Skip to content
On Air
All channelsAll
CBS Radio Mystery Theater artwork

From the CBS Radio Mystery Theater collection

Fire and Ice

Episode 751December 7, 197741 min 19 secTranscript

Writer: Himan Brown

The written record

Read the transcript

Read along with the recording · About 24 min to read

CBS Radio Mystery Theater presents...

Come in.

I'm E.G. Marshall. "I am mortised and tenoned in granite, and I know the amplitudes of time," said the poet. The amplitudes of time, and also of space—infinite, illimitable, with neither an end nor a beginning. So much time, so much space. We're frenzied, crowded creatures. Why are we so hurried?

Marcella, I'm asking you to marry me.

Yes, William, I heard you.

Well, your answer?

The answer is no.

No?

It has to be no.

Why does it have to be no?

Because, well, I don't love you.

Oh, is that all?

Is that all?

Yes, I thought you had a good reason.

A mystery drama, "Fire and Ice," was written especially for the Mystery Theater by Sam Dann, and stars Fred Gwynne and Marian Hailey. It is sponsored in part by Contact, the 12-hour cold capsule, and True Value Hardware Stores. I'll be back shortly.

The world has changed in many ways. There was a time when every man's home was his castle, and every man was king. It doesn't necessarily mean that his wife was a queen. What it meant was that his word was law, and everyone in the house obeyed it, or often enough to be very much of a problem in most places. At any rate, we're concerned with an autocrat named J.J. Trelawney in the year 1912.

Father?

Who's that?

Yes, Father, it's me, Marcella.

What's that on your face?

No, Father, it's powder.

This is bad.

Well, it's rice powder, Father. Even the minister's wife wears it.

The same rice we eat?

Yes, Father.

Father?

Don't just stand there.

Well, um...

The same rice we eat.

Oh, yes, yes, Father. I see you're wearing enough of it to save an entire heathen village from starvation.

I hadn't thought of it that way.

I don't know what the world's coming to. Father, may I speak with you?

Of course you can speak with me.

Well, Father, there's this young man...

What? Which young man?

Well, the one I met at this concert.

What did you want to meet a young man for? What did you want a concert for?

No, Father, he's really very nice.

Well, nice, fine, but what about William?

William?

Yes, William. William's my right-hand man.

Well, I know that. He's a fellow for you.

But, Father...

You must admit, he's smart.

Well, yes, yes, he is.

And he's gonna be rich one day.

Rich.

Well, yes, yes, he will.

Well, then, meet other young men for.

Well, Father, Edward is so...

Oh, that is it. Yes, Edward. Edward. He's so...

So?

Um, I don't know. And you see him going on him? And when I ask you why, it's because he's just...

Oh, but, Father...

No, no, no, no. That won't do, my girl. William Stilwell's the man for you.

Please, Father, I don't love William Stilwell.

Love? Love. What's love?

Well, it's, it's, um... It's, uh, what? I can't define it exactly, but...

Well, I looked in the dictionary. It's a strong liking. Fondness. You see, my girl, I happen to look it up. I like to be sure of my ground. Now, you've got to put your life on a practical basis.

Yes, Father.

And you've got to do the thing that makes sense.

Father?

Which is why I have to choose your husband for you.

Carried away by... I can be depended on to make the proper choice. Please do not have the qual...

Father.

Hey, William Stilwell, one fine day. The opera by Mr. Puccini. Madam Butterfly.

Oh, yes. And that fellow's in it who has such a fine voice. Uh, what's his name?

Mr. Caruso, Father, but he didn't sing the aria.

Oh, the Japanese girl?

Yes.

They're all a bunch of foreigners. Well, I guess they really know music, don't they? But, uh, with this thing you, you call... Why does the poor Japanese girl kill herself? A, a beautiful girl. Have a great future. Why does she kill herself?

For love.

That's my point. Love. What is she needed for? What good did it do her? Where did it get her?

Well, but, Father...

So, let's not hear another word about love, all right?

Yes, Father.

He had a way, my father did, of making things so crystal clear. But he was older, wiser, more experienced, which meant he knew better. And everything was for my own good. I look back at it now, after all these years. The world now is so different, but back then... Well, I went to the concert that night to hear a young Russian violinist named Mischa Elman. Well, that's not why I went, because I knew he would be there.

Edward.

And we would meet at intermission. We would meet even though nothing could ever come of it.

Marcella, why do you say that?

Oh, please, Edward.

Why do you say nothing? Nothing can ever come of it.

Because it's true.

Why is it true?

I must do what my father tells me.

And if you don't?

If I don't?

Yes, my darling. If you don't, what will he do? What can he do?

Please, Edward.

Disinherit you? Cut you out of his will?

Oh, it isn't that. I have a job. I can support us, you know that.

Yes, I...

I'm not after your father's money. You know that, too.

Oh, yes, I know that.

Then why... Why don't we just stand up to him?

Edward, we'd better not see each other again.

Never see each other?

Yes.

You call this seeing each other? This hurried ten-minute encounter?

Well, whatever it is, Edward...

This brief pause during a concert in the midst of a thousand people?

It's for the best. There is no other way.

Your father has no right...

Oh, he has every right.

Why?

Because he's my father.

Is that you, Marcella?

Yes, Father.

Did you enjoy the concert?

Oh, yes. I'm not excited.

Yes, William spent the evening with me. We had some reports. He's in my study. He's sensible. Did it work hard enough? Did I help you to some caviar, Marcella?

No, thank you.

Some pheasant?

Oh, I, um... I'm not hungry.

Uh, did you enjoy the concert?

Yes.

Well, I'm not one for music. I, uh... I find it a waste of time.

Oh?

You know, I don't find it productive.

Productive?

Mm-hmm. You know, on those rare occasions when I'm dragooned to one, I see people around me sitting in deep silence and thinking and concentrating. Isn't that so?

Well, yes. I know how I do that. Well, it requires mental energy, does it not?

Yes, some.

Shouldn't there be... Shouldn't there be some reward for this expenditure of energy and effort?

Oh, there is a reward.

Is there?

Oh, yes.

Well, I'm not sure. I'm not sure I can describe it.

Well, then it's, uh... It's a rather poor reward.

Oh, no. No, it's rich.

Rich? In what?

In, uh... Things of the spirit.

Things of the spirit. Tell me something, Marcella. These, uh... Things of the spirit. What can one do with them?

Do with them?

Mm-hmm. Uh, can you take these things of the spirit into a bank and discount them for cash?

Uh, no, I... I don't suppose so.

Well, then. Of what value are they?

Well, uh... William, they do things for the mind, for the heart, for the soul, and...

Well, as I understand it, you spent two hours in Carnegie Hall listening to some Russian fiddler.

Yes.

Hmm? And you gave him all your attention and concentration.

Yes, I did.

And as a result, you claim to be richer in things of the spirit?

I think I have a headache, William. I, uh... I may have concentrated, you know, a bit too deeply.

Oh. Oh, I'm sorry. I'm sorry. I'm sorry. I'm sorry. I'm sorry. I'm sorry. I'm sorry. I wonder if you'll excuse me.

Yes, of course. Good night, William.

Yeah, good night. Oh, before you go, I had come here this evening for one purpose.

I know. To work with my father.

No, no, no. Not exactly. But to see you.

To see me?

Yes. I, uh, didn't know you'd be out. See, the reason I came here, well, should not come as a complete surprise to you. It was to ask your hand in marriage.

Oh. Yes, I had discussed it with your father.

Oh, I know that.

He's quite enthusiastic.

So I understand.

He thinks it's a splendid idea.

Yes, I'm sure he does.

He's all for it. He already told me.

Then it's all settled.

Regardless of my answer?

Your answer. Of course. I must have your answer, too.

Oh, it's very sensitive of you to ascertain my wishes. William, I would marry you gladly. However, there's a problem.

A problem?

A problem? I don't love you.

What did you say?

I don't love you.

And that's the problem?

Yes, that's the problem.

My dear Marcella, I was afraid it was something serious. Love, says the popular song, your magic spell is everywhere. Well, not quite everywhere. Not in the heart of Marcella Trelawney. Well, it's in there, but obviously not for Mr. William Stilwell. So, that should be the end of it. But don't forget, the year is 1912, and that was another world. And we shall return to it shortly, when I bring you Act Two.

Love is for the philosophers, the dreamers, the romantics. And we wonder why sometimes, since it seems to have treated most of them quite shabbily. Well, today, of course, we claim to marry for love. A generation or so ago, this wasn't the case. Are we happier than our grandparents?

But you don't understand, William. I don't love you.

Is that a reason not to marry me?

Please, William, you must excuse me. I'm very tired.

I went upstairs to my room. I prepared for bed. I was very tired and confused and unhappy. I didn't know what to do. There was a knock on the door. It was my father. I was sort of expecting him.

I spoke with William, my dear.

Father.

You don't love him?

He understands that.

Well, then why do you insist that I marry him?

Because he'll make you an excellent husband.

Without love?

Love, my dear, only confuses the issue.

Oh, please, Father.

The issue is clear enough for me. Marriage should primarily be a strengthening of one's position. Did kings and queens marry for love?

Father, I'm not a queen.

Ah, but you are. You're the daughter of a millionaire. It is your duty.

Take your fortune.

My fortune?

The fortune you will one day inherit from me.

Oh, Father, I don't care about...

Nobody does at 21.

Father, I mean it. All I can tell you is that I don't love William Stilwell.

It's unfortunate. William Stilwell is a man who could preserve your fortune.

Father, he doesn't like art. He doesn't like music.

Teach him to enjoy them.

Well, it isn't that either. I mean it.

Well, then what is it?

Well, it's just that there's something, you know, something about him. I, um, something, uh...

Yes?

It's just something.

You were determined not to like him, I see.

Oh, sorry, Father.

And you refuse to marry him?

Well, I can't refuse to marry him if you command me to. I, I, I understand. I was hoping you could arrive at the proper conclusion for yourself. It's, uh, it's, uh, certain...

Yes, Father.

It seems to me a man can be as... as wise as King Solomon, as handsome as Apollo, as strong as Hercules. He could be the paragon of every virtue known to man, and, and yet, if he does not possess that, uh, mysterious, certain something the woman herself cannot define, or, or even describe, he isn't worth her passing glance. This, uh, other fellow, what's his name?

Edward.

Edward Wilson.

Edward. What will we see, Father?

We'll see... We'll see... We'll see... We'll see... We'll see... We'll see what he's... He's wonderful. That's what we're gonna find out. I think he can... I think he'll be better for you than William.

Oh, you will, you will.

Just hear me out. I'll give him a fair trial, and then... I'll stack each of them up against the other, and come to my decision. I'll agree with my choice.

Yes, Father.

Uh, and that will be the end of it. You'll obey your father with no... ...nonsense. Do you agree?

Oh, Father, I agree. I agree. I agree. Of course I agree.

Such a wonderful man, my father. He could have simply commanded me to marry William. But he loved me. Yes, much as he had no use for that word. He loved me. And he wanted me to be happy. And so Edward, my Edward, would get a fair trial. The very next night, Edward was asked to dinner.

You say you're an astronomer for a goodly amount?

Edward, how would you like to take a job with me?

A job, sir?

Back up into the Arctic.

The North Pole has already been discovered.

I know. By this fellow, and that other one who wants to get forced by it. It's like you. Looking up at the sky and counting the stars now.

Mr. Trelawney, think about it.

It's Father's way of finding out about you.

Well, he doesn't have to send me to the Arctic to find out.

My life's an open book. But he does have to send you to the Arctic. Why? To see if you measure up to his standards. Besides, I... William Stilwell is going. Now he wants to see both of you together. Marcella, why do you have to... This absolute domination by your father. Please don't say that. But it's true. I can't help the way I am. And I'm not sure it's wrong. You're not sure? Well, if cousin, every instinct... Oh, please, darling. What do I know about the world? I've always been sheltered, taken care of. My father's always protected me. Oh, his wise Edward experience. I know he loves me. He wants me to be happy. Now, would he insist on my marriage to William Stilwell if he weren't sure that that was the best choice? I know. I know he only wants what's best for me. And you? Shouldn't you have anything to say about that? I love you, Edward. That is, I... I think I love you. You think? Well, what... What is it I really have for you? Only a feeling. Something I can't explain. Why I feel this way. I don't know. Against this. It's my father's wisdom. I'm only heir. My father is solid rock. That kind of thinking is wrong. It is. Now, I would have to get used to a new... A new way of life. A new way of looking at things. It can't happen overnight and all at once. I want to be free. I want to be independent. I want to be one of Mr. George Bernard Shaw's women. Oh, how much I want to. Well, then become one. You just don't do it. I want to change, Edward. Then change. I have already. A little. How? Falling in love with you. Even though I know my father's intended me for someone else. But to go off with your father on this expedition to the Arctic. Don't you understand? I have a job. I have a career. I have to give it up. Be a change in my life. Yet, what you're asking me to do is to make a change in mine. Well, that's different. We're in love. Shouldn't that be enough for marriage? I don't know. It's enough for some people, but not for others. I don't know if it would be enough for us. Why did I have to fall in love with you? Well, go on the trip. Oh, darling. I know father will see that you are the best man. Oh, no, Marcella. William Stilwell is going to be the best man. I shall become the bridegroom. What do they say? Sensible intelligence. Intelligent people never fall in love. Well, if they don't, they do avoid a great deal of grief. They also miss out on a goodly amount of fun. Why do we marry? And whom should we marry? The average person faces these problems at least one lifetime. There are some who never face them at all. And others who keep facing them all the time. Should you marry because he or she is attractive? Rich? Should we marry to please our parents? To better ourselves? All through? Through history and all over the world, people have married and still do for any one of these reasons. And statistically, there is no proof that any one reason is true.

May I come in, Marcella? Please do, father. Our ship sails tomorrow. I know, father. And I must say, I'm rather taken with this young man. I knew you would be. Both under some rough conditions. Oh, you'll be so proud of Edward. It comes out. You agreed to abide by Marcella. My decision. What a week that was. Such hectic preparations. I hardly saw Edward at all. And then, just before it was time to leave, each of them came to say goodbye to me.

My darling, I'm glad I'm going. It's good sometimes to see someone else's point of view. And just being with your father this week is, well, it's taught me a great many things about him. I knew you'd like him. Well, I'm not sure I like him exactly. But I do know he's a most unusual man. And he wants very much for you to be happy. You know that's all he's ever wanted? And so, now that I look at it from his point of view, he doesn't seem unreasonable at all.

Careful there, Marcella. Here, let me take your arm. That gangplank sways quite a bit. Here you are. Well, hey, what are you doing down here at the dock? Well, I just came down to, um... Yes, I, uh, I know you didn't come to see me. Well, I came to look at the boat. Uh, you mean the ship. Oh, I didn't know there was a difference. Well, it has to do with size. Marcella, what do you see in this, uh, fellow Edward? Hmm? Oh, he has a beautiful soul. Oh, what is the use? I talk to you and what do I get? I get words that really have no meaning. Words like love and soul. All right, what is soul? You even have to ask such a question. I do. The fact is, no one has ever seen me. They haven't seen a soul, have they? Well, now, that's ridiculous. Why? Why is it ridiculous? Now, how big is the soul? What does it look like? Where can you find it? William, may I ask you something? What do you want with me? I mean, why do you want to marry me? Oh, I know, I know. Well, if you don't beat all... If you know, why do you ask? Well, it's the right, the practical course of action. I'm a logical choice. But shouldn't there, William, be more than that? I mean, shouldn't two people be happy? We'll be happy. Well, how can we be happy, William, if we're not in love? What love? Oh, there you go again. What did I say now? Oh, you have to ask.

And then the boat, or the ship, sailed. It was quite a day. Flags were flying in the harbor. The air was filled with cheers. Whistles from all the crafts. Bands were playing. I mean, there were reporters and the mayor was there and the governor and important people. Important people from Washington. Oh, President Taft himself sent a telegram. And then the ship was gone. And all that I had were letters.

I've never seen such brilliant colors. Everyone thinks the Arctic is white. Ah, but when the sun hits the ice, it explodes into thousands of glorious rainbows. I long for you constantly.

Nothing much to report. One day is pretty much like the other. Just ice and snow and the sun. Soon we're going to lose the sun and just be stuck with the ice and the snow.

Come with him. Whatever there is to the summer is about to disappear. We are now going to get into the real Arctic. It's getting to be constant twilight. Soon it will be night. A night that will last for six months. It's good. It's starting to separate the men from the boys. I'm getting to know things about both things I could never learn in the ordinary way back at home.

You're loving. But he never did. He never wrote another letter.

The reporters wouldn't stop ringing my telephone. Knocking at my door. What did they want of me? They knew more about it than I did. Miss Trelawney, do you have a statement? A statement? Tell us about the great tragedy. Tragedy? Your father is reported missing in the Arctic. Well, yes, I know. What can you tell us about it? Nothing. But surely, Miss Trelawney... Please, gentlemen, I don't know what to say. Do you have any plans? Plans? Yeah, plans. What are you going to do about the Trelawney industry? I don't know. Well, would you assume personal control? Do you intend to become America's first great woman industrialist? I haven't thought anything about like that. What are your views on woman suffrage, Miss Trelawney? Please, gentlemen, please.

There was only one thing I wanted to do. And I did it. I ordered a boat. Or a ship. And I commanded the captain to sail north along the Atlantic coast. Up past Labyrinthine. Salvador, Newfoundland. Find a place called Baffin's Island into the Davis Strait. Then up north to the very edge of the frozen polar wastes. Finally, I arrived at the site of my father's base camp. It was a large, well-constructed settlement. It was warm. It was safe.

Marcella! But you shouldn't have come here. Why not, William? There's nothing you can do. Where's Edward? He's out looking for your father. Yes. Yes, he would be. You, of course, are staying here in the base camp where it's safe. Oh, I have been looking, too. It's just that you came here on the day that he's out. Where's father gone? Where? I'm trying to find the trail. Which trail? Well, just before the winter set in, your father had a little camp made for himself. It's not too far from here. It's a hut with a stove and food and everything he needed. And you let him go. Well, who can tell your father anything? He wanted to be alone, just for a little while. He wanted to think things out. I know, I know. He was supposed to come back, but he was caught in the first storm, in the first terrible cold of the winter. It's been a month. We haven't heard from him. He doesn't have enough supplies, enough food, enough fuel. Please. That's what you wanted to know. You just have no sensitivity.

I will remain here all winter until the light of summer returns. And then they will be able to see the trail once again. And then they will recover my father's body. And perhaps there will be a letter for me from him, his very last letter, in which he'll tell me his decision. But don't I know that decision? Even now don't I know it? Now that he's seen Edward under these terrible conditions, can there be any doubt? Edward, the kind, understanding, gentle Edward with the beautiful soul. If he didn't choose Edward, Edward? Edward? Edward? Edward? Edward? Edward? Edward? Edward? Edward? Edward? Edward? Edward? Edward? Edward? Edward? Edward? Edward? How could I bear it? How could I obey him? But he did choose Edward. He did. Because the very next day, Edward came back to the base camp with proof. The written proof.

Oh, darling, I'm so sorry. So sorry. You found him? Yes, I... And he's dead? I'll tell you how. But you must... You must tell me everything. He died of... He froze to death. You can bring him back here. Wait for the summer. I understand. But some things have changed. Some things of his I knew you would want. Very much written in it for more than a month. He was growing weaker all the time. Before the cold set in, he wrote long notes to his plans and projects he was developing. Even as his fuel and food ran out, he kept writing. Another day. Another day. Cold. Bleak. Another day. Perhaps it will bring rescue. They're trying to find me. I know. I know. And then pages of nothing. Until the final day. See what he writes? I never doubted it. Never. In the end, your father became a believer. A believer in what? Whatever that is. Your father made the choice. Do you want to be the first to... William. You're ready to leave. Edward has decided to give up teaching permanently. So he told me. He's decided to run father's business for me. I knew that. You did? Yes. I just told me of his decision this morning. I knew about it for weeks. Months. Ever since we got on a ship to sail out here. You mean he told you? I guess he didn't have to tell it in words. Well, how else could he tell it? You ask a question like that? You believe in things that don't need words. Love, soul, and so forth. I don't understand. I guess for the first time, he saw how it is to be rich. And how good living is. How great it is to have power to order people around. You could see it in his eyes. You could hear it in his voice.

Arthur? Yes, darling? My dear, you're not packed. Well, what's a few hours one way or the other? We'll leave at noon instead of ten. But the ship is getting up steam. Every hour that we stay here is costing us money. Oh, darling, we have plenty of money. That does not give us the right to waste it. Now, dear, I'll send in some of the men to help you. William? Yes? We should have a talk about the status of things as soon as possible. Okay with me. Marcella, darling, please, don't waste any more time.

What did I tell you? I told you that underneath it all, Edward was always cut out to be a businessman. And father understood it. And that's why father approved of him. Do you approve of him? What a question. But you haven't answered it. I promised my father I would abide by his decision. Well, you could sound a little more enthusiastic. How about it? What do you know about anything? I used to know nothing at all about anything. And then I came out here. I realized that I was not a man. I realized how unimportant we really are in the face of, well, call it nature.

I guess the Arctic does different things to different people. It showed me how small I am. I guess it convinced Edward of how big he could be.

You, uh, you're still going to work for the company, aren't you?

No.

Why not? Edward needs you.

But I don't need Edward.

I need you, though. Now, William, my father made the decision and I promised him I would...

Your father didn't make the decision.

But he...

He didn't decide on Edward, did he?

It is his last word.

He didn't write them.

How can you say that?

Can't you see it? It's obvious. Read what he's supposed to have written. Can it be 200 below? My fingers are frozen stiff and solid. How could he write under those conditions?

Could manage it somehow.

Maybe he could manage his fingers. But how about the ink?

The ink?

Wouldn't the ink, like everything else that's liquid, be frozen solid?

You see?

Yes.

End of transcriptBack to the beginning ↑