Skip to content
On Air
All channelsAll
CBS Radio Mystery Theater artwork

From the CBS Radio Mystery Theater collection

It's Murder, Mr. Lincoln

Episode 241March 18, 197544 min 20 secTranscript

Writer: Himan Brown

The written record

Read the transcript

Read along with the recording · About 33 min to read

And now, Mystery Theater. I'm E.G. Marshall, and we're doing business as usual, featuring our full assortment of the mysterious and the bizarre. Quis custodiet ipsos custodes? Who shall guard the guards? Or, to take it a step higher, who shall judge the judges? This was a problem that plagued the ancient Romans, and obviously it remains with us to this very day. And actually, the act of judging is a highly hazardous affair, because the book warns us, Judge not, lest ye be judged. And so, between the necessity to judge and the admonition not to do it, we human beings are in a constant state of doubt, which is not the worst thing in the world.

Hold! Hold on there! What do you want? What are you doing with that pistol?

That's highly your affair, Mr. Lincoln. A man prowling about at night holding a loaded pistol is certainly an object of curiosity.

Only to those that don't mind their own affairs.

I consider the safety of the community to be very much my affair, Mr. Barnes. You'll oblige me by handing over that pistol.

And you'll oblige me by going about your own business, Mr. Lincoln. I'm afraid I'll have to take that pistol.

I'd advise you not to try it.

Hand it over, sir. I warn you. Not another step.

Our mystery drama, It's Murder, Mr. Lincoln, was written especially for the Mystery Theater by Sam Dann and stars Keir Dullea.

When conditions are bad, we Americans always spend a great deal of energy not in finding a solution to the problem, but rather in deciding what to call it. Is it a depression? Is it a recession? Back in 1837, they called it a panic. So, you see, we have made progress. 1837 was certainly a year to tighten one's belt. Definitely, it was not a favorable year to embark upon a new career. And a young man named Abraham Lincoln is discovering this the hard way. He has just settled in Springfield, Illinois, where he has opened a law office. Abe Lincoln sits in his law office and waits for clients. This afternoon, as usual, he is sitting down. And although he is completely unaware of it, a case is being created for him just down the street in Fellman's Tavern.

Now, what I want to know is, what's the point in having Martin Van Buren sitting in the White House? Why, we might just as well have Andy Jackson.

Ah, well, Tom, Andy's old and sick. Why, he's half dead.

Well, better an Andy Jackson who's half dead than a Martin Van Buren who's all alive.

Yes, that's a good one, huh?

Yeah, he sure is, huh? I have to remember that one.

Good afternoon, gentlemen.

Good afternoon. You want to hear a good one, sir? I was just saying to this gentleman here, Mr. Ephraim Barnes, I was saying, better a half-dead Jackson than an all-alive Van Buren. Isn't that what I said, Ephraim?

Something like that.

Are you Tom Fellman?

Yeah, in the flesh. I'd like a room.

Cost you a dollar.

All right.

In advance. Oh, no, man, anything. It just says in Corinthians. Where is it? Back. Well, here's your dollar.

Thank you. Drink?

No, not for me. It'll come to the price of the room. I never drink while there's work to be done. Huh? Well, what's your name, stranger? You know mine. I'm Tom Fellman, and this gentleman here is Ephraim Barnes. He runs a bank.

Ah, glad to meet you, Mr., uh... Jones? Franklin Jones. What's your business, Mr. Jones?

I assure you, this is the First National Farmers and Merchants Bank of Springfield is very much at your service.

Oh, thank you, Mr. Barnes. I'll keep that in mind. Could either of you gentlemen tell me where I might find a Mr. Cyrus Darrow?

Cy Darrow? He's got a farm. Big place it is, too. Just turn just north of here. You just follow the road right out of town. Uh, may I inquire your business with Mr. Darrow, sir?

Well, that depends on Mr. Darrow.

Well, that's playing the cards close to the vest. Uh, bread eaten in secret is the sweetest, as it says in Proverbs. Where's that Leviticus?

There's nothing secret about my business with Mr. Darrow. He swindled me out of some money. Now he's either gonna pay it back, or I intend to blow his head off.

Yeah, well, now, Mr. Jones, there's no need for that. If you have proof, you can take him to court.

Well, I don't have proof, so I'll just have to do it my way. I've come here to get what's mine by rights. And I have the instrument with which to secure it.

Well?

Well, that's a wicked-looking weapon you got there, sir.

I fought in Florida, in the Seminole War. This pistol was first and last fired in the service of my country. I earned the right to use it in my own behalf.

Now, sir, you cannot flout the law.

Yes, indeedy. The law is sitting right here by your side. In me, you see the sheriff, and Mr. Barnes is the judge for this term.

Well, gentlemen, all I can say is... that if a man don't get no justice, he will have to make his own.

My room, sir?

Up the stairs, first door to your right. Supper's at five o'clock.

That young fellow bears a bit of watching.

Yeah. I pity him if he goes up against old man Darrow. Cyrus will just chew him up and spit him out.

Wicked-looking pistol, that. You know, I'm not a wagering man, Ephraim, but if I was... I'd lay my money on Cyrus Darrow. Poor fellow. Seems kind of young to die after surviving an Indian war and all.

Devil's name's out there this time of night. What's your business with me? Go on home! Got a bone to pick for Cyrus Darrow? You come around in the daylight time, like honest, respectable folks.

All right, all right, all right. Don't bust her down. I'm coming. I'm coming.

Oh, it's you, eh? Come whining around to see if I'll leave you off the hook, eh? Well, you can hang there, and you can go. And squirm till I'm good and ready. You think that pistol can scare me, eh? You ain't man enough to... Come on, now. Hand it over before I make you chew it up. You yellow-bellied...

What? Who's there?

The sheriff.

Sheriff?

That's right. Open up in the name of the law.

Oh, hi, Mr. Fellman. Oh, Mr. Fellman, the tavern keeper. Yes, sir. It's Mr. Fellman, the sheriff. You'll have to come along with me soon.

What for?

What for? Mr. Jones, it looks like you did what you came here to do.

What's that?

Kill Cyrus Darrow.

Kill Cyrus Darrow? But I didn't. He's dead, son. Big hole in his forehead caused by the forcible entry of a pistol ball.

There must be some mistake.

No, sir. There's no mistake. This here, this your pistol?

Of course it's my pistol. It was found 50 yards away from Cyrus's house.

No, you couldn't have found it 50 yards away, because... Because?

Well, because... It can't be my pistol. I remember. I put it back in my bag.

Yeah?

Yeah. Hey, it isn't here.

Of course not. How could it be in that bag and in my hand at one and the same time? I never... I didn't...

Mr. Jones, as sheriff of Sangamon County, I hereby arrest you for the murder of Cyrus Darrow.

What?

And may the Lord have mercy on your soul.

What are you saying?

Well, that's right. That's right. I shouldn't say that just yet. After all, you ain't been tried. But you'll get a fair trial before they hang you.

I don't know what to say, Franklin. I don't know what to say.

I didn't kill him, Emily. I didn't.

Franklin, everyone says...

I don't care what everyone says. You just got to believe in me. Why did you have to come here with a pistol? Why did you have to threaten him in public? Why did you... Why, why, why?

Because I'm stupid. That's why.

Oh, Franklin, I'm sorry. I guess I really am in the soup this time. He... This man, Cyrus Darrow, was very well liked. And the evidence against you, it's so strong.

Evidence? What evidence? What evidence?

Oh, Franklin, your threats to kill him, the pistols...

I swear to you, Em... I believe you, darling. But there's gonna be a trial. I'll make them believe me. I'll make everyone believe me.

You'll need a lawyer.

Yeah, well, I'll hire a lawyer. And I... Yeah, what is it, dear?

A lawyer... Yeah, well, that's just what I said, my darling. I'll hire a lawyer.

Dear, there are no lawyers.

No lawyers here in Springfield, the state capital? Why, in a place like this, there are nothing but lawyers.

I've been asking around, and I've gotten answers. One fella says, sorry, ma'am, I just couldn't take on another case. And meanwhile, he's got his feet on the desk, and I can see the holes in his shoes. And then another fella says, I never did try a murder case. What is it? There isn't nobody in this town doing murder cases. There isn't nobody in this town doing 15 cents worth of business. And they say, each of them say to me, sorry, Miss Jones, I just can't see my way clear.

Well, why won't they take my case?

Well, it... Is it because they don't think they can win?

Emily, that should make no difference. Law says every man's entitled to a lawyer.

I know. But what the law really means, every man's entitled to a lawyer, provided he can get one.

Yes, ma'am. Are you Judge Barnes?

Well, here in the bank this week, I'm Mr. Barnes. I don't start being Judge Barnes till next week. Now, who do I have the pleasure of addressing?

My name is Jones. Emily Jones. Mrs. Franklin Jones.

Oh? Judge, my husband can't find himself a lawyer.

Well, surely, Miss Jones, in all of Springfield, there must be somebody who, uh... Who don't mind ruining his reputation?

Now, Miss Jones, lawyers don't see things that way at all.

Then how does it happen no lawyer's willing to defend my husband?

Well, if it's a busy time...

How busy? Look at your bank. Ain't a soul in here except you and me.

Yeah, well...

Well, what, sir? People going broke left and right, nothing being brought in or sold? No contracts to draw up? What are all these lawyers doing?

Well, I'm sure if you look around...

I looked. I looked everywhere. And everybody's turned me down.

Everybody?

Everybody.

Ah. Hmm. Have, uh... Have you spoken to a man named Lincoln? Abe Lincoln?

Abe Lincoln? No, the name ain't familiar.

Well, why don't you give Abe a try? He's the kind of lawyer that'll take any case he can get.

Well, I must say, Judge... That don't sound like a very enthusiastic recommendation.

Well, well... It's the only recommendation I can give you.

Yes, ma'am? Will you please tell Mr. Abe Lincoln I'm here?

No need to do that, ma'am. You've already done so.

You? You're Abe Lincoln?

Plea is guilty, ma'am. Now, to whom do I have the pleasure of, uh... But you don't. I know. I don't look like a lawyer. Well, the fact is, I don't look very much like anything else, either. Well, I... Would you have a seat, ma'am? Now, I... I, uh... My name is Emily Jones. My husband, Franklin... Oh, he named after Ben Franklin?

Yes, sir. I believe so.

A great man.

Yes, sir. He... He, my husband, is gonna be tried for murder.

I know. And I need a lawyer.

Well, you've come to the right place.

You mean you're willing to defend him?

I'm ready, ma'am.

Well, that may be, but... I've got to ask you about your qualifications. How many murder cases have you tried?

Uh... How many? To be exact, ma'am... None.

None? Miss Jones, a fella has to start someplace.

Well, but not with my husband.

Well, I do have one qualification. Matter of fact, it, uh... Could turn out to be the most important qualification of all.

What's that?

I'm the only lawyer in town willing to take the case.

Didn't Longfellow say, Lives of great men all remind us We can make our own sublime And departing leave behind us Footprints on the sands of time?

Yes, he did. However, what we should realize about the lives of great men... Is the fact that most of them weren't always great. Can you imagine being unhappy to have Abraham Lincoln as your lawyer?

I'll return shortly with Act Two.

His name is Franklin Jones. Right now, he is in the jailhouse in Springfield, Illinois... In the early autumn of the year 1837. He's accused of murder. His prospects are bleak. The betting is better than ten to one. He'll feel a rope around his neck before the month is out. The odds have not been lowered by the fact that his lawyer... Is a young man named Abe Lincoln. And who was in the tavern when you came in?

Uh, Mr. Fellman, uh, Mr. Barnes.

No one else?

Nope, no one else.

I asked if they knew where I could find Mr. Cyrus Darrow... And they asked why, and I told them.

Couldn't you tell them that it was your own affair?

Well, I didn't.

Oh, you always have to be bragging about something. No matter how many times I tell you.

Please, Emily. Mr. Lincoln here ain't interested in our personal business.

Oh, but I am.

You are? Why?

Because you never can tell what might be important.

All that's important is to keep the rope away from Franklin's neck.

Well, that's exactly what we're trying to do, Miss Jones. Now, Frank, you, uh, came here the night before last from Valley Junction.

That's right. We just started farming.

Miss Jones, I appreciate it. We let Frank answer.

Well, I can give you the facts faster and clearer.

I know, ma'am, but, well, Frank's gonna need practice. He'll be the one that has to answer at the trial. So, Frank, you came here the other night. You, uh, engaged a room. You stated your business to Mr. Feldman and to Mr. Barnes.

Like a fool.

Uh, yeah, yes, sir. That's right. And you, uh, showed them the pistol. Why?

Well, uh, the pistol was a present to my dad from General William Henry Harrison. Dad was with Harrison at the Tippecanoe.

You see? He wanted to brag about it.

Uh, Mr. Feldman and Mr. Barnes, well, they weren't easy fellas to talk to. Uh, you know what I mean.

I know what you mean, Frank. Uh, so, I-I just went upstairs to my room and I went to bed, figuring I'd see Cyrus Darrow first thing in the morning. And, uh... Next thing I knew, there's a knock on the door, and it's the sheriff. I'm being arrested for murder.

And at no time during the night did you arise from your bed and go forth to Mr. Darrow's place and shoot him?

I did not shoot him. I was asleep in my room.

Well, we have to make that defense stand up.

You sound like you don't believe him.

Oh, I believe him. I'm not the problem. We've got a judge and a jury to consider. Frank, the pistol, where was it?

In the bag.

You placed it in the bag before you went to sleep?

Yes, sir.

Well, how did it get to where it was found, in the field, 50 yards from Mr. Darrow's door?

I don't know.

Well, the prosecution will say that you went there, shot Darrow, fled from the scene, and in your guilty terror and confusion, you dropped the gun.

Well, I couldn't have dropped the gun when I wasn't even carrying it to start with. I wasn't there.

Well, then we must claim that someone came into this room while you were asleep and stole that pistol.

Yeah, well, that's the only way it could have happened.

You were conscious of no one?

Oh, I was asleep.

Tell me this. What was your business with Mr. Darrow?

Why do you want to know?

Frank.

Is that important?

The first question the prosecutor will ask. I should know.

Oh, that was before he was killed.

Frank.

Well, I enlisted in 1829. 1830. Oh, 18, yeah, that's right. And I served in Georgia and Florida. And when I wanted to marry Emily, you... Well, you don't get married on sergeant's pay.

Oh, not to me, you don't.

Anyway, there was this fella in the company. First platoon he was, a funny little fella, fat and baldy, you know, but smart. He was a Frenchman or a German or something like that. He spoke funny. You know, the army's full of all kinds of foreigners.

Well, they had to run here because they're having all kinds of revolutions in Europe.

Will you get to the point?

Now, why should Mr. Lincoln care beans about them revolutions in Europe?

Yeah, well, well, his name was Fulda. And he knew all about plants and flowers, you know. And he said, Jonesy, some of these varieties could grow very well up north.

Yeah, it would.

Yeah, well, I never did find out. You see, he and I were going into business and we collected boxes and boxes of various seeds and we was going to sell them to farmers up this way where I was well known. That is, I knew some people.

And since I was one of the biggest farmers in this part. Well, we wrote to him and he wrote back offering to buy a special kind of feed. And we sent him thirty dollars worth and he never did pay up. So we wrote and we asked him for our money and he sent back an answer saying he'd be hanged if he pay a cent for some sticky Georgia thistles.

What was that man talking about anyway?

Well, I don't know. I could have made a mistake and not cleaned out the seed like Fulda said you had to do.

Well, he invited me to come up and look at his brand new thistle patch and also give me an opportunity to wring my neck at one of the same time.

And I said, Frank, you go up there and you get your money.

Well, did I know he was going to take a gun?

And at no time then did you visit Darrow's farm?

No, sir, he did not. He was nowhere near that place.

Frank?

No, sir.

As far as you know, it could. That is, the seed you sold him could very well have been thistle or burrs or whatever.

Well, supposing they was. What does this have to do with the killing of Cyrus Darrow?

You weren't up there, Frank.

I said I wasn't.

Well, I better be getting along.

Where are you off to?

I think I'll ride up to Darrow Farm.

Whatever for?

I might learn something.

What's to learn? The man's been murdered. We know that.

Well, I might find some evidence.

What kind?

I have no idea. But I have to look.

You mean you're going to look for something and you don't know what?

Yes, I suppose you could put it that way.

What was that, Miss Jones?

Nothing. Just...

What are you, Tom?

Now, do anything?

Well, I'm about to take a run up to Darrow Farm. Maybe some evidence.

Yeah, evidence, evidence of things not seen, as it says in Leviticus.

Hebrews.

Yeah, well, leaving soon. I'd like to get back before supper.

You've taken the Jones case.

Yeah, I was retained this morning.

Well, maybe... Think that's wise?

Wise? I'm a lawyer.

What do you have to think of your career? You know, you've got to lose that case. It's plain as a cabbage on a rose bush. The boy's guilty.

Isn't that why we're having a trial?

Oh, we're having a trial because the law says he's got to get one. You know what the verdict's going to be?

Tom, I'm surprised at you.

No, no, you're the surprise. Now, look. You can't win. If you lose, you look bad because you're a loser. And if by some miracle, you could have a miracle, because as Milton says, the age of miracles is forever here.

That was Carlyle.

Carlyle. Anyhow, if by a miracle you win, well, folks will resent it.

Why?

Well, the boy's so obviously guilty, people want him to hang.

Look, Abe, I'm thinking of your future.

My future?

Yeah, you could have a great future in politics. I've seen you operate. Why, you single-handed got the state capitol moved up here from Vandalia.

Oh, no, that's not really true.

It is. It is. Abe, you could go far.

Oh, no, no, not me.

Why do you say no?

Well, I just don't look like a politician.

Well, there's no special way a politician's supposed to look.

Yeah, it isn't so. He's got to look kind of solidly dignified, like Daniel Webster, sharp and smart like Clay or Calhoun or shrewd like Tom Benton or even jolly like Stephen Douglas, but he can't... Well, he can't afford to be funny looking like me.

Well, I wouldn't say he was all that funny looking, Abe.

I'm too tall, too thin and too bony and gawky.

But you got all the brains.

Brains alone was never enough. Abe, is there some way you could get out of trying this case?

No, I mean it. And for your own good, Darrow was well liked.

I wouldn't get out even if I could, Tom. Darrow was very well liked and folks are mad to think about that.

There's nothing to think about.

Well, just thought I'd paint your picture. After all, as William Shakespeare said, forewarned is forearmed.

No, that was Miguel Cervantes.

Wow.

Hello there, Abe.

Good day, Mr. Bennett. What brings you out here, Abe?

Oh, I thought I'd come out here and look.

For what?

For anything I could find. I saw someone moving around in the house. Turns out to be you.

Well, I was his lawyer. I'm just getting his papers put together.

Well, come in, come in. Look around, if you like.

Thank you, Mr. Bennett.

Right here in the doorway is where he fell. I found the body, you know, in the morning. I'd come by to go over some contracts. There he was, dead.

You going through his papers?

Mm-hmm. I'm trying to.

Mm-hmm.

Anything missing?

Well, Abe, either stuff is missing or he hid them away somewhere.

What do you mean?

I mean, he didn't tell his lawyer everything. No client ever does. You're going to find that out.

Well, what would seem to be missing?

I haven't had a chance to go through it all, but I know for a fact he's been lending out money all over town. The way things are with the banks and all, he was the only one with hard cash.

Yes, I heard.

Well, you could say there were plenty of folks who might have had a motive, Mr. Bennett.

Yeah, you could say that, Abe. But I think your man is going to pay the bill.

But he told me he never even came up here.

I know, Abe. When you've had as many clients as I have, you learn how easily they can lie to you.

It's hard to believe this boy isn't telling me the truth.

Yeah, that's what makes this so dang difficult. Maybe he thinks he's telling you the truth.

Abe, you're in trouble on this case. Admit it.

I never denied it.

Let's step outside before we might find a way out of this problem. Now, Abe, just off to your left, leading to the road. There's a full acre and it's planted in what?

Now, hold on, Mr. Bennett. That's a wild field.

That's a planted field, Abe.

But who'd want to plant all those weeds and burrs and thistle?

They come from the seeds my client bought from your client.

That's hard to believe.

Why?

Let's say your client's a sharper or he made an honest mistake. Don't matter. But he made my client mad. My old client was ready to kill that boy on sight.

Get my point?

Mr. Bennett, I think I do. Now, well, taking it straight from there, you begin to see a new line of approach in the case. Mr. Bennett, let me tell you, sir, I am eternally in your debt. To think I had just considered this case was hopeless.

Abe, when everything looks hopeless, that's the time you really start to hope.

And of course, that was a lesson that Abe Lincoln never forgot. Certainly in the years to come, he would be faced with more apparently hopeless situations than almost any other president. But our concern is with the case in hand. And what is the light that has suddenly dawned? Well, that will all be made visible when I return in just a few moments with Act three.

It is always surprising to consider that what we call psychology is a science of recent vintage. We speak so easily of things like the split personality, the other self, the active falsehood without realizing that these terms would be unintelligible to people who lived even 100 years ago. But although our forebears did not know these things intellectually, they could understand their implications. After all, Sigmund Freud was only 10 years old when Abe Lincoln died. Yet Lincoln already sensed a great deal of what Freud was to discover.

No, Mr. Lincoln, he don't lie to me. That's one thing.

What would you do?

He don't lie to me.

Emily, maybe he has no choice.

What do you mean?

Well, maybe... maybe he's afraid he'd lose you if you knew he was a murderer. What would you do if he confessed?

What would I do?

Would you leave him?

Well, I... You see?

Oh, I'd raise up a storm, I guess. I'd holler and rip, but afterward, well, I'd stand by him.

Well, then you must convince him of that.

But will it save him?

At least it's a defense. I could plead it. This way, all I'm doing is begging the mercy of the court.

But will it work?

Self-defense always gives a man a chance.

How much of a chance? Well, I'm a lawyer, Emily. I'm not a prophet, but we can get witnesses to prove that Cy Darrow was furious with Franklin.

But why?

Because Franklin had sold him nothing but weeds.

How do you know?

I was up there, Emily. I saw them. A strange kind of growth for this part of the country. Brambles and... burrs and weeds.

It really wasn't Frank's fault, Mr. Lincoln. He just doesn't know.

But Cyrus Darrow was boiling mad. Now, oddly enough, this could create some sympathy for Franklin.

How?

They'll all think Frank was a swindler.

Well, maybe not a swindler, more of a sharper.

Oh, what's the difference?

Well, Emily, you have to know these old horse traders up here. They might even admire him.

Why?

Because he's done something nobody else was ever able to bring off.

What's that?

He got the better of Cy Darrow in the deal. He went up to Seaside to brazen it out. Being careful, of course, to bring his pistol. The fact that the pistol was given to him by General Harrison won't hurt either.

Well, then you think we've got a chance?

Yes, Emily, I would say that what with one thing and another, we've got a fighting chance.

No.

You heard, Emily. I said no.

But Mr. Lincoln just explained.

I know what Mr. Lincoln just explained. Don't you understand? If you don't plead self-defense, you're sure to hang.

Well, I ain't going to do it.

Why?

I told you once. I told you a thousand times. I wasn't there.

What, Frank?

I didn't kill him.

I give up. What can you do with him, Mr. Lincoln?

Mr. Lincoln, would you want me to get up there on that stand and tell a lie?

Is it a lie, Franklin? You mean you didn't kill Cy Darrow in self-defense?

Huh. Here's a hole to be in. A man's wife won't believe him. His lawyer won't believe him.

Frank, we only want...

Franklin, I can only plead the defense my client gives me. If I wasn't at the scene of the crime when the murder took place, I don't know what happened.

Well, I don't know neither. I wasn't there myself. I was asleep in bed in my room at Fellman's Tavern.

But Franklin, nobody's going to believe that.

Well, ain't that what I got a lawyer for? So we can make folks believe me? Or is this case too tough for you, Mr. Lincoln?

Well, it's tough enough. Hey, did you find anything up there at Darrow's place?

How'd you know I was up there?

Well, look at your pants.

Oh, yeah, them little burs. Almost too small to see. Unless you're looking for them.

Yes, sir, you'll be picking them off your pants legs for weeks.

I thought I'd gotten rid of most of them.

No, sir, they're hidden where you can't even see them. And some of the seeds, why, they'll even germinate on the clothes, seems like. You better boil those pants.

Well, thank you. I guess Darrow was right, Emily. We did sell them weeds.

I didn't mean to, Mr. Lincoln. It's just that Corporal Fulda would have known what to do. He said you have to wash the seed in something called weed, and I don't even know what it is.

What are you going to do now, Mr. Lincoln?

Tell me, who else was in the tavern when you came in?

Well, I told you, just Mr. Fellman and Mr. Barnes.

Nobody else?

No, sir.

You positive?

I'll swear to it.

Well, do you know anyone in the town?

No, sir. Not a single solitary soul. Why do you ask?

Well, Emily, it's about time I started asking questions.

But you've been asking questions all along.

No, not the right questions. And I haven't been asking the right people either.

Well, Abe, I can only tell you the boy insists on having a rope put around his neck. He refuses to plead self-defense. In my opinion, he'd rather die having his wife think he's not a murderer.

I believe him.

It can be a dangerous business when you start believing clients.

It can even be a more dangerous business when you don't.

What can I do for you, Abe?

You've been through all of Cy's papers yet?

All I was able to turn up? With either Tom Fellman or Ephraim Barnes, I was a vote of money.

Well, now, Abe, this is a lawyer-client relationship. You asking me to break it?

Well, the client's dead, Mr. Bennett. And I'm not asking out of idle curiosity.

Yes, he did have a mortgage on Fellman's.

I thought Tom Fellman owned the place free and clear. He's been a moneymaker for years.

Don't you know there's been a panic on? There ain't a nickel's worth of cash to be had.

Well, why would Tom Fellman go to Cy Darrow when he could get money at bank rates from his good friend Ephraim Barnes?

Banks don't have it either, Abe.

Did you find any papers for either Tom or Ephraim?

What are you trying to say, Abe?

I'm just asking, Mr. Bennett. To answer your question, no. There was no papers for either one of them. And yet, they both owed him money.

I'm reasonably sure of it, Abe.

Well, thank you, Mr. Bennett. Good afternoon, gentlemen.

Well, Abe.

Well, afternoon, Abe. Have a drink. How's the law business coming?

Slow.

Well, slow but sure moves mighty mountains.

Aristotle.

Euripides.

Yeah. Abe, I swear one day I'm going to catch you.

Gentlemen, we have some business to discuss.

Let's discuss business at my office only.

This is legal business, Ephraim.

Then I'd rather discuss it at your office.

It has to do with the upcoming trial.

The trial of Franklin Jones. In that case, I don't discuss it at all. I'm scheduled to be presiding judge.

I don't think so, Ephraim.

Well, as you're saying, you can see the calendar. I'm going to ask you to disqualify yourself, Ephraim.

What are you saying, Abe? Here's one of the finest... Abe, don't you believe I'm a fair man?

It's nothing personal, Ephraim.

Well, then why...

To begin with, you're a material witness.

Who is?

You are. You and Tom here, you're the ones that... the only ones who heard Tom ask for the whereabouts of Cy Darrow. And who heard Tom threaten to kill him.

Yeah, well, I...

Well, you can't be a judge and a witness at the same time, can you?

Yeah, but you...

Besides, there's more to it than that.

What are you driving at, Abe?

Well, my client insists that he's not guilty.

Well, you wouldn't expect him to admit it now, would you?

Yes, if he were guilty, I would. Especially since I found a way he could plead guilty and still save his neck at the same time.

What's that?

Self-defense. Old Cy was sore and mad at him. Mad enough to kill him. But the boy refuses to take that defense, which proves to me that he's a young man of his word. And I have to respect that word.

Abe... Abe, if Franklin Jones didn't kill Cy Darrow, who in thunder did?

Well, we'll have to sit down, the three of us, and reason together. If Franklin didn't kill Cy, who did? We know somebody did, because Cy's dead.

I'd like you to come straight and tell me exactly what you're driving at, Abe.

Well, it couldn't be suicide. After all, how would Cy get a hold of Frank's pistol?

Well, what motive would Cy have for doing away with himself?

None. But you can't be too careful in these things. You have to explore every possibility.

Ah, but you also have to be headed someplace.

Don't be impatient, Ephraim. I am.

Well, if it wasn't Frank, who else could it be? Who else knew Frank was in town? Who else knew Frank was mad enough to go to Cy's place with a pistol? Who else would even know that Frank had a pistol? The answer? Either one of you two.

Well, hold on there, Abe. Are you saying that Ephraim here, or me, could have killed Cy Darrow?

Abe, Abe, I am your best friend in town. How could you even think that?

Abe, I thought you was always a man of good sense. But this is monstrous.

Have either of you gentlemen been up to see Cy lately?

Well?

Been up to see Cy Darrow's place since, since I bought a pony from him in, uh, thirty-three, no, no, it was thirty-four. Why, yeah, it's been three years.

Ephraim?

It's been at least a year since I had occasion to visit Cy's farm.

Where'd you transact your business?

Whatever business we would transact, we would do at the bank.

Gentlemen, one of you two is lying.

Hey, now look here. Now, now, you, you want to be careful now, Abe. Friendship only excuses just so much.

Let me borrow that chair.

Now, I'm going to put my foot up on the seat of it.

What for?

Oh, come on, let's humor him, he's mad.

You'll notice that the lower part of my trouser leg, it's covered with very tiny little sticky burrs.

Uh-huh, so?

So, these are typical of a growth that occurs only in northern Florida, or southern Georgia. You can't find them anywhere else in the country except at Cy Darrow's farm.

Well, now, what's that got to do with the price of tea in China?

They grew from seeds sold to Darrow by mistake by Franklin Jones.

I still don't see what you're driving at.

I was up there just before. That's how they got all over my pants leg. Now, will each of you gentlemen please place his foot up on the chair?

I'll be hanged if I do.

Is that a prophecy, Ephraim?

Eve.

Ephraim, them little burrs, them sticky little burrs. You got them on your...

Ephraim, if you wasn't up at the Darrow place, how'd them little burrs get all over your pants?

I, uh, I poured me a drink, Tom. You was always, you was always an honest man.

Yeah, for 50 years, I've been honest as the day is long. And where did it get me? I didn't speculate. I didn't hedge. I guarded my customers' money. And I got wiped out. I had to borrow from Cy Darrow. And he was going to take away my bank. Well, this boy came marching in here and... And you decided to steal his pistol and kill Darrow yourself.

Well, it wasn't that clear cut, you know. It just worked out. And I found my notes and destroyed them. Yours too, Tom.

Ephraim, a man like you, could you really let that boy hang for you? Could you?

Eve, I'd like to think that, in the end, I wouldn't let that boy hang for me. I'd like to think that.

Would your conscience let you?

Conscience? Eve, when you face the rope, you know the saying, conscience does make cowards of us all.

Sir Rogers.

No, Shakespeare.

You're a good lawyer, Eve. Would you defend me?

Ephraim, you mean you want me? Why, you could have anyone, even Stephen Douglas.

I want you, Eve. Nobody but you.

Thank you, Ephraim. I'm grateful. I'm humbly grateful.

The case went to trial with a new judge and a new defendant. And the young lawyer, Abe Lincoln, argued ably and well. And the result was a hung jury. But, as Abe Lincoln said afterwards, better a hung jury than a hung client.

Well, you hang around. I'll be back shortly.

Franklin and Emily Jones, Tom Fellman, Ephraim Barnes, they are all obscure footnotes in the book of Abraham Lincoln's life. And yet, these are some of the nameless, unknown people who helped shape his character. All around us are young men and women whom we, in our anonymous fashion, are also molding by our precept and by our example. And we are molding them into what? Think about it.

Our cast included Pierre Deloe, Jennifer Harmon, Paul Hecht, Joe Silver, and Robert Dryden. The entire production was under the direction of Hyman Brown. This is E.G. Marshall inviting you to return to our mystery theater for another adventure in the macabre. Until next time, pleasant dreams.

End of transcriptBack to the beginning ↑