The written record
Read the transcript
Read along with the recording · About 31 min to read
The CBS Radio Mystery Theater presents... Welcome. I'm E.G. Marshall. Everyone has heard of the fabulous goose that laid the golden eggs. But trust Sir Arthur Conan Doyle to ring some changes on that story when he sends the world's favorite detective, Sherlock Holmes, on a wild goose chase.
Breckenridge, I was recommended to you by the landlord of the Alpha. He says that you have the finest geese in town.
Oh, yes. I sent him a couple dozen last week.
And I'd like to know where you got them.
And I shall take it in my life.
Who did you sell them to? What did you take for the geese? Questions about the geese will take you free.
Our mystery drama, The Adventure of the Blue Carbuncle, was adapted from the Sherlock Holmes classic, especially for the Mystery Theater, by Murray Burnett, and stars Kevin McCarthy. It is sponsored in part by ARM, Allergy Relief Medicine, and Buick Motor Division.
I'll be back shortly with Act One.
So many of the Sherlock Holmes stories begin in that famous flat at 221B Baker Street that we overlook one obvious fact. The address is so well known, we assume everyone knows exactly where Baker Street is. And somehow I think that's a mistake. For those of you who've never been in London, let me place Holmes's headquarters more exactly. Baker Street runs from Regent's Park to Hyde Park. At the southern end, near Marble Arch, is the site of the United States Embassy. And so halfway between Regent's Park and Hyde Park, we join Sherlock Holmes and Dr. Watson at 221 Baker Street.
And it wouldn't be amiss, a Merry Christmas.
The second morning after Christmas, 1893, I called upon my friend Sherlock Holmes with the notion of wishing him the compliments of the season. But I found him intently examining a very disreputable and seedy hard-felt hat. Seeing him thus occupied, I said, Oh, if you're engaged, I don't mean to interrupt you.
Oh, my dear Watson, I'm delighted to have a friend with whom I can discuss my results. The matter of this hat is perfectly trivial, but there are some points of interest.
I suppose it's the clue which will guide you to the perpetrator of some crime.
No, no crime. This trophy belongs to Peterson, the commissionaire of the club. You know him?
Oh, yes. Yes, of course. Is it his hat?
No, no, no, no. Peterson found it. The owner is unknown.
Oh. How did you get it?
I received it on Christmas morning in company with a good fat goose, which I have no doubt is roasting at this moment over Peterson's fire.
Well, what are you bothering with it at all for?
Come, come, Watson. Interested in even the smallest of problems, Peterson brought it and the goose to me under circumstances of my curiosity.
Well, you've certainly succeeded. It isn't whetting my appetite to know more. How did Peterson come by the hat and the goose?
Interestingly, he was returning home from a party about four o'clock Christmas morning. In front of him, he saw in the gaslight a tallish man walking with a slight stagger, carrying a white goose slung over his shoulder. As he reached the corner of Goodge Street and Tottenham Court Road, a row broke out between him and a gang of roughs.
Oh, dear. I see. In the fracas, he lost his hat.
Mm-hmm, yes. One of the rowdies knocked off his hat and whereupon, the man raised his stick to defend himself. But swinging it over his head, he smashed the shop window behind him.
Oh, dear me. An unfortunate way to celebrate Christmas.
There's more misfortune to follow. Peterson ran forward to protect the stranger from his assailants. But the man, espying a person in uniform rushing towards him, took to his heels and vanished.
Oh, and the goose?
Glad at the appearance of Peterson, so that he was left with the battle. Unimpeachable.
But surely he restored order.
My dear fellow, there lies the problem. The finding of this hat and thousands of Smiths, a few hundreds of Henry Smiths in this city of ours, restore lost property to the rightful one.
I see. What happened to the goose?
It didn't till this morning. Like frost, it should... I see. Therefore, it's now roasting on the hearth of the finder.
Didn't this Smith advertise?
No.
Oh. Then you have no way of establishing his identity.
Only as much as we can come to.
You must be joking. What in the world can you gather from this old... You know my methods? What can you gather yourself as to the individuality of the...
I took the tattered object in my hands and turned it over rather ruefully. All I could see was that it was a very ordinary black hat, much the worse for wear. The lining had been of red silk, but was much discolored. There was no maker's name.
I saw the initials.
There seemed to have been something... Some effort to hide the discolored patches by smearing them with ink. Then I handed it back, saying, I see nothing else.
On the contrary, Watson. You see everything, but you fail to draw inferences.
All right. Then you tell me what you can infer from that hat.
The man was fairly well-to-do within the last three years, although he has now fallen upon troubled days. It's foresight, but less now than formerly, pointing to a moral retrogression. Which, when added to the decline of his fortunes, seems to indicate some evil influence, probably drink. This may also account for the obvious fact...
I never heard such flights of fancy.
He has, however, retained some degree of self-respect. He's a sedentary man. In middle age, his hair has been cut in the last few days, and he uses lime cream.
Church, you must be joking.
Also, by the way, it's extremely improbable that his home is lighted by gas.
Oh, now, that's too much.
Sure. But I'll skip that. Let's go back to the deduction about his fortunes being in decline. Where do you see that?
This hat is three years old.
Oh, so you say.
These flat brims curled at the edge were fashionable then, but not since. It's a hat of the very best quality. Look at the band of ribbed silk and the excellent lining. If this man could afford to buy so expensive a hat three years ago, and afford none since, then assuredly he's gone down in the world.
Oh, yes, when you explain it. How about the foresight and the moral retrograde?
That's right, Watson. This little disc one showing a certain amount of foresight since he went out of his way to take this precaution against the wind. But the elastic's broken.
Precisely, Watson. And he hasn't troubled to replace it, although it's cheap and easy enough to have done. Therefore, he is less formerly.
I can't see that. Why isn't it that he just doesn't care?
Impossible. He's tried to conceal some of the stains on the hat by daubing them with ink, so he hasn't entirely lost his self-respect.
Well, I suppose you'd deduce that he's middle-aged, recently had his hair cut, and uses lime cream from an examination of some stray hairs found in the hat.
Good, Watson. If you use the lens on the lower lining, you'll find a number of hairs clean-cut by the scissors of the barber. The odor of lime cream and the hairs are... Yes, yes, fine. But the sedentary life...
The dust on the hat, Watson. Not the gritty, gray dust of the streets. It's to love him.
Upon your hat, I shall fear that you also have been unfortunate.
Why, what?
Why, he might be a bachelor.
Doc Watson, you forget. He was bringing the bird home as a peace offering to his wife. Remember the card on the bird's leg?
Fair enough. But you will admit that you were guessing when you said he was without gaslighting.
Not at all, not at all. One tallow stain on a hat, even two, may come about by chance. But when I see no less than five, I think there can be very little doubt that the individual must come into frequent contact with burning tallow. Can you not see him, Watson, walking upstairs at night after a drinking bout with his hat in one hand and a guttering candle in the other?
Well...
Come, my old friend. You must admit he never got tallow stains from a gas jet.
Well, Joe, you have an answer to everything. But all of this seems... To me, rather, a waste of energy.
The goose. Mr. Holmes, the goose. What of it? Has it returned to life and flapped off through the kitchen window?
See here, sir. See what my wife found in its crop.
By Jove, Peterson, that's treasure trove indeed. I suppose you know what you've got.
Diamonds.
Hmm, it's mortar stone.
It's the precious stone. By Jove, the Countess of Morcar's blue carbuncle, I've called.
Close eye, doctor. I see you've been reading the advertisements in the Times also.
Reward of... Of 1,000 pounds, and that's not within a twentieth of its market price.
1,000 pounds? I'd have to go right off to the police with it.
Mm-hmm. No, no. You leave the stone with me, and I'll see that you'll get the reward. Will I tell my wife? What did you tell her before you came here?
Well, that I was off to see you, and then to the boarding.
Tell her the truth. You wanted to go to the police. I was the one who wouldn't have it.
When Peterson left, Holmes took the magnificent blue carbuncle and packed it very carefully. And left Baker Street saying that he would return shortly. And if I cared to continue pursuing the answer to this puzzle, I should wait for him. Well, needless to say, I waited.
Who is it?
That's Lestrade.
Ah, Lestrade. Come in. It's been a long time since we've met. Where is Holmes?
Oh, I've no idea. He told me to wait for him. I expect him any moment.
Ah. Do you have some little problem? You think my friend can help you with it?
This time the shoe's on the other foot, Doctor. It's Mr. Holmes who has the problem.
Well, I don't understand.
Well, I'm afraid your friend Holmes has made a serious mistake.
Ah, there, Lestrade. I was expecting you.
There's no doubt you were. I'm here to inform you that I have a warrant for your arrest, Sherlock Holmes.
Unthinkable has happened. Sherlock Holmes under arrest. Now, we all know that Lestrade isn't the most brilliant officer at Scotland Yard. But he's honest. He also has a warrant. So it isn't Lestrade alone who believes Holmes is guilty of a crime. I'll continue with Act Two.
Even the best of us cherish small victories. Although Sir Arthur Conan Doyle doesn't mention it, I suspect that Lestrade, so often proved wrong by the astute Sherlock Holmes, must have felt a measure of satisfaction when he placed the brilliant detective under arrest.
And here Holmes is the charge. Being in possession of stolen property.
Are you?
I refer, of course, to the Countess of Morcar's...
Ah, so you admit it.
Nonsense. But how would you know what I was talking about unless... Because I know righteous women, Inspector.
Meaning Mrs. Peterson?
Now you'll admit that's where you got your information from, won't you? Nothing to be ashamed of. She's an honest, law-abiding citizen who... Who, as I foresaw, when her husband told her, I kept the stone and asked her not to inform the police.
Oh. Now here, read this note, which, as you will see, is upon the Countess of Morcar's own stationery.
Yes, I see. From Mr. Sherlock Holmes, Esquire, the blue carbuncle, which was stolen from my suite at the Hotel Cosmopolitan upon the 22nd of December. I have given Mr. Holmes my bank check for 1,000 pounds, made out to Mr. Peter Peterson, who was responsible for the finding of the gem. Signed, Helena Mercatus, Countess of Morcar.
So, Inspector, I am not in possession of any stolen property, but I've returned it to its rightful owner and will shortly deliver the money. I will deliver the reward to Peterson. Now, I want your word to keep this matter of the recovery of the carbuncle secret.
But why?
Because it's necessary that the man who stole it still believes that it's missing.
Oh, we have the thief.
I doubt that you have the right man.
Ah, so that's the way the wind blows. Again, you're going to fly in the face of the evidence.
The evidence being?
Now, it's clear, isn't it? This fellow John Plummer, he was working in the dressing room of the Countess, and he was soldering the second bar of the grate, which was loose. The attendant of the Cosmopolitan named James Ryder. Didn't he stay with him?
Well, for some time he did.
But then he was called. When he returned, open in a small Morocco casket they empty upon the dressing table, Ryder instantly gave the alarm. There was an arrested in. Found to have been convicted on a previous robbery charge and is now awaiting trial.
That's it. What makes you think we don't have the right man?
Several things. Can you tell me how the stone went from Horner into the crop of the goose, which Mrs. Peterson was cooking?
For a moment. No doubt we'll find that out when he confesses. But so far, he strongly protests his innocence.
That's right, Aldo. Another question which occurs to me is, how did Horner know exactly where the Countess kept it? To me, these are questions that his defense counsel might raise at his trial. But since I'm a police officer, I don't think I have to answer them.
Well, finding a link in the chain. Would you then agree to keep the recovery of the stone quiet?
The tool depends. It depends on whether you're all slight of fancy. I know for a fact that the stone was in the crop of a goose in the possession of Mrs. Peterson. I know that before it came into her possession, it was carried by Mr. Henry Smith. I'm supposed to locate this and find out what part he played.
If I agree, how do you intend to do that?
By the simplest means possible. An advertisement.
So it was agreed. Lestrade left. An advertisement was placed reading, found at the corner of Goodge Street, a goose and a black felt hat. Mr. Henry Smith can have same by applying at 6.30 this evening at 221B Baker Street.
Now, I did my professional rounds the next day, but was back at Holmes' flat at 6 o'clock. My friend was waiting for me, lounging on the sofa in a purple dressing gown, thoughtfully staring at a plump white goose, which was conspicuous on the sideboard. He waved at it and said, Isn't that a fine-looking bird, Watson? Ha! Ha! Makes my mouth water. But I presume we're not going to have the pleasure of eating it.
Correct. If we receive an answer to our advertisement, this bird will put us a lot farther along the trail to the answer we seek.
You think Horner innocent?
That's putting the shade too strongly. I'd rather say that the police have accepted all evidence at face value and made no effort to answer the questions I put to Lestrade here yesterday. However, Mrs. Hudson is preparing our dinner, which we shall have at 7, unless we're interrupted.
Before we could start dinner, there was a knock at the door. I opened it to admit a tall man in a Scotch bonnet with a coat buttoned up to his chin. Holmes rose from the sofa to greet him.
Ah, Mr. Henry Smith, I believe.
Oh, yes, that's my name.
Pray take this chair by the fire, Mr. Smith.
Oh, thank you, Mr. Holmes. It is Mr. Sherlock, isn't it?
Yes, and this is Dr. Watson.
Oh, no. Well, I don't mean to be impertinent, but I'm at a loss to understand how a man of your reputation comes to be involved in a matter concerning a goose and a hat.
This is your hat, sir.
Oh, yes, yes, thank you. But since you know my identity, you must also know my disposition for observation and oblige me by putting it on.
Oh, of course. Hmm, a perfect fit.
Well, sir, we've retained these things for you for some days because we were looking for you giving your address. Shillings aren't so plentiful with me as they once were. I believe that gang of roughs who assaulted me had made off with both my hat and the bird. I didn't care to spend more money in a hopeless attempt to recover them.
Quite so. Oh, by the way, about the bird, we were compelled to eat it.
Oh, to eat it? Yes, I'm sure that you and I kept it here for this length of time.
Oh, yes, yes, I can see that. However, would this other goose upon the sideboard, been perfectly fresh, be a suitable replacement for the one you lost?
Oh, that's very handsome of you, Mr. Holmes, and I'll be very happy with this bird.
Oh, one more thing. We still have the feathers, legs, and crop of your own bird if you wish to...
Oh, well, outside of serving as reminders of my adventure, I see no earthly use for them. So with your kind permission, I'll just take this excellent bird and be running along.
Oh, one moment, by the way. You see, I'm somewhat of a fowl fan. And I've seldom seen a better-grown goose than the one that you lost. Would you mind telling me where you bought it?
Oh, not at all. Now, few of us frequent the Alpha Inn near the museum. Well, this year, our good host started a goose club, the purpose of which was to see that all of us, by paying a few pence a week, would each receive a fine goose at Christmas. Well, the rest you know. And once again, gentlemen, my thanks.
The store had not long closed, on Mr. Smith, before Holmes turned to me and said...
It's quite certain our friend Smith knows nothing of the matter. Are you hungry, Watson?
No, not particularly.
Then I suggest that we turn our dinner into a late supper and follow up this clue while it's hot. Or perhaps we could even get a bite at the Alpha, whilst we chat with the landlord.
One glass of beer with the genial landlord of the Alpha elicited the information that he'd purchased Smith's goose along with the others, for the club, from a Covent Garden dealer named Breckenridge. When we reached his stall, he was about to put up the shutters for the night.
Good evening, Mr. Breckenridge. Cold night. You must have some reason to be out in it. I see you sold out of geese.
Oh, I've ordered tomorrow.
I'm afraid that won't do. They recommended to me. Where did you get them?
Out in Mr. And you'd better make it straight.
Straight enough. I should like to know who sold you the geese you supplied to the Alpha.
And I'm not... I'm not telling. Now, be off.
Why should you be so warm over a trifle?
If you were as good as I am, you'd be warm, too. When I pay, goodness will be an end. Every day, where are the geese? What would you take?
With other people who've been making inquiries. But I'm always willing to back my opinion on a matter of fowls, and I have a fiver on it that the bird I ate is a country bird. I have a four-inch town bred. It's nothing of the kind.
You think you know more about fowls?
Just be taking your money. But to teach you not to be up. Isn't it?
With a sovereign against you?
It'll be the sovereign now. Give me the books. The weather account ledger. And in the... Shilling sixpence. Alpha at twelve.
I might take a bet with a tradesman. Come on, Martin. You were fortunate that you managed to get him to wager with you, Holmes.
Not fortunate. Observant. When you see a man with whiskers of that cut, with a pink betting slip protruding from his pocket, the odds are all in your favor that he can be drawn by a bet. If I'd put one hundred pounds... One hundred pounds down before him, I'd never have gotten such complete information as he gave me because he thought he was getting the best.
Enough of you and your bets. Any more talk of bets and I'll set the dog on you. Come. Watson, come. Good. I didn't buy the bets. One of them with mine all the same. We'd like a word with you.
Come on, Watson. The fellow's taken to his heels. Chaperone's like a hare. He won't get away. It'll be worth your while to talk with us.
Tell the smasher that I can't give him what I ain't got.
We rhyme about the theft of the goose. It goes in part like this. John, John, the gray goose is gone. And the fox is strictly applicable in this Sherlock Holmes tale because we're not sure who the fox is. Nevertheless, we'll track him to his den.
No one's familiar with the phrase, your goose is cooked. In the adventure of the blue carbuncle, the king of the goose marked the beginning rather than the finish of a case. We pick up Sherlock Holmes and the faithful Watson hot on the trail of a man also interested in the whereabouts of the receptacle of famous blue carbuncle.
It's useless, Watson. We've lost him. Time to stop using our feet and start employing our brains.
I'm happy to know that, Holmes. Just to tell the truth, I'm not in the best of shape for running through the streets of London. What do we do?
Follow up two clues that have been given to us. The smasher is an infamous name in the London underworld. I have ways of reaching him and...
And Mrs. Oakshott?
No, not quite yet. I discovered where the goose was grown. I think we should set about...
I left my friend to go to my home but made an appointment to have dinner with him the following night. Much to my surprise, when I arrived, I found Inspector Lestrade of the yard sitting opposite Holmes. Lestrade had a long face.
Watson, the inspector's superiors at Scotland Yard are expressing some concern over the fact that they may look foolish if it turns out that they have once again a man.
They're much... Much more concerned over our rowdy disturbance at the Hotel Cosmopolitan this morning.
Hmm. What has that to do with me?
Now, cap off it, Mr. Holmes. I know what a marvel you are at disguises and I'll bet my last copper that you were one of those tough into a disgraceful brawl in front of the hotel...
Indeed, Inspector. And can you advance the reason why I should be involved in such a fracas?
Because you're still poking around about the Countess of Morcar's blue carbuncle. And convinced of Horner's innocence that I'll be able to marshal enough facts to render me some assistance.
Ah. You admit you need our help. What do we get out of it?
I think I can promise to save you and the yard some embarrassment in the matter of the man now in jail.
First, I'd like to know what you want from us.
Doesn't matter. Anything that will hold him overnight. Use the brawl at the Cosmopolitan. He wasn't there. But two of his boys were. And...
That's of no... No moment now. Should be out of the way tonight.
Why? Do you think this smasher took the carbuncle?
At the moment, what I do know is the smasher is involved. Tops be posted at the Cosmopolitan. And most of the people who stay at the Cosmopolitan might have had some other reason. The fight didn't start until they found out someone else was inquiring about Mr. James Ryder. Who, quite coincidentally, called in sick today. He was not at work.
Mightn't he have been really...
If my theory is correct, he is ill of fright. I think Mr. Ryder knows something that the smasher wants to know. And that knowledge is scaring him half to death.
After some grumbling and a promise from Holmes that the yard could release the smasher the first thing in the morning, Lestrade agreed. Holmes and I immediately set out for Ryder's lodgings, which weren't too far from Mrs. Oakshott's address in Brixton Lane. Ryder had a room tucked away at the top floor of a small house at the end of a mews. As we approached it, Holmes warned me...
Now, keep a sharp eye out for anyone loitering around the entrance, Watson.
Huh. You think the smasher has some of his men watching the house?
I think it's a distinct possibility. I'm not concerned about them watching. I just don't want them preventing us from entering. Follow my lead now.
I don't want you getting any wrong ideas now, mister. Sister's a very refined girl. Not the sort you can play tricks with. She's used to gentlemen. You understand?
You told me all that in the pub. But I don't have any wrong ideas. Oh, I'll behave in a proper fashion.
We weren't challenged as we entered, and whilst we were climbing the stairs, Holmes complimented me.
You did well out, Watson. Just enough to throw them off the scent if they had instructions to stop anyone who might be looking for Mr. James Ryder. Here we are. My name is Sherlock Holmes. Open up.
What do you want?
I can be of assistance to you in a matter that's troubling you.
What do you know about it?
I know everything.
What do you know about it? How do I know it isn't a trick to get me to open?
If you're interested in geese, order one goose, white, bar across its tail, which was sold to Mr. Windigate of the Alpha Inn and given by him to Mr. Henry Smith.
Oh, sir, you're the very man I've longed to meet. I can hardly tell you how interested I am in this matter.
Come in quickly. These elaborate precautions for your safety won't be necessary, Ryder. The smasher's in jail, and that's where you'll be very shortly. Unless you tell me the few things I need to know to make my case complete.
Oh, for Lord's sake, have mercy, sir. Don't have me thrown in jail. Think of my father. Think of my mother. Oh, please, sir, have mercy.
I am thinking of John Horner, the innocent man you put in the dock for a crime he didn't commit.
I'll leave the country. I won't give evidence against him, but then the charge will be dropped.
We shall see. I will tell you that I have almost every link in my hands and all the proofs a prosecutor would need. I'll be able to check you if you lie.
Oh, Mr.— You shall have it all.
Very well. Now, you decided to steal the stone. When and why?
Well, I... I wanted to get married. You see, Catherine Cusack and... Her ladyship's waiting, may I?
Oh, yes. Well, we... Well, I was mad for her, and she said the only way she'd have me was if we had a nest egg to set aside. Then she told me where the countess kept her gem, but I could see no way for us to get it and not be suspected. Until I heard about Horner.
Indeed, Ryder, there's the making of a very pretty villain in you. You learned that Horner, the plumber, had been mixed up in some such matter before. You laid your plan. You and your confederate created some small job in my lady's room, knowing that Horner should be sent for. He did the job, left, you rifled the jewel case, and had the poor soul arrested. This I know. The open question, and how did the smasher get into the picture. The truth now, for that's your only hope.
After Horner had been arrested, it seemed to me I'd best get away with the stone at once. For I was afraid the police might take it into their heads to search me and my room.
A pity they didn't.
Well, I wish it had never happened. Believe me, it was the first time, and I was really in a sweat. I left the hotel, as if on some errand, and went to my cousin's house. Now, she lived in Brixton, where she fattens geese. When I got there, she asked me what was wrong, because I was so pale and in a sweat, despite the cold. Well, I told her I'd been upset about the robbery in the hotel. Then I went into the backyard and smoked a pipe, and wondered what was the best thing to do.
And that was when you got the idea about the goose.
No, no, no, not at first. I was thinking about how to turn the stone into money. I knew I'd have to have help, and that's when I thought of the smasher, but I just couldn't face the idea of going out into the street again with the stone in my pocket. Well, I saw the geese waddling about, and I remembered my cousin had promised me to pick out her geese for a Christmas present.
Mm-hmm. Then it was then that you got the ingenious idea of secreting the stone in the goose.
Well, Mr. Holmes, I was sure I'd found the perfect hiding place. I drove one of the birds behind a little shed in the yard, cut it, and tried to pry open, and pushed the stone down its gullet as far as my fingers could reach. The bird gave a gulp, and I knew it had swallowed the stone, but the creature flapped and struggled, and out came my cousin to see what was the matter. As I turned to speak to her, the bird broke loose and fled off among the others.
Ah, so you were, so to speak, a gone goose.
Well, I didn't think so at the time. My cousin had picked out another bird for me, but I remembered the bird I had, a big white one with a barred tail, and I insisted that that was the one I wanted.
Had you kept your eye on it?
Well, as well as I could. My cousin was a little hot because I wouldn't take the bird they'd expressly fattened for me, but anyway, she told me to go ahead and take my bird and turned and went back into the house.
So you wasted no time, but slaughtered the bird, and then?
Well, then I slung it over my shoulder and went about getting to see the smasher. I'd heard of him about the hotel.
So you're the shrimp what's been asking for me, eh? All right, now.
Well, I, uh, I've got something I want to dispose of.
Yeah, something hot, eh?
I, well, I guess so. It's, well... You lifted something.
Well, yes, you might say.
I want to know how you heard about me. You know a man named Monley?
Course I do. He's doing five to ten in Pentonville. How do you know Monley?
Well, he's a... Well, he's a... Well, he's a... He used to work where I do. The Hotel Cosmopolitan.
Don't tell me you're the bloke that pinched that there buh-bunkle of the Countess.
I am.
Well, now, maybe there's more to you than meets the eye. You got it with you?
Yes.
Now, hold on a minute. You have to understand, this is... Well, I'm... I'm not really experienced at this sort of deal. How does it work?
Like clotted cream. Who gives you a whistle?
Well, 70 for me and 50 for you.
Well, that seems like an awful lot for you. I'm the one who's taken all the risks. Let me see the stone.
Right, yeah? In the goose?
Well, maybe there's more to you than appears on the surface.
Right, yeah. In the crop.
You trying to play me?
Well, it's got to be, yeah. I felt it go down. I know it did.
Stop messing about with that bird and tell me what you really did with the stone.
Well, it's been a mistake. I must have taken the wrong bird.
Oh, sorry. So there's been a mistake. I know the likes of you. You didn't like the split. So you think you're talking to Tindall. I never had a Tindall. I've got the wrong bird. I'll go back to my cousin to get the right one.
Give it to me straight. You run back to wherever you've got this bird and get the right one. But from now on, the boys will be watching you every blessed minute. I'll be back in half an hour.
You see? And when you got back to your cousin's, you got it, sir.
Well, I've been out of my mind trying to catch the bird and stay away from the smasher. Now, that's the whole story. Say, what's going to happen to me?
Well, if you do as I say, much less than you deserve.
Oh, sir, I'll do anything. Anything.
First, you will tell Catherine Cusack to hand in her notice to the Countess.
Oh, I will. I swear.
And then you will leave the country.
I will, but the smasher...
Will lose all interest in you when he discovers that you don't have the gem.
Oh, God bless you, sir. I swear that I'm—
No more words. No more words before I change my mind. Come, Watson. We have to keep our word with Lestrade.
After informing Lestrade that he could release the smasher and that the case against Horner would be quietly dropped when no witness would testify, Holmes and I were walking slowly back toward Baker Street. He must have read my thoughts because he said...
And don't be disturbed because you think I've compounded a felony by not handing Ryder over to the police.
Holmes! Hi— How did you know what I was thinking?
My dear friend, your face is an open book.
Oh, well... But look at it this way. We have saved an innocent man and perhaps also a soul. This Ryder is too frightened to go wrong again. And after all, Christmas, the season of forgiveness...
When you put it that way, I confess it makes me feel better. And since we pass White's on our way back, why don't we drop in for dinner? I have a ridiculous craving for roast goose.
It seems that Charles Dickens isn't the only English writer who wrote the Christmas—
Oh, I'll admit that Ebenezer Scrooge is better known than Sherlock Holmes for celebrating the spirit of Christmas. I'll be back shortly.
Arthur Conan Doyle wrote a number of stories which didn't involve Sherlock Holmes and one notable novel, The White Company. It's been a well-kept secret that he collaborated with Sir James Barrie of Peter Pan fame on an operetta. I wish, although I know it's in vain, that someday, someone would put it on so that we could see just what kind of librettist Doyle was. Our cast included Kevin McCarthy, Court Benson, William Griffis, and Lloyd Battista. The entire production was under the direction of Hyman Brown.
A preview of our next tale.
He's recently moved here from New York, hasn't adapted to the diplomatic way of doing things. Let's get this over with. Okay. Come in, Sergeant. I think I've got our first real lead. Yes. No, no, forget her. She's the scrupulous type. Drives 40 miles to return fountain pens. It's Lomas. I see. First, you want me to put a tail on Miss Reed and check Simpson's bank account, and now it's Lomas. I think he knew Simpson was going to shoot himself. The case is closed, Fritz. What? Sergeant, man... This is Barney Judd. He's from the Department of Defense. The Pentagon. So what gives? You mean you guys are taking over the investigation? There is no more investigation, Sergeant.
What you got to listen to me?
Radio Mystery Theater was sponsored in part by Contac, the 12-hour allergy capsule. This is E.G. Marshall inviting you to return to our Mystery Theater for another adventure in the macabre. Until next time, pleasant dreams.
