Skip to content
On Air
All channelsAll
CBS Radio Mystery Theater artwork

From the CBS Radio Mystery Theater collection

The Child's Cat's Paw

Episode 649May 17, 197744 min 38 secTranscript

Writer: Himan Brown

The written record

Read the transcript

Read along with the recording · About 22 min to read

The CBS Radio Mystery Theater presents, Come In, Welcome, I'm E.G. Marshall. It was the noble Bassanio who asked a question in The Merchant of Venice, Tell me, where is fancy bred? Or in the heart, or in the head? Now in Bassanio's case, the question was rhetorical for a philosophy, because he really didn't expect an answer. But, a little late perhaps, here is at least one answer. Fancy is bred in both the head and heart of a bright little girl called Dinah.

She talks to herself, David.

Who doesn't, Cheryl?

Out loud?

Sometimes, like to an imaginary playmate.

Well, this isn't exactly the same. The playmate talks back in a different voice.

You've got to be kidding.

I only wish I were.

Our mystery drama, The Child's Cat Paw, was written especially for the Mystery Theater by E.G. Marshall. And stars Sarah Parker. It is sponsored in part by Buick Motor Division and Contact, the 12-hour cold capsule. I'll be back shortly with Act One.

Everyone suffers from claustrophobia, especially if the winter is severe enough to make moving about almost impossible. This is a story of one family cooped up by circumstance, by living conditions, and by the accident of an awful, severe winter. It's the story of a cat. Of a little girl with too much imagination. And of how dangerous dreams can be if we determine to make them come true for anyone but ourselves.

It's fun to be stuck way out in the country when there's no school.

On account of there isn't enough heat.

Awfully lonely.

How much do people talk?

She has time. Or taking care of Daddy.

Busy writing. And because he's sick.

Wish I could make him feel better.

Think about it.

Who's talking to someone?

Doesn't sound like a cat to me.

You're sure there's no one else in this room?

It's lonely, isn't it? Honey, I can't. Why don't you go on downstairs and keep Uncle Willie company? He looks like he could use some. Maybe a game of checkers. Not a team of Chinese checkers, though. So come on. Go wipe them off the map.

Not much of a name for a cat.

It is for this one.

Your what?

Read about in a book. About witches, goblins, and if you're a witch, you can have a familiar.

That's like a real friend.

And that mangy little cat is your bosom buddy?

Yes. And you aren't a witch. Oh, go on down. See your uncle and give him a few laughs.

Thought it would be all right to come in. I didn't hear the typewriter going.

Well, I'm up against a real block, Joan. You know, hazard to the profession, or whatever you call her.

Oh, no big deal. Just Dinah.

Well, what's she gotten herself into now?

Well, it isn't exactly what she's gotten herself into. More like what we have.

Meaning?

Darling, it's terribly simple. We wanted to flex some wings. You gave up teaching to write your novel, and I gave up a cushy job at the museum.

Check.

Not quite. We thought it all out. Brave new world. Hole up in the country and keep with Uncle Willie as our angel. Only we forgot one member of the family.

Dinah.

Dinah? Mm-hmm. Well, we both agreed that at least one year in country schools would be a happy change for us.

Sure, darling. Except, who knew winter was going to be there?

Yeah. This way. Who knew our love child was going to be so desperate she'd have to start inventing companionship of her own?

Hey, hey, hey. Wait a minute. It can't be that bad.

Well, it's okay for you. You sit here in your ivory tower away from it all.

Wait, wait, wait a minute. That was the deal, Joan. A year off for me, for the both of us. Now, you didn't know it was going to be tough. I mean, living on next to nothing. That's why we're buried in the country. Lord knows we can't afford to live anywhere else. Or even here, if it wasn't for Uncle Willie.

Hmm. Lousy thing to imagine that if he hadn't got sick, he couldn't have swung us.

Well, let's not bury ourselves in any martyr complexes, Dave. We were happy to have his financial help in exchange for, well, what do we really offer him? Three squares a day, a roof over his head, and Dinah.

Dinah. Yeah, that's a rather special gift. I just worry about him. I just worry about how much we're offering her.

Oh, Dinah can manage very well. Oh, she's a complicated little mechanism.

Darling, we did take her away from all her friends, and it's so remote out here, particularly with this awful winter and...

And what?

And... Oh, I know it's childish and ridiculous of me, but why did you have to find her that darn cat?

What about a cat?

Fanny.

Huh?

Fanny, the cat. Short for familiar.

Oh, that's her name? Oh, that's what Dinah dubbed him. It's whatever the scrawny thing is. It's kind of scary when you come right down to it.

What, the cat?

No, the cat is a cat, but the way Dinah feels about it.

How does she feel about it?

Well, you know what a familiar is. The alter ego of a witch.

What? You're suggesting that Dinah is a...

Oh, don't be ridiculous, but she read about it somewhere. You know how much she reads and how suggestible she is, and I swear she's got this notion that the cat is... Well, I thought I said it already. Her other self.

Oh, come on, Joan. What on earth would give you the idea that...

She talks to herself, Dave.

Who doesn't if you're alone enough?

Out loud?

Well, sometimes, like to an imaginary playmate.

Well, this isn't exactly the same. The playmate talks back in another voice.

You're kidding.

I wish I were.

What kind of voice?

As if it were a cat's voice.

You mean that stray cat I found her?

Maybe.

Well, it's crazy. We're all uptight. Gotta get used to the new life. But everything we decided was great for us. The problem is that child we made together. All together too long ago.

You make me feel like a fool.

I didn't mean to, except... Well, I am one. I should be thinking of her future instead of mine.

Well, could you spend just a little time with her?

Yes. Yeah, of course. Of course I'll spend time with her. But I don't know how to say it. I have a deadline for this novel. I have gambled everything to take a year off to finish it. All right, I'll admit it. I'm not much use to you, Joan, anyone. I'm soaked in this, in what I'm doing.

Oh, can't you handle the rest?

Of course I can, darling. I don't want you to worry anymore.

Yeah, but I do. Where's Dinah now?

Oh, I... I think she's with Uncle Willie.

You've questioned Uncle Willie?

What? Oh, yes, of course. Why not, child?

Sick? Now, Dinah, what kind of question is that? I was sick.

What is sick?

Well, it had to do with my lungs and...

Really? That's something I shouldn't talk with you about. Forget it. I'm fine now.

No more sniffles?

No more sniffles. She wasn't that sick at all.

Sad all the time.

Sad?

Yes, I... Yes, I am sad.

Because...

Well, I don't know. I... Well, now, I'm not that alone. Mother and father...

Sit, Uncle Willie.

...is my problem. I don't have someone of my very own. Simply because there's nobody who wants me. You won't have to have someone who wants him. It's a difficult trick. I just haven't been able to. And I wish you could.

Who'd want me?

Well, everyone.

Could you find me, child, in this god-forsaken world?

Well, I... I... I am nothing, dear. In this god-forsaken wilderness. Together...

You didn't call out for me?

Never mind, darling, you must have been having a bad dream. Now really? That cat in bed again... I think that's what's disturbing you. I'll take her away. I don't dislike you. Hungry-looking kitten? Maybe it's because you're more of an outcast than all of us. Oh, what's the matter with me? What harm could you... Possibly bring anyone?

Harm indeed.

...behind by some summering family... who were hard-hearted enough to abandon it when they left. Picked up by the Hastings family out of the kindness of their hearts and welcomed by a lonely child as their closest friend and confidant. What could the cat call familiar?

I'll return shortly with Act Two.

One has fantasy. We even, like Walter Mitty, act them out sometimes. It's an inexpensive, harmless enough pastime and may even be very good mental therapy. Except if we start to believe our fantasies. Then, sometimes, they can lead us into trouble. Like the trouble Dinah caused with nothing but the best of intentions.

Wake up everyone in the house?

Try to snuggle in?

I've got to do with another whole day. Any ideas about me thinking of them first? Which it is.

Uncle Willie?

Gloria to him. He got all sort of jumpy and red in the face. All for her.

What about the eggs?

I heard you're a long clock.

Oh, you forget there was no school. Maybe by Monday. It'll be warm enough to really go out.

Oh, I'm sorry, Pammy. Dinah, I didn't see her and she shouldn't be in the bed with you anyway.

In each other's arms?

While you were talking to yourself.

Oh, don't be silly. I just heard a mumble coming down the hall.

Dinah, try and ride with it, please. Give Daddy a chance to finish his book. Then we can move back again where there are more people.

Oh, it's all right. I'm really talking to myself.

All right, dear. Now, how about some breakfast?

Where are you planning to walk to?

Well, maybe I'd go down the edge, maybe. To Maggie Robert's house?

Oh, I don't know. With all this snow, it's a little far for you alone. Maybe he could. We'll ask him. And if that's where you're going, we could kill two birds with one stone.

What do you mean?

Well, we're almost out of bread. You can bring me back a couple of loaves.

What did you think I meant?

Nothing. Nothing. Dinah, are you up to something?

Oh, I'm morning. What could I be up to?

She is up to something, David. I know it.

Now, what could she be up to?

I don't know, David. She's just too darn smart for her own good. And maybe ours.

Come on, Joan. What are we doing to hurt her?

Well, we didn't set up the deep freeze this winter. And anyway, how long can it last? Now, all we need is a good warm spell to get us tracking again.

Oh, uh... Incidentally, where is our femme fatale?

Oh, she's off to Maggie Roberts to pick up some bread with Uncle Willie in tow.

Well, that should keep her out of trouble. Better than being at home and carrying on those eternal dialogues with that cat.

I don't like that cat.

You just don't like cats, period.

That isn't true.

Darling, have you ever taken a good look at that cat?

Well, sure. I'm the one who picked it up and brought it home from the woods. A smoke-gray cat with blue eyes.

Yep. That's what she is. You know there's a kind of legend around here about a cat like that.

The witch cat of Witcherly Corners?

Sure. That's how Dinah and me gave the cat its name.

Well, anyway, I don't have to worry about Dinah today. She has Uncle Willie to look out for.

Well, if I was a girl, I suppose I'd say because I never got asked.

But you're not a girl.

That's right. So then, I guess you'd have to say because I never got asked. I never found the right one to ask. But we've been down this road before, Dinah.

Not all the way.

What's that mean?

Recollect? Something like that?

Well, she's almost young enough to be my daughter.

She thinks you're awful cute.

She does?

We were just talking nonsense.

You did?

Fanny? Why you said that?

Not Fanny. Why would I be?

Well, it's just she's so young and sure of herself.

Well, I don't think this is something we should be discussing.

The bread isn't quite baked yet. I'm afraid you'll have to wait, Dinah.

All right. I hope Mr. Brown doesn't mind too much.

Oh, no, no, Mrs. Roberts. I'm like Dinah. No smell in the world like baking bread. I'd make you a cup of coffee, but I've got to get the dough ready for a new batch.

What's your sister today, Miss Roberts?

Gloria? Oh, most likely glued to TV.

We could just walk up to the house and say hello.

Hello? I don't want to bother Miss Roberts.

Maybe she'd like to be. But her sister said she was looking at TV. That means she must be bored.

It's quite a long way to the house. She might not even be there. I'll run ahead and see if she is.

What can I do for you?

I'm going up the hill there.

Very rich. That's nice. She doesn't want to say so.

Find the right girl.

He's rich?

Shida, I think we ought to be getting back.

The bread should be ready now, Miss Roberts.

I don't do that. Uh, Brown... Willie Brown. Oh, correct me if I'm wrong. Yes, and I, uh, noticed you. Don't know, I... You want some? I don't know how you can say that. Well, I mean, why would you? You noticed me? That's different. Young and... And vibrant. Glad I got the chance to kind of... Kind of get to know you.

Me too, uh, Miss Roberts.

Oh, come on. Calling you Willie like I know you all my life. Gloria. Some kind of a girl. Oh. Not as long as I'm around. Oh, but that's silly that you're so rich that... Now you've got your health back, you'll cut out, and I probably won't ever see you again.

Money isn't everything, Gloria, and, uh... Now that I've met you, I know... I can feed... I've got all my health back. Hey, listen. How'd you like to go to town tonight? Have dinner? See a movie?

So am I, Dinah. So am I. Otherwise, I just can't believe that... Why is it quite a bit farther? Than I expected. I wasn't thinking of you, Dinah, just myself. I... I never went so far in my life. Thanks to you. No, no, it's all right. Of course, we're all asleep, but... Mm-hmm. All right, you're a big boy. No, of course. Fine. Oh.

Your Uncle Willie went dining and dancing in town, and when he and Gloria Roberts were about to start back, he found his battery was dead. And they're going to have to stay in town overnight.

Overnight?

Halfway through it already. The difference. A little girl opens up life for an even lonelier and far older man. Uncle Willie has become involved with a woman whom he can have no sensible future. Was the influence led him there? A naive little girl? Smoky cat with the blue eyes who might, might not be a witch. I'll return with Act Three.

In our finite world, the atom, the source of... ...of its most devastating destruction. So, too, the most naive and innocent meddling in emotions can sow an equally minuscule seed of possible destruction. Not that, on their way home from town, Willie and Gloria are conscious of anything like that.

Willie, I'm a few too much. It's a dream. What is like that? I couldn't hold a princess in that old wagon I was driving.

Oh, you say the nicest thing.

Maybe he said the nicest thing yet. You going to marry me, Gloria? Oh, take me out of witchily coolness? Darn right. And anywhere you want to go, I can afford it.

All right, Willie. You're going to marry this bro... I mean, this, uh... You're going to marry Gloria?

That's right, David.

Oh, don't you think she's kind of... Well, I mean that you're sort of old. I mean, you really think it's going to work?

David, son, I'm a new man. And I just want you and Joan to know I've paid up the rent and I'll take care of the utilities. And everything just the way you planned.

Oh, no, Willie. You don't have to.

Well, it's the least I can do. After all, I owe my whole new future to your little girl, Dinah.

You're going to be married? You and Miss Maggie?

To Mr. Brown?

That's right.

But you don't love him.

What's the deal, Maggie? Tell him.

You want to know? That has nothing to do with...

Oh, sure. That has nothing to do with you wanting to spoil it for me. I don't care about you, Gloria. I don't care. I learned a long time ago you seem to be able to take care of yourself. I just don't want you to spoil it for him.

So, Mother, what are you going to do to stop me?

Nothing, I suppose. What can I do? Willie's coming with the ring money this morning. $500 so I can pick something real nice.

$2,500? Listen, kid, I've taken my lumps enough for men. Especially that Lonnie boy. I never thought I'd see the day when I wish he was around again.

What?

Because he's your type. You wanted to get away from the farm. That's the kind of riffraff you should have taken off with. Oh, you're no good, Gloria. Why don't you leave that poor nice man alone?

Do you? No, sir. Because you'll walk out on him the first chance you get. You're just looking for a chance to escape from here. All you want from him is his money.

Well, I couldn't get it in cash, so... I'll take you to the next bank. I think I'll walk up to the road to meet sweet William. I don't want him getting the wheels on his new car. I'll dirty it with the farmyard muck.

Uncle Willie, just a minute.

Yes? What is it, Joan?

Are you driving into town?

Yep.

I hate to ask you, but with the weather, she's been so housebound. Could you take Dinah with you?

Joan, dear, I'm sorry, not today. Gloria and I are going to buy an engagement ring.

Oh. Well, have a nice day.

Well, I expect to. Today's the beginning of a whole new life for me. Bye, Joan. Bye, Dinah.

I guess he didn't want to take...

No. He's taking his... He's taking Gloria.

What a mess. Willie and that... That girl. It's all wrong, and I don't know how to stop it. I just wish I knew who started it. He's making the worst mistake of his life.

Why, Mommy?

You think you should have someone to love?

Everyone should have someone to love, but... If Willie had to pick on one of the Roberts sisters, why couldn't he have picked on... Maggie?

Hey, Gloria, baby. You waiting for me?

Lonnie. I'm first. Not a picture. Here, I'm good.

Well, baby, things are uptight, so I split for a while. I never said I wouldn't be back.

No, but you sure didn't live up to no promises.

Had to build a safe, babe, so I tooled around, seen where it's at, so now I'm back.

Just passing through, huh?

Oh, no way. I'm here to pick you up.

Pick me up?

Sure. All you and me ever wanted was to... Split the scene, so now we can. Gee, and I made a couple of scores.

But, Lonnie, I...

Oh, come. Well, this guy I'm waiting for now, I mean, he's like he's older and all, but me and him, we... We're supposed to be married. He's bringing money today and...

Hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey. What's that got to do with me? Hey, you want to be my chick again, huh? You want to ride easy?

Lonnie... I'm just trying to get us back where we were, babe. You and me, you know. That is old character. Ditch him.

Hey, if you want me, Lonnie, I'll try to.

What is it? I have to tell him...

Why, hold up, huh? Hi, Precious. What are you doing? Waiting for me here up on the road.

Hey, she's not waiting, man. She just... Just happened to catch us before we cut out.

Cut out?

Yeah. Me and my chick.

Is he talking about you, Gloria?

Sorry, Willie.

What do you mean you're sorry? In any way. But we were going to get the engagement ring and...

Hey, wise up. Now, what are you trying to do? Rob the cradle, huh? You can't handle something like Gloria, so just bow quiet.

You'd take a bum like this over me, Gloria, old as I am? You're not saying, Willie...

Hey, hey, hey, let me handle this.

What's that? What's that, huh? You figure yourself you're better than me?

I know enough about you to know you're no good for her.

Oh, now, let's not mess around, man. I'm not going to let you abduct her.

Abduct? Oh, now there's a laugh.

This isn't... A laugh, any of it. I'll tell you I'd kill you before I... Back, back off, man. Willie, back... I'm going to let you have it now. You're not taking Gloria away from me.

Okay, buddy. Oh, listen. I'm sorry, Gloria, baby, but he asked for it.

He didn't. No, no, I'm just Lady Mama. Come on, come on, let's split.

And... Come around. You sure? I didn't hit him that hard. If we're going... Yeah? You want to stay to ride us for a while? He's got the cash right in his pocket.

Maggie, can you help me to get yourself up? I don't want to get up. Just want to sleep.

Come on, Miss. We didn't know where he was, but... What time is it?

Six o'clock. In the snow all night.

Oh, yes, I'll get my husband up and we'll get there as soon as we can.

It's Uncle Willie. He had an accident and lay all night in the snow. Maggie Roberts is sent for the doctor. Because his sweetheart, Gloria, took off with another man. And in trying to stop them, Willie got hurt. How do you like that, Dinah? What do you mean? Weren't you responsible for getting Uncle Willie and Gloria together?

Here's a little soup, Mr. Brown, to warm you up.

Smells good. Tastes good, too. That's the bread. Have to bake it every morning.

It's morning?

Yes.

I've been out... That long?

Almost a whole day. Gloria's gone, I suppose.

Yeah, she's gone. With the money?

What money? Oh, it doesn't matter.

Well, I suppose I should curl up and die, but... Well, nice to hear. You said the soup was marvelous, and, well, the bread always has been.

Oh, I'm glad you like it.

Maggie?

Yes?

You're a very beautiful woman. That is true. Oh, I think so. Then I want to be beautiful. Now, try it harder. I can't. Why didn't I ever see that before? It's really worth being sick for me to find out. I mean, with his life, he hadn't meddled. It's a message that I have won for you. Heaven's greater. Snow is melting. It's not going to allow you to talk back anymore. Fancy bread in the heart. I said in the beginning that it was in both the heart and the head of a... But perhaps I'll amend that a little at the end of it all. For Willie Brown and plain Maggie Roberts, it was in their hearts. And as for the active mind of a cooped-up little girl with spring on the way, her fantasies would no longer have to be acted out. He would be reliving the wonderful fantasy of just being young among her peers. I'll be back shortly.

As anyone might wonder, the planned wedding of Willie Brown did take place. With one major change. The bride was named Maggie. Instead of Gloria. The maid of honor was Dinah Hastings. A new and rather poised young lady who had somehow moved from child to reserved teenager. Who still retained enough freedom of soul to save one flower from the bridal bouquet she caught. To fasten in the collar of her dearly loved forgotten.

Our cast included Sarah Parker, Bryna Rayburn, E.V. Juster, Earl Hammond, and Guy Sorrell. The entire production was under the direction of...

Now, a preview of our next... Out of this, you and me are going to buy the whole future. For a lousy thousand dollars they're paying to take this crew? No. The little deal I set up when we hit Caracas. A deal that's going to put us on easy street. You're not setting up some kind of double cross. No, no, no, Howie. My brother Louie will get his chance to sneak into the States, thanks to us. But, just as long as we're playing outside the law, I'm... I'm going all the way. This is our chance to make a stake for the rest of our lives. How? Just do as I tell you, except for one thing. What's that? When the switch is made, you and Louie are going to exchange clothes. Also, sling bags. Just let me handle the bags. Why? Because, honey, you leave me alone and the future is ours.

Radio Mystery Theater was sponsored in part by ARM. Allergy Relief Medicine. This is E.G. Marshall inviting you to return to our Mystery Theater for another adventure in the macabre. Until next time, pleasant dreams.

End of transcriptBack to the beginning ↑