The written record
Read the transcript
Read along with the recording · About 21 min to read
The CBS Radio Mystery Theater presents... These writers have been seduced by the charms of the ghost story. Certainly, you know the names of Rudyard Kipling, H.G. Wells, Bram Stoker, Conan Doyle. But there have been others, dozens of men and women, not so well known, who have likewise been infatuated with the terror of the white ghosts. I give you, for example, Fitz James O'Brien, Amia Northcote, Mrs. Henry Wood. But the list goes on and on, and we had best cut it short and get to the tale which we have chosen to call Once Upon an Island.
What's here? Who's in this room with me? Who is with me in this room?
The mystery drama Once Upon an Island was written especially for the Mystery Theater by Elspeth Herrick and stars Norman Rose. I'll be back shortly with Act One.
The tale which you will hear with, we trust, delicious horror was published... in 1899 as part of a series called Real Ghost Stories. Its authors were two persons listed simply as E. and H. Herrick. We confess in advance to having toyed with it a little, modernized it slightly, changed the locale, and even introduced a character not found in the original and impertinently altered the title.
My position as professor of philosophy at a well-known university and bought a large tract of land on one of the Caribbean islands which I had visited several times during summer vacations, and for which I had developed a great fondness. I put up a modest house and settled in quite contentedly. Since I had never married, I planned to leave it intact to my great-niece, Betty, daughter of a nephew whom I had known little and liked less. I remembered Betty as a child, and I was delighted beyond measure when I heard from her that she was about to be married and that she and her fiancé intended to visit me in my island home as part of their honeymoon trip.
Hello! Hello there! Uncle Jasper!
Betty! Betty, is it really you?
Really, it's me!
Oh, come, come, let me have a look at you. Jack Payne, taxi.
Oh, Uncle Jack.
Jack? Jack is your young man?
This is my husband, Uncle Jasper. For two whole days, I've been Mrs. Jack Turner. Isn't that marvelous?
Positively marvelous.
Isn't he beautiful?
Positively beautiful.
Jack? Uncle Jasper. Young man?
Delighted to know you.
I'm delighted to know you, Mr. Lowe. Betty's told me a lot about you.
What could she remember about me? It's been ten years.
Whatever she remembered, it was all good.
Come inside. I've got a good rum drink waiting for us and something to eat.
Oh, good. We haven't eaten a thing since we left the mainland.
And you'll be ready for some excellent flying fish with breadfruit and sliced cold mangoes.
Sounds marvelous. After you.
After me? You've got it all set out.
Yes, ready and waiting for you. Sit down, Jack.
Here, Uncle Jasper.
Oh, no, no. No need, no need. May I?
How was your trip?
Perfect, wasn't it, Jack?
I don't remember a thing, except you. Oh, we got married in Duluth, and then we flew to Miami, and then we took a little plane to Puerto Rico.
Hottest airport in the world.
And then we took that dear little boat to this dear little island. And a taxi to this dear little house.
Ah, drinks, everybody. My own concoction. Made with native rum, of course.
Yummy, yummy, yummy.
Call me Uncle Jasper. Or just Jasper, if you like.
All right, Jasper. On our way here from the boat, my friend. Now, just hold out your plate.
Yes, okay. Just before we got here, we passed an interesting old house.
And here's the breadfruit, staple of the island.
It looked as though nobody'd lived in it for a hundred years or more.
And the mango. You're going to love them.
Do you, uh, know anything about that?
Old house, Mr. Lowe? Uh, uh, Jasper?
Hmm? Oh, yes, yes. I know a great deal about that old house. You see, it's on my property.
You own it?
I suppose I do. It's on my property.
But, uh, you don't do anything with it? Rent it or anything?
Oh, no. Would rent it. Of course, it would need a little fixing up. No matter what I did with it, no one would rent it.
Well, then why not sell it? Get rid of it.
Once they've heard its history.
History, Uncle Jasper?
Oh, no, you don't want to hear it.
What can we do? You're not going to tell us the house is, uh, haunted, are you?
No, I'm, uh, I'm not going to tell you anything.
Oh, Uncle Jasper. Come another time.
I suppose the old, uh, house has a ghost in it, at least one.
Now, don't joke.
I didn't mean to. I'm a psychologist. I have my degree. And when Betty and I go back to the States, I'll set up practice there. Both these old tales. And myself, of course, don't subscribe to any of them.
Nor do I. I believe in natural law.
Oh, yes, so do I. The phenomena of the, um, shall we say the, uh, supernatural realm are no more than projections or extensions of natural laws.
Oh, I agree.
Well, then?
Oh, there are things, I'm afraid, about the old house that won't fit in with any natural law that I know of. Things impossible. Absurd.
Such as?
Oh, such as, such as the, of course, the two young people all over me demanding to know what I meant by... The Shining Man. But no matter how they begged me, I would not go into further detail. Such a gruesome story was not meant for the ears of two young people embarked upon the greatest adventure of their lives.
After dinner that night, Jack Turner was at me again. And Betty, too. And at last, I relented.
There is a tragedy connected with the old house that goes back a century and a half. When the sugar plantations were worked by slaves. The owner was a certain James Mackian. He'd been a merchant of sorts in Honduras. And when he'd made himself a small fortune, he came here and settled down in that house with his pretty daughter.
There must have been a lovely place in those days.
She was happy there.
Oh, yes, I believe she was. For a time. Mackian had a number of servants. Slaves, they were, for this was a long time back. They worked. Some worked in the house. And they were well-treated. Life was very pleasant, I'm told. For all concerned, until...
Yes, sir?
Until?
Want me to go on?
You can't stop now.
Two years of company. Mackian had to go to Central America to finish up some business there. Leaving his young daughter in the house with only the servants for company. But he did not worry because they were all loyal and devoted. Especially his personal retainer, Jake, a man who had saved his life in prior days. But, uh, death of sleeping medicine, no explanation. And there is none to this day. Uh, but in his grief, Mackian blamed his faithful servant, Jake, for the tragedy and threw him out of the house. After a violent quarrel, so they say. At any rate, Jake disappeared and was never seen or heard of after that. As for Mackian, he... He fell into a deep melancholy and, uh, later... Well, later he was found lying on the couch in the library. Quite dead. Hopeless, imbecile, in fact.
Of course, that, that was a long time ago.
There's been nothing since? Nothing recently?
Well, there's the story of a descendant of Mackian's who wanted to clear up the mystery. And the agent allowed him to spend the night there. This was just before I came here. And when he did not appear the next morning, they went looking for him. And they found him lying on that same couch in the library. And they... A physical fright, you know, acting on an overwrought brain. Such things happen.
What about... Muscular shoulders gave an impression of such... Oh, I don't know, such hostility, such animosity, that I left the house in a hurry. And I have never gone back. And I... Believe me, I could tell that. And I cursed myself for having let them drag the story out of me.
They quickly changed the topic of conversation, and a few minutes later I excused myself to make us some rum drinks. When I returned, both young faces were smiling and friendly. And in their secret hearts, they considered me...
I believe there is a French gentlewoman. I don't believe in ghosts, but I'm afraid of them. Jasper Lowe might well echo the lady. He does not believe in supernatural phenomena, such as a shining man and a light in the window of an empty house. But he is afraid of them. I'll be back shortly with Act Two.
Jasper Lowe was delighted to hear that his great-niece, Betty, would, in the course of her honeymoon, visit his island home. But Betty's new husband, Jack Turner, has innocently probed into the secrets of an old house on Jasper's property, from which, so it is said, a light shines from time to time, and which is haunted by the spectral figure of a man who shines in the dark. Now, Jasper has confounded the young couple by confessing that he has himself seen the light from the window. And, on one occasion, the shining man...
Everything had gone so well, till I had been led into telling them of the... the library window and the presence in the old house of the shining man. Had I been content to lean on such freaks of nature in the realm of superstition, all might have passed off well. But to admit to them that I had seen them both myself, with my own eyes... I can scarcely be blamed if the next morning I...
Oh, girl, he'd visit us, and... we'd take long walks together, and talk about, you know, all sorts of things. But he was fine when we got here. He was so high-spirited, and he seemed... He certainly seemed that way to me. Nothing for you started bothering him about that old house.
Oh, that was natural, wasn't it? Perfectly natural curiosity.
But couldn't you see he didn't want to talk about it?
I didn't see anything of the kind. Maybe you did, I didn't.
Don't you say another word to him about that house, or the light in the library window, or... or the shining man. Not one word, you understand me? If you do, I'll...
Listen. Everything was perfectly okay till it came to the shining man. That's when he started to get... well, peculiar.
Well, why didn't you let him alone?
Well, he was the one that mentioned the shining man first.
You're the one who brought the subject up again.
Only after he said he'd seen the light in the library window. Many times, he said. He'd seen it many times.
I suppose you're gonna claim he didn't say that.
It was after dark and seeing the shining, standing on the stairs. He was hiding, so he ran out and never went back.
Well, there's something.
This was taken up with a discussion of how they would spend the rest of their honeymoon. A cruise through the islands ending up in Barbados. And then we went sightseeing again. Had lunch in the only decent restaurant the island afforded. Pleasant. We spent the afternoon in my really splendid vegetable garden, picking all manner of things for our dinner. And then we all retired for a nap. Because the next morning, Jack and Betty would fly to Puerto Rico to pick up the cruise ship that would take them for the rest of their honeymoon. All day there had been no mention of the old house, the light in the window, or the shining man.
Yeah.
Yes, Betty?
You awake, Uncle Jasper?
Oh, yeah. Yes, my dear. Come in.
I'll bet I woke you up.
No, you didn't. I was just lying here thinking about...
A particular thing? And things in general, too.
Well, did you have a good nap? A big day tomorrow?
Actually, I didn't take a nap.
Oh, you should have. I'll go to bed early tonight.
No. What I did was wash all the vegetables we picked.
Oh, I'd have done that.
Oh, good practice for me, don't you think? After all, I'm going to be a wife. Then I cut the vegetables into bite-sized pieces.
Well.
Simmered some of them a little. Some of them raw.
You are going to make a splendid wife. Now, turn it back for a minute, girl, while I slip into some dungarees and a shirt. And then we're off to the kitchen.
All right.
I watched the sun go down. It was beautiful.
Where's Jack?
He didn't say exactly where he was going.
Not telling me the truth, are you? Where Jack went, don't you?
Not for sure.
I don't know why you say that.
Because... Because I stood outside your bedroom door this morning and I heard you talking about me.
Oh.
Yes, you did. It meant that I'm getting old and feeble-minded.
No, no. Now, where did Jack go? To fetch a doctor? To tell the authorities that I am incompetent?
Uncle Jack. Jack wouldn't do a thing like that. Did he go off to make arrangements to have me committed to the sanitarium in San Juan?
No. I know the head doctor there. A man by the name of Marty. To be put away? No sir, not yet.
Uncle Jack, but what you said about the old house, the light in the library window, the...
Thought so.
You said... I did. But that's no reason to put me away. Lock me up.
Nobody wants to do that.
Then why did Jack go to ask about Dr. Martinez and the sanitarium in San Juan?
He didn't. The old house. Why? Because he was no explanation for the... for the light in the window and the shining man. He is there now.
Yes, but he'll be back any minute and... and he'll know. Come on.
Hello, Uncle Jasper. He could wait for Jack to come out. Not in there at all. There's only one way to find out. Come on. As may be. Let's go in.
I don't want to.
Oh, this is like vapor when I move. Logging weight presses upon me, and I'm exhausted and disgusted by the terrible odor, and the atmosphere thickens and cloaks the walls with drowsy horror. But now, tears begin to show through it. Nearer and nearer to my own, and the light changes to black dripping fluid, and the drops begin to fall. Fall.
Uncle Jasper, help him. I don't know what to do. I can't save myself. I can't fight back. But my hands reach up to the face above me, and I see the glazed skin quiver, and I see myself on the couch and fall.
It's not their fault, is it? The limitation lies not in our ghosts, but in us.
Act Three.
...disturbed by what he considers to be his new relative's hallucinations, has gone alone to the old house. Betty and her great-uncle Jasper have followed him there and found him stretched out. Stretched out upon the library floor, babbling unintelligibly of what they take to be his venture into the old house. Now he has lapsed into insensibility. Between us, Betty and I managed to get her unresisting husband into the car, back to my house and into bed, where he lay inert and unresponsive to all our overtures. Clearly, this was an illness beyond my poor powers to correct, and I had to tell Betty that we must get her husband to Puerto Rico, to the sanitarium and Dr. Martinez. She concurred, and somehow we got Jack onto the little inter-island boat and finally into the office of Dr. Martinez, where we told our story.
They told you now, eh? That is all, Doctor. He only went there because he and Betty here were worried about me. But I assure you, Dr. Martinez, I did on one occasion actually see the Shining Man, and I've observed the light in the window of the old house several times. The house is on my property. Just across an open field, so I've had a clear view of it.
But you never went back?
No, no. Once was enough for me. And I regret, Doctor, more than I can say, that I ever told Betty and Jack about that one and only visit. You see, if... It wasn't Jack's fault. I told him about it. Why didn't you go with my husband, the psychologist? And then the concern for Uncle Jasper and what might be... It seems now that there were not.
Dr. Martinez, you will keep Jack here, won't you?
I will keep him.
Oh, thank you.
I shall do what I can for him. But I won't go on. I can promise nothing. He was healthy and believed in the... Well, the supernatural, the occult. That's why he went to the old house. Proved to Uncle Jasper that the things he'd seen must have their basis in reality and in natural laws.
Mr. Law, you remember the descendant of the original owner who gained admittance some years ago? Spent the night there? To establish the very same thing?
Yes.
They found him the next morning lying on the couch in the library. Took him away. And brought him here.
That is, he was here until last night.
You mean he left? Was he well enough to leave?
I do not mean that. Care to see the body?
Hmm?
Then come with me. Mrs. Turner, you will stay here. The body is not a pretty sight. Come, Mr. Law. This way.
Of course, the original owner of the federal house, Mr. Nuckian, I believe his name was.
Yes, that's right, James Nuckian. He arrived before my time. This man, his descendant whose body we are going to look at, he too was brought in before I took up my post. But I have taken an interest in the case, even though I could do nothing to help. In here, Mr. Law. You will see that this body was once a direct power with noble features. You see, this coloration extends from the center of the forehead to a place behind the right ear. When this man was first brought here, he had a small dark spot on his forehead, but it spread rapidly over his entire body.
Cancerous, do you think?
The cancerous character, I should say. Likely to occur after a shock and perhaps after severe mental strain.
Such as a visit to the old house?
The first result of the shock in the case of this man here was imbecility. Then, an increasingly lethargic condition of the body. Finally, coma.
I know very little of such things, but on close inspection this discoloration would appear to be the result of a fungoid growth. Could I be correct?
You may very well be. Perhaps akin to the Indian disease known as mesotoma. Caps the underlying tissue and eventually the bones.
Is there any hope for Jack Turner?
There is always hope, my dear Mr. Law. Let us go back to the lovely young wife we left waiting in my office. I have something to ask her.
And what is that, Doctor?
Is the coat her husband was wearing when he was brought here the same coat he wore when he visited the old house?
We will in San Juan as quickly as possible. Dr. Martinez refused to enlighten us on the reason for his question and asked us to go home and wait for his phone call. Of course, we did. Never left the house together. And after a week or so...
Oh, well, I'll answer it, Betty. Yes, hello. Dr. Martinez, you talk so fast. Doctor, tell me, is he better? Say that Jack was showing improvement.
I did not tell her that the doctor was coming to the island and what he planned to do on his arrival. But late in the afternoon of the following day, I invented a plausible excuse and went to the pier to meet the boat which brought the doctor to the island. In my car, we drove immediately to the old house.
Dr. Martinez, that room there...
What makes you think so?
I have the impression that's her. Let's go in.
Hack the chip over your mouth and nose before we go into that room.
...properties. These are manifested not just during decomposition, but during the period of growth. The light is only visible from time to time. Active conditions admit an occasional efflorescence.
So Jack was poisoned by fungi. But he escaped. The others died.
Because the fungi only touched his clothing, not his skin. In my gleaming, where years ago, I tried to cultivate his form. Dangerous occupation, I assure you. An airless space like this. It is quite clear to me that either by accident or design, he became infected by the fungus poison, which in time covered his entire body.
And he tried to explain to Betty what he had endeavored to convey to me. I believe she comprehended even less than I did. But we both were heartened by Dr. Martinez's prognosis for Jack. He predicted that within a few weeks, Jack would come back to us, rejoin his bride, and after a few days, the two of them could continue on their honeymoon. And indeed, less than a month later, the doctor called to say that he himself was bringing Jack home.
Take the boat, Uncle Jasper.
Dr. Martinez was very insistent that we do no such thing. He's bringing Jack to the house in a taxi. He wanted it that way. Here they come now. Ah, yes, there's Dr. Martinez. Where is Jack? Jack's not with him.
Uncle Jasper, what happened?
Now, now, wait until the doctor has a chance to tell us.
Uh, Dr. Martinez. Hello! Hello, how are you? Oh, and you, Mrs. Turner? Where is my husband? Is he all right?
Oh, quite all right. He'll be along presently.
But, uh, where is he? We thought he'd be with you.
Now I must tell you. When Jack and I were on our way here, I explained in detail how he fell ill and why. And she said to me, how can this horrible old house, with deadly dust and poisonous fungi, be got rid of? And I said, only by burning it down.
That's what he's doing now. Look at that old house burned. Betty, look. Where is Betty?
I believe that is she running across the field to meet her husband.
Oh, uh, by the way, Mr. Law, I trust you will forgive my presumption in allowing the young man to set fire to the old house?
Of course, of course. After all he's been through, I could not resist denying him the pleasure.
You have done a good thing. You have exorcised a ghost. Happy ending for such a gruesome story. I should like to have been there to watch the old house go up in flames. And with it the deadly dust, the mysterious fungi, the poisonous spores, and of course the shining man who would shine no more.
I'll be back shortly. This time, of course, there turned out to be no ghost at all. Only natural phenomena issuing from natural causes. In a way it's a pity, don't you think? I was beginning to like the vision of a shining man and bookie-like flickering now and then from the window of an old deserted house. We don't always get what we want, do we? Better luck next time.
Our cast included Norman Rose, Diana Kirkwood, and Russell Horton. The entire production was under the direction of Hyman Brown. This is E.G. Marshall inviting you to return to our mystery theater for another adventure in the macabre. Until next time, pleasant dreams.
