Skip to content
On Air
All channelsAll
CBS Radio Mystery Theater artwork

From the CBS Radio Mystery Theater collection

Down the Garden Path

Episode 1179April 1, 198142 min 55 secTranscript

Writer: Himan Brown

The written record

Read the transcript

Read along with the recording · About 23 min to read

CBS Radio Mystery Theater presents... It is essentially good to have those who insist that man is basically evil, of each. To complicate matters further, we have those who contend that good and evil are not absolute. That they change with circumstance and cases. We may all be somewhat wiser.

Are you sure you really want this, Alfredo?

Who would refuse immortality?

Consider, to achieve it, you will have to die tonight.

Of course.

You have to die in order to become immortal. But if you're dead, what good does it do you?

I'll be immortal.

But you won't know it.

What's the difference? It'll be true.

It was written especially for the Mystery Theater by Sam Dann, and stars Gordon Gould and Mandel Kramer. I'll be back shortly.

Repetuate themselves in office. That's what Niccolo Machiavelli said in the year 1500. And the reason we quote him, and why he is to become the hero, or the central character of our story, is because his philosophy is so modern and so applicable to our present day. Therefore, once again, we validate the old adage, the more things change, the more they remain the same. Or as the French would put it, Plus ça change, plus c'est la même chose.

I would just assume you didn't mention the French.

Or the Spaniards.

Or the Germans. These are the predatory foreigners who continue to rape and pillage my beloved Italy.

Beloved. Does that word seem strange on the lips of Niccolo Machiavelli? Why? Have I not devoted my entire life to the service of Florence, my city? And Italy, my country? I was never a rich man, or even a great one. I was never more than secretary to the ruling council of Florence. And I was always being called on to perform extra little duties.

Please be seated, Niccolo.

Thank you, Excellency. And how is the newlywed?

Newly delighted with my newly found happiness, Excellency. And the beautiful bride, Mona Marietta. She glows.

Ah, Niccolo. To abandon your nuptial couch to undertake a confidential mission.

I am ever at your Excellency's command.

You must proceed at once to Imola. A special envoy to Cesare.

To his usual mischief.

He insists. Listen, German mercenaries. And hire his condottieri to protect the...

I seem to recall, sire, that we had signed a contract with him to that effect.

And you should also recall that each of us has broken it in the past. As it may have suited our convenience.

Yes, Excellency.

Now, Borgia tells us we must assume the salaries of...

His soldiers. Or he will declare war on Florence.

And when he asks about the money, Your Excellency...

Promise him nothing. And refuse him nothing. Buy for us the most precious commodity in the world.

I am sent as ambassador by Don Piero Soderini, President of the ruling council of the Republic of Florence. And I am expected to match wits with the illustrious Duke Cesare Borgia. One of the most ruthless and powerful nobles in Italy. A man of genius, whose cunning and guile have already become legendary. Needless to say, the Duke saw through me at once.

Ah, Secretary, you've brought me the money.

The money, Your Grace? From the Republic of Florence to pay the wages of 1,000 lancers and 3,500 infantry.

No, Your Grace.

Why have you come here?

To ascertain the nature of your demands.

The nature of my demands has been crystal clear these past 18 months.

Perhaps if we might review them.

No matter how many times we review them, they shall still... still remain the same.

And yet, Your Grace, isn't it a fact that nothing remains the same? Time is constantly altering circumstances.

And what has time altered in our circumstances, Secretary?

Florence has signed a treaty with King Louis of France.

I am aware of it.

He will come to our defense if we are attacked.

Our? Isn't it possible that my artillery wreck the city before his troops could arrive? I offered him half the loot of Siena.

I can only repeat a treaty.

All you have given King Louis is a piece of paper. You can send him a wagon train loaded with gold, silver. His share. The bones of the city of Florence.

Mandeville. The council and informant. I have no authority.

Of course, Your Grace. The truce. Is your informant positive? Is the council aware of your very strong feelings in this matter?

No. Secretary, I would prefer if you would leave for Florence the very first thing in the morning. And convey those feelings in person. For my benefit, Don Piero. The kinsman of his. This young Emilio de Forli. The council must decide whether or not he is to get it. He is asking us for a favor. If I earn our debt, pay for it. Great importance, but we cannot dismiss it lightly.

Why did Duke Cesare Borgia want Alfredo Petrucci tried and hanged for murder? There was no connection between them that I could see. And the relationship between himself and his slain kinsman, Emilio de Forli, was so distant and tenuous that it was almost non-existent. Finally, the council arrived at a decision.

Niccolo, we have decided to arrest Alfredo Petrucci for the murder of Emilio de Forli.

Why? Why? I see. I see that it may be desirable to appease Cesare Borgia by hanging Alfredo Petrucci. If you are so considered.

There is another possibility. May I speak freely, Don Piero? While the people may be angry with Borgia, the council for giving in to him. In the long run, Borgia is ahead. It was that I must find a way. Until I could discover just why Borgia wanted Alfredo Petrucci's life, I could see no way to solve the problem. Indeed, I didn't even know what the problem was.

One day, Caterina di Modena, one of the most beautiful women in Italy, and the mistress of Cesare Borgia.

Messere Machiavelli, so kind of you to come.

What man could possibly refuse a summons from the queen of beauty?

May I offer you refreshment?

I would rather you offered me enlightenment.

Alfredo Petrucci. How does this concern you, Mona Caterina?

May I rely on your honor?

I love him.

Petrucci?

I love him desperately.

Borgia wants him dead?

I simply do not love Cesare. He abandons me weeks, months, even a year at a time to attend to his tiresome never-ending military conquests. If I wanted to live without love, I would have taken the veil. Now understand the nature of Duke Cesare's feeling against Alfredo.

Oh, I told Cesare that Alfredo means nothing to me.

But you said you loved him.

Of course I love him. I love his handsome face and his curly hair and his slender and supple body. But in a few years, these shall be gone. His hair will fall out. His face will become lined and bloated. His body shall run to fat. Then what will be left for me to love?

He's the man I shall love forever.

You'll also grow old and bald and bloated?

Yes. Why, Cesare wanted Alfredo.

Now that I know, I see it doesn't matter.

Why not?

Because it changes nothing.

Die in any event.

Oh, no, no. Please save him.

How?

Well, surely a way will occur to you.

You give me too much credit.

Perhaps I am not giving you enough inspiration.

Inspiration?

Yes. And the most beautiful gardens. Shall we go outside and stroll through them? Their loveliness should inspire all sorts of ideas.

I should find that delightful.

The roses are in bloom. What a heavenly smell.

Sari Machiavelli. You would not take it very well. Do you have the advantage of a poor, distraught, lovelorn lady?

No, Mona Caterina, never. And you promise me, you give me your word that you will save poor Alfredo Petrucci?

Save him?

Yes, Messere, save him.

Let me say this. I shall make him immortal.

Immortal?

Immortal. It's the best I can do.

Is it good enough?

Oh, yes, it is good enough. And now let us walk down this path. It leads to a most quiet, lovely, and private little bower.

Donna strolled down a garden. But who is taking whom for a walk? Quite a woman, this Caterina di Modena. Also, one who is considerably ahead of her time. Can she be ahead of Niccolo Machiavelli? This will form the substance of act two. Think of Machiavelli. We usually conjure up an image of a man deep in the great affairs that rock nations, entire world. He operated on a more modest, some very basic observations of human nature. And could be expressed in rather simple, straightforward terms. Since he is credited by many as the author of the expression, there is no use crying over spilt milk.

Has slept with his mistress, Caterina di Modena.

Charges of murder?

Yes, Don Piero. Make of it, Niccolo. Decided not to press us too hard for the money to pay his condottieri. He is not too sure of King Louis of France. He too is playing for time. Some sort of victory over Florence. And bend us to his will, demanding tangible evidence of our friendship.

Now, Mona Caterina. You promised me you would save him.

I promised you I would make him immortal.

Well, isn't that the same thing?

Not quite. All I know is he shall stand trial and then be executed. We can only hope for the best.

If the council gives in to this, this blackmail by Cesare, it will be the worst for them. Have you heard the people on the street?

Yes, I always listen to the people on the street.

They are outraged.

That's true. It is no longer a matter of Alfredo's life. It has become now a test of the honor of Florence.

I understand.

You understand, and yet you propose to do nothing?

I am even now considering a plan.

Yes, tell me.

Um, shall we go for a stroll to your lovely garden?

Niccolo Machiavelli, would you take unfair advantage of a poor, distraught, lovelorn lady?

Oh, no, Mona Caterina. Never.

Shall we?

I cannot tell you what a delightful source of inspiration was Caterina di Modena. And in that lovely garden bower, I conceived the idea that would be the salvation of Florence. And in a way, also, the salvation of Alfredo Petrucci.

Thank you, Sergeant. You may leave us alone.

Good morning, Alfredo.

Is it morning? In this dank hole, no one can tell.

I shall arrange for you to have more comfortable quarters.

I want nothing from you, Messere.

Perhaps you can even have a visitor.

I want nothing from any official of the corrupt and cowardly government of Florence.

A most lovely visitor.

Please, please. Why must you torture me? Hang me. Get it over with.

I brought some wine.

I'll say this. It will do the council no good.

Drink. You'll feel better.

I shall proclaim my innocence in the courtroom.

Now, my boy, you know better than that. They will get you to confess.

Oh? You're sure of that?

Finish your glass.

Yes, I will. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. This does not make any sense.

When they place a man on the rack and begin to stretch, and finally break his bones, he will confess to anything.

Then that's what they will have to do to me. The people won't be fooled.

Because I was driven mad with pain. I had come here hoping to save you from all that.

Who? Save me.

I was hoping that you would agree to be dressed in brilliant robes. And that you would stand at the bar of justice filled with joy, and that men and women would weep at the sight of you.

Yes?

Your voice filled with conviction, flowing with sincerity, you would confess to the murder of Emilio De Forli.

That's what I think of your wife.

Alfredo, listen.

Never.

Do you love your city of Florence?

What is this to do with my confessing?

Would you die for Florence?

I am willing to die for Florence, but not for Cesare Borgia.

Cesare Borgia is the most dangerous enemy of our city.

Then why do we pander to him? Why don't we fight him?

Alfredo, Alfredo, we were waiting.

For what? For whom?

Drink some more wine.

No. Break the glass. It's my last one.

Alfredo, the tragedy of our country. Please, leave me.

I'll tell you. We don't fight for ourselves. We call in foreign princes to protect us. And then these rapacious people strip us of everything.

What is all this to me now? In less than a week, I'll be dead.

And as if the foreigners aren't bad enough, we have our own native bandits, condottieri, who pick away at the... leftovers. And the most powerful of all these is Cesare Borgia.

You will have to live with him from now on, not I.

Italy could be a united, powerful country. Do you know the if or that one? Maybe you might drop it. We were waiting for a leader. Know who he is? Already. Why are you the one who is talking nonsense? You, Alfredo Petrucci. You decided to strike a blow for freedom. Florence.

I did.

When?

When you killed Emilio De Forli.

When I killed it. I didn't.

Now pay attention. My glass is empty.

Easily remedied.

Thank you. Now listen. Do you know who Emilio De Forli was?

I never laid eyes on the man in all my life.

Did you know he was an agent of Cesare Borgia?

He was?

He was sent here to undermine the Council of Florence, to incite the citizens to overthrow the government.

A scoundrel.

And in the confusion and disarray, Cesare Borgia would march in with his troops and take over the republic.

Oh, the treacherous villain. That's why you killed him.

I, I what?

That's why you killed him, Machiavelli.

I may be, uh, drunk, yes, but I'm not quite drunk enough to swallow that.

Alfredo, the deepest desire of your heart is to ensure the freedom of your beloved Florence.

Why you killed Emilio De Forli.

To rouse the people.

But I didn't.

You must stand at the bar of justice, as I have just said, and proclaim your guilt proudly.

I have no intention of.

What a speech you shall make. Fellow citizens, I, even if I were the only one, had decided that I must strike a blow for Florence, and so I killed the wretch. Let Cesare Borgia know that death awaits all his minions and himself, should he dare to set foot within our gates.

Please, Messere Nicola, I'm miserable enough now.

Have some more wine.

Thus, you will become a hero to all of Florence.

Mmm, a dead hero.

No, my boy, you will become a hero to all of Florence. A hero who shall live forever. You shall be immortal.

But I'll be dead.

Well, yes. You must die in order to achieve immortality in the first place, but that's an insignificant detail.

Well, not to me.

My boy, death comes to us all sooner or later. What are a few years, more or less?

Everything.

I offer you immortality.

What will I do with it?

Is there a drop left in that bottle, Messere Nicola?

Listen, my friend, already Florence hails you as a martyr.

I have another in my bag.

I love her.

Oh, my boy, she shall repay you with her adoration forever.

Messere Nicola, I've listened to you. I know. I don't believe a word you're saying.

Under escort, rode through the streets of the city. The people crowded along the route, and along the way, you could hear whispers. It's Alfredo Petrucci, Alfredo the martyr, Alfredo the safety, Alfredo.

What did I tell you? See, the people?

I, I don't know what to say.

Why is everyone so quiet? If you were just an ordinary hero, the air would be split with shouts and cheers and salutes. But you, Alfredo Petrucci, are destined for immortality. And this is the respectful silence which is louder than all the artillery of Cesare Borgia.

But I don't understand.

Already they have been told why you killed Emilio.

But, but I, I didn't kill Emilio.

Who is right? You or the entire city.

But... My boy, look at these faces. See what you have done. See the fires that... Smolder in everyone's eyes. See the resolve on everyone's jaw. You have turned Florence into a proud city. A city that will fight for its freedom. Don't betray these people.

We returned to his cell. There was a great look of exaltation on his face. Somehow you could sense that there was something different about him. I offered him some more wine.

No thank you, Niccolo. Well, Alfredo, you saw for yourself.

Yes, yes, I saw. I saw how my deepest and dearest wish could be fulfilled. If I die now, they will sing songs about you, write verses. Your picture shall adorn every patriotic home in Florence.

You're right. I must die for the murder of Emilio De Fori.

Anyone can be convinced of him, as long as the convincer is of the caliber of Niccolo Machiavelli. Do all of his problems end here? How can they? This is only the curtain for the second act.

It concerns Niccolo Machiavelli when he was younger and... The problem. Alfredo Petrucci will confess to the murder of Emilio De Fori. Bye for Cesare Borgia. In short, it was a patriotic murder. A martyr. And the entire Republic of Florence is united in its hatred of Cesare Borgia.

Splendid, Niccolo. I always knew we could defend on you.

Thank you, sire. Alfredo Petrucci. He had been transferred to a rather comfortable suite of rooms in the council building itself. Crowds stood outside in the streets, hoping for a glimpse of him at the windows. He was allowed to receive visitors. And the apartment was filled with nobles, artists, clergy, dignitaries of all kinds. Finally, I was able to corner him alone for a few minutes.

Ah, Messere Niccolo. They told me you were waiting. So good of you to receive me, Alfredo.

Oh, Niccolo, I'm not one to forget my friends. All of this. Had it not been for you, I would have been a poor, stubborn wretch broken on the rack.

And for what purpose?

For what purpose, indeed? Now, thanks to you, I shall achieve immortality.

I'm glad I was able to... I'm glad I was able to... I'm glad I was able to assist you.

Immortality! You know who was here to see me yesterday and study my face for a portrait? Leonardo da Vinci.

Who?

The great...

Yes. Mona Caterina has insisted on braiding the hanging rope with colorful silk and threads of gold. The hangman was moved to tears.

I see. Do you know how lovely she is?

Begins tomorrow. From King Louis, a friend who plead not guilty. And he wants me to instruct the court to seize the mistress of the Chevalier Saint-Denis. King's nearest and dearest friend.

Why does everybody's mistress always seem to be getting us into these scrapes? So, Alfredo must change his plea.

But it would be good for Florence if he were hanged for that murder.

I agree. It would unify the city and fan the fires of patriotism. Which may also be an element in King Louis' thinking.

Alfredo even wants to plead guilty.

I know. What's to be done now?

Now, you must talk him out of it.

I don't know if I can do that.

Why not?

I'm into it. Miss Ari Nicolo, I sent for you because I am highly displeased.

I am devastated if I am the cause of any...

No, I won't let you talk around me. I understand you intend to rob Alfredo of his immortality.

No, Mona Caterina. How could you be so cruel?

I am thinking of his happiness.

But he is deliriously happy now.

By living, he can do more for Florence than by dying.

I don't believe you.

Caterina, have I ever lied to you? Fondly, I hold his interest in my heart. How dedicated I am. And to his happiness.

Very well. Tell me. I'm listening.

How can we talk vital matters here? Let's walk in the guard's advantage of a poor, deserted, love-lorn lady now. Would you?

I'm sure I convinced the beautiful, charming, delightful Mona Caterina of my sincerity. But convincing Alfredo was another matter. He wore his immortality like a cloak. He refused to take it off.

But you were the one who told me... You were the one who told me... Die for Florence.

Listen to me, Alfredo. Committed a sin.

So have you.

I am the one whose guilt is greater. Convinced you to claim that you killed Emilio De Forli.

But I did kill you, De Forli.

No. How can you say no?

Emilio De Forli was carelessly stabbed to death in a drunken brawl outside a bordello near the Ponte Vecchio.

That's a lie. I killed him.

How did you kill him? When? Where?

Tim, I... You promised me immortality.

I know, but things change.

I don't care. I have seen immortality. I have...

Alfredo, immortality is only granted to us by the creator. You cannot earn immortality if you go to a liar's death.

But it's not a lie. I want to stand in the condemned box. I want to hurl my accusation at Cesare Borgia. My patriot's death and my hero's reward.

My poor Alfredo. And nothing, nothing you can hope to say will deprive me of it. Look that way. And it seemed that perhaps he might not be the only prisoner in the box. I had a most... Unsatisfactory interview with Don Piero Sodorini, president of the council.

He refuses to change his plea?

That is right, Don Piero.

But it is the express desire of King Louis XII to France that Alfredo plead innocent of the murder of Emilia de Forli. That he be acquitted.

I understand, Excellency.

So be done, immediately.

Of course. It was your idea to begin with. This whole harebrained scheme. To have him proclaim his guilt in order to fan the patriotic flame in Florence, wasn't it?

Yes, Don Piero.

So, now, you will get that. To change his plea, you understand? Not only too well, but what could I say to Alfredo? The fact is, I had spun the web that trapped him originally. And I spun it too well. However, there will always be those times when appeals to the intellect are doomed to failure. That is when we must think of other parts of the human organism. Once again, I asked for an escort. And we rode across the city to the church. The church of the Santa Croce. A beautiful place where all the famous are entombed.

Why have you brought me here?

To look at immortality, Alfredo.

Immortality? Which you avidly desire.

Well, look about you. Underneath all these beautifully carved marble stones are tombs. And we walk on them. See? The inscriptions. All the mighty names of Italy. Medici's, Sforza's. Borgia's, Borgia's, Orsini's, Dante d'Alighieri. All of them are immortal here. This is immortality. Is this what you want?

Yes. Yes. It's so cold.

But... Come with me.

But this is where... This is the home of Mona Caterina.

Come. Let us dismount.

Why have you brought me here?

We shall go this way. Beautiful garden. Mona Caterina. So that you may feel the sweet of mortality, my young hero. Tomorrow under the floor of Santa Croce. Or a warm today in the arms of Mona Caterina. Here in the quiet, lovely, private bar where she comes to you.

It wasn't really a difficult decision. Nor did it take very long. I went home feeling quite pleased with myself. I had saved my career and possibly my freedom, if not my life. When a summons came to appear before Don Piero.

Now what?

Must do it. Feels we have broken our word in this Alfredo Petrucci matter. We want him to go free.

Borgia is even now en route to Florence with an army of 10,000 men. King Louis is too far away to be of any use to us. And the flames of patriotism. Florentines cannot defend Florence.

Yes, Don Piero. And so, to fling this challenge in Borgia's face. Alfredo Brooklyn. That he killed Borgia's henchman.

I went to Mona Caterina's palazzo. I say without thinking because if I had stopped to think I may very well have gone mad. When I arrived there, I took young Alfredo, who was fresh-faced and filled with love and joy, aside.

Niccolo, I find you're a man of unusual wisdom.

Thank you.

You are always worth listening to.

Then listen to this. Do you remember what I told you about immortality?

Oh, yes. How could I? How could I ever forget?

Well, then... Niccolo, this message just arrived from the council. It is marked urgent.

Thank you, Caterina. Will you excuse me, my friends, for a moment? I broke the seal. The great red seal of the council. The letter was written by Don Piero himself. Messere Niccolo Machiavelli. Please be advised that Cesare Borgia was killed this morning in an ambush set up by rebellious units of his own condottiere. Thus, Tyrant perishes. And the matter of the murder of Emilio De Forli can be allowed to sink into oblivion. The council thanks you for your dedicated efforts in this affair and has decided to award you with a richly deserved holiday. Why not spend the next few days with your beautiful new bride, Mona Marietta?

Messere Niccolo. On the subject of, uh... Concentrate on me in secluded places in a lovely garden. Ah, and, uh, such a place in your gardens?

No, but I'm on my way home right now.

Oh, Machiavelli was a man who enjoyed all the delights life had to offer. We live once, he said, and whatever joys we miss, we miss forever. Don't miss me. I shall be back. The words that Machiavelli developed do not represent his own personal feelings, which, when he allowed himself to express them, were rather generous.

They emerged from what he saw. He lived among the powerful, and his writings merely reflect those who rule, are unaware of moralism, and are responsive only to expediency. Who can prove him wrong?

Our cast included Gordon Gould, Mandel Kramer, Russell Horton, and was under the direction of Hyman Brown.

"Les, what do you want? A loving Gary, whose sexual appetites are never quite satisfied."

"I don't know what you're talking about, Phyllis, but really, I wish..."

"Look, you know exactly what I'm talking about. Fire that so-called female doctor, lad. These last two months, and come on home."

"Phyllis, be reasonable. Dr. Thurston is invaluable to me. Every time she pulls the string..."

"No, I'm brainwashed. There's nothing else I can do. Why don't you get rid of her?"

E.G. Marshall inviting you to return to our mystery theater for another adventure in the macabre.

End of transcriptBack to the beginning ↑