The written record
Read the transcript
Read along with the recording · About 22 min to read
The CBS Radio Mystery Theater presents... Come in. Welcome. I'm E.G. Marshall. William Alger, a clergyman of these parts, a hundred years ago was asked about fate. And he said, fate is the friend of the good, the guide of the wise, the tyrant of the foolish, and the enemy of the bad. Do we agree or disagree? Whether fate is friend or enemy, we're about to discover in the unusual tale we have chosen for you today.
Unsolved crimes, Henry. The books are full of them. Murderers have gone away clean. Well, take your own family. Your Uncle Joseph was mysteriously poisoned. No one will ever be found guilty.
I could explain his death.
You could? What's your guess?
It's no guess. I know who murdered him.
Really? Who did?
I did.
Henry, are you joking?
No, I'm deadly serious.
Our mystery drama, Guilty, adapted from a story by Edith Wharton, was written especially for the Mystery Theater by G. Frederick Lewis and stars Paul Hecht. I'll be back shortly with Act One.
I don't know how it is where you live, but in the big cities in the USA, success is measured by address. So when attorney Peter Ashton welcomes a client into his Park Avenue office, you can be sure Peter is successful in the legal profession. As for his client, Henry Graham, how successful is he?
I don't think I can answer that.
I haven't seen you in a long time. Everything going well?
Oh, Peter, not bad, not bad, but not so good either.
Isn't that what you lawyers would call an equivocal answer? What can I do for you?
Peter, we've known each other for quite a few years. Well, this is going to be harder for me to say than I thought it would.
But take your time.
I've always felt that you were more than just my lawyer. Not that you've gotten very rich representing me, but I've always thought of you as a friend.
Well, so have I. And I'm not only a friend, but a fan. I've said to you many times, you get one of your plays on Broadway and I'll sell enough tickets to my clients to keep you open for months.
It's not going to happen.
Don't tell me you're going to Hollywood.
I wish. No, I'm not going to make it. In ten years, I've had one play, off-Broadway, and six rejections. Six plays that never got off a desk in a producer's office.
Well, I've read your plays, not all of them, Henry, and... Well, I think you're off your head to give up now. Why now, Henry?
You know what they tell me? Producers, directors, agents? I lack imagination. My work doesn't ring true. People don't talk like that. Then a month ago, it came to me. What was wrong. But I can't face it alone. That's why I had to see you.
Well, I'm sorry it couldn't have been sooner, but I've been up to my ears with Mrs. Leslie Ashgrove. You've read about her. Handling her assailant... Oh, you've met the famous and now rich Mrs. Ashgrove. What's your opinion?
About the death of her husband? Yeah. My opinion, Henry, is that nothing will ever be known about who poisoned him. Whoever did it will never be discovered. An unsolved crime. Another unsolved crime. The books are full of them. Come to think of it, take your own family. Your Uncle Joseph, who also died mysteriously. Poisoned, wasn't it? No one will ever be found guilty, person or persons unknown.
I could explain his death.
You could? What's your guess?
It's no guess. I know who murdered him.
Really? Who did?
I did.
There's a playwright for you.
I'm serious. I'm deadly serious.
Sure, sure. So am I. Well, so you murdered your uncle ten years ago to inherit his money, right?
That wasn't the main reason. You never knew my sister. My sister, Kathleen. She was older than I was. A lovely girl in so many ways. No, no, you didn't know her. She died before you and I met. Yes, it was partly for money I killed him. I needed it for her.
Henry, is this some kind of dramatic scene you're trying out to see if it'll play?
It's no drama. It's truth. It happened. That's why I've turned out to be what I am.
Peter?
Because I killed Uncle Joseph. It's always there. Whatever I'm writing, my characters won't say what I want them to say. My words are fake, unbelievable. My life, all of it is a constant cover-up of hatred and guilt. You can't have reservations when you write. You can't fake people's emotions. You have to feel them yourself and... Can you help me?
Well, I can listen, Henry. Ten years ago, I had everything going for me.
Was that when your first off-Broadway play opened?
Yes, my first and only play. My sister Kathleen stayed home. She should have been in the hospital, but I didn't have the money to swing it. I was hoping the play would be a hit. I'd make some money and I could take good care of her. Opening night, I was standing in a corner by the door as the play ended.
Hello, I'm Robin Draper. You're Henry Graham, aren't you?
Yes, I am. I thought so. I write for the Village News. We ran a picture of you when you went into rehearsal. I took the picture.
I'm sorry, I didn't see you.
Oh, I take the pictures, I write the stories, I sell advertising space, and tonight I'm the drama critic. Henry, I love the play, and I hope it's got a long run ahead of it.
Miss Draper...
Robin.
Robin, you may be the only person who likes the play this much. I don't want you to vanish on me.
I won't.
I suppose you have to run back to your newspaper and write your criticism fast to get it in the morning edition.
No, no, I don't. The Village News is a weekly. Let's go across the street for coffee.
Well, just what I was going to suggest.
On me, Henry. You see, this is the first time I've met a playwright of a play I loved. So, coffee's on me.
Oh, no.
Henry?
Henry, you wrote the play. I'll get the coffee.
So, you see, Robin, I'm the only one there is to take care of my sister. TB isn't getting any better.
Well, if I become famous and that helps pay for her special treatments, that's okay. About once a week I take Kathleen to the clinic for tests, but we're kidding ourselves. She doesn't need any more tests. She needs special treatments in a hospital.
Kathleen is the Kathy of your play?
Yeah, yeah. And her father is me. Helpless, but, well, mean. And the man at the end of your play who comes knocking on the door and you, well, you just know there's hope. Is he based on someone you know?
No. There's nobody like that in our family. There's only one person who has money and that's my Uncle Joseph. And the only reason he's got it is that he's never given any away. No, he doesn't spell hope to me.
Well, I'm predicting here and now, Henry. Henry? We're going to write more and more plays and more and more people will listen.
I know, Robin, but when?
Well, maybe it'll take time. But it'll happen.
I don't know that I can wait that long.
Sure, they like my one and only play. But they said it was too special to move uptown to Broadway and next time I ought to write something more commercial. Kathleen, my sister. Doctors at the clinic just shook their heads. Henry. They said that if Kathleen didn't get the right treatment soon, they didn't know how long she could hang on. These treatments were very expensive.
Henry, what are you doing staring out the window?
I just decided something.
To Renfield and see Uncle Joseph. I know he's tight, but he's getting along in years. He's our only relative.
You can't ask him for money just like that.
Why not? I need it now, not when he's gone.
My boy, I don't know what occasion this visit. Don't know why, after all these years, you suddenly had to see me, but now that you're here, just look at these melons and tell me if you have ever in your whole life seen anything to equal this.
No, I never have, Uncle. How many greenhouses have you here?
Three. The first one's where we grow the more exotic melons.
Well, one looks more delicious than the next.
I wouldn't know about that. I grow them for the farm shows and the county fairs because I like to look at them. But I can't eat them. Buttermilk and toast. It's all I'm allowed. It's time for my nap. So we'll talk later, huh? What's the matter with you, Henry? You always have that worried expression on your face?
Uncle Joseph, it's Kathleen. I'm concerned about her. You should have brought her.
Well, she has TB, and I don't have any money for the special treatments which could cure her.
What do you do for a living?
I've written a play, and I've started another.
You can't eat plays. How do you eat?
Oh, I'm a waiter in a coffee house in the village.
Your sister, how old is she?
Twenty, thirty?
No, she's thirty-five.
Never married?
Always been sickly. I've been taking care of her.
Well, my advice to you, Henry, is don't worry. Be cheerful. No one likes to see a man who frowns. You have to cultivate a smile.
I do.
I stayed on a few days, trying everything I could to make this ugly creature understand that Kathleen's health was worth at least as much as the care of half a dozen of those acres of melons with their thermometers and humidity controls and all the gadgets and... and gardeners that went with his expensive hobby. But Uncle Joseph was so self-centered, I knew it was useless. I went to say goodbye to him. He was in his pet greenhouse. When I got there, the glass door was open from the inside, and the head gardener ran out, slamming it shut behind him.
And, Mario, don't you dare ever show your face in here again, or I'll have the police after you.
What is it, Uncle? What happened?
Just look at it. And did you ever see... Such a beauty. Do you know what that Mario did? This was my prize cassava. I told him to pick it for the county fair tomorrow. Do you see what that idiot did? Dropped his trowel right on the melon. Look at that gash. It cost me a blue ribbon.
I'm sorry, Uncle, but I'm afraid I can't stay here any longer. I'm worried about Kathleen.
All right, to Washington. He's probably here illegally. Oh, I'll make him pay. Will you look at that melon? It's a crime.
Uncle, will you listen to me?
You're right, Henry. You're right. I should calm myself. Bad for the heart.
Please, I've tried to ask you before. Can't you possibly give me a loan? I'll leave the amount to you. I think it's your niece, Kathleen. It's not her fault she has this condition.
Henry, you're getting all red in the face.
Just a little. Just a little. Just a little money. You wouldn't even feel it, and it could help cure her. I guarantee on my word to pay you back. I have a half-written play, a wonderful play. I'd give that to you as security.
A half-written play as security? That meant it's too much for me. I can feel my heart pounding. I'm going to my room to lie down.
I decided this horrible and selfish old man should not live, and it was up to me to kill him. The fact that I would inherit some of his money when he died didn't matter nearly as much as stopping his breath forever. But how to do it? To murder without getting caught. Without getting caught. A question asked since Cain slew his brother. Those who were driven to dealing death often regard the killing as their duty. Desperation silencing morals, the sense of wrong, and stifling conscience. Henry Graham is in exactly such a predicament as we shall see when I return shortly with Act Two.
In Exodus of the Good Book, we read, Eye for eye, tooth for tooth, hand for hand, burning for burning, wound for wound, life for life. It was this that fired Henry Graham to action. And it is these events leading to the murder of his uncle he now tells to his lawyer.
So that was ten years ago, Henry?
Yes, Peter. Almost to the month. I left Renfield. And came back to the city. No plan. I just knew I shouldn't let him live. While I was awake, Kathleen's condition got worse. A week later, the telephone rang. It was Uncle Joseph. I prayed that he had changed his mind. But my prayers were not answered.
So what did he want?
He withheld his two-week severance pay.
What he done to me? Next Sunday. About your diet. If a melon would...
Was fate, Peter. My chance. He called on a Tuesday. And Sunday was five days away. I could do it.
Excuse me, Henry.
Yes.
Tell them I'll be with them in a minute.
Henry, when you began this confession of yours, I had no idea it would take so much time.
Stanner. We met last night at the theater.
I see. And you were following me.
Henry, I was not following you. I was there to see the play, just as Miss Draper was.
Then why are you here now?
Because the district attorney's office asked me to be here. I've been consulted about your case.
My case? So there is a case?
Mr. Graham, please sit down. Dr. Stanner, Miss Draper, I think we should all be candid with Henry. Mr. Graham, we've investigated your story thoroughly. The garage on 20th Street? It was torn down twelve years ago, not ten. There never was a car rental operation there. Professor Dawes? He died in 1955, fifteen years ago, at the age of 72, not 96. And he lived in Boston, not New York. The poison you claim to have used? We had the body exhumed. There was no trace of poison in your uncle's remains. He died of a heart attack, just as the original coroner's report stated.
Then the melon...
Your uncle didn't eat melon that morning. The servants confirmed it. The melon in the refrigerator was thrown out unused because it had spoiled.
But Robin, you remember. You spoke for me at the inquest.
Henry, I spoke for you because I believed you were working that night. And you were here when I arrived. But I never knew where you'd been before that.
Then I didn't... I didn't kill him?
There's no evidence that anyone killed him, Mr. Graham. Except perhaps you, in your own mind.
But why? Why would I imagine such a thing?
Dr. Stanner?
Mr. Graham, you've told us yourself. Your sister died because there was no money for treatment. Your plays were rejected. You felt beaten, worthless, at forty. The mind can be... merciful, in its way. It can give us what we need. For some, that's forgetfulness. For others, it's purpose. Even if that purpose is punishment.
You mean I wanted to be guilty?
I mean you needed to be guilty. Guilt is a kind of company, Mr. Graham. It fills the silence. And if you're punished, you're noticed. You're real.
Then what do I do now?
That depends on whether you can accept a different truth. A harder one, perhaps. That your uncle died of natural causes. That you are innocent. That you must find another way to fill your life than with confession and remorse.
I don't know if I can.
Mr. Graham, we've asked Dr. Stanner to recommend a course of treatment. Not because you're insane, but because you're suffering. Will you accept help?
I... I don't know. Robin?
Henry, I've known you a long time. I've watched you destroy yourself with this... this story. Please. Let someone help you find the real one.
The real story.
Yes.
I sat there, in that office, with three people looking at me with something I hardly recognized. Concern. Not suspicion, not duty, but care. And I thought of Kathleen, who had loved me. Of the plays I had written, the ones that failed and the ones still in me. Of Robin, who had not forgotten me after all.
I'll try.
Good. That's all we ask, Mr. Graham. That you try.
I left the district attorney's office that afternoon with Robin. We walked for a long time without speaking. At last, she stopped at a coffee shop, the same one where we'd gone after the theater.
Henry, do you remember what I said to you? When we first met again? I never forget voices, faces, or dreams.
I remember.
Then don't forget this. You have a voice. You have a face. And you still have dreams. The real question is whether you'll use them.
I looked at her, and for the first time in ten years, I felt something other than guilt. I felt possibility. Uncertain, fragile, but real.
I'll write to you, Robin. I'll send you a play.
You'd better. I'm still an art critic, you know. I'll be harsh.
I know.
And I smiled. It felt strange, like a language I'd forgotten. But I remembered.
This is E.G. Marshall inviting you to return to our Mystery Theater for another adventure in the macabre. Until next time, pleasant dreams.
Stanner, the psychiatrist.
Yes, I am.
Mr. Green, why did you do that to me? Send a psychiatrist.
Because I looked into your story and there's nothing to it.
Henry, please. Everyone here wants to have—
I want to know why the assistant D.A. played such a trick on me.
I had to. It's part of my business. In fact, Dr. Stanner is a detective. Every doctor is.
Oh? And what did he detect?
Well, it's overwork, Graham. Yours is not an uncommon form of hallucination.
Dr. Stanner, I killed my uncle.
Gentlemen, I think we've gone about as far as we can on this investigation. The taxpayers would be up in arms if we spent any more time on it. Dr. Stanner, I appreciate your work.
Henry, let's go somewhere. Just you and me. Henry, I'm going to cook us a little supper. Now, you put your feet up and look at the papers. There's a whole pile. Read one of them and tell me what you think.
I'm tired. All I've been doing in the past few weeks is running around trying to prove something. I couldn't stop.
Uh, Robin?
Yes?
Why are you wasting time with me?
Because you're in trouble and I'd like to help?
Robin, come here.
I'm preparing something for us to eat.
It can wait. Come here, will you?
Okay, my friend. Move over on this sofa so I can sit. Why do you want to help me?
I just want to. I'd like you to have some peace of mind.
I'm not going to stop now. I have to prove I'm the murderer.
Henry, wouldn't it be better if you just closed the book on it?
Sure. Sure, it would be better. I can't. There's got to be some way of finding the man I rented the car from. Some relative of Jim Dawes who knew he was a chemist and how he made poisons.
No one believes that.
Tell you what else. Old Joseph had a housekeeper, a Mrs. Cruz. Yeah, maybe she knows something. Maybe my fingerprints are somewhere in the kitchen near the refrigerator. I've got to go up there and look around. If Renfield is still standing, they wreck a lot of those old estates.
Robin, I wish you wouldn't keep doing that.
Doing what?
Whenever I come up with something, you knock it down.
Henry. Henry, I'm your friend. I'm just trying to be logical.
I don't need that kind of friendship. About everything I've said and do something about it. Try everything you can to prove I'm guilty. You've got to.
Oh, if that's what you want, sure. But what if I can't? What if none of the people or things you talk about are around anymore?
Robin, this isn't going to settle this. Even if I have to kill again to prove it.
It's Robin Draper. Graham is here. He's been here all evening and I think he's not well. I'm hiding in my bedroom and I can't leave my apartment. 724 East 72nd. Knock on the superintendent downstairs. He'll have a pass key. Where? He's dozing on the sofa, I think. Oh, please, get over here as fast as you can.
I don't know what happened then. I would never have hurt Robin. I don't care what they say. But it's turned out all right. They asked me to stay in this place and take it easy. I sort of lose track of the time. But the day my lawyer, Peter, came with Robin, I'm not likely to forget that.
Hello, Henry. It's good to see you.
Hello, Peter. They said I had two visitors. Who's the other?
Well, there she is.
Miss Draper. My darling, Henry. Such a long time. May I kiss you?
You're embarrassing me.
Robin? Robin, what is it? You're crying.
No. It's all right, Henry. He looks so much better than the last time, doesn't he, Peter?
Much better.
Have you two been here before to see me?
Yes.
Well, I don't know. I don't know. I don't know. I don't know. I don't know. I don't know. I don't know. I don't know. I don't know. I don't know. I don't know. I don't know. I don't know.
You're not—ah?
I don't remember that.
You're safe here. And we'll come to visit you as much as you like.
How long is it? How long?
Yes, that... that I... that I've been here.
Well, we won't bother you with numbers.
How are they treating you?
Oh, great. Just... just great. Once I got to know the people here, I explained to them how I killed Uncle Joseph. They... they're very interested in it. I've taken the time to write a more complete statement of how I killed him. I had been a little vague before. For instance, about Mrs. Cruz, the housekeeper. That night in the kitchen when I put the poison in the melon, I heard a noise and got out of there fast. But when I was closing the door behind me, I saw her and she saw me. It's all in here, Peter. I've written it all down. See what you can do, okay? And let me know next time.
Robin, when are you coming here again?
Are you politely telling us to go?
There's a play producer who happens to be staying here. He wants to talk to me about a production.
Peter, be sure you read that statement carefully, huh? Find out everything you can so that I can take my punishment.
Henry, stop that.
What?
I'm not going to let you ask us to get you convicted and then talk about putting on a play in the same breath. Do you want to be accused of your uncle's murder or not?
Of course. Publicity value. Author of this season's Broadway smash hit awaits his final curtain in death row.
Peter, do you mind? Before we head back to town, my knees are kind of buckling under me. Let's sit a moment on this bench. I'm a little shaky myself.
He's worse. It's almost a joke. And he's still convinced that he did it. There's no shaking him out of that, is there?
Robin, there's something I have to tell you. Something I learned the day before yesterday. Thanks to you and that tip you gave me about the housekeeper, Mrs. Cruz. I found her, what he said. She did see him, but said nothing about it when they questioned her because she thought she must have been dreaming. She couldn't believe... Henry would have poisoned his uncle. So she suspected the person she saw in the kitchen was the gardener who had been fired.
It was Henry, after all.
Yes.
So what do we do now?
Oh, what can we do? The housekeeper say anything?
No, she's scared out of her wits.
Peter, I say we do nothing. Henry is being punished. And the punishment may go on for years in this place. But it's his crime he wants to be punished for. I won't be responsible for giving him the death he wants.
Say, Peter, you could live with the knowledge that you sent him to his death?
It's been said that a neurotic is a man who builds a castle in the air. A psychotic is a man who lives in it. And a psychiatrist is a man who collects the rent. In the case of Henry Graham, we hope the landlord will effect the cure. I shall return shortly. Round out this story of Henry Graham. And I ask myself, should he be forgiven or forgotten? I am reminded it was Robert Louis Stevenson who said that there is so much good in the worst of us and so much bad in the best of us that it behooves all of us not to talk about the rest of us.
Our cast included Paul Hecht, Joyce Gordon, Lloyd Battista, and Ray Owens. The entire production was under the direction of Hyman Brown. This is E.G. Marshall inviting you to return to our Mystery Theater for another adventure in the macabre. Until next time. Pleasant dreams.
