Skip to content
On Air
All channelsAll
CBS Radio Mystery Theater artwork

From the CBS Radio Mystery Theater collection

Death Will Not Silence Me

Episode 1260November 16, 198144 min 29 secTranscript

Writer: Himan Brown

The written record

Read the transcript

Read along with the recording · About 27 min to read

you know by now that the door you have just entered into a strange world a land of forbidden fantasies people by giants and pygmies kings and cobblers saints and sinners happy children play in its streets while just behind alert inexorable crimes are committed here by the sovereign in this place it is the realm of your own imagination our story this time searches one of its deep the hidden place our mystery drama Death Will Not Silence Me was especially written for the Mystery Theater by Arnold Moss. It stars Marion Seldes and John Beale. I'll be back in a moment with Act One. In ancient times, disease was often attributed to the supernatural, the spiritual. Or, at times, it was thought to be the result of what was called humors. In more recent years, we have learned that some ailments may arise from...

hereditary abnormalities, disorders passed on from one generation to the next. The year is 1839 in the heart of the bluegrass region of Kentucky. The city of Lexington, a young lady from one of the city's leading families, 21 years old, watches terrified as the rain beats in savage fury against the glass of the windowpane.

Run in on the window. I've been mad. Every time there's a storm, I become so desperately ill. Why do my hands shake? My head is throbbing with a killing pain. The entire left side of my face feels paralyzed. Blinded with suffering. And worse of all, I feel so alone. Just to stay alone. I was less than seven years old the first time it happened. Sad news for you, little sister Mary. I have a new baby brother, but our beloved mother... ...was a mystery of death, of being abandoned by someone I loved completely, by someone who loved me in return. There was a driving rainstorm, just like today. And as I listened to the pounding of the rain, a terrible sickness overcame me. And I had the feeling, even then, seven years, some odd way, I had been the cause of my mother's death.

Older sister Elizabeth has invited me to spend some time with her and her husband in a home in Illinois, Springfield, Illinois. And it will be arranged in my honor. Oh, thank you so much. That was delightful. So lively. I feel as if I'll never be able to catch my breath ever again. Oh, you are enjoying yourself, Nanny. Thank you. I'm convinced that Springfield is the most interesting collection of people I've ever met in my life. There's such fun. Oh, and some of the most desirable and... Eligible young bachelor. I know. Oh, you have no idea what a relief it is to be out of a house in Lexington, even if it's only for a brief visit. That house is just burst in with noisy children, busy servants, inquisitive visitors, and relatives. And, alas, very few unmarried young men. Men of promise and good reputation, that is. Not too many, I see, Elizabeth. Not too many. Pity. The only career that's open to me is...

His matrimony. And now, what is wrong with that? Oh, nothing, nothing. So here I am, at 21, a confirmed spinster. And speaking of exceptional young men, I think you're going to be asked for this horse by that gentleman coming over to us. Which one? The tall, born-looking one. The one with the deep-set eyes. He's tall, isn't he? Who is he? Oh, he's an up-and-coming young country lawyer. A little rough around the edges, maybe, but... Miss Todd, I'd be pleased, ma'am, if you'd honor me with this waltz. I'd be delighted. Excuse us, Elizabeth. I've been wanting to dance with you all evening, Miss Todd. In the worst possible way. Well, thank you. Let's see now. Springfield, Miss Todd? Oh, yes, indeed. I was licensed just three years ago. I had a choice of learning to be a blacksmith or a lawyer. I chose the law. The risks and challenges are not as great as...

Blacksmithing. I beg your pardon this time. I'm afraid I stepped right on your foot. Forgive me. No, no, nothing. It's nothing. Before that, not much, I'm afraid. I spent some time earning a modest livelihood splitting rails, clearing land, farming, operating a general store, then the Black Hawk War, terming the Illinois State Legislature, and... That about sums up the story of my life. Not very colorful, not very eventful. Go again. I'm so sorry. I'm not a very good dancer, I'm afraid. Oh, you're doing quite well. I must say that in every respect, you are back in the way you look, the way you stand, as far as I can judge your mentality. You're quite unique. You are totally unlike any man I've ever met before in my entire life. Very sorry, Miss Dodd. Good.

I escort you back to your seat, Miss Hart. Thank you. I appreciate your tolerating my conversation. And above all, what I call my dancing. Well, you did say you wanted to dance with me in the worst possible way. And I can only add that that's what I certainly did. Well, you have made a rather profound impression on me, sir. And on your dancing slippers, too, I fear. My feet are fine. It's my neck. It's a bit stiff. Your neck? From looking up at you as we dance. I'm only five feet, two inches, whereas you, sir, are... Six-four. Well, you see what I mean? It's Lincoln, man. Abraham Lincoln. Take eyes on him. That Mr. Lincoln is the man I am destined to marry. After a courtship with many ups and downs in 1842 in the spacious home of my sister Elizabeth, Abraham Lincoln and I repeat our marriage vows and become man and wife. There is no wedding trip.

For the link. Not being able to afford a home, I've only decided to go to the Glode Tavern. Rather noisy, crowded, but thin, expensive hotel boarding house near the edge of town. No! There's nothing to be frightened of. It's bad things to me. You know how my head splits with pain, horrible pain. The rain, the lightning and thunder, they always do that to me. What can I do to help? I'll do anything you'd like me to. Oh, I know, I know. You are a dear man. Your heart is as big as your arms are long and comforting. I'll be all right, Mr. Lincoln. Just keep on... I knew in my bones that despite everything, our marriage had in some weird way started that. With a storm that was about to break, there came the usual sinister omen. An eerie presentiment of impending death and disaster. It's the following year.

1843. Still the globe tappens as I lay in bed. Come in, please. How do you feel? Looks so very beautiful. Everything is just fine and dandy. To have a time like this, to be here beside you, and not away on the legal circuit. What shall our son's name be, Mr. Lincoln? The choice, my dear, is yours. Then, if you don't mind, may we name our firstborn after my father, Robert Todd? Robert? Todd Lincoln. A good name, mother. I think so. Months later, I may be bequeathed in my unspoken terror, my silent anxiety. When he's elected to Congress, I begin to bask in the reflected light of my husband's rising star. But, do what I may, I cannot afford the shadow of the thin-edged sword that was each on the February morning in 18...

It finally falls. Little Eddie, you will recover? The doctor is concerned, you know. Doctors don't know everything. Please hand me that cold compress, Mr. Lincoln, for his heart. Here. This will help bring down your fever, Eddie. It'll... What is it, Mary? My baby was only four years old. There's something about me that breathes death. My mother was the first to go. No, Eddie. Stay away. Oh, you must... Put these strange ideas out of your head. It was the will of God that little Eddie should leave us. You had nothing to do with it. Yeah, I did. How? I don't know. If anything should happen to you, Mr. Lincoln, or to our son Robert, I'm out of my mind. I really mean out of my mind. Nothing will happen to Robert, dear wife. And certainly nothing will happen to me. That I can promise you. Her persistent ill health, both...

mental and physical, continue to eat away at Mary Lincoln. With each new day, she becomes progressively inconsolable, more alone, more frightened than ever. And in her depression, she insists that she carries the germs of calamity in her bloodstream. In the light of what we know now of history, where then can what she called this fiery furnace of affliction lead? I shall return shortly with Act Two.

Ten years in the life of Mary Todd Lincoln, from 1850 to 1860, were marked by her husband's phenomenally successful march from relative obscurity to the highest office in the land. But it was a land that was coming apart at the seams, a union that was slowly disintegrating, whose future was bleak under the ominous clouds of war. And through it all, Mary Todd Lincoln was persistently haunted by the specter... of a destroying angel within herself. An angel that she saw as a messenger of disaster and of death. 1850, that our darling Eddie died. The good Lord blesses us with another son, little Willie. His sunny presence does much to soften the heartache of Eddie. Willie often gets up during the night and toddles in our bedroom. He's right there at the foot of our bed to comfort me. If it were not...

For that, I would still be drowned in the tears I shed over Eddie. You must stop grieving over Eddie, my dear. Eddie's gone. But you have two other sons. Young Robert, who one of these days will be preparing to enter college. Well, of course. And dear little Willie. Willie, yes. He stands there at the foot of the bed with that sweet, adorable smile of his. And did you know that he does not always come alone? Not alone? That's right. Eddie sometimes comes in with him. 53, our fourth son is born, Thomas. Mr. Lincoln gives him that nickname. I call him Tad because he's as squirmy as a tiny little tadpole. And then on November 6th, 1860... Mother? Yes, Mr. Lincoln? I've just had word from the telegraph office we won New York. Oh, my God, isn't it great? This means a total Republican victory.

Just 30 years ago, I fell in love with a struggling young country lawyer. Today... Today, you're not only my first and only lady, you're also the first lady of the land. On the rain-swept morning, Mr. Lincoln and I are on the threshold of a new life. In Springfield, Illinois, the one-time prairie lawyer stands on the back platform of the train that will take us on a slow... 12-day journey to our new life in Washington. Here in Springfield, I have lived a quarter of a century. And here, I have passed from a young to an old man. Here, my children have been born. And here, one is buried. I now leave, not knowing when or whether ever I may return. You all right, Mother?

I'll be fine. May we go inside the car? Of course. What is it, Mother? I keep thinking of some of the things that have been coming to me in the mail, and they terrify me. Now, pay no attention to them. I don't. You know they're just sent by crass. What's that on your life? Ghastly little effigies of you stuck through with pins. Dark hints that you'll never live long enough to be inaugurated. Well, it's all so much nonsense. The train will be starting any minute. Mr. Pinkerton tells me they're taking you off the train for security reasons, that you'll join us again tomorrow. I am afraid. They hate me as much as they hate you. The southerners hate me because they think I'm a traitor to the cause of the South. And because I was born in the South, the rest of the country thinks my sympathies are with the South. One letter even called me a spy. You must pay no attention to such nonsense. Once we get to Washington, take our place in the White House. I beg your pardon, Mr. President.

Forgive me for breaking in like this. What can I do for you, sir? I'm Alan Pinkerton, in charge of your personal safety, and Mrs. Lincoln on this trip to Washington. I know. What is it, Mr. Pinkerton? What seems to be wrong? Well, we've just had word that a band of Confederate thug uglies is planning to blow up the bridges and all the rail connections just this side of Baltimore. They mean to halt the train and take you and Mrs. Lincoln captive after she's rejoined. I don't believe they would dare. Believe it, Mrs. Lincoln, they would. We've checked everything out, sir. What, sir, do you suggest we do? As we approach within, say, 20 miles of Baltimore, you must both board another train. An unmarked, regular passenger train at night, of course. I see.

We'll both then travel on to Washington accompanied only by me and one of my most trusted associates. We will be your only companions and bodyguards. I suppose I must agree, Mr. Pinkerton, reluctantly, but it must, I suppose, be done. Thank you. Thank you very much, Mr. President. It has already begun. How will it all end? It's February, 1862. The war, now ten months old, is going badly for the North. As the Union begins to split apart, the atmosphere each day grows thicker with hatred, rumor, and divided loyalties, especially as they affect the Lincoln family. Although Willie had come down some days before with a slight fever, we do not cancel the White House reception scheduled so long in advance. While my old assistant, Elizabeth, sits with him upstairs in his bedroom, I am dancing at the ballroom.

with my oldest son, Robert Todd Lincoln. You're the very best dancer on the floor. I can hardly keep up with you. Oh, such flattery, Robert. And at only 19. It's true. Look at the other women, even those younger than you, panting and heaving for breath. I am so proud of you, son. Just think, my Robert, a student at Harvard College, tall, handsome, and surprisingly mature. Am I hype? It comes from my father. My good looks, if indeed there are any, from you, dear mother. Well, you know, Robert, and the whole family around me, I think I'm experiencing the first real happiness I have known in months. You headed soon for law school, Willie, wonderful 12 years old, little tad, a delicious nine. And Eddie, you know, 16 had he lived. Yes, mother. In spite of the almost unbearable burdens of the war, I...

You manage to see your father occasionally. The father is a great man, Robert. I know that, mother. Speaking of my father, here he comes. Have I your permission, sir, to dance a waltz with this attractive young lady? My pleasure, sir. May I presume to caution you to handle her with the utmost gentleness? I shall do my best. Thank you, son. There's a young girl over there who looks as though she'd very much like to dance with you. Thank you, Father. Mother, you look especially beautiful tonight. Thank you, Mr. Lincoln. And I like your gown. Excuse me, Mr. Lincoln. Excuse me, Mary. Mr. Elizabeth, what are you doing down here? What is it? Is anything wrong? As soon as this dance is over, please leave the floor discreetly so as not to attract too much attention.

There are too many tongues ready to wag. Follow me up to Willie's bedroom. No! Is Willie all right? He seems to have taken a turn for the worse. His fever seems out of control. Please, Whitey, let nothing happen to Willie. If you must take somebody's life, take mine, but not his. Not his! Sickness within me once more shows its evil, ugly head. demon that possesses me proves its awful power once again. Willie, at the age of 12. Listen to me, Mother. Please, listen to me. The fairest of most frequently taken from a world of trial for some wise purpose that we can't understand. Miss Fortune, they say, come in threes. First it was Eddie, now Willie. Father, do you think we'll be the third? 1863.

Driving from the White House to the soldier's home, the carriage in which I'm traveling is in a grave accident. I suffer a serious head injury. The suffering is almost unbearable. I begin to feel that the third person destined to die in this trilogy of death, after Eddie and Willie, may very well be myself. I recover. Then, in the spring of the following year, 1864, You said you wanted to see me. Oh, I did, Mother. Oh, I did. Well, any concerns that come in election, I... Not directly, Mother. You will be re-elected, Mr. Lincoln. There's no doubt about it. And then you must learn to take things a little easier. You look so worn out. I sometimes fear you won't get on for the next four years. I wouldn't worry about that, Mother. I feel just dandy. I know, but you want to talk to me about the bill from A.T. Stewart in New York. My purchases of gowns and cashmere shawls and millinery. I suppose...

him some debt. $27,000. But you wouldn't want the wife of the President of the United States to be in rags. But, Mother, we are a nation at war. Well, of course. Oh, I forgot to tell you. Our big son's coming home from law school. Robert's spending the holidays with us. Well, we're going to be keeping him, I wonder. His train was due in from Boston almost an hour ago. Come in. Excuse me, Mr. Lincoln. Mary, this telegram just arrived. It's for both of you. It's marked... Edson, something terrible has happened to Robert. I know it. I know it. You must try to be calm, Mother. There came a noise in my head that was there when Eddie died, that thunder. And then when Willie died, just some devil were pulling wires out of my eyes and bolts of lightning were shooting through my brain. Tell me, what has happened to Robert? What has happened to him? Macbeth, realizing that his wife has gone mad, asks her physician, Canst thou not minister to a mind diseased? Raise out the written troubles of the brain?

and with some sweet oblivious antidote cleanse the stuffed bosom of that perilous matter which weighs upon the heart. The doctor answers, Therein the patient must minister to himself. The events of the next few years were to test to the fullest Mary Todd Lincoln's ability to minister to herself. With what success? I'll return shortly. It was Daniel Webster who said, There is nothing so powerful as truth, and often nothing so strange. Another way of saying that truth is stranger than fiction. The sorrowful life of Mary Todd Lincoln would often seem to strain the limits of credulity. But her story is there in the records, sometimes in her own letters. A tragic, heartbreaking chapter in America's past. That same ache in my head that there was when Eddie died, and then when Willie died.

Tell me what happened to Robert. What's happened to him? Is that telegram? What is it, Mother? It says, near accident in Philadelphia Railway Station. Nothing to worry about. I don't believe that. Then it says, arrival Washington slightly delayed. Now, Robert. There, you see? I have had the most uncanny feeling all day long. Something told me I knew something terrible had happened to Robert. But nothing has happened. Nothing to worry about, he says. Besides, he's 22 years old. He can take care of himself. I can't wait till he gets here. What happened in Philadelphia? I can hardly believe that it did happen. Well, there I was, standing at the edge of the railroad platform where you change for the Washington train. Please listen to me, Mother. Well, there was a huge crowd. Suddenly, a passenger hurried past me. I lost my footing.

fell into the very wide gap between the edge of the platform and the wheels of the train. And you said the train had just started to take off? Exactly. For a moment, I was stunned. Then a man reached over, grabbed me by the coat collar, and hauled me back up the safe. Oh, my poor boy, my poor boy. You could have been crushed to death. The man actually did save my life as I started to thank him. To my astonishment, I saw that I had been snatched from a certain death by no less than the great American actor Edwin Booth. Really? I've always been an admirer of his. We must do something to show our appreciation. I already have done that, Father. I've taken the liberty of inviting him to the White House to meet you and Mother sometime in the near future at your convenience, of course. That was most awful of you, Robert. Well, he asked if he might be accompanied by two other actors. And you said? I said yes, considering that the actors were his father, Junius Brutus Booth, and his younger brother, John Wilkes Booth.

I shall look forward to meeting all three of them. And so shall I. Today, 1865. Mr. Lincoln has been re-elected president and the sweet smell of Union victory is in the air. On a day in April, the slaughter ends. The war is over. The violent end. The day is Good Friday, 1865. There are fiends about us. that fly about the heads of all our family, themes that will not allow any of us to escape. Now, you must stop thinking these thoughts. We've had more than our share of personal misery, but now that the war is over, life owes us a little joy. And after all, we do have two wonderful sons. Well, you have no idea what pride I take in, Robert. And when little Tad is near me, my heart overflows with happiness. I know. Mother?

Did you say we were going to the theater tonight? Only if you're up to it, Father. That's one of the few things that have lightened the burdens of these last years. Well, tonight may be a bit of a disappointment for you. How so? Oh, this is a British potboiler. Our American cousin, they call it. And it's with Laura King. Oh, dear. But why not? Frankly, I'd prefer it if it was something like Hamlet or Merchant of Venice with one of the booths. But we'll make the best of it. Won't we, Mother? The events of that fateful night are too well known to repeat. What is it that forces the ones I love most to abandon me? What have I done in my life to deserve this? Four weeks later, I arrive in Chicago to live in what is no more than a boarding house. So different from what I had known as First Lady. The only one I choose to see, and that...

Very rarely. It's my older sister, Elizabeth Edwards. Mary, you can't go on living like this. It doesn't make sense. It does for me, Elizabeth. You haven't left these rooms in over two months. These miserable rooms. You haven't even gone out for a short walk. To expose myself in these black morning clothes to the prying eyes of all my enemies? No, thank you. Enemies? I have enemies everywhere, wherever I go. They're there. And worst of all... Yes? I'm alone. I'm so desperately alone. Only because you choose to be. Had Mr. Lincoln lived, our dreams would have come to something. But now I have nothing. I am nothing. Stop talking that way. I think for a minute that I don't know what they're saying about me. I do read the newspapers, you know. What are they saying, Mary? That I am mad.

The Chicago Tribune, the Springfield Journal, I read them all. They say it is a well-known fact that I have been deranged. That is the word they use. Deranged for years. It's beginning to get dark, Mary. Shouldn't we light the gaslight? Of course not. Don't you touch it. Don't you know why, Lizzie? No, Mary. Because gas is the vile invention of the devil. You didn't know that, did you? That is why I keep so many candles in this room. I see. You may light one candle. Elizabeth, the one on the table there. If you will, dear sister. My demons do not leave me. In July of 1871, my sweet darling Tad, only three months past his 18th birthday, slumps forward in his chair and passes away before the anguished eyes of myself and his brother. Three sons and a husband. Now only Robert remains. He is all I have. But...

I suspect he is up to something odd. What it is exactly, I'm not sure. But whatever it is, he means no good to me. Of that I am certain. That, in a nutshell, Your Honor, is the way things stand with my mother. I love her dearly, but my request, if you will grant it, is the only way out. You say, Mr. Lincoln, that... This all happened after the death of your brother, Tad. I say that it got worse after Tad's death. Since then, she's becoming completely irresponsible in her actions. Some days ago, believing herself to be impoverished, she offered her old clothes for sale right on the streets of New York. How awful. One day she imagines that I, too, am dying. The next that I am trying to poison her. I must remind you, Mr. Lincoln.

Appearing to judge your mother's sanity with you, her only surviving son as chief witness against her, will subject you to the harshest criticism from every quarter. You're aware of that? It's the last thing in the world. The only way she can be restrained from hurting herself. The only method of receiving effective medical treatment. The decision is yours, Mr. Lincoln. Testify that he has examined Mrs. Mary Lincoln. We go. and that he is of the opinion she is insane and a fit subject for hospital treatment. Son, Robert Lincoln, has testified at this hearing in the fullest detail as to his mother's unnatural behavior. I therefore order that Mrs. Lincoln be committed to an institution, and I appoint her son, Robert Todd Lincoln, as conservator of her estate. No, don't do this to me, Robert. You can't betray your mother to her enemies.

Please, Mother, they will help you. You'll see. The Lord will punish you for this. Trust me, Mother, I love you. I would never do anything to hurt you. You will have death as I have to those who are dear to you. Mother, please, I beg of you. You will be cursed as I have been all my life, cursed by the seeds rotting inside you, poisonous seeds of death. I know, my son, for it was I who gave those seeds to you. A month later, I am released. in the custody of my sister Elizabeth. I patiently watch every move that Robert makes, waiting to see my prophecy about him become reality. In 1881, President James A. Garfield appoints him Secretary of War. On a Sunday morning in July, President Garfield is shot at the railroad station in Washington by a crazed office seeker. Standing...

Not more than ten feet away from Garfield when the fatal bullets strike are you, my son. With profound sorrow, the Secretary of War announces to the army that James A. Garfield, President of the United States, died today at Elberon, New Jersey. You see? You two Robert and Al carry our death. Yes, you! At the age of 64, I join my three dead sons and my murdered husband. Now the grave has closed at last, but the legacy of death which I bequeath to my only living son will go on and on and on. 89, President Benjamin Harrison appoints you, my great and distinguished son, ambassador for the court of St. James in Great Britain.

In the following year, your only son, Abraham Lincoln II, succumbs to blood poisoning and dies at the age of 17. You do hear me, don't you? Silence me, nor will the grave ever still my voice. Your son has joined me and his grandfather and his three dead uncles here in the presidential vault in Illinois. And as long as you live, there will always be room. For more. 1901, President McKinley shot and killed by a lunatic anarchist in the city of Buffalo, New York. And where are you this time? As you had been to Garfield, three presidents have fallen under the bullets of a captain. Your own father, McKinley. 26, Robert Todd Lincoln. Dead of a cerebral hemorrhage at age 83. You.

are one of us now. The newspapers write glowingly of you. Call you your father's son. But we know better, don't we? No one knows better than we that you were the son of your mother. The final internment of Robert Todd Lincoln took place in March 1928 in the Arlington National Cemetery near the nation's capital. Associated so tragically... And so eerily, with the deaths of three martyred presidents of the United States, Robert Todd Lincoln now lies buried close to the grave of a fourth, that of John Fitzgerald Kennedy. I shall return shortly. ...you have been listening to were gleaned from the more than 600 letters of Mrs. Lincoln which have been preserved. They are the agonizing evidence of a woman who came to the White House at a tragic hour of her nation's history and was destroyed by the experience.

Was she, as she fancied herself, a carrier of death? And if she was, did her son inherit this legacy? Those are questions you will have to answer for yourself. Our cast included Marion Seldes, John Beale, Carol Tytel, and Lloyd Batista. The entire production was under the direction of Hyman Brown. He died some years ago. I could find out more if you're interested. No, no, no, thank you. I was just... mildly curious. The next night was my last in Trieste. I had some reports to complete and I was ready for bed before midnight. I had an early plane. My eyes had just fallen asleep. Where was I? Certainly not in the hotel room. It appeared to be a kind of cave. Get down. Get down, Gavry. What? Get down behind that rock. Hey, you're that man. Get down behind that rock or I'll shoot you here and now.

Marshall inviting you to return to our mystery theater for another adventure in the macabre. Till next time. Pleasant dreams.

End of transcriptBack to the beginning ↑