Skip to content
On Air
All channelsAll
CBS Radio Mystery Theater artwork

From the CBS Radio Mystery Theater collection

Forty-Five Minutes to Murder

Episode 495June 28, 197647 min 0 secTranscript

Writer: Himan Brown

The written record

Read the transcript

Read along with the recording · About 32 min to read

The CBS Radio Mystery Theater presents... I'm E.T. Marshall. ...of the demons and devils that descend upon us at this hour. We've been told by a gallery of characters as diverse as Douglas MacArthur, Thomas Edison, and Aldous Huxley that there are no substitutes for victory, hard work, and talent, respectively. Does that imply that there can be no satisfactory substitute? For anything? Well, suppose you were condemned to death. How about a substitute who would walk that last mile for you? But I didn't kill him, Lieutenant. Come on, Mr. Raglan, you're only wasting time. I tell you I'm innocent. You sent him that bottle of liquor. It was poison. But I... It was a birthday gift. The note was in your handwriting. I have the testimony of the clerk at the store. He remembers selling you this bottle. Okay.

Now let me ask you, if I did kill him, would I be crazy enough to leave so many clues pointing to me? Sure. Sure, because maybe that's your defense. You figure the members of the jury will ask that same question. Would he be crazy enough to leave all those clues? Well, I wish you luck, because you're going to find out the hard way. For Mr. Drama, 45 Minutes to Murder, written especially for the Mystery Theater by Sam Vance. and stars Larry Haynes. It is sponsored in part by Anheuser-Busch Incorporated, Brewers of Budweiser, and Derrick Motor Division. I'll be back shortly with that one. We are told thou shalt not kill. The laws, both secular and divine, define murder as the ultimate crime for which the ultimate penalty must be exacted. And yet, deep or not so deep, In all of us is a bloodlust. And some of us satisfy it actively. While most of us, fortunately, are happy to indulge it vicariously. After all, isn't that why you listen to our program? What you want is murder. You got here just in time. The body is still a bottle of coke. Doc, you say quick, actually. How quick? It's actually the killers of my wife, Lieutenant. Say the murder.

Tell me what you know, Mr. Murphy. These ragdolls have always hated my life. Why? My talent, my success, my position as vice president of Caroway Chemicals. The job he thinks should have been given to him. Why, he's so extravagant, wasteful. His money would be bankrupt in a year. Well, if he hated and envied you, why should he kill her? Is he competent? Did you end up on your birthday? I haven't looked on yet. Okay, tell me exactly what happened. I tried to, and so I...

A gift from Jim. Leave the card, darling. It's fine, Jimmy. It's handwriting. It must be a practical joke. Remarkable after all these years. I always wanted to be reconciled with Jim. And since he's taken the first stab, yeah, I'm going to open the bottle and drink to it. What better way? I dare you. What? Oh, pour some for me, too. But darling, you never drink. I know, but this... Guys call for a celebration. It certainly does. It means Jim has finally matured. Oh, it's going to hell for the office of Jim Lineley. I propose a double toast to your birthday. No, don't remind me. I'll give you the flowering, or the re-flowering of a friendship. We're holding our glasses aloft, as you do when you toast. It seemed to me that I noticed a kind of cloudiness in your cognac. It might be one of the most expensive...

of cognac you can buy. Well, this might have been a defective bottle. I was going to say, let's not drink this just yet, darling. He had already swallowed it down. Aren't you going to drink the old one? Oh, dear, I, uh... Did you notice anything strange about the cognac? Strange? I don't really know enough about cognac. I mean, the taste. Well, I don't know how it's supposed to taste. Well, it's kind of rich, my lady. I know. What? Well, maybe I'm not... You used to what? I'll call a doctor. When help arrived, there was nothing anyone could do. Well, thank you, Mr. Martindale. No, no, Lieutenant. You don't know everything. I had every intention of killing Jim Ragland. Killing him with my bare hands. Let your officers be. Let justice take its course. I said justice.

Second, I'll take my own. You didn't kill her. You didn't mean to kill her. You sent the bottle of poison cognac to him. I didn't send a bottle of poison cognac to anybody. Now, Mr. Ragland, I want to help you. If you want to help me, you'll find out who's trying to frame me. Did you send Mr. Martindale a... Yeah, you don't deny it. But it wasn't poison. It was done since cognac. A hundred years old, it cost $200. I need to spend on a birthday gift. Well, especially for a person you really don't care for. Who told you that? Do you like Mr. Martindale? Are you in the habit of giving him gifts on his birthday? I just thought he'd been at short points long enough. Short points? Well, it's just that we disagree on money. He hates to spend it. I decided it'd be better for the firm if we pulled together. Or if you could, pull along. I only wanted to make peace with him. That $200 present? I didn't...

There's a good impression. The business required both of us to work in harmony. I don't suck in the company. Well, we have the note in your handwriting. Would I be such a fool? Well, sure. Murder is basically a fool's occupation. All you have is Emma's word for it. For what? That the cognac I sent in is the same cognac that poisoned his wife. Listen. Suppose she wanted to kill him. Why? Well, suppose. The cognac arrives. It has the note in my handwriting. It's a sudden flash of inspiration. He opens it. He spikes it with a poison. Yeah, sure. You're able to get the poison. We're in the chemical business. He's a chemist. He has a laboratory in the house. He gets his wife to drink some of the cognac. And here I am. He's Yale, the killer.

Well, you must admit it sounds a bit far-fetched. I don't admit anything. Mr. Rodman, make it easy on me. Anytime you're ready to make a statement, why, you... I'll have your badge. I'll see this town for false arrest. How dare you accuse me? Now, look, Mr. Rodman... Why don't you go to Barnaby's Liquor Store on 4th and Van Buren? That's where I bought the cognac. I said, give me a bottle of Dunstan's. He got it. I said, just slap and put this card inside. He did it. And then I said, deliver it. There was no way I could have poisoned that cognac. I remember, Lieutenant. I don't sell a bottle of Dunkin's every day, you know what I mean? Very few liquor stores even carry that quality. Now, he came in here after the Dunkin's. He wrote a note. Yeah? He says, just wrap it and put this note inside, which I did. So, now we have this wrapped pack. Now, tell me the next thing that happened. The next thing he said. I want this delivered.

Sure thing. Right now. To Mr. Emmett Martindale. 13 Pleasant Drive. Well, my delivery guy won't come in until noon. That's more than an hour from now. I'd like it delivered at once. It's only an hour away. All right. Suppose you forget the whole thing. Oh, no way. Let us not be hasty. You stay here a minute. Watch the place, will you? I'll run next door to the grocery. Maybe this guy will help. Rand, let's go out to Martha with this place. We do favors for each other, see? But his kid was already on the list. You left Mr. Radnum and the package all alone in your store? Yeah. For how long? Oh, I don't know. A couple of minutes. Thanks. Thanks very carefully. Was he carrying anything? Yeah. One of them, um... Can I take that? You're sure? Yeah.

Positive. Then he did have the opportunity to switch bottles. Now, the point is, he was alone with the package. Well, sure, he was alone with every package in the store. I see. And then what did you do? I went back, and I told him straight out, I can't deliver this for at least an hour. Oh, then you can't deliver it. Oh, no, wait. Wait, wait, let me think. It took me ten minutes to get to Flushing, ten minutes back. I can close the store for 20 minutes there, a half hour. Look, I'll deliver it myself. What do you think? I delivered the package. I want you to explain every detail. I drive up to the door. I park the car. I ring the bell. Yes. Hey, good guess. Oh, I got a package here for Mr. Martindale. From whom? From Mr. James Radcliffe.

Hey, hey, uh, what's your name? Are you sure it's our Mr. James Raglin? Watch my heart and hope to die. Uh, wait here. With that, she leaves me standing at the door. Now, from inside, I hear voices. What kind of voices? Voices. So what? Well, I couldn't hear. It isn't more than a minute, and she comes back. Oh, thank you. Uh, that'll be all. Uh, what time do you get off tonight, honey? You know, I did pretend it. You win some, you lose some. Yeah, yeah. Did you know exactly what time that was? You bet I know. Every minute was costing me money. It was exactly nine minutes after 11. Your name is Marguerite Willis? Yes, officer. And just after 11 this morning, a man delivered a... A bottle of cognac for Mr. Martindale. I brought it in, Dan. Oh.

Tell me, why did you ask the delivery man to wait? I couldn't believe Mr. Raglin would send Mr. Martindale a present. Why not? I couldn't say this, perhaps, but there's always been such bad blood between them. I see. Now, tell me what happened when you brought the present. A gift for you, for Mr. Raglin. Are you sure? Well, it could be right. We'll find out. You can leave the room if you like, Marguerite. Be a bomb. Well, it's a bottle of cognac. Not just cognac, it's Dunson's cognac. Maybe he wants to poison it with Dunson's. Nobody would poison too much money. Emma, Emma dear, come in here. It's a gift from Jim. A gift from Jim? Walked out of the room and I began to dust the parlor. I could hear them talking about it. They opened the bottle.

He said that he'd join them. How long did that take? Just as long as it takes to tell you. Next thing I know, I hear him yell for me to call a doctor. Did you? Well, I was standing here at the phone, so I just lifted it and called the police emergency number for an ambulance. And they came right away? Oh, yes. Right away. Thank you. I guess that's all. That's all for whom? It could be all for Mr. James Ragland, but... You know we can't be as simple as this. After all, it's only the end of Act One. We'll have the usual quota of surprises set up for Act Two, and if for Act Three... But let's take them one at a time. I'm Hyman Brown, producer-director of the CBS Radio Mystery Theater, inviting you to a week of supernatural history. Beginning this Sunday, July 4th, We'll celebrate this bicentennial with seven new and original dramas of suspense rooted in America's past. In The Angels of Devil's Mountain, for instance, a 20th century man becomes one with a revolutionary soldier. Listen, are you telling me he's the reincarnation of the soldier in the painting? All I'm saying is he's the same soldier. And when you go through here...

Something came over me. He felt that terrible pain again. We'll take you back to the revolution with Thomas Jefferson and George Washington, to the Civil War with Lincoln, exciting stories of intrigues, spies, and ghosts. Be sure to join us each night next week for seven dramas of supernatural history on CBS Radio Mystery Theater at 10.30 every night on WBBM News Radio 78.

The French say, which means everyone to his own taste. All too soon, we become enslaved by our tastes and form habits, which leads to patterns of actions. And to these, we remain true. If we are rash and impulsive, we do everything in a rash and impulsive manner, including murder. If, on the other hand, we are devious and complicated, we do everything in a devious and complicated manner, including murder. What sort of people are we dealing in our story? Lieutenant, what am I getting out of you? Now, Mr. Ragland, while you were in that store, you did have an opportunity to doctor... What are you talking about? The owner of the store left you alone for several minutes while he went next door to...

Listen, Lieutenant, you've got to believe me. Now, you'd have been in the clear to tamper with that bottle. I don't know what you're talking about. I'm innocent. Now, look, Mr. Raglin, you gave me a lead. I followed it. But you're in just as deep as ever. I didn't poison the cognac. Well, if you didn't poison the cognac, who did? I don't know. Martin did. Now, you've said that before. Why would he want to kill his wife? Oh, okay. Yes? Because she was too good for him. In what way? In every way. She was delicate and aesthetic and he was kind of vulgar. And that would motivate him to kill her? That and Marguerite. Marguerite? Her maid. Oh, what about her? Hey, senior. Good looking. Sexy. Oh, Martindale was having an affair with her? How did you know? Well, that's what you're trying to say, isn't it?

Well, it's true. Everybody knows. Who's everybody? All of his friends. Her friends. Your friends? Well, that's not good enough. Would they be willing to swear to that in a court of law? Well... You know, these things that everyone knows usually come apart on the witness stand on the road. But it's true. All you have to do is look at them. Listen to the tone of their voices when they talk to each other. Oh, why didn't Emmett Martindale divorce his wife and marry the maid? A gentleman doesn't do that. Besides, you know... Poor, deluded way. Emma was madly in love with him. She wouldn't let him go. And that's why he took the opportunity to get rid of her. Yes, Mr. Edmunds. You don't believe. Well, could I believe you? In this country, a man is supposed to be innocent until he's proven. You'll be given a chance to prove you're innocent. He had some chance. The state has unlimited resources, money, manpower, experts. What have I got? Ah, look, Mr. Ratman, I don't create the...

set up. I just worked for it. Now let's go back to the beginning. You and Martindale were on the out. Why? We couldn't agree on anything. Mostly on how the business should be run. You see, he's the craziest human being in existence. He won't spend a dime on anything. I believe you have to spend it to make it. We fight each other constantly. Well, finally I decided we'd have to find a middle ground. It was his birthday, and I took the attention to send him a very expensive gift. Why not take him for $10 or $15? I don't know. Are you in the habit of giving people expensive gifts? No. Wasn't there a lot of defiance in this particular present? Hostility? Wasn't it your way of saying, see how generous I am and how cheap you are? Joey, maybe that's true. Then wouldn't you say the basic purpose of the gift was not to wish him well, but to irritate him? What if you're right?

What if I did it to an outrageous, shriveled, miserly, stingy soul? I hated him for being mean and blasting, but that doesn't prove I wanted to kill him. Ah, let's do any kind of a dozen of those clamps of regonauta guts. Can you be watching your diet, Lieutenant? Those clamps on that weight, they're precious. They're supposed to have a lot of cholesterol. Still and all, I can't think unless I eat. What do you get to think about? Oh, nothing, nothing so simple can happen to me. But noon today, a Mrs. Emma Martindale drinks from a glass which a guy named James Raglin sent to her husband as a birthday gift. It kills over. Good. The booze, despite, was poison. James Raglin missed the kill friend's husband. And some went wrong. Now, seven hours later, we have Mr. James Raglin in a cell. He'll be charged. The D.A.

He has enough to ask for an indictment. But I'm thinking. Yeah? It can't be this easy. It can't be this open and shut. There's something about this case that I just can't seem to get hold of. What's that? I don't know. I don't know, Gus. Listen, if you have any more of that key line cry, I'm going to talk to you. Do you? Why don't you leave just well enough alone? But thank you, Lieutenant Cooper. Very quickly and efficiently. You've gotten these statements from all the witnesses. I don't see how a jury can come up with anything to the verdict of guilty in the first degree. Now, Mr. D, none of this talk. See, I am not... Well, I, uh... With all the evidence? I, uh... Mr. Quentin, I'm just not sure. Why? I don't know why. What are you trying to tell me? Well, I know, I know. The case looks ironclad, but I think there's a leech here, and the whole thing can come out. There has to be a reason for the way you feel. What is it? Well, that's it. I don't know. Well, maybe I do.

It's just that I can't believe James Ragland is guilty. Why? Well, I know how this sounds, but I don't think he's one of those reasons. Look, Lieutenant, we've both been around a while. It happens every now and then. You get someone who you can't believe can be guilty. Mr. Hutch. Maybe it bothers you. I know exactly what you're talking about. This one does bother me. But we've got him. We've got him cold, Cooper. You know me. I'm not running for governor. It's as much a job to prove a man innocent as guilty. But James Ratner is 100% guilty. Well, it's too perfect. Ever ask yourself why every now and then somebody bothers you? Because guys like us, we always have it on our conscience that we may be railroading an innocent person. I understand. But not him. Yeah, yeah. But I still want to poke around. See if I can come up with something. Okay.

Since it bothers you. I'd be glad to help in any way I can, Lieutenant Creeper. Now, your full name is Marguerite Willis. How long have you worked for the military? Oh, eight years. Oh, that's a long time. What was your relationship with the family? My relationship? Mm-hmm. Well, I'm well treated, but I am a servant. Yeah. But you think there were rumors that your relationship with Mr. Martindale is, uh... It's another level. Oh, dear. Oh, they give rumors like that. If there's a woman servant in the house and if her face doesn't stop a clock, people always assume some hanky-panky with her husband. Oh, it's not a marriage. Those rumors don't bother me. Yeah, well, it's a question that has to be... Oh, I understand. And it's a line of investigation that has to be followed. Well, go ahead. You'll find anything.

The truth is, Mr. Martindale doesn't like women. That is, he has no romantic inclinations in that direction. If you know what I mean. No, I'm not sure I do. Well, he's completely involved with his work. He brings it home every night. How did he behave toward his wife? Oh, like a gentleman. Did they get along? Very well. Did they ever fight? They can't. Has somebody been talking to you? Oh, many people talk to me. Well, I'm in a very peculiar position here. Because of my job, I know certain things I have no right to discuss. But I have an idea someone is slandering Mr. Martindale. Mm-hmm. And I'm sure you have an idea who that someone is, assuming it is slander. Well, this conflict between Mr. Martindale and Mr. Raglan, it's...

Well, it wasn't only because they couldn't agree on how to run the business. Oh, but what I'm about to say isn't going to help him. But my loyalty has to be to my employers. He was in love with Mrs. Martindale, James Ragland was. He knew her before Mr. Martindale did. I even think they were engaged. Then he introduced her to Mr. Martindale, and the next thing everyone knew, Mr. Martindale and Emma were married. And Mr. Ragland never mentioned it. No, I guess not. Mr. Ragland would come here to see her regularly. I remember. It was all the same conversation. Darling, darling, Emma, darling. You made a mistake. Admit it, you don't love him. I do?

I love him. That isn't you saying it. It's your pride. If you make a mistake, you don't have to pay for it for the rest of your life. Just walk away from it. No. Look at what he does to you. What does he do to me? He neglects you. He abuses you. Jim, he's my husband. You didn't know what you were doing. Jim, don't. First of all... Now, this is history. And you might learn a lesson. Look at yourself. You've been wearing that same dress for three years. Oh. The man's a millionaire. You're starving to death in here. Oh, now, I would hardly say that I'm starving. I mean, your soul is starving. Your spirit. You've become dowdy. You haven't written a line of poetry since you're married. No one sees you anymore. I'm happy. I'm happy. Then you wouldn't care. One day, I will. He said that.

One day I will. Yes, Lieutenant. Thank you. Very helpful. Marjorie, you can't leave light burning when you're not at home. To meet, Lieutenant? Yes, I was just leaving. Mr. Marjorie, I almost went up with you. Yes. Are you sure? I can see him through the window. He's getting into his car. Oh, he's diving off. What did you buy me, baby? I reckon that's perfect good. What are we going to do with all this? Practically every one of them seems to be telling a lie. Well, maybe the lies will cancel out and we'll be left with the truth. Maybe the truths will cancel out and we'll be left with a lie. Nothing will happen until I return shortly with Act Three. Emma Martindale was killed when she drank some poison cognac. This much is definite. The rest...

is all loose end. We really don't know for a fact who put the poison into the bottle, nor do we know if Mrs. Martindale was the intended victim. Our knowledge is exceeded by ignorance, which, however, can be said of everyone, everywhere. You lied to me, James Radcliffe. You never told us you engaged Emma Martindale. Well, we once really engaged her. Now, you never said you were in love with her. You hated Martindale for taking it from you. Not really. I wonder if this holds vital information, but literally that's the same as mine. Now, do you deny saying to Emma, I could kill him? I didn't you also say one day I will kill him? Well, I may have said something like that. I didn't mean it that way. Well, then why did you say it? Because a man gets mad, gets drunk, and says a lot of things he doesn't mean.

I know it looks bad. You don't know how bad. But I'm innocent, no matter what. Okay, I should have told you about the way things were between Emma and me. It was a mistake. But I was scared. You can't quit on me. You have to help me. Now, I went to the DA. I stuck my neck out for you, and all the time you were holding out on me. I told you, I was afraid. Now, that's the end of the line. I'm getting off this train because it just isn't going anywhere. Got garlic bread? Yeah. Let's see. I didn't say you were going to go someplace else. Gus, Gus, I have some heavy thinking to do. About what? About the same flag that he got. You still feel he didn't do it? Now, believe me, Gus, I'd like it if he did it, but the package is still too neat. Even though he's been lying to you? Yep. Even though he's got the motive? That's the trouble. He's got everything. What's he doing? Well, you ain't going to enjoy your dinner. I know, I know. It's going to spoil the place.

What do you mean? It's all running around in my head, Gus. I just knew something would happen to make it stand for a minute so I could sort it out. Give it time. Look, I'll start with the salad. But, Gary, what did you say? I said, okay. No, no, no, no, no. You said, give it time. Time, time. Do you realize, Gus, that this whole thing is based on time? Time is a crime out loud. It's been right out there in front of me all along.

How long did you say it took for her to swallow the drink? In a couple of minutes, she's dead, right? Now they call the ambulance immediately. The request was made at 12 noon. It arrived six minutes later at 12.06. Yeah, but don't you see? The question is, when did she drink it? Mr. Barnaby, how many bottles of Dustin's coffee? Are you kidding? At that price? I just kept the one. And there's no way anyone could have sneaked in here and replaced the bottle of Dustin's. You had with one that had been poisoned, huh? In the first place, I got a special protection system, see? And there's only one key to the store. I never let go of it. And besides, there's the burglar alarm. Now, Dave Draplin came in yesterday to buy the cognac, huh? Yeah, I told you all that. Now, this was just before 11 o'clock. Oh, yeah? And you gift-wrapped it. Look, I'm prepared to testify to that effect in court. He wanted immediate delivery.

So I went next door to see if the grocer's delivery boy was around. All right. All right. Now answer this. Where was your delivery boy? Well, it turns out he had a little accident on his motorbike on the way downtown. I see. In the normal way, would he have been here in the morning? Oh, sure. It's his job. Yeah. Now, when Mr. Raglan bought the cognac, he assumed you could deliver it at once. Yeah. Oh, yeah. Yeah. All right. Now, he would have no way of knowing your delivery boy was unavailable. Even I didn't know that. The bottle on the shelf had to be good. You're not kidding, so then. If your boy had been here, he would have taken the bottle and gone to deliver it, and there'd be no way for Raglan to tamper with it, right? He couldn't have planned to use this method to commit murder. I'm glad to hear you say that, Lieutenant. All right, now one further question. Yeah? Is this the bottle that you sold to Mr. Raglan?

Yes, sir. It's got the Dunstant label, see? And on the bottom, it's got my own sticker. Barnaby's Better Stick. Examine it very carefully. Now, this is the bottle that contains the poison cognac, Mrs. Martindale-Grant. Is it the same bottle you delivered? Oh, yes. It contains... Oh, wait a minute. Wait a minute. Hold a second now. Now, this is the wrong bottle, sir. There was never any Dunstant cognac in this bottle. Why not? Well, look, it may look like a bottle of Dunstant's, but Dunstant's doesn't use this particular bottle. Here, look at the bottle. You see the little raised letters here? It says K.R. Now, that stands for Kruger's. Now, there's a theory that they don't even make cognac. Then this can't be the bottle you delivered to the Martindale house, huh? No way. But the switch had to be made somewhere. This is not the same bottle you sold Raglan. Oh, this is Lieutenant Cooper speaking. Sergeant.

You got a call earlier to send an ambulance to a Mrs. Martindale. The record says noon. I want you to check that book of yours. Make sure it wasn't about a quarter after 11. I see. It was the first call you took when you came on at 12. Thank you, Patrick. I need some money. But I gave you money yesterday. It's gone. Gone? Yesterday is gone, too. But you just can't go around spending money as if it's... That's what money says. Well, you're just going to have to learn. Money has to be saved. Protected against waste. The way she landed. Emma was quite prudent where money was concerned. Petey, if you want to make me into another Emma, why did you get rid of her in the first place? You must never say that, even when we're alone. Oh, the only things we should say to each other when we're alone is I love you. Now, I should go shopping. Marguerite, I say I'm going to have to teach you some basic facts of economics. You're not going to teach me anything.

I'm going to teach you. Well, it seems to me you're forgetting who you are. I could fire you on the spot. And I could walk out of here and report to the nearest police station. What are you talking about? I'm talking about a bottle of Dunstan's Cognac. And everything that happened to it from the moment I took it from the delivery man to the moment Emma drank it. Well, you wouldn't. I mean, that's... Who's that? See who it is? I can see who it is from here out the window. That detective. That's his car at the curb. What can he see down here? He was just here a few hours ago. Don't start looking nervous. I suppose he suspects. What can he suspect? How can he suspect? Answer the door. I have to see him. Yes, Lieutenant. What can I do for you? I'm finishing my report. I want to be sure I have everything. Unless Willis, you answer the door. Mr. Barnaby was here.

Well, I don't know if his name was Mr. Barnaby. And you accepted a gift-wrapped package. You brought it in here, and you, sir, opened the package and summoned Mrs. Martindale. You uncorked the bottle, poured a drink for her and a drink for yourself. Yes, I. Now, immediately, she became fatally ill. You had Miss Willis here call for an ambulance. I believe I've already made a statement, as I say. Now, Miss Willis, after Mr. Martindale asked you to summon an ambulance, how long did it take you to do so? Oh, no time at all. I heard himself. I lifted the phone. I dialed the police emergency number, and I was connected in, well, maybe five, ten seconds. But how much then, Miss Willis? How long was it from the time you accepted the package from the delivery man to the time Mrs. Martindale took that fatal drip? How long? Yes. Well, it couldn't have been more than five minutes. It might have been less.

You see, it all happened so quickly. Yes, well, we agreed then on five minutes. Now, Mr. Barnaby says he delivered that package to you at about ten minutes after eleven. Five minutes after the delivery, you placed the call for an ambulance. Well, hasn't that been abundantly clear by this time, Lieutenant? Yeah, well, unfortunately, it poses a problem. What sort of problem? Well, somehow we have lost or mislaid 45 minutes. What do you mean? Well, we can't account for the 45 minutes that elapsed between the time you say Mrs. Martindale drank the cognac and the time you say you called the ambulance. But I called the ambulance immediately. Yeah, but you didn't call for it at 11.15. You see, the police records show that the call came in exactly at 12 noon. Well, we may have been mistaken at the time. Yeah, well, unfortunately, we can prove the cognac was delivered at about 10 after 11.

And you are already on record as having said you opened it and Mrs. Martindale drank it five minutes later. Well, we... I was just that nervous. Didn't get to open the cognac until five minutes to noon. There. Oh. So, uh, you're changing your story, then? It's my right upon sober consideration. Yeah, but that means that Miss Willis will also have to change her story. Of course. Are you changing your story, Miss Willis? Now, Marguerite, you get to tell him we were mistaken. Now, before you answer, Miss Willis, let me account for the discrepancy in time. There was no discrepancy. Now, the package is delivered. You see the note, Mr. Martindale. It says to Emmett on your birthday to be slowly signed Jim Radcliffe. Now, you say to yourself, what a way to get rid of Jim and my wife at the same time. Now, just a minute. So, you go to your laboratory. You get some hydrocyanic acid.

This is all... Now, now, the thing to do is to pour some hydrocyanic acid into the bottle of Dunstan's cognac and then reseal it. Now, but you're basically a stingy man. Why ruin the exceptional cognac, huh? So you remove the Dunstan's label and the liquor store sticker and you fix them onto a cheap bottle of whiskey. I'll see you for defamation. Now, you work very carefully. Take nearly 45 minutes. And then you call your wife. Play the little charade with her, get her to drink the poison liquor, and have Miss Willis phone for the ambulance. This brings us to 12 noon, and now it's time to reckon. Are you daring to offer me a Dunstan that should be right here in the liquor cabinet? Oh, you have no right to open my liquor cabinet. Now, this bottle here, without a label. Now, can you look at some raised letters on the bottom of the bottle? You see? Little raised letters spelling Dunstan. Well, Miss Willis, might you read?

He can't be, will he? What does he offer you, 20 years to life, even a chair? Marguerite, he's bluffing. He does have money, but will he be more generous with you than he was with his wife? Marguerite gives nothing away, even when it costs him nothing. Now, that bottle of Dustin, had he not wasted precious time, had he just poured the poison into it, he would have been in the clear, but no, he's so cheap, he wouldn't even use good whiskey to poison his wife. So now he has to pay the price. Marguerite, don't you... see what he's doing. Lieutenant, he's, he's talking to kill me. Who was it that said the cheapest way always costs more in the end? At any rate, the jury felt that Marguerite was a helpless tool. Oh, she'll be released shortly after a short stay in jail. Emmett will never be released. He has a lifetime career in the prison library.

He also teaches chemistry in the prison school. So, at least our story has some redeeming social value. And I shall return with even more values. To see suddenly a multitude of possibilities in what is on the surface only a confused mass. And to examine a single drop of water and divine therein the scheme. of the universe. Opportunity of all kinds surrounds us constantly for good, for evil, and for seven times each week to listen to this program. Our cast included Larry Haynes, Leon Johnny, Cork Benson, Sam Gray, and Joan Shea. The entire production is under the direction of Hyman Brown. Radio Mystery Theater was sponsored in part by Buick Motor Division.

and Anheuser-Busch Incorporated, Brewers of Budweiser. This is E.G. Marshall inviting you to return to our mystery theater for another adventure in the macabre. Until next time, pleasant...

End of transcriptBack to the beginning ↑