The written record
Read the transcript
Read along with the recording · About 34 min to read
Stay tuned for Mystery Theater.
Welcome. I'm E.G. Marshall. Our tale is another domestic story. It's about the happy home life of a modern young family. A life, unfortunately, which is cut brutally short. Please be warned. Some of the scenes may not make you feel safe and secure. Even if your door is locked and bolted. It's a story about a family man named David Farmer. Our mystery drama, Promise to Kill, was written especially for the Mystery Theater by Henry Slesar and stars Gordon Gould. It is sponsored in part by Buick Motor Division and Anheuser-Busch Incorporated, Brewers of Budweiser. I'll be back shortly with Act One.
The scene is a suburban community called, appropriately, Park Pleasant. For that's exactly what it is. Pleasant and park-like. And very serene. A haven for the families of busy city executives like Dave Farmer. Dave is a lucky young man. He has a good job. He has a beautiful young wife named Connie. He has a daughter who promises to grow up looking just like her. But little Susan has plenty of time for that. She's only five years old. The day is Monday. The time is 8:15 a.m. The day is just beginning. So is the nightmare.
Dave, will you please hurry up? Dan's gonna drive me crazy with that horn.
I'm coming, I'm coming.
I wish you wouldn't fly down those stairs. I'm always afraid you'll break your neck.
Listen, it's my neck that's the problem. I can't seem to tie my tie around it this morning.
It's no wonder with Dan blowing his horn that way. What's the big hurry? It's only quarter past.
He's got to be in court this morning.
Well, that's his problem. You don't have to be at work until nine. And I insist that you have some breakfast.
I really don't have time, honey.
Yes, you do. Look, the eggs are all made. The toast is halfway done.
No, it isn't. You haven't plugged it in.
Oh, my. That's Susan again. She insists on pulling plugs out of the wall.
You better keep her away from wires and stuff. She'll electrocute herself.
Anyway, here are the eggs.
Hey, what's going on here?
Come on in, Stan. I've been intimidated into eating breakfast.
Breakfast? Breakfast? Listen, I've got a case to argue this morning, and this carpool was your idea.
It's okay. I'm all ready.
That didn't take long. You didn't even taste those eggs.
They were great. Terrific.
I am sorry to rush you out so early, Connie.
Dad!
A new complication. It's my Pooh bear.
That's right, my darling. You told Susan you were going to bring her a Pooh bear last night.
But I did. I just got home too late to give it to her. She was already asleep.
Well, where is it, Daddy?
Wait a sec. Oh, for Pete's... Say, come on. Come on, Dave. Am I going to hang up my client for a woolly bear?
I want my Pooh bear.
Here it is. Just as I promised.
Oh, isn't he cute? Don't you love him, Susie?
Oh, yes. Say thank you, Daddy.
Thank you, Daddy.
Dave, will you please come?
So long, darling. Uh, bye. And will you call me this afternoon?
Don't I always? Have a good day.
You too, Stan.
Oh, thanks. You two have already ruined my day.
Serves you right, bachelor.
Say one thing for married life. Hasn't hurt Connie's looks.
Yeah. She really looks great, doesn't she?
Yeah. I've almost forgotten how pretty she is. It's the first time I've seen her in more than a month.
That's not my fault, pal. I told you what to do. Get yourself a date and we'll make it a foursome one night.
That's the trouble with being a bachelor. You've always got to scrounge around for a date.
Okay, we'll make it a threesome. I'm sure you'd rather not.
Three's a crowd, right?
Not when two of them are married. Anyway, it's about time you made it a permanent foursome. Why don't you make up your mind which of your 55 girlfriends you want to marry?
Tried it once. I didn't like it.
If at first you don't succeed, try, try again.
That's what you say.
Ah, you hit it right the first time.
Just lucky, I guess.
No kidding, Stan. How about going to the theater at the... Oh, the theater. What about it?
I forgot to tell Connie to go to the box office.
What for?
Some tickets were left for us at the Park Pleasant Playhouse for tonight. But we have to pick them up before noon.
Ah! Ah, relax. We'll stop at a phone booth on the way.
Susie, are you sure you want to try those dishes? Mommy can do them.
I will.
Well, it's sweet of you, baby, but there are only a few. Two scrambled eggs.
No, dear. Bears don't eat eggs.
What do you mean? Bears eat honey.
Who gives you honey?
No. You can't give Winnie the Pooh any honey, either. I mean, bears don't eat anything this time of year. They just sleep.
Isn't that bad.
Now, that's a good idea. How long do bears have to sleep?
Well, they usually sleep through the whole winter.
Ah, look. Maybe Pooh bears are different.
Ah, run along now, dear. Mommy has to answer the phone. Maybe it's Daddy.
Maybe so.
Hello?
Hi. Oh, one second. It's not for you, baby. It's your Aunt Paula. Now, you go give Pooh bear a nap. Okay.
Paula, hi. How are you feeling?
Oh, fine. You're calling pretty early, aren't you?
I'm calling to give you a wonderful opportunity. It's 12 noon. I'll buy you lunch, and then we can go shopping.
Oh, I can't today, Paula. I'm sorry.
Why not?
Well, Susie's home from school, for one thing. They're having one of those teachers' conferences.
Why can't the maid take care of her?
Because it's Emily's day off, and I've got a dozen things to do around the house, and at the moment, I have to answer the doorbell. Go ahead, will you?
Well, do you want to hold on, or should I call you back?
I'll hold on.
Oh. Hello, Burton.
Hi, Mrs. Farmer. What in the world time is it?
Oh, gee, I don't know. I don't have a watch, but, well, I thought it was the right time.
Well, you usually deliver the groceries around ten, don't you?
Well, sure, usually. But I thought, well, you know, they come early today.
Well, all right. I suppose it doesn't make all that much difference.
It does to me, Mrs. Farmer.
What?
Well, listen, what do you want me to do? I mean, sure. What do you want me to do?
I don't know. I don't know. I don't know. I don't know. I don't know. I don't know. I don't know. I don't know. I don't know. I don't know. I don't know. I don't. I don't know.
It does to me, Mrs. Farmer. Yes, it does to me, Mrs. Farmer.
What?
Um, listen, what do you want me to do, I mean, should I bring in the stuff right now?
Well, of course. I mean, I could leave them out on the truck for a while. No, I guess that isn't such a smart idea. I mean, you've got milk and cream and stuff. They might get spoiled.
Well, of course they might get spoiled, Vernon. What an idea. Bring them in right away.
Well, sure, I'll do that, Mrs. Farmer. It won't be long.
OK. Are you still there?
I'm here. What's going on?
Well, he's just a boy from the supermarket. Uh, Burton, whatever his name is.
Oh, yeah. Well, there is certainly something wrong with his head today. He's talking so strangely. Anyway, listen, about the city. Thursday is absolutely the first day I can make it.
Oh, here it is, Mrs. Farmer.
All right, Burton.
Paula, what do you think about Thursday?
Thursday's fine. I'll call you Wednesday just to make sure you don't chicken out.
All right, Paula, bye.
So long.
Um, Mrs. Farmer?
What?
Uh, is it okay if I put everything here?
Well, yes, of course, Vernon. Pretty big load today, but I can handle it. I mean, I'm strong, you know?
Uh, yes. Uh, yeah, you want me to put the milk and stuff, uh, in the refrigerator?
No, no, just leave them there. You know, it was really something this morning. I mean, the way I felt driving over here.
Yeah.
Yes, uh, it's a lovely day.
You know what I mean? Driving over here and knowing that, well, that I was going to see you.
Well, that's, uh, very sweet, Vernon.
Kept seeing your face in front of me like it was in the windshield, you know?
But, Vernon, what a strange thing to say.
Kept thinking about, well, about how it was going to be. And when I rang the bell and you opened the door and you saw me, and, uh, I don't know, I just, here we are. I mean, just acting like always.
Like always?
You know, like nothing was special.
Well, uh, never mind the rest of that stuff, Vernon. I'll empty the boxes myself.
Yeah. Yeah, okay, that'll be better. Well, we don't have much time, I guess. I gotta be back to the store around 9, 9:30.
Vernon, what are you doing?
Oh, you've got such soft hands, you know?
Please, don't do that.
Uh, listen, what about, uh, her, you know, your little girl?
Susie? What about her?
When, uh, where is she, school or something?
Vernon, stop that.
Oh, your skin is, oh, I don't know, it's like something else. It's just, it's just, for heaven's sake.
Please, uh, don't, don't tease no more, Miss Farmer. Don't tease, I ain't got much time.
Vernon, will you let me go?
What?
You want to, you want to go upstairs?
You let me go. You let me go, or I'll bring the house down.
No, don't, don't, don't go. I'll call the police, I swear I will. I'll just, ah!
Now, you stop that, Miss Farmer. You just stop playing games with me.
Don't, Mrs. Farmer. Now, please, be nice. Don't make me, don't, don't make me hurt you. Please, please.
Are you sure you dialed the right number?
Positive. Think I don't know my own number?
Connie's got to be home. We left her only half an hour ago.
Maybe she's in the bath. Miss Susie picks up the phone when she is. I'll try just once more.
I was calling the Farmer residence. Maybe you can answer the same question, since it's my house.
Yes, that's right. And who are you?
This is Patrolman Ernest Meckley.
Did you say Patrolman? What was that? Listen, is there something wrong out there? Was there a fire or something? Good Lord, say, what was...
No, Mr. Farmer. I'm in a phone booth on the expressway.
For Pete's sake, will you tell me what you're doing in my house? Let me speak to my wife.
I'm sorry, Mr. Farmer. You can't do that.
I'm not doing anything until you tell me what happened there.
I'm a little... I mean... I want to know what kind.
You had better just come back here, mister. Your wife and kid were... were hurt very bad.
Connie. How bad? What's going on, for Pete's sake? I want to know what happened. I want to know how they were hurt. And how badly.
I hate to tell you, Mr. Farmer.
Damn you. Tell me.
It's a strange place to find yourself in the middle of a nightmare. A highway crowded with cars and trucks. The bright midwinter sun shining in your eyes. Hearing a disembodied voice telling you that everything you cared for in life is gone. Vanished in one bloody instant. One terrible moment of madness. One meaningless action. But this nightmare isn't over for Dave Farmer. Or for a young man named Vernon White. We'll be back in just a moment with Act Two.
The scene changes. We are no longer in the quiet suburb of Park Pleasant. Large, high-ceilinged room. Flanked by American flags. Solemn with the traditions of American justice. This is a courtroom. Seated in the front row is David Farmer. Beside him sits his friend Stan. His sister-in-law Paula. His face is ashen. Haunted. And at the defense table. His hair neatly combed and brushed. His cheeks rosy. Wearing his best blue suit. Looking very much like the all-American boy. Sits Vernon White. Killer.
Your Honor.
Yes, Mr. Waterman.
The defense has no objection to these photographs being submitted to the jury. But these proceedings have been delayed long enough.
Very well. Is the prosecution ready to proceed?
Yes, Your Honor.
Then please continue your examination of the witness.
Yes, Your Honor. Patrolman McLeary, you've seen these photographs we've shown the jury?
Yes, sir.
Is it an accurate representation of the scene you discovered that morning at the Farmer House?
Yes, sir. That's what I found.
A young woman, brutally assaulted, strangled to death.
Yes, sir.
Evidence of a struggle.
Yes, sir.
A young wife and mother slain in her own kitchen.
And a child five years old. Slain. Just as horrible.
Your Honor, may I object to the prosecution's use of such emotional terms?
I beg the defense attorney's pardon. You're quite right. One hardly needs words like brutal and horrible to describe this crime. The facts speak for themselves.
Patrolman McLeary, did you also see several boxes of groceries in that kitchen?
Yes, sir. About four boxes.
You concluded that a delivery had been made that morning.
Yes, sir. The perishables hadn't been put away.
And that led you to make inquiries in the neighborhood about the arrival of the grocery truck.
Yes, sir. We learned that the truck from the Park Pleasant supermarket had been there and left.
And you sought out the delivery boy. Or should I say, the delivery man.
Yes, sir. I interrogated... Mr. Vernon White.
See? And what did he tell you?
He apologized.
For what?
He apologized for killing Mrs. Farber and her daughter.
---
Eat something, will you? Don't just stare at your plate. Now, come on, eat.
No. I can't.
David, this is ridiculous. No breakfast. No lunch. What good is that going to do you?
No good.
Oh, you talk some sense into him, Paul. Look at him. He's lost ten pounds since the trial started.
David. Please. She was my sister. I loved her. I loved Susie. But I know that I have to stay alive. I know that. And so do you.
---
Let's get that to court.
Was Mrs. Farber alone when you walked into the kitchen?
Yes.
Did you attack her right away?
Attack her? You heard me. Did you just reach out and grab her?
Well, no. Of course not.
Did you try to embrace her? Kiss her? Or anything like that?
Yeah. Yeah, I guess I did. Because, uh...
Because what, Vernon?
Well, because I thought she liked me. Because I thought she wanted me to.
---
The defendant will rise. Vernon White, you have been tried and convicted for the crime of homicide in the first degree. The laws of this state, as amended on October 5th, 1974, impose a mandatory sentence. Therefore, it is my duty to instruct the warden of the state prison in Pigstown to take you to a place where you shall be kept until the 31st day of March, 1976, at which time you will be hanged from the neck until death. May God have mercy on your soul.
---
I said, who is it?
It's Farber. Please let me in, David.
All right. Well, well, will the real David Farmer please shave?
How did you find him?
Your brother did.
Your brother did find me. If you must know, Stan told me.
Stan has a big mouth.
You look terrible. You look as run down as this hotel.
What did you want me to do? Stay up there in that house?
You could have found something better than this.
This suits me fine.
If you want to stay in a hotel for a while, fine. But the least you can do is get a decent room.
This isn't a hotel room, Paula. This is a waiting room.
What?
A waiting room. A place for me to wait for the 31st of March.
Oh, Dave. Dave, that's terrible. That's so senseless.
What else have I got to do but count the days?
But to do this to yourself. To hole up in this awful flea bag, staring at the calendar, thinking of nothing but that poor moron's execution.
He's not a moron. He's Jack Armstrong, the all-American boy. Didn't you hear what he said in court? He thought Connie liked him, that she wanted him.
Dave, listen. Listen to me. Vernon White killed something very precious to me, too. Dave, I have to tell you something.
Tell me what?
What you want to happen isn't going to happen.
What did you say?
There isn't going to be any 31st.
There's always a 31st, seven months out of the year.
I mean, there isn't going to be any execution. Stanley called to tell me, and I think that's why he gave me your address, so I could break the news to you.
What are you talking about?
The appeal was accepted because of Vernon's substandard intelligence or something like that.
You're lying to me.
Dave, they'd commuted his sentence to life imprisonment.
They can't do that. They can't.
They did, Dave. Vernon White went through tests. He's not an imbecile, and he's not insane, but he's just not smart enough to know the difference between right and wrong.
They can't do that. They can't do that. They can't do that. He killed Connie. He killed my little girl.
Good Lord, Paula.
You've got to accept it, Dave. Don't let it make such a difference to you.
No. Never. I'll never accept it. Do you think I can go on living with him alive and breathing and walking around and smiling and Connie and Susie dead? No. I won't let it be.
Admit it. Vernon isn't crazy. He's not crazy. He's not crazy. He's not crazy. He's not crazy. He's not crazy. They would have pleaded insanity if he was.
It's not a matter of sane or insane, Dave. There is such a thing as clemency.
Yes, clemency for the criminals, not for the victims. This kid's got an IQ of under 80. He was smart enough to think Connie liked him. He thought she had a crush on him. He was so used to having girls ogle him in the supermarket, juggling those crates with his big muscles.
Dave, Dave, this is useless. The court has accepted the appeal. You just don't have any recourse.
You're wrong. I do.
Like what?
I'm going to kill him, Stan. That's all I can do right now. I have to kill that animal or I have to stop living myself. One or the other.
That. You're crazy, Dave. I don't believe you mean that.
I mean every word. I'm going to kill him and you're going to help me.
But the man's in prison.
People get killed in prison. There's a way to do everything if you have the desire and the money. I have both. You haven't got that kind of experience. But you have, Stan. You were in criminal law once. You must know people.
I'm sorry, Dave.
You're supposed to be my best friend. If that's what you are, prove it. Help me wipe this germ off the face of the earth.
It wouldn't prove anything.
It will to me. I want his life for Connie's, Susie's, and mine.
Whose life do you want to save, Stan? Vernon White's or mine?
Oh, no, no, no. I hope you're not talking about...
Sure, that's what I'm talking about. Here's what I said. I can't live if he does. I'd just as soon stick my head into an oven.
You are putting me in one hell of a spot.
Find out what I have to do, Stan.
---
Uh, Mr. Ross, this is Dave Farmer.
Hello, Mr. Farmer. Nice meeting you.
Yes, hello. Uh, Mr. Ross was in the, uh, transportation business. He was a client of mine a few years back.
Yeah, long distance hauling, you know.
Yeah, can we get to the point?
Well, uh, this is the point. Mr. Ross has a brother named Joey.
Yeah, Joey, right. Well, unfortunately... Probably a few years ago, the Rosses got into a jam. Uh, when was the moving company, uh, me and my brother?
Yes, I got Mr. Ross off, but his brother wasn't that lucky. He's serving a ten-year sentence right now.
In Peekstown?
Uh, Peachtown, right. Well, Joey's a friendly guy. You know, he's made a lot of friends in prison.
Yeah, Joey's okay.
The point, Stan.
Um, proposition is this. Uh, Joey is a trustee at Peachtown. And even though he's made some, you know, errors in his life, he, he doesn't like child killers any more than we do. Uh, he might want to do something about burning white.
Uh, we ain't talking about favors, though.
No. No, not favors. What we're talking about entails a certain amount of risk. So it's only fair that we arrange some compensation.
I'll pay anything. Name your price.
We've already agreed on a price.
Okay. $3,000. I'll make it five.
Wait a minute, Dave.
I'll make it five if you kill him before the 31st.
---
That's he. When did you pay this plumbing bill?
I don't know, Paula. Mark paid, but I don't see the canceled check.
Well, what does it matter?
It does matter, Dave. You can't let everything slide this way. Half a dozen people are threatening to sue you for this or that. And I suppose you know that you let your insurance policy lapse. You went right past the 30-day grace period.
What's the difference? You know why I had that policy?
But it's ridiculous to let it lapse. One of these days, you might want to...
Don't say that, Paula. Anyway, I called your broker and arranged to have it paid. I'm surprised Stan didn't do that for you when he had the power of attorney.
Stan isn't a bookkeeper. He's a lawyer.
Still, he could have been more helpful. He knew how spaced out you were. He could have hired a girl or somebody to pay your bills. Keep your accounts in order.
Paula, will you stop taking off on Stan? What have you got against the guy?
What have you got in his favor? He's my best friend. He moved that.
Maybe. I wonder how friendly he'd be if you were broke.
Cut it out, Paula.
Oh, look at this checkbook. None of the stubs filled in. And you must have spent a zillion dollars.
They were expensive.
I know that. But Stan sold those securities for you back in March. That meant it was a deposit of almost $100,000.
Paula, I can't think now.
Okay. But I just wanted you to know that there are expenditures I can't explain.
---
Hello?
Yeah. What's happening?
He had a deal, Stan. You don't care about the money?
It's just a tool.
For how long?
We can't... He's got to.
---
Although the executioner has failed to perform his allotted task, Vernon White is alive and not so well in the prison hospital. But the physicians who will treat his wounds don't know that he's suffering from what might well be a terminal illness, the disease called revenge. We'll see if Dave Farmer gets that revenge in a few moments when I return with Act Three.
---
But Constance and Susan Farmer are still alive. David Farmer is alive, too, if walking, talking, and breathing are signs of life. As his sister-in-law, Paula, sits at a restaurant table and looks at his pale features, her eyes are clouded with pity.
Dave, when I first met you, when Connie introduced us, I remember thinking you were sweet and kind, maybe a little vulnerable.
Vulnerable?
Seeing what you wanted to see in people, giving them nice, clean images, even if they were more complicated than you wanted them to be.
I suppose you're talking...
I'm not talking about Stan.
No, I'm talking about Connie.
Connie?
You see, I had my sister for a sister much longer than you had her for a wife.
I never saw anything complicated about Connie.
It was hard to see. She had such a bright, glowing surface.
Paula, we were married six years. Do you think I didn't know Connie?
She always wanted so much, Dave. That's what worried me when she told me she was getting married. She was used to all this. She was used to a hundred phone calls, seven dates a week, fifty men in her life at all times.
She was beautiful, Paula.
I know. She was dazzling. Maybe that's what happened to that poor delivery boy. He was dazzled out of his senses.
Is that why you wanted to have dinner with me? To defend that moron?
No, Dave. I had another reason.
Well, what is it?
I finished all the books last night.
So?
I did everything I could, Dave. I got everything to balance. Practically to the penny.
I knew you were a great bookkeeper.
The only trouble is, I still can't explain some of the cash withdrawals that were made by Stan.
Forget them.
Forget? You heard me. Forget $25,000.
$25,000?
That's right.
Well, now even you seem surprised.
Well, it can't be that much, Paula. It just can't be.
It is. It is. It is. It is. It is. It is. It is. It is. It is. It is. It is.
You must know what that means.
$25,000? All taken out in cash.
Well, I thought that there were expenses, Dave. You know that. I'm sorry if they weren't all itemized.
Not like you, though. You were always a stickler about money. You always said you were raised poor, so you had respect for the buck.
Look, Dave, I wasn't at my best at the time, either. Connie meant a lot to me, too. You know.
---
Stan. Stan. What happened to that money?
Hey, hey, come on. What kind of tone of voice is that?
I want an answer.
Oh, wait, wait. Now, are you accusing me or something?
Oh, wait a minute. I just got it. Oh, Paula put you up to this. Hmm? Well, Paula never liked me much. She's found the perfect way to get back at me.
The money's gone. It went into somebody's pocket. And I want to know whose. I want to know if there's something you're hiding.
Maybe there's something that's got to be hidden.
Nothing like this.
You were willing to spend $5,000. That was different. That money had a special purpose. Now, what's the special purpose for that $25,000?
I wanted to spare you the truth, Dave.
What truth?
Well, even now, I don't want to tell you. I'd rather you thought that I was a thief and a swindler than that I robbed you.
Is that what you did?
No, no, no. What I did, I did for you. And for Connie.
Connie? I swore to myself that you'd never learn about it.
Learn about what? The money?
About what the money bought.
Well, go on.
It went into somebody's pocket, all right.
George Waterman's. Vernon's defense attorney? Are you kidding me?
I had to do it, Dave. I had to make things easier.
Well, how could they be easier? Vernon confessed. His prints were on everything. There wasn't any doubt of his guilt.
Dave. Dave. Dave. I bought a note.
What note? I should have burned it the minute it was in my hand, but I didn't. Lord knows why. Who knows? Maybe I was afraid that this would happen, that I'd have to account to you for what I did.
What note? Who wrote it? What did it say?
I have it here. It's in this drawer. I would give my right arm if you never had to see it.
It's Connie's stationery.
Yes, yeah. Her handwriting.
Yes. I have to see you. Dave leaves for the city at 8:30. I'll try to send Susie out to day school. I'll be waiting for you, darling. Please don't.
I am sorry, Dave.
It's her handwriting.
Yes, I know. I have to see you. Dave leaves for the city.
Good Lord, what does this mean?
The note. It was sent to Vernon White.
It just can't be.
He turned it over to his attorney after the arrest. Waterman didn't want to submit it into evidence before he talked to me. He knew it wouldn't make any difference as far as the verdict was concerned. Well, it might even have made his client a little less pathetic, but he knew it would make a difference to us.
I'm not going to believe it. I'm not. Oh, heaven help me.
I didn't want to either. But it's the truth. Twenty-five thousand dollars worth of ugly truth.
Who is it?
Paula, please open the door, Dave. Don't worry. I didn't bring you chicken soup. Just a couple of containers of coffee.
Did you think I'd need sobering up?
You do, Dave.
I haven't been drinking.
I thought... Well, I thought you might be upset tonight.
Why? Because of what happened. Have you been talking to Stan?
No, of course not. I have nothing to say to Stan. And he, vice versa. I meant about Vernon White.
Do you still take your coffee black?
What about Vernon?
He was released from the prison hospital. But the authorities thought it would be too risky just to put him back among the same prisoners. So they transferred him.
Where?
Well, I guess they thought he couldn't be very dangerous after the knife wound and all that. But he must be a strong young man.
Get to the point.
He got away, Dave. Vernon's loose.
It wasn't easy, Mr. Farmer, let me tell you. But you really know something?
I know everything. This kid Vernon is the dope. He ain't playing with a full deck, you know what I mean?
I know.
Well, a pal of mine, he lives on East Avenue. He gives me the tip. Some kids in the neighborhood, like a gang, they do a lot of prowling around the section where they're knocking down buildings for some kind of housing project. Well, they spotted this blonde guy sleeping in one of the condemned buildings. I think maybe they rolled him over. They rolled him, only he didn't have no money.
What happened to him? Where is he now?
Well, my pal, he goes to have a look at the guy and sees the kind of clothes he's wearing. He figures he busted out of the joint.
Where is he? Where is Vernon White?
My friend got him, like in custody. You know what I mean. Sometimes there's a reward for turning in escaped cons.
He wouldn't call the police?
No. My friend is not exactly friendly with the cops. But bread is bread, Mr. Farmer.
I'll pay your friend. How much does he want? A thousand? Uh, more like it, two. And then there's me. I, uh, I put in a lot of time.
All right. A thousand for you, two for your friend. Only, I want one other thing. I want a gun.
Vernon? Oh, I guess I don't. No, wait, you look kind of familiar. Look hard, Vernon.
Nope, I just don't remember. Uh, Vernon? Hey, you, you, you bring me something to eat?
My name is Farmer.
Yeah, the man that was here before, he said he was gonna bring me sandwiches or something. I sure am hungry.
Vernon, doesn't the name mean anything to you?
Oh, well, what was it again?
Farmer. David Farmer. My wife's name was Connie. My daughter was named Susan. Do you remember now?
Uh, yeah. Yeah, I remember. I, uh, saw you up at Park Pleasant and, uh, in the court. I'm her husband, Vernon. The husband of the woman you murdered. The father of a child.
Gee, uh, Mr. Farmer, I'm, I'm, I'm really sorry about what happened. I really am.
Yes, Vernon, everyone told me you were sorry.
Yeah, I, I mean, I didn't mean to hurt your wife. I really didn't.
And the little girl?
Yeah, I, I didn't mean to hurt either one.
You liked them, didn't you? You liked my wife, and she liked you.
Well, I thought she did, Mr. Farmer. She told me she did. Only when I came to see her, like she asked me to, she put up this big fight, and I got all upset about it. I, I, I didn't know what I was doing anymore.
A lot of the girls like you, don't they, Vernon?
Yeah. A lot of girls at the store is, hey, is that a real gun?
Yes.
Well, anyway, uh, she sent me that note, and I thought she was like the girls in the store. Um... Well, she said it was good-looking. That's what he told me.
He? Who told you?
Well, he did. He did. The, the man I used to see there.
What man?
Uh... I forget his name. Uh, the lawyer.
What?
Yeah, he, he told me that she liked me. And I'd be loading up stuff at the supermarket, and he'd drive up and say, Hey, Vernon, Mrs. Farmer thinks you're a real good-looking kid. She'd really like to get you all home.
You're crazy. Nobody told you any of that thing.
Yeah, he did, he did. He did. And, and then he gave me this note that she wrote to me.
He gave you the note? The lawyer?
Yeah. I swear, he gave me this note, and it said, I want to see you. My husband's going to the city, and I want you to come around.
You're a liar. You're a liar.
No, look, I, I swear it's true. He was that friend of yours, the one that you drove around with a lot. And, and he gave me the note, and I went there, and, and...
And? And? And?
She didn't like me. She didn't like me at all. And that's, that's when everything went wrong.
It's very... Stan? Oh, thanks. Did you hear the good news? About Vernon White?
Yes, I heard.
Well, they'll be holding him in maximum security for a while. You can scratch any idea of getting at him, at least for the time being.
It's okay, Stan. I've dropped the idea. Vernon's death doesn't mean anything to me now.
Well, I'm relieved to hear that. In fact, I was the one who turned him in. That anonymous tip to the police was mine.
But how did you know where...
I didn't see any reason for Vernon's death. Not after he told me about the note.
Yes, I talked to him, Stan. Mr. Ross helped me find him. And we had a good, long talk.
I hope you, uh, I hope you didn't take him too seriously, Dave. You know the kid's boring. He's dim-witted, not a moron.
Dim enough to think that Connie liked him just because you said so. Dim enough to believe that note was meant for him. It was really sent to you.
Uh, no, wait a minute, Dave. I couldn't understand it at first. Then I remembered how it was between you and Connie before I came along. I had a little more to offer, so she picked me. But she didn't want to give you up either.
Dave, now...
I don't know what you heard. Something happened, Stan. Connie threw you over for some reason. I remember when you stopped coming around to the house.
Dave, I swear to you that...
She must have hurt you pretty bad. So bad that you wanted to hurt her back. So you picked Vernon.
But please, please, let me say something.
He told me all about it. What you used to say to him to goad him on, get him all excited. And then you gave him that note. The note Connie once sent you.
I didn't mean it to work out the way it did. So help me, I didn't. I didn't know what he'd do. I just... I just wanted to teach her a lesson.
That's why you were willing to help me. Willing to let me kill that boy. So he'd never give you away.
Dave, Dave, I didn't mean it. I didn't want it to happen, Dave. But it happened. He killed them. Connie. And Susie.
You killed them.
No, no, it's not, not me. I swear it wasn't me.
Will you swear, Stan?
Yes, yes.
On your knees.
On my knees, Dave, on my knees. I swear it, it wasn't me.
Dave. Dave, that gun, you...
It's the 31st. An execution has taken place on the 31st of the month. In the mind of David Farmer, justice has been done. But now... The executioner himself must face the bar of justice. For usurping the privilege only the law can have. Only the law...
I'll be back shortly. Didn't find our little domestic tale too grim? When violence strikes close to home, it's always more upsetting. If you are disturbed, why not sit back now? Have a nice warm drink. Go to bed early and take tomorrow off. Then you'll be all ready for a little more terror and suspense when we return with another episode of Radio Mystery Theater.
Our cast included Gordon Gould, Earl Hammond, Russell Horton, Hedy Galen, Leslie Woods, and Roy LeMay. The entire production was under the direction of Hyman Brown.
Radio Mystery Theater was sponsored in part by Anheuser-Busch Incorporated, Brewers of Budweiser, and Buick Motor Division.
Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
This is E.G. Marshall inviting you to return to our Mystery Theater for another adventure in the macabre. Until next time, pleasant dreams.
Mystery Theater was also brought to you in part by ShopRite Supermarkets, where you get a lot more for a little less.
The preceding program was furnished by CBS Radio. Your dial is set for news with John Scott. Paris police shoot two gunmen dead after they'd held hostages all day in a bank hold-up. And President Ford's plan to bail out New York City continues to make progress in the United States Senate. It's 31 degrees and clear in mid-Manhattan. The man says clear, windy, and cold tonight, with a low in the middle 20s. Sunny and cold tomorrow with a high in the upper 30s.
This is John Scott with the 8 o'clock edition of the news. Paris police shot two gunmen dead in a street battle early today after the men had held more than 20 hostages for 14 hours in a Paris bank, demanding $2 million in ransom. The gunmen had left the bank with hostages in a getaway car provided by police, and with sacks apparently containing money. A few hundred yards away, just off the Champs-Élysées, their car collided with a taxi. They opened fire on the car.
