The written record
Read the transcript
Read along with the recording · About 24 min to read
The CBS Radio Mystery Theater presents E.G. Marshall.
My father, who had a great deal of wisdom, used to say that the friendship of the over-friendly is like a fire in the grate, exceedingly bright to look at, but not reliable, should you wish to keep warm on a really cold day. The tale we're about to unfold for you, written by the incomparable Edgar Allan Poe, is not about a friendship that could be described as despairing.
Kramer, Charlie. Let me understand what's keeping Horace this long in Boston. The girl thinks he never got there.
The Case of the Chateau Margot was adapted from a story by Edgar Allan Poe, especially for Mystery Theater by James Agate Jr. and Jackson Beck and Robert Dryden. It's sponsored in part by Buick Motor Division and Contact. I'll be back shortly.
If you've been taking notice of some of our 1977 Buicks, and if you've been thinking, wouldn't this summer be a great time to own one? It is. Announcing Buick's Open Door Policy. An open invitation to come in and inspect, examine, and really discover why the 1977 Buicks are selling better than any other Buicks in history. And to discover that this is a great time to buy a new Buick. Your Buick dealer is open to reasonable offers. Buick's Open Door Policy. At your Buick dealer.
When I was a little girl, just about your age, Sarah, Aunt Jane and Grandma and I spent hours going through the orchards getting the biggest, juiciest apples. Then Jane washed the apples while I unwrapped the Kraft caramels. And when Gramps got home, we all made caramel apples. Oh, they'd come out so gold and shiny, I couldn't wait to take a bite. You know, it just isn't autumn without them. Kraft caramels make the best caramels. The recipe's on specially marked bags, along with five sticks inside.
Doesn't it make you angry when something tragic occurs that might have been avoided? Well, birth defects are a tragedy that afflict over 250,000 infants every year in America. And the March of Dimes thinks it should make you angry. Angry enough to do something about it. Many of those birth defects might be prevented with good prenatal care. Prenatal care is the medical attention every pregnant woman needs to help safeguard her own good health and a newborn baby. It simply means seeing a doctor or going to a prenatal care clinic as soon as she thinks she may be pregnant. She ought to eat nutritious foods, get plenty of rest, exercise in moderation, and avoid unnecessary drugs and medicine. You can't guarantee a healthy baby. But prenatal care goes a long way toward protecting the unborn and the newborn. Give your anger some action. The March of Dimes for your baby's health by seeing a doctor early and often throughout your pregnancy.
Have you ever thought how dreary were there no one you could call a friend? Someone who thinks as you do, likes what you like, and even more than that, likes to spend time with you. With whom you could share any confidence, any time. Suppose it's no wonder that in the small, isolated New England town of Mystic Falls, a man was delighted when a man his own age moved next door and became Horace's friend. The time is 1910.
Let someone who actually lived through those curious and...
Edgar. My full name is Edgar. Edgar. I grew up with that awful handicap, but finally after years of kidding here in my hometown, Mystic Falls, Massachusetts, I'm going to settle for Edgar. Edgar, Ed, or Mr. Edgar. I write, print, and publish the Mystic Gazette, our local town newspaper. We've never missed a weekly appearance since my father started the Gazette 75 years ago.
One day, I had a visit from Noah Greeley, the town magistrate.
Have you heard the latest, Edgar?
About what, Noah?
Kramer.
Couldn't be. I saw him the day before yesterday.
Well, so did everyone else in Mystic Falls, but I haven't seen hide nor hair of him all day, yesterday or today.
Noah, if you think it news that the richest man in town has gone off somewhere by himself and told nobody where he was going, I can't print that.
Now, hold your horses, Ed. Looks like foul play.
Oh, please, now, you know old Horace doesn't have an enemy in the world.
He doesn't have a friend in the world, which is worse.
Well, you'll forget him, Charlie, now. I can't talk to you while that press is operating. I'll come back later.
No, no, no, stay. Stay, I'll stop this run. Tell me what you know.
All right. Day before yesterday, morning, Horace saddled up. Told his servants he was going to Boston for the day, and that he'd be back that night.
Fifteen miles.
Thirty. And sitting on this and doing nothing?
I only just got the news myself. You're the magistrate.
Hi, morning. Why didn't you tell somebody your master disappeared?
What did they say?
They told Charlie, they said. He told them, you can see who wants to... What Charlie said. Speak of the...
Good morning, good morning, good morning. How fortunate to find two of Mystic Falls' most prominent...
Morning, Charlie.
Two gentlemen cooking. Do you understand what is keeping Horace this long? You think he's still there?
Edgar and I think he never got there. It's possible he met with foul play.
I think you both... He wouldn't put up with ends from any highwayman.
I first met Charlie Nash six months ago. He pulled into town, not knowing a soul. In two weeks, he was on buddy-buddy terms with rich, retired Horace Kramer. Charlie never let a day pass but that he was there for dinner. No question Charlie was good company and the last time I had knocked on Horace's door, the two old codgers were carrying on like kids.
Hope I'm not intruding, Mr. Kramer.
Are you fellas celebrating something?
Shall we tell them?
Why not? Come on now, Charlie. Do you think our little jollification is worth a headline?
I'd rather be a headline than a footnote any day, wouldn't you?
Here's to it, Edgar. What brings you here? I understand your nephew, Philip, will be arriving soon and...
It was six months since this man, Charlie, and I met and it's his six-month anniversary. We're celebrating with some good wine.
I'd say so. Have a glass, Edgar. Chateau Margot.
No, thanks, Horace. I never drink while I'm working.
Well, you never work while... Even if you didn't, my boy, you could never be able to catch up with Charlie here. He downs this Chateau Margot like water. Does my heart good.
Yeah, Mr. Kramer...
No, no. Call me Horace, Eddie Edgar. You always have. I won't stay but a moment. I just want to verify...
You're more of a party pooper than your father was, Eddie, my boy. Come on now, have some wine.
No, no, no. Thanks, really. You know, Charlie, I knew this boy's father very well. Wilbur Edgar. Wilbur Edgar. He was a great parlor magician.
Ventriloquist.
Ah, yes. Wilbur Edgar was quite a practical joker. I mean, who else with the last name of Edgar would have given his son the identical first name? Edgar, Edgar. Well, the boy's father used imagination in the room of imagination. Edgar, let me tell you, when a man gets to be my age, all his old friends have either taken to their beds or died off. That pretty well leaves an older man friendless. Yeah, but I was fortunate. Along comes Charlie Nash here, drifting into town.
Correction, I never drift.
Yeah, moves in right next door, and I'll say his friendship has given me a brand new lease on life.
Horace, I can say in all sincerity, you have done...
Congratulations to the both of you. Charlie, you are by odds the heartiest old fellow I have come across in all my born days. And since you love to savor the wine in that fashion, I'll be darned if I don't have to make you a present of a great big box of that very same Chateau Margot. Now, don't say a word. It'll be coming your way one of these days when you least expect it.
Horace, can I say thank you?
What I did come to ask you, Horace, was about your nephew. I just got word over at Sam's General Store that your nephew is arriving. Arriving from Boston, he's going to be staying with you. It'd make a nice piece in our social column.
You mean Philip? I don't want to talk about him. He's a no-good, high-living son of my dear departed sister. And he's staying with me because he has no place else to go.
Horace, can you tell me a little about him, what he does, how old, and so on?
I said I don't wish to talk about him. I don't approve of him, nor his way of life, and I don't particularly want him here.
And that was the last time I saw Horace Kramer. His nephew, Philip, arrived in Mystic the following day. He seemed quiet enough. By talking with him or playing an occasional game of checkers over at Sam's General Store, I couldn't determine whether he was of bad character or dissipated habits. One day, Charlie Nash came in while Philip and I were playing.
I'd move the red.
Hey, Charlie, will you please go away? Philip and I are having a dandy game without your help.
Well, I just don't want to see you taking undue advantage.
What are you talking about? We're playing on a board with everything in sight. Now, just go sit down, Mr. Nash, and leave us be.
Now, if somebody's elder to Nash, I've seen your type before. And frankly, the way you're sponging off my...
Get the game, Philip.
Not yet, Noah, but I will. Horace's horse wandered into town with no saddle and no saddlebags. The chest looks like... to wonder if it can still walk. And as I said, everything's been taken from the animal's back.
I know Uncle Horace was carrying two saddlebags for Boston. I know that. Excuse me. But top of lard, my uncle has been robbed and probably killed, and you talk about hopeful.
Now, young man, I can...
It's no greater than...
Now, gentlemen, first things first. Let's go see this horse.
My point is, the wound on the horse could have been...
Explains Horace's dispirits. Well, three days later, you all... You said they were torn. I charge you to make an immediate search. I want you to organize a hunt for the body of my...
You take that... He's an old man.
Can I give you a hand, Charlie?
Yes.
Young man, knocked by his wealthy uncle, suddenly appears in town. Shortly thereafter, the uncle disappears. That the uncle may have been robbed. Charlie, who claims to be the uncle's best friend, is the young nephew. Does he know more than he is saying? We shall know either more or less, Edgar Allan Poe's story, when I return shortly with Fall Shopper Circular, and you'll have hundreds of bargains right at your fingertips. We're all to tell you, you'll find values like a Master Mechanic 25-foot tape measure. Our return for just $5.70 for purchase. Tape measure for just one penny. Do their one cent sale. Fall Shopper Circular from your True Value hardware store offers savings on items you'll be needing now. What ideas for fall and winter do-it-yourself needs. Mechanic flat-top toolbox for just $6.99. And a handy socket divider. Or get a 26-inch hand saw for just $5.95. The blade will give you years of service. These values... Fall Shopper Circular value hardware store's True Value. It's much more than just a name.
Did you know there are seven genetic diseases that affect primarily Ashkenazi Jewish people? Did you know that these recessive gene disorders could be transmitted through birth? Did you know that some of these could be prevented through counseling and testing? Did you know that the National Foundation for Jewish Genetic Diseases is dedicated to eradicating these devastating disorders through its nationwide educational program? To inform the public that these diseases do exist and attack without warning, an audio-visual film strip, The Tragic Legacy, is available for presentations to interested organizations from Foundation headquarters. Additionally, the Foundation will sponsor the first international symposium on genetic diseases among Ashkenazi Jews on December 12th through the 14th in New York City. For more information and a free brochure describing these diseases, write the National Foundation for Jewish Genetic Diseases, 608 5th Avenue, Suite 702, New York City, 10020.
Who was it who said, Murder, though it have no tongue, will speak with most miraculous organ? before today's mystery is solved?
We shall give you the answer, and you'll be no little surprised how much this saying applies to our tale by Edgar Allan.
To return to town, Magistrate Organized a Pratt Hall meeting. Not everyone agreed how to go about it.
"Order! To conduct this inquest in the proper way, Mr. Jim, not to have done it before. Mrs. Nephew, volunteered to lead a search party in, let us say, a five-mile radius."
"I see one hand. It's your hand, Ashwood. Care to..."
"The village green at two o'clock, that we can set off."
Charlie Nash. It turned out an excellent guide. The bunch of us, at least twenty, followed him through all kinds of out-of-the-way paths, finding places none of us knew existed. First day, we searched till it got dark, about six. Almost a week from morning till night. Not a trace of Horace Kramer. Until the day Charlie led us to a farm near Mystic Falls.
"Seen Philip Kramer?"
"Philip? Right back there."
"On the heel of each shoe?"
"Yes, I do. Uncle Horace's horse."
"Suggest we search these three trenches here, and the pond's running off pretty quickly. Isn't that something lying down there on the bottom?"
"Oh, you raised something. What is it?"
"Uh, down, down there. See if I can shift it with my shovel."
"Yep, I see it this way. The front could be blood."
"Yes, I think it is."
"Admittedly it may belong to Horace."
"Now, hold on. We don't know that it is blood."
"Precisely. Doesn't rule him out."
"Just a moment. We don't know for certain."
"He's planning to disinherit him. All we have to do is locate a will. And if indeed Philip is cut off without a penny..."
"Sense in all my life. I'm not giving up hope that Uncle Horace isn't still alive. Frankly, this search is too comic for me. Now, we've been traipsing through bramble, and all we've got to show for it is a muddy waistcoat."
"What's in your pocket?"
"This knife belongs..."
"Spanish knife, yours?"
"Yours. I see. Initials? Your knife."
"Knife is lying out here on the road. You want suspicion of the murder of your..."
"That is my waistcoat. I'd like attention."
"Huh?"
"I said that waistcoat was mine. I clearly remember tracks made by my uncle. The same ones I should have told us? At vicinity, and moreover, you now admit to carrying a rifle for the purpose of deerstalking. Isn't it?"
"Yep."
"And what do we have the pleasure of your company this evening? It's the shank, the very shank of the evening. I'd expect you to be out dancing, carousing, gambling, or whatever it is you're so noted for. What are you doing home?"
"You don't think much of me, Uncle, do you?"
"I ask more of you than a place to sleep. I'm dependent on you for the rest of my life."
"Well, then, I'm going to go. I'm going to go. I'm going to go. I'm going to go. I'm going to go. I'm going to go."
"I asked more of you than a place to sleep, I should have asked more of you than a place to sleep. But, you know, I always have to ask for your favour. Well, just in case you're harboring the hope that because you are my only living relative, Philip, let me assure you, I'm planning to revise my will and your name will not be mentioned in it."
"I'm sorry to hear that, Uncle."
"I bet you are! I've threatened such action before, but now, knowing you better, tomorrow I shall actually take steps. Yes, I must. Tomorrow morning, I'm off to Boston with two tasks. One, to make a cash deposit at the Farmers and Mechanics Bank. And two, to sign my new will. Now, if you'll be so good, kindly leave Charlie and me alone, so that we can continue our checkers game."
Philip Kramer, you just heard Charlie Nash here recount an event that happened the night before your uncle set off for Boston. Is this the truth or not?
"Is what the truth?"
"Did you know your uncle was going to Boston in the morning to deposit money? Did he tell you he was about to change his will to disinherit you?"
"Yes."
"Would you repeat your answer clearly, please?"
"Yes, Uncle Horace did say that. I still say I know nothing of his disappearance, and I did not kill him."
We must leave this tale of suspicion and mystery at this very moment. Does it strike you as strange that Philip Kramer, the only person suspected of having had a hand in his uncle's disappearance, seems so very self-assured? Is he feigning innocence? Hiding guilt? Or is someone else the actual guilty party? We'll be back with some of the answers.
Can your cold medicine fight the congestion, shrink the swollen membranes, help relieve the runny, sneezy, clogging misery caused by every known cold virus? Are you sure? Contac can. Today's Contac does all that... all that... all day, all night, no matter what cold virus attacks. That's the one thing. Contac. Keep your cold...
Announcing Buick's Open Door Policy. An open invitation to come in and inspect, examine, and really discover why the 1977 Buicks are selling better than any other Buicks in history. Take a look at the Electra, the ultimate Buick, with meaningful room for six and an interior that's pure Buick. Power steering, power brakes, power windows, all standard. And discover also that this is a great time to buy a new Buick. Your Buick dealer is open to reasonable offers. Buick's Open Door Policy at your Buick dealer.
This is Frank Sengalese. Leukemia, a disease of the blood-forming organs, afflicting adults as well as children, is no longer a hopeless disease. Life-sustaining responses through chemotherapy are occurring more frequently. Less than a decade ago, adults with acute leukemia had an average survival of only four months, with almost no one living three years or more. Today, leukemia may be referred to as a life-threatening disease rather than a terminal illness. These accomplishments in medical science have been made possible because concerned Americans have supported privately funded research as an adjunct to the efforts of the federal government. This willingness to help those whose finances have been drained proves without a doubt the need for an all-out effort. Together, we must try to solve the mystery of this disease before this decade is over. This message was brought to you by the National Leukemia Association, a non-profit voluntary agency dedicated to the proposition that tomorrow's children can ask, Daddy, what was leukemia?
Has Edgar Allan Poe taken us? Thus, evidence has been uncovered pointing in only one direction to a wasteful nephew now suspected of murder. But, knowing Edgar Allan Poe, I would caution you not to believe there is an easy, straightforward answer to the question of why many a twist and turn is completed.
When Philip Kramer admitted he knew the purpose of his uncle's trip to Boston, I really deputized me and the owner of the inn to make a search. When we returned to the town, Charlie was still there.
"Well, it didn't take you two very long."
"It's not a large room. We found this pocketbook empty in Philip's room. We recognized it right away. And these, uh, bedriff and stuff?"
"Uh, uh, look carefully. That may be blood on them."
"Well, I think we have an open-and-shut case here, don't you?"
"Well, I'm not defending Philip, but I do say a man is innocent till proved guilty. I mean, no, I..."
"You have no corpus delicti, no body."
"Horace's body yet, but I do have his horse's. Now that I got word Horace's horse died in the stable from the wound he'd got."
"Oh, if it weren't for the fact that my uncle is missing, I'd say the lot of you are behaving like incompetent bumpkins. Supposedly blood on it. Anyone could have put it there, smeared it with anything. Ketchup. Supposedly covered with my uncle's blood. Then sheets and shirts under my bed. You don't know if it's red paint. Well, I haven't the faintest idea. And if it were true, then why would I leave evidence lying around or under my own bed, you ask me? I'd say it's a... Mr. Nash, I've had a feeling about you all along. I've been wondering if you really are concerned about Uncle Horace. Helpfulness is an act."
"Are you gentlemen going to stand and see me maligned?"
"Custody on suspicion of murder. A lot of evidence, admittedly, is still unproven."
"Oh, go do your worst, my young city..."
The actual bullet that killed Horace's horse.
"Please lead us."
See now, this renowned checker player, wine drinker is also a horse doctor. Swiftly, Charlie Nash found the bullet in the horse's chest cavity, which had somehow escaped Dr. Corwin's eye. Philip identified the bullet, recognizing it as one of a special set he had made for his hunting rifle. At the very next criminal session, Philip was brought to trial. He still treated the matter lightly, not even seeking legal advice. Appointed a lawyer to defend. Confronted with this unbreakable chain of circumstantial evidence, the jury returned an immediate verdict of guilty in the first degree.
"In conformity with an order transmitted to our firm two months ago by Mr. Horace Kramer, I have the honor, this morning, to your address, of Chateau Margot's most obedient servants."
"It is news. Read what it is."
"We'll reach you by wagon the Monday following the receipt of this letter."
"I seem to remember that. Well, put in the weekend edition of the..."
"The news that I am extending an invitation."
And Chateau Margot arrives from the Millbracken people. The town was at Charlie's on Monday. There was lots of food and drink. The case of wine didn't arrive till early evening. By that time, everyone was in a very happy mood.
"That is the biggest wooden crate I've ever seen. Lift it right up. Wait a minute, I brought a big hammer, Charlie. Pry the box open."
Gordon is the center of all attention. This moment was his dream come true. A place surrounded by friends and neighbors. They were waiting for what Charlie would give them. Suddenly, top of the huge box flew open. And from inside, sprang up into a sitting position, facing Charlie, bloody, nearly putrid corpse of old dead Horace Kramer. He seemed to look right at Charlie with his sightless eyes. Then, suddenly...
"Charlie, could you do this to me?"
Having said that, the decaying corpse of Horace Kramer fell over the side of the crate. His arms sort of... Ben fainted. Some ran for the doors, magnetized.
"You're free. The body of your uncle was delivered to Charlie's house in a crate of wine. And he, your uncle, accused Charlie of killing him."
"What, what, what way?"
"Not so fast. Anyway, Charlie confessed."
"I'm afraid... I thought you might have, Edgar. You were the only one who believed the evidence. Philip wasn't guilty, but I was pretty sure Charlie wasn't that innocent."
"From the beginning?"
"Yeah. Don't you think it was strange, Noah, that it was always Charlie who discovered things?"
"Well, was I with my eyes closed? First of all, Philip was an outsider. Secondly, almost everyone in town liked Charlie, so why should you suspect him?"
"Just one step there, it was Charlie who found... Why didn't you tell me? We could have held up the trial."
"No, I couldn't stop you. Besides, I had to find the body. Remember how it was Charlie who led the search party?"
"Myself. And wherever he had gone, I went in the opposite direction."
"This was down there. Vincent..."
"Where do you get horrors to speak?"
"Talent I've had since I was a boy."
"Could you do this to me?"
This is one of the great horror stories from the prolific pen of that master of the macabre, Edgar Allan Poe. I think it is almost as though Poe took and dramatized that one famous sentence of William Shakespeare's...
"Will have no tongue, he'll speak."
...time on radio and television, and I'd like to put in a good word for the hobby that made broadcasting. You see, about 60 years ago, some early radio experimenters did our first stations. There are nearly a million amateurs standing ready to provide us with emergency communication in time of a disaster and still developing new electronic techniques. They have their own amateur television stations and even satellites circling the globe. On our trips overseas, my troupe and I kept amateur radio stations. You want to know how you can join in? Now that many people are discovering them by personal radio, maybe you'd like the really exciting and wonderful world of amateur radio. It takes study, but it's worth it. For free information, write to the American Radio Relay League, Newington, Connecticut, like they say, amateur radio.
It is said that Edgar Allan Poe is a modern detective, but I think he goes far beyond that, bringing together the strangely imaginative and the grotesque. A bloody knife, a book. On these few objects, Poe hangs an entire plot of villainy and bizarre retribution. Man has always been fascinated by writing about their criminal use. Detective work, studying and analyzing objects, but one doesn't have to be a scientist or a PhD.
Our cast included Robert Dryden, Jackson Beck, William Griffis, and Lloyd Battista. Our production was under the direction of Andrew Brown.
A preview of our next tale.
We had the compartment to ourselves, and a batch of newspapers Holmes had brought along with him. As we settled down for the journey, Holmes asked...
Have you heard anything about the case?
Well, I haven't seen a paper for some days.
That's just as well. The London press hasn't had very complete accounts, and that's why I brought these local papers along. I've already read through them, and I gather it's one of those simple cases which are so extremely difficult to prove.
Really? Isn't that paradoxical?
Of course, and profoundly true. Singularity is almost invariably a clue. The more commonplace a crime, the more difficult it is to bring home. In this instance, however, the police seem to have established a very serious case against the son of the murdered man.
Well, it is a murder then, huh?
According to our old friend Lestrade, it's not only murder, but he has the guilty man under lock and key.
Huh.
Radio Mystery Theatre was sponsored in part by True Value Hardware Stores, inviting you to return to our Mystery Theatre for another adventure in the macabre. Until next time, pleasant...
