Skip to content
On Air
All channelsAll
CBS Radio Mystery Theater artwork

From the CBS Radio Mystery Theater collection

Invited Guests

Episode 1269December 22, 198144 min 36 secTranscript

Writer: Himan Brown

The written record

Read the transcript

Read along with the recording · About 26 min to read

presents. Ever Proudly was a strange man. Everybody in town felt it, but nobody could have told you why precisely or what was strange about him. He looked ordinary enough, dressed pretty much the way everybody else did, though possibly a trifle more neatly, had impeccable manners, but was never standoffish or at all conceited. Never seemed to think he was better than anybody else. He was somehow different and strange.

Dr. Mabley? Yes, Louise? Was Oliver Proudly in church this morning? Why, yes. Yes, I believe he was. I thought I heard his voice when we sang Bringing in the Sheaves. Mr. Proudly's voice is a great contribution to the hymn singing. Booming out like that gives the whole hymn more body, gives the congregation courage to sing out. Don't you think so? Yes. Yes, I do. Only what, Louise? Why is it, Dr. Mabley, that it's only during the hymn singing that Oliver has any courage at all?

Our mystery drama, Invited Guests, was written especially for the Mystery Theater by Elspeth Eric and stars Russell Horton and Terry Keene. I'll be back shortly with Act One.

Proudly lived in the big house he'd been born in. He lived alone and he was a painter, but I thought he was a great man. There were no things sufficient to call him strange. Others lived alone in the houses of their birth. Oliver was probably the only painter in town. But if a man could afford to indulge himself in a harmless hobby like that, no one thought the less of him for it. No. Oliver Proudly was just strange.

Sermon, Dr. Mabley, just fine. Many thanks, Frank, for those kind words. Just fine, Dr. Mabley. I'll see you at Vespers. Probably. Good. See you there.

Well, Mrs. Whittaker, how are you? So, Louise, what's for dinner? What's always for dinner on Sundays? Fried chicken, mashed potatoes, string beans, and ice cream. Well, that's what's for dinner. Chocolate sauce? Oh, Frank, I'm going back and speak to Dr. Mabley. What for? Wait for me right here. No chocolate sauce? I'll be right back.

Dr. Mabley? Dr. Mabley? Yes, yes, Louise? Dr. Mabley, could I speak to you for a minute? Why, yes, of course. Do you want to come inside? No, this is all right. I won't keep you but a minute. Frank's waiting for me. He wants his dinner. Dr. Mabley, was Oliver Proudly in church this morning? Oh, yes, I believe he was. I thought I heard his voice when he sang Bringing in the Sheaves. Mr. Proudly's voice is a great contribution to the hymn singing. Booming out like that gives the whole hymn, all body, gives the congregation courage to sing out, don't you think? Yes, yes, I do. Only why is it that it's only during the hymn singing that Oliver has any courage at all?

I'm not sure I know what you mean, Louise. Dr. Mabley, Frank and I have known Oliver since we were all kids in school. We were very close, actually. But since Frank and I were married, that's three years now, we've asked Oliver to the house for dinner time and time again. We'd love to have him, you know, talk over old times and all like that. But he never accepts. He's very polite about it, very appreciative, but he always has some excuse why he can't come. And it's beginning to upset me. Oh, to have dinner with old friends? I know it sounds silly, but it's the only thing I can think of. There's a sort of a look about him when I invite him. He? Looks frightened. As though Frank and I might hurt him in some way. What sort of excuse does he give you for not accepting? Well, that's another thing that's got me worried. He always says he has guests coming for dinner. So that sounds reasonable. Yes, that's what I thought the first few times. But every single time? Like for three years? There's something fishy about that. Fishy? Well, you know, it's strange. Are you sure you're not unduly alarmed, Louise? Well, maybe. But I happen to know that he never goes to anybody's house. I've asked around, you know, in a tactful way. And he gives other people the same excuse that he's expecting guests. Well, if he never goes out anywhere, then who comes to his house? Oh, I've never asked him that. After all, there are limits beyond which you cannot go, even with old friends. Yes, yes, I suppose. I suppose. Oh, well, I've taken up enough of your time. Oh, that's all right. I don't know what good I thought I could do. It was just that I thought I had to talk to someone. That's what I'm here for, Louise, is to be talked to. Well, I'd better get back to Frank before he wants his dinner. Thank you, Dr. Mabley, for listening.

Just a second, Louise. Yes? The thought just occurred to me, you know, that it would be of any use, but I could try. Why don't I invite Oliver for dinner? Dr. Mabley, would you do that? Well, my housekeeper's a pretty fair cook. Oh, that would be wonderful. I'll wait till next Sunday after the service, and then I'll ask him. Sort of on impulse, as it were. I'll say, how about coming back to the rectory and having Sunday dinner with me? And he doesn't have to know that you and I talked about it. Fried chicken and ice cream, I'll say. How does that sound to you?

You at Vespers, Mrs. Whittaker? Oh, Mr. Crouse. Oliver, Oliver, how are you? Fine, Dr. Mabley. I thought I heard your baritone voice carrying another day for we three kings. I enjoy the singing very much. Everybody's gone home, Oliver. Why don't you and I sit down on the steps and have a little talk? Would you rather go inside? I should be getting on home. Oh, just for a few minutes. You and I have never really got to know each other, have we? No, we haven't. Oh. Oh, my. Now, come, come, sit down. Well, I... The steps are nice and warm, and the sun's been out all morning. Now, now, tell me something about yourself. There's nothing to tell, really. Oh, I don't believe that. I don't believe there's a soul on Earth who hasn't got something to tell. A great deal to tell, if it comes to that. Really, there's nothing. I've only been the minister here for a year. I haven't got caught up on all my parishioners. Now, let's see now, Oliver. You're an artist, isn't that right? Well, yes. Portraits? Oh, no, no. I work in watercolors on canvas board. Oh? Pastels and scenic things? What sort of things do you paint? Three bottles on a stone fence. Not much background, and the fence is sort of sketchily drawn. The important thing. What else? That's all. No, no, I mean, what other things do you draw? What? What? What? What? What? What? Bottles, trees, houses? Just three bottles on a stone fence. Just that? I'm trying to get it right. Three years now, I haven't got it right. You should go on to something else. Oh, no, no, I couldn't do that. You could always come back to bottles. I have to get them right before I can turn to anything else. How many times have you drawn the three bottles? Hundreds of times. I've lost track. Could I, would it be possible for me to see your work sometime? Would you be interested? Well, not that I know anything about art. No, I don't. But yes, yes, I'd be interested. After all, I'm interested in you. So, I'd be interested in anything you do. Well, maybe sometime if you're not busy. Oh, never too busy for one of my flock.

It's very nice talking to you, Dr. Mabley. Hold on a minute. I've been keeping you from something. No, no, not at all. No, no, I just had an idea. Why don't you come back to the rectory with me and share my dinner? I have a housekeeper who's not a bad cook. That's very nice of you, but I'm afraid I can't. Oh, now, don't tell me you have another engagement. I'm expecting guests. A dinner? A dinner. How many are coming? A lot of people? Big party? No. Just treating yourself? Oh, yes, I always do. I like to cook. It's a hobby of mine. I see, I see. What are you cooking today? I'm trying out a new recipe. A squab stuffed with a pecan dressing. Now, that does sound good. Mm-hmm. A watercress salad and cucumbers poulet. No wonder you'd rather eat at home than with me. Oh, I didn't mean that. Well, with me, you'd get fried chicken and mashed potatoes. I'm sure it would be delicious, but I have these guests coming to the house, so you see, I... Well, some other time, perhaps? Yes, perhaps some other time. Oliver, just a minute more. I'm going to ask you a very impertinent question. You don't have to answer it if you don't want to. What's the question? You won't be offended. A bit personal. Who are the two guests you invited for dinner? You said two people, I believe. People from around here? They used to be. Oh, I didn't even know it. Hmm. Probably not anyone I would know. Someone else might, huh? Someone in town, like Nathan? Oh, yeah. Oliver, forgive my persistent curiosity. I know it's in bad taste to go on prying into your life like this, but who are they?

Almost ready, Louise? I'm just setting the table. You forgot? I've got the spoons for the ice cream. Oh. Dear me, so I did. I'll get them. Hey, you... Not really. That's a spoon. Just set them down, Frank. I'm too nervous. I can tell. No, I'm not. I'm just wondering about Dr. Mabley. What about Dr. Mabley? He looked okay to me. Dr. Mabley and Oliver Proudly. What about them? Dr. Mabley. Dr. Mabley. Dr. Mabley was going to invite Oliver for dinner today, after the service. That's a laugh. Well, you never know. He might accept. When he won't come to our house. And we've known him since first grade, and Dr. Mabley's only known him for a year, and not very well at that. But he's the minister. That might make a difference. Do you want me to get the phone? No, I will. Here, finish setting the table. Hello? Oh, yes, Dr. Mabley. I just wanted you to know... Yes? Did he accept? Did he accept? No. Oh, dear. But I sort of took... Who are they? Anyone we know? His mother and father? But it couldn't be his mother and father. They've been dead for years.

It would seem thus far that Oliver Proudly is indeed a strange man. But wait. Wait for the rest of the story. You may discover that Oliver Proudly is no more strange than you are, or I am. There have been times when I have thought myself... A little strange, and I think if you are honest, you'll say the same of yourself. I'll be back shortly with that truth.

...mean by strange. Odd? Eccentric? Grotesque? I think perhaps we only mean unfamiliar. Not quite what we're used to. Something outside our experience. Not exactly conforming to our notions of what people should be, or at least appear to be. But where did these notions come from? Who gave them to us? And how? How substantial are they?

Well, for heaven's sake. What's the matter, Louise? Frank, you know I told you Dr. Mabley was going to ask Oliver Proudly to have dinner with him today after the service. Well, he did. Mm-hmm. And Oliver said, no thanks. Am I right? Yes, but that's not all. Said he was expecting guests, right? If you'll stop being so smart, I'll tell you. Dr. Mabley said, who are the guests you're expecting? It's something we never had the nerve to ask. Oh, it wasn't none of our business who. No. It wasn't none of our business who. It wasn't none of our business who. It wasn't none of our business who. It wasn't none of our business who. Well, Dr. Mabley made it his business. Maybe that's what we should have done a long time ago. Come right out and ask him. Because when Dr. Mabley asked him, you never guessed what Oliver said. Who? Nobody around here, I'll bet. You could say that. You could say nobody from around here. Well, who? Anybody we know? People we used to know. Appears to be a few. I do. For Pete's sake, Louise, who? His father and his mother. Well, they're dead. Both of them are dead. I know. Been dead for four or five years. I know. Well, maybe he just said that for something to say. You know, like he didn't feel like saying who his guests were, really. Like it wasn't any of Dr. Mabley's business. So he just said the first thing came into his mind. That could be. Couldn't it? I suppose it could. Well, maybe old Oliver has got a lady friend he doesn't want to talk about. Maybe she's married or something. A clandestine affair. He wouldn't want to tell a minister or something like that.

Frank, I'm going over there.

Over where?

To Oliver's house.

You can't do that.

Yes, I can, and I'm going to.

What if you bust in on something?

I don't care.

I care. Nevertheless, I'm going.

Louise, I forbid you to.

Forbid? Frank, the day is long gone for husbands to forbid their wives to do anything. I am going.

Well, you're not taking the car. I forbid you to do that. I mean, the car is in my name, and I forbid you to take it.

All right, I won't take the car. I'll walk. It's not much. I'm young and healthy. Frank, I've got to know.

Come in, Mother.

Thank you, Oliver.

Father didn't come with you?

Your father is parking the car.

I see. Let me take your hat, Mother.

Thank you, son. I'll hang it up.

All right. The place looks very nice and neat. Who cleans it for you?

I clean it myself.

My, my. You don't say. Um, come into the living room and have a glass of sherry.

That sounds good.

It's a new kind. Spanish. Better put the bottle away before your father gets here.

Is he, uh, still...

Periodic.

Periodic.

Here you are, Mother.

Thank you very much. There's, uh, cheese and some water biscuits.

You're very thoughtful, Oliver.

I try to be. Well, cheers.

Cheers, Mother. And to your continued good health.

Oh, the less said about that, the better. Hey, how's Louise? I've been seeing a lot of her lately.

Some. I've been seeing her some.

I like Louise.

So do I.

Always liked her.

Me too. She seems a lot of that, uh, Frank-what's-his-name, doesn't she?

I think they go out some.

I hear he's crazy about her.

I wouldn't know.

Well, they've been seen around together lots of places.

Oh? Have they?

She must like him a lot to go out with him so much. Don't you think?

I don't know how much she goes out with him.

A lot. She goes out with him a lot.

Mother, uh, would you like to see my latest?

Your new watercolor?

Oh, yes. You want to show it to me?

I thought you might like to see what I've been up to.

Certainly. If you want me to.

What do you think of it?

I already saw that one.

Oh. This is a new one.

It's the same fence, same three bottles.

Oh. No, no, no. Can't you see?

I see three bottles on a fence. Anybody can see that.

No. It's more. It's more.

Now, Oliver, I'm sure it's very nice.

It's not nice.

I think it's very nice.

I think it's very nice.

I think it's very nice.

I think it's very nice.

I think it's very nice.

I think it's very nice.

It's very nice.

If there's one thing it isn't, it's nice. It's not nice.

If you say so, son. I think that's father at the door.

Oh, put the bottle away.

Oh, mother, what good does it do to put the bottle away? It removes the temptation.

It's not a temptation. It's a compulsion. Don't you know that yet? If it isn't this bottle, it'll be another bottle.

Why do you put up with it?

He is my husband.

Well, that's no reason.

If he left me, I would be all alone. Unless, of course, you should take it into your head to marry Louise. Then... then... then... then... then... then... then... then... then... then... then... then... then... then... then... then... then... then... there would be a place for me and there would be our grandchildren, God willing.

Are we having squab for dinner?

Squab is nice. Expensive. Stuffed with pecan.

I don't think I've ever heard of that. And cucumbers, poulet.

Cucumbers don't agree with your father.

Oh. I forgot about him. I'll go and let him in.

Hide the bottle for a second.

It's too late.

Father.

Hi there, son. Glad to see you.

I'm glad to see you, too. And look what I brought you. Your old .22 rifle.

Where did you find it?

Up in the attic. Remember when I gave you this?

My 14th birthday.

Oliver's a man now, I said to myself. Time he learned how to shoot. And then I went right out and bought you this nifty little .22. And a lot of bullets.

Yeah, yeah. I found some of those up in the attic, too. All packed away real carefully.

Yeah, and the gun's in fine shape. Cleaned out the bore for you. Oiled it.

Thank you, Father.

Loaded it and brought it with me. Here, here. Take it.

I don't really want it, Father.

Take it.

Really don't want it.

Don't be a little bit boy, for heaven's sake.

Can't you see he doesn't want the stupid gun?

Well, I'll just set it here against the wall, okay?

I wish you'd take it back.

What do I need with this dinky thing? I got shooting pieces of like a witch you wouldn't believe. What's this? Sherry? You don't want any.

Who says I don't want any?

I say it.

Hey, I see you've been having a little nip.

That's different.

Hey, what do you say, Oliver? You and I go out shooting small game one of these days.

No.

You know, rabbits, chipmunks. Maybe there's some pheasant around here. I saw some once.

I've never seen any.

Now we'll bring down something.

Stop pestering the boy.

I just said...

You keep everlastingly at him. Nag, nag, nag. Why don't you let him alone?

Why don't you let him alone?

When are you going to see Louise, Oliver? When are you going to take her out dancing? She's not going to ask you, you know. You've got to ask her.

I don't do that.

She's going steady with Frank now. He'll cut you out if you're not careful, and then will you be.

I don't do that. I have never done that.

You do it all the time.

I don't do that. I have never done that.

You do it all the time. You do it all the time. And you, what do you do? And he got to the pistol range with a bottle. That's what you do. That's your contribution to the family.

Stop it. Stop it, both of you.

Tell him to stop.

Tell her.

I can't stand anymore. I don't want to hear anymore. I'm fed up. I try to make things nice, make things pleasant. I cook dinner for you. You know, crab and cucumbers.

I can't eat cucumbers.

And you come over here, and it's the same thing all over again. Every single time. It's the same thing over and over and over. The same old thing. It's never anything sweet or helpful. It's the same old thing. Time after time after time.

Do you want me to?

I want you to very much.

I thought I heard you talking to someone just now.

To myself, probably. People do that when they live alone. So I've been told or read it somewhere. But please, will you use it?

Well, if you're sure.

I'm sure. I'm very sure.

All right, then. You're positive there's nobody here?

There's nobody but you and me. I wouldn't want you to intrude.

Let me pour you some sherry. There's a full glass right here.

Oh, is there? Looks like it hasn't been touched. I must have poured it for myself and forgotten it. I think I'll drink it now. Oh, would you like some?

No, thank you. No, for me. You see a lot, Frank. And I... Are you going steady, Louise?

Oliver.

Because I love you, Louise.

I think I better leave now.

Oh. Take a look at it. I can almost hear you.

Oliver Prouty is a strange man. Is he perhaps mad? But wait. Before you make a judgment, remember the observation of Polonius when Hamlet was behaving in a most peculiar manner. Though this be madness, yet there is method in it. In our third act, we shall try to show you the purpose behind Oliver Prouty's strangeness.

Oliver, you're not dead, are you? Oh, I can feel your pulse. That means your heart's beating so you can't be dead. Oliver, what's happened to you? Oliver, listen. I hope you can hear me. I'll phone for Dr. Mabley. He's coming over right away. He'll know what to do. I'd have called a regular doctor, and I didn't know how to explain what happened, what I'd say. I don't even know what to say to Dr. Mabley.

Dr. Mabley. Oh, there he is now. Dr. Mabley's here, Oliver. Everything's going to be all right. Oh, Dr. Mabley, come in. Come in.

Where is he, Louise?

In there. In the living room. On the floor. You said on the phone you thought he'd just fainted. I hope and pray. I don't think he's dead. I think his heart's beating.

No. No, he's not dead.

Oh, thank the Lord. Tell me what happened, Louise. I gather you were here when he fainted. You didn't arrive to find him.

Oh, no. I was here. I'd been here for five, ten minutes.

Yes, well, what happened? I hardly know how to tell you.

Start at the beginning and simply tell me.

All right. After I talked to you, after I told you that Oliver's father and mother had been dead for years.

You're sure about that?

Dr. Mabley, we went to their funerals, both Frank and I. It was before we were married, but we went to comfort Oliver the best way we could. Not that he seemed to need it. Either time.

Whatever do you mean by that?

Well, he just stood by the grave both times, staring off into space with a sort of frozen look on his face. As though the funeral had nothing much to do with him. As though he was just there out of, you know, politeness or something.

Tell me what happened today.

Well, after I talked to you, I told Frank I was coming over. I told him I was here because I was worried about Oliver. What he said about his mother and father coming for dinner.

Yes.

And Frank said, oh, don't think badly of him, Dr. Mabley. It's just a way of speaking that men have. But Frank said, probably he told you that because he had an engagement with some woman, maybe a married woman. I know Frank shouldn't have even thought of such a thing, but, well, you know.

Yes, yes, I do know. Just go on.

Well, Frank got very upset and he said he forbade me to go.

Well, you know, Dr. Mabley, men just don't say things like that to women anymore.

So I've heard. And besides, I... Dear, something just occurred to me.

What is it, Louise?

I think, I think maybe I was jealous. I used to be very fond of Oliver. Actually, for a while there, I was expecting him to ask me to marry him. And if he had, well... Who knows? He never asked me to, so... That is, he never asked me to today.

Today? He asked you to marry him today?

Just before he fainted, he said, please marry me, Louise.

I think you'd best go back to where you left your house to come here, Louise.

All right. Well, I walked over because Frank wouldn't let me use the car. And as I got to the house, I heard Oliver's voice. It was quite loud. Very angry. He was saying, same old thing, same old thing, never anything helpful, just the same old thing. So I thought he could be talking to some woman, and it seemed logical. So I knocked on the door a couple of times, and he opened it. And sweet as pie, he said, well, Louise, how nice to see you. Do come in, Louise. I didn't want to intrude if he was having an argument with some woman, but... He insisted, so I came inside. There was no woman, there was nobody. Oh, wait till you hear the rest of it. You won't believe it. He offered me some sherry, and I said, well, look, there's a full glass right here. And he said something like how he must have poured it and forgotten it, and he'd drink it now. He tossed off the sherry in one gulp. And then he started talking about Frank. Asked me if Frank and I were going steady. Well, that's when I started to get really uneasy.

Yes, of course.

Oliver said he loved me. And then, all of a sudden, he changed the subject. Said he wanted me to look at his latest watercolor. I did, and I said I liked it, and he said he thought he had it just about perfect. And then, the gun.

The gun? What gun, Louise?

The .22 rifle. It's over there. I picked it up after Oliver fainted. That was right after he shot the picture and asked me to marry him.

Shot the picture?

Now, look at it. It's over there on the easel.

He shot the picture?

He was very proud of himself. Shot all three bottles right through the neck, he said. He was right. He did. And then he said, please marry me, Louise. And he fainted.

Good Lord. What do you make of it, Dr. Mabley?

I don't know. Oh, Louise, I think he's starting to come around.

Yes, he is. He went home to Oliver privately. If you say so. Please. Let us know if he's all right.

I will. I will. Don't worry. I don't know how Frank is going to take all this.

Mr. Prouty, Oliver, Dr. Mabley, asked me to come over.

Who?

Why should I faint? I'd like to have you tell me why. I have no idea. Why? It's ridiculous. I never fainted.

Well, maybe it's not as ridiculous as it seems at first. Remember after church this morning when I asked you to have dinner with me at the rectory?

Mm-hmm. I remember that. Expecting guests for dinner.

I said that?

Yes, that's what you said. These last few years, whenever anyone asked you to come for dinner, I... your guests were... You said your mother and your father.

I said that?

Yes, you did. Everybody in town. Particular. Just to be with you.

I don't know. I don't remember.

It was Frank and Louise, wasn't it? You were very close to one another at that time, weren't you? The three of you?

You could say that.

I am saying that. I want you to see something of Louise, won't you?

No, I'm not.

Did you ever think of asking Louise to marry you? Did you ever ask her?

Why you didn't?

Well, she was crazy about Frank, and I... The chance of asking her and being turned down? Could have been. It could have... Who cares? She and Frank are married now. They're very happy, so who cares? It's the time when my parents died and Louise married Frank, so you don't know anything about it.

I don't know everything about it. And it's got nothing to do with why I'm lying here, why I fainted.

Oliver, when you came home after the service this morning, did you stuff three squabs?

Only one.

What are you talking about?

Squab. With the can stuck in. How many?

I don't know if I cooked any. Shall I go up to the kitchen and look?

No. I didn't cook any. I didn't buy any. It was just an idea I had. What I would do, what I might do, in case they ever... Just in case they show up.

Is that what you mean? The idea I had. They show up? How could they? So they're not here right now?

No, they're not.

I'll bring it to you.

What is it?

I think it's the last watercolor you painted.

Is it?

It's got three holes in it.

Those? How did they get that? I did?

Oliver, why have you only painted three bottles on a stone?

Don't know. Pretty good at it. To the rest of you. Also wicked, depraved, and beyond redemption?

Have a little compassion. You yourself have suffered some of what he has suffered. Be sparing in the adjectives you use to describe him. After all, he did nothing. He only thought.

What about you? Have you never thought and felt sure that everything you have ever felt, or thought, has been pristine? Before you answer, think again.

The cast included Russell Horton, Terry Keene, Lloyd Batista, and Lou Turin. The entire production was under the direction of Hyman Brown.

A preview of our next tale.

Without interest.

How generous.

There is a condition.

Name it.

Show my associates of your fidelity.

It's clean. It will be brought to you so that you may place your fingerprints on it. It will be kept in a safe place. To know about it. As long as we are assured. Life in your hands. Where do you think it's been for the last year? Must be your killing.

This is E.G. Marshall. Inviting you to return to our mystery theater. For another adventure in the macabre. Until next time. Pleasant dreams.

End of transcriptBack to the beginning ↑