Skip to content
On Air
All channelsAll
CBS Radio Mystery Theater artwork

From the CBS Radio Mystery Theater collection

Diamond Dotty

Episode 1394November 18, 198245 min 31 secTranscript

Writer: Himan Brown

The written record

Read the transcript

Read along with the recording · About 30 min to read

The CBS Radio Mystery Theater presents... I'm Tammy Grimes. They say diamonds are a girl's best friend. Of course, when they say it, they refer to what diamonds represent. Wealth, power, luxury. However, there can be a time when a diamond, a hard and glittering diamond, can acquire a personality. And yes, even life of its own. Of course, when you have life, you may also find death.

Are there any more chops?

Yep.

Madam.

Nope.

It's time we had a talk. You can't hide behind that wall of food any longer.

What are you talking about?

You can't fortify yourself behind a hill of flesh anymore. You've got to face the world.

And do what?

I don't know. Rob, kill, swindle, whatever's necessary, but get on in this life.

Our mystery drama, Diamond Dotty, was written especially for the Mystery Theater by Sam Dann and starred Terry Keane. And I'll be back shortly with Act One.

What did a certain Mr. Lewis say? Those long, dull, monotonous years of middle-age prosperity or middle-aged adversity are excellent campaigning weather for the devil.

Yes. The devil's always lurking about, isn't he? Ever on the alert for an opportunity.

Doesn't he ever take any time off?

Well, the year is about 1880. We are in a small western frontier town, in a lobby such as it is of the Excelsior Hotel. The Excelsior is an extremely accommodating establishment which caters to a great many needs. You can get a room. You can get a drink, a meal. A game of chance. And even the companionship of a sympathetic lady. It is late of the Saturday afternoon. And the place is going, as they say, at full blast.

Suddenly, someone notices a woman standing in the door.

Hey, who's a pretty girl?

Oh, yes, sir. What a looking girl.

There is quiet. She is, indeed, a different sort of woman. She is, perhaps, in her late twenties, with lovely, luminous blue eyes. Spun golden hair seems to form a halo about her beautiful, delicate face. But she seems to be troubled and tired, frail, careworn, vulnerable.

Ma'am, are you all right?

I'm still...

Here, now, you let me have that bag.

No. Nobody will take this bag from me. Do you hear? Nobody.

Now, ma'am, you be careful with that pistol.

Now, let's everybody be careful.

You don't look so good, ma'am. A drink of water?

Water, please, yes.

Hey, Jerry, get her a glass of water.

The gun is so heavy.

Hey, somebody catch her. She's fainted.

No, no, easy now. Set her down on this chair, right here. Now, one of you girls, you run upstairs and get some smelling salts or something.

You just set it on down right there beside her.

Oh, I can't get it loose. She's clutching it to her.

Why? Why did we come here, Bobby? Why? I don't want to be rich. I just want to be happy and I want to be in love.

She is out of her mind.

Who's got that water?

Bobby? Where'd you go, Bobby?

Now, you just drink this, ma'am.

What?

Drink the water.

The water?

Easy, ma'am, easy.

Oh. No, don't take it away. Oh, it's been so long.

Yeah, that's why you have to go slow now. Now, that's plenty.

Please, more.

No, no, that's all for now. You can't drink it all at once.

What? What place is this?

You're safe and sound in the Excelsior Hotel, Drywell, Arizona.

My bag. Where's my bag?

You're still holding on to it.

Where's my gun?

Now, now, somebody pick up that Colt 44.

Hmm. Smells like it's been fired recently.

Oh. Hey. Hey, you got six empty shells in there.

What happened? My horse. I think I left him outside.

It's my horse.

Oh, I see. Now, Tommy, go on out and bring him around to the stable.

Oh, thank you. You're all so kind. You're so generous.

Well, ma'am, you're in God's country now. You ain't back east any longer.

How did you know I was from the east?

Well, ma'am, I guess the same way you could tell I'm from the west. Just as soon as I opened my mouth.

Oh, my name's Joe Selig, and I own this hotel.

I'm Harriet Truesdale. Miss or Mrs?

Mrs. I'm Harriet Truesdale. Mrs.

Mrs. Truesdale. It's kind of noisy place on Saturday night.

Oh, that's all right. I haven't slept in three days and three nights. I'll sleep.

Uh, Mary Lou, you want to escort Miss Truesdale here upstairs and help her out, huh?

Yeah, come with me, honey.

Oh, wait. I have to do something first. I have to do something. Bobby, uh, told me to do something. What did Bobby tell me?

Oh, well, oh, the diamonds.

Diamonds? Which? Which diamonds, ma'am?

Bobby put them in here. Just before he died, Bobby put them in oh, in here.

You mean that sack's got diamonds?

I'm going to safeguard those diamonds, he said, to a safe. Yes, I must put them in a safe so that Carling and Olsen can't steal them.

Carling and Olsen? You mean Bud Carling and Swan Olsen?

Why, there's a reward out for them. Do you know where they are?

Yes.

Well, come on, let's get the sheriff and form a posse. Where are they?

They're, they're dead.

Dead? Near the mine.

Which mine?

Well, how do you know they're dead?

How do I know?

Yes, ma'am, how do you know?

I killed them.

You killed Bud Carling and Swan Olsen?

With the Colt 44 with Bobby's gun. I killed them both.

How?

No. No, no, I can't talk about it. Not now. Please. I'm so tired. And I'm so frightened.

Uh, Mary Lou, uh, help her upstairs, huh? You come with me, honey.

No, not until I keep my promise to Bobby. He says safeguard the diamonds.

Your diamonds are safe, Miss Truesdale.

No. They're after me.

Who's after you?

Bud Carling and Swan Olsen.

But, but didn't you just say you killed them?

Did I?

The, the gun. Well, the, Bobby's gun. Yes. It's empty. It's empty.

Well, ma'am, I told you it was empty.

I must have emptied it. Yes, now I remember. I surprised them. I pointed this gun at them, and I kept pulling the trigger and pulling the trigger till it just clicked empty. I, uh, I killed them. I confess I killed them. Will I hang?

Well, ma'am, the governor of the territory will give you a reward.

You see, we had pitched our tent right near the mine on the claim, and he had gone out. Bobby had gone out to dig, and he had left the gun inside the tent with me. I could grab some water. My head is starting to ache. I'm sure now, but not too much. Oh, thank you.

Now, they, they'd followed us, Olsen and Carling, and they they just shot him down.

Yes?

They were searching through his pocket for, you see, they didn't see me. I came crawling out of the tent, and I just started to shoot. I didn't stop shooting until the gun went, the gun went.

Now, now, now, don't you worry, ma'am. Everything's gonna be all right now. Now, you just let one of the girls help you get upstairs. Mary Lou?

You come with me, honey. Now, you get some rest, and you're just gonna feel fine.

No, first, first, I must safeguard the diamonds.

But like I told you, Miss Truesdale, them diamonds are absolutely safe. Now, nobody's gonna steal them.

But how do I know? You're asking me to trust you, aren't you?

Well, I guess I am.

Well, three days ago, I would have trusted you. Three days ago, I would have trusted anybody. Everybody. But now, all I trust is this. Bobby's Colt 44. And I can't even trust it till I, till I... Will somebody please, please lend me six cartridges?

Now, ma'am, there is no need.

There is every need. I learned about this world. I learned a lesson I'll never forget. Because it was written in blood. Now, will somebody sell me six cartridges?

Well, all right, I'd consider it an honor, ma'am, if you'd take it from me.

Oh, thank you, sir. You are a gentleman. You see, these are my friends. My true friends.

All right. Now I'm ready for anything. For anybody. Sir, do you have a safe in this hotel?

Safe? Well, no, but I got a drawer in my desk that I can lock.

A drawer?

Well, yeah, you can hold on to the key.

No, but I need a safe. A big iron safe. Is there a bank?

Yes, ma'am. The farmer, cattleman's, and miner's.

All right, I'll go there right now.

Well, you can't.

Why not?

Well, it's closed.

Closed?

Well, it's Saturday night, and he'll be closed until Monday morning.

But he can't be closed.

Well, them are the hours for regular business, ma'am.

This isn't regular business. Who's the banker?

John Manning.

All right, call him on the telephone.

The what?

The telephone. You've heard of the telephone?

Well, no, ma'am, I can't say as I have.

Do you really mean there's no one here that's ever heard of the telephone?

What is a telephone, ma'am?

It was invented a few years ago by a man named Bell, and you can talk over wires.

I don't believe it.

It works.

Well, now, maybe it does, maybe it don't, but, well, we ain't got none of them out here yet.

I must see this Mr. Manning. Where does he live?

You mean you want to go over there now?

I don't have a moment to lose.

But you can't do it.

Why not?

Well, because right now he's sitting down to his supper, and I tell you, ma'am, you don't disturb Big John Manning in the midst of a meal. I mean, you just don't.

I will wait till he's finished.

But, Miss Truesdale, Big John sits down to his supper at six o'clock, and he don't get up until midnight.

Then I'll talk to him at midnight.

But he won't talk to you.

Why not?

Because one second past midnight, it'll be Sunday, and Big John will not talk about business on the Sabbath.

Where does he live?

That's the house. Now, we'll see.

Ma'am, will you just listen to me?

Not you, you sure. Oh, here.

Ma'am, oh, ma'am, you just hadn't ought to be doing this.

Yes, is this the home of John Manning, the banker?

What?

Yes. It's Joseph Selig, and Tom Bourne, and Hank, and the whole town's here.

Why?

Is Mr. Manning in? I have business to transact with him.

Oh, no. Oh, no, he will not talk about business at home.

Will you tell him it's a matter of life and death?

I can't tell him anything. Not while he's...

He's eating his supper.

Are you his wife?

Yes, ma'am. But even I won't disturb him while he's digesting his food.

You won't?

Well, I will.

Now, ma'am, you can't come in.

Please, ma'am.

Is that the side?

Please. Now, you can't. Now, in there, you can't.

Mr. John Manning?

Now, who are you?

Oh, uh, excuse me, sir. But I have never seen anyone eat like that.

Now, madam, who are you?

Oh, that's... Food piled on the table. It's only set for one.

Madam, what is your name?

My name is Mrs. Harriet Truesdale. And what is the meaning of this unseemly interruption?

I'm here on a matter of business. Call at my office Monday morning, promptly at 9 a.m.

But, sir...

Good evening, Cleo.

Sir, forgive me for interrupting you.

I could never forgive you. Now, have the goodness to leave.

No, not till you hear me out. I have in this bag... A hundred diamonds. Now, each is worth at least $1,000. I own a mine on which can be found hundreds. And for all I know, thousands like them. I require the services of a banker. Not on Monday morning, but at this very moment. Now, tell me, sir, are you that banker?

My dear Mrs. Truesdale, I am...

At your service?

They say money talks, but diamonds shout.

Ah, Mrs. Harriet Truesdale. Came into Drywell, Arizona one evening alone, frightened and friendless. Two of those conditions have already been altered. While she still may be frightened, she is obviously no longer alone and friendless. But other changes are in store, quite a few. And some shall occur in act two, shortly.

We like to think of the Wild West as a particularly American experience. But wasn't it really a variation on an older theme, with its heroes and heroines? Good guys and bad guys. Wasn't it all very much like the days of chivalry in Europe? While the hotel Excelsior in Drywell, Arizona could hardly be mistaken for the court of King Arthur. Still, wasn't Mrs. Harriet Truesdale a damsel in distress? And wasn't every silver miner and cowboy willing and anxious to be her champion?

What is it you would have me do for you, Mrs. Truesdale?

Mr. Manning, I want you to place these diamonds in your safe. At once.

My dear Mrs. Truesdale, your slightest wish is my command.

We'll just put the diamonds inside, please. It comes all the way from Denver. Take them from me. I shall give you a receipt. And please let me see you place them in the safe and lock the door. Of course a receipt is hardly necessary, since the whole town is outside gaping and gawking at this transaction. Put them away, please? Yes, yes, of course. And now the door that could withstand the volley from a battery of howitzers. Cheryl's swung shut. Soon I know the combination is turned.

Oh, Bobby. Bobby, darling, I did just as you told me. Now, now I simply must just sleep.

Sleep? Mary Lou, now you and the girls, now you take her back to the hotel and put her to bed. You all come with me, honey.

Good morning, honey.

Oh, is it morning already?

Yes, but not the morning you think it is. It's the following morning. I swear, honey, you were that done in. You slept twice around the clock.

Oh, no.

Yes. And now you're thinking today's Sunday. And it isn't?

No, ma'am. It's Monday.

Oh, my goodness. I have to get up.

All right. Oh, first. First, have some breakfast. See? I brought you some coffee and bacon wheat cakes.

Goodness, I am starved. You know, you're quite a little lady, Miss Truesdale, you know?

Well, why? What did I do?

Well, the way you went and faced everyone down. And those are all tough hombres. I mean, especially that fat John Manning.

Mary Lou, shall I tell you a secret? I was petrified. I never spoke like that to anybody. And it's just that, I don't know, I guess I was out of my head.

Oh, yeah. Oh, you had a bad time.

Well, I really don't want to think about it. I'm just... poor Bobby. Oh, oh, now why? Why did we have to come out here? You know, we'll make millions, he said. I suppose now we will, from that mine. But you see, he won't ever spend a penny of it.

Well, I guess them things just can't be helped.

Why didn't we stay home in Philadelphia? I could have done that. I don't know. I don't know. I don't know. Why did he feel driven to... Oh, well, there's no use of that now. How am I ever going to manage alone?

You know something, Miss Truesdale. You're managing pretty good as it is.

What have I done?

Well, just to begin, you gunned down them two desperados.

I was out of my head.

And then, of course, for me, the real brilliant thing you done was the way you went about getting them diamonds into Fat John Manning's safe.

What did I do that was so... Oh, look. Had you gone to see old John all alone without no one knowing and giving him that sack of diamonds... Well, well, what?

He might have stolen them from you.

Stolen? Are you saying he's a thief?

Well, is he or isn't he? Well, it ain't always that clean cut.

But he's such an honorable looking man.

Huh? Look. Oh, and that Joe Selleck. He wouldn't mind trying to find a way to separate you from them diamonds neither.

I find that impossible to believe.

Listen, anything you can think of ain't impossible. But the way you worked it, you done the entire transaction in front of the whole town. Everybody's seen them diamonds. Everybody knows where they are and how they got there. So, you're safe.

Uh, the safekeeping? Of your diamonds? I'm sure they're secure enough, Mr. Manning. Uh, may I inquire as to your plans?

Is there a telegraph office nearby?

Yes, 20 miles south. Station at Sadler's Gulch.

Well, I would like to send a wire.

The stagecoach leaves at noon every day. And I'm sure the driver would accommodate you. Would you be good enough to handle it for me?

Why, it would be my pleasure.

Thank you. I wish to send a wire to a Mr. Edmund Napier. Uh, that's N-A-P-I-E-R. Yes? At 21 Delray Street, uh, in San Francisco. Uh, please come to Dry Well, Arizona to appraise diamond samples as per agreement with my husband. All right, I have that. I'm sending $500 for expenses and partial payment of fee. Oh, and sign Harriet Truesdale.

Oh, well, this should be wired from Sadler's Gulch this very afternoon.

Thank you, Mr. Manning. Now, uh, who, uh, who is this Mr. Napier?

Oh, Professor Napier, the leading authority on diamonds and precious stones.

Oh! He emigrated here from South Africa.

South Africa. Oh, my goodness, I understand that has become a virtual El Dorado for diamonds.

Oh, yes. He was quite famous back there. That's how Bobby heard of him.

And your husband knew him?

Well, poor Bobby, he was a geologist. He heard of the fantastic diamond discoveries in South Africa, and he said to me, why, Harriet, it's the same kind of desert terrain we have in the American Southwest. Why, aren't there diamonds all over Arizona and New Mexico and California? So, he started a correspondence with Professor Napier, and they became friends.

Uh, how long should it take? How long should it take for the professor to arrive from San Francisco?

I'd say a week, uh, perhaps less. I hope the time won't hang heavy on your hands, Mrs. Truesdale.

Well, it doesn't really matter. Without Bobby, there isn't any time.

Are there any more?

Yep.

Nope.

What are you saying, Jessica?

I'm saying it's time we had a talk, John.

About what?

About the future.

What about it?

Well, from where I'm sitting, it looks as if we don't have one.

Jessica, what has gotten into you? I never heard you talk like this.

I know, it sounds strange to me, too. But it has to be said. John, we are on our way to the poorhouse.

Jessica, are you feeling well?

I'm overstating the case, but not by much. You and Joe Selleck, the two of you, you bet on Dry Well. You've already lost that bet. The railway. The railway went to Sadler's Gulch. Now, see here, Jessica. One by one, the silver mines are playing out. There's not enough grass for cattle or even sheep. There's not enough rain for farming. In ten years, maybe less, this is going to be a ghost town.

Jessica, you are unnecessarily alarmed.

You took all my money, John. You invested it in this town. Well, this town is doomed.

Well, you have absolutely no idea about how business should be run.

And will you please bring out the rest of the chocolate?

Nope.

Nope? You can't hide behind all that food any longer. It won't protect you. No, sir. Not when the crash comes.

So what are you going to do?

What can I do? There's a fortune in diamonds in your safe. Now, what plans do you have for them?

What plans could I have?

You mean you haven't even thought about it?

Yes, I have thought about it.

And what about Joe Selleck? What ideas does he have?

I haven't said anything to Joe Selleck.

Has he said anything to you?

No.

Well, don't you think it's time the two of you started talking?

About what?

Somewhere, not far from here, there's a field or a mine that's full of diamonds. Now, why can't you get your hands on them?

I... I am trying to think.

Well, think faster. Think harder. Who do you have to outwit? Some silly little slip of a woman?

John Manning, are you suggesting that we attempt to steal this poor widow woman's property?

I'm not suggesting we attempt. I'm suggesting we succeed, Joe.

You know, I always suspected you were a thief in your heart, John.

I may well have been. It's just a timid... Now, honestly, it's for policy. If we do not succeed in separating this lady from her property, we will not survive.

Well, I'm game. Just tell me how.

There must be a key to this.

Oh, good morning, Miss Truesdale.

Good morning, Mr. Selleck, Mr. Manning.

Why, where are you bound for this beautiful morning, miss?

I just thought I'd take a little ride.

May I inquire, what are your plans?

To sell it.

You mean you don't choose to operate?

Oh, what do I know about mines or diamonds? And besides, my heart wouldn't be in it.

Well, now, you plan to sell? Oh, that would be fine. Now, uh... Well, that's why I'm waiting for Mr. Edmund Napier. He can judge the grade of the diamonds and determine the value of the fields, you see. At least that was what Bobby thought.

Yes, yes, yes, yes. Sounds like an eminently... sensible idea. I'll see you gentlemen later on.

Of course. Good morning, Mrs. Truesdale.

Good morning.

Well, John, we'd better start a-thinking.

I know. Now, the longer we wait, the harder it's going to be. Especially after this Napier fella gets here and tells her how valuable the place is.

What did you say?

I know, I know what you said. What's the key?

Napier. He's the key.

Yes, how?

Ah, look here. Suppose Napier were to look at the diamonds and say they were of inferior quality. Not worth the trouble.

Yes, mm-hmm. I suppose she would release the rights to the property.

But why should Napier come to such a conclusion?

Well, he might.

Oh?

She says she never met him, but only corresponded with him.

I see. Mm-hmm.

Professor Napier of our own.

Yes, sure. Now, all we need is a very smooth confidence operator.

Just a man in mind. And I think I know where I can find him, too.

Now, wait. Now, we may have a problem. Now, the real professor may show up in the middle of everything and spoil the show.

That's impossible. I've already taken care of...

John Manning, I never knew you went in for any rough stuff.

That wasn't necessary. He can't show up.

That's what he did. Or didn't do.

What is that passage from the book? A certain man... A certain man went from Jerusalem to Jericho and fell among thieves. Look at our own Mrs. Harriet Truesdale. She has certainly fallen into what can only be described as a nest of vipers. And the worst kind of that, because these vipers are the highly respectable kind. Well, we shall see who gets bitten in a tree shortly. Diamond cut diamond, said the playwright John Ford in his 17th century drama called The Lover's Melancholy. And we seem to be setting up just such a confrontation. Is Mrs. Harriet Truesdale about to be swindled out of her diamond mine? The odds would seem to be against the little lady. But most of the smart money also bet on Goliath against David.

Now, who is our man going to be, John?

A fellow named Harry, the actor.

Oh, yeah? Well, he is an actor. When can he be here?

I'm going to Sadler's Gulch this afternoon to talk with him. Call me Professor Napier. I must begin to live the part. Napier, a professor from South Africa. A geologist. Explosive diamond. Oh, yes, I have studied up on the field.

Good. Now, what do you want me to tell her about the diamonds?

I want you to say they're worthless.

Well, that's a problem. Our husband was a geologist. He convinced her that they were valuable stones.

Oh, stone. That's Professor Napier. And if they're worthless, why do you want them? Why do you want the title to her claim?

All you have to do is convince her that the diamonds are worthless. You're the producer and director of this little drama. How soon can you be ready?

Give me another day to read up on diamonds and become an expert.

Ask me to come here, Mr. Manning?

Yes, ma'am. Yes, ma'am. Please, please, Mrs. Truesdale. I want you to verify that your property is... To be in order?

Yes, everything is here. May I put it all back?

Why, of course.

Mrs. Truesdale, Mary Lou said you'd be here. This telegram arrived for you.

Oh, for me?

Yeah, the stagecoach driver brought it from Sadler's Gulch.

Oh, dear Mrs. Truesdale, I shall arrive in Dry Well on Tuesday the 18th. Oh, that's... Signed, Edmund Napier, the fabulous... Edmund Napier. At last, I'm going to meet him.

Mrs. Truesdale.

Professor Napier.

Ah, you're just what I imagined. Just as poor Bobby described you.

And you, Professor. You look the way I had imagined, too.

Oh, really? How?

You look like a man who would sacrifice everything for love.

Ah, you flatter me. But you must tell me everything about Bobby. We never met face to face, but... so much and said so much to each other. I felt we were such good and close friends.

Well, there isn't much to say, Professor. He simply couldn't think of anything besides diamonds.

Yes, I know, I know. I'm that way myself. He was looking for a certain type of terrain, certain weather conditions.

And he found the correct combination, stake to claim. And then we just came upon them. A field of... A field of diamonds.

Ah. But a pair of desperados came across the trail. They attacked him and killed him.

Oh, no.

But they didn't notice me. But I had Bobby's gun. And I really can't talk about it anymore.

Well, I'm sure you've been asked this question before. But what are your plans?

I want to go back east. I shall sell the mine. I will accept your word for the value. I wish I could just walk away and forget about it. But it's all I have in the world.

I understand. When shall you start your appraisal?

My dear, there is no time like the present. So, maybe I'll...

Mr. Manning? What is it, Professor? What do you have to say?

My dear, do you have all the letters I wrote to Bobby?

No. Oh, not all.

Well, then, perhaps you may not be aware that I kept writing over and over again. That I simply could not believe diamonds could be found on the North American continent.

Oh, but Bobby insisted.

Well, in North America, you do not have the same calcareous deposits. You do not have the identical clay masses necessary for the formation of...

But Bobby said...

Yes, Bobby. You couldn't talk him out of it. Now, look here. These are diamonds. It's true that they could shine more brilliantly, but that's all a matter of just cutting the facets. You know that.

But these aren't diamonds.

Well, what are they then?

Well, my dear, they're almost diamonds.

Almost? Perhaps that is why poor Bobby was fooled.

Almost diamonds? These, all of these are what is known as bort, impure crystals. They cannot be used. They cannot be used for jewelry. They, unfortunately, have no value.

No, they are diamonds. They are diamonds. Please say they're diamonds.

Yes, I would give anything to be able to say that they were, Mrs. Truesdale. And Bobby... Bobby, he died for nothing.

Mrs. Truesdale, where are you going?

I don't know the first thing about diamonds, Mr. Manning. I just read some of the pamphlet.

Remarkable. Well, what happens now?

Now? I will have to do to give her anything. I shall walk away into the field.

But they're supposed to be phony. Why should we want to buy them? Won't she smell a rat?

Not this rat. She's coming in now. Now, you take your cues from me.

Good evening, Mrs. Truesdale.

Good evening. Thank you. I, I had a most terrible shock.

Yes, I can imagine.

I suppose I always knew deep down that there couldn't be any diamonds.

Now, Miss Truesdale, don't say that.

I thought I was a wealthy woman. I had all those diamonds. But I have nothing. How am I going to pay my bill?

Oh, now, you just forget about it.

No, I'm sorry. I can't. I'm back in the real world now. You see? Nothing but the clothes on my back.

Oh, no.

Do I?

Yes. They're even now reposed on the fields in which they were found. Worthless crystals in barren deserts.

Now, you don't have to worry about that.

Well, you never know. They have no value to anyone.

It might be to me.

Oh, yeah, yeah. Now, perhaps we might buy them from you.

No. No, thank you.

Well, why not?

It's a business.

It isn't business. It's charity, and you know it.

Mrs. Truesdale, you let me put all my cards on the table. I'm not sure I believe this Napier fellow.

Why not?

Well, your husband was also a geologist. He was convinced the place...

But Napier examined...

But Napier examined these. They weren't real. That was his opinion. Bobby thought differently.

Yes, poor Bobby. And I have to choose between American Bobby Truesdale and this foreigner. Why don't we get another opinion?

No, I don't think so.

But why?

I just want to get away from it. I hate it. I hate diamonds, the whole idea.

Then sell it. We're willing to take this.

Oh, please.

We're serious. We'll give you... Five thousand... Make it ten. Ten thousand dollars. And go back home where you belong. Yeah, and teach music. You'll meet another fine young man.

Oh, please. I think I'm going to cry. Why are you so good to me?

Hello there, Mary Lou.

Oh, Sheriff. Is Joe Selleck around?

No, he went off into the desert somewhere inspecting a claim. We've got to get together a posse.

But Bud Carlin and Squint Olsen are dead again.

No, you're making a mistake. Bud and Squint are dead. They were killed, oh, let's see, a week and a half ago.

Oh, yeah? Then how could they have held up the stagecoach last night?

Well, that can't be, Sheriff. Is John Manning about? I've got bad news for him, too.

John's off with Joe Selleck.

Well, it was his cash that Bud and Squint robbed off the coach.

John's in the desert with Joe Selleck. They're partners in a claim. But if Bud Carlin and Squint Olsen are alive, well, then, then...

Mary Lou, what you mumbling about?

Well, then, they didn't kill her husband, which means she told us all a lie. And if that's true, well, then, then maybe that whole story about the diamonds.

What diamonds?

Well, see, this young lady, she came in here about two, three weeks ago and says her husband was bushwhacked. By Carlin and Olsen. And she shot them both.

What lady?

Well, she told us all this story about a diamond mine.

Diamonds?

Uh-huh.

A blonde lady?

That's right.

A very pretty lady?

Oh, beautiful lady.

Why, that is Diamond Dottie.

Who?

She's been working that swindle all throughout the Southwest.

She has?

Sure. Well, she gets herself a bag full of phony diamonds and she spins this yarn about a diamond mine.

She does?

Why, in the past two years, she must have made herself $100,000 easy. How much did Joe and John bite for?

Well, here, $10,000.

My goodness, how can grown men fall for such a swindle? Everybody knows there ain't no diamond mines in Arizona.

Oh. Mary Lou, what you laughing at?

This lady, something from the goodness of their heart. You just went and restored my flickering faith in human nature.

A rather extreme and cynical view, but after all, Mary Lou lived in rather extreme and cynical times. What's the biblical saying? I was a stranger and he took me in. Sometimes that happens all too literally. Well, you and I, we're not strangers. And we shall meet again shortly. All that glitters isn't gold and everything that sparkles doesn't always... Turned out to be a diamond either. They say you can't cheat an honest man, but the problem is, where can you find one? Diogenes prowled the streets of Athens incessantly with a lamp, vainly trying to encounter him. The truth of the matter, if there is a little bit of good, even in the worst of us, then there has to be just a tiny bit of bad, even in the best of us. Our cast included Terry Keane, Carol Teitel, Earl Hammond, and Bernard Grant. The entire production was under the direction of Hyman Brown.

Preview of our next...

Get him down. But his type is like mercury. Quicksilver. He kept smiling and nodding his head. Suddenly I realized he wasn't listening to me. So I started listening to myself. Do you know what I sounded like? A bitter, frustrated, middle-aged woman. I ran out of there at two o'clock in the morning. I got in my car and started... I started to drive. I had to get away quickly. Do you know why?

You wanted to kill him.

I saw myself killing him. I saw him lying dead at my feet. And when I was walking down Decatur and reached Howell, I turned my head to the right, and there he was, lying dead on the pavement, just as if I had wished him there. And that's what helped. It was just as you had diagnosed.

Radio Mystery Theater was sponsored and powered by White Westinghouse Appliance Company.

End of transcriptBack to the beginning ↑