Skip to content
On Air
All channelsAll
CBS Radio Mystery Theater artwork

From the CBS Radio Mystery Theater collection

Is He Living or Is He Dead?

Episode 409January 6, 197645 min 12 secTranscript

Writer: Himan Brown

The written record

Read the transcript

Read along with the recording · About 33 min to read

Welcome. I'm E.G. Marshall. The great French writer Balzac called life a human comedy. Our own Mark Twain saw it as a human tragedy. What's in a name? There are a great many laughs in a true tragedy and plenty of tears in a genuine comedy. Mark Twain's long suit was irony. And now we have an opportunity to see how he plays that kind of hand in one of the greatest... stories of deception ever written. And there's no doubt about it. You can be wealthy. Oh, I like that. Famous. Famous, too. Absolutely. And powerful. Wealthy? Famous? Powerful? A fourth in the world of all. It sounds wonderful. That's what you're giving me. And in return, what do I have to give you? Your life. Our mystery drama, Is He Living or Is He Dead? was adapted from the Mark...

Twain Classic, especially for the Mystery Theater by Sam Dan and stars Alexander Scorby. It is unfortunate but true that a great many creative men are killed by poverty. As a matter of fact, the circumstance has been so universal that it has even been made romantic. How many stories, operas, plays are about artists who starve in garrets? Van Gogh, Schubert, Mozart, Rembrandt, Poe, to name but a tiny few, all died of neglect. Must it be ever thus? Mark Twain is about to present another perspective. I was spending the month of March, 1892, at Montaigne on the Riviera, fully enjoying the flooding sunshine, the balmy air, and the brilliant blue sea.

without the marring additions of human fuss and display, which one encounters a few miles away at Nice and Monte Carlo. As a rule, the rich do not come here, but now and then a rich man does show up, and I got acquainted with one, partially to disguise him as we'll call him Smith. One morning we were having breakfast at the Hotel des Anglais when he exclaimed, Quick, cast your eye at that man. Huh? Which man? The one just going out the door. He is? Do you know who he is? Why are you so excited, mister? Oh, no. Do you? Do you? Well, I think so. He spent several days here just before you arrived. Do you know anything about him? Well, someone said he's an old, retired, very rich silk manufacturer from Lyon. Or was it Lille? Well, what else do you know about him? Well, I don't know anything about him except... Except what? Well, I...

would assume he must be all alone in the world. Oh, why? Why? Well, he looks so sad and dreamy, and he doesn't talk with anyone. Would you know his name? Yes, it's Théophile Magnan. Well? Well, what? Well, what are you going to tell me? Tell you? About the old gentleman. Oh. Smith... Taking you by and large, you're quite a character. Here, the mere sight of a person sends you into a perfect fit. One might have thought the man was Jack the Ripper, the way you seem to take on about him. And now you simply cannot say, oh, and just haul down the flag. Smith? Smith, are you awake? I'm trying to think. About what? One of Hans Anderson's beautiful little stories.

Well, how did he get into the discussion? I remember only one part of it. Do you remember the old man who just left? It seems a child has a caged bird, which it loves, but thoughtlessly neglects. And the bird pours out its sweet song, unheard and unheeded. You follow this? Well, yes. In time, hunger and thirst assail the poor bird. Its song grows feeble and plaintive. and finally ceases, and the bird dies. Well, the child comes by, and you know what happens, don't you? Well, I would say the child sees the poor dead bird and is smitten to the heart with remorse. And then with bitter tears, the child calls his mates, and they bury the bird with elaborate pomp and the tenderest grief. Well, then you have read the story. Oh, it's an old story.

The children don't know that they're only aping their elders, who also starve poets to death, and then spend enough on their funerals and monuments to have kept them alive and made them easy and comfortable. And now, how about the old gentleman? Twain, can you keep a secret? No better than you. You look like a man who's bursting to break one. Well, it's been a secret for many years between me and two others, but I'm going to break the seal now. You know, a long time ago, I was a young artist. You? You, Smith, were an artist? And I wandered around the French countryside, just sketching, you know. Were you successful? Oh, bless you, no. I was starving. Well, how did you live? A typically American question. Why not? I'm a typical American.

The answer is I pawned my way across France. One by one, I sold all my belongings till I was reduced to the clothes on my back. Even they started to go one by one. Finally, almost naked and down and out, I found myself in a small Breton village. And there I was taken in and literally saved by a fellow artist named Francois Millet. Who? Francois Millet. With a great Francois Millet? Oh, great. Wasn't any greater than I was. He hadn't any fame at all, even in his own village. Oh, the great Francois Millet. Let me tell you about the great Francois Millet. He made me welcome. What a generous, great-hearted fellow he was. I'll never forget that first day. Smith! Smith! Our old Englishman named Smith. Sometimes it seems that way. Now, where can you sleep? Well, sleep anywhere. There are no soft places on the floor, so one is as good as another. Now!

For dinner. I feel badly. I can see there isn't very much, Monsieur Millet. You cannot call a French painter monsieur till he's received the Legion of Honor. And I have a better chance of being struck by lightning. You must call me Francois. Now, dinner. All we have are turnips. Unless, of course, Carl can scare up something. Carl? Carl Boulanger. He's also a painter, and he lives here, too. Ah, speak of the devil. How shall we prepare the turnips tonight, Francois? That tells me everything. Well, how about turnips remoulade? We have no egg yolks. I have it, Carl, sautéed with mushrooms. We have no butter. I don't trust your judgment when it comes to picking wild mushrooms. Then I suppose we'll have to boil them as usual. Who is this? Oh, Smith, an Englishman. Smith?

This madcap is Carl Boulogne. Hello. He doesn't look like an Englishman. All Englishmen are supposed to be rich. Smith is a painter. Poor devil. Why didn't you arrange to be born in France and then you would have learned to starve properly? I can starve as decently as any Frenchman. What's that? What? That canvas against the wall. I just noticed it. Oh, that. I call it the Angelus. Hmm. It isn't too bad, eh, Smith? I've never seen anything like it. It's a masterpiece. It's a feeling of oneness with God. Carl, I have a confession to make. Yes, sir? I was offered five francs for it. When? Last week. Yes, a week ago Thursday. And what happened? I turned it down. You turned it down?

Four soix, five francs means a dozen eggs upon the butter. I know, I know, but you see, the man appeared anxious. Yes. And so I asked for eight francs. And? He said he would think about it and let me know. Oh. The kiss of death. Why didn't you take the five francs? You mean you would have Francois sell the Angeles for five francs? Right now, I would sell it for a pork chop. Sautéed with onions and without the choc vinaigrette. Salad niçoise and a very dry Bordeaux. Carl, when will you learn that the proper wine for pork is a light burgundy? I must educate your palate. You have scalded. What a fantastic pun. Don't you get it, Smith? No, I... The English, the English is the rule, Carl, are rather slow in these matters of humor. Francois was also my painting teacher, and you see, he has educated both my palate and my palette. You still don't get it? Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah. It is rather funny. No, no, no, no, you're right. It is a rather feeble jest. But you see, it passes the time, and then we forget how hungry we are.

And how tired and disappointed and disillusioned. Oh, come, Carl. One cannot have everything. Look at what we have in this room. Behold these canvases. A feast for the eye, a feast for the mind, a feast for the soul. And not even a crumb for the stomach. Be of good cheer, Carl. Perhaps tomorrow something will turn up. I taught you another pun. You get it, Smith? What will turn up tomorrow will be another turnip for dinner, as usual. Oh, yes. Well, now, gentlemen, the situation is quite serious. We are on the verge of starvation. As usual. And we must come up with a solution. Agreed. What do you suggest, Francois? I don't know. How about you, Smith? Nothing occurs to me either. Well, then, let's sleep on it. Which we did.

after having had, of course, a boiled turnip for dinner. The next morning, I was starved, but that was nothing unusual. I decided to take the bull by the horns. I looked at Millet's paintings. How could anyone in his right mind not jump at the chance to buy them? Accordingly, I placed a few under my arm, the Angelus, Man with a Hoe, the Woodcutter and Death, and I began to knock on doors. Practically every door was slammed in my face. Only one elderly woman deigned to talk to me at all. What are you selling? Oh, I see. That's painting nonsense. Oh, but madame, I assure you... And have you joined the other two? The scoundrels and ne'er-do-wells? Madame, if you please... The good-for-nothing lazy tramps who refuse to work for a living. Madame, painting is one of the most difficult of all occupations. Painting a house, maybe. Madame, I am here to help you to get rich.

You must admit that there are paintings which are worth millions, yes? Now admit it. Well... But here is your golden opportunity. A few pennies invested today will bring fabulous dividends tomorrow. How do I know? Because these are the paintings of the great François Millet. The great François Millet. Yes, madame. These paintings will increase a hundredfold, a thousandfold in value. Because François Millet is a genius. He is. There's no doubt about it. Who says so? She slammed the door in my face. And at that moment, a great light exploded in my brain. Who says so? I raced home. I couldn't wait to share this flash of sudden insight with my companions. Hunger creates great divisions, Francois. Continue, Smith. She and everyone else in this town.

They don't make up their own minds. They don't decide things for themselves. But that's how people are everywhere. And so she looks at you, Francois, and at me, and at Carl. How is she to know that the paintings have merit? It should be obvious. Of course. The colors, the figures, why, it's all over the canvas. Ah, but unfortunately, no one has told her that as yet. What do you mean, no one? I've been trying to sell these paintings for months, years. I patiently try to explain. But who are you? Who am I? I'm Carl Boulanger, a painter. No, you're Carl Boulanger, a shiftless good-for-nothing who would prefer to beg for his bread sooner than work for it. Who has perpetrated this infamous falsehood? And so am I, and so is Francois. What he says is true, Carl. And yet, yet, if someone in authority were to say, I...

François Millet, truly a great master. Why, overnight, François would be the toast of the town. Yes, authority. That's what the people look for. No one wants to make up his own mind. Therefore, François, we shall have an authority to authenticate your greatness. An authority? Of course. A great Parisienne authority. I know Professor Louis de Courbet. Who? He's the most respected professor of art at the university. No, no, no, he won't do, François. But he's the most learned. We don't want learned people. We want famous people. Oh, I have it. Madame Lucerne. She runs the most talked-about salon in Paris. You mean the most notorious... If she says a painting is great, it'll be hailed as a masterpiece. Yes, but does she know anything at all about painting? Probably not. Well, the question is, who should go? You are the smoothest talker, Carl. No, I nominate Smith to be our envoy. Me? Why?

Because you're the handsomest. Oh, but what does that have to do with... Do you recall the legend of the Golden Fleece? Oh, yeah. And the legendary band of ancient Greek heroes who went after it. Whom did they choose as their leader? Not Hercules, the strongest, or Ulysses, the wisest, but Jason, the handsomest. Because they knew it would be necessary to seduce a woman in order to win the prize. Oh, but I... You... may not have to go that far. And what if he does? We must all make sacrifices for art. Yes. And some of us must make heavier sacrifices than others. But, as you can see, there's more to becoming a famous artist than merely painting a great or even a good picture. Sometimes, one must play the game of love and even the game of death. However, All that is the affair of the second act, which I shall bring you in just a few moments. We may all have to revise some of our ideas about art before our story is over. At any rate, we're back in the year 1892, and Mark Twain is chatting with a wealthy elderly Englishman in a hotel on the sun-washed shores of the French Riviera. Now, Smith, what are you telling me? That some 25 or 30 years ago...

You and the painter Francois Millet and... Carl Boulanger. Yes. And yourself were starving artists in a provincial French town. Exactly. And that you concocted some mad scheme to get Millet recognized. Ah, but you haven't heard the scheme yet. You see, if you're a creative artist, people don't know you're good unless somebody who speaks with authority says so. You get no argument from me on that, scoresmith. Well, they had the idea to send me to the salon of Madame Lucerne in Paris. She was a former mistress of King Louis Napoleon himself. Which made her an eminent critic, connoisseur and authority on the art. Exactly. Well, how did you propose to gain admission to Madame Salon? You were, after all, ragged, unknown. Well, I did the only thing any sensible man would do under the circumstances.

I broke into a bedroom. Who is that? Don't be alarmed, madame. I'm not a burglar. You are not a burglar? And please don't pull on that bell cord. Allow me to give you two reasons why you are a burglar. First, you break into my room. But, madame... Second, under your arm I see some paintings, which you have obviously stolen from my house. Ah, no, madame. I haven't come here to steal paintings, but to present you with some. Present me? Yes, madame. Because you are the supreme and sublime authority on art. Ah. Look at these, madame. Isn't each a masterpiece? Frankly, monsieur, I wouldn't have the faintest idea. Now, what is this game you wish to play with me? A game? All men have one game or another in mind where I am concerned. And since you are not half bad looking... It is for a friend. Ah. The man is a gene.

One word from you... One word from me. How simple you make it all sound. But it is simple for you. You've turned unknown men into great writers, composers overnight. Oh, it's not a simple matter. And it doesn't happen overnight. The man must have something. Francois Millet has everything. He's a genius. The woods are filled with genius. But surely, I mean, just look at these paintings. Now, I could make a great painter. Out of you. Me? You are the love bandit. You break into the boudoir of famous ladies and you leave behind a painting as a memento of the adventure. These you have here are excellent for the purpose. May we begin? No, these paintings are not mine. Who would know the difference? They're the work of Francois Millet. Must we discuss that?

tiresome, Millais. You see how each painting bears his hallmark, his unique style? Monsieur, these things are lost on me. I know nothing of art. Oh, isn't there anything you could do to help Millais? Oh, sit beside me and we can talk more comfortably. Yes, yes. No, no, surely there's something you could do for him. Why? Well, because one day he would be a glory to France. Oh, Monsieur, you're an Englishman. Yes. Why should you worry about the glory of France? Well, the glory of the world. Oh, well, I think we must decently dispose of Millet. There's only one way I could hope to help him. Oh, how? He would have to be dead. Dead? I'm sorry, but that's the way it goes with the geniuses. Now, where were we? Dead.

The woman is crazy. Gentlemen, the woman is right. What's this? It's a matter of history. She convinced me. You mean Francois is to die? That is rather extreme. Look, an artist has to be starved and dead before he's acknowledged. It happens so often, we could write a law that says the prices that the public will pay for a man's pictures will only climb after he dies. But what good does it do the dead artist if others make money on his pictures? Death lends grandeur to a man. Death makes his name illustrious. Why? I don't know, gentlemen. I don't know. There's no way out, Francois. You simply have to die. Now, look, he asked me... No, no, let us hear him out first, Carl. Now, take several weeks, better several months, to die. And in the meantime, paint. Paint day and night. Enlarge your stock of paintings. Leave behind a ton of work. And Carl and I will make a fortune. A fortune? On the works of the late, great Francois Millet. No, I'll have no part of this. Wait!

What Smith says is not devoid of merit. Francois. Look at us. How we live. How far are we from death. How much longer can we starve like this? Free to without. In a few years, we will be young no longer. And we'll be dead in any event. This way. This way is madness. I won't let you die to make me rich, Francois. No, but listen. That would be enough out of you too, Smith. You didn't let me finish. I said Carl and I would make a fortune selling your paintings, Francois. Which we would then split three ways. Three ways? Yes, Carl, three ways. You and I and Francois. Francois? What did you think I meant for Francois to actually die? What did you say? No, no, no. Why should Francois die? He'll just vanish and change his name. And we'll bury a dummy and cry over it and... Smith! You are the greatest...

to ever leave. Thank you. What a magnificent plan. What do you say, Francois? Well, would it be proper to play this kind of trick on the world? On the other hand, since the world will have it no other way... But we need work. We'll put it to the test. How? Carl, you and I will go out and do some painting. You head north and I'll go south. Choose a villa or a business establishment of some sort. Make sure the owner notices you. He'll come over out of curiosity, and the rest will be easy. So I chose a large country house and set up my easel and began to sketch. I saw the proprietor standing on an upper veranda. I paid no attention to him. I knew that sooner or later he'd saunter over. That's not bad. Not bad at all. Yes, yes, yes. I think you captured that...

Pretty well. Hey, you're good, you're good, you know that. Well, thank you, monsieur. Well, I ought to be good. Look who taught me. Let me see if I have one of his works with me. Oh, here we are, my statue. I suppose you recognize that signature down at the right there? I beg your pardon? He was my teacher. Oh. You mean you don't know the signature of Francois Millet? What have you been spending your life? It's Millet. Francois Millet. Millet. Oh, of course, of course. What could I have been thinking about? Of course, Millet. I recognize that now. Millet, the greatest painter in France. Yes, Millet. This little sketch is genuine Millet. How can you fail to see the brush stroke? Of course, of course. Is it for sale? For sale?

I may not be rich, but I'm not that poor. You know, I really would like to buy it. Well, I don't... Genuinely. I'd like to sell it to you because I can see you really do appreciate great art. But, well, there's a practical consideration. Huh? I'd be a fool to sell it now. Why? Why? You mean you don't know? No. Millet is on his deathbed. The doctors say he can't live three months. And once he dies, his pictures can't be had for love of money. Monsieur, I'll give you 800 francs for that little sketch of his. Oh, you really do love it, don't you? It's a genuine Millet. Oh, I am a fool. All right, take it. 800 francs, Mr. Duane. And Millet would have sold it for a bottle of wine.

You know, two years ago, I sold at auction for 80,000 to Mad World. Well, when I came home, Carl was dancing for joy. A thousand francs! I sold Francois' picture of the little girl and her mother for one. 1,000 francs? Well, your 1,000 francs sell Carl and Smith 800. What a feast we can make this evening. This evening, Francois, you'll have to get sick. Sick? Oh, I never felt better in my life. Tonight, you will take to your bed with the illness that will finally kill you. All right, all right. After dinner. You'll have to look pale one week for all the distinguished visitors. They'll flock here in droves. Why? Well, because they'll want to see you die. He's right, Francois.

No one would walk across the street to see an artist who's alive, but they'd travel the length and breadth of Europe to see what they'd... Well, you may as well prepare yourself, Francois. You're about to become an institution. And this place is going to be a shrine. You wish to see... I see, madame, you've forgotten me. Which one are you? Mr. Smith? I'm sorry to intrude. Oh, well, I am just listening to Mr. Schumann here. He's a composer. Oh, excuse us, please, for just... moment, Monsieur Schumann. Well, now, Mr. Smith, how have you been? Where have you been keeping yourself? I wonder, madame, if you remember your promise. Oh, I never forget a promise. To help my friend. Your friend? Yes, Francois Millet. Millet, Millet. Oh, yes, yes, I recall now, but Mr. Smith, I also remember telling you there was only one way I could help him. He would have to be dead. Yes.

Well, madame, he's getting there. Oh, Mr. Smith, we are all getting there. I know, but he should arrive there in less than a month. Eh? What are you saying? Madame, he's on his deathbed. Oh, this is tragic. Here, sit by me. Now, what is he dying of? I believe a broken heart. A broken heart. Wonderful. Yes, his heart has been broken because the world has failed to recognize his genius. Oh, this is Monsieur Millet. He's on his deathbed, actually? Actually. What a cooperative gentleman. Oh, he certainly deserves to become famous. I brought you some of his paintings. Oh, yes, I see. I see. The unmistakable stamp of genius. His name shall become a household word.

Is that how it's done? Well, it's a way. But is it all that simple? No, not really. We'll encounter a few problems. After all, Francois Millet has to die in a convincing manner and in front of witnesses. Well, that's why we have third acts, isn't it? I shall return in a few moments.

Today, our entertainments are dominated by something known as the caper. This is usually an elaborate scheme to swindle something from somebody. Money from a bank, secrets from a spy ring, anything, anywhere, anytime. Like most art forms, this one is hardly new. We're listening to one right now. It was inspired by a short story by Mark Twain. And if the word had existed in Twain's day, he might very well have named this piece the Francois Millet Caper. I don't understand at all, Smith. Why did you need this Madame Lucerne? After all, you proved you could make money by using Millet's name. Both you and Carl had already sold his pictures. Yes, but that was good enough for the provinces.

Twain, but we wanted more than just a little local reputation. We required fame. And for that, you needed Paris. And no creative artist has ever conquered Paris without the help of a woman. Meanwhile, we were having our problems. Millet didn't mind starving when we didn't have a sou. But now that there was some money... But if I don't eat, I'll die. Well, that's the idea, Francois. But since I'm not to die, actually, what difference should it make? But people come to see you. You can't look healthy and robust on your deathbed. Smith is right. The reporter from that English journal yesterday did give you several suspicious looks. Meanwhile, I'm not painting. You can't have everything. And at mealtimes, I can't have anything. Well, your jokes are becoming feeble at any rate. I have an idea.

Why don't we say I'm too ill to see anyone? In that way, I can eat like an elephant. And you'll get to weigh as much as an elephant, too. We won't be able to get you into your coffin. Who's getting into a coffin? You'll have to be carried out of here when the time comes. That is something no one has explained to me. How and when do I die? And how and when am I to be buried? All the details have not yet been worked out. Suddenly, Twain, we were invaded. Everyone wanted to see the great Francois Millet. Carl and I almost wore ourselves out guarding the door. No, I'm sorry, monsieur, the master is too ill to receive anyone. Yes, yes, of course, of course, we will convey your regard. Meanwhile, Millet was painting away, piling up stock, as we called it, and Madame Lucerne was selling them, discreetly, of course, in Paris. The great sale was the Angelus for 2,200 francs. Little did we know that the day was coming when France would struggle to own it.

And a stranger would come along and capture it for a half million cash. And meanwhile, we were having problems with Millet. Or I should say, with his appetite. I don't understand it, Carl. He gets fatter every day. Well, fatter and healthier looking. This won't do. Carl, do you allow him to sneak in some food on the sly? How can you accuse me? Well, how can he gain weight on tea and toast? Well, especially tea without sugar. And toast without butter. Wait, wait, wait. Inside, listen. Inside his room. Do you hear what I hear? Well, I'm not sure. Shh. That has to be the sound of a spoon against a bowl. He's eating. But how? Oh, why can't we think of it? Somebody's smuggling food into him from the outside. But who? That has to be the answer. Sneaking food into his room through the window. Now, you sit here. I'll steal around to the back of the house. What are you doing here? Oh, I... Oh, it's Madame Mofigneur. Well, I... Explain yourself, Madame. When it's so...

Francois Millet is a genius, a great genius. He is? Who says so? Why, everyone says so. It's a known fact. And when I heard he was dying, I thought perhaps... What do the doctors know? The poor man probably needs a decent meal. Well, no one is allowed into the house, and so I... Yes, yes. Well, we can't have any more of this. Why not? Because of... Because the doctor says food will kill him. Should it matter? He's dying anyway. And you should see how happy he is with my soup and the roast fowl and the fish. Madame, he is not a goose to be stuffed for pate. You needn't yell at me. I was only doing my Christian duty. But we only want him to die in comfort. And I want him to die happy. Poor fellow. He starved most of his life. Must he go hungry to his grave? But he's very ill. He looks fine to me. Fat and rosy. Perhaps.

My cooking can save his life. Or do you want him to die? Why would I want him to die? Well, there's nothing to be done. It could prove a great embarrassment. So we let her deliver the food every day, and of course Carl and I were forced to eat it. Meanwhile, the house was besieged. People came from everywhere for the death watch. It was unbelievable. Read what it says here in the paper. The lamp? Flickers for Francois Millet. Great painter. Said to be in his last hours. He's all over the world. Look, England. The final chapter in the Millet story. In America. Curtains for Francois. I shall die in earnest if I am not fed. What are you doing here, Francois? Why aren't you in bed? Wasting away. Look at me. Nothing but skin and bones while you two guard yourself on Madame Muffineux's heavenly cuisine. It's not fair.

This is the thanks we get for making the man a genius. Hang being a genius. When can I get a decent meal? Really, Smith, we should hire a butler. Francois, back into bed, quickly, quickly. Just the wing of the chicken? No. Not even the neck? Into your room, quickly, Francois. I might as well die and be done with it. Now, let me see who that is. Oh, let me in, quickly. Oh, Madame Lucerne, please. You know the whole world is talking about the great François Millet? Yes, madame. A tragedy. The demand for his paintings rises by the hour. We have plenty stacks of them, which madame can take back to Paris and sell. Oh, no, monsieur. They will sell better after he dies. The poor man. He's a death's door, is he not? Yes, madame. Standing on the threshold, as it were. Oh, may I...

Pay my respects. Well, madame, you see... Mr. Smith, please tell your friend I am so attached to the master that I shall be desolated if I cannot see him at least once before... before I cannot tell to see him. Oh, madame, madame, this way, please. Francois, Francois, a beautiful lady to see you. Oh, poor Francois, he seems to be in a coma. Monsieur, he looks remarkably healthy. For one who is supposed to be terribly ravaged by illness. Oh, well, looks are deceptive, you know. I thought you said he was a deaf dog. He is, he is. Oh, well, timing, you realize, is everything in life, as well as death. This would be an excellent week. It would. Next week, everyone will be talking about a new opera by Wagner, and we expect some stunt or other from Alexandre Dumas, the younger. But this...

This is a very quiet week. Oh, I see. Of course, I realize that man goes when he has summoned to the divine presence, and not a minute before. How true. However, there is always the possibility that one is too busy to hear the summons. Yes. Well, as you can see, madame, he is failing before our very eyes. Oh, poor man. Well, I must return to Paris, where I shall say, of course, that he died. In my arms. How tragic. Yes. Well, I must hurry back there to speak with all the journalists. Of course, of course. I had taken the liberty to order a coffin. A coffin? Yes. It should be at your doorstep at any moment. Oh. A most splendid final home for a man of such magnificence. Thank you, madame. Well, I felt it was the least I could do.

And now, if you will excuse me, I must return. Of course. Oh, oh, do you mind if I leave this valise here? It might be too much trouble to carry back. Of course not, madame. I thought I would stay longer, and I had brought a change of costume, but that dress bothers me. Why not give it to some loving charity? As you wish, madame.

A few hours after she left us, there was another knock on the door. And it was, um, you guessed it, the coffin. A small coffin. How would Francois ever get into it? Oh, what was I thinking? Francois wouldn't get into the coffin. Carl and I had already prepared a dummy for that purpose. Our basic problem was... How am I supposed to get out of the house? Are we ready to make the announcement? We have a problem, Francois. Well, uh... I thought you were working on that problem, Smith. Well... I could sneak out through the back window. Oh, the house is surrounded. Where would you go? Everyone knows you for miles around. Especially now. Smith, you should have thought of this before. I did think of it. I just couldn't come up with any solution. I can't die until I know where I'm going. Would we could all say that. And the best time for it, as that Madame Lucerne said, is this week. Ah, Madame Lucerne.

Why didn't we ask her to propose a way out of this difficulty? Madame Lucerne, of course. She foresaw the problem and she's given us a way out. How? Hand me her valise. How can her valise give up? Here, here, here. See? You see this costume? A black dress. Yes. Black hat. A veil. These are for the lady in black. Who is the lady in black? Oh, a mysterious mourner. A woman who loved you deeply, passionately. But who is she? Oh, no one knows. Put on the dress. Oh, but I... Hurry, Francois. Come on, I feel ridiculous. You'd better start feeling sad. Very sad. No, no, just a few quiet sobs. Nothing loud, nothing uncontrolled. Just, let's say, the dignified weeping of a woman of high breeding and great dignity. Is that what she's supposed to be? Oh, well, would our friend Francois choose any other kind of mistress?

Oh, by the way, is the coffin sealed? Coffin is ready. Picture avail, Francois. Oh, fine, fine, excellent. Come, my friends. Those of us who loved him best, his pupils and the mysterious woman who loved him, we have an announcement to make to the world. Open the door, Carl. Ladies and gentlemen, I have a most melancholy statement to make. So you buried Francois Mireille, eh, Smith? Yes, Twain, we buried the dummy in the coffin. There was a great funeral. Oh, yes. And Millet disguised as the woman escaped detection. The world was convinced Millet had died. What happened to him? Oh, can you keep a secret? I can only cry. Remember that elderly gentleman I pointed out to you earlier this morning? That... That was Francois Millet? That was Francois Millet. For once, a great artist was not...

Starved and killed by indifference and neglect, and then given the vain and empty pomp of a loud and meaningless funeral. We saw to that. Francois Millet has never known, and will never know, another hungry day. Who was it that said, live well, and that's the best revenge? Live well. So few artists can manage it in the face of indifference and just... plain misunderstanding. And when Mark Twain wrote the story, he did it in the spirit of here's one for our side. Well, we're always on your side. And we'll be back here in just a few moments. Is he living or is he dead? Well, of course, he's dead today. But was he living back in 1892, the date of the story? Was Mark Twain playing a gentle hoax on all of us?

Was the old practical joker himself the victim of a practical joke? We'll never know. But we do know we'll be here seven times each week. Our cast included Alexander Scorby, Court Benson, Paul Hecht, and Bryna Rayburn. The entire production was under the direction of Hyman Brown. Tragedy at its finest. Inevitable. Inexorable. And somehow... in the honesty of all but the sinful villain, ennobling. I'll be back shortly. It would be unfair, of course, to leave our tragedy just as it resolved itself, for only one reason. That sinister, despicable, unforgivable Iago. I'm glad to report that for those of you who might not know in advance, his punishment well fitted the crime. Since Cassio was governor, and in a sense, dictator of Cyprus, it was left to him to dispose of Iago. When all the facts came out, how kind would you have been? Our cast included Arnold Moss, Marion Seldes, Joan Arliss, Court Benson, Ralph Bell, and Ian Martin. The entire production was under the direction of Hyman Brown.

End of transcriptBack to the beginning ↑