Skip to content
On Air
All channelsAll
CBS Radio Mystery Theater artwork

From the CBS Radio Mystery Theater collection

Kill Now, Pay Later

Episode 1111August 20, 198043 min 18 secTranscript

Writer: Himan Brown

The written record

Read the transcript

Read along with the recording · About 20 min to read

The CBS Radio Mystery Theater presents. I'm E.G. Marshall. As the Frenchman said, God created man, and finding him not sufficiently alone, gave him a female companion so that he might feel his solitude more acutely. Yes, we think to fly from solitude by seeking companionship, only to discover that in the arms of a loved one, we find the greatest loneliness of all.

You say you're in love with her?

Yes.

I'll kill that love.

You can't. Nobody can.

I can keep the money away from you for 15 years.

I'll get a job.

Doing what? She'll have to support you. You'll begin to resent each other.

We'll manage.

You won't. That's how I can kill your love.

You won't. How can you stop me?

I can kill you.

Our mystery drama, Kill Now, Pay Later, was written especially for the Mystery Theater by Sam Dantzler, and stars Tony Roberts and Fred Gwynne.

Timing, you will admit, is everything. Consider the caterpillar. One day, he's earthbound, a dull, drab, fuzzy worm. And another, he's a brilliant, beautiful butterfly dancing through the skies. The wheel of fortune spins for us all, and we should win just as often as we lose. Provided, of course, that the wheel is on the level.

Sheriff Roy Hollister. Sitting in the Star Diner in the town of Belden Corners.

So, Sheriff?

So, you are driving with young Stuart Belden?

Young Stuart Belden? He's my age.

Chronologically. You make it sound as if I'm robbing the cradle.

In many ways, you are.

Is this what the citizens pay you to do, Sheriff? Check on who dates whom?

His aunt will never hold still for it, Morty.

Well, she'll have to. You don't know her like I do. She'll... She'll cut him off without a nickel.

It's his money.

No, it isn't.

But it's rightfully his.

Legally, it's hers. For a fact, she won't give him a dime. The way it has to be.

What does Stuart think?

He doesn't care.

He doesn't care now. But how will he feel ten years from today?

You know... In ten years?

Meaning what, Sheriff?

I know what you're thinking. All I want is the money.

Yes.

Yeah, but not the whole truth. I may even love him.

But you wouldn't look like... Would he look at me if I wasn't beautiful?

Sheriff, if a guy can marry a girl for her looks, why can't a girl marry a guy for his money?

I always liked you.

What's this?

Like it here. Something bad can always happen. I'm in it.

What is it you mean?

I wish I knew.

Then on that basis, you want me to leave town?

Okay, Morty.

Morning, Aunt Melissa.

There's not much left of it, but I suppose you just got up.

Uh, yes, ma'am.

Well, as long as you're here, you might just as well help me. Now sit down and start opening the mail. You should learn about all the investments and the real estate. It'll all be yours one day.

Uh, Aunt Melissa.

What is it?

Um, nothing.

Well, get to work on these letters. Separate the statements from the checks. Here. How do you like my new letter opener? Actually, it isn't new. I found it up in the attic. It's your grandfather's bowie knife. I want to keep it on my desk as a reminder of the time when we had men in this family.

That's not fair. You've yet to show what you're made of.

I want to discuss something very important.

After we've gone through the mail.

Well, this can't wait.

Oh, what is it?

It's about Maud Sanderson. I want to marry her.

I won't allow it.

But, Aunt Melissa, I...

I said I won't allow it. And that ends all discussion. Doesn't it?

That's some more meatloaf.

You mean you're turning me down?

Hmm?

A penny for your thoughts, Sheriff.

These days, Cora, what else gets you a good deal?

They're not worth a penny. Not these thoughts.

Well, what are they?

About what?

The Sanderson building.

That old biddy owns half the county. Why do you feel terrible about her?

This thing about her nephew's tuition is...

But, why do you have this feeling?

Well, what do you see there?

I'll tell you what I see. I see this domineering old lady. I see this kind of... He's like... Milk and toast. And he's infatuated with this smart, pretty little hustler.

Hustler?

I mean it in the sense of someone on the make. After all, she's her father's daughter.

Huh?

No, but I can see where Melissa's building would be scared to death of her. And so, she'll put her foot down. And it'll remain a furtive little affair until Maudie Sanderson finds someone more promising. And that'll be the end of it.

Legitimate concern of a... Chef.

Wait a hell of a year to close up, Maudie.

Uh, Joe took care of everything. Stuart, all I have to do is lock the door.

Great. Let's go. There's a picture playing over in New City.

Drive around.

You didn't answer my question.

You and me, Stuart. Where are we going?

Don't tell me you've gone and changed your mind.

Did you talk to your aunt?

Well, did you?

You said you would definitely do it this morning.

I know. I, uh... She won't let me. She simply refuses to talk about it.

Stuart, what's going to happen?

Oh, yeah. Oh, yes, she can. What you are saying is, let's go on the way we are, hmm? The wall can become a year, five years, ten, and we'll be up there in our thirties, getting old and getting sour. This frosty old lady hangs on and on. When do I have children? When I'm 40? Just because you don't have the guts to talk to your aunt?

Okay, okay. I'll talk to her. At the right time.

You'll never talk to her.

Then do it now. Right now.

Did you hear what I said? Right now. Talk to your aunt. Talk to your aunt. Talk to your aunt. That's all you know how to say. Talk to your aunt. Me, will ya? I'll never bug you about anything again.

Would you mind leaving? The place is closing for the night.

Morty, Morty, I didn't...

The place is closed.

Morty, I didn't mean it.

Get out of here. Get home to your auntie. Maybe she'll give you a lollipop.

I don't know what got into me. Joe is still in the back.

Will you leave? Or should I have him throw you out?

Please, Morty. Please, Morty.

I never want to see you again.

Up bright and early, I see. Had your breakfast?

Uh, yes, Aunt Melisande.

Sit down. Sit down. These past several weeks, Stuart, you really seem to have taken hold. It appears you're not going to become a rich young ne'er-do-well after all. I've actually come to depend on you. Now, let us begin with the correspondence as usual.

Yes, ma'am.

Of course, what helps is the fact that you no longer stay out every night till all hours. Do you agree?

Yes.

And don't you feel the better for it? Confess now.

Now, start opening the mail. You've become quite deft at it.

Stuart, who thought about marriage? The oldest Drake girl, Helena. Why do you want me to marry Helena Drake?

Oh, for the best of all reasons. You'll have money. She'll have money. Between you, it will be a most impressive fortune.

I think I should have the right to choose my own...

No. No. No, you shouldn't. No. Because I am more qualified to choose a sensible, responsible mate. And now that your affair with the Sanderson girl is over...

You have no right to call it an affair.

How else can I characterize what had existed between you? What other type of relationship is your Miss Sanderson capable of?

Maude Sanderson is a wonderful girl. If only you would talk with her.

But I won't. And that's the end of...

Stuart, what's on the envelope?

It's blood.

What did you do?

Look at your finger.

Cut it with the letter opener.

I'm sorry. I got it all over the checks.

Poetic justice. Most people accuse me of collecting blood money. Go get a band-aid. And in the future, keep your mind on the business at hand.

Maude.

I told you to stay away from here.

Please, Maude.

We are about to close up.

I have to talk to you.

About what?

About us.

Well, don't talk to me. Talk to your aunt.

I can't live without you.

I'll put flowers on your grave once a year.

Don't talk to that. That's the way of the world. The grown-up world, little boy.

I think about you all the time. I can't sleep. When I'm with you, I feel I'm somebody. Smart and confident. Not afraid of anything or anybody.

Is that your aunt, Millicent?

No. Not anymore.

Where?

Together. I'll just face it.

You want me to go with you?

Yes. Right now.

You sure?

Let me see your aunt. Talk to your aunt.

I'm going to do it.

What are you trying to tell me?

Scared. Until I'm 40 before I can touch the money? A stock market? I'm not afraid of what she can do. I'm just scared of what she might make us do.

And what's that?

Go see her now.

All right, let's hurry before I lose mine.

Situation fraught with unknown dangers. Is it possible for somehow make its presence felt? Is there an aura that seems to illuminate the existence of the very deed itself? We shall try to light up some of these dark corners very shortly.

The dogs of war. That's a shout that is heard in one of Mr. Shakespeare's plays. But is there always a noisy prelude, a thundering overture, as it were, to a deed of violence? Not really. The greatest crimes may be committed without warning and with hardly a sigh to break the silence.

Aunt Millicent, this is Maude Sanderson.

Why have you done this to me, Stuart? Do you know I refuse to acknowledge this woman's existence? Why have you forced her upon me in my own home?

Oh, this is my home, too. I have a right to invite a guest.

Entertain her in the kitchen, then.

Please.

She is not fit to be your wife.

Why not?

Her father was a convicted criminal.

Miss Sanderson, I have nothing against you personally, but this match is impossible.

My father may have been a man who drank, who gambled.

You admit it?

Yes, but... But?

He was a good father to me.

A proper example, no doubt. The test of a lady, which is what you claim to be, is how well she can keep her temper no matter how she is insulted. Now, my father did wrong. He lost money that was entrusted to him by others, but he paid for it. He died in prison.

My nephews and nieces will not have tainted blood.

Tainted blood? But you were willing to have his tainted blood, weren't you?

What are you saying?

You had a crush on Jack Sanderson. Jack Sanderson, my father, when you were both in high school.

That's a lie.

I can show you a copy of the yearbook. Romeo and Juliet, Jack Sanderson, and Melisande Belden.

Is this true?

For all that, my father was weak and easily tempted. He refused to marry you for the Belden money. Instead, he fell in love with the poorest girl in the class.

He did it deliberately to spite me. Now, get out.

I won't let you throw her out.

I'll throw you out, too. We'll see about that.

What do you think you're going to do? Go to bed? Call it?

Yes. Yes. That's what I'm going to do.

Your father's will was explicit. He knew you were weak, undependable. He made sure you wouldn't squander your inheritance.

Let's get out of here.

I won't let her do this to us.

Please, Stuart, I'm afraid.

I can't let her do it to us.

Please, Aunt Melisande. This love I have for Maudie, it's the one thing that sustains me. I have to have it. Don't kill it. Please.

Stuart, don't beg. Don't plead with this dreadful woman. Let's just get out of here.

Give us your blessing, Aunt Melisande.

My blessing? Are you mad?

Yes.

Stuart.

Don't kill our love. Don't.

Stuart, what are you doing?

I'll kill you first.

No.

Aunt Melisande.

Put down that knife.

That was his grandfather's. He's not man enough to use it.

I'll show you who's a man.

Don't, Stuart.

What did you do?

With this, he'd make me kill her. Don't you see? To kill our love, she wanted you to go to jail, and that would be the end of you and me.

Yeah. That's what's going to happen.

Oh, yes, we can. Let's get out of here.

Where can we go?

To my place.

Yes, but the sheriff will find us there.

He has no reason to look for us.

Says so.

Here. Who knows we came? Uh, quickly. Break a pane of glass in the French doors leading to the patio. Come on. Now, the sheriff will think that's how a burglar broke in.

A burglar?

Yes. A burglar did it. He made his way in here. He tried to force your aunt to tell him where her cash was hidden, and he killed her.

Uh, we'll make sure both the front and the back doors are locked.

I don't know.

We have to do it, Stuart. Otherwise, you'll have killed her for nothing.

Know who it is. The sheriff. What are we going to tell him? What can we tell him? We don't know anything. We have been here all evening watching TV. Now, I am going to open the door. Remember, you killed her so we could always be in love. You keep that in mind.

Yes, ma'am. Yes, ma'am. Yes, ma'am. Yes, ma'am. Yes, ma'am. Yes, ma'am. Yes, ma'am. Yes, ma'am. Yes, ma'am. Yes, ma'am.

Anything the matter, Sheriff?

Me all the time. But why do you accuse me of killing her? What are you trying to do? And you're involved in this thing too, Morty.

Sheriff, you have no right. You and I know what happened. You had and you killed her.

Anything of the sort. Stuart and I were here watching.

Oh, I resent this. What are the reasons, Stuart?

Crime I didn't commit, Stuart. Maybe the sheriff, but I think you're crazy. My aunt asked you to leave my house. She's out later in ten years. If they can't find anything today, what will they be able to find ten years from now? Do you see what he's trying to do? He's trying to destroy our love for each other. But he won't. He can't. It's like forging another bond between us. We love each other.

What is it?

Did you hear what he said about the knife? He said, my fingerprints disappeared.

I said not to worry about it. The presence of mind to get rid of the knife. I did. For the third time, Stuart, don't worry about it.

You remain. The life of... Nubial bliss? Those people who insist that everything between lovers must be out in the open, while others contend that what a man or a woman doesn't know isn't going to hurt him or her. How this arrangement works out will be the business of Act Three. They've tried to determine what makes the most solid foundation, for they have compiled quite a list of requirements. As you might imagine, love is on that list, but not necessarily at the head. As expected, you will find things like interests in common, a sense of humor, sympathy, but why go on? One thing is not on the list, but it's what must hold the hero and the heroine of our story together, and that...

I told you, Stuart, trust me. Always trust me. Away with it. Never doubt me. It's three weeks, and the sheriff can't find the, uh, the killer. Nobody can find him. It's even making him look bad.

Yes. Perhaps we can help him, who have taken your aunt's place. You are... You are the influential force in this community now. You have to start living up to it.

Why?

Nothing that ever happened in this town took place without Melisande's okay, one way or another. I don't care if Hollister is sheriff or not. But you're the one who has to decide. Okay. Let him go. Let him stay, so he knows who's boss.

I didn't look at it that way.

I know, honey. That's why you got me.

Without you, Monty? That never has to come up.

Why don't you want to tell me?

Because it's best.

Another cup of coffee, sheriff? Where's this morning's paper?

I think he forgot to leave it.

I want to see it. It'll spoil your appetite. The editorial. We hardly have one murder in a decade. And when we do, our sheriff is completely stymied.

Yeah. That's what he's been saying for weeks. Oh, you're not scared, are you? It's tough to run on the heels of an unsuccessful murder investigation.

I'll get it.

Morning, sheriff. Stuart. Stuart. Come in. Good morning, Mrs. Hollister. For you, a cup of coffee? No, thanks. I just stopped in for a minute. Sheriff, I've always been an admirer of yours.

Yes?

I don't think you're getting a fair deal in the media around here. I think you're the best qualified person for the job. And I should let it be known that I intend to support you for re-election. I thought you'd like to be aware of it. And now I'd better be getting on.

Mrs. Hollister?

He desires Caesar feed. His aunt hasn't been in her grave six weeks, and already he's just about taken over the town. His idea this was.

Listen, could you be wrong?

No, honey. You're only human.

Sheriff, buy you a cup of coffee? I like to drop in every once in a while, say hello to... Stuart says she looks just like me. I don't think so. No, I think she looks... I don't think so. I think she looks like her late great-aunt. What are you talking about? Ten years. Let me buy you that cup of full plenty. I'm... It's not going to work. Here it is you're trying to do. Maybe he's... I'll still buy you that cup of coffee, Sheriff.

He'd be amply reimbursed if he'd drop the charge. He'd fit to... It's money. Decide whom to support for the state senate seat?

Sure of that. Also spend enough to win it for Russ. Why are you so opposed to my... I thought we agreed. You're better off behind the scenes. It makes more sense. What idea was it for you to run for the senate?

Mine.

Who proposed it to the nominating committee?

I don't know. I think it was Helena Drake.

What's the difference? You know I can't stand that woman.

What's wrong with her?

I don't like her. She's very rich. She has a great deal of influence.

Oh, tell me more.

Well, what's there to tell?

Well, you could, for instance, tell me she was the girl your aunt wanted you to marry.

That was years ago.

Not yet. Not so many. But I didn't want to marry her. I wanted to marry you.

Why did your aunt want you to marry Helena?

I don't know. What does it matter?

I'll get it. Hello? Yes, Helena. Have I heard the news? What news? Stuart's running for the senate. How were you ever able to convince him? You must have really worked on him. I'll have him call you when he gets in. Goodbye, Helena.

Dear? What do you mean, when he gets in? Why didn't you let me talk to her?

Because I want to talk to you. Look, you're blowing this whole business out of proportion.

Am I?

You're jealous. I'm a drake. Do I have cause? And you're also jealous of me. I'm not putty in your hands. In many ways, you're just like my aunt.

Talking about your aunt. You're not out of the woods there, either.

What did you say?

Remember what the sheriff said. There's no statute of limitations.

On me?

On murder. You would be in it as deeply as I am.

Maybe I don't care.

The fact there's no evidence. Did anything occur to you? Missing knife. Now, you are going to call the chairperson of the nominating committee, Miss Helena Drake, and say to her, you've reconsidered and you do not choose to run.

Darling, we can't afford it.

I know we have to. I just wish you'd have said we should stay together because we want to. Please. To ourselves.

What is there between you and Helena Drake?

Quit bugging me about Helena Drake, will you?

Bugging me? Just what you said to me seven years ago that night in the diner.

Well, don't worry. I won't bug you about anything at all. Ever again.

Marty? Where are you going? Get me the sheriff. Well, there isn't time. Tell him to come to the Belden house on the hill. Quickly. Keep away from me. Marty, I want that knife. Now, don't touch me. I'm warning you. Stuart, get a hold of yourself. I want that knife. There isn't any knife. You're lying. I don't have it. What did you do with it? I threw it in the river. Afterward, I threw it in the river. You told me you're... It was a lie. I told you I had it. You're lying. I want the knife. I don't have it.

She knew everything. But some crimes become much more expensive as they grow older. And the longer you wait, the more you can lose. You won't lose anything at all if you're a few minutes until I return. And she did. And then she discovered... That she didn't at all like. At that time, it was too late. Much too late. And what is the moral of our story? Of you ladies and gentlemen, who are in the process of choosing your mates, never try to change what you see. The cats into tigers may wind up not as dinner companions, but as dinners.

Our cast included Tony Roberts, Fred Gwynne, Terry Keene, and Bryna Raeburn. Entire production was under the direction of Hyman Brown. E.G. Marshall inviting you to return to our mystery theater. For another adventure in the macabre. Until next time, pleasant dreams.

End of transcriptBack to the beginning ↑