Skip to content
On Air
All channelsAll
CBS Radio Mystery Theater artwork

From the CBS Radio Mystery Theater collection

Never in This World

Episode 364October 20, 197544 min 9 secTranscript

Writer: Himan Brown

The written record

Read the transcript

Read along with the recording · About 26 min to read

The CBS Radio Mystery Theater presents... Come in. I'm E.G. Marshall. It might occur to you that since I live so much in the world of the macabre, I could become jaded. Nothing could be further from this. For the deeper I delve into Satanism, the occult, the mystical history of the past, the more I realize how little I know. How much is yet to be revealed. An example, this tale. An unassuming one, filled with such brooding and haunting terror. I'm sure you will share it with me.

I love you. We are of different faith. To hell with faith and church. I will still make you mine. You never can. Never in this world. And in the next. If I cannot have you alive, no one shall. Dios, forgive me for what I do. Oh, don't. Too late. Too late. But you. God have pleased us. Faith will ever forgive.

Our mystery drama, Never in This World, was written especially for the Mystery Theater by Ian Martin and stars Alexander Scourby.

Legend. If a man walked withershins about a church, arms of the devil. Withershins is of Gaelic derivation and means to walk contrary to the path of the sun. This is the story of an American of Scottish background who on an idle fancy challenged the legend at the beginning of this century. Two centuries before.

All right, Mr. Blodgett. You and Martha handle the bags.

Yep.

I'll take care of that, Mrs. Gamble. Now take my arm, David, and step down carefully.

Oh, don't be foolish, Lucy. I can manage by myself. After the siege you've been through right at death's door.

I only had the influenza. That was months ago.

Followed by what amounted to a nervous breakdown. That's why we're up here again.

Dr. Chambers is an old fuzzpot. Nervous breakdown. Just plain debilitation. Dehydration. No matter. No matter. I'm great. I'm grateful to him just the same. Oh, smell that good New Hampshire air.

Never mind smelling it. Feel it. Chilly as always. You get right in the house.

In good time. In good time. First of all, a little walk. I think I'll stroll on down, see how Ephraim weathered last winter.

But that's nearly a mile's walk.

Oh, just a stroll. Now I'm back in the country. It's good to stretch my legs after being pent up these last years in the city.

You walk slowly, you hear? And be sure to be back here for dinner on time. You know I don't like to be kept waiting.

Yes, dear, I know.

Married 24 years to a good woman. No doubt about Lucy being that. She reminds me of it often enough. A placid, uneventful life. Successful business. One child. The delight of my life. The rest of it, floating along in a rut like an autumn leaf on the muddy waters in a wheel track. Fiftiesh, fattish. Feeblish after my first brush was dead. Feeblish. Feeblish. Yes, I found I didn't have to be told to walk slowly. I had to.

On my way to see my old friend, the Reverend Ephraim Bean.

I'm coming. Come in. And behold, I come quickly. Revelations chapter 22, verse 11, I believe. The right Reverend Ephraim Bean at your service.

Don't tell me I've changed that much.

So my sight is getting to be a caution. Now, where am I spectacling?

Try your forehead.

Oh. David. David Campbell by Toffit. Is it not?

It is indeed.

Well, come in, come in, come in, man. Oh, I see. You'll look in the pink. Sit you down, and I'll refresh you with a glass of cider. And you must tell me all.

Not much to tell. Long bout with influenza.

That is a plague on the whole country this year. Here now. You'll have a glass. Looks just the ticket. But tell me about your illness. The influenza. Epidemic this year, the good Lord knows, has been widespread and virulent.

Virulent enough in my case. I'd like to have carried me off. But for some moment's strength, I gathered somewhere, and so got my reprieve.

Oh, tell me, when was its onset?

The day after New Year's.

Good heavens. And it's lasted all the way now into August?

The germ itself was brought under control months ago and finally washed from my disease. Or if you want, unease of the mind afflicted me. The choice, I suppose, would be your nervous breakdown.

Well, my good friend, I'm glad you returned. We must shake these shadows from the corner of your soul. If they still persist.

Not as good a face-hunter as I can, but yes, even they do persist. Even more than that, no voice. Shall I tell you what haunches me? Why I was so glad that Lisbeth was not to come?

Because I don't know whether it is for good or evil. I only know it must be.

Remember, Isaiah, woe unto them that call evil good, and good evil.

No, that's not what I said. Not in so many words. But look deep in your heart, David, and ask yourself if somewhere, somehow, the thought is not there.

Walking back from the Reverend Bean's on that early August afternoon, long and deeply, trying to find with his suggested key some door to unlock my long depression. Neither there nor there. Neither then nor on succeeding walks, longer and longer as I grew stronger, could I find an answer to the strange call which tugged at me, but gave me no intimation which way to follow and find the answer.

But where do you go on these long rambles of yours?

Nowhere in particular. I just like to walk, to listen to the drowse of the bees, and feel the wind in my face.

The wind. Oh, yes, first thing we know, you'll be back with the influenza again if you don't stop exposing yourself to the chill.

I know. I doubt it. That's past.

You're still determined to go off on this jaunt today?

Oh, yes. Now, I feel strong enough. I've always wanted to go back up to the Devil's Glen. There were so many happy times there with Lisbeth when she was a child.

Well, you have your lunch all packed up that Martha made for you. Yes, Lizzie. Now, don't dilly-dally till too late. Martha says her rheumatism is acting up, and that means a thunderstorm is on the way.

It was a glorious Sunday afternoon. And after lunching at the Devil's Glen, I had a great time. I was looking at the Devil's Glen and basking a while in happy, old memories. I was tempted to walk just a little farther, a trail I'd never taken before. I followed the stream a little, and then the trail bent into the woods. All of a sudden, I broke from the trees into a clearing, in the center of which stood the ruins of an old church and a weed-covered graveyard beside it. After pottering around, reading some of the weathered headstones, a cursed whim struck me. I'd not been to church that morning, and on an impulse, as if obeying some order from beyond imagining, before heading for home, I was driven to circle the church twice, withershins, perhaps recalling some ancient dare as a boy that I'd refused to take because of legend. It fell near, except that I was suddenly swept, a wave of exhaust stretching out my legs. And I found that my feet, resting on the edge of a flat tombstone, I could barely make out, the legend. Jose Ribeiro. These bones lie here, in an alien land, the life's by mine own. With heavy-lidded eyes, I tried to trace the dates etched in Roman numerals, but a great character's. Dear Jose, cannot. Never. I love you, but we, we are of different faith. The devil with faith and church will still make you mine. You never can. Never in this world. Then in the next. Never in this world. Never in this world. Never in this world. Never in this world. Never in this world. Never in this world. Never in this world. Never in this world. Never in this world. Never in this world. Never in this world. Never in this world. Never in this world. Never in this world. Never in this world. Never in this world. Never in this world. Never in this world. Now, if I cannot have you alive, no one shall. Just forgive me for what I do. Jesus' faith will ever forgive!

No, my... For he galvanized awake by a pulse of lightning which must have hit the tree. And the thunder continued to grumble menacingly, so with what widths were left to me, I fled the dream and the storm, and ran pell-mell for home, letting myself in. I could hear my wife hectoring poor Martha in the kitchen. I stole upstairs, leaving my dripping greatcoat and the bedroom door behind me, locking it with some strange reflex. I trimmed the wick. Who was that? A dark, fierce, keen and saturnine face of his eyes burned into mine as he looked back at me from the mirror. In a red-haired, melancholy but gentle David Campbell. Who else then? Raise up the desk. You locked this door. Say, what can I? This is too mortifying of you. You must be in there. Why don't you answer?

I'm not feeling myself right now.

Let me in. I want to help.

The only way you can help is I'll let you in if you do something for me first.

What?

Please, don't think I'm being unreasonable. It's terribly important. Pushing a key under the door, you see it?

Yes.

It's the key to the old roll-top desk in my study. I want you to open it. On the left-hand side, the first row of pigeonholes. Pull them to you and they'll slide out. There's a secret compartment. Inside it is a letter. Get the letter and bring it back to me here. But I don't... Please, do as I ask. There's no other way.

No other way for what?

When you bring it back, you'll see. Or maybe, by some miracle, all this won't be necessary.

Finally, Lucy left on her errand. Myself, I returned, hoping against hope. Through outward view and sound, I was a different man. That man was only a prison. Still held, David Campbell. The inner man was still the same. How to convince anyone else of that?

David? David, I'm back.

Yes, Lucy, did you find it?

No stamp. Two cupid hearts drawn by pen with an arrow. Piercing them together. Right?

Yes. When I was young and foolish, I used to do that. One heart has the letters L-C-M in it. The other, D-M-C. Of course. But, David, this is absurd. We both know.

But nobody else knows about this letter.

I hope not.

It begins, David, I know you want to, but I'm tired of waiting for you to ask me. We are to be in love. Why shouldn't we be married? If you won't ask me, I'll ask you. David, hush. Martha might hear. Really. These family secrets... They shouldn't be spoken out loud.

They have to be. Otherwise, you wouldn't be able to do it.

Oh, David, I can't stand this nonsense anymore. Open this door immediately or I'll have to send for a doctor.

Very well. Only, only wait just a moment before you come in.

Oh, do stop it. Open the door.

Come in, Lucy.

What's the matter, David? I can, I can scarcely see.

It's quite deliberate on my part.

Very well. Now, would you mind telling me what all this fizzle-fabble is about? Keys, secret drawers, old letters?

A matter of proof. I want to prove it. I want to prove it. I want to prove it. I want to prove it. I want to be sure you know who I am.

What's, what's the matter with your voice? Have you caught cold in the rain?

Say, I... I think I'd better get the doctor.

I think you'd better wait first.

For what?

For what I'm about to show you. Remember that I am David as I turn up the lamp and let you see.

David, no, no, no. Who, who...

I don't know. Whatever you feel would be best. Talk to me as honestly as you can.

But really, how can I?

Why not?

Because I... Because now that you know who I am, I can't. I can't. I can't. I can't. I can't. You face the actuality.

Well, how can you blame me? I mean...

Hold. Don't leave this room. Stay where you are. Don't you dare make a move toward me or I'll scream the house down. We're not alone, you know. Your brother George and his friends are all downstairs and Mr. Blodgett, the game people...

It's all right, Lucy. I don't blame you for being scared and very brave at the same time. But the lies are not necessary.

They're not lies. The house is full of...

Besides us, there is only poor old Martha. My brother George has been dead for five years.

Yes.

Blodgett runs a general goods store and lives well over half a mile from us. And I am no stranger, no matter how I look. Twenty-four years. Twenty-five, come this November 23rd. No matter how I look.

Oh, what are we going... What are we going to do?

Now, darling, don't worry too much about me. Some way we'll find a way to straighten things out.

I'm not worried about you. Somehow you brought this on yourself. I mean, what are we going to do, Elizabeth and I? What... What on earth can we say to people? How can we live this down?

I think there are more serious problems here to be considered first. I'm not capable of solving them. You need a doctor or perhaps a minister. I'm going to make up a spare room where you can sleep tonight, whoever or whatever you are. Then I'll bring your dinner up to you. And tomorrow, first thing tomorrow, I'm going to the Reverend Bean and tell him everything. Maybe he can make heads or tails of it.

I can't... Lucy spoke about you suffering some sort of change.

Oh. Oh, I... I... Bless my soul. Yes. Yes. Yes, indeed. You do find me changed, then?

Oh, without a doubt. I'm rather sorry. I thought to bring my spectacles for once.

Do you recognize me by any chance?

Not while I wear these. They are... I think I shall remove them. The shock will be less profound. David, do you believe I am David?

I am a man of faith.

But my looks, my voice... You are shocked.

I admit when seeing all too clearly. Yes, David, I... I accept you for who you are.

But how can you?

Because you asked me to. Tell me, how have you suffered this change?

I could feel the sting of tears behind my stranger's eyes at the simple kindness of this good man's faith, friendly trust. I told him what little I could of my walk that day. My discovering the ruined church, my sudden weariness, my sitting by the grave of the man named Jose Ribeiro, falling asleep until the lightning striking the tree. While I told him, I watched the expression on that open face, too ingenuous to hide any emotion or thought.

I've heard of him, Murrah. Any such family here?

Believe me, after all... Did I say that?

You didn't have to. I believe the transformation. I believe that no matter how you look or sound, you are my dear friend, David Campbell.

Other things or something else again?

What other things?

I've lived here all my life in Camelworth, man and boy. I know this country like the back of my hand.

No doubt no one knows it better, Ephraim. Just what are you getting at?

The church, ruined or otherwise, the clearing in the forest, the graveyard. A man named Jose Ribeiro. I tell you this solemnly, since I know every tree and trace of all that area, David, my old friend, there simply is no such place.

The statement of mine swayed him from that stand. There was no recourse. I must return there for myself. Easier decided than accomplished. These days, Lucy watched me like a hawk. I dared not show myself in front of Martha, to whom I would be an unexplained stranger in the house. But finally, a day came.

David, nothing. It's just so difficult to call you by name when, looking at you, I cannot recognize the man I married. And yet, come to the light a moment. I do believe, I think perhaps you're starting to change back.

Oh, don't hope too much. I suppose it's just an illusion that you're growing used to.

No, no, no, I will never get used to it. No, I have to go marketing. Don't leave the room. Martha is in the house.

Just don't lock me in. I can't stand that. Give me the key.

Promise you won't do anything foolish.

That I can promise with all my heart.

As soon as I saw Silas Blodgett drive Lucy away, I stole down the stairs, passed Martha, busy in the kitchen, and down the street. By the time I reached the Devil's Glen, it was late afternoon. A hazy day, with the sun trying to burn through a low cloud cover. I hastened up the path I remembered, holding my breath. And suddenly, there I was, back in the familiar clearing. The ruined church, the graveyard, the shade tree part blackened by the lightning bolt that had hit it. Tortured, broken tombstone, twisted with the heat. A huge crack beside the seat I had sat in. Only one thing was different as I approached. On the seat, still as death, leaning on a stick as though waiting, the figure of a woman who suggested incredible age, but at one and the same moment, timeless beauty. Her head was shrouded in a veil, so this was only an impression as I approached her.

Am I intruding? Forgive me, but I've been ill, and I...

Need you ask? Sit, my darling. It is so long that I've waited for you, but I knew that somehow, you would come back.

Fantasy? Dream meeting? In an actual place? Fixation of the mind? And if so, on whose part? David's? Or the woman's who turned aside a face that is at once as lovely as it is ancient? A woman who, with eyes half shut, might appear to the beholder, as she does to David, loveliest, desiring, a terrible thing in the world.

I'll return shortly with Act Three.

Suddenly dropped, a flight of twilight. Ages washed away from the woman's face. Her gray eyes, and on David, are wide, shining with love. But to him, lovely as it is, it is a stranger's face. Search his memory as he will, he cannot remember ever having seen it before, although the voice and the vagrant chord of memory.

Know me? Can you ask such a question, Jose?

Not Jose. I look like someone you once knew.

I know you do. But looks are unimportant.

No, you are me, Jose, the man you think I am. Grave, who says he took his life with his own hand? Took his life with his own hand, but who is no longer.

I'm me. Me? The living. But only an image. Not the man, the being himself.

No. No, you don't understand. I'm not the way I look. I'm someone else. My name is David Campbell. No, I don't look this way at all.

If you don't want to look yourself, time. The moon is not yet at the full, and I cannot stay any longer.

Wait, wait. There are so many questions I need to ask you.

You mean David Campbell is the one who wants to ask a question?

Of course. That's who I am. I can't read the date on his tombstone, but he must have died a long time ago.

Long? Oh, a hundred years, to be exact.

Me? Me as I am now? You could be one and the same.

How can you be so sure?

It should have been his wife. Answer it, you.

I must go now. It's almost dark. I can tell you more, if you wish, much as you can come to tea Thursday, but not before. Out to the left, down to the waterfall, it's the second house, Slaphead. You can't miss it.

I don't even know your name.

Remember, Prudence Pennypacker.

...pounded behind my eyes as they might when close at night the idea crossed my mind. In the dark. Besides, I would be in enough bad odor with Lucy being late to dinner. It could wait too.

I just can't stand it any longer, David. If you are David, going on with this charade, though I've made all the arrangements...

Now, wait a minute, wait a minute. What charade? What do you mean?

I can't make up any more lies or half-truths or excuses about you. Martha can't understand why, if you're ill, she can't bring a tray up to you. Cy Blodgett and the others in the village can't imagine, if you don't need a doctor, why you stay cooped up. Oh, I could go on and on, but I don't intend to. I've spent the day packing us up. We're going back to Boston. Take you to Dr. Chambers or whoever he recommends, and get you the treatment you need.

I'm not leaving here before the end of the week. You go to Boston and get a good look at the world you think is turned right-side up. Then come back, knowing that within the week I'll know where the future lies. If there is any at all for me.

You reverend being, if you didn't have to have me over for meals all the time like this, I wouldn't be here, sir. The idea was for your housekeeper to drop me off.

Well, she did, a couple of times. But it's easier this way and provides me companionship. Besides, I had to see you today in order to write a shocking piece of information I gave you.

Oh, about what?

Your ruined church and graveyard. I've been searching through our church records, unfortunately very scanty and full of gaps, but I find I was wrong. There was indeed a church, and I have no doubt a graveyard, on or about just such a site as you mentioned.

Oh, I could never have missed its ruins myself.

Probably so overgrown, you could never find them.

Well, then how could you?

Because I was intended to find them.

Why you?

If for no better reason than I walked about the church with the shins.

With the shins?

Yes.

Ah, yes. Ancient Gary Tom. Who with a devil his first compactor begins. He first must have us. The churcher with the shins, eh? Anonymous, eh? Do you believe in the devil, David?

Believe in God to be the other. I believe I've made an unwitting pact with the...

Oh, now, even granting that, you can still be saved. If you were indeed a kind of reincarnation of Sintra Ribeiro, if I remember his name correctly...

You do, you do.

Then more and more you are thrown off his influence and returning to yourself. For David, I declare, the sun makes your hair seem full red again. And you're getting back your own nice, comfortable, roundy look.

So there's still hope for me?

There has been. Such a church, though, as I have described.

Oh, dear me, yes. Built and established in 1695 by one Hiram Pennypacker.

Pennypacker? A curious old name.

Very common about these parts once. Still, for that matter. Now, you'll join me for dinner.

For you, from good old friends, I think I will make out for myself this evening. I see you later. I'm not sure. I may decide to take a long, long sleep tonight. Lucy's due back in the morning.

Ah, then I'll be trotting along. I have a feeling of something undone. Have I forgotten anything?

You've forgotten nothing. Even me, who little deserved to be remembered.

It was the Thursday, and for my own reasons, I must be early. As soon as Ephraim was gone, I headed for the Devil's Glen and beyond. I went to the graveyard. In the glare of the sinking afternoon sun, it took me some time to find it. In full legend, Prudence Pennypacker, 1789. But she is in her grave. Oh, the difference to me. That quotation from Wordsworth shocked me beyond belief. Subject of his lament over a lost love was for a girl named Lucy, not Prudence. From the grave, with a sense of urgency, I found my way down the path to the house beneath the waterfall, and to the girl who had been buried 200 years ago, and to the end of the world.

You're late. Things have come up. There won't be time for tea.

Not too late for some explanations.

That depends on what you consider an explanation.

Who was, or is, Prudence Pennypacker and Jose Ribeiro? What were they to each other, and where do we fit in?

Quite a lot.

No, not in my mind. As far as I can discover, both you and Jose have been buried for 200 years.

I'm still alive, even if I'm locked like a hermit crab in another man's shell. Where do I go from here? Or you?

Jose, the very romantic Portuguese who fled a dictator king who was slaughtering the nobility. With his knowledge of languages and education, he became my father's secretary.

Your father was the minister of the ruined church up the hill?

Yes. Jose fell in love with me and we wanted to be married. But we were of different faiths.

The dream. The dream I first dreamt. Sitting on the bench by your lover's grave before the tree and for all I know I was struck by lightning.

Did he really murder you and kill himself?

If I could not have him, I wanted to die for him. But he wanted to die for me. Because of my father and my faith, I was buried in consecrated ground. But because he took his own life and was an apostate, Jose was buried in unhallowed ground. He was forced to wander forever until he could find some other body not owned by the devil. I chose to share his exile waiting for the moment when he could.

He risked an old superstition and went about the church the wrong way. He entered into my life, my body.

He took your body, not your soul. That is still yours to command.

But is it so much to hold on to? Would you not rather come with me at last to love and be loved no matter who you are or what your name is?

I want to and yet I don't. I'm afraid. Maybe I can still find my way back to what I was.

Karen, if that's really what you want, remember you can have it for only a brief moment.

With me, it could be all eternity.

David! God, I've been so worried. Where have you been?

To the edge of beyond.

What does that mean?

It doesn't matter.

Home so soon. This is it. She was so worried about you. And I'm so glad now I came.

Are you?

Yes. You look wonderful. Your old self again, aren't you?

Oh. Yes, Lucy. We must start building you up with right food and rest, right?

Yes, Lucy. It's a positive miracle. You look exactly like yourself again. It's all over, isn't it? Whatever it was. You're David Campbell again.

Yes, Lucy. Just the way you always were.

Yes, Lucy.

Oh, I could look in the mirror. Day by day, my looks had returned to exactly what I had been to begin with. What I had neither the heart to tell Lucy or perhaps even faith myself was that as my physical form remade itself outside, so my soul and my personality, name it what you want, was bewitched. The passion, the anger and violent emotion that ran within me was almost more than I could restrain. And I knew it would never be satisfied till I had and owned Prudence. I would destroy everything for that. You see, Lisbeth, even myself.

I was suddenly interrupted with the Reverend Ephraim Bean who led the search. A deep instinct told the old man that David had returned to the graveyard and the ruined church. What was found was David's body floating in a pool underneath a small waterfall far above the Devil's Glen. The body lies buried now in one of Boston's most exclusive cemeteries. The body has gone. End this tale as the Reverend Ephraim Bean might. With a quotation from Shakespeare: Now are ended. We are such stuff as dreams are made on, and our little life is rounded with a sleep.

Our cast included Alexander Scourby, Lori March, Ian Martin and Mary. Production was under the direction of Hyman Brown.

And now a preview of our next tale.

I'm the girl who gambled and lost.

Stop talking in riddles.

I'm Althea Judge, the town girl who wasn't good enough to marry Richard.

Dick, what's the meaning of...

The meaning is that I promised to pay you back and I'm giving Dick one million dollars to kill you.

This is crazy.

Show him the revolver, Richard.

This is a joke. It's a...

Nobody should joke with a loaded .38 in his hand.

Dick, I've done for you.

What have you done for him lately?

Dick, I swear to you, I'll... I'll leave you everything in my will. Here, I'll even write it out now and sign it.

Can you leave him a million dollars?

No, you don't have that much and that's my bid.

Dick, you can't kill me. I've known you since you were...

Shoot him.

This is E.G. Marshall inviting you to return to our mystery theater for another adventure in the macabre. Until next time, pleasant dreams.

End of transcriptBack to the beginning ↑