Skip to content
On Air
All channelsAll
CBS Radio Mystery Theater artwork

From the CBS Radio Mystery Theater collection

How to Kill Rudy

Episode 558December 2, 197642 min 47 secTranscript

Writer: Himan Brown

The written record

Read the transcript

Read along with the recording · About 19 min to read

I'm E.G. Marshall. You cannot fly like an eagle with the wings of a wren. Ordinarily, this proposition would be only of interest to wrens, and not to all wrens either. Just those tiny puny birds who have an eagle's mentality. Well, fate plays her ironic little jokes on us all, doesn't she? Sometimes the smallest people get the biggest ideas. The piranha, a fish that's half the size of your little finger. is more than a match for the whale, which could be twice the size of your house. Our mystery drama, How to Kill Rudy, was written especially for the Mystery Theater by Sam Dan and stars Paul Hecht. Sponsored in part by Buick Motor Division and Anheuser-Busch Incorporated, Brewers of Budweiser. I'll be back shortly with Act One. The nutritionist will say, you are what you eat.

There may be some validity to that, but isn't it also true that you are what you read? The ideas, the principles that govern your life, where did they come from? Did you just create them out of nothing? Or did you read about them somewhere? So many books do not end on the last page. Good morning, Lieutenant Foster. Now, if you're going to call me Lieutenant Foster, I'll have to call you the sleigh maker, huh? I thought we'd become friends by now. Joe and Rudy. I appreciate your efforts to help me, but... Come on, Rudy, you'll feel better after you tell us. Why can't we just leave things the way they are? I killed them. I admit I killed them. I'm willing to pay for killing them. There are plenty of other crimes you could be concerned. Judy, it's one of those mornings. I can see that. I'll drop by after lunch. Anything I can bring you? Oh, yeah, yeah. There's a new book out by Mace...

Hacker. Sure. Yeah, he writes the best murder mysteries in the world. Don't you read it? No. To tell you the truth, after a hard day's homicide, my taste runs to Stendhal and Tim Opperson. Yeah, well, Mace Hacker is truly a giant of literature. This is the last book that's been published. I've got the book for you, Rudy. I could also bring you some of the critical essays of that at Toll Farm. No, thank you. I prefer Mace Hacker.

Oh, dear, I had no idea it was so late. Oh, it's all right. No, it's not all right. A wife should make her husband's breakfast before he leaves for work. Well, all I ever want is coffee. That's easy enough. No, you want more than coffee, and my job is... Uh, dearest, I'll miss my bus. Oh, Rudy, darling, you're so kind. So patient, so understanding. I can see you're sleepy. You just go back to bed. Oh, darling, you're so good to me. I love you, Ramona. And I love you. Must have missed the bus. Jack Jessup glowers at me if I come in late. He glowers by that mean old thing. Although recently he's taken a coming in late himself. Is that so? Yeah. Some days he doesn't get in till 10.30, 11 o'clock. Something ought to be done about that. What? He's the boss, darling.

And besides, the less I see of him, the more work I can get done. Oh, you're just too nice for your own good. Well, I can't finish my coffee. I have to run. That's how it was at home with my wonderful Ramona. Of course, at the office, I didn't have an easy time of it. Because Jack Jessup was not an easy man to work for. Rudy, why didn't we bid on this Northside project? How could you be so... I mean, the biggest job in town, we didn't even... Jack. I don't want to hear any excuses now. Jack, look, uh... The fact of the matter is you're losing your grip. If you read the morning paper... Ah, yes, what else are we missing out on? Did you look at the paper? Oh, for crying out loud, I'm sitting here talking business. You're shoving a newspaper at me. What do I care who made it who? The Northside Project is on the front page. Yeah, sure, it's making history. What are we getting out of it? We're getting out of it with our lives. It's bankrupt. It folded. All the contractors are stuck. Now, let me see that. Well, sure.

What did anybody expect? You know that gang that's in there. They've been involved in one shady deal after another. Well, we'll see if their city hall connection is keeping them out of jail this time. What'd I tell you? The minute I heard who was in it, keep away from that Northside project. Isn't that what I always said? Yeah, that's what you always said. As I recall, you suggested preparing a bid, didn't you? Well, let this be a lesson. Look behind the corporation. And doesn't this prove it? Oh, yeah, yeah, sure does. Jack Jessup, owner of Jessup & Company Electrical Contractors, the most difficult man to work for. These days, a job is a job. Why do you put up with him, darling? Oh, I have a rather pacific temperament, as you know, Ramona. Oh, but still, darling. Besides, I understand him. You see, he was an all-American football player at college. He was a hero, a celebrated man of importance.

Afterward, well, there are what are known as triumphs of the flesh. Triumphs of the flesh? What an odd phrase. Where did you get it? I read it somewhere. And I know where. Mace Hacker. Yeah, I know it's fashionable to make fun of Mace Hacker, but his insights... Yes, dear. We were discussing... Triumphs of the flesh. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Well, these were the triumphs Jack Jessup knew very well. He graduated, grew older, and then... Well, the body no longer rules supreme. It's business. You do all the work. Well, yeah, he knows that and resents it. You should be told in no uncertain terms. It doesn't matter, darling. Believe me, it doesn't matter. I was happy. I didn't mind my job. It was just an interlude. The important part of my life was the time I spent with Ramona and reading. Mace Hacker is, without a doubt, the most...

prolific writer in the world. A new novel comes out almost every month, and each one is better than the last. Why, I ask myself, am I so enthralled by Mace Hacker? Look, I do have taste, and he deals in sex. Well, so does Shakespeare for that. But Mace Hacker, when his language is so explicit, nothing is left to your imagination. I found the answer. I was rereading an old Mace Hacker.

Ramona. What is it, Rudy? Do you remember reading about the man who murdered those three women? Darling, why do you bring up such a gruesome subject? What was his name? I'm sure I don't remember. His name was George, wasn't it? Yes, it was George. Yeah, and the three girls. One was Felicia, the other was Prudence, and the third was Charity. Very good. So you remember, too. No, I don't remember. The papers. Only last month. This crime, this triple murder, it came to light last month, correct? Yes. This is a Mace Hacker novel, published seven years ago. The murders are described here minutely. Well, the story of a man who murders three women, what's so special about that? It tells exactly how he murdered the women, why he murdered them, and their names. There must be an explanation. Ramona, darling.

He predicted these murders some seven years ago. It's uncanny. I'll say it again. There must be an explanation. Happened years after the killer book was published. I went back almost 20 years. And sure enough, all the murderers and all the victims had the exact same names as they bore in the Mace Hackers. It was, it was a fact. Somehow, Hackers' annual goal. I'm a rather indifferent goal. for myself poor, actually, but Jack insists on the same foursome because he, being a scratch golfer, has an opportunity to feel superior. Keep your head down, Rudy. You're bending that elbow. Don't sway. Well, what do you expect? In the rough again. Listen, you were lucky you hit the ball at all. Well, fellas, we may as well help Rudy find his ball.

Do you see any signs of it, Mr. Slaymaker? I don't believe so, Mr. Tallow. I don't think we'll ever find that ball. I'll put a new one in play. I'm just slowing up the game. Oh, no hurry, no hurry. It's such a lovely day, I'd rather sit under a tree like this one here and just read. Yeah. Yeah, so would I. As a matter of fact, I wish I could sneak back to the locker room and get my favorite book. Oh, what's that? The latest Mace Hacker mystery. The triumphs of the flesh. Hey, that's fantastic. Why, why, are you a Mace Hacker fan? Oh, from way back. I've read all 140 Mace Hacker mysteries. 140 and one. No, I think you're mistaken, Mr. Tallow. Oh, no, no, no, I'm sure I'm quite right. If you read your jacket on the latest Mace Hacker book, it says the 140...

Oh, I know it says that, but it happens to be wrong. You see, this particular publisher has brought out 140. Yeah, but that's his only publisher. No, no, no, no. The very first Mace Hacker was called... Yeah, I know what it was called, Death is a Lonely Woman. I'm sorry, but that's not so. Mr. Tallow, I don't like to boast, but I can name all 140 of Mace Hacker's books. Oh, I'm sure you can, my boy. But there is... one other book. His very first. It was with another publisher long since defunct. I've never heard of it. Few people have. A fantastic book. What was it called? The name of it is Rudy, Jack, and Ramona. We have Mr. Rudy Slaymaker, a dedicated fan of mystery writer Mace Hacker. And why? Convinced that Hacker's stories are all prophecies of murders that will occur in the future.

Hacker even names his real-life ones. Tale come true. We have a few moments intermission until I return with Act Two. Who sincerely believes in turning the other cheek at a soft answer and intonation. The name of that book was, Mr. Tallow? Rudy, Jack, and Ramona. Why is it impossible? Because it was me, Hacker's very first published work. A rather small-time publisher who went out of business shortly afterward. And then Mace Hacker caught on with the present firm where he's been ever since. Rudy Jack? What is the book about? I don't know, do you know? I've never read it. I've only heard about it. However, I would assume one of them kills the other two, wouldn't you? Where can I get a copy? Oh, I don't think you can. The book's out of print and the publisher is out of business. Rudy Jack and Ramona. It's probably the only cast of characters that didn't come true.

What do you mean? Well, you call yourself a Mace Hacker fan and you ask that, you know what I mean. After he writes the book somewhere, that story really comes true. Same names, everything. Well, do you remember any murder cases involving three people named Rudy, Jack, and Ramona? There's a package for you. Oh, uh... What's in it? I didn't open it. I think it's a book. A book? The return address reads Book Finders Incorporated. Oh, yeah. Let me see that. Five years old. Rudy? I had no idea it was so late. It's all right. No, it's not all right. A wife should make her husband's breakfast. All I ever want is coffee. No, you want more than coffee. And it's my job to... Dearest, I'll miss my bus. My blood froze.

I looked at the printed page. That was the dialogue. Those were the actual words that passed between Ramona and me on any given morning. And here, here, Mace had written it all down 25 years ago. Why, that would have been 12 years before Ramona and I were even married. Pray to go on. What would be on the next page? I didn't want to find out. I didn't want to know. The resolve never mustn't miss. the bus. Jack glowers at me if I come in late. He glowers? Why, that mean old thing. Although recently he's taken to coming in late himself. Oh, you're just too nice for your own good, darling. Can't even finish my coffee. Have to run. Into an end. Find on the next page. Mona watched him hurry down the street corner bus stop. He and the bus arrived simultaneously. Stepped on board. Telephone. Hello, Jack, darling. He's gone.

Yes. Yes, he just got on his bus. Yes. Get here as fast as you can. You know I do, darling. Leave my eyes. I could not accept what I had just seen in black and white. Ramona. My Ramona. With what we can have, even if it's only... Hey, Loretta and I should marry you. For each other, two sticks in the mud who don't like to do anything, go anywhere. But that can't happen, darling. Yes, I know. And you should be returning to the office. I know. Rudy talks about it sometimes. He says he covers for you when your father-in-law happens to drop by. Your father-in-law gets very upset when you're not around. Yes, I'm aware of that. But I hate to go. Rudy scares me. He scares you? I give him a hard time. But it's only in self-defense. It's just he knows so much about the contracting business and I know so little. I couldn't care less. Get divorced.

You and I could go. Rudy would never give me a divorce. He doesn't believe in it. Besides, darling, you're absolutely unfit for any work at all. In six months, you'd hate yourself, and you'd hate me. Right. What we have now is... Isn't... You'd better get back to the office. The way things have been going when I was out of the house, I refuse to believe it. I hid the book in my desk. It's serving... I made you those Brussels sprouts you like so much, darling. Is something wrong? What?

What should be wrong? Well, I don't know, darling. It just seems to me that you're very... No, no, I'm fine. I'm fine. I'm all right. You seem very upset, very nervous. I'm not aware of it. Did you have a hard day? No, no. Harder than usual. Was... Jeff... Jeff is troublesome again. Huh. Jeff. Honestly, Rudy, you're... Darling, you're not yourself tonight. What's bothering you? What was I going to tell her about this thing? I decided after I got on the bus, I would just get off a few blocks away.

I boarded the bus. After it turned a corner, I was very careful on the radio. And suddenly... Rudy! What are you doing home? What am I doing home? Goodness, you scared me. I heard the door open. I couldn't imagine who... Oh, I forgot something. Oh, I'm sorry. Yeah, I better get it. It's in the bedroom. Oh. Yeah. In the bedroom. It wasn't there. Nobody was in there or anywhere else either. It was wrong. Jessup wasn't coming here mornings after I left. That night, I finally got all my courage together. According to the book, when Rudy left that morning, Ramona had a premonition. She couldn't explain it, but she was a woman who, though she refused, she dialed Jack's number once again. Yes, he just left, but don't come here. No, no, no, no, please, don't come here. Yes, my darling, I want to see you more than anything in the world, but I have this feeling, this...

Terrible feeling. No. No, meet me for lunch. Yes, usual place. Yes, darling. She knew something was wrong, terribly wrong. Something that could destroy all of them. At 12 o'clock, she arrived at the little Eastside restaurant where they had spent so many happy hours. Darling, what's wrong? It's Rudy. What about Rudy? He knows, Jack. He knows? How much does he know? He knows about us. And he knows everything. Are you sure? I had this premonition. I can't account for it, but I can't disregard it either. I told you not to come? Well, a half hour after he left, he came back. He what? He came back to the apartment. Why? He said he'd forgotten something. Or maybe he did. No, Jack. No, you know he didn't. He came back expecting to find us together.

We'll have to stop seeing each other. Oh, no, we can't. It's for a while. Not now, we can't. Loretta's going out to the coast to spend a few weeks with her aunt. I plan for us to use that time. No, darling. But Rudy suspects, and I'm... I can't let Rudy come between us. But Rudy exists. Problem? Loretta would be alive. You wouldn't be able to marry me. There's got to be some way to kill Rudy. Some safe, foolproof way. There probably is. But the problem is to find it. Just as blooded as that. The way to kill way. That's how Mace Hacker has been talking in his book. And here I am reading all this in a 25-year-old detective novel as if it's all happening to some fictional character. It's going to happen. I'm Rudy. Is Ramona my wife? And Jack? Is Jack Jessup my boss? However, Rudy has an advantage. Rudy knows something that...

Jack and Ramona are unaware of. Rudy has a copy of the script. In just a few moments, a homicide detective is urging him to make a confession. It's easy. Someone handed you a book and said, here is the story of the rest of your life. Would you be anxious to read it? I would have thrown the book away, but Ramona Slaymaker led a double life with brilliance and flair. She was Jack Jessup's ardent lover, and she was also Rudy Slaymaker's. Find a way to kill him. Yeah. Where do my mother-in-law come from? have no objection to our marriage. Believe me, I think it's logical for us to get together and you'll be an excellent mother to his grandchildren. What we're doing is wrong, Jack. It's murder. My darling, it's the only way we can find happiness. Looked up from the book. Finally, the plot was arranged to kill Rudy, to kill me, the way Mace Hacker had written it. He could kill off Loretta, Jack's wife, but in real life...

Jack's wife, Loretta, was still very much alive. And as long as she was alive, there was no point in their trying to kill me. I was at the office. The telephone rang. It was Loretta's father. Yes, sir. I keep telling him how foolish it is. Right near the old bridge. He'll be waiting there. I'll take his wallet, watch, and his ring so it'll look like brother. Stony silence, but I knew how to break through that. Fifty bucks invested in the right people can bring you all sorts of useful information. And so, in a few days, I found myself in a modest apartment building. All neat, plate on the door, red. The old lady and son are looking for Mace Hacker. Go away. No, please, it's a matter of life and death. There's nothing to me. Please, you must let me see Mace Hacker. You can't turn me down. A plea to waste. I don't know what it is.

write stories about murder, and years later they come true. Do they? Yes, even the people's names. How do you account for it? How do you account for it? Look, I came here for answers, not questions. No answers. There are... My boss and my wife. How did you know about us? How? I mean, even the words. We speak to each other in private. How did you know? I'm... I am usually not this. Please, first, don't go to sleep. Tell me what I must do to come. No, dear, I have a slight cold. Ah. Well, I won't be long. Don't walk too far, and please, dear, do be careful. Yes. I'd get there before he would, or before I left the house, and that was just the head start I needed. I waited until I heard the sound of footsteps.

Till he was almost upon... And then, the little pistol barked like an angry dog in the night. He fell on his face in an undainly sprawl. He was dead before he hit the ground. Now, let's finish the story the way Mace Hacker had commanded me to finish. Good to see me, Ramona. Surprise? Why should I be surprised? It wasn't supposed to work out this way, was it? I don't know what you're talking about. I'm sure you do. Rudy, what are you doing with that gun? What do people usually do with a gun, darling? No, Rudy, no. Have you gone crazy? Goodbye, darling. Why? Why? You had your friend Jack try to kill me. You told him I'd gone for a walk. But I saw him first. I killed him first. And now you. Jack is over. By the bridge. It wasn't Jack. She didn't tip him off. And I guess, I guess they weren't.

Having an affair that, according to Mace Hatcher... Make a statement, Lieutenant. You'd never believe me. You'll be surprised some of the stories I hear. Never heard a story like this one. Neither did the jury. Rudy Slaymaker away for the rest of his life. He certainly thought it was self-defense. For all we know, maybe it was. You just stayed there. Our cast included Paul Hecht, Patricia Elliott, Ian Martin, and Ralph Bell. The entire production was under the direction of...

End of transcriptBack to the beginning ↑