The written record
Read the transcript
Read along with the recording · About 28 min to read
the cbs radio mystery theater presents welcome i'm e.g marshall and everything's in order in its proper place neatly sorted and labeled all the items of suspense mystery terror and the macabre it only remains to mix and brew of all sad words of tongue and pen the saddest are these it might have been it might have been what might have been could we but recall that hasty word that heedless act yes indeed had we but known then what we know now how different things would be today or at least that's what we like to tell ourselves but would things really be different
my boy you take an unnecessarily dim view
do you realize i'm going to hang tomorrow morning
perhaps
perhaps not
what do you mean perhaps not
tomorrow we'll come and go and you will still be alive
how
you will not be here in this place
how am i going to get out
leave that to me
look around you guards doors locks how could i possibly get out
they will all disappear
what are you talking about
look what happened
our mystery drama the garrison of the dead was written especially for the mystery theater by sam dan and stars mandel kramer it is sponsored in part by buick motor division i'll be back shortly with act one
the word is alibi from the latin alias ibi which means to be somewhere else which is precisely the idea of the thing no if you are required to commit a murder in one place you must make sure you can commit a murder if you were someplace else at that exact time this point is so elementary so simple one might consider it too obvious to be worthy of mention perhaps but the executioners have been kept busy and the prisons full by those forgetful folk who neglected the basics and no one is more aware of this than andrew macefield tonight it will be necessary for andrew macefield to murder jerome carlson
it is a serious and most dangerous crime
it is a serious and most dangerous crime
it is a serious and most dangerous crime
andrew would rather not do it but we live in a world where a man does what he must
hello jerry
andy macefield but you were in jail
with the comedy jerry you knew i was out on bail
you're gonna ask me to come in
no jerry i've got to talk to you
whatever you and i would have to talk about has already been said
jerry you got to give me a break
i know all your stories by heart and try to understand and remember if sinners entice thee consent thou not
down the road you're going to have to understand and remember if sinners entice thee consent thou not
down the road you're going to have to
what's this you you dare to quote the bible
sure i dare after all the bible was written more for me than it was for you
okay get over this you're gonna make me stand outside
behold there has risen a new andrew macefield from the ashes of the old
ah by yourself spoken with your usual flair for the redundant andrew
well what revelations have you to share with me jerry
jerry do you want me to go to jail for ten years
actually i would want you to go to jail for life and pay a half million dollars in fines that money never belonged to you
jerry i'll give you half that's your cut to keep your mouth shut
so it really isn't a new andy macefield
a quarter of a million jerry how many magazine stories do you have to write before you can see a quarter of a million
i'm sorry
jerry give me a break
i trusted you jerry i helped you you came to me you said you wanted to do an article on how a real estate development is put together
i did
because i thought we'd become friends i told you things well off the record and now you're going to go to court tomorrow morning and you're going to testify
that's right andy
well doesn't friendship impose a certain obligation
there's a higher obligation
to what
to the law
look what i told you was strictly on the qt jerry and why to let you win on a good thing give you a chance to make some money
you mean give me a chance to break the law
oh law what's so holy about the law people break the law every day didn't you break the law a couple of years ago when you wrote an article telling young guys how to avoid military service
that was a matter of conscience
what you really mean is it's all a matter of personal taste
perhaps but my taste doesn't run to swindling poor ignorant people out of their life's savings
grow up jerry these are suckers who were born to be taken
we've been through all this andy
i guess we have so you're going to walk into that courtroom tomorrow and explain to the jury just how i separated those suckers from their dough
i think it's time we said goodbye
yes it is
waste than one
you're crazy to point that gun at me
crazy this is the only thing that makes any sense i offered you money no dice i tried to appeal to your friendship no good so now i have to kill you
you can't get away with it
why not everybody knows you'd stop at nothing to prevent me from testifying you threaten me in public you're the only one with a motive
threats motives they won't matter i'm going to have an alibi
how could you hope to prove that you
a guy like me never hopes he plans
now on my watch i've got exactly 9 57 the coroner is going to fix the time of your death at exactly 10 p.m
oh andy put that gun away
you think this is a joke huh
no jerry it's on the level but i'm going to have an alibi
marguerite
that's the best i've ever heard marguerite
why is it so funny
because marguerite is not that kind of woman who could commit perjury your problem is you don't know people jerry you don't know what makes them go marguerite may have all those letters after her name but underneath it she's just a woman
now hold it
she loves to be treated like a woman marguerite is in love with me
she was until i came along and besides i'm going to give her ten grand
i can't believe it
now with my left hand i'll just pick up this phone and i'll put it down and dial i'm dialing marguerite marguerite and you'll be able to hear for yourself
go ahead
pick it up jerry talk to the lady yourself
hello marguerite it's me jerry
marguerite andy's gone crazy he's here pointing a gun at me no no he's here he wants to kill me no marguerite listen to me no no marguerite marguerite
hang up jerry that's all there is
no listen my voice is on a tape recorder that apartment has walls now you know how neighbors love to listen to a lover's quarrel so marguerite will swear that i was with her
no
plenty of people will swear they heard me but if i'm dead everyone will know that you killed me
what everyone knows and what everyone can prove are two different things jerry i've got the alibi
you won't get away with it how could i be here to shoot you dead at 10 p.m when i was in marguerite's apartment in north hastings 35 miles away
that car of yours that loud flashy car someone sure to spot it
i'm not using my car tonight i'm driving having marguerite's mousy little nandy
nandy nandy what
you want to make a deal now jerry it's too late timing jerry timing is everything in life
who who besides you would kill me
take your watch your ring your wallet break the back window
you won't fool the police
i remember that you told me that civilized men build the cities and then the barbarians sweep down from the hills and destroy them well the barbarians win again
it won't work it won't work something will go wrong
nothing absolutely nothing is going to go wrong nandy at 10 o'clock tonight i won't be here nandy marguerite will swear that i was 35 miles away nandy think of what you're doing think
where has the time gone it's exactly 10 o'clock
no no no it's fast
goodbye my best and only friend
no
i have to believe i'm sorry jerry but that's the only way you'd have it
after 10 p.m at vacation where jim will have a sweet evening for you first intersection of roots and main and b if you have an r license plate
yes sir an r and a five it would inform you that you have cashed one in the jackpot yes sir folks he doesn't believe it i can tell from the look on his face that he does not believe it you don't have the time to reach out and grab 650 dollars do you mind if i just
the money is yours now what's your name sir please i don't have to
the rules and regulations compel us to give this money to the driver of any car with r and five on his license plate
i don't have an r and a five on my plate
is that true sergeant
his plate number is r55 huh man you've got it in spades
i said you i don't have a
don't you even know your own license plate number
this isn't my car
it isn't your car
no it belongs to a friend so if you don't mind i'll be on my way
one moment sir may i see the automobile registration
what do you want to see the registration for
may i see it please
now look i am a law-abiding citizen
may i see the registration and your driver's license
but i haven't done anything
friend all we want to do is give you 650 dollars your license please
yeah yeah sure
look out everybody
well how do you like that we offer a fellow 650 dollars and he turns into a wild beast
the obvious thing here would be to quote from bobby burns the best-laid plans of mice and men gang aft agley we could quote him but we won't because really the plan didn't go wrong the plan was fine something else went wrong but what and how where when well we're really only a third of the way home you can't expect to know everything right now can i i'll return shortly with act two
you know the old russian proverb he that is fated to drown can even drown in a cup of water and so it is with our friend andrew macefield except andrew will not drown he will hang he will hang for the murder of jerome carlson and of course you know why when that beautifully crafted alibi suddenly collapsed the judge and jury made quick work of the case the date for the hanging has already been set and the days if we may quote that beautiful song are dwindling down to a precious few
i couldn't help it it was him or me i didn't want to do it he was my friend tell him jerry tell him we were friends tell him tell him we were friends jerry we were friends and you know it was nothing personal you don't hold it against me do you do you jerry
oh no certainly not
you see he forgives me he forgives me tell him you said so at the trial jerry you should have said so i mean somebody's got to help me don't want to hang you're supposed to have brains you teach college don't you know that's no good how could i have been with you when the cops picked me up jerry they're gonna hang me he's got to do something hang do something
i guess you got it
i must say mr fallowfield your mind doesn't seem to be on this game
you could be right mr paris you've got a faraway look in your eyes
i'm thinking about somebody
who
a fellow named macefield andrew macefield
andrew macefield macefield would he happen to be your client by any chance
he would
well what about him
he's going to hang tomorrow morning
why
murder
did he do it
oh yes yes he did it no question about it he did it
then that should be that
i know but
but what
well i know what it is to be hanged i know from personal experience the hard way
but you were innocent
that didn't make it any easier to take
well what can you do you're his guardian angel but you did what you could
i still think i failed him
we can only advise we're not supposed to go down there every time a client gets in a jam
maybe i don't know how to communicate mr paris
you win some you lose some after tomorrow you'll be assigned to somebody else
there he goes again
i'm going down there
okay but don't say i didn't warn you
it's not right it's not right help me please somebody's got to help me
mr macefield
mr macefield
what do you want
be out of the guard
it's not time yet
It's not time yet. No, no, no. It ain't no one-year time. You said you'd let me know in advance. You said you'd give me plenty of warning.
Sure, sure. Sorry I had to wait you, but you've got a visitor.
A visitor? Yeah.
You've got to be joking. Who would want to see me?
I would.
What? Who are you?
May I come in?
What do you want?
Well, I want to discuss your case.
My case? Yes.
My case? What case? I've been turned down everywhere by everybody.
Is that a fact?
It's gone all the way to the Supreme Court. I don't have a case. I've decided to hear it.
May I come in?
My name is Fallowfield.
Are you a lawyer? Because if you are, you're wasting my time. I've run out of appeals. Besides, I don't have a dime left to my name.
I'm not a lawyer. I'm your guardian angel.
You're my... I'll get this nut out of here.
Don't make so much noise. What's the angle? Come on, level with me, buddy. After all, I'm an old hustler myself.
Well, I'm really... I'm really not supposed to be here.
Is that a fact?
I want you to have another chance. But you have to convince me...
This is going to be my last night in this world. You've been saying you've got a bad deal. Now tell me, why? Why is it a bad deal? You killed Jerry Carson, didn't you? Why shouldn't you pay the price?
Because... Well, go ahead. Why? I have to know.
All right, what's the difference? It's just another nightmare. No sense in my getting uptight.
You know, this isn't a nightmare. You sent for me.
I sent for you? You always send for me. But when I come to you, you never listen. Tell me why you shouldn't hang.
You know why. Look, everybody in the world has got his place in... Well, Jerome called it the scheme of things. A wolf kills a lamb. Do we blame the wolf? How can we? He was made for that purpose. He can't help it.
You're not a wolf. And Jerome wasn't a lamb.
I am a wolf. I had to be a wolf, or it would have been curtains for me years ago. I had no parents since I was five years old. I had to shine shoes, peddle papers, or hustle, or go under.
But man has free will. Man decides whether or not...
Don't talk to me about free will. I was brought up in a jungle. Other men had mean beginnings and have risen above...
I'm not other men. I'm me. Look, something, somebody made me into what I am. The kind of guy who would have to commit murder one day. Now, why should I have to hang for it?
That, then, is the point of your brief?
Whatever it is, the defense rests. But why do I say defense? I should say prosecution. Why should I be on trial? Whoever, whatever made me into what I am should get the rope.
So, you want another chance?
Oh, definitely. I've got one coming.
Another chance? To do what?
To be what I always wanted to be. Don't laugh. A writer.
A writer? Like your friend Jerome?
Yeah. Yeah. You see, I learned something from him. He didn't have much money. How many people ever heard of him? But he was happy. You know why? Because he was creative. He was expressing himself in the right way. You know my problem?
No.
I'm a creative guy, too, but I didn't have the education to express it in stories and plays and scripts, so... I expressed it in creating hustles and deals. Do you see?
Yes, I see. That hustle I put together, the last one, that was a work of art. When I... When I had to kill Jerry, even the alibi, you've got to admit, maybe it didn't work. But it had a touch of class to it.
Hmm. Another chance. And this time you'd become a writer. And you'd express yourself in fiction. This time... Would you listen to me?
Would I listen to you? Look, if this is how... If I was on the level, would I forget how close I came to that rope?
Will you listen to me this time, Andy? Will you... Sure, sure! I shouldn't say this, but my job would be on the line with you. If I guess wrong, well, you've got to understand I'm going out on a limb for you. Promise, promise you'll listen to me this time. Will you promise, Andy?
I promise, I promise.
Mr. Fallon? But he is promising. He's promising. Promise me, Mr. Parris. Oh! Andy, will you... Will you become a writer? A fine writer? And a credit to both of us?
Yeah, yeah, sure. Hey, look at me. You got me believing it.
Andy, in just one minute, a strange thing is going to happen to you. You won't be in this jail.
No?
I don't know. Because you will have lived a different life, I hope. And so you... You will be wherever that life has taken you. But where are you going to be?
Where I'm supposed to be, Andy. Watching over you, trying to guide you.
And what will I have become?
What you claim you wanted. A writer.
A writer? Will I be rich? Famous?
Why? Is it important? As long as you're creative, isn't that the main thing?
Sure. Sure. That's all that counts.
Andy, in 30 seconds, you'll be 37 years old, just as you are now. But instead of being in a cell, you will be wherever your different life has led you. And, Andy, I hope you keep your promise and listen to me.
Did he listen or didn't he? Where even angels disagree, who are we mortals to explain? Who are we mortals to express an opinion? One thing is certain. If you're about to be hanged, it's wonderful to have a guardian angel who's willing to climb out on a limb.
So, whom shall we meet in Act 3? A different or the same old Andrew Macefield? A moving finger writes, and having writ, moves on. Nor all your piety and wit can ever lure it back to cancel half a line. Nor all your tears, wash out a word of it.
We humbly beg to differ with you, oh great Omar Khayyam, because our man Andrew's piety and wit has lured back the moving finger and his tears have washed out every single word of it. In his death cell, he swore, give me another chance and I'll become a great creative writer. Let me live my life again. I'll make something of myself.
So, he is living it again and he has reached this day. Today, in his new life.
This is Hop Around Harvey Hopkins hopping around all over town to where the action is. And right now, the action is at the Celebrity Club Party for literary giant Andrew Macefield to celebrate the publication of his latest blockbuster of a novel, Kiss Away the Blood.
Hi, Andy. Hello, Harv. Andy, they tell me Kiss Away has already been sold to the flicks for the record price of one million smackers. Congratulations.
Thank you, Harv. Yes. Folks, this is the fellow they call Handy Andy Macefield because he's so handy with that typing machine. How does it feel to be the world's best-selling writer?
Well, I have a deep feeling of humility and responsibility.
Andy, how do you answer those highbrow critics who claim your work is violent, pornographic trash?
Well, I say in all humility that Dostoevsky, Dreiser, and Hemingway were slandered in a similar fashion.
Hmm?
I've got gin, Mr. Fallowfield.
Ah, so you have, Mr. Parris. You know, Mr. Fallowfield, this is the first time in 37 years I've been able to beat you at gin. Your mind isn't on the game.
No, I suppose not. It's that client of mine.
It happens you did the right thing. You saved him.
No, Mr. Parris. I didn't save him.
How can you say that? He's a great success.
No, he's a failure. When I saved him from the rope, he promised to listen to me. Well, he did. Look at him today.
He didn't listen to a word I said. He squandered his gifts. He frittered away his talent. He said he wanted to be truly creative, like his friend Jerome Carlson. But he lied to me. All he wanted... All he wanted was success.
What's wrong with success? You mean creative people have to starve?
No, no, no. A man must be true to himself. Or his soul becomes twisted and deformed, mean, and diseased.
Mr. Fallowfield, you did a wonderful job with him.
But he promised he would be like Jerome Carlson. With all due respect, Jerome Carlson is a schlemiel.
Perhaps. But Jerry Carlson has two things. One is Andrew Macefield covets.
Is that so?
Yes. Jerry has talent. And Jerry has Marguerite. And for those two things, Andrew Macefield will be willing to commit murder. And I have to stop him somehow. Now, I'm going down there.
You can't keep going down there.
It's the only way. He doesn't listen to me. I must confront him.
But the brass here doesn't want us to keep going down there all the time.
Every 30 seconds, seven years. I think that should be allowed. It's finally over. Mind if I turn the TV off?
Jerome, why didn't we go to that party?
Marguerite, my dear, you know what I think of those parties.
Andy begged you to come.
I wouldn't be seen.
I know, I know. You wouldn't be seen at a place where rich, successful people get together. You like to wallow around with miserable, neurotic losers. Failures, like yourself.
And I don't think... I think of myself as a loser and I don't believe I'm a failure. I write what I please. Maybe it pleases you. It doesn't seem to please anybody else. I have faith in myself. And one day...
Certainly, one day, when we're old and gray...
Didn't you feel sorry for that pompous jackass preening himself on that program? I am filled with humility.
You're jealous.
Me, jealous of that untalented slob? He's a fine, sensitive, humble human being.
You know, Marguerite, maybe you should have married Andy.
Maybe I should have.
Andy. Where were you? You didn't show up for the party.
Andy, you knew Jerry would refuse to go. I lined up a whole gang of people for him to meet. Agents, publishers, producers. He could have done himself some good. Why didn't he want to come?
He's working on his book.
Oh, his book. All right. Let's forget it. Where is he now?
Where would he be at midnight?
Sound asleep.
Marguerite.
No, no, Andy, don't.
Marguerite, I love you, darling.
He's your best friend.
I can't help that. You mean more to me.
He's shortchanging you, darling. He gives you nothing. You even have to support him.
Andy, he's really a great writer.
Yes, a great writer who nobody ever reads.
Please.
Oh, you keep working, honey. Keep doing without. Keep worrying about paying the bills. Get lines in your face and age before your time.
I don't know what to do.
Divorce him.
Oh, I can't. I can't. He'd never let me leave him to go with you. That would be the final outrage. He'd kill me before he'd let you have me.
What are you saying?
Andy, there's only one way I could ever leave him to go with you. And that's if he were dead.
You mean you don't want to believe it. But you're a realist. You know the things that have to be done to get what you want. Think about it. Think about what? Reality.
Good evening, Andy.
What? Who are you?
An old friend. How did you get in here?
My name is Fallowfield.
I don't believe this. You didn't believe it 37 years ago, either. How could you have gotten in here? The door's locked. The window... I'm 28 floors above the ground.
Andy. 37 years ago, this very day, you promised you'd listen to me. You faced the scaffold. I gave you another chance.
Wow. Keep talking. I'm having a vision.
No. This is all real. I'm breaking the rules.
What rules?
I don't want you to hang.
Hang? Me? Why?
For the same reason you were sentenced last time for the murder of Jerome Carson.
You're nuts. Or I'm nuts. Do you think I'd kill Jerome just for Marguerite? I mean, I'm tempted, but no dice.
You wouldn't kill Jerome just for Marguerite. Perhaps. But you would kill him for Marguerite and...
And what?
And his talent.
What are you saying? I can't say anymore. I've said too much already. I have to leave. I'll keep trying to advise you and guide you in the usual way. But this time, please listen.
Oh, sure. Look, Mr. Fallowfield. Ma... Where'd he go? Something. I'm being while I'm wide awake.
It's Jerome. Busy, Andy? Want a pal? Knocks at the door? Come on in.
What have you got there?
In this little carton... Looks like a manuscript.
It is. But to call it a manuscript hardly describes it. It represents my entire life's work.
In what way?
It's my life as a writer, Andy. Everything I ever saw, it felt... And this manuscript, this... These 500 pages. They decide whether I have the right to call myself a novelist.
Well, I'm sure it's great.
What's it called?
The Garrison of the Dead.
Great title. What's it about?
It's about all of us.
Sounds heavy.
You are my closest friend. I value your opinion. I want you to be the first to read it.
Oh, Jerry. I'm honored.
Jerry, turn on the TV. Andy's going to be on the show with that... that obnoxious Harvey Hopkins again.
If he's so obnoxious, why do you listen?
Oh, I haven't seen Andy in weeks. Ever since I gave him my manuscript to read. And when do I haven't heard from him?
That's my title. Sounds like a... That's my book. It's mine. He stole my book.
Calm yourself, my dear.
Who stole my book?
Jerry, are you ill?
Do you deny that you stole my book? I asked you to read it so you would see what you could have written if you hadn't frittered away your talents. I wanted you to read the work of a novelist, you pornographic hack.
Jerry, you've gone crazy.
You won't get away with it. I'll sue you for plagiarism. I'll expose you for the fraud you are.
Jerry, please. Don't make a fool of yourself.
Why, Margaret? How could he have proof? Suddenly, I've got an idea. What time is it now?
Get away, Andy. You're crazy. This trial has generated too much publicity. Everyone will know that you killed me. And why? Forget that I'll have an alibi. How could I have killed you here in South Freehold if you hadn't killed me? It would have been at 10 p.m. if I was at my apartment in North East. Marguerite's covering for you won't help. What was she doing in your apartment, anyhow? People will ask. She came to me as your loyal, loving wife to beg me to go easy on you. No, you won't get away with it.
Oh, yes. At 10 p.m., when you were killed by a burglar, I'll be able to prove I was in my apartment. Would your wife lie to save me? No. So you see, Jerome, I get it all. The woman, the fame, the fame. And you won't get the chance to show that magazine. You won't get away with it.
Keep saying that if it makes you feel better.
No, please, Anthony, no.
I'm sorry, Jerry. Really sorry. I had to have that book. It's exactly 10, and we no longer have a problem. I'll get on the turnpike and see you in an hour. Of course. The automatic lane so that no collector might see me pick up my ticket.
What's the matter, Sergeant?
Sir, it is my present duty to inform you that, exactly four minutes past 10 this evening, you have become the one millionth motorist to use the turnpike.
What?
The turnpike authority presents you with this savings bond. All right. Take his picture, boys. Hold it right there, sir. Now, sir, what's your name? Mr. Paris, so I see, Mr. Fallowfield. Incidentally, do you hear someone calling to you?
Yes. But, as you like, I'd like to say you win some, you lose some.
What do we know for sure? We know for sure that back at that toll booth, they asked Andy his name, and his name turned out to be Mud. And what does it prove? It proves that after a while, even the most patient, kindly guardian angel will stop listening if you irritate him long enough. So, please listen to yours. I shall return shortly.
How many chances do you get? Just one? Well, how do you know? And what are you doing now? Is it something you may have done before and paid a price for? How do you know? Since you never know, and since there's no one who can really tell you, stay with what you can count on. And you can count on being with us seven times a week right here on my mystery theater.
Our cast included Mandel Kramer, Joan Lovejoy, Court Benson, Leon Janney, and Bob Kaliban. The entire production was under the direction of Hyman Brown.
And now, a preview of our next tale.
It's incredible. That's what it is. Now, just a minute. You say she was willing to pay $1,000 for it. Imitation leopard skin. But she wanted it and had to have it for her twin sister? Well, I don't buy that, Mother. This second attempt to get a hold of the coat, I mean, by a guy who was ready to kill us in an accident if it turned out that way. No. There's something about that coat. Something somebody wants.
Yes, but what could anyone want with an imitation leopard skin coat? Where'd you buy it, Rose? Harrods in London?
I wish I knew how to straighten out the mystery of Rose's coat.
Oh, dear. You don't straighten out a mystery. You solve it. And I ought to know. I've read hundreds of them every year. Fall most of them, too.
Well, try solving this one then, Aunt Ruth.
Well, if you don't, as a matter of fact, I've been thinking, and I may have the answer.
This is E.G. Marshall inviting you to return to our mystery theater for another adventure in the macabre. Until next time, pleasant dreams.
