The written record
Read the transcript
Read along with the recording · About 27 min to read
G.G. Marshall. Welcome to a world where fears and suspense are the order. In cities and towns of North Africa, it's a common sight to see an old man sitting in the public square, surrounded by an admiring crowd who squat on their haunches as they listen to an age-old tale of courage, of romance, but above all, of mystery. Like that old man, the public teller of tales, I have a story. A story that takes place in our own country, which deals in matters that defy explanation. Matters which can be explained only from the tomb.
Who's shooting at us?
Don't ask questions while I reload.
Fire? At what?
Straight ahead of you, where the grave is moving.
What are we doing? What is it? You saw it this time, didn't you? You saw the movement, the blurry outline of a shape.
I saw movement, but nothing else.
There, you just had a look and you'd have seen it, I think.
What the devil are you talking about? You seen what?
You know, damned thing.
A mystery drama, The Damned Thing, was inspired by the celebrated American writer Ambrose Bierce. It was especially written for the Mystery Theater by Arnold Moss. It stars Robert Dryden and Joan Tompkins. It is sponsored in part by Buick Motor Division and Sign Off. The sign is medicine. I'll be back shortly with Act One.
By the light of a kerosene lamp placed at one end of a rough wooden table, a tall, gaunt man is reading something written in a book. The man reads silently as his fingers trace the words. As the man lifts the book toward the light, the shadows cast by the ledger throw half of the small room into darkness, obscuring the faces of seven men, sitting against the log walls of the little cabin. On the other side sit three people, two women and a man, an elderly Indian, all equally silent, equally motionless. Next to them is an empty chair. By extending an arm, any one of them can touch the man who is lying on the table, face upward, covered by a sheet, his arms at his side. The man, Hugh Morgan, is dead. The man with the book is the district coroner. They all seem to be waiting for someone to occupy the empty chair.
Finally, the tall man closes the book.
There are three things to determine at this inquest. The identity of the deceased, the time of death, and finally the mode of the departure, the manner in which his life came to an end. There's no question of identity. These have been positively confirmed as the remains of Hugh Morgan, famous scientific book writer and, until three years ago, a well-known professor at the state university. Upon resigning from the university, he came up here to our mountains with Mrs. Morgan to get away from city life, to get what he called closer to nature. He built this cabin pretty much with his own hands. Is that a fair statement, Mrs. Morgan?
That's correct, Mr. Bentley.
The time of death has been determined by medical examination as between thirty-six and forty-eight hours ago. We are now waiting for Mr. William Harker, the young newspaper fellow from San Francisco, former student of Professor Morgan. His testimony, we are led to believe, may be of the greatest importance in this determination. Until such time as he arrives, we shall proceed with the investigation. I first call on Mr. Harker. Mr. Harker? I call on the wife, the widow, of the demised. Mrs. Morgan, if you please?
Yes?
Can you kindly repeat to these gentlemen what you've already told me about how your late husband met his death?
My husband loved these mountains, second only to his work, his writing. He loved nothing more dearly than walking, hunting, fishing, in all seasons, all kinds of weather.
Oh, of course. Uh, tell us, please, about... Tell us, please, about the visits of young Mr. Harker.
Well, as you've already stated, Mr. Harker is a newspaper man, a former student, a protégé of Professor Morgan's. He had visited with us for a few days, five or six weeks ago.
You do not like Mr. Harker, do you, Mrs. Morgan?
No, I do not. I have my reasons.
Did anything unusual happen during Harker's first visit, five or six weeks ago?
No. Uh, except...
What?
The dog.
The dog?
The hunting dog, Sandy. Professor Morgan and Harker went hunting. Sandy was horribly mutilated by some other animal, and he died. I've never seen Harker so upset after all those things happened.
And Mr. Harker's second visit?
Three days ago. There was something he said he wanted to talk to my husband about. Something that had happened on that first visit. It had to do with money. I was in the kitchen. And I distinctly remember hearing my husband say...
But, Bill, a debt is a debt. And $5,000 is a lot of money.
I know that, Hugh. And if I can nail this story down, write it so it makes sense, so people will believe it, I'll get that $5,000 as a bonus. And I'll return it to you.
I hope so, Bill. It's been almost four years, and we need the money.
Trust me. Just help me get this story.
I don't know what you expect me to do. All we have to do is go back to where Sandy got hurt. It's one thing for a dog. I suppose, just, just suppose...
Stop worrying.
What makes you think you can write it so that the paper will take it?
With your help, I can do it.
Get your gun.
I've got it.
Is it loaded?
Of course.
All right, let's go.
And the two of them left the cabin, both with loaded guns. What time of the day was it, Mrs. Morgan?
It wasn't day. It was night. Night before last. Clear, bitterly cold. It was a shock. I remember looking out the window after them. They had been gone no more than five minutes. When I heard the strangest sound, it's hard to describe to you, and then almost immediately there was a scream. Two shots, one right after the other.
And then, Mrs. Morgan?
A few minutes later, young Harker burst into the cabin looking as if he'd seen a ghost. He could hardly speak. When he was able to catch his breath, he said, Mrs. Morgan, he was dead! Killed!
Who killed him, Mr. Harker?
I don't know. I was right there. And heaven help me, I don't...
Is it your feeling, Mrs. Morgan, that...
My husband was a big man, sir. A strong man. He played football at college. Wrestling team, too. The only thing he couldn't do was swim. But he was in perfect health. And Mr. Harker's a very slight young man. No match physically for my husband. Which leads you to believe...
To do away with Hugh, Harker needed his gun. In other words, you're convinced that the shot you heard...
Had to come from William Harker's hunting rifle. A double-barreled gun.
Harker's motive being?
To wipe out Hugh and his debt to him at the same time.
For the time being, I must ask these gentlemen of the jury to question what you're implying. You see, there is some doubt whether Mr. Harker, or anybody else, could possibly have shot your husband. Why is that?
Because the condition of the body is such that, at this time, we cannot tell whether or not it contains so much as a single bullet wound.
I call now on Miss Viola Mae Atwater.
Is that Atwater?
Call me Viola Mae. Like everyone else does.
Yes, yes, yes, yes, of course. Now, it's been previously established, Miss Viola Mae, that you worked here in the Morgan household?
Worked.
And your duties were?
Keeping the place clean. Doing some of the cooking. Especially when Mrs. Morgan wasn't feeling just right. Driving to town in the wagon for supplies.
Hmm. Professor Morgan was in love with you, wasn't he?
Well, I wouldn't exactly call it love, but we did get along quite well.
I'd like for you to tell us all how well.
I'm going to have Hugh's child. That's how well.
Thank you, Viola Mae. Now, you do understand why we're all here, don't you?
Well, I think so. This is not a trial. No one is being accused of anything. Yet. We're just trying to find out the truth. We just want to know what happened night before last.
I can tell you.
Please do.
Well, you know how it was between the professor and me. And for the longest time, he'd been telling me he was going to get rid of Mrs. Morgan. Some way. But now, she ain't such a fool. She didn't know what was going on.
Well, night before last, I was in the kitchen doing the supper dishes. I couldn't help hearing every word they said.
How much longer do you think I'm going to put up with this?
No one's asking you to put up with anything.
A man your age, a man of your reputation, having a sordid affair with a stupid, ignorant girl. Where's your pride?
That stupid, ignorant girl is something you never had.
That is pretty obvious, dear.
I'm talking about things like, like compassion. In her own simple way, she has a warmth and a tenderness that you've never shown in all the years of our marriage. She understands you, doesn't she? You poor, miserable...
And there's something else. Since you've started, Viola Mae is going to have my child.
I know.
I want that child to have my name. Simple as that.
Simple as that. Before I'd let you throw yourself away on a girl like that, and before I'd let you toss me aside like some old, worn-out shoe, I'd kill you first.
I'm sure you would.
Don't push me to where I'd have to prove it.
Excuse me, ma'am. This is done. Kitchen's in order. Is there anything else you'd like me to do before I turn in for the night?
That'll be all. Thank you.
Then I'll just say goodnight.
Well, Hugh, I'm going for a walk. Round the lake. If you like. After we get back, I can pay a visit to your little friend.
And they both went out together.
Now, what time of the night would you say it was when they left?
Nine-thirty, maybe. Ten at the latest.
What'd you do after they left?
Straighten things up a little more.
And then?
Well, they wasn't gone very long. Maybe, oh, maybe five minutes. Not more. When I heard a most peculiar sound, like nothing I'd ever heard before. Jackie described what it was like, and...
And then there was a scream that went right through...
Go ahead, follow me.
A minute or two later, Mrs. Morgan bust right into the cabin. She couldn't hardly talk. Finally, she said, Mr. Morgan is dead. Drowned. In the lake.
Mrs. Morgan told you herself that you, uh, Professor Morgan, couldn't swim. Now, I think you gentlemen can see for yourselves what happened. The first chance she got, she pushed him into the lake. At the part where it's real deep. Now, he struggled for a piece, and in the darkness of the night, finally gave up. And drowned.
I see. As I've explained before, Viola Mae, this inquest has been called because there's reason to believe that Hugh Morgan met his end through some kind of foul play.
Like I said.
Not quite like you said. Chances of Professor Morgan's death coming about as a result of drowning... is very slim. Medical examination of the body thus far shows that the lungs seem to be perfectly normal. No water in them. Not a drop.
Truth is a very strange thing. What seems real to one person is very often a lie to another. The fact, as one person sees it, becomes a fiction in the eye of his neighbor. What, then, is real? And at what point does imagination, for example, color reality? I'll return shortly with Act Two.
In an isolated cabin high in a deserted area of the mountains of Northern California, a corpse lies cold and rigid on a rough hand-hewn table. The dead man, science writer Hugh Morgan, has come to an unexplained and unnatural end. The district coroner and his jury... await the arrival of a man who may turn out to be the key witness in this death. Two other witnesses, the wife and the mistress of the dead man, have already testified. The coroner turns up the wick of the kerosene lamp, calls on a third witness, the elderly Indian, who has been sitting in stony silence, listening.
Joe Crowfoot?
Yes, sir.
You earn your living as a guide to hunting parties. Is that right?
Yes, sir. I know every stream, every trail, like the back of my hand.
Would you please repeat, for the benefit of these gentlemen, what you already told me? What happened night before last?
It was about 9:30. I'd put out the lamps and was just about to call it a day. Hunting party at five the next morning. I'd just gone out to the rear of my shack.
You said you loved me, Hugh. You said I was the only thing in this whole wide world that mattered to you.
That's true, Viola Mae.
Then what's all this talk you've given out to me about how the time ain't right for a divorce?
It would kill her. I may not love her, but at the same time, I wouldn't want to do anything to hurt her.
Ain't you the considerate one? You think nothing of hurting me.
Look out for that snake. Quick, get back on the path.
Oh, that was close.
I couldn't see it.
Well, how could you? Here, let's sit down on this stump for a minute. Heaven's sake, keep your voice down. Joe's asleep, and we don't want to wake him.
You've got a responsibility, Hugh. I'm going to be mother to your child.
So you say.
What makes you so sure it's mine? Who is in fact that thing behind yours?
I told you to keep your voice down.
I'll tell the whole world what a dirty old man you really are.
You little fool. I hope you get bit. You deserve it.
Snake, it's there. I can see it. But don't move. The lie here is quietly... It's lifting its head, but...
What makes you think Joe would help you? Give him up yourself, lover boy. In no time at all.
I had him in my shack. Did everything I knew to kill the poison the snake had shot into his body. But...
Yes, Joe?
I guess I was... I guess I was too late.
A very short time.
Professor Morgan. And it is your testimony that he was pushed by the young lady, the girl called LeMay, into the spot, the area where she knew there was a rattlesnake?
Yes, sir.
That's very interesting, Mr. Crawfoot.
Why do you say that?
A medical examination. As far as we can determine, not a trace of the snake's poison is in the bloodstream. Not a trace.
Mr. Bentley, I got here as fast as I could.
You young man are...
I'm William Parker of the San Francisco Press. Forgive me if I've held things up.
Oh, delighted to see you, Mr. Harker. I left the minute I got your call. This is not the easiest place to get to.
I won't finish this business tonight.
Well, I think you should know that when I left here early yesterday morning, it was not to evade your summons.
No?
No, it was to get the story to my paper. The story of Hugh Morgan's death.
Now, Mr. Harker, we've heard three different versions tonight of how Hugh Morgan met his death. And none of them has yet been substantiated by the fact of the medical examination of the body. Now, have we any reason to expect that the account you posted to your newspaper, Mr. Harker, would be anything like the story you will give here?
That's up to you, sir. I've made a carbon copy of what I wrote for my paper. You're welcome to see it.
It's incredible. More incredible than pure fiction. But it is the truth. I'll swear to it.
That will resume the inquiry. Doctor, are you going to be seated?
Now, you knew the deceased Hugh Morgan?
Yes.
How well?
He was my professor at the university. He taught me everything I knew about writing. More than that. He was the closest friend I had.
And you were with him when he died?
I was with him when he died.
How did that happen? You being here, I mean.
Well, I came up three days ago to shoot and fish. Part of my purpose, however, was to follow up on the story of the dog, Sandy. You see, I had been here five weeks earlier. On a purely friendly visit to your old teacher?
Well, on that occasion, we went out hunting. As we'd usually done on previous visits. It was still dark. The sun had not yet risen when we left the cabin.
Sandy! Sandy! Here, boy!
Have you any idea where that silly dog went?
Well, he was here a minute ago, Hugh. Funniest thing, he just disappeared.
In the meantime, we'll have to do without him. Well, now, let's see if we're as good as he is in raising some quail. What's our best ground?
Uh, beyond that ridge, I'd say. We'll have to go through the chaparral to get to it. It's a pretty level ground. Thickly covered with grain. Uh, let's go, Bill.
I think we've startled a deer.
Oh, I wish we'd brought a rifle instead of just shotguns.
Shh! Be very quiet.
What are you doing, Hugh? You're not going to fill up a deer with quail shot, are you?
Is anything wrong? Hugh, have we jumped a grizzly?
Cock your gun, Bill.
Well, now what?
And your mouth shut.
And that's exactly what I did.
What happened next?
A minute or two went by. Suddenly, there was this weird sound that seemed to come from out of nowhere. It grew louder and louder. It got to the point where I had to put my hands over my ears to shut out the sound. It was so shattering, and then it stopped, suddenly, as it had started.
And what did you see, Mr. Harker?
Well, up until then, the bushes had been deathly still. It was too early for birds. Not a bit of movement of any kind. I turned to Professor Morgan and was about to speak when the field of wild oats we'd been watching began to move in the most curious way. It seemed as if the oats were being stirred up by a streak of wind, which, well, not only bent it, but pressed it down, crushed it, so that it didn't rise, as if some huge, invisible, what can I call it, presence was moving slowly along through the oats, stepping on it with giant feet. And this movement, foot by foot, was prolonging itself directly toward us.
What was your feeling, Mr. Harker, as you were watching this strange occurrence?
Oh, I must confess that I lay there in the chaparral, right beside Professor Morgan, watching this fantastic phenomenon. This thing happened, and I was not afraid.
Was this equally true of your companion?
No. He was terrified.
What are you doing, Hugh? What are you shooting at?
Don't ask questions. Just fire while I reload.
Fire? I'm straight ahead of you.
The grain is moving.
Well, if you say so.
What are we doing? Oh, no. That poor, poor Sandy. Just look at him. As if he'd run into the blades of a... of a threshing machine.
But what did it? I didn't see anything.
Well, you saw the movement, didn't you? And a sort of... a sort of blurry outline of a shape?
I saw the movement. Nothing else.
Well, where are your eyes, Bill? It was there to see. You just had a look, and you'd have seen it, I think.
What the devil are you talking about, Hugh? Seen what?
The thing! What I call it. The damned thing. First, it did away with my chickens, and then... the pigs, and the cattle. And now, poor Sandy. And that's not the end. Only the good Lord knows what the damned thing will destroy next.
Is it possible that there is a grain of truth in the incredible story Harker has just told? And can Hugh Morgan's fear of a shapeless, sinister force... of a thing that seems to challenge all reason and logic... be justified? We'll find out when I return shortly. With Act Three.
From the blank darkness outside the cabin... come the familiar noises of night in the wilderness. The long, nameless note of a distant coyote. And all that mysterious chorus of sounds that seem always to have been but half heard... when they suddenly cease. But none of the company present seems to be aware of anything other than the corpse on the table before them.
Please, continue, Mr. Harker.
Well, that's about it. Uh, we buried the dog and went back to the cabin. And never said another word to each other about what had happened that morning.
You stayed on for a while?
No, sir. I returned to San Francisco the next day.
Then, five, six weeks later, three days ago, you came back here. Why?
To fill in some of the blanks. There were too many unexplained things.
Tell us what happened.
And not far off. I think Hugh had a pretty good idea of why I had come back so soon after the episode with the dog. It was he himself who suggested that we go out. To hunt whatever might be around.
I think our best chances are this way.
But, Hugh, isn't that the same ridge where Sandy...
Of course it is, of course. See that your gun is loaded.
It's loaded.
Good. Keep your eyes and ears open. We've got a full moon and visibility is real good. Now, if anything...
Nothing.
Well, just be very careful. It comes up on you out of nowhere. It gives you no warning.
Don't load both barrels.
And here's mine.
Anything.
I was thrown violently to the ground by the impact of something unseen in the haze. Something soft and heavy hurled itself against me with great force. Before I could get back to my feet, I heard Morgan crying out in mortal agony. I don't know that. Mingling. Mingling with his cries. His eyes were hoarse, savage sounds. Like from the throats of mad dogs fighting each other to the death. Snarling and growling. This time I was terrified. I struggled to my feet. I looked for Professor Morgan and... And may heaven and mercy spare me from another sight like that.
Not easy, Mr. Harker.
Twenty yards away, my friend was down on one knee. His head thrown back at a... terrifying angle. His hat was gone. His long hair was in disorder. His whole body was convulsed with violent movements from one side to the other. Backward and forward. His... His right arm. And at least I could see none. The other arm was completely invisible. Morgan seemed like a... Of some kind. Determined and yet overcome. Beaten by a force of... A superior weight. Greater strength. And all this time, all you saw was Morgan?
Yes. Nothing else? Nobody else?
No, just him. And then, not always distinctly. And throughout the whole thing, such sounds of rage and fury as I have never heard in my life. From man or beast.
Now, what, if anything, did you do to help your friend?
Well, I ran. I ran toward him. I had a funny kind of feeling that... Well, that he was suffering from a fit or from some kind of convulsion. I looked up. And by the light of the moon, I could see as... As I had weeks before. The same mysterious movement of the wild oats. Retreating. Rolling itself back from the place where Hugh lay. Toward the edge of the woods. When I got there, I... I looked down at my friend. And he was... Lying on his back. Absolutely still and quiet. He was dead.
Gentlemen, you have now heard four different accounts from four different witnesses. Now, finally, there is the version of death in some mysterious manner. That Morgan was killed by an unknown force or creature of some kind. Which Morgan called the damned thing.
Mr. Bentley?
There are two things more. I would like to bring to your attention.
Yes, Mr. Harker?
First, that book you placed under the table. I recognize it as Professor Morgan's diary. You seem greatly interested in it. In fact, you were reading it while I was testifying. May I see it? I'm sure it would throw a great deal of light on Morgan's death.
The book will cut no figure in this matter, Mr. Harker. All the entries in it were made before Hugh Morgan's death.
That's ridiculous.
Now... Now, you said there's something else you'd like to bring to our attention before a verdict is rendered?
Well, there's one substantial bit of evidence which has not yet been revealed.
Yes, Mr. Harker?
The body of Morgan. I demand that you uncover the body right now. So that we can all see whether or not I was telling the truth.
I will be happy to meet with your request, Mr. Harker. Thank you, sir. Gentlemen of the jury. The body of... Of Hugh Morgan. Now, it may be difficult to see details in this light. I read from the medical report, gentlemen. The body of the demise is covered with broad maculations of bluish black caused by extravasated contusions. That's those big black and blue marks here and here and over here. The chest and sides appear to have been beaten with some heavy weapon. Such as a bludgeon. I call your attention to these huge tears in the flesh. Where the skin has been ripped in shreds and little strips.
Might we know why there's that silk handkerchief passing under the chin and knotted on top of the head?
You may indeed. I'll remove it. And I think you'll see why it's there.
If it weren't there... Oh! Oh! Oh! Oh! Oh! Oh! Oh! Oh! Oh! Oh! Oh! Oh! Oh! Oh! Oh! Oh! Oh! Oh! Oh! Oh! Oh! Oh! Oh! Oh! Oh! Oh! Oh! Oh! Oh! Oh! Oh! Oh! Oh! Oh! Oh! Oh! Oh! Oh! Oh! Oh! Oh!
What was once the neck and throat have, as you can see, been chewed away. May it satisfy you, Mr. Harker?
Thank you very much. Now I will ask the jury to adjourn for its verdict.
And let the remains of professionals come to their deaths at the hands of a mountain lion. You can't mean that!
Just the same, there it is. Just the same, there it is. All of us thinks that the remains was subject to a simple case of fits.
Oh, Mr. Harker, can't say I'm surprised to see you. To what does my humble office owe the honor of your visit?
I, uh, can't accept the verdict your jury gave last night.
Well, unfortunately, there ain't much you can do about it.
I think there is, sir. I can establish the truth about Hugh Morgan's death.
And how exactly are you supposed to do that, Mr. Harker?
Take a look at this.
What is it?
A reel of tape and a recording machine. Months ago, I asked Hugh to make a day-by-day recording of whatever he saw, whatever he experienced in connection with this phenomenon. Would you like to hear it, Mr. Coroner?
Uh, yes. Yes, of course. This might just possibly make you change your mind. Listen. Listen carefully.
You recognize that as Professor Morgan's voice?
Yes, I do.
He kept barking fuel.
The next entry is a few weeks later. Like I said. Shh. Just... You heard. Days here with me, he has. He acts, whether or not he...
Turn it off. I've heard all I intend to hear.
Not yet, sir. We're coming to the most important part of the whole thing. Just listen.
Too high in pitch. Mr. Harker. Listen, please. With sounds. Must be. So it is. By things that are not visible. Are all of them rulers? They're ruled by the same phenomena that govern sounds. At one end of the solar spectrum, there are infrared waves and ultraviolet waves at the other. The eye can only see a few octaves of this huge band between the infrared and ultraviolet. I was there. What happened?
Mr. Harker, you play this tape for anybody, and they'll swear that Professor Morgan was as crazy as a loon. I don't think you'd want that, would you? What are you going to do?
Now, please have that reel tape. I love the truth as well as the next fella. The world needs the truth. But there are times when the world has an even greater need for what is not true. For the untruth that may offer something like consolation, compassion, or hope. And so, Mr. Harker, with your permission, I think destroying this—well, is not a good thing. This tape is the best thing we could possibly do.
As the last foot of tape turned into ashes, the skies opened up, and it began to rain. And the mutilated body of Hugh Morgan rested quietly where it was. They say, blessed is the bride the sun shines on, blessed is the corpse the rain falls on. Who knows?
I'll be back in a moment.
An interesting footnote on Ambrose. Ambrose Bierce, the American writer on whose story, The Damned Thing, our tale was based. In 1913, he left his work, disappeared into Mexico, and every trace of him was lost forever. Never heard from again. Is it just possible that he, like Hugh Morgan, met his end at the hands of some damned thing? Who knows?
Our cast included Arnold Moss, Robert Dryden, Joan Tompkins, E.V. Juster, and Bob Kaliban. The entire production was under the direction of Hyman Brown.
And now, a preview of our next tale.
Even tricks go wrong.
Yeah, they do. Did anything like that ever happen to your husband?
Well, yeah, once. He couldn't open the lock on his handcuffs. You see, he had a key hidden in the cuff of his trousers, but it slipped out of his hand and fell between the cracks of the floorboard. He... He wasn't hurt or anything. It was just a wicker basket escape on stage.
I see. But if anything like that happened now, I mean, at the bottom of a lake...
Well, that would be terrible. It would be awful.
Yeah. It would be really tragic. I... I don't want to think about any such thing. I... I just don't want to think about it.
No, no, no, of course not. At least we won't think about it.
Radio Mystery Theater was sponsored in part by Anheuser-Busch Incorporated, Brewers of Budweiser. This is E.G. Marshall inviting you to return to our Mystery Theater for another adventure in the macabre. Until next time, pleasant dreams.
