Skip to content
On Air
All channelsAll
CBS Radio Mystery Theater artwork

From the CBS Radio Mystery Theater collection

Side Effects

Episode 947January 19, 197946 min 3 secTranscript

Writer: Himan Brown

The written record

Read the transcript

Read along with the recording · About 20 min to read

The CBS Radio Mystery Theater presents On the Just and the Unjust Alike. And while this is undeniably true, how does it happen that some people always seem to weather the storm? How do you account for the fact that some people always manage to have an umbrella? How can you explain why some people can be caught in a cloudburst and get wet?

It went off.

Did it really?

The police are satisfied. It ended with a gun. Theater by Sam Dann, Robert Dryden, and Mandel Kramer. Sponsored in part by True Value Hardware Stores. I'll be back shortly.

We're delighted by the writings of a man named Peter Finley Dunn, who called himself quite a phrase maker. He had one for every occasion. For example, he described a fanatic as a man who does what he knows the Lord would do if only the Lord had the facts in the case. The remark that is germane to our story, about just... Justice is blind, and she's also deaf, and dumb, and has a wooden leg, seen that way. Provided he should... I'll drive your car off. I think you'll want to go back to the lab with me.

Paul and he's entitled to know first, now. Maybe you shouldn't drive. Let me go with you.

No, no. Some people it might very well be. I'm as good as dead now.

Right, Mr. Urban?

No, I'm not dead. At 87, the car isn't built to take that, especially your tires.

Yeah, I should have known better, Sheriff. The pressure coefficients would certainly... What am I going to do with you, Mr. Urban? I see you'll have to write me a ticket. I don't have jurisdiction on the interstate. What's your drive? Look, I have an appointment at the lodge with Mr. Rutledge. He's expecting me. I'm only trying to save your life. I'm late. Very late. I'm supposed to meet Mr. Rutledge and do some duck shooting. You? Penalty for that's a fine. Tell me what I have to do to pay it, and I'll be on my way. Give me your car keys. Now, wait a minute. I'll send someone back to pick up your car. I'll drive you to the lodge myself.

I'll hurt your shoulder.

Paul. Paul's got my limit now. Look at that bag. Paul. You sure kept both of our busy retreats. Ah, you're the dog. Paul, I don't know how to save this. Pick up that gun. You can bag at least three of them. Paul, get ready.

I don't want to get ready. I don't want to kill anything. I hate the stupid, vicious massacre of innocent creatures.

This is too good to miss. You pretended to like it just to please your boss. True?

Yes. Now you don't have to pretend anymore. Now we've got a winner. Now that Alderaan has taken... Now that you're going to be rich, you don't have to butter up the boss any longer. Is that it?

Why did you come? You got a phone and said no. Paul, we have to have a talk. On Sunday? Who had this morning?

Is it true?

Yes. I got to deal with you, Melvin. You refuse to behave like a rich man. Are you going to be a little insecure chemist for the rest of your life?

I'm not going to be rich, Paul.

What do you mean you're not going to be rich? Do you know what your royalties in Alderaan will amount to?

Paul. Be recalled. It simply isn't ready. Some of it, a batch of it, breaks down into... It's a complex chemical.

All right, come to the point. It's basically a fatty acid that can be fatal.

All right. Let's not panic. We have a batch that for some reason was improperly formulated.

No, that's not what I'm telling you. I'm saying that we can get a batch or run whatever five to ten percent reacts in a completely unexpected fashion. And it can produce deadly results.

Now look, Melvin. The government tested our product inside out. It passed with flying colors. It's okay. The doctors are screaming for it. It's been hailed on all sides as the antibiotic of the future.

I got a phone call from Jerry Scott. He was at the lab. He's ambitious. He's conscientious. He's checking out some studies on the computer. He simply couldn't comprehend the readout, so he called me and I came over. Right out, I knew what it was.

What was it?

It was the earliest Alderaan samples. You remember, Bob, we called it proto-Alderaan when we started five years ago?

Yeah, I saw.

Well, I found faint traces of fatty acids then. But that doesn't have to mean that we're going to... Samples we submitted to the government were later ones. That was a different Alderaan.

No. It was the same. We just sent the newer samples, that's all. And they passed. But now those same acids are showing up. I told you. Between five and ten.

And what are you suggesting?

Take it? Off the market. And bring it back into the lab until it's foolproof.

Who knows about this?

I do, and you do.

What about Scott?

Well, he knows that he's getting confusing data on the computer, but he may not be aware of what it means. Not yet.

You told no one else about it?

No. Not even Rita?

No, not even Rita.

Paul, we're going to have to take it off the market.

No, we can't take it off the market. I just told you. No, no, let me tell you. I went for broke on Alderaan. I sunk a fortune into it. It's what I needed to save Rutledge Drug, which has been in my family for 150 years. Paul, Alderaan is not dead. Now, you better listen. The orders are coming in. They're pouring in. Rutledge Drug is going to make millions. And so are you.

I don't think you understand.

I'm still talking. I was very good to you, Melvin.

I appreciate that. You were knocking your brains out as a teacher. I took you on. I paid you real money.

I know what you did for me.

Do you? Do you also know that I saved your marriage? You saved my life, Rita. Parties, travel. She was in a rut as a schoolteacher's wife. Ready to walk out. Tripled your salary. You started to get around. You became an exciting, important guy. I need something. What are you suggesting?

We're in the clear. Didn't you hear what I told you?

What did you tell me? Samples may have a tendency in rare cases to produce a harmful acid.

I'm kind of here. I'm sneezing.

What are you saying? That we continue to market Alderaan? We test out perfectly. Suppose Scott hadn't been fooling around in the lab today. This would never have come to your attention.

But it did.

But suppose it didn't.

Go on. Maybe a year from now it would come out that a minute percentage of Alderaan can be harmful. Fatal. We're in the clear legally, ethically. Any discovery, new product made by any employee belongs to the employer. Those conditions, don't they?

Yes, Paul, but that...

What do they give you? When you discover something for them. A hearty handshake. Then you write off. You come up with something, you get a piece. And I've lived up to my bargain.

And I appreciate that. But how much time do we have?

Who knows? Six months? A year? Maybe more, maybe less.

Give me six months. By that time I'm on my feet again, financially. Then we'll pull it off the market ourselves.

I'm sorry, Paul.

You go along with that. We have to withdraw Alderaan tomorrow.

And don't you... Look, at any time, anywhere, any batch of Alderaan may go bad, may become fatal. You do realize that, don't you?

I'm sorry. Nothing I can say to you.

Paul, it all comes down to this. The man does what he has to do.

That's right. What you have to do. You have no choice.

Yes, Melvin. You just said it. You just said it. Each of us is required to make. And each choice leads us inexorably to the next one. Logically. Because once we choose the pathway... We follow it to the end, wherever it may lead us. With us, the second act. Blast fired deliberately by Paul. Closest to friends. When they met that morning, neither of them harbored anything but the warmest feelings for each other. What is it? What do we carry around inside us? What unknown and terrifying thing that can make the calmest among us vicious of killers?

Not sure I know. I had the 12. I wasn't having any luck with the 12. I wasn't having any luck with the 16-gauge. So he said to me, Paul, let me borrow yours for a minute. 12. He reached for it, took it, and I guess he dropped it.

He dropped it?

I think he dropped it. So I could pick up the 16-gauge. I didn't see. The next thing I heard, the 12-gauge went off, and he was dead. He didn't care beans about duck hunting. He just came up to please me. My darling.

I could ask you just one question, Rommage.

Of course. Of course. Mr. Arvin, did he seem to act in any... bothered or something?

Well, it's obvious he caught a charge from the 12-gauge. Which went off accidentally. I guess so. Well, at least that's how Paul Rutledge tells it.

That isn't the way it happened?

What with the 16?

Yeah, so? Asked for the 12. He's just lying. No. Too close to 100. Distraught. About what? I don't know. I said, what are you trying to do? Kill yourself? He said, I might as well. I'm as good as dead now. He's a bad way.

Yeah. And Rutledge said there didn't seem to be anything wrong with him.

Yeah. Maybe he'd recovered his composure by that time. After all, Paul was his employer. Mel might have felt that he had to maintain a certain front.

Yeah, well, why should Mel have thought he was as good as dead? What did he mean by that?

Yeah, sometimes people find themselves in moods, you know?

Yeah. Well, Doc, you're the coroner. You satisfied with the verdict of accidental death? Look, Nick, you're the sheriff. Can you bring me any evidence to the contrary?

How difficult a time this is for you, but I saw your husband. He was in a very agitated state.

Yes, I know.

Tell me why he was so upset.

Life was over. Dead.

That's right, Sheriff. You're in the lab this morning, huh?

Sir, how do you score a point?

Yes. Well, I was checking some records on the computer, and I couldn't believe the printout. Well, I don't know anything about it, and you can never explain it, so I couldn't understand it, but in a general way, what do you mean?

Well, Sheriff, uh, every step and a little bit. I've done a long series of processes, and, oh, they ramified a hundred thousand... Well, what do you mean, he just didn't go? They furnished a series of answers which you have to check out. I wasn't getting logical answers. Something was wrong.

With what?

One of our procedures.

Mm-hmm. To produce such agitation in my library?

Yes.

What did the computer refer to?

Well, I don't know. Very tight security around here.

Well, if you had a guess...

Collectors?

Mm-hmm. Big number one. Most effective. Biggest all-around antibiotic ever made. We just got the go-ahead, and we're swamped. We can't turn out enough of it.

Well, is Mel Arvin depressed because it develops or is something wrong with Alderaan? Could there be anything wrong with Alderaan?

Well, why was he so down? He's really set back, wasn't he?

Oh, yes.

Why?

I don't have the faintest idea.

Hey, that sounds pretty good. What's he mean?

You're certain that Mel Arvin's death was an accident?

What was it?

Yup. I am. Paul, it's a very bad drug they came up with. Alderaan's been test-fired, investigated. They're gonna use it on all my patients. Not an infection so far. I have to stand up to it.

Well, I'm just giving you the facts.

What facts?

Well, at MD, Mel Arvin's discovered something about how it was like a man at the end of his rope. Paul Rutledge was lying. But you have to come up with a motive. Paul, Mrs. Arvin, and Jerry Scott. And then, the whole sense of this thing. As soon as I could.

Oh. I can understand. It's a shocking thing, Rita. Certainly. Uh. A problem is solved. He's... I haven't loved Mel in years. They're gorgeous. Probably because of the coroner's inquests. Yes, I'm sorry. You may have to testify. Oh, no. Don't do that. There's nothing to be afraid of. They're all local people. They all think very highly of me. But what? And full of good spirits when he left here. But he was. If you say so. But... This has to appear as an accident. It comes out that Melvin was upset, agitated. People might ask, Why did I permit him to shoot with me? Once you get questioning started, you can never tell where it leads.

Ask a question. A gun went off.

A gun went off? When it went off?

Rita, for you, I can't know about the Alderon. Which could make him run out of here like a madman. The truth. I couldn't kill him just for you. And I couldn't kill him just for the Alderon. It needed both of you at the same time, in the same place. Now, listen. Don't worry that he was happy. He left directly for the lodge. He did not go to the lab at all. But Jerry Scott will tell you an entirely different story. Don't worry about it. But, but then... You'll be surprised, dear Rita, how cheaply you can buy the Jerry Scotts of this world. Money talks. Money talks louder than truth. Money talks and money commands. With money, you may rewrite the past, design the present, and shape the future. But not always. Sometimes, when you think that money is the supreme ruler of the universe, something unexpected happens. Money is suddenly reduced to just some soft metal and fragile paper.

Attend with us, the third act.

Does life mimic art? Or does art imitate life? Or does it matter? Stories, things can be suitably arranged for an author's convenience, his desire. It's dramatist's novel. They decide who lives, who dies, who should be rich, who should be poor. It is the fair lady, and do with just a few words on paper. Powerful, unscrupulous men. Real life.

Mrs. Arvin, what happened on Sunday morning?

Sunday? Doc Irwin. He had this appointment with Mr. Rutledge. Doc hunting on Mr. Rutledge's estate. We had his breakfast and...

Something to say, Sheriff?

Uh, may I ask the witness a question, Doc?

Go right ahead.

Mrs. Arvin, didn't your husband receive a telephone call?

Who? I...

Mrs. Arvin, when I spoke to Jerry Scott, I called him from the lab.

Yes, sir, yes, sir, indeed.

All right, then, now, where on Sunday?

The park. I go jogging every Sunday.

Were you at the laboratory that morning?

No. I mean, why? Why would I go there on a Sunday? Kill the weekend.

Mr. Scott, remember that I spoke to you?

Oh, yes, Sheriff, I do. I most certainly do.

Do you remember?

Most certainly didn't.

Well, you... You didn't go into the laboratory. It caused you to call.

No, Arvin. Sheriff, I can't imagine where you get that idea.

Said he had no luck, and therefore he wanted to try your 12.

Yes, sir.

Excuse me, I caught a bad cold Sunday morning in the duck blind, and seemed to...

But the examination of the 16 gun just an hour after the death of Mr. Arvin proved it had not been recently fired.

What he actually said was, I never have any luck with a 16. And that's why he didn't even want to bother me.

And you claim he didn't seem to be quite relaxed and happy, having been to the lab.

No, nothing at all. Nothing about the problem or the product?

No, not at all.

Now, Sheriff, we seem to be going round and round with these witnesses. If you have got anything new to bring up, please do so. Otherwise, I shall have to ask the jury to leave and consider their verdict.

Now, this coroner's jury, have you reached your verdict?

Yes, Your Honor. It's due to the accidental murder of Mr. Arvin. Accidental discharge of a firearm.

Hi, Sheriff.

Hi. What'll you have?

How'd you like me yesterday? First time in me life I was ever on a jury. I mean, for a person, at that.

Harry.

Dr. Buck Rustin. We've been friends a long time, so a word to the wise. Later, starting to talk, they noticed it.

Were you actually out to get Paul Rutledge?

To get him? It sure did look that way.

Oh, I believe I had. It seemed you were trying to prove that Paul murdered Mel Arvin.

He did.

Nick. Look, I was the last one to see Mel Arvin alive, besides... Listen to me. And I may be wrong about the motive.

What motive?

Well, I figured it had something to do with the laboratory. The way I doped it out, Mel uncovered something that could only mean a disaster. Maybe, well, maybe Paul had to kill him.

Really going on, aren't you?

And suddenly, I saw the two of them in the courtroom.

The two of whom?

Paul and Rita Arvin.

And what about Paul?

Paul and Rita Arvin. They're a pair. A combination.

Come on, Nick.

Mary, look. I'm saying, Paul, you hear me out. What you have is a lot of fancy speculation. I know I'm right. I've caught every one of these people in a lie. You don't have one shred of proof.

Tell you what I heard Joe Soames say here last night at the bar.

Joe Soames?

Joe was saying, well, something like, Nick is too young to be Sharon. But I'm 41 years old.

He said that you're bored. There's no action here. So when something like this happens, you try to squeeze all the juice out of it you possibly can, even if there isn't any to begin with.

Why is it so clear to me and to nobody else?

Because nobody wants to believe Paul Rutledge could do anything wrong. You weren't born here. You're an outsider. I've lived here 20 years. You're still a stranger. The Rutledges are original settlers here. The Rutledges were always millionaires. But they always loved this place. They always helped the folks hereabouts. Nobody went hungry if the Rutledges knew about it. If some poor kid was smart, the Rutledges fixed it for him to go to college. And who do you think sent Doc to med school? Paul's father.

I know. I'm aware of all that.

And what about jobs? There's always a job at Rutledge Drug for anyone who's out of work.

But I only know I have a duty to perform.

Uh-oh.

People are blind when it comes to the faults of any Rutledge. Blind, deaf, and dumb.

Well, what am I supposed to do? Even if you're right. Even if Paul Rutledge did, as the lawyers say, willfully and with malice aforethought shoot and kill Melvin Arvin. He who wants to know about it.

Where are you going?

Over to see Doc. What for? Well, he's an officer of the law. I hope I can get a straight answer from him.

I don't know what this is. I can't shake it.

Has Doctor seen you last night?

No. He gave me a shot. If you ask me, I'm feeling worse. Well, see Doc. They told me that he'd be here.

He's on his way.

There I go.

Some question. Answer it. Quickly. You like.

They have decided on accidental death. But they didn't. Founders saw you together. Waiters, waitresses, or. I dare make no such evidence exist. Something exists. Going against you.

Look, I know how people here feel about you and the Rutledges. Succeeded in making yourself thoroughly unpopular.

That's not important.

People everywhere. You can't touch me, Dick. In the position of the evidence, no money. To completely destroy whatever evidence could bring me your book. Destroy only yourself. It has to be. I'll risk it. I'm not a killer by nature. I was in a situation where I was overwhelmed. I did what I had to do. I know I'll never do anything like it again. Whatever. Nothing exists.

You really believe that?

I may be a fool. Comfort. You see, I'm not well. I would like to get some rest. I'm sure you can let yourself out.

Bye, Dick.

Goodbye, Mr. Rutledge.

Sides, you could be wrong.

No, I don't think I'm wrong.

At the wrong time to bother him now. He's not feeling too good. He picked up this bad respiratory infection.

Let me answer the bell. Maybe he's asleep. No, he was just down here talking to me.

Yeah? Well, Nick, that window there is partly open. Do you think you could climb in and open the door?

He's just lying here on the floor.

I said, well, let me give you a shot. That's better. In fact, I said to myself, wow, that's sure some miracle drug.

What is?

What I call medicine. Alderon. Quicker than anything else, classically brings all the malefactors to book. So as you see, in this case, justice was served simply and quickly and most appropriately. Always get away with murder. And I don't let you get away until I've told you something else.

Right.

Prevent Child Abuse. Box, Chicago, Illinois.

His side effect.

And what is the side effect? In medicine, quite simple. You get a drug that has a beneficial and healing property, but after a while, you discover it also creates problems. As it is in medicine, so it is in every human relationship. Whatever you do, no matter how noble your intention, there's a side effect. It allows people to move freely, to live better. But it floats the air. You can't have everything.

Our cast included Mandel Kramer, Robert Dryden, Joe Silver, and Bryna Raeburn. The entire production was under the direction of Hyman Brown.

Our next take. And I would have to marry her?

Yes. Yes. That's the only exception. Yes. And thus described as a bringer together. It comes to my attention that certain people have certain needs and that certain others are in a position to satisfy those needs. All right. I then, as I said, simply for a fee. Yes, it's called a finder's fee. You would expect me to pay you? Mr. Fenris, I'm making it possible for you to become.

I'm inviting you to return to our mystery theater. Another adventure in the macabre. Until next time, pleasant.

End of transcriptBack to the beginning ↑