Cool Carl killed the young man who robbed without apology, now killed without regret. People went to work looking over their shoulders, wondering if they'd be next. The heat of notoriety was on the cool killer but it was also on the police before his guns fired again.

We took men from anywhere they could be spared. Beefed up the street patrols, the squad cars, and the detective division. The search took Detective Wellicott from our precinct to a movie house the night of the 4th. They were showing an old war movie. The Japanese attacking Pearl Harbor. In a back row, apparently dozing, sat the man we were looking for. Detective Wellicott recognized him.

Wake up, Hefner.

What is it?

If you just open both your eyes you'll notice I got my gun and my gun pointing straight at you. Hold your hands up.

What do you think you're doing?

Stand up slowly. Are you Carl Hefner?

Who's Carl? I never heard of him.

No kidding. You don't even read the newspapers. All right. Move out to the aisle.

You don't have any right to do this.

I'm a police officer. You're under arrest. Now march up the aisle into the lobby. Up there. Through the swinging doors.

I think he walked in.

Sorry, I stumbled. I'm just not awake yet. I didn't mean anything.

I'm right behind you. Now march. And no tricks. I don't want to use this gun in a crowded theater, but I will if I have to. Push open those swinging doors.

Why, Scott?

Sorry, I'm sorry. I didn't mean to let that door swing back in your face like that.

Dave Wellicott? Dave, it's me, Poletti. You're in the hospital since last night. Now don't talk, Dave. I'll see you in a minute.

Tight on my chest. I'm strapped. Up there to my neck.

You're fired at your point blank. Three slugs in the chest.

No kidding. You don't know the half of it. Charmed life.

Question the guy behind the candy counter, Dave. He saw the whole thing. He saw you bring Hefner into the lobby. Hefner in front of you. He turned around and pushed the swinging door into your face. And when you got the door open, he let loose with both guns and was out of there before anyone knew it.

I remember. That's right, you did. The guy at the candy counter said you got him in the leg. We found blood all the way into the street.

For the time being, I don't feel very good.

You were on the operating table from midnight until four this morning. They took out three slugs and then sewed you up.

Bullets in my chest. That's it. Cool, Carl. It's not the only one that leads a charmed life. You know, the doc told me that at that split second when you were shot, your heart had contracted. If it had been expanding, the bullet would have nicked the heart, and right now, we wouldn't be talking.

So you'll be as good as new, Dave. They're sure about that. As soon as the stitches are out of your chest, I'm persuaded the commissioner to pin a medal on it.

Within minutes of the attack on Detective Dave Wellicott, we had a complete circle cordoned around ten city blocks of the area. No one could leave or enter without being questioned. What we didn't know was within minutes after the shooting, Carl Hefner was ringing the front doorbell of an unsuspecting family of four. Mr. and Mrs. Edward Kegel and their two small children. This is the way that encounter was pieced together for the police later.

Mrs., I'm coming.

Hey, be sure to put the chain on the front door before you open it. You know what we said on television.

Okay, hon. I guess you know who I am.

Yeah.

Is that them ladies? Oh, they both are. I just shot another cop. Now, do as I say, and nothing will happen to him. Take your foot out of the door.

Gary, what is it, dear? Who is it?

Ah, good evening, sir. Um, I just told your wife to take it easy, not to panic, to keep calm, and nothing will happen to him. Hey, look, there's a gun to your point. Hey. Aimed right at your wife, sir. And I can shoot a lot faster than you can close this door.

What are we going to do, sir? That's the man Carl Hefner they've been talking about on TV.

Look, would you go away, please? We have two little children upstairs.

You sound like a nice family. They'll never look for me here.

Will you go somewhere else and leave us alone, will you?

If you're really thinking of your kids, you wouldn't want them orphans, would you? Just let me inside. And close the door behind me quietly. I really mean it. I promise you. I just need... I just need... I just need to stop running and rest for a bit. I won't hurt you.

I'll let him in. Come on in.

Are you the man they're calling?

Yeah, yeah, that's me. And now, about your children.

They're upstairs. They're watching television.

Well, I think it's about time that they went to bed. I've been thinking about this. I don't really think you should spend the night here.

Of course you can, Ed. I've got some blankets. I'll make you comfortable on the sofa.

You out of your mind, surely? What are you doing? This man is a hunted criminal.

Get over there, Mr. Hefner. Didn't you hear what I said? This man is a killer.

He's a human being, isn't he? Surely, I don't get you with all...

Here you are in the kitchen making a pot of coffee. I must be dreaming.

Why not? If we had people over in the evening, we always get in coffee.

Well, for heaven's sake, he's not exactly an invited guest.

Oh, I wonder if I've got any cake left over from yesterday.

Well, maybe... Wouldn't do that.

Huh?

Uh, do what?

Take your hands away from there. Leave the phone alone, okay? You sit down there and have some coffee.

Coffee? Why not? On the level?

Oh, sure, he's on the level, all right. When she says coffee and cake, she means it.

Indeed, all that. It happens. But did you do it for standard?

Sure, if you say so. Carl, if you don't mind putting those guns away, huh? I mean, we're not going to jump you or anything.

You're crazy, we're not.

That's a reasonable request. I'm a reasonable person. I'll put them on the kitchen counter.

Will you two men just stop hiding over me? The coffee will be ready as soon as the kettle's boiling. Both of you. Eddie, you take this chair. Carl? No, on the other side. We always eat in the kitchen. Eddie, will I get the mug down when you've got the cake? Carl, I'll have a sandwich for you in a jiffy.

You guys don't seem to be a bit scared.

Oh, sure, I'm scared. I'm scared for Shirley, for David and Betty upstairs. I mean, where are you at? I meant to ask. Are they all right, the two of them?

I brought them their milk. I tucked them in for the night. Did you tell them you had a friend today?

Well, there's time enough for that in the morning.

What? What's that?

I can't believe it. Put those guns... Come on, silly, is the water boiling? You'll have a quiet cup of coffee, and Carl, you eat. Here's the sandwich, I hope you like it. I don't want to hear another word out of you, young man, until your plate is clean.

You know, you sound just like my mother.

Her? How long do you think it'll be a... Dang it. It suddenly will.

Oh, and the kids are David and Betty. And what do you do with?

Teach mathematics at Union City High. Shirley works in the same school. Who takes care of children?

Well, she has both a mother and a teacher.

Oh, my goodness. How? What does she do?

I'm not exactly a teacher, Carl. I'm Shirley's... Wait, what's that?

Carl? You're eating my blood all over your leg.

Oh. Oh, yeah. I thought I'd stopped it with my handkerchief.

Sit around in that chair. Now, stick your leg out. And will you look at that? The boys heard. They're charging us up so I can take care of it.

Lady. I, Shirley, I... You're crazy. I mean, I've shot two cops, and today one of them nicked me, and you... You... Holy... Holy... God. You don't know my wife.

Carl, if she wants to help someone, nothing's going to stop her.

I'm not helping anyone but me. Now, you go get some bandages there. They're in the medicine chest upstairs. I'm not going to have blood all over my nice new linoleum kitchen floor.

I've been lying here thinking about it. It's awfully sad, isn't it? Why would a boy like that, obviously intelligent, turn on society?

Look, Shirley, don't you think your sympathies are a little misplaced? Carl Hefner's a murderer. The whole city's looking for him.

I don't know. He's so young. You've fed him. You've cleaned off his wounds. You've bandaged him. You've given him a blanket and a pillow. How am I thinking of David and Betty? You think they're safe with this crazy guy now?

He wouldn't hurt them. He promised. He promised. You think this trigger-happy kid, you think he knows the meaning of the word?

Okay, I'm over understanding that. Well, if you're stalling for time, that's fine. That's okay by me, Shirley. All I'm saying is, we've got to have a plan before he kills us all.

There's someone on the landing.

Get up, you two cunts. Oh, fuck's sake. I'm going to get to the wall. What is it? What is that?

Power. Power. I'll see you when I pull the trigger. You don't hear the police outside, do you? You don't know anything about them. I might have known. Coffee and cake and mothers. Are you just doing this? One broken promise deserves another. In the underworld, the code of the criminal rewards treachery. But cool killer Carl is obeying that code. Is he of life? He never heard of it. To him, it is not a matter of revenge, but justice. On me. He deserves to die. Besides, no matter how many more corpses Carl Hefner adds to his grave, you pay him back. Here's a young man that's killed without some function. Normal? Abnormal? Psychopathic? What's the difference by what name he is labeled? For some reason, he is revenging himself upon society. Without his gun, what kind of person is he afraid?

I never thought it would end like this. Shot in the back by a coward. He's a coward. He's a coward. He's a coward. He's a coward. He's a coward. He's a coward. He's a coward. He's a coward. He's a coward. He's a coward. He's a coward. He's a coward. He's a coward. He's a coward. He's a coward. He's a coward. He's a coward. He's a coward. He's a coward. He's a coward. He's a coward. He's a coward. He's a coward. He's a coward.

We didn't call the cops, I swear it. And then, I'm coming up here for you, Ed, and the children.

Stupid roast cops. Are they? Poor police. Maybe they're just out there getting parking tickets.

Don't be funny. I disagree with you, Carl. It just doesn't make sense to me that you'd kill me. And my husband, and David, and Betty. For what? You'll be caught, finally. And you'll have four more deaths on your conscience.

You called the police, see? I mean, what did you expect from them? I told you, I didn't. Ed didn't. I thought you'd treat us the way they treated you.

What do you know? They're going. You must be a police. I can tell you this. Shirley, you confuse me.

The only one who wants to help you confuses you?

I don't want to think about that. I don't want to get caught. Not just yet, that's all.

Is your leg still hurting?

It's all right. You ought to get to a doctor. Wound gets infected, it could, you know. A bullet wound.

Do you really care?

Of course I do. I mean, what am I to you? I keep thinking of my son, David, and supposing someday something went wrong for him and he needed help. What if I wasn't around? I'd hope he'd find someone to help him, too.

I don't know if he'd do what any mother would.

Maybe if I'd had you for a mother.

I can't believe your mother didn't love you.

Hey, Charlotte. Is she still alive? Does she know where you are?

She does now. They got pictures of me. I haven't spoken to her. She made me a... You did a job. What are you doing hanging around the... She bought me a comb. I kept taking it, what you were saying, and I kept eating it. She always makes me take my new comb and bust it. I never even found it. But you should talk to her.

Is she there for us?

Well, Barrett Hill is right outside of the city. Good job. All this time, I didn't do one thing. Done it all wrong. They'll get me the cops. They'll kill me. I'll go to the church.

You could make it easier for your mother, you know. Four years. But say if you're on death row, they give you one last wish.

Oh, I'll tell them. I want to see my mother.

Maybe you won't get that chance.

I threatened with a gun, I know that. But the other guy always had his finger on a trigger before I did.

I believe you.

When I was a kid in school, nobody took me seriously. I was a school joke, you know that? I was always dropping things. I was always striking things. Comes and cuts cars. That was my nickname, Carl the Klutz, when I was a kid. That sure changed everybody's opinion. I was in the middle of a .44. Made twice as much of a threat. Sure. But you didn't ask to be taken at your own risk.

Oh, boy. Oh, boy. They knew I wasn't kidding around. I had to do that. For my own self-respect.

Carl, tomorrow morning, if I get your mother on the telephone, will you talk to her?

Oh, you mean just like that? I'm going up to bed now and have a look at the children to make sure they're all right. And you go to sleep, too, right here on that sofa. And in the morning, I'm coming down and get your mother on the telephone and I want you to talk to her.

You think I should?

Is this Mrs. Hefner? Mrs. Hefner, you don't know me. My name is Mrs. Shirley Cable. We live in Union City. I'm calling you at the request of your son, Carl.

Why?

It's a right idea. Your son. He's here in our house. I know Carl hasn't been in touch with you lately, but he says he'd like to talk to you, so just a minute. Please hold on. Another call. Another end.

How are you?

Fine. What have I been doing? I had a job in the filling station. Yeah, some work on cars. Mostly pumping gas. No, no. Wait a second. Listen. I had a real nice job for a pretty long time. I'm stacking books in the library. No, not the one near home. The big one downtown in the city. Why didn't I keep that try-the-mark, didn't I? I mean, you were always asking me to get a job. Well, I got jobs. I got lots of jobs. So what? Don't you have to believe everything you read? Yeah, that was me. So what? Now, look. Look, Ma. Look. Just listen to me, Ma. I didn't want to call you in the first place, but this lady where I'm staying, she said that I should. Oh, boy. Oh, boy. I knew you'd still be after me. You can't do it. You never... Ma? Ma? Ma? Are you crying? Ma, don't do that. Please don't cry. I didn't mean that honest, I didn't... Listen to me, Ma. Whatever they say about me, they don't know anything. I mean, some of it's true, what I did, but not all of it. Ma, you gotta stop crying. I do love you. Sure I do. Yeah. And I miss you. I've missed you lots of times. I get so lonely sometimes. I had to go away from home. You never listen to me. Oh, no, no, you didn't. See, listen, Ma, I had to make people listen to me. Come home. I gotta lay low. I wish I could see you, too. Hey, Ma, if everything goes wrong, don't they get me? I promise I'll see you. I'll make them get you to come see me.

This is Mrs. Cable.

Yes, it's all right. I know he's a good boy. Mrs. Hefner, you can't blame yourself. I'm sure you did. And whatever caused them, I'm sure you pleased them. I certainly didn't. And you take care of yourself, too, Mrs. Hefner.

It was Carl's, aren't you?

Yes. I know you want to speak to him. I know you do. You're gonna get me. I know they will. Thank the blessing. I've been running away for years. I can tell you. I can tell you that. I said that.

Yes, you did. I'll bring the children their breakfast, and then who?

And I deny it?

Carl Huffman kept the Cable family prisoners in their own home all that morning. He watched television down in the living room, staring at the special news bulletins about his escape and the wounding of Detective Wellicott. While he watched, Mr. and Mrs. Cable had a hurried, tense consultation in their bedroom.

We can't go on like this, sir. Hour after hour, just waiting. Waiting for what? We've got to get the kids out of this house.

He's calmed down, Ed. He really has.

Yeah, but now? I think I could make him get himself up.

Not in a million years. Don't count on it. He's erratic. He's irrational.

You're wrong, Donnie. You slipped in there when you called his mother. He can be reached.

Donnie, you know, I respect everything you stand for and be, but this isn't some rejected teenager in school that you can steer with guidance counseling. Carl, after he killed in cold blood, he's way past the point of being able to return.

Ed, please. Don't do anything. Wait. Just a little longer.

Now, listen to me. Listen to me for a minute. Let's tell him our kids are really going stir crazy. They're not used to being kept in all day, and I just can't keep them in the house any longer. And if he'd be a good fellow and let us all out of the house for a breath of fresh air, we won't do anything that would jeopardize his safety. I'll promise him that if I have to.

Well, that's a great promise. Kitty, see him for what he is, please.

Honey, I have to think of our safety. I have to think of our safety first.

Well, you'll have to make those promises to yourself. I can't. He trusts me. You just go get the kids ready and leave the rest to me.

At 3:35, I got a telephone call from Ed Cable from a street phone booth. They had run from their home ten city blocks. He had his family safely with him and they were going to his mother's. At 3:45, we had the Cable house surrounded.

Blood was the young man. He'd been hit pretty bad.

Kid, not me, you wad. I live here. I belong here.

Carl Hefner, it's you we want.

You don't want me. I'm not him. I'm not him anymore.

Help us search the house, boys. We've got him.

Leaving behind him a trail of blood, a young man so sure he was misunderstood, that nobody cared, that his work was unrecognized. Six months later, cool killer Carl paid the supreme penalty. But in his final earthly hours, he was granted his wish. His mother came to see him. Troubled youth at long last.

Somewhere between self-love and self-hate lies the balance of a peaceful mind. Overweigh either on one side of the human scale and the result can be self-destruction. We've told this story of Carl Hefner in order to shed some light and perhaps even sound some warning. Psychological misfit, we'd rather remember him as a man who thought he was unloved.

Our cast included Mason Adams, Marian Seldes, William Griffis, Ian Martin, and Mandel Kramer. The entire production was under the direction of Hyman Brown.

A preview of our next tale.

Mommy, well, that's not bad. Coming from the astral world, you wouldn't expect it to be exactly the same as in life. Couldn't make it a little younger, could you? What did I have to do? Well, get some more dry ice for the vapor. And you better go check your Hessian costume because you've lost some more weight. Oh, how about the wrap? Get so thin that you can't do that anymore because the wrapping set the tone. The whole thing. She will be here at nine o'clock and I want everything ready. I want you ready because this may lead to something very big. Really big.

Inviting you to return to our Mystery Theater for another adventure in the macabre. Till next time, pleasant dreams.

End of transcriptBack to the beginning ↑